2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Social Security Link Answers › Bipartisanship
Brin, Think Advisor Financial Journalist, 22
[Diana, 9/16/22, Think Advisor, “New Study Finds Broad Bipartisan Support for Social Security Fixes,” https://www.thinkadvisor.com/2022/09/16/new-study-finds-broad-bipartisan-support-for-social-security-fixes/, Accessed 7/2/23, J.D.]
What You Need to Know
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Public Won’t Support Climate Policies
Deiseroth, Data for Progress Interim Executive Director and Blank, Data for Progress Journalist 21
[Danielle, Lew, 4/19/21, Data for Progress, “Voters Overwhelmingly Support the Green New Deal,” Accessed 7/2/23, S.A.M]
The Green New Deal Remains Popular
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Public Won’t Support Climate Policies
Lloyd, Scientific American, 22
[Robin, 8-23-2022, Scientific American, "Climate Change Actions Are Far More Popular Than People in U.S. Realize," accessed 7-2-2023, S.A.M]
A multibillion-dollar slate of moderate climate-mitigation measures in the Biden administration’s Inflation Reduction Act has been met so far with general public approval. But a broader reaction to the historic federal action underlies the discourse: What took you so long?
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
[Marcela, Saul, 3-11-22, Data for Progress, “The Green New Deal is Incredibly Popular,” https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2022/3/11/the-green-new-deal-is-incredibly-popular, date accessed 6-30-23, DG]
The climate crisis is in full swing, and by now, nearly every community in the United States has experienced a hurricane, flood, wildfire, heat wave, or other event that is unfamiliarly severe or strangely timed. Over the past three years, the campaign for a Green New Deal (GND) has successfully reframed the conversation away from strictly technology and market solutions, and toward heavy public investment as the core solution needed to stabilize the climate. In many ways, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and the reconciliation bill are watered-down policies carrying many pieces of the Green New Deal. But as the negotiations for the reconciliation bill drag on, the Green New Deal is gaining steam once again.
New polling finds the Green New Deal is incredibly popular among voters — nearly across the board. Three new core GND bills were introduced for the first time last year in Congress: the Green New Deal for Cities, the Green New Deal for Public Schools, and the Civilian Climate Corps. Numerous other bills have shifted the climate conversation, improved existing bills, and built out other aspects of the vision.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
[Alec, Cary Funk, director of science and society research at Pew Research Center, Brian Kennedy, senior researcher at Pew Research Center, 4-18-2023, Pew Research Center, “What the data says about Americans’ views of climate change,” https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/04/18/for-earth-day-key-facts-about-americans-views-of-climate-change-and-renewable-energy/, accessed 7-2-23, DG]
A recent report from the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has underscored the need for international action to avoid increasingly severe climate impacts in the years to come. Steps outlined in the report, and by climate experts, include major reductions in greenhouse gas emissions from sectors such as energy production and transportation.
But how do Americans feel about climate change, and what steps do they think the United States should take to address it? Here are eight charts that illustrate Americans’ views on the issue, based on recent Pew Research Center surveys.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
[Zoya, 10-14-20, Grist, “Feeling the Heat How the Green New Deal lit a fire under the GOP,” https://grist.org/politics/republican-party-climate-change/, accessed 7-3-23, DG]
Regardless, the Green New Deal was a hit with Americans. In July 2019, it had a higher approval rating in a survey of adults than a wealth tax, a semi-automatic assault gun ban, and free college tuition. (It polled on par with legalizing marijuana.) The unexpected popularity of the proposal forced Republicans to start coming up with a plan of their own.
“What the Green New Deal did is bring the issue of climate change to greater prominence,” Carlos Curbelo, a Republican climate hawk who lost his House seat in South Florida amid the 2018 Democratic wave, told Grist. “So it became harder for conservatives to ignore the issue.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
Wilkins, Common Dreams writer, 21
[Brett, 4-19-21, Common Dreams, “Poll Finds Majority of US Voters Back Green New Deal and Want Lawmakers to Co-Sponsor Resolution,” https://www.commondreams.org/news/2021/04/19/poll-finds-majority-us-voters-back-green-new-deal-and-want-lawmakers-co-sponsor, date accessed 7-1-23, DG]
As Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Sen. Bernie Sanders reintroduced their "Green New Deal for Public Housing," a survey published Monday affirmed that most U.S. voters support the Green New Deal and want their members of Congress to co-sponsor legislation to make the ambitious climate emergency plan a reality.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
Deiseroth, Data for Progress Senior Climate Data Analyst and Blank, Data for Progress senior writer, 21
[Danielle, Lew, 4-19-21, Data for progress, “Voters Overwhelmingly Support the Green New Deal,” https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2021/4/19/voters-support-green-new-deal#:~:text=The%20Green%20New%20Deal%20remains,sponsor%20the%20Green%20New%20Deal, accessed 6-30, DG]
In 2019, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Ed Markey introduced the Green New Deal, a landmark resolution outlining the critical steps America should take to tackle the climate crisis, address environmental injustices, and ensure every American has access to a good-paying job. Since the Green New Deal’s introduction, Data for Progress has conducted extensive research and polling on the popularity of the bill and its policy planks.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › AT – Green New Deal Unpopular
[YouGov Blue, 3-19-19, Data for Progress “Memo: U.S Voters Strongly Support Bold Climate Solutions,” https://www.dataforprogress.org/the-green-new-deal-is-popular, accessed 7-2-23, DG]
On behalf of 350 Action and Data for Progress, YouGov Blue fielded an online survey of US voters from March 3, 2019-March 11, 2019. This survey is based on 1,025 interviews conducted by YouGov on the Internet on the population of self-identified voters. The sample was weighted according to gender, age, race, education, and Census region based on registered voters in the November 2016 Current Population Survey, conducted by the U.S. Bureau of the Census. Respondents were selected from YouGov's panel to be representative of registered voters. The weights range from 0.33 to 4.4 with a mean of 1 and a standard deviation of 0.51.
