Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Topic Link Arguments › Generic Link Arguments › AT – Plan Is Bipartisan

The plan deepens partisan divide, makes opponents politically constrained to oppose what the other side proposes.

Kolbert, The New Yorker, 21

[Condé Nast, 12-27-21, The New Yorker, "How Politics Got So Polarized," , Accessed 7/3/23 S.A.M]

Lilliana Mason is a political scientist at Johns Hopkins. In “Uncivil Agreement: How Politics Became Our Identity,” she notes that not so very long ago the two parties were hard to tell apart, both demographically and ideologically. In the early nineteen-fifties, Blacks were split more or less evenly between the two parties, and so were whites. The same held for men, Catholics, and union members. The parties’ platforms, meanwhile, were so similar that the American Political Science Association issued a plea that Democrats and Republicans make more of an effort to distinguish themselves: “Alternatives between the parties are defined so badly that it is often difficult to determine what the election has decided even in broadest terms.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness – AT – Polling

Polls this far out are worthless – prefer our predictive evidence

Baker, New York Times White House correspondent, 5-8-23

(Peter, 5-8-23, New York Times. “Biden Casts Himself as the Trump Beater. Polls Suggest That’s No Sure Thing.”. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/08/us/politics/biden-2024-polls.html)

Others cautioned against overanalyzing data this early, noting that anything can happen in the next 18 months and recalling that projections based on polling — or misinterpretations of polling — proved to be poor predictors in recent cycles, including the 2022 midterm elections when a forecast “red wave” did not materialize.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness – Progressives Support Biden

Progressive environmental groups coalescing around Biden -this answers all their claims that the left doesn’t see Biden as progressive enough on climate – and they’ll still vote for him because the alternative is worse

Nilse, CNN climate reporter, 6-14-23

(Ella , 6-14-23, CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/14/politics/joe-biden-lcv-speech/index.html)

Four major environmental groups endorsed President Joe Biden’s 2024 reelection for president on Wednesday night, ahead of his speech at a League of Conservation Voters dinner in the nation’s capital.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness – Progressives Support Biden

Progressives have committed to sticking with Biden --- they might not love Biden but they hate the GOP alternatives

Dovere, CNN senior reporter, 7-13-23

(Edward-Isaac, 7-13-23, CNN, Senior reporter for CNN, covering Democratic politics and campaigns across the country. Slow pace of Biden’s reelection campaign feeds Democrats’ 2024 anxiety. )

Some frustrated next generation Democratic operatives compare Biden to a house guest who’s overstayed his welcome whom they still have all agreed to back at this moment. More committed progressives say they are ready to fall in line too because of the threat they believe Trump and other Republicans pose – “it’s basically a popular front to stop what Biden calls the attacks on freedom,” said Larry Cohen, the former president of the Communications Workers of America and board chair of the Bernie Sanders-aligned Our Revolution.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness & Internal Link – Biden Wins

Biden wins the nomination – No serious primary challengers

Samuels, 538, 4-25-23

(Alex, 4-25-23, Fivethiryeight.com. Biden Is Running For Reelection. What Are His Chances For 2024? https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/biden-reelection-2024-chances/)

That ennui might be unavoidable for Biden, because a number of polls and reports suggest that Democrats’ biggest issue with Biden isn’t his performance in office — it’s his age. Biden was the oldest living president the day he was sworn into office, and according to a USA Today/Suffolk Poll from mid-April, a plurality of 2020 Biden voters (42 percent) said that his age makes them less likely to support him. What might work in Biden’s favor, though, at least in a primary, is that 55 percent of his voters said his age didn’t make a difference to them. Meanwhile, a second survey from CNN/SSRS conducted in March found that two-thirds of adults felt as though Biden doesn’t have the stamina and sharpness to serve effectively. And there are also real concerns that he’s not a particularly motivating figure, even if Democrats probably prefer him to a Republican alternative. That CNN/SSRS survey found that a majority of respondents thought that Biden does not inspire confidence (65 percent) and does not care about people like them (54 percent).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness & Internal Link – Biden Wins

Its close but Biden leads Trump – polls show a 1 point lead

SHAPERO, The Hill Breaking News reporter, 7-11-23

(Julia, 7-11-23, The Hill, “Trump slips behind Biden in hypothetical match-up: poll.”https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4091122-trump-slips-behind-biden-in-hypothetical-matchup-poll/#:~:text=Former%20President%20Trump%20slipped%20behind,would%20back%20the%20former%20president)

