Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Impact Block

A Trump presidency makes nuclear war with North Korea likely – empirically proven

Levin, Vanity Fair politics correspondent, 7-10-23

(Bess, 7-10-23, Vanity Fair. “Trump Administration Officials Were Legitimately Worried About Trump Provoking Nuclear War With North Korea: Report.” https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2023/07/donald-trump-miles-taylor-north-korea-nuclear-war)

There are countless reasons to worry about the prospect of Donald Trump winning a second term in office. One of them is his reported plan to purge the government of career employees with actual expertise, and replace them with only the most hard-core loyalists. Another is that whole January 6 insurrection business, a.k.a. how he reacts when things don’t go his way. Then there’s the fact that he’s an abject racist and a massive bigot; a threat to reproductive rights; an unapologetic grifter; a certified sexual predator; a pathological liar; and a friend to very bad people. Oh, and also the fact that during his first time in office, his own officials feared he was going to get America reduced to nuclear waste.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Impact Block

Dembicki, Vice investigative climate reporter 20

[Geoff Dembicki, 2-12-20, Vice, “Here's Exactly How a Trump 2020 Win Would Spark a Nightmare Climate Scenario,” ]#NCC

Let’s say Donald Trump wins the election in 2020. There’s no doubt some climate advocates will try to put an optimistic spin on it—just like they did when he first won in 2016. Renewable energy is getting cheaper all the time, they’ll argue. Investors are moving rapidly away from fossil fuels. The European Union and China are stepping up to solve the emergency. And so are U.S. states and cities. Young people are becoming a political force to be reckoned with. All of this was true four years ago, and will continue to be accurate if Trump begins a second term. But none of it will change a horrifying reality: a re-elected and emboldened Trump would likely destroy the world’s best-case outcome on climate change, and potentially send us hurtling towards a worst-case scenario. His second term could result in global temperatures roaring past 1.5 degrees Celsius, the danger line identified in the devastating United Nations climate report from 2018, beyond which forests, croplands, freshwater sources and other natural systems that support human life could be irreversibly transformed. We would also likely surpass 2 degrees, the target the world’s nations agreed to in 2015 at Paris, raising the odds of catastrophic tipping points like the melting of all Arctic sea ice. Trump's reelection dramatically increases these risks not only because of the massive additional emissions his fossil fuel-boosting policies could cause—potentially as much as 3.1 gigatons by 2035, which is over four times the entire annual carbon footprint of Canada. A second Trump term could also mean that one by one, countries drop out of the Paris agreement, possibly causing it to unravel completely. In this scenario, keeping temperature rise below 2 degrees would be extremely difficult. “I would say it would make [achieving] it impossible,” said Noah Sachs, a University of Richmond environmental law professor who described in a paper last year what Paris self-destructing could look like. “If Paris fell apart, we would blow right by that target.” That would mean that virtually all the planet’s coral reefs will bleach a sickly white. The world will lose more than 155,000 square miles of coastal wetlands and drylands. The number of people unable to access reliable drinking water could double. Hundreds of millions won’t have enough nutritious food to eat. And Trump, who turns 74 this June, likely won’t even be around to see it happen. The world is on the cusp of climate disaster Global temperature rise above 2 degrees wouldn't mean the imminent collapse of civilization. Nor would it mean the world should give up on cutting emissions. We’re already facing monumental disasters like the Australian bushfires, and the impacts of climate change will get exponentially more destructive and harder to survive with each increase in global temperature. This will make it worth fighting for carbon reductions, no matter how warm the planet gets. But above the 2 degrees goal that countries signed up for in the Paris agreement, damage could come at a scale that’s hard to fathom. In a 1.5 degrees scenario the probability of an ice-free Arctic summer is 3 percent in a given year. At 2 degrees that rises to 16 percent. And at 