Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Bidenomics Helps Biden

Biden in trouble on economics – misery index proves

Brooks, Commentator and New York Times Opinion Columnist, 6-29-23

[David, 6-29-2023, New York Times, "Why Biden isn’t getting the credit he deserves" , Accessed 7/15/23, S.A.M]

The misery index is a crude but effective way to measure the health of the economy. You add up the inflation rate and the unemployment rate. If you’re a president running for re-election, you want that number to be as low as possible.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Bidenomics Helps Biden

Biden leaning in on the economy – but polling on it is NOT GOOD

Knox, Washington Post National Political Correspondent, 6-28-23

[Olivier, 6/28/23, Washington Post, “everything – on ‘Bidenomics’”, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/06/28/biden-bets-lot-not-everything-bidenomics/, Accessed 7/15/23, KCD]

Today, Biden will give what the White House has billed as a “major address” on “Bidenomics” in Chicago. It’s technically an official event, not a campaign speech, but it’s impossible not to see the relevance to his effort to win reelection in 2024. It’s the economy, stupid, to borrow a phrase.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › AT – Bidenomics Helps Biden

Bidenomics messaging flawed – going all-in on the economy will not pay off

Schoen, Former advisor to President Clinton, 7-10-23

[Douglas E., 7-10-23, The Hill, "Why going all in on ‘Bidenomics’ is flawed ," , Accessed 7-10-23, S.A.M]

Last month, the Biden administration kicked off an ambitious nationwide initiative to tout the president’s economic record, labeling it “Bidenomics.” They are framing it as a “middle-out” and “bottom-up” approach to the economy, in direct contrast to the GOP’s longstanding philosophy of supply-side, “trickle-down” economics.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › GOP Using Inflation Against Biden Now

Despite dropping inflation rates, Republicans bashing Biden on the economy

Bolton, The Hill Senior Staff Writer, 7-14-23

[Alexander, 7/14/2023, The Hill, “GOP mulls retooling message as inflation rate plummets,” , Accessed 7/15/2023, J.D.

Some Republicans continue to hammer away on the inflation theme.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Public Perception of Economy Is Bad

Bidenomics perceived badly now

Bade, Politico Senior Washington Correspondent, et al., 7/5/23

[Rachael, Eugene Daniels, Politico White House Correspondent, Ryan Lizza, Politico Chief Washington Correspondent, July 5 2023, Politico, “Playbook: The looming battle over ‘Bidenomics”, , accessed 7/8/2023, S.P.]

BUT, BUT, BUT — Biden’s sales pitch continues on Friday, when POTUS will pivot to a focus on his work lowering prescription drug prices for seniors and cracking down on junk fees. The real question is: Are voters even buying what he’s selling?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Bidenomics Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › Public Perception of Economy Is Bad

Americans generally don’t think the economy is good

Boak, White House and Economics Writer, et al., 6/28/23

[Josh Boak, Emily Swanson, Associated Press Polling Editor, Chris Megerian, Associated Press White House Reporter, 6/28/23, AP, “President touts ‘Bidenomics’ though new poll shows just 34% approve his handling of the economy,” , 7/8/2023, EJ]

Overall, 30% of U.S. adults say they think the national economy is good, up slightly from the 25% who said that last month, when the president and congressional Republicans were in the midst of negotiations over raising the nation’s debt limit and a historic government default was a risk. No more than about a third have called the economy good since 2021.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › No Internal Link – McCarthy Savvy

Mulvaney, Former White House Chief of Staff and house representative, 23

[Mick, 6-5-2023, The Hill, “Is Kevin McCarthy just really that good at his job?,” https://thehill.com/opinion/4032447-is-kevin-mccarthy-just-really-that-good-at-his-job/, accessed 7-2-23, DG]

I’m a little confused. I watch lots of cable news, I read a lot of mainstream media, and I even talk to a lot of elected officials — including sources that lean left (sometimes far left) of how I see the world. And I keep getting the impression that many folks in that universe live in a different Washington, D.C., than the one I know.

