Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Impact Answers › Extension Likely

No unique impact – extension likely now

Dorenkamp, Brownfield Ag News, 7-7-23

(Mark, 7-7-23, 1430wcmy, "Grassley talks farm bill timing as possibility of extension grows, , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M) (NOTE FOR THIS EV, DORENKAMP POSTS NEWS THAT IOWAN RADIO STATIONS SHARE)

The possibility of a one-year extension grows as farm bill negotiations run deeper into the summer.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › No Vote Scheduled

The House and Senate are saying different times on the Farm Bill Passing

McCullough, RFD-TV, 7-12-23

[Currey, 7-12-2023, RFD-TV "The House and Senate seem to be on different Farm Bill timelines," , Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

We are just two and a half months out from the Farm Bill expiring, and the House and Senate appear to be holding two different timelines on their goals.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Farmer Polling Doesn’t Matter (To be read to extend 2AC ‘Rodeo’ Evidence)

The Farm Bill directly affects the lives of farmers and their communities: the link chains originate from them: their input is more valuable than political fluctuations

Celec, Bucks County Audobon Society executive director & Parzen, Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania executive director, 6-29-23

[Michael, Molly, 6/29/23, “A Farm Bill For Us All,” Bucks County Herald, , Accessed 7/12/23, J.D.]

When you hear the phrase “Farm Bill,” you probably don’t think about streams, trees, birds, or many of the other environmental highlights of our area because, after all, what do they have to do with farming and agriculture?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › NDAA Amendment Fights Coming

Farm Bill inevitable – Ag Chair Thompson will ensure bipartisan bill

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23

[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

And Mr. Thompson made it clear when he ascended to the committee chairmanship after Republicans took control of the House in January that he was going to continue that tradition.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › NDAA Amendment Fights Coming

No unique link to the plan – the National Defense Authorization Act is the hot-button issue – controversial amendments trigger partisanship

Brooks, Hill, 7-11-23

[Emily Brooks, 7-11-2023, The Hill "Moderate Democrats call on McCarthy to reject GOP extremes on defense bill,” , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M]

Leaders of the New Democrat Coalition, a group representing nearly 100 center-left Democrats, are calling on Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) to reject “extreme elements” of his party as the House takes up the annual National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) this week — and conservatives push for amendment votes on hot-button issues.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Uniqueness Double Bind

No unique impact – Spending fights make extension likely

Magnuson, Iowa Agribusiness Radio Network, 6-19-23

[Mark Magnuson, 6-19-23, Iowa Agri Business Radio Network, "Congressional spending debate posing new challenges for farm bill writers,", , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M]

A changing political environment for budgeting on Capitol Hill is posing new challenges for farm bill writers, who are already facing a daunting October 1st deadline to complete work on a new bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Uniqueness Double Bind

Uniqueness double bind – either Farm Bill fight likely due to triple witching and/or the merits of the Farm Bill, making it the DA inevitable – or extension inevitable– avoiding the impact

Pergam, Fox News, 7-3-23

[Chad, 7-3-23, Fox News "Must-do: What Congress has left on its plate at year's halfway mark”, , accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M]

The financial world features an economic phenomenon called "triple witching" which unfolds four times a year. It’s the simultaneous expiration of stock index futures, stock options and stock index option contracts on the same trading Friday. The confluence sometimes spikes trading volume and fuels volatility in the markets.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Farm Bill Won’t Pass Now

Debates over Farm Bill now – Passage not guaranteed.

Brasher, Agri-pulse editor, et al. 7/5/2023

[Phillip, Steve Davies, Jacqui Fatka, Noah Wicks, Bill Tomson, Agri-pulse editors, Agri-pulse, “Agri-Pulse farm bill preview: Key issues and proposals for each title”, , accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

The House and Senate Agriculture Committees are still several months away from voting on a new farm bill, but the major issues in each of the 12 titles are coming into focus even as lawmakers continue offering new proposals they’d like to see included.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Farm Bill Scenario Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Farm Bill Won’t Pass Now

Farm Bill not certain now – GOP infighting and lack of time – extension likely

Magnuson, Iowa Agribusiness Radio Network, 6/19/23

[Mark Magnuson, 6/19/23, Iowa Agribusiness Radio Network, “Congressional spending debate posing new challenges for farm bill writers,” , Accessed 7/12/2023, EJ]

A changing political environment for budgeting on Capitol Hill is posing new challenges for farm bill writers, who are already facing a daunting October 1st deadline to complete work on a new bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Bidenomics Can’t Save Biden › Too Late for Credit

Bidenomics Sucks, makes Joe lose.

Marshall, Progressive Policy Institute President & Founder, 7-14-23

[Will, 7-14-23, Hill, "Why working families aren’t sold on Bidenomics," , Accessed 7-14-23, S.A.M]

The U.S. economy presents a frustratingly mixed picture. Viewed from some angles — low unemployment, rising wages and bullish financial markets — it conveys strength. From others – high prices, interest rates and debt — it looks heavily burdened and susceptible to recession.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Bidenomics Can’t Save Biden › Too Late for Credit

Too late to claim credit – the moment has passed on Bidenomics

Shapiro, Georgetown University McDonough School of Business Senior Fellow, 23

[Robert J, 5-23-2023, Washington Monthly, "Why Don't Americans Recognize that Inflation is Down and Incomes Are Up, , Accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