3 degrees it’s 63 percent. Sea-level rise at that scale means cities such as Miami, Osaka, Alexandria and Shanghai could effectively cease to exist. Meanwhile, there could be disasters like 97 percent of wildfire-sensitive regions in Mediterranean Europe burning every single summer. The chance of the American West going up in flames could increase by 400 percent. The Rhodium Group, a New York-based research firm, calculated in December that for humankind to keep warming below 2 degrees, we need to reduce emissions a colossal one-third from current levels by 2030. They identified five crucial things that could get us globally on track toward closing that gap: the European Union adopting a Green New Deal, Brazil halting its destruction of the Amazon Rainforest, China’s economic growth and the emissions it produces slowing to a more sustainable rate, and demand for electricity in India growing only moderately and being met mainly by renewables. The fifth one is Trump losing in 2020. Trump has already done a significant amount of damage A re-elected Trump would keep dismantling environmental rules—he's slashed 95 in total so far—that limit fossil fuel companies or other polluters of the atmosphere. And he would make the damage much harder to reverse by continuing to stack the courts with conservative judges who tend to rule on the side of greenhouse gas-spewing corporations. There already aren’t many years left to reduce emissions on the scale necessary to avoid further devastation. Trump's second term would at the very least be more wasted time. If the U.S. is to have any hope of meeting the 1.5 degrees goal, its emissions need to be reduced 40 or 50 percent from 2005 levels by 2030. But the Trump administration has wiped out Barack Obama–era emissions standards for cars and trucks, allowed oil and gas producers to release all the methane they want and engaged in many other acts of climate destruction. This would leave only six years to close a massive gap after the end of a second Trump term, after which U.S. emissions cuts might only hit 12 to 19 percent, according to the Rhodium group. And that estimate is based only on existing Trump rollbacks. “If he were elected for an additional four years, it’s very likely that the administration would do more to further erode the progress that the Obama administration made,” said Kate Larsen, a director with Rhodium who leads the group’s international climate and energy research. The increase in U.S. emissions would be a major global setback, given how rapidly the world’s carbon footprint needs to shrink over the next decade. So would the lack of leadership needed to help other countries meet their national goals. “If the Trump administration continues its current policies, the multi-gigaton emissions gap that the world will have to close will be much harder,” Larsen said of keeping global temperature rise below 2 degrees. “Without the U.S. there, it’s hard to see how that would happen.” Trump will send the fossil fuel industry into overdrive Insofar as Trump has any kind of coherent or consistent ideology guiding his presidency, it’s to do as many favors as possible for the fossil fuel companies who have unprecedented access to his administration. Some observers refer to this as Trump’s “energy dominance” agenda. “It really emphasizes maximizing U.S. production of oil and gas, maximizing exports of oil and gas and petroleum products,” said David Goldwyn, a former special envoy to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. “It means rolling back, or revising, or rescinding regulations, which they perceive as putting costs or time delays on fossil energy production.” Goldwyn and his colleague Andrea Clabough described the gifts oil and gas companies could receive from a reelected Trump in a paper this January for the Atlantic Council. These gifts include legislation handicapping the ability of states and tribal authorities to oppose fossil fuel projects, doubling down on efforts to open Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling, and a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission dominated by Republicans, meaning even less environmental oversight of new oil pipelines or liquefied natural gas terminals. Granting the fossil fuel industry’s wildest wish list is an ongoing project—last week, the administration finalized a policy giving energy companies mining access to 5 million acres of previously federally protected wilderness. Trump is also locking in the damage further by appointing conservative judges favorable to these rollbacks. These include Brett Kavanaugh, a longtime