Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: A2 “Skills Development”

Guarantee disincentivizes workers from acquiring new skills

Gulker, AIER Senior Research Fellow, ‘18

[Max Gulker, PhD, Economics, Stanford University, Senior Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, THE JOB GUARANTEE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS, American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, p. 15]

6.2 Impact on Worker Incentives

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: A2 “Private Sector Improves Jobs”

Private sector cannot keep up—guarantees productivity losses

Smith, former Stony Brook professor, ‘19

[Noah Smith, journalist and former professor, Stony Brook University, “A Federal Job Guarantee Is Asking for Trouble,” WINSTON-SALEM JOURNAL 3—11—19, , accessed 6-9-23]

Even more troubling, there's the possibility that the guaranteed federal jobs could cannibalize the private sector and make the economy less productive. The New Deal jobs programs were undertaken at a time when the economy had a huge amount of unemployment, and there was little chance that workers with private sector jobs would jump ship. But in the absence of very high unemployment like that of the Great Depression, a job guarantee will compete with private companies.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: A2 “Job Growth”

Guarantee is a bad way to create jobs—meta-analysis proves

Drum, journalist, ‘18

[Kevin Drum, journalist, “Raw Metadata: What Kinds of Jobs Programs Work the Best?” MOTHER JONES, 4—24—18, , accessed 5-1-23]

What’s the best way to get people working? There have been hundreds of jobs programs studied over the past few decades, and you can draw some general conclusions from them. A couple of years ago David Card and two colleagues published a meta-analysis of 207 studies conducted between 1980-2012. Here are their main results:

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: A2 “GDP Growth”

Their claims are about GDP growth are exaggerated

Dolan, Niskanen Center Senior Fellow, ‘18

[Ed Dolan, PhD, Economics, Yale University and Senior Fellow, Fiscal and Monetary Policy, Niskanen Center, “Three More Reasons to be Cautious About a National Job Guarantee,” Niskanen Center, 5—21—18, , accessed 4-30-23]

6. Beware of illusory additions to GDP

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Productivity—2NC

The plan hurts productivity and worker skill development

Smith, former Stony Brook professor, ‘18

[Noah Smith, journalist and former professor, Stony Brook University, “A Federal Job Guarantee for Everyone? Be Skeptical,” MACOMB DAILY, 7—10—18, , https://www.macombdaily.com/2018/07/10/a-federal-job-guarantee-for-everyone-be-skeptical/, accessed 6-4-23]

The first potential drawback would be if a job guarantee lowers productivity. If people shift out of productive private-sector jobs into government jobs that generate only half as much real value, the productivity of the nation will go down.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Productivity—2NC

Undermines productivity—job mismatch, job-lock, crowd-out

Nunn et al., Hamilton Project researcher, ‘18

[Ryan Nunn, Hamilton Project and Brookings Institution, Jimmy O’Donnell, Hamilton Project, and Jay Shambaugh, Hamilton Project, Brookings Institution, and George Washington University, “Labor Market Considerations for a National Job Guarantee,” FRAMING PAPER, The Hamilton Project, 12—18, p. 17]

Implications for Productivity

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Productivity—2NC

The plan would doom us to low productivity—gridlocks the economy

Standing, University of London researcher, ‘18

[Guy Standing, Fellow of the UK Academy of Social Sciences, and Professorial Research Associate, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, “Why a Job Guarantee Is a Bad Joke for the Precariat – And for Freedom,” OPENDEMOCRACY, 9—7—18, , accessed 6-9-23]

A job guarantee would be a recipe for perpetuating low productivity. What would happen if a person in a guaranteed job performed poorly, perhaps because of limited ability or simply because they knew it was ‘guaranteed’? This was a fatal flaw of the Soviet system. If you are guaranteed a job, why bother to work hard? If you are an employer and are given a subsidy to pay employees guaranteed a job, why bother to try to use labour efficiently?

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Nationalization—2NC

Would result in a government takeover of the economy

Harsanyi, Federallist senior editor, ‘18

[David Harsanyi, senior editor, The Federalist, “Democrats' Universal Job Plan Would Be a Socialist Disaster,” REASON, 4—27—18, , accessed 6-9-23]

Most of all, making government responsible for every American's job prospects would change the dynamics of governance—forever. Not only would politicians be expected to help create the economic conditions that make growth possible; they would then face another unrealistic expectation. Unemployment would no longer be a function of economic conditions but rather heartless politicians who fail to create jobs for voters.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Nationalization—2NC

Creep means the government would take over whole sectors of the economy, hurting growth

Haskins, Heartland Institute research, ‘20

[Justin Haskins, Heartland Institute researcher, “Rep. Ilhan Omar’s Government Jobs Program Would Be Economic Disaster,” FOX NEWS, 8—1—20, , accessed 6-9-23]

Over the long run, a jobs guarantee would also encourage governments to take over more parts of the economy. As more Americans sign up for the jobs program, additional new services would need to be offered by government to ensure its growing number of employees have work to do.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Inflation

Attempting to expand employment in a tight market is inflationary

ECONOMIST ‘18

[staff, “A Jobs Guarantee Is a Flawed Idea,” THE ECONOMIST, 5—10—18, , accessed 6-4-23]

The timing of Democrats’ revival of the idea of a jobs guarantee is strange because many economists, including those at the Federal Reserve, think that the economy is beyond full employment. To their mind, the unemployment rate is unnaturally low, and if policymakers try to sustain it via stimulus, inflation will result. If they are right, today’s joblessness is the result of structural factors, such as insufficient skills, unrealistically high wage demands, or an unwillingness of workers to leave stagnant areas. It is not the involuntary unemployment, resulting from a weak economy, which so concerned Keynes.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Inflation