This has been especially true recently when it comes to Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › McCarthy Concessions to Right Now

Garcia, The Independent Chief and senior Washington Correspondent, 6-22-23

[Eric, 6-22-23, The Independent, “Kevin McCarthy has turned the House of Representatives into a circus to keep power,” https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/kevin-mccarthy-house-biden-schiff-b2362492.html, accessed 7-3-23, DG]

Earlier this month, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy looked like a hero after he successfully brokered an agreement with the White House to raise the debt limit. Rather than a protracted and drawn-out fight with his own conference that his Republican predecessors faced, most of his conference joined him.

Nevertheless, it looked like his strategy of embracing right-wing lawmakers like Reps Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA), Jim Jordan (R-OH) and Thomas Massie (R-KY) might have paid off. All three voted to make him speaker and then voted to raise the debt limit.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › McCarthy Concessions to Right Now

McCarthy is putting the NDAA in danger from concessions – he needs everyone together

Perano, Daily Beast, 7-14-23

[Ursula, 7-14-2023, Daily Beast "Kevin McCarthy Cedes Speakership to the Far Right Once Again,", , Accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

Indeed, not only are these votes jeopardizing the GOP’s political prospects come next November, they’re also jeopardizing passage of the overall bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › McCarthy Concessions to Right Now

McCarthy is conceding everything to the Far Right

Perano, Daily Beast, 7-14-23

[Ursula, 7-14-2023, Daily Beast "Kevin McCarthy Cedes Speakership to the Far Right Once Again,", , Accessed 7/14/23, S.A.M]

If there’s one lesson from Kevin McCarthy’s speakership, it’s this: In order to stay in power, you have to give up control.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › GOP Divided Now

Republican governing weakened by tumultuous House majority

Weaver, The Hill Staff Writer, 6/11/23

[Al, 6/11/23, The Hill, “Conservative Revolt In House Alarms Senate GOP,” , Accessed 7/3/23, J.D.]

Senate Republicans are growing increasingly concerned with the antics of House conservatives as they paralyze business in the lower chamber with key legislative battles looming in the coming months.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › GOP Divided Now

Inconsistencies in Republican Party make strong agenda changes unlikely

Waldman, Washington Post Columnist, 6/19/23

[Paul, 6/19/23, The Washington Post, “Opinion | How Republicans Are Wasting Their House Majority,” , Accessed 7/3/23, J.D.]

Watching the antics of House Republicans right now, one can imagine an alternate universe in which they made good use of their control of the lower chamber. They would have devised a plan of action compelling in both substance and political strategy, one shrewdly designed to convince the American public that they have a thoughtful vision for governing that can lead the country to a brighter future.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › GOP Divided Now

Shephard, New Republic staff writer, 23

[Alex, 4-28-2023, New Republic, “Kevin McCarthy Is Not Good at This,” https://newrepublic.com/article/172251/kevin-mccarthy-debt-ceiling-bill, accessed 7-2-23, DG]

The debt limit bill narrowly passed by the Republican-controlled House of Representatives on Wednesday evening contains few surprises. The measure is cruel and draconian; it is full of deep and devastating cuts to a series of essential federal programs. It slashes aid for health care, education, and veterans; it cuts taxes for the rich. Its main purpose is to own the libs: It cuts $200 million in maintenance to Nancy Pelosi’s district in California because, well, that’s what Republicans are there to do.

One reason this bill has ended up being particularly bad is that Republicans are currently having to bend over backward to pretend that they’re not actually interested in cutting Medicare and Social Security—just Medicaid. Donald Trump threw a wrench into the party’s decades-long effort to roll back the New Deal by acknowledging that doing so was wildly unpopular—and by making preserving those programs a litmus test in the budding Republican primary. (For what it’s worth, Trump, like all Republicans, isn’t serious about maintaining them either; unlike them, he realizes that actively trying to eviscerate them is bad politics.)