Former President Trump slipped behind President Biden in a hypothetical 2024 match-up, according to a new Morning Consult poll.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness & Internal Link – Biden Wins

Biden wins now and independent voters are key

Burton & Alomran, Data for Progress Senior analyst and lead analyst, 6-21-23

(Brian & Isa, 6-21-23, Data for Progress. A No Labels Candidate Would Be an Unserious Contender and a Threat to Democracy. https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2023/6/21/a-no-labels-candidate-would-be-an-unserious-contender-and-a-threat-to-democracy)

As things look right now, a hypothetical rematch between Biden and Trump would already be a relatively close race. In a two-way race between the candidates, we find that Biden beats Trump by a +2-point margin across all likely voters. Importantly, while both candidates expectedly win the lion’s share of their own party’s voters, Biden’s victory in this head-to-head is largely driven by a +6-point advantage among Independent voters, where he beats out Trump 43 percent to 37 percent. Given the candidates’ matching leads among their own voters, successfully appealing to Independent voters of all stripes becomes an even more critical deciding factor in this hypothetical race.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

Even small shifts in working class votes can swing the election

Leonhardt, New York Times Senior writer, 6-13-23

(David, 6-13-23, The New York Times. How Democrats Can Win Workers. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/13/briefing/democrats-elections-poll.html)

A key point is that even modest shifts in the working-class vote can decide elections. If President Biden wins 50 percent of the non-college vote next year, he will almost certainly be re-elected. If he wins only 45 percent, he will probably lose.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

Working class swing voters will be a critical voting bloc to Biden reelection – he CANNOT win within them

Weissert & Kim, National Political Reporter, 6-16-23

(Will & Seung Min, 6-16-23, NBC Philadelphia, “Biden is returning to union roots as 2024 campaign gears up in Philly.” https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/decision-2024/biden-is-returning-to-union-roots-as-2024-campaign-gears-up-in-philly/3586893/)

Joe Biden opened his 2020 presidential run at a Pittsburgh union hall, declaring, “I'm a union man. Period." As he gears up for reelection, the president's first political rally is being held at a union gathering on the other side of Pennsylvania, punctuating just how much Biden is counting on labor support to carry him to a second term — especially in a critical battleground state.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

New spending will be attacked as inflationary

Jonathan Chait 3-20-23 (Political Columnist. NY Intelligencer. Why Joe Biden’s Honeymoon With Progressives Is Coming to an End Expect a lot more Democratic infighting. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/03/why-bidens-honeymoon-with-progressives-is-coming-to-an-end.html)

A key foundation to Biden’s expansive domestic agenda was a long period of low inflation and interest rates and economic slack. Deficit hawks had lost the argument within the party because there was no cost to red ink. The government could simply borrow as much money as it wanted, and investors would lend it to them for very little cost.

Meanwhile, the great recession had left a legacy of chronically slack labor markets and stagnant wages. The economy had just begun to approach full employment when the pandemic struck in 2020. The overriding economic imperative was to get back to full employment as fast as possible, even if it meant running high deficits.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

Economic policy will be the primary issue framing Biden’s reelection campaign – its essential he focuses on his past legislative successes and persuade Americans things are getting better because of him – the plan shifts that narrative at a critical point in the cycle

Popli, Time, 7-7-23

(Nik, 7-7-23, TIME, “Why Joe Biden is Running on the Economy.” https://time.com/6292925/joe-biden-economy-election-2024/)

With the presidential election just over one year away, the Biden Administration faces a challenge: how to convince skeptical voters that the economy is in much better shape than they think.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

The plan is a huge tax and spend liberal policy that comes exactly when Biden can’t be seen as adding to the inflationary fires – this turns off moderate and independent voters who will decide the election

Marshall, Progressive Policy Institute founder and president, 7-14-23

(Will, 7-14-23, The Hill. “Why working families aren’t sold on Bidenomics.”https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/4095230-what-bidenomics-is-missing-the-needs-of-everyday-people/)

The U.S. economy presents a frustratingly mixed picture. Viewed from some angles — low unemployment, rising wages and bullish financial markets — it conveys strength. From others – high prices, interest rates and debt — it looks heavily burdened and susceptible to recession.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Link Block

This is a risky political strategy and Biden MUST stay on his centrist economic message to win back moderate and independent voters that are crucial to re-election