The program would increase inflation

Paddison, award-winning journalist, ‘18

[Lauran Paddison, former CUNY Resilience Journalism Fellow and journalist, “What Is A Federal Jobs Guarantee?” HUFFINGTON POST, 7—6—18, , accessed 6-8-23]

Washington Post columnist Robert Samuelson writes that guaranteed jobs would “almost certainly be a disaster,” and that such a program would add to the deficit and lead to inflation. In a May column, he expressed his opposition bluntly: “The fact that it’s taken seriously is evidence that many Democrats, like Republicans before them, embrace loony economic agendas that are more public-relations gestures than sensible policy.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Inflation

The plan increases inflation—wage/price spiral

Bhandari, Third Way researcher, ‘19

[Ryan Bhandari, Senior Policy Advisor, Economic Program, Third Way, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” THIRD WAY, 3—25—19, , accessed 6-9-23]

#4: Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker.5 We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Human Capital Program Tradeoff—2NC

Costs would be enormous and would only increase in a downtourn—would tradeoff with other programs that build human capital

Kim, PPI senior fellow ‘18

[Anne Kim, Senior Fellow, PPI, GUARANTEED JOBS: TOO BIG TO SUCCEED, Progressive Policy Institute, 5—18, , accessed 6-8-23]

Finally, there is the consideration of cost. As mentioned above, the large-scale national job program envisioned by its leading proponents would cost $543 billion, or 3 percent of GDP, to employ 10.7 million people. This translates to a per-worker cost of $50,747 a year – or just slightly below the median household income in 2016 of $57,617.19 By comparison, federal spending on Social Security totaled $922 billion in 2016 while benefiting 61 million people,20 a relative bargain by comparison.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: GND—2NC

The Green New Deal thrashes the economy and worsens environmental outcomes

Loris, Heritage analyst, ‘19

[Nick Loris, Deputy Director, Thomas A. Roe Institute, Heritage Foundation, “It’s Not Just About Cost. The Green New Deal Is Bad Environmental Policy, Too,” Commentary, Heritage Foundation, 11—15—19, , accessed 6-14-23]

We're not hearing much about the "Green New Deal" these days, but it's still a priority for some candidates, as anyone who's attended a recent Bernie Sanders rally can attest.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: GND—2NC

It will literally destroy the economy

Sullivan, CNN journalist, ‘19

[Kate Sullivan, journalist, “Trump’s Top Economic Adviser: ‘The Green New Deal Will Literally Destroy the Economy’,” CNN, 2—28—19, , accessed 6-14-23]

President Donald Trump’s chief economic adviser believes “the Green New Deal will literally destroy the economy,” he told an audience of conservatives Thursday afternoon.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—Small Business 2NC

GND job guarantee fails- shortfalls in implementation, distorts the labor market, and kills small businesses

Ernst- United States Senator, 18

Johi Ernst- United States Senator. Senate RPC. . GREEN NEW DEAL: A CRAZY, EXPENSIVE MESS. DECEMBER 11, 2018. DOA: 06/17/23. AR.

The Green New Deal also proposes a job guarantee for every American who wants one. Beyond promising a not-yet-defined living wage, the details are scarce. Other job guarantee proposals popular among Democrats generally promise federally subsidized jobs in fields such as infrastructure and public works, child care, and the environment, for anyone whether they are currently employed or unemployed.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—Ext

Guarantee results in profound market disruptions

Gulker, AIER Senior Research Fellow, ‘18

[Max Gulker, PhD, Economics, Stanford University, Senior Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, THE JOB GUARANTEE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS, American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, p. 14]

We must approach any discussion of the impact of a federal job guarantee on the wider economy with an abundance of caution. Our sample size for evaluating a program that the Levy report’s authors term a “radical transformation of the labor market” is zero. Even countries with much larger public sectors do not operate under the mandated system of a job guarantee.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—Ext

Workers will flood to public jobs—private employers cannot compete

Dolan, Niskanen Center Senior Fellow, ‘20

[Ed Dolan, PhD, Economics, Yale University and Senior Fellow, Fiscal and Monetary Policy, Niskanen Center, “Can We Put Everyone to Work? — The Alternatives to a “Job Guarantee,” Niskanen Center, 1—14—20, , accessed 4-30-23]

First, even though guaranteed jobs would be designed not to compete directly with the private sector, a JG would still be disruptive. Private employers would lose workers if they did not match a job-and-benefit package worth some $20 per hour. JG advocates are confident that private employers have enough slack to raise wages without cutting employment, but I am not so sure. JG jobs would not only offer good wages and benefits, but also, as advocates promise, they would be more accommodating than many private sector jobs to workers’ personal schedules, family needs, and disabilities. A large outflow from private employment to guaranteed jobs could raise the cost of the program sharply.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—Ext

Private companies simply would not be able to compete in the labor market

Haskins, Heartland Institute research, ‘20

[Justin Haskins, Heartland Institute researcher, “Rep. Ilhan Omar’s Government Jobs Program Would Be Economic Disaster,” FOX NEWS, 8—1—20, , accessed 6-9-23]

Providing people with access to jobs in areas that are struggling economically might sound like a good idea at first glance, but on closer examination it is deeply flawed and extraordinarily harmful.