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – McCarthy Link Answers › Uniqueness Answers › GOP Divided Now

Non-unique – GOP angry at McCarthy now

Punchbowl News Staff, 6-8-2023

[Punchbowl News Staff, 6-8-2023, Punchbowl News, “Scalise says Republicans are angry at McCarthy,” , accessed 7-15-23, EJ]

We had a chance to speak at length Wednesday afternoon with McCarthy’s No. 2, House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, about the situation. It was a fascinating conversation.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › CP Links to Politics › EITC Links to Politics

Democrats and Republicans don’t see eye-to-eye on EITC – the program is not bipartisan, and it links to their politics DA.

Rep. Auchincloss (D-MA), 6/28/23

[Jake, 6/28/23, Fox News, “I’m a Democrat, and here’s what I think Republicans should do if they want to pass tax reform,” , ACCESSED 7/13/23, PE]

One – reward work, not wealth. The earned income tax credit (EITC) was Ronald Reagan's favorite tax. Democrats like it, too. It's a negative income tax for the working poor. Congress should expand the EITC by up to 20 percent. To pay for it, repeal the step-up in basis for inheritance taxes, a provision that cuts capital gains taxes for heirs.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › AT – Trump Wants to Cut Social Security

Trump opposes Social Security cuts

McGraw, Politico White House Reporter, 23

[Meridith, 1-20-23, Politico, “Trump to GOP: Don’t touch Medicare or Social Security in debt ceiling fight”, , accessed 7/2/23, S.P.]

Republicans have vowed not to raise the federal government’s borrowing capacity unless Biden makes steep cuts to federal spending, potentially impacting social insurance programs like Social Security and Medicare. Trump’s video is a warning to his fellow party members not to go there. Instead, he suggests targeting foreign aid, cracking down on migration, ending “left wing gender programs from our military,” and “billions being spent on climate extremism.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › AT – GOP Backlash

No link – Republicans don’t want to cut Social Security

Pandolfo, Fox News Reporter, 23

[Chris, 2-8-23, Fox News, “Republicans blast Biden for 'lying shamelessly' about Social Security, Medicare during State of the Union”, , Accessed 6/30/23, S.P.]

GOP lawmakers are furious with the president, who accused them of wanting to hold the economy "hostage" and sunset Social Security and Medicare. Biden's statements were met with raucous boos in the House chamber, and Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., was seen shouting "Liar!" at the president. Others joined in on social media during and after Biden's speech.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › AT – GOP Backlash

Its political suicide if Congress doesn’t reform Social Security

Gloor, AMAC Social Security Advisor, 7-12-23

[Russell Gloor, 7-12-23, Main Line Times & Suburban, “Ask Rusty: Will Social Security be there for me?,” , accessed 7-15-23, EJ].

Dear Weary Worker: I don’t suggest changing your strategy due to fears of Social Security not being there — it will be.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › Democrats Support Social Security Expansion Act

Multiple Democrats support the Social Security Expansion Act

Sen. Gillibrand (D-NY) Press Release, 23

[Kirsten, 3/2/23, Kirsten Gillibrand Press Release, “Gillibrand Fights to Expand Social Security Benefits and Extend Program’s Solvency Through 2096,” , Accessed 7/2/23 J.D.]

Today, U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand [Dem- NY] held a video press conference announcing the Social Security Expansion Act of 2023. In 2021, Social Security lifted 26.3 million Americans out of poverty, but fast-rising costs and the aging population are putting benefits of current retirees and future generations at risk. This bill would expand Social Security benefits by $2,400 a year and ensure Social Security is fully funded for the next 70+ years – all without raising taxes by one penny on over 93% of American households that make $250,000 or less.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › Bipartisanship

Bolstering Social Security has bipartisan support – ensuring cooperation

Kull, University of Maryland Program for Public Consultation director, Youngblood, Common Ground Solutions executive director, ‘21

[Steven, Jillian, 1/08/21, The Hill, “Congress Must Listen to the People,” , Accessed 7/2/2023, J.D.]

As the new session of Congress kicks off, there is substantial concern that it is headed for the same kind of gridlock as in the last one. Indeed, 2020 was the least productive year for Congress in recent memory. The violent clashes at the Capitol this week have further added to the public notion of a fractured country. One of the common reasons for this state of affairs is that Americans are divided on the issues and there is little that lawmakers can do without fear of backlash from their constituents.