opponent of climate regulations. Trump’s administration has already appointed 50 federal appeals judges, compared to the 55 Obama appointed during his entire eight-year presidency, a trend that will continue in Trump’s second term as long as Republicans maintain control of the Senate. If those judges make rulings limiting the government's power to fight climate change, future administrations—Democratic or Republican—could have a difficult time reversing the onslaught of climate-destroying regulations during the dwindling years we have left to hit 1.5 or 2 degrees. “In that respect, the outcome of the election is highly determinative of the future course of [climate and energy] regulation,” Goldwyn explained. Trump will block the government from fighting climate change Even with Trump and his fossil fuel executive allies vandalizing the atmosphere until 2024, Goldwyn said the best-case climate scenario of 1.5 degrees is not out of reach. “Regardless of who wins the U.S. election, the investment in technology that will both reduce the cost and increase the volume of greenhouse gas reduction… I think will continue and intensify,” he argued. “That push is going to continue from private companies, from the innovation space in the United States, from our universities, as well as from the Europeans and from China.” Others aren’t convinced. Though it’s now cheaper to install solar panels or wind turbines than building new coal or natural gas plants in many parts of the world, a trend many analysts expect to continue, technology alone may not be sufficient to solve an emergency. Experts say we need to halt leasing public land to fossil fuel companies, completely change the way we design and build cities, bring in strict laws for protecting carbon-sequestering forests and radically reform the agricultural system. These and other crucial steps require decisions by elected officials and the federal government. Climate advocates contacted by the Washington Post last year had other suggestions: Federal leaders could expand tax credits for buyers of electric vehicles. Pass a ban on food waste. Give financial aid to farmers for more sustainable crop-growing. More strictly regulate factory farms. Price carbon emissions. Pass a Green New Deal. Even a Democratic president might have trouble doing these things, given the structural barriers in Congress, but Trump won’t even try. “You hear this view that it really doesn’t matter what governments do—that climate change will be solved by people seeking profit and by looking for profitable opportunities to reduce emissions,” said Sachs from the University of Richmond. “I’m not so optimistic.” Trump could trigger an international catastrophe Trump already badly damaged the international effort to fight climate change by announcing withdrawal from the Paris Agreement in 2017—a move especially insulting to the rest of the world because the accords were designed to satisfy U.S. demands. For example, Obama pushed for Paris to be voluntary so he could sign on without approval from the Republican-dominated Senate. But four more years of U.S. absence could be a deathblow. “I predict a scenario of dysfunction and dissension and probably a breakdown of the treaty,” Sachs said. The agreement as it stands is insufficient. Plans submitted by countries would ideally only limit temperature rise to 2.7 degrees. In theory, countries are supposed to keep increasing their ambition, submitting ever more transformative plans that reduce the odds of climate impacts becoming cataclysmic. But big emitters are already failing to do so, and with Trump reelected countries like China or India might give up on meeting their already more modest goals. This could set off a chain reaction where other big emitters like Australia withdraw, sending the process into disarray and potentially killing Paris altogether. “Such outcomes would be disastrous and threaten the habitability of many parts of the planet,” Sachs writes. We are already seeing a version of this play out in Brazil, where deforestation of the Amazon rainforest was actually declining in the mid-2000s, but is now accelerating under the far-right presidency of Jair Bolsonaro. “He is largely feeling like he is not beholden to a U.S. president or the international community,” Larsen from the Rhodium Group said. “The signal that a Trump reelection would send about America’s willingness to rejoin the international community on emissions is going to be very important.” That’s an understatement. If Trump wins in November, the climate is screwed.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Impact Block