This memo focuses on the results of three items related to the Green New Deal, federal climate policy and the influence of fossil fuel money in politics. The first is concerned with a policy known as “keep it in the ground,” designed to phase out fossil fuels, which are the primary drivers of climate change. The second is concerned with the creation of jobs through clean-energy investments in American communities and infrastructure. The third is concerned with a pledge candidates for office in the United States might sign to reject campaign contributions from fossil fuel corporations, which have a vested interest in stopping or curtailing climate action.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Green New Deal Link Answers › Democrats Support Green New Deal
Sen. Markey (D-MA) Press Release 4-20-23
(Rep. Alexandria Ocasio Cortez and Sen. Bernie Sanders are Democrats from New York and Vermont Respectively.)
[4-20-2023, The Office of Sen. Markey, “MARKEY AND OCASIO-CORTEZ REINTRODUCE GREEN NEW DEAL RESOLUTION,” https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/markey-and-ocasio-cortez-reintroduce-green-new-deal-resolution/, accessed 6/30/23, S.A.M]
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Politically Popular
O'Neill, Brown Political Review writer, 20
[Thomas, 12-29-20, Brown Political Review, “Radical or Reasonable? The Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee,” , accessed 7-2-23, JC]
Several notable Democrats have already come out in favor of a federal jobs guarantee. New York Senator advocated for full employment sponsored by the government during her 2020 presidential primary campaign. Known progressives, of New York’s 14th District and of Vermont, have both endorsed a jobs guarantee. While no Republicans have come out in support of one, a federal jobs guarantee can appeal to the core of both the Republican and Democratic parties. For Democrats, an FJG builds upon the party’s history of commitment to the American working class. Meanwhile, Republicans can rally behind a program that rewards work with a paycheck rather than blanket unemployment payments.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Politically Popular
Darity, Duke Sanford School of Public Policy professor & Milam The Justice Collaborative Institute Senior Advisor, 20
[William, Jr. & Dawn, 9-18-20, The Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity, “THE CASE FOR A FEDERAL JOB GUARANTEE PROGRAM,”, accessed 7-2-23, JC]
Polling by Data for Progress and The Justice Collaborative Institute shows strong bipartisan support for a federal job guarantee program. Sixty-four percent of likely voters, including 78% of Democrats and 53% of Republicans, said they would support a federal job guarantee program as part of the government’s response to the economic crisis.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Politically Popular
Loomis, University of Rhode Island history professor, 18
[Erik, 4-25-18, The New York Times, “The Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee,” , accessed on 7-2-23, JC]
Job creation fits American cultural norms around work more effectively than the idea of universal basic income. It avoids politically unpopular forms of welfare while significantly bolstering the welfare state for those who need it. Encouraging private sector job creation would limit the impact on the deficit while adding tax money to the nation’s coffers.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Democrats Support Jobs Guarantee
Rep. Pressley Press Release, 21
[Ayanna, 2-18-21, Pressley website, “REP. PRESSLEY, ECONOMISTS, ADVOCATES UNVEIL HISTORIC FEDERAL JOB GUARANTEE RESOLUTION,” , accessed 6-20-23, JC]
“It’s time to establish a legal right to a job for all people in America. For years, we have legislated hate, harm and injustice in this country. It’s long past time to pursue bold, intentional policies that affirm equity and recognize the dignity and humanity of all people,” Congresswoman Pressley said. “A federal job guarantee is an important investment in the American people, our communities, and an equitable economy that works for all. It affirms the right to meaningful, dignified work and a living wage. I’m proud to build upon and honor the legacy and work of generations of Black women Civil Rights leaders by introducing this historic resolution.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Democrats Support Jobs Guarantee
Sen. Booker (D-NJ), 19
[Cory Booker, 9-12-19, Cory Booker, “Sen. Booker, Reps. Watson Coleman and Omar Introduce Bicameral Bill to Create Federal Jobs Guarantee Program,” , 7/2/23, EJ]
“In a 21st century America, the ability to find stable work should be a human right. This is not a Democratic or Republican idea—it is an idea that is overwhelmingly popular with the American people. Over a decade after the Great Recession, communities across the country are still suffering from low wages, inconsistent work, and a tax code that prioritizes the needs of the wealthy over working people. If we are going to build an economy that works for everybody, we as a nation have a responsibility to make sure everyone who wants work can find it. In 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. called on our government to ‘guarantee a job to all people who want to work and are able to work.’ I am proud to join Senator Booker and Representative Bonnie Watson Coleman to make the vision of Dr. King’s vision a reality,” Rep. Omar said.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Democrats Support Jobs Guarantee
