Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Be Progressive/Reduce Inequality

“Redistribution” is intended to achieve greater social equality

Lindberg, The Oxford Pocket Dictionary of Current English managing editor, 23

[Christine, 5-28-2023, The Oxford Pocket Dictionary of Current English, “Redistribute”, , Accessed 6-25-2023, RT]

re·dis·tri·bute / ˌrēdəˈstribˌyoōt/• v. [tr.] distribute (something) differently or again, typically to achieve greater social equality: their primary concern was to redistribute income from rich to poor.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Be Progressive/Reduce Inequality

Regressive taxes aren’t fiscal redistribution.

Hicks, Northwestern University ’86 — [Alexander Northwestern University; 1986; “CLASS INFLUENCE ON REDISTRIBUTIVE POLICY: THE CASE OF U.S. STATE GOVERNMENTS, 1951-1961*”; Journal of Political and Military Sociology, Vol. 14; University of Kansas Libraries, JSTOR]

The present redistributive policy focus is on a particular type of government redistribution that may be called direct fiscal redistribution to the poor (hereafter DFRP). Fiscal redistribution refers here to redistribution of money and in-kind income among strata of households by means of both government spending and taxing (i.e., fiscal) activities. For example, increased generosity in public assistance payment levels and reliance upon progressive income as opposed to regressive sales taxes can provide positive fiscal redistribution. Direct fiscal redistribution refers to that part of such redistribution that can be accounted for in terms of government's relatively direct and immediate give-and-take of expenditures and taxes to and from income strata of households. Current evidence suggests that such redistribution is considerable in advanced capitalist political democracies, especially vis-à-vis the poor (e.g., Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977; Hicks and Swank, 1984b). During the 1970s DFRP apparently augmented the "pre-fisc" income share of poor households in the U.S. by over 100 percent (see Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977: 74 on the U.S.; and Hicks and Swank, 1984b on advanced capitalism).

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes OR Transfers

Fiscal redistribution can be transfers only- South Africa example.

IMF Direct 20 [via Newstex Blogs, February 7, “Chart of the Week- South Africa: Bridging the Income Divide,” Accessed 7/5/23 p. L/N, GAL]

 South Africa started the 1990s with already elevated inequality as the policy of apartheid excluded a large swath of the population from economic opportunities. South Africa's Gini—an index that measures inequality—has increased further in the early 2000s and has remained high ever since. Meanwhile, its peers have made inroads in reducing inequality. The South African government has used different tools to tackle the stubborn levels of inequality, including through progressive fiscal redistribution. Efforts to reduce inequality have focused on higher social spending, targeted government transfers, and affirmative action to diversify wealth ownership, and promote entrepreneurship among the previously marginalized. Rising debt is reducing the scope to further use fiscal policy for redistribution. In the future, existing measures will need to be complemented by reforms that promote private investment, create jobs, and foster inclusive growth if South Africa is to bridge its great income divide. [ 1]:   

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Must be Taxes AND Transfers

Can’t evaluate redistributive effect of individual taxes and transfers piecemeal- must look at whole distributive system.

Bruenig, People’s Policy Project, founder, 5-13 (Matt, 5-13-23, “What Makes a Consumption Tax Regressive?”, , Accessed 7-5-23, ED)

If we apply the spending-policy meanings of the words, we would say that cutting the VAT on electricity is very regressive: it gives five euros to the rich for every one euro it gives to the poor. But if we apply the tax-policy meanings of the words, we would say that it is very progressive: the tax savings for the poor are four times what they are for the rich after dividing by income.

Because this is a tax cut and not a tax increase, and is specifically a tax cut aimed at achieving a spending-program type goal (providing electricity subsidies), it appears to have been analyzed by at least some Finnish commentators using the spending-policy word meanings and was thus criticized as horribly regressive.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Must be Taxes AND Transfers

Fiscal redistribution must have a coordinated view of tax and transfers rather than analyzing them piecemeal.

