Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: PC › 1AR---Biden PC Fails

PC’s fake AND doing more actually benefits his agenda

---added [retain control of the Senate] in brackets for readability

Paul Waldman 12/3, opinion writer for the Plum Line blog, “Joe Biden has to move fast,” 12/3/20, The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/02/joe-biden-has-move-fast/

For every day of his presidency, Joe Biden will be restrained and bedeviled by Republican power. Republicans will probably retain control of the Senate, and even if they don’t [retain control of the Senate], they will do everything they can to sabotage Biden’s agenda. They will obstruct and delay, whether it’s on legislation, appointments or anything else, to make sure Biden has as little as possible to show for his time in office.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: PC › 1AR---Biden PC Fails

Democrat’s PC consistently fails to achieve its objectives

Matt Robinson 5/31, former congressional staffer, 5/31/23, “Biden Has Had a Remarkable First Term. Why Is He So Unpopular, Even With Democrats? | Opinion,” https://www.newsweek.com/my-fellow-democrats-era-big-government-over-thats-good-us-opinion-1803567

Democrats spent recent years throwing political capital at ambitious, flamboyantly-named federal proposals that foundered, went nowhere, or had to be rescued after a torturous whittling process. Think of Medicare for All, American Jobs Plan, American Families Plan, Green New Deal, and Build Back Better.

To be sure, this was probably smart legislative strategy: They ultimately got more out of Congress by not negotiating against themselves. But it turned into terrible politics. All of those gaudy achievements came via an alphabet soup of legislation that no sane human being could follow, and only after enduring months of Fox News pummeling and mainstream media both-sidesing.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: PC › 2AC---Biden PC Fails

Biden PC fails

Scott Remer 6/7, master’s degree in political thought and intellectual history at the University of Cambridge, 6/7/23, “Biden Is Turning Out to Be More Like Obama Than FDR,” https://inthesetimes.com/article/biden-obama-fdr-debt-ceiling-neoliberal-manchin-bernie-sanders

Yet these programs did indeed expire, as was easily predictable. And now the Biden administration awaits a likely Supreme Court decision that would end his student loan cancelation program. Biden recently pleaded in his 2023 State of the Union for a divided Congress to restore the expanded CTC, a highly unlikely prospect with a Republican-controlled House of Representatives. More recently, Biden acquiesced to a harmful debt ceiling deal after protracted negotiations with Republican racketeers who blackmailed him into imposing strict work requirements for food stamp recipients and cutting social spending as the price of staving off a calamitous default.

No FDR

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: Link › 1AR---AT: UBI Link

There’s broad support for UBI across parties.

Evangel Penumaka et. al 21. With Isa Alomran & Abby Steckel, Researchers for Data For Progress. July 2021. Data For Progress. https://www.filesforprogress.org/memos/voters-support-a-guaranteed-income.pdf

These survey results show that a majority of likely voters broadly support a guaranteed income and associate it with positive impacts on their lives. The pandemic has exposed the financial and economic instability faced by working Americans on a day-to-day basis. Implementing a guaranteed income would be a vitally needed expansion to our existing social safety nets — and one that is popular across likely voters. A guaranteed income would ensure that we are taking the right steps for families to achieve secure financial futures and reduce the income inequality we see today. As city leaders begin to implement pilot programs for a guaranteed income throughout the U.S., they can do so knowing they have the support of voters behind them.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: Link › 1AR---AT: UBI Link

Supporting UBI is a winning political strategy---that builds PC.

Lucia Graves 21. Writer based in Washington, D.C., and a columnist for the Guardian. "Democrats Are Finally Unafraid to Be the Party of Free Money". New Republic. 1-8-2021. https://newrepublic.com/article/160842/ossoff-warnock-andrew-yang-money

Democrats may have learned the larger lesson: Rather than campaigning on triangulation in a battleground state, they can campaign on helping people, with the simple promise that if they get elected, there will be tangible rewards to come in the form of money that folds. Perhaps it’s such a basic notion that it wasn’t sexy enough for the wonks who have overthought themselves several hundred miles past the obvious: that money solves problems and giving people money is just the right thing to do. But Democrats’ recent successes suggest that it’s also a winning political strategy, as well. So even the cynics can take heart.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › AT: Link › 2AC---AT: UBI Link

UBI is a populist winner that attracts support from Republicans.

Bonnie Kristian 21, Former deputy editor and acting editor-in-chief of The Week, 1/4/21, "Are pandemic relief checks making UBI inevitablehttps://theweek.com/articles/957862/are-pandemic-relief-checks-making-ubi-inevitable

Major crises can effect rapid changes in public opinion that otherwise would have required years or even decades to develop. Among the permanent opinion shifts of the COVID-19 pandemic, I expect to see a new — and perhaps even bipartisan — move toward universal basic income (UBI) or something like it, an evolution influenced by Americans' experience with pandemic relief checks, both the fact of them and the drawn-out political fights surrounding their passage.