Trump will push all-in on American first and withdraw from NATO and abandon Europe – risks Euro proliferation and the rise of Authoritarianism across the continent

The Economist 7-11-23

(7-11-23, The Economist, What would Europe do if Trump won? , accessed 7-11-23)

If so, the return of a “Trump unbound”—more resentful, more organised and less constrained than in his first term—could be a calamity for Ukraine. It might be a disaster for Europe in other ways. He might well enact a threat, dating from his first term, to leave nato. He would face stern opposition in Congress. But alliances rely on trust. And merely suggesting he would not fight for allies could complete the destruction of the European order that Russia is attempting.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › 1NC – Trump Election Bad 1NC Shell

B. The impact is existential – Trump reelection leads to global nuclear war

Beres, Purdue International Law professor, 3-23-23

(Louis, 3-23-23, Professor of International Law at Purdue. Modern Diplomacy, “If Trump Returns as President: An Existential Threat to the United States.”.)

Credo quia absurdum, “I believe because it is absurd”-Tertullian

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › 1NC – Trump Election Bad 1NC Shell

A. President Biden is leaning into “Bidenomics” – selling voters on the success of his centrist agenda is critical - he needs to get in front of the GOP messaging and own this issue but also has to avoid making himself a target for the GOP through progressive inflationary spending like the plan

McManus, LA Times columnist, 7-12-23

(Doyle, 7-12-23, Columnist for the Los Angeles Times. BDN. Why the president is selling ‘Bidenomics’. https://www.bangordailynews.com/2023/07/12/opinion/opinion-contributor/why-the-president-is-selling-bidenomics/)

President Joe Biden wants to persuade Americans that the economy is better than they think — and that he deserves credit for turning it around. He’s calling his strategy “Bidenomics,” and it’s already become a central theme of his coming reelection campaign.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Summary

More specifically, here are the reasons why moderate/centrist and independent voters are triggered by the plan in such a way that it would actually influence their voting decision. These are the various warrants that will allow you to spin a multifaceted, nuanced link argument about why those voters flip their votes or choose to stay home on election day

Taxation and economic growth: Progressive policies advocating for higher taxes on the wealthy and corporations can hinder economic growth, discourage investment, job creation, and innovation, which could negatively impact moderate and independent voters who prioritize economic prosperity.

Regulatory burden: Progressive economic policies often involve increased regulations on businesses and industries that can stifle entrepreneurship and inhibit the growth of small businesses, which may be seen as detrimental by moderate and independent voters who value free market principles and limited government intervention.

Government spending and deficits: Progressive economic policies such as expanded social programs and government-funded initiatives can lead to higher levels of government spending and increased deficits. This may worry moderate and independent voters who prioritize fiscal responsibility and are wary of excessive government debt.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Summary

Expanding Social Security

Appeal to older voters: Expanding Social Security is often seen as a policy that directly benefits older Americans who rely on these benefits for retirement income. Demonstrating support for strengthening Social Security may resonate with older voters, who tend to have higher voter turnout rates and can be a significant voting bloc. Garnering support from this demographic could positively impact a politician's electoral chances, particularly if they have a strong base of older supporters.

Economic security and social welfare: Expanding Social Security can be viewed as a commitment to enhancing economic security and social welfare. Advocates argue that increasing benefits or implementing other reforms can help alleviate poverty among older adults and provide a safety net for those who depend on Social Security as their primary source of income. Support for such measures may attract voters who prioritize economic equity and social safety nets, potentially strengthening a politician's electoral prospects.

Fiscal considerations and opposition: Expanding Social Security involves financial implications, such as increased government spending or potential adjustments to the program's funding mechanisms. Critics may argue that expanding benefits is fiscally unsustainable or could place a burden on future generations. Concerns about the costs and long-term viability of expanding Social Security may influence voters' perceptions and affect a politician's electoral chances, particularly if opponents can effectively frame these arguments in the political discourse.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Summary

Jobs Guarantee

Appeal to certain voter demographics: Support for a federal jobs guarantee could potentially appeal to individuals who are concerned about unemployment, income inequality, and economic stability. It may resonate with working-class voters and those who prioritize job creation and economic security. Securing support from these groups could enhance a politician's electoral prospects, depending on their overall voter base and the importance of these demographics in the election.

Ideological and partisan considerations: The reception of a federal jobs guarantee and its potential impact on electoral chances can vary based on ideological and partisan factors. Support for a federal jobs guarantee is often associated with progressive or left-leaning ideologies, which may resonate with a portion of the Democratic voter base. However, it's worth noting that opinions on a federal jobs guarantee can also differ within a party. The political climate and the dominant narratives around job creation within a party can influence the electoral impact.