Lustig, Tulane University Latin American Economics Professor 17 [Nora, Director of the Commitment to Equity Institute (CEQ), “Fiscal Policy, Income Redistribution,and Poverty Reduction in Low- and Middle-Income Countries,” CGD Working Paper 448. Washington, DC: Center for Global Development, http://www.cgdev.org/publication/fiscal-policy-redistribution-low- middle-income-countries Accessed 7/5/23, GAL]

There are a few lessons that emerge from the analysis. Let’s start with those pertaining to the diagnostic of fiscal redistribution. First, the fact that specific fiscal interventions can have countervailing effects underscores the importance of taking a coordinated view of both taxation and spending rather than pursuing a piecemeal analysis. Efficient regressive taxes (such as the value-added tax) when combined with generous well-targeted transfers can result in a net fiscal system that is equalizing. Even more, because a net fiscal system with a regressive tax could be more equalizing than without it (Lambert’s conundrum), policy recommendations—such as eliminating the regressive tax—based on a piecemeal analysis could be flatly wrong. Second, to assess the impact of the fiscal system on people’s standard of living, it is crucial to measure the effect of taxation and spending not only on inequality but also on poverty: the net fiscal system can be equalizing but poverty-increasing.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Transfers Only

There are two forms of redistribution- new taxes are part of the “monetary regime”- under the “fiscal regime,” transfers are financed by allowing inflation.

Bhattarai, UT Austin Econ Profressor, et al 22

[Saroj, Jae Won Lee, UVA Econ Professor, and Choongryul Yang, Federal Reserve Board, “Redistribution and the Monetary–Fiscal Policy Mix,” Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2021-013. Washington: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, March 2021, Revised September 22, . Accessed 7/5/23, GAL]

We compare two distinct ways to finance transfers in a two-agent New Keynesian (TANK) model. In the model, a set of households are unable to borrow and lend to smooth consumption over time. A transfer policy redistributes resources toward such "hand-to-mouth" (HTM) households and away from "Ricardian" households that own government bonds.2 In the first policy regime, the government raises taxes. Inflation is then stabilized in the usual way by the central bank. We call this case the "monetary regime." In the second regime, the government commits itself to no adjustments in taxes, and the central bank allows inflation to rise to stabilize the real value of debt, thereby imposing "inflation taxes" on households that hold nominal government debt. In this "fiscal regime," the fiscal theory of the price level operates.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Tax and Transfer- Includes Consumption Taxes

Fiscal redistribution includes carbon tax.

IMF Fiscal Affairs Department, 2014 [IMF Policy Paper, Approved by Sanjeev Gupta, Prepared by staff from Fiscal Affairs Department supervised by Sanjeev Gupta and Michael Keen, and comprising Benedict Clements, Victoria Perry, David Coady, Ruud De Mooij, Stefania Fabrizio, Baoping Shang, Allan Dizioli, Luc Eyraud, Csaba Feher, Valentina Flamini, Alvar Kangur, Javier Kapsoli, Carlos Mulas-Granados, Peter Mullins, Philippe Wingender, Dora Benedek, Ryan Espiritu, and Louis Sears. Production assistance was provided by Pierre Jean Albert, Jeffrey Pichocki, and Mileva Radisavljević. “Fiscal Policy and Income Inequality,” January 22, , Accessed 7/5/23, GAL]

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Fiscal policy is the primary tool for governments to affect income distribution. Rising income inequality in advanced and developing economies has coincided with growing public support for income redistribution. This comes at a time when fiscal restraint is an important priority in many advanced and developing economies. In the context of the Fund’s mandate to promote growth and stability, this paper describes: (i) recent trends in the inequality of income, wealth, and opportunity in advanced and developing economies; (ii) country experience with different fiscal instruments for redistribution; (iii) options for the reform of expenditure and tax policies to help achieve distributive objectives in an efficient manner that is consistent with fiscal sustainability; and (iv) recent evidence on how fiscal policy measures can be designed to mitigate the impact of fiscal consolidation on inequality. This paper does not advocate any particular redistributive goal or policy instrument for fiscal redistribution.

Both tax and expenditure policies need to be carefully designed to balance distributional and efficiency objectives, including during fiscal consolidation. The appropriate mix of instruments will depend on administrative capacity, as well as on society’s preferences for redistribution, the role envisaged for the state, and political economy considerations. Options for redistributive policies that help minimize efficiency costs, in terms of their effects on incentives to work and save, are the following:

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Tax and Transfer- Includes Consumption Taxes

Fiscal Redistribution means income transfer funded through progressive taxes, capital income taxes, wealth taxes, or consumption taxes.

