Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › UBI Links › UBI Triggers Inflation Spiral

UBI decreases the workforce, and slows economic growth and risks spiraling inflation

Mitchell, University of Newcastle Centre of Full Employment and Equity Director and Economics Professor, 17

[William, 5/31/17, William, Professor in Economics and Director of the Centre of Full Employment and Equity (CofFEE), at the University of Newcastle,“A Basic Income Guarantee does not reduce poverty,” https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=36105, accessed 6/27/23, EP]

So there you have it. A BIG as is typically proposed is not a magic cure for poverty.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › UBI Links › UBI Triggers Inflation Spiral

UBI causes an inflationary spiral – reverberating throughout the economy

Archetto, former Department of State Bureau of Political Military Affairs foreign affairs officer, 18

[Greg, 7-16-18, The Hill, “Implementation of a ‘universal basic income’ would be a disaster,” https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/397192-implementation-of-a-universal-basic-income-program-would-be-a-disaster/, accessed 6-27-23,, ah]

If everyone suddenly had an extra $10K a year, and everyone knew that everyone had an extra $10K a year, prices would go up and inflation would rise, thus negating the perceived gains of such a program.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Minimum Wage Increase Increases Unemployment

Minimum wage raise leads to unemployment, economists agree

Phelan, Center of the American Experiment economic & Cobden Centre fellow, 19

[John, 3-25-19, Foundation for Economic Education Stories, “5 reasons raising the minimum wage is bad public policy,” https://fee.org/articles/5-reasons-raising-the-minimum-wage-is-bad-public-policy/, 6-26-23, DS]

So what are the effects of increasing minimum wages? Any Econ 101 student can tell you the answer: The higher wage reduces the quantity of labor demanded, and hence leads to unemployment.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Job Guarantee Cost Links

Job guarantee programs have hidden liability costs

Standing, SOAS University of London Professorial Research Associate, 18

[Guy, 9/7/18, New Economics, “Why a Job Guarantee is a bad joke for the precariat – and for freedom” https://neweconomics.opendemocracy.net/job-guarantee-bad-joke-precariat-freedom/, accessed 6/26/23, MR]

At its unlikely best, a job guarantee would be paternalistic. It presumes the government knows what is best for individuals, who would be offered a necessarily limited range of jobs at its disposal. Suppose someone was pressed to take a guaranteed job on a construction site (‘infrastructure’, a favoured area for guaranteed jobs) and that person proved incompetent and was injured. Would the job guarantee agency be held responsible and pay compensation? It should, since it put the person in that position. How would that be factored into the costing of a job guarantee scheme? Similarly, if a person put into a ‘social care’ job was negligent and caused harm or distress to the care recipient, would the latter be able to sue the job guarantee agency for compensation?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › AT – Job Guarantee Boosts GDP

Dolan, Niskanen Center Fiscal and Monetary Policy Senior Fellow, 18

[Ed, 5-21-18, Niskanen Center, “Three More Reasons to be Cautious About a National Job Guarantee,” https://www.niskanencenter.org/three-more-reasons-to-be-cautious-about-a-national-job-guarantee/, accessed 6-27-23, DS]

6. Beware of illusory additions to GDP, Optimists contend that a JG program would provide a huge boost to the economy. For example, Wray estimates that a national job guarantee with 15 million participants would add $560 billion dollars to GDP, about 3 percent, with little impact on inflation. But, even if he is right about the numbers, how much of the measured addition to GDP would represent a real increase in the economy’s output of goods and services?

It would be easier to know if, for example, the JG workers were put to work sewing shirts. Their output would then be measured by multiplying the number of shirts times the price at which they were sold. If that came up to $560 billion, you would have added an honest increment to GDP. If customers didn’t like the shirts, or too many were produced, their price would fall and the factory’s contribution to GDP would decrease accordingly.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › AT – Job Guarantee Solves Unemployment

Dolan, Niskanen Center Fiscal and Monetary Policy Senior Fellow, 18

[Ed, 5-21-18, Niskanen Center, “Three More Reasons to be Cautious About a National Job Guarantee,” https://www.niskanencenter.org/three-more-reasons-to-be-cautious-about-a-national-job-guarantee/, accessed 6-27-23, DS]

These are valid points. Let me add three more reasons to be cautious about a national job guarantee.