My late boss, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, a sage and successful politician, once told me that in politics, “If you don’t get credit, it didn’t happen.” The White House and congressional Democrats need to relearn that lesson. In March 2022, 75 percent of Americans thought the economy was flailing despite more than a year of historic gains in GDP and jobs. Today, the public’s discontent is focused on inflation and incomes, with 68 percent disapproving of the president’s performance on inflation and 50 percent feeling worse off economically than a year earlier. Yet, the reality is that inflation has been falling fast, and people’s incomes after inflation have been rising rapidly.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Bidenomics Can’t Save Biden › Bidenomics Won’t Solve

Bidenomics won’t save Biden AND Biden’s family scandal undermines his case against Trump

Tomasky, The New Republic, 7-10-23

[Michael, 7-10-2023, New Republic, “What Do Bidenomics and the President’s Grandchild Have to Do with Each Other? Everything. ," New Republic, , accessed 7-10-23, S.A.M]

Joe Biden recently unveiled the term “Bidenomics” to express and encompass the positive economic news—and there’s a lot of it—that he hopes will lift him to reelection.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Bidenomics Can’t Save Biden › Bidenomics Won’t Solve

People just don’t like Joe Biden, there is nothing he can do about it

Werschkul, Yahoo Finance Economic Policy Washington Correspondent, 6-18-23

[Ben, 6-18-23, Yahoo, “Why Biden polls so low on the economy — and what he is trying to do about it,” https://finance.yahoo.com/news/why-biden-polls-so-low-on-the-economy--and-what-he-is-trying-to-do-about-it-142504457.html, accessed 7-8-23, DG]

It’s a feature of Biden’s 2024 re-election effort so far that is surely causing heartburn in his inner circle: not only are the president’s overall approval ratings low but voters usually rate his performance on the crucial issue of the economy even lower.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Bidenomics Can’t Save Biden › Bidenomics Won’t Solve

Bidenomics not key to reelection or agenda

Continetti, American Enterprise Institute Senior Fellow, 6-30-23

[Matthew, 6/30/23, American Enterprise Institute, “’Bidenomics’ Won’t Save This Presidency,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/bidenomics-wont-save-this-presidency, Accessed 7/8/2023, J.D.]

President Biden’s latest pitch for “Bidenomics” is an admission of weakness. Biden knows he’s vulnerable. He and his team can read the polls. They can see that voters’ dismal assessment of the economy is dragging him down.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Dem Internal Link Answers › AT – Bidenomics Boosts Support with Dems

Dems don’t love Biden’s handling of the economy

Boak, Associated Press White House and Economics Writer, et al., 6/28/23

[Josh, Emily Swanson, Associated Press Polling Editor, Chris Megerian, Associated Press White House Reporter, 6/28/23, AP, “President touts ‘Bidenomics’ though new poll shows just 34% approve his handling of the economy,” , 7/8/2023, EJ]

The new poll identifies a weakness within Biden’s own base. Many of the Democrats he needs to marshal in 2024 are comparatively unenthusiastic about his economic record. Seventy-two percent within his party say they approve of his handling of his job overall, but just 60% say they approve of his handling of the economy.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Voters Like Bidenomics

Voters want concrete solutions, not Bidenomics

Potts, FiveThirtyEight 7-11-23

[Monica, 7-11-2023, FiveThirtyEight, "Biden Says The Economy’s Doing Great. Lots Of His Own Voters Don’t Believe Him.," , accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

And it’s not clear that the job market will continue to boom — or that people are all that happy with it. In June, unemployment remained low but job growth slowed somewhat, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. A slim majority of workers are extremely or very satisfied with their jobs overall, according to a Pew Research Center survey from March, but only 34 percent say they’re satisfied with how much they’re paid. Quit rates have also declined since last spring, meaning fewer workers are confident they could find a new and better job if they left their current one.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Voters Like Bidenomics

Americans of all parties hate Bidenomics.

Potts, FiveThirtyEight, 7-11-23

[Monica, 7-11-2023, FiveThirtyEight, "Biden Says The Economy’s Doing Great. Lots Of His Own Voters Don’t Believe Him.," , accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

The economy is doing well. Americans just don’t believe it.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Voters Like Bidenomics

No one is buying Bidenomics

Bade, Politico Senior Washington Correspondent, et al, 7-5-23

[Rachel, Eugene Daniels, Politico Washington Correspondent, Ryan Lizza, Playbook Author, 07-05-2022, "Playbook: The looming battle over ‘Bidenomics’," POLITICO, ]

BUT, BUT, BUT — Biden’s sales pitch continues on Friday, when POTUS will pivot to a focus on his work lowering prescription drug prices for seniors and cracking down on junk fees. The real question is: Are voters even buying what he’s selling?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Bidenomics Helps Biden

Biden economic leadership unpopular

Boak, Associated Press White House and Economics Writer, et al., 6/28/23

[Josh Boak, Emily Swanson, Associated Press Polling Editor, Chris Megerian, Associated Press White House Reporter, 6/28/23, AP, “President touts ‘Bidenomics’ though new poll shows just 34% approve his handling of the economy,” , 7/8/2023, EJ]

CHICAGO (AP) — President Joe Biden made his pitch Wednesday to a skeptical public that the U.S. economy is thriving under what he now touts as “Bidenomics” -- even as a new poll showed that could be a hard sell as the foundation for his 2024 reelection campaign.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Bidenomics Helps Biden

Bidenomics unpopular now – polls prove

Sutton, Politico Financial Services Reporter, 7/5/2023

[Sam, July 5th 2023, Politico, “Voters don’t love Bidenomics. Markets are coming around.”, , Accessed 7/8/2023, S.P.]

Still, despite low unemployment, wage growth and a relatively robust stock market, Americans have given the president dismal marks on economic policy. An Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research poll released last week found that barely a third of respondents approve of Biden’s leadership on economic matters.