Coady, IMF, fiscal affairs department, head of expenditure policy division, and Le, IMF research officer, 20 (David & Nghia-Piotr, June 2020, International Monetary Fund, “Designing Fiscal Redistribution: The Role of Universal and Targeted Transfers”, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/WP/2020/English/wpiea2020105-print-pdf.ashx, Accessed 6-27-23, ED)

For the most part, advanced countries already have strong fiscal redistribution systems, as reflected in relatively high levels of taxes and transfers. The existing set of tools at their disposal means that these countries can closely approximate the optimal income tax schedule discussed above through a combination of means-tested social assistance transfers (high MTRs at the bottom), consumption taxes (flat tax in the middle), and progressive income taxes (increasing MTRs at the top). In many countries these are complemented by categorical transfers including child benefits and social pensions, as well as comprehensive social insurance systems. However, there are some areas where these systems could be further strengthened (IMF, 2017):

 Personal income taxation (PIT): There appears to be room in many advanced countries for increasing the progressivity of income taxes, which has fallen in many countries since the 1980s.22 Top marginal PIT rates have declined significantly since 1980. The progressivity of income taxes is often even lower than suggested by statutory rates due to the proliferation of tax exemptions which can be more easily exploited by high-income individuals through aggressive tax planning (Alstadsaeter, Johannesen, and Zucman, 2018). Recent empirical studies suggest that in many countries progressivity could be enhanced without adversely affecting economic growth (Gerber et al., 2018). In the context of increasing income volatility and income uncertainty driven by rapid technological change, more progressive income tax systems will also strengthen the insurance role played by fiscal redistribution.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers To Reduce Inequality

Redistribution is a government policy, reducing inequality, through a tax and transfer.

Martinez-Vazquez, GSU Professor of Economics, et al 12 (Jorge, Blanca Moreno-Dodson, World Bank Researcher, Violeta Vulovic, Georgia State University Researcher, 4-1-2012 “The Impact of Tax and Expenditure Policies on Income Distribution: Evidence from a Large Panel of Countries, International Center for Public Policy Working Paper 12-25” Page 106)

Income inequality is measured here by the Gini coefficient, although of course inequality has many other dimensions. 17 The term “redistribution” is used to mean a reduction in income inequality as measured by the Gini coefficients as the result of government policies controlling for other factors that typically have been identified in the past literature as significant determinants of income distribution. On the side of government policies we consider all direct and indirect taxes, 18 as well as a variety of government expenditures beyond social welfare expenditures.19 We take a long run view of how tax and expenditure policies may have affected income distribution over a continuum of 30 + years. . Using a multi-country study can be criticized because even though income distribution is affected by a set of common factors across countries, there are many institutions and processes that are particular to each country that cannot be reflected in the variables used in the regression. However, this issue is minimized because in our estimation technique we control for those fixed country effects.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers To Reduce Inequality

Redistribution is tax and transfer policies to reduce income inequality

Luebker, International Labor Organization Senior Regional Wage Specialist, 12 [Malte, 6-2012, International Labor Office, “Income Inequality, redistribution and poverty”, , Accessed 6-24-2023, RT]

It is thus not surprising that redistribution, broadly defined as the use of tax and transfer policies to reduce income inequality, has re-entered the mainstream of the poverty debate — much like income inequality itself has been ‘brought in from the cold’ by the economics discipline in the mid-1990s (Atkinson 1997; see also Kanbur and Lustig 2000). Whereas redistributive instruments are generally more developed in the advanced countries — where relative poverty has remained a policy concern — developing countries such as Brazil are now using cash-transfer programmes (along with other policy tools, such as minimum wage legislation) to reduce poverty and to put a dent into sky-high inequality. By contrast, tax and transfer systems have only a negligible impact on inequality in other Latin American countries such as Guatemala or Columbia. Even among developed economies, the welfarestate literature has found a wide gulf between the redistributive efforts made in Nordic countries and in the liberal market economies of the Anglo-Saxon world.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers To Reduce Inequality

Fiscal Redistribution is the transfer of income from higher to lower income families via taxes and transfer schemes

Coady, IMF, fiscal affairs department, head of expenditure policy division, and Le, IMF research officer, 20