Schoen, Political consultant who served as an advisor to President Clinton. Contributor, 7-10-23

(Douglas E., 7-10-23, The Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/4088051-why-going-all-in-on-bidenomics-is-flawed/)

Instead, to win back moderate and independent voters in the 2024 general election, Biden would be wise to run on a centrist message highlighting his bipartisan legislative successes as well as his efforts to reduce the deficit and the national debt.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness Framing

Selling Bidenomics and the success of centrist policies to swing state independents and moderate Democrats is critical to 2024

Chen, CNN, 7-10-23

(Lanhee J. CNN. Opinion: This is the truth about ‘Bidenomics’. https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/10/opinions/bidenomics-2024-presidential-election-challenge-chen/index.html)

President Joe Biden’s recent adoption of “Bidenomics,” an economic theory based on using the power and resources of the federal government to help generate jobs and economic growth, has become fodder for the Republican presidential candidates competing to run against him. Recently, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ campaign released a memo tying the term to higher prices and inflation, while South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott took to the airwaves with a similar critique.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness Framing

Biden centrist economist policies have done enough for the middle class to get him over the finish line

Bloomberg 7-5-23

(By Shawn Donnan, Claire Ballentine, Alexandre Tanzi and Christopher Cannon. The US Middle Class’s Economic Anxiety Will Decide the 2024 Election.https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2023-bidenomics-middle-class-economic-anxiety-2024-election/?in_source=embedded-checkout-banner)

Joe Biden is obsessed with the American middle class. It’s the very spine of the US economy, as the president regularly puts it, and the deliberate target of everything from his administration’s efforts to rewrite economic policy and seed an industrial revival to its foreign policy and geopolitical competition with China.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness Framing

Biden has work back working-class voters through centrist job creation and blue-collar pocketbook policies –

Jonathan Weisman, NY Times political correspondent, 2-8-23

(Jonathan, 2-8-23, NY Times. “Biden Aims to Win Back White Working-Class Voters Through Their Wallets.” https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/08/us/politics/biden-blue-collar-white-voters.html)

With his call for a “blue-collar blueprint to rebuild America,” President Biden on Tuesday night acknowledged rhetorically what Democrats have been preparing for two years: a fierce campaign to win back white working-class voters through the creation of hundreds of thousands of well-paid jobs that do not require a college degree.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Uniqueness Framing

Biden is changing the narrative – he’s leaning into his economic successes which will ultimately resonate with voters and lock up a 2nd term

Waldman, Washington Post columnist, 7-12-23

(Paul, 7-12-23, The Washington Post. How Biden learned to stop apologizing and love the economy. )

Something has come over President Biden and his White House. Rather than talking about the economy in their usual tone of apology and nuance lest someone think they haven’t acknowledged the feelings of anyone who might be unhappy, the “Bidenomics” push has become positively triumphal.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Impact Block

More evidence – there are preparations to dismantle civil institutions

The Economist 7-13-23

(7--13-23, The Economist, “A second Trump administration would get its way far more than the first.” https://www.economist.com/briefing/2023/07/13/a-second-trump-administration-would-get-its-way-far-more-than-the-first)

The resemblance is not a coincidence. Mrs Rollins worked in the White House under Donald Trump and briefly ran his Domestic Policy Council. She purchased her West Wing furniture when she left. Towards the end of Mr Trump’s first term, she was in charge of putting together a policy agenda for his second one. After Mr Trump lost his bid for re-election in 2020, she set up a think-tank to continue that work, the America First Policy Institute (afpi).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Impact Block

And, there would be absolutely no checks on Trump’s agenda in a second term – this time around they could dismantle democracy and the global order with ruthless efficiency

The Economist 7-13-23

(7-13-23, Economist, “How MAGA Republicans plan to make Donald Trump’s second term count.”, https://www.economist.com/leaders/2023/07/13/how-maga-republicans-plan-to-make-donald-trumps-second-term-count)

The overwhelming memory of Donald Trump’s time in office is of chaos and resentment. It was summed up by the shameful end to his presidency, when his whipped-up supporters sacked the Capitol in a bid to keep him in power. Mr Trump has since lurched from an ignominious post-electoral impeachment to two criminal indictments, with perhaps more in the offing. The former president seems obsessed with relitigating his election loss in 2020: “I am your justice,” he thundered to a crowd of supporters this year. “I am your retribution.”