4. Don’t exaggerate the pool of eligible candidates

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Jobs Guarantee Links – Sector Costs

A jobs guarantee program would raise costs in multiple sectors

Bourne, CATO Institute Public Understanding of Economics Chair, 18

[Ryan, 4/24/18, CATO Institute, “A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster,” https://www.cato.org/blog/jobs-guaranteed-economic-disaster, accessed 6/25/23, EP]

There’s good reason to expect the policy will reduce the efficiency and productive potential of the economy too. Taxes will eventually need to be raised to cover the net cost of the program. In infrastructure and care giving provision, costs will rise – because nobody would now work in these directly substitutable sectors for less than the wage and conditions offered in the job guarantee program. This will waste resources, and there’s highly likely to be overinvestment in lots of relatively low value ventures and programs to ensure workers are employed, especially given the explicit aim is to provide employment rather than deliver projects at low cost.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › AT – Phillips Curve Outdated

Phillips Curve is back – recent data proves declines in unemployment rates cause inflation

Hobjin, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Economic Advisor, et al., 23

[Bart, Russell Miles, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago research assistant, James Royal, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago economic research intern, Jing Zhang, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago senior economist and economic advisor, January 2023, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, “The Recent Steepening of Phillips Curves,” https://www.chicagofed.org/publications/chicago-fed-letter/2023/475, accessed 6/27/23, EP]

The gist of our main result is apparent in figure 1, which shows the Phillips curves of the United States, United Kingdom, and France during two time periods: the seven years (or 28 quarters) before the pandemic (2013:Q1–2019:Q4) and the six quarters of the recovery for which we have data (2021:Q1–2022:Q2).2 These three countries’ Phillips curves have steepened significantly during the recovery, in stark contrast with their flat Phillips curves of the pre-pandemic period. Before the pandemic, the U.S. Phillips curve had been flattening for over a decade3 and was considered “dead” by many economists.4 It appears this pattern has sharply reversed over the first six quarters following 2020. Phillips curves of the United States, United Kingdom, and France: Pre-pandemic and recovery periods In the rest of this article, we show that Phillips curves have steepened across a sample of 29 industrialized countries using data from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).5 This change in the relationship between unemployment and inflation is robust to the inclusion of crude oil prices, inflation expectations, and other measures of economic slack besides the unemployment gap.6 What drives our results is that declines in unemployment rates are associated with larger increases in inflation rates during the recovery from the pandemic than during the pre-pandemic period. Our results are generally the same when we examine countries individually (within-country variation) or when we study them pooled together (cross-country variation).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Wage Inflation

A federal jobs guarantee causes worker backlash which causes wage inflation and kill small businesses.

Misra, Bloomberg freelance contributor, 18

[Tanvi, 12-10-18, Bloomberg “The ‘Sweeping’ Effect of a $15-an-Hour Job Guarantee.” , access date: 6-25-23, CC]

How employed workers react to such a program depends, in large part, on the kind of economic ripples a federal jobs guarantee creates. Currently, 27.9 million full-time workers earn below $15 in the country, and would clearly benefit from switching over to a government job. So would 15.9 million part-time workers.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Wage Inflation

A federal jobs guarantee would cause the price of labor to skyrocket, causing inflation.

Bhandari, Third Way Former Senior Policy Advisor, 19

[Ryan, 3-25-19, Thirdway “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” , access date: 6-25-23, CC]

#4: Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker.5 We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Decreasing Unemployment Increases Inflation

Lower unemployment will drive up inflation, risking recession

Tetrina, Forbes Contributor, 22

[Kat, 8-31-22, Forbes, “Inflation and Unemployment,” https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/inflation-and-unemployment/, accessed 6-24-23, ah]

Economists have determined that there may be a relationship between inflation and unemployment, described as the Phillips Curve, in honor of economist A.W. Phillips, who identified the relationship in 1958. The Phillips Curve hypothesizes that there is a correlation between inflation and unemployment. When inflation is high, unemployment is low. Conversely, when inflation is low, unemployment levels increase. This connection poses a difficult challenge to policymakers. While low unemployment may sound like a positive for the economy and workers, too low an unemployment rate may drive inflation up. But if the government takes steps to curb inflation, that may chip away at unemployment and trigger a recession.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Decreasing Unemployment Increases Inflation

Inflation and unemployment are inversely related – decline in unemployment will trigger inflation

DePersio, Investopedia freelance contributor, 20

[Greg, August 22, 2020, Investopedia, "What Happens When Inflation and Unemployment Are Positively Correlated?," , June 24, 2023, ah].

Inflation and unemployment have traditionally had an inverse relationship. When one rises, the other drops and vice versa. Governments typically rely on monetary and fiscal policies in order to keep the economy from overstimulating or from slowing it down too much.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Decreasing Unemployment Increases Inflation

When more Americans have jobs the impact ripples through to employers causing inflation.

Foster, Bankrate Senior U.S. Economy Reporter, 22

[Sarah ,01-07-2022, Bankrate.com “The Phillips curve, explained – and what it says about soaring inflation in the COVID economy” , access date: 6-24-2023, CC]

The description sounds complex, but consumers live through this phenomenon every day without even realizing it.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Employment Links › Employment Links – Decreasing Unemployment Increases Inflation

Economic theories prove that when more people are employed, inflation goes up.

