Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate

The Farm Bill key to help solve climate change

Foster, Environmental Defense Fund Contributing Writer, 5-25-23

[Joanna, 5-25-23, Environmental Defense Fund, “Not just about cows: Why everyone should care about the farm bill,” https://www.edf.org/article/not-just-about-cows-why-everyone-should-care-about-farm-bill, accessed 7-12, DG]

You may not own a tractor or a single pair of overalls. And maybe the only thing you’ve had a hand in growing is a neglected, windowsill succulent. But if you think the farm bill has nothing to do with you, you’d be wrong.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate

Farm Bill will be a key step in solving climate change

Semple reporter and an editor for The New York Times 23

[Robert, 6/12/2023, New York Times, “America Has a Chance to Make Farming More Climate Friendly,” , Accessed 7/12/2023, eo]

In an age defined by technology, we tend to take farmers for granted. Yet farmland continues to dominate the American landscape. An astonishing number of acres — close to 900 million, more than half of the contiguous United States — are devoted to agricultural production of one sort or another. A lot of it is for the grains, fruits and vegetables we eat but also, and more fatefully for the climate, for the grazing and feeding of animals.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate

The farm bill must be passed now to solve climate – we can’t afford to extend the bill and wait another five years for environmental provisions

Uyeda, Prism environmental and climate justice staff reporter, 7-12-23

[Ray Levy, 7-12-23, Prism Reports, “The Farm Bill Could Address Climate Change And Structural Racism”, , accessed 7-12-23, EH]

Yet the Farm Bill is legislation that needs approval from several committees and positive votes in the Senate and House of Representatives, where Democrats have a slim majority and minority, respectively. Farming and ranching take place in Democratic and Republican states—food isn’t partisan. Everyone has to eat. 

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate

The farm bill incentivizes farmers to adopt more climate-friendly practices – key to climate

Haiar, Nebraska Examiner reporter, 6-26-23

[Joshua, 6-26-23, Nebraska Examiner, “Farming Carbon: Farm Bill Presents Opportunity To Unite Farmers, Climate Activists”, , accessed 7-12-23, EH]

On the rolling plains southwest of Chamberlain, South Dakota, lies a 30-square-mile farm and ranch that serves as a testament to the power of soil health practices.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate/Environment

The Farm Bill would help ensure enough clean water for future generations, reduce pollution, and help combat climate change

Shambaugh, Pennsylvania Association of Conservation Districts Executive Director, 6-21-23

[Brenda, 6-21-23, The Daily Item, “Support increased funding in Farm Bill,” https://www.dailyitem.com/opinion/support-increased-funding-in-farm-bill/article_9e3dc66c-0f6f-11ee-9b7f-abd3ca0e6f41.html, accessed 7-12, DG]

Did you know that over one-quarter of all the land in Pennsylvania is farmland? Of the 52,700 farms on this land, 88% are small producers making under $250,000 in gross revenue each year.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Climate/Environment

The Farm Bill crucial to environmental protections – including water quality and climate

Celec, Bucks County Audobon Society executive director & Parzen, Conservation Voters of Pennsylvania executive Director, 6-29-23

[Michael, Molly, 6/29/23, “A Farm Bill For Us All,” Bucks County Herald, , Accessed 7/12/23, J.D.]

When you hear the phrase “Farm Bill,” you probably don’t think about streams, trees, birds, or many of the other environmental highlights of our area because, after all, what do they have to do with farming and agriculture?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Solves Equity

The Farm Bill is key to promote social equity

Derrick, Environmental and Energy Study Institute Communications and Policy Intern, 23

[Lynlee, 6/26/23, Environmental and Energy Study Institute, “Reimagining Public Food Procurement in the 2023 Farm Bill,” , accessed 7/12/23]