Sen. Booker (D-NJ), 19
[Cory Booker, 9-12-19, Cory Booker, “Sen. Booker, Reps. Watson Coleman and Omar Introduce Bicameral Bill to Create Federal Jobs Guarantee Program,” , accessed 7/2/23, EJ]
“We have roads and bridges in disrepair, families that can’t find childcare, aging and toxic water infrastructure, and communities paying more for their energy costs than is necessary which means there are plenty of jobs available and unfilled. This is not the result of a lack of people willing to do the work, it’s a gap created because localities cannot afford to pay them. The Federal Jobs Guarantee Act creates a pilot program for the communities who need it most, giving good paying jobs to people who have suffered while both wages and opportunities have dwindled. The work they’ll do will make tangible improvements in those same communities and reverberate through the national economy,” Rep. Watson Coleman said.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Democrats Support Jobs Guarantee
Sen. Booker (D-NJ), 19
[Cory Booker, 9-12-19, Cory Booker, “Sen. Booker, Reps. Watson Coleman and Omar Introduce Bicameral Bill to Create Federal Jobs Guarantee Program,” , accessed 7/2/23, EJ]
“Both Martin Luther King, Jr., and President Franklin Roosevelt believed that every American had the right to a job, and that government would see to it that every person who wants to work would be able to. This legislation is an attempt to fulfill that ambitious vision. A federal jobs guarantee is a major investment in our country’s most valuable asset – our workers – by getting them off the sidelines and into the labor force with a living wage and meaningful benefits, like paid sick leave and safe working conditions. Addressing the entrenched structural hurdles that hinder workers’ success by offering bold solutions is how we strengthen the working class, grow the economy, and broaden prosperity and dignity for workers in this country,” Senator Booker said.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Democrats Support Jobs Guarantee
Sen. Booker (D-NJ), 19
[Cory Booker, 9-12-19, Cory Booker, “Sen. Booker, Reps. Watson Coleman and Omar Introduce Bicameral Bill to Create Federal Jobs Guarantee Program,” , accessed 7/2/23, EJ]
WASHINGTON, D.C. — U.S. Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ), Reps. Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-NJ), and Ilhan Omar (D-MN), today reintroduced ambitious legislation to create a three-year pilot program at the Department of Labor to test the promise and impact of a federal jobs guarantee in up to 15 communities and regions experiencing high unemployment. The Federal Jobs Guarantee Development Act would guarantee that adults in participating communities who want to work can do so, in a job that pays a living wage and provides benefits like health insurance, paid sick leave, and paid family leave. When it was originally introduced in 2018, this was the first federal jobs guarantee legislation ever to be introduced in Congress.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Popular
Smith, Prism Writer, 22
[Trevor Smith, 1-21-22, Prism, “BIPOC workers won’t see ‘full employment’ without a federal jobs guarantee,” , accessed 7/3/23, EJ]
However, in 80 years following the success of the New Deal, no similarly ambitious and far-reaching jobs program has been implemented, but the time to do so may have finally arrived. While some opponents point to the high cost of such a program, recent polls have shown that a Federal Jobs Guarantee has bipartisan support. A September 2020 Data for Progress poll found that 78% of Democrats and 53% of Republicans agreed that a Federal Jobs Guarantee was a viable way for the government to address the economic upheaval wrought by COVID-19. After Democrats regained control of the House in early 2021, Congresswoman Ayanna Pressley introduced a resolution for the federal government to recognize its duty in creating a Federal Jobs Guarantee. The resolution would fulfill the “promise of full employment, ensure a just, equitable recovery, establish a more resilient and inclusive economy, and begin to close racial and gender income gaps,” echoing former President Roosevelt’s thwarted attempts to establish an Economic Bill of Rights and pass the Employment Act of 1946.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
AFF – Topic Link Answers › Jobs Guarantee Link Answers › Job Guarantee Popular
Rader, Christopher Newport University Political Science Professor & Guadron, Data Analyst, 6-15-23
[Katie Rader, Carissa Guadron, 6-15-23, The Nation, “What Running on a Jobs Guarantee Could Mean for Democrats,” , 6/30/23, EJ]
In fact, one of the clearest findings from a new survey launched by the Center for Working Class Politics (CWCP) is the persistence of support for progressive jobs proposals as part of a broader economic strategy. In our first study, titled “Commonsense Solidarity,” we found that candidates who run on bread-and-butter economic issues like jobs policies fare better with working-class voters than candidates that do not. In the survey we just launched, “Trump’s Kryptonite,” respondents were given the choice between candidates with a variety of demographic characteristics and policy positions, including two jobs policies: one a more moderate and mainstream jobs proposal, and the other advocating a bold federal jobs guarantee. Both policies were broadly popular across the group of respondents, underscoring the continued importance of jobs policies for American voters.