(David & Nghia-Piotr, June 2020, International Monetary Fund, “Designing Fiscal Redistribution: The Role of Universal and Targeted Transfers”, https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/WP/2020/English/wpiea2020105-print-pdf.ashx, Accessed 6-27-23, ED)

Although increasing income inequality has been observed in many countries, the varying experiences across countries, with inequality even decreasing in a sizeable share of countries, suggests that public policy and institutions play and important role in determining such outcomes.2 In this respect, fiscal redistribution (i.e., the transfer of income from higher to lower income households via tax and transfer schemes) has a key role to play in addressing income inequality. For instance, evidence from studies of fiscal redistribution shows that over threequarters of the difference in average disposable income inequality between advanced and Latin American countries (with the lowest and highest average disposable income inequality, respectively) is accounted for by differences in the extent of fiscal redistribution rather than by differences in market incomes (Bastagli, Coady and Gupta, 2015).

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers To Reduce Inequality

Broad definitions of redistribution include nearly all government action. “Fiscal redistribution” means only direct government interventions via taxes and transfers to reduce income inequality.

Luebker, Institute of Economic and Social Research 17 [Matle, Wirtschafts- und Sozialwisswnschaftliches institut (WSI), May 18, 2017, ResearchGate, “Redistribution policies”, accessed 6/27/2023, ero, , italics in original]

In dictionaries, redistribution is defined as “to alter the distribution of” something.2 This is a useful starting point: what follows is that income redistribution policies encompass all government interventions that alter the distribution of incomes, including those that affect the primary distribution of incomes. As argued in Part II of this volume, granting collective bargaining rights (or denying them) has consequences for the functional distribution of incomes and for wage inequality, as do minimum wages. However, governments alter the primary distribution of incomes in other, often even less visible ways. For instance, the liberalization of financial markets since the 1980s is widely believed to have contributed to a concentration of incomes at the top, and to a shift away from wages and towards profits (see Stiglitz, 2012; ILO, 2012). Likewise, trade liberalization has differential impacts on the incomes of various groups in society (see Jansen and Lee, 2007).

Such a broad definition of redistribution underlines the fact that most government action has redistributive consequences. To gain support for unpopular decisions such as the opening of trade, governments sometimes try to compensate the losers and impose a corresponding tax on the winners (ibid.). At this stage, redistribution becomes more apparent since it directly alters the primary distribution of incomes. This direct intervention in the form of taxes and transfers is commonly at the heart of public debates over redistribution, simply because it is more visible, even though the impact can be minuscule when compared the original policy decision. For example, trade compensation schemes are commonly thought to redistribute less than 5 per cent of the gains from trade (ibid.: 75).

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers

Redistribution requires tax and transfers.

Sharony, Ben Gurion University of the Negev Lecturer et al 16, [Chen, Shlomo Mizrahi, Professor in the Department of Public Administration and Policy and Miki Malul, Professor, Department of Public Policy and Management “Public Preferences for Redistribution and Policy Outcomes: A Comparative Study,” European Social Survey, ]

The study deals with public preferences concerning redistribution policy, and their effect on actual policy. Redistribution is defined in the literature as a reduction of inequalities in the distribution of wealth through government taxes and transfers (Durante & Putterman, 2009). There is a mismatch between public preferences and policy in this field in certain countries. That is, in some countries the public displays a high demand for redistribution policy, but the government's social spending is low or vice versa.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers

“Fiscal Redistribution” is tax and transfer policies.

Pelke, University of Heidelberg Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences doctoral candidate, 21 [Lars, 26.03.2021, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences of the University of Heidelberg, “Rethinking Inequality under Autocracy. Parties, Citizens, and Preferences”, , Accessed 6/26/2023, RT]

The third central concept is (income) redistribution. As Tullock argues, ‘‘redistribution is probably the most important function of most modern governments’’ (Tullock, 2013, p. 1). However, the level of redistribution and its cross-sectional variation cannot be modeled using only purely economic explanations, such as the level of inequality in a given society (see McCarty & Pontusson, 2009). Therefore, I focus on the question of how political processes and institutions, such as autocratic ruling strategies and the degree of incumbent party institutionalization, determine the level of redistribution and inequality. In this dissertation, redistribution is broadly defined as the transfer of resources from one person or group to another person or group (see also Albertus, 2015; Boadway & Keen, 2000; Solt, 2020; Tullock, 2013). More precisely, income or fiscal redistribution is defined as the transfer of resources via taxes and fiscal transfer policies from one person or group to another. By contrast, land redistribution —a second influential type of redistribution (Albertus, 2015) —is defined as land reform measures that lead to a reallocation of land properties from landed elites to the landed poor.10 In addition, income redistribution is also often conceptualized as the transfer of resources to the poor.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR = Taxes and Transfers

“Fiscal Redistribution” is redistribution of income via spending and taxation.