Alongside investments in sustainable practices, public food procurement programs can help achieve social benefits by sourcing from socio-economically disadvantaged farmers and providing nutritious meals to underserved communities. If these programs establish and prioritize explicitly-stated values of social equity, they could provide numerous social benefits that uplift Black, Indigenous, Hispanic, and low-income communities.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Structural Racism

The Farm Bill would help solve racism and help minorities keep their land

Ann Sebastian, Union of Concerned Scientists Communications Officer, 6-27-23

[Kyle, 6-27-23, Union of Concerned Scientists, “Food and Farm Bill Can Help Black Farmers Keep Their Land, Science Group Says,” https://www.ucsusa.org/about/news/farm-bill-can-help-black-farmers-keep-land, accessed 7-12, DG]

Over the course of the 20th century, Black farm owners lost nearly 90% of their farmland and the number of Black farmers dropped precipitously, from one in seven U.S. farmers at the start of the century to one in 72 today. The next Food and Farm Bill can help keep Black farmers on their land by including provisions that help resolve ownership and title issues that put Black farmers at risk of losing their land, according to a new policy brief from the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Structural Racism

Farm Bill can help Black farmers keep their land

Sebastian, Union of Concerned Scientists Communications Officer, 6-27-23

[Kyle Ann Sebastian, 6-27-23, Union of Concerned Scientists, “Food and Farm Bill Can Help Black Farmers Keep Their Land, Science Group Says,” , accessed 7-3-2023, EJ]

Over the course of the 20th century, Black farm owners lost nearly 90% of their farmland and the number of Black farmers dropped precipitously, from one in seven U.S. farmers at the start of the century to one in 72 today. The next Food and Farm Bill can help keep Black farmers on their land by including provisions that help resolve ownership and title issues that put Black farmers at risk of losing their land, according to a new policy brief from the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS).

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Structural Racism

The farm bill is key to stopping structural racism within the US agriculture industry

Uyeda, Prism environmental and climate justice staff reporter, 7-12-23

[Ray Levy, 7-12-23, Prism Reports, “The Farm Bill Could Address Climate Change And Structural Racism”, , accessed 7-12-23, EH]

A significant piece of legislation most voters have likely never heard of will spend the summer sitting on the cutting room floor of Congress. When the legislation is ready for a vote, it will ensure people aren’t sentenced to hunger for lack of income, dictate international trade policies, and provide support to a farm system that—depending on who you ask—is either failing or flourishing.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Health/Nutrition Impact Module

Food nutrition turns case – solves economic inequality through Medicare savings

Dr Hyman, American Physician, 6-29-23

[Mark, 6-29-23, Washington Examiner, “Congress's farm bill could improve our health”, , accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

Indeed, data show that using food as treatment for diabetes alone decreases the risk of death or serious complications by at least 40%.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Health/Nutrition Impact Module

Farm bill solves – Prevents death and disease via food nutrition

Dr Hyman, American Physician, 6-29-23

[Mark, 6-29-23, Washington Examiner, “Congress's farm bill could improve our health”, , accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

Lawmakers ought to keep this in mind as they debate this year’s farm bill. Food is medicine. Proper nutrition is well documented as being effective in preventing, managing, and curing many chronic diseases, improving long-term wellness, and generating substantial savings through cost avoidance. If we are armed with nutrient-dense foods from the early days of our lives, our bodies may be well-equipped to fight disease before its onset as we age.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Health/Nutrition Impact Module

Status quo insufficient – Current food policy is terrible for health and the economy

Dr. Hyman, American Physician, 6-29-23

[Mark, 6-29-23, Washington Examiner, “Congress's farm bill could improve our health”, , accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

But first we must recognize that our current approach to tackling the epidemic of chronic disease is flawed. It is based on an outdated approach of treating the systems of chronic disease rather than the root causes, mostly our diet and food system. Currently, our diet is made up of 60% ultra-processed “food,” concoctions of industrial food components that have now been proven to be the biggest cause of disease and death on the planet, killing more people than anything else, including smoking.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Key to Food Security