Economic impact and opposition: Implementing a federal jobs guarantee would have significant fiscal implications. Critics argue that such a program would require substantial government spending and potentially lead to inefficiencies in the labor market. Concerns about the economic feasibility and unintended consequences of a federal jobs guarantee could affect electoral outcomes, particularly if opponents can effectively frame these arguments in the political discourse.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Elections Scenario › Summary

UBI

Appeal to certain voter demographics: Support for UBI could potentially resonate with certain voter demographics. It may attract younger voters who are concerned about income inequality, economic instability, and the future of work. The appeal of UBI may also extend to individuals with lower incomes who perceive it as a way to alleviate poverty and provide a safety net. Securing support from these groups could enhance a politician's electoral prospects, depending on their overall voter base and the importance of these demographics in the election.

Ideological and partisan considerations: The reception of UBI and its potential impact on electoral chances can vary based on ideological and partisan factors. Support for UBI is often associated with progressive or left-leaning ideologies, which may resonate with a portion of the Democratic voter base. However, it's worth noting that UBI also has proponents from across the political spectrum, including some conservatives and libertarians who see it as a way to streamline welfare programs and empower individuals. The political climate and the dominant narratives around UBI within a party can influence the electoral impact

Fiscal concerns and opposition: UBI implementation raises questions about its financial feasibility and potential impact on government budgets. Critics argue that funding a UBI program would require significant increases in taxes or government spending, which may raise concerns among some voters. Opposition to UBI based on fiscal conservatism or concerns about disincentives to work could potentially affect electoral outcomes, particularly if opponents can effectively frame these arguments in the political discourse.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › AT – Farm Bill Spending Increasing

Farm Bill spending tight now – little room to maneuver

Boyer, AgInfo Reporter, 6-15-23

[Lorrie, 6-15-23, AgInfo, “Milk Producers Seek Strong Safety Net in Next Farm Bill”, , accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

Galen says the biggest challenge is there is not any new money to work with in the upcoming Farm Bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › AT – Extension Solves

Farm Bill not certain now – GOP infighting and lack of time – extension likely

Magnuson, Iowa Agribusiness Radio Network, 6/19/23

[Mark Magnuson, 6/19/23, Iowa Agribusiness Radio Network, “Congressional spending debate posing new challenges for farm bill writers,” , Accessed 7/12/2023, EJ]

A changing political environment for budgeting on Capitol Hill is posing new challenges for farm bill writers, who are already facing a daunting October 1st deadline to complete work on a new bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › AT – Extension Solves

Farm union leaders want the bill without an extension – new farm bill needed to strengthen the safety net

Urness, News Dakota, 7-10-23

(Steve, 7-10-23, News Dakota "Farmers Union President Wants New Farm Bill Agreement," , Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M]

JAMESTOWN, N.D. (Prairie Public Radio) – The president of the North Dakota Farmers Union says he hopes Congress will agree on a new farm bill soon, before the current farm bill expires.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Rural Childcare

Farm Bill key to rural childcare

RFDTV 7-3-23

[7-03-2023, RFD-TV, "Childcare is now a priority during Farm Bill discussions," , Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

For the first time ever, the American Farm Bureau and National Farmers Union are prioritizing rural child care as they share their wants for the Farm Bill.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Broadband

Farm Bill key to broadband and closing the digital divide

The Hagstrom Report 06-21-23

[6-21-2023, The Hagstrom Report, "Thompson: Broadband bill to be basis for broadband in farm bill,"https://www.thefencepost.com/news/thompson-broadband-bill-to-be-basis-for-broadband-in-farm-bill/, Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

House Agriculture Committee Chairman Glenn “GT” Thompson, R-Pa., said today that a broadband bill that the committee passed in the last Congress but did not receive floor consideration will be the basis for the broadband title in the farm bill.In an opening statement before a hearing with broadband stakeholders, Thompson said H.R. 4374, the Broadband Internet Connections for Rural America Act or BICRAA, “set the stage for a historic commitment and investment in rural broadband, and for us to finally close the digital divide.”Thompson said “Specifically, the bill:▪ “Codified the ReConnect program and merged it with USDA’s existing retail rural broadband program;