Hicks, Northwestern Sociology Professor, 86

[Alexander, Spring 1986, University of Florida Press, “CLASS INFLUENCE ON REDISTRIBUTIVE POLICY: THE CASE OF U.S. STATE GOVERNMENTS”, , Accessed 6/26/2023, RT]

The present redistributive policy focus is on a particular type of government redistribution that may be called direct fiscal redistribution to the poor (hereafter DFRP). Fiscal redistribution refers here to redistribution of money and in-kind income among strata of households by means of both government spending and taxing (i.e., fiscal) activities. For example, increased generosity in public as-sistance payment levels and reliance upon progressive income as opposed to regressive sales taxes can provide positive fiscal redistribution. Direct fiscal re-distribution refers to that part of such redistribution that can be accounted for in terms of government's relatively direct and immediate give-and-take of expenditures and taxes to and from income strata of households. Current evidence suggests that such redistribution is considerable in advanced capitalist political democracies, especially vis-à-vis the poor (e.g., Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977; Hicks and Swank, 1984b). During the 1970s DFRP apparently augmented the "pre-fisc" income share of poor households in the U.S. by over 100 percent (see Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977: 74 on the U.S.; and Hicks and Swank, 1984b on advanced capitalism).

2023 GDI Topicality
Increase › Increase = Net Increase

Must be a net increase

Rogers 5 Judge – New York, et al., Petitioners v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Respondent, NSR Manufacturers Roundtable, et al., Intervenors, 2005 U.S. App. LEXIS 12378, **; 60 ERC (BNA) 1791, 6/24, Lexis

[**48]  Statutory Interpretation. While the CAA defines a "modification" as any physical or operational change that "increases" emissions, it is silent on how to calculate such "increases" in emissions. . According to government petitioners, the lack of a statutory definition does not render the term "increases" ambiguous, but merely compels the court to give the term its "ordinary meaning." See ; ; . Relying on two "real world" analogies, government petitioners contend that the ordinary meaning of "increases" requires the baseline to be calculated from a period immediately preceding the change. They maintain, for example, that in determining whether a high-pressure weather system "increases" the local temperature, the relevant baseline is the temperature immediately preceding the arrival of the weather system, not the temperature five or ten years ago. Similarly,  [**49]  in determining whether a new engine "increases" the value of a car, the relevant baseline is the value of the car immediately preceding the replacement of the engine, not the value of the car five or ten years ago when the engine was in perfect condition.

2023 GDI Topicality
Increase › Increase Not Preexisting

“Increase” doesn’t require prior existence

Reinhardt 5 U.S. Judge for the UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT (Stephen, JASON RAY REYNOLDS; MATTHEW RAUSCH, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP, INC.; HARTFORD FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendants-Appellees., lexis

Specifically, we must decide whether charging a higher price for initial insurance than the insured would otherwise have been charged because of information in a consumer credit report constitutes an "increase in any charge" within the meaning of FCRA. First, we examine the definitions of "increase" and "charge." Hartford Fire contends that, limited to their ordinary definitions, these words apply only when a consumer has previously been charged for insurance and that charge has thereafter been increased by the insurer. The phrase, "has previously been charged," as used by Hartford, refers not only to a rate that the consumer has previously paid for insurance but also to a rate that the consumer has previously been quoted, even if that rate was increased [**23] before the consumer made any payment. Reynolds disagrees, asserting that, under [*1091] the ordinary definition of the term, an increase in a charge also occurs whenever an insurer charges a higher rate than it would otherwise have charged because of any factor--such as adverse credit information, age, or driving record 8 --regardless of whether the customer was previously charged some other rate. According to Reynolds, he was charged an increased rate because of his credit rating when he was compelled to pay a rate higher than the premium rate because he failed to obtain a high insurance score. Thus, he argues, the definitions of "increase" and "charge" encompass the insurance companies' practice. Reynolds is correct.