The Farm Bill is key to help keep the food supply secure

Duvall, American Farm Bureau Federation president, 7-2-23

[Zippy, 7-2-23, Farm Week Now, “Reasons to celebrate: Food, independence and optimism,” https://www.farmweeknow.com/general/reasons-to-celebrate-food-independence-and-optimism/article_2c7e66f6-15b6-11ee-a56c-7b61829d1cd6.html, accessed 7-12, DG]

Farm bill programs are critical to our national security and independence. Tools for risk management, like crop insurance, help farmers hang on through severe weather and market downturns, so that we can keep farming from one season to the next. That doesn’t mean farmers don’t feel the effects of inflation right now like everyone else. But it does mean that more family farms can stay in business and continue our mission of keeping our food supply secure, even as the cost of land, supplies and equipment increases.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Key to Food Security

Farm bill key to food security – empirically proven

Brasher, Agri-pulse editor, et al. 7/5/2023

[Phillip, Steve Davies, Jacqui Fatka, Noah Wicks, Bill Tomson, Agri-pulse editors, Agri-pulse, “Agri-Pulse farm bill preview: Key issues and proposals for each title”, , accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

Plus, the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act pumped $17 billion into farm bill conservation programs with additional funding for clean energy and forestry programs that were priorities for President Joe Biden’s climate policy.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Key to Food Security

Farm Bill solves food assistance and security – helps millions each year

Hussain, Sentient Media Staff Writer, 6-7-23

[Grace, 6-7-23, Sentient Media, “The Farm Bill Is Crucial. Here’s Why.”, , Accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

The farm bill doesn’t always grab headlines. Yet twice per decade or so, this crucial piece of legislation sets the standard for our food system. The farm bill has an impact on what farmers grow and how they grow it, and it also dictates implementation of the SNAP food assistance program which benefits more than 41 million people every year.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Key to Agriculture

Farm Bill key – needed to keep farmers in business

Boyer, AgInfo Reporter, 6-15-23

[Lorrie, 6-15-23, AgInfo, “Milk Producers Seek Strong Safety Net in Next Farm Bill”, , accessed 7/3/23, S.P.]

“One of the key things is making certain that we have the most robust risk management safety net that's possible in the Farm Bill. We've come a long ways since seven or eight years ago when the concept of having margin insurance was first introduced in the farm bill back then. So we're basically looking at ways to strengthen the value of the dairy margin Coverage Program, and also make certain that programs that would benefit larger producers programs, there would be the livestock gross margin program and the dairy Revenue Protection Program, just our efforts will be to bolster all of those so that farmers have a suite of options to choose from.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Impacts › Farm Bill Key to Agriculture

Farm Bill key to strong ag industry

Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23

[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” , accessed 7-3-2024, EJ]

The bottom line, Mr. Thompson said, is to pass legislation that helps ensure a strong agriculture industry.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › SNAP Internal Link

If GOP tilts further right on SNAP, it will collapse the Farm Bill

The Columbian, 6-28-23

[The Columbian, 6/28/23, “In Our View: Farm Bill about helping people, not scoring points,” , Accessed 7/12/2023, J.D.]

Until a crisis arose last month over the debt ceiling, the Farm Bill was expected to be the most significant challenge facing Congress this year. When lawmakers return to session following a Fourth of July recess, that challenge will take center stage.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario › Internal Links › SNAP Internal Link

Fight over SNAP risks no Farm Bill passes

Brasher and Wicks, Agri-Pulse editors, 6/21/2023

[Phillip, Noah, Agri-Pulse, “GOP hardliners' anger could delay, imperil new farm bill”, , Accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]

House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., affirmed in February that he intended to see a new farm bill passed before the end of the year with bipartisan support. But the conservatives’ outrage over the debt ceiling agreement, which is expected to increase, not reduce, the number of people getting Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits, and new demands for deep cuts in domestic spending will further test McCarthy’s command of the GOP conference heading into the farm bill debate.