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Ag Innovation

Farm Bill key to innovation in rural communities

Rep. Budzinski (R-IL), 6/22/23

[Nikki Budzinski, 6/22/23, Fox News, “Here’s the Farm Bill 101 on protecting family farms,” , accessed 7/12/23, EJ]

While the Farm Bill affects all of us at the grocery store and the gas pump, its policies most greatly impact the people and communities too often overlooked by leaders in Washington — the family farmers and rural communities who sustain the heartland. The people I’m honored to represent in Congress.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Conservation Reserve Program

Farm Bill key improving the environment and extending the Conservation Reserve Program

Stegenga, SD News Watch 7-1-23

[Abbey, 7-1-2023, "With CRP acres dwindling nationally, Congress seeks reforms,"DakotaNewsNow, , Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

HENRY, S.D. (South Dakota News Watch) - For nearly 20 years, Carolyn Eck and her husband rented out their pastureland for cattle grazing northwest of Watertown, near Warner Lake. The land has not been tilled since before Eck moved to the property in 2003, she said.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate – Young Farmers & Equity Module

Young farmers and climate key to equity – increasingly diverse

Brimm, Yale Climate Change Communication Public Voices Fellow, 7/2/2023

[Katie, Bangor Daily News, “If we want climate-friendly food, we should support young farmers”, , accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

Young farmers are stepping up to the plate to grow nutritious food using sustainable methods. They’re increasingly diverse and majority women, which more accurately represents our country than the outgoing crop of retiring farmers. Combined, these factors make them more likely to be alarmed by climate change and demand action than previous generations.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate – Young Farmers & Equity Module

Farm bill key to climate – supports young farmers(ALT)

Brimm, Yale Climate Change Communication Public Voices Fellow, 7/2/2023

[Katie, Bangor Daily News, “If we want climate-friendly food, we should support young farmers”, , accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

But we have an opportunity for change. It’s estimated that nearly half of U.S. farmland will transfer ownership in the next couple decades as a generation of farm owners age out of the profession. Rather than selling off our farmland to private investors, why not transition these lands to young, diverse farmers equipped with the ecological skills to do climate-resilient farming?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate – Young Farmers & Equity Module

Farm bill key to climate – supports young farmers

Brimm, Yale Climate Change Communication Public Voices Fellow, 7/2/2023

[Katie, Bangor Daily News, “If we want climate-friendly food, we should support young farmers”, , accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

While Beyonce’s Renaissance Tour may be capturing our collective attention at the moment, there’s an admittedly less compelling event on stage in 2023: the farm bill. By some accounts, a dusty relic of the New Deal era, the farm bill contains billions of dollars for anti-hunger and agricultural programs. And it may be one of our best tools for addressing the climate crises. Advocates are pushing for it to include climate action, building momentum on billions of dollars set to be funneled by the U.S. Department of Agriculture to support farmers to adopt climate-friendly practices.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate

Farm Bill key to solving climate through reduction of dairy emissions

Sumner, American Enterprise Institute adjunct scholar, 23

[Daniel, May 2023, American Enterprise Institute, "Dairy Policy and the Next Farm Bill," https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/2023-05-Sumner-Dairy-Policy-and-the-Next-Farm-Bill.final_.pdf?x91208, Accessed 7-12-23, S.A.M]

Over its nine-decade history, the FMMO system has experienced many adjustments but no fundamental changes. The dairy industry is now pressing for another round of adjustments to raise consumer prices and reinforce anti-market restrictions.15 There seems to be little dairy industry recognition that more significant changes to the dairy marketing status quo, such as scaling back or eliminating the FMMO system, might allow long-term gains for both the industry and consumers.16