“Increase" means to make something greater. See, e.g., OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY (2d ed. 1989) ("The action, process, or fact of becoming or making greater; augmentation, growth, enlargement, extension."); WEBSTER'S NEW WORLD DICTIONARY OF AMERICAN ENGLISH (3d college ed. 1988) (defining "increase" as "growth, enlargement, etc[.]"). "Charge" means the price demanded for goods or services. See, e.g., OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY (2d ed. 1989) ("The price required or demanded for service rendered, or (less usually) for goods supplied."); WEBSTER'S NEW WORLD DICTIONARY OF AMERICAN ENGLISH (3d college ed. 1988) ("The cost or price of an article, service, etc."). Nothing in the definition of these words implies that the term "increase in any charge for" should be limited to cases in which a company raises the rate that an individual has previously been charged.

2023 GDI Topicality
Increase › Increase is Preexisting

“Increase” implies pre-existence

Brown 3 US Federal Judge – District Court of Oregon (Elena Mark and Paul Gustafson, Plaintiffs, v. Valley Insurance Company and Valley Property and Casualty, Defendants, 7-17, Lexis

FCRA does not define the term "increase." The plain and ordinary meaning of the verb "to increase" is to make something greater or larger. 4 Merriam-Webster's [**22] Collegiate Dictionary 589 (10th ed. 1998). The "something" that is increased in the statute is the "charge for any insurance." The plain and common meaning of the noun "charge" is "the price demanded for something." Id. at 192. Thus, the statute plainly means an insurer takes adverse action if the insurer makes greater (i.e., larger) the price demanded for insurance.

An insurer cannot "make greater" something that did not exist previously. The statutory definition of adverse action, therefore, clearly anticipates an insurer must have made an initial charge or demand for payment before the insurer can increase that charge. In other words, an insurer cannot increase the charge for insurance unless the insurer previously set and demanded payment of the premium for that insured's insurance [**23] coverage at a lower price.

2023 GDI Topicality
Increase › Increase is Preexisting

Increase must be of something that already exists

Buckley 6 Jeremiah, Attorney, Amicus Curiae Brief, Safeco Ins. Co. of America et al v. Charles Burr et al,

First, the court said that the ordinary meaning of the word “increase” is “to make something greater,” which it believed should not “be limited to cases in which a company raises the rate that an individual has previously been charged.” 435 F.3d at 1091. Yet the definition offered by the Ninth Circuit compels the opposite conclusion. Because “increase” means “to make something greater,” there must necessarily have been an existing premium, to which Edo’s actual premium may be compared, to determine whether an “increase” occurred. Congress could have provided that “ad-verse action” in the insurance context means charging an amount greater than the optimal premium, but instead chose to define adverse action in terms of an “increase.” That definitional choice must be respected, not ignored. See Colautti v. Franklin, 439 U.S. 379, 392-93 n.10 (1979) (“[a] defin-ition which declares what a term ‘means’ . . . excludes any meaning that is not stated”). Next, the Ninth Circuit reasoned that because the Insurance Prong includes the words “existing or applied for,” Congress intended that an “increase in any charge” for insurance must “apply to all insurance transactions – from an initial policy of insurance to a renewal of a long-held policy.” 435 F.3d at 1091. This interpretation reads the words “exist-ing or applied for” in isolation. Other types of adverse action described in the Insurance Prong apply only to situations where a consumer had an existing policy of insurance, such as a “cancellation,” “reduction,” or “change” in insurance. Each of these forms of adverse action presupposes an already-existing policy, and under usual canons of statutory construction the term “increase” also should be construed to apply to increases of an already-existing policy. See Hibbs v. Winn, 542 U.S. 88, 101 (2004) (“a phrase gathers meaning from the words around it”) (citation omitted).

2023 GDI Topicality
Increase › Increase- Make Greater

Increase means add duration to

Word and Phrases 8 (vol. 20B, p. 265)

Me. 1922. Within Workmen’s Compensation Act, § 36, providing for review of any agreement, award, findings, or decree, and that member of Commission may increase, diminish, or discontinue compensation, an “increase” may include an extension of the time of the award. –Graney’s Case, 118 A. 369, 121 Me.500.—Work Comp 2049.