Tretina, Forbes Contributor and Financial advisor, 22 [Kat, 08-31-2022, Forbes, “Inflation and Unemployment”, , access date: 6-24-2023, emphasis in original, CC]

The Phillips Curve hypothesizes that there is a correlation between inflation and unemployment. When inflation is high, unemployment is low. Conversely, when inflation is low, unemployment levels increase.

This connection poses a difficult challenge to policymakers. While low unemployment may sound like a positive for the economy and workers, too low an unemployment rate may drive inflation up. But if the government takes steps to curb inflation, that may chip away at unemployment and trigger a recession.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › AT – Taxes Solve the Link

Raised taxes slows the economy

Heil, Hoover Institution Policy Fellow, 21

[Daniel, 2/18/21, Hoover Institution, “Tax Rate Hikes And The Economy,” https://www.hoover.org/research/tax-rate-hikes-and-economy, accessed 6/27/23, EP]

Until 2018, the United States had the highest statutory corporate tax rate in the developed world. Even before accounting for state taxes, the top rate was 35 percent, well above the rates in Ireland (12.5 percent), Canada (15 percent), and the United Kingdom (19 percent). The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA) permanently lowered the top rate to 21 percent. Now the Biden administration wants to increase the rate to 28 percent, higher than most of the developed world but still 20 percent below the 2017 rate.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › AT – Increase Income/Benefits Boosts Growth

No solvency – Consumption does not drive growth

Dowell, Boston College Austrian Economics Finance PhD student, 19

[Jacob, 3/8/19, Foundation for Economic Education, “Andrew Yang’s Math Doesn’t Add Up on Universal Basic Income,” https://fee.org/articles/andrew-yang-s-math-doesn-t-add-up-on-universal-basic-income/, accessed 6/26/23, EP]

However, there is an even deeper flaw in the argument that the UBI would expand the economy. It rests on the assumption that consumption spending grows the economy and drives production.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › Benefit Expansion Link

Welfare expansion drives inflation – causes employers to pay more for benefits

The Foundation for Government Accountability, 22

[The Foundation for Government Accountability, 3/28/22, FGA, “FGA Research Shows Expanded Welfare Benefits and Labor Shortages Are Causing “Bidenflation””, , 6/24/23, EP]

FGA researchers found that in 2021 alone, annual gas prices increased by 49.6 percent, food prices increased by 12.5 percent, and used vehicle prices increased by 37.3 percent, leaving many families worried about meeting monthly expenses.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › Benefit Expansion Link

Increasing disposable income triggers inflation

, American Enterprise Institute Economic Policy Studies senior fellow, et al. 23

[Alex, Kyle Pomerleau, American Enterprise Institute Economic Policy Studies senior fellow, Grant M. Seiter, American Enterprise Institute senior research associate, 6-8-23, American Enterprise Institute, "Flawed Approach: The Working Families Tax Cut Act as a Response to Inflation," https://www.aei.org/economics/flawed-approach-the-working-families-tax-cut-act-as-a-response-to-inflation/, DOA – 6-26-23, DD]

While inflation has adversely affected households and the US economy as a whole, a temporary expansion of the standard deduction is a poorly designed policy response for several reasons.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › Fiscal Expanstion Link

Expanding fiscal policy triggers inflation and risks massive rate increase

Thorbecke, Research Institute of Economy Senior Fellow, 22

[Willem, 9/19/22, Financial Times, “Letter: Fiscal discipline is what the US economy needs,” https://www.ft.com/content/6aac3a0c-ecdd-4492-ac17-eab93472f2b5, accessed 6/27/23, ep]

Frederic Mishkin is correct that the Federal Reserve must not imitate Paul Volcker’s mistake of easing monetary policy before inflation is defeated (Opinion, September 15). President Joe Biden must also avoid Ronald Reagan’s mistake of running stimulative fiscal policy while the Fed is fighting inflation. In the 1980s, US deficits reached 5 per cent of gross domestic product. To offset this stimulus, the Fed was forced to raise rates to what Helmut Schmidt observed were their highest levels since the time of Christ.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Neg › Generic Links › Money Supply Link

Increased money supply causes inflation – more cash gives more reasons for consumers to buy

Frick, Harvard Business Review Editor, 22

[Walter, 12/23/22, Harvard Business Journal, “What causes Inflation,” https://hbr.org/2022/12/what-causes-inflation, 6/24/23, EP]

Money supply: Then there’s the demand side of the equation. An increase in the money supply will tend to cause inflation, as Moss explains. “With more cash in their pockets and bank accounts, consumers often find new reasons to buy things,” he writes in the book. “But unless the supply of goods and services has increased in the meantime, the consumers’ mounting demand for products will simply bid up prices, thus stoking inflation. Economists sometimes say that inflation rises when ‘too much money is chasing too few goods.’” This is sometimes referred to as “demand-pull inflation.”