UBI is exactly what it sounds like: a government income program which is not tied to recipients' employment (like unemployment insurance), age (like Social Security), income (like TANF), medical care (like Medicare or Medicaid), or food purchases (like SNAP). It's simply a monthly cash stipend that goes to everyone. The stipend could be big enough to cover all basic expenses (this is called a full UBI) or it could merely supplement other income (former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang's proposal of a $1,000 per month "Freedom Dividend" is an example of this sort of partial UBI).

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › 1AR---UQ

Passing a farm bill is structurally unlikely in this congress.

Forrest Laws 23. "Farm bill looking increasingly less likely in 2023". Farm Progress. 2-23-2023. https://www.farmprogress.com/farm-business/farm-bill-looking-increasingly-less-likely-in-2023

Writing a new farm bill can be difficult under the best of circumstances but passing an ag law in the 118th Congress in 2023 or 2024 could prove to be especially challenging.

For openers, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s commitment to allow each of the government’s appropriation bills to be considered individually rather than in an omnibus spending resolution could take up a large portion of 2023.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › 1AR---UQ

Dems waste PC protecting SNAP---Republicans will win on other priorities

Luke Goldstein 23, Writing fellow at the American Prospect, 5/24/23, “How Washington Bargained Away Rural America,” https://prospect.org/power/2023-05-24-how-washington-bargained-away-rural-america/

For their part, Democrats expend their political capital to protect SNAP, and cede most decision-making about agricultural programs to Republicans. To the extent that Democrats push for changes to the agriculture titles, they often broker compromises to expand programs that suit the parochial interests of the states they represent. For example, Michigan Sen. Debbie Stabenow, the current Democratic chair of the Senate Agriculture Committee, championed the Local Agriculture Market Program (LAMP) in the 2018 farm bill, which delivers grants to help farmers markets.

“It’s a lot like a hostage negotiation between both parties to jam their priorities through,” said policy adviser Ferd Hoefner.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › 1AR---UQ

Far-right rebellion in the House derails the farm bill

Meredith Lee Hill 6/15, POLITICO, 6/15/23, “Far-right Republicans threaten to derail another House priority,” https://www.politico.com/news/2023/06/14/mccarthy-house-gop-farm-bill-00101968

The recent far-right rebellion that brought the House floor to a halt is a bad omen for another rapidly approaching legislative fight: the 2023 farm bill.

Major battle lines are forming within the House Republican caucus over the $1 trillion farm bill reauthorization expected to hit the full House this fall — just as Washington is set to descend into another all-consuming battle to fund the government. GOP hardliners are still fuming over the deal House Speaker Kevin McCarthy struck with President Joe Biden to raise the debt limit earlier this month, especially a provision that could expand the number of people on federal food aid. And they are keen to take another swing at limiting that anti-hunger program, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, up for reauthorization in the farm bill — which promises to be politically polarizing.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Aff Answers › UQ › 2AC---UQ

Won’t pass

Jim Wiesemeyer 6/5, Washington analyst for Pro Farmer, previously a Washington editor with Doane’s Agricultural Report and Washington editor and managing editor of the Washington Farmletter, 6/5/23, "3 Reasons the Farm Bill is Behind Schedule," https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/3-reasons-farm-bill-behind-schedule

The Senate and House Ag committees are facing delays in drafting the next farm bill, and it is expected to be the most expensive farm bill to date, clocking in at around $1.5 trillion.

The process is “behind schedule” judging by past experiences with previous farm bills. Neither of the committees have established a timeline for crafting the legislation, although whispers have a draft coming before the August recess, or no later than September.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---Turns Economy

US food supply shocks shred the global economy

Gert Peersman 16, Professor in Econ at Ghent University, with; Jasmien De Winne, Management Assistant at Strabag Belgium, 2016, "Macroeconomic effects of disruptions in global food commodity markets: Evidence for the United States,” https://www.brookings.edu/bpea-articles/macroeconomic-effects-of-disruptions-in-global-food-commodity-markets/

The authors compare their estimates on food supply shocks to the impact of similar economic shocks, such as to the global crude oil supply. They find that the impact of a rise in real food commodity prices on economic activity is roughly twice as large as the impact of a rise in crude oil prices of equal size, and that while the dynamic effects of both shocks on real personal consumption are more or less the same, the average food supply shock has a slightly stronger and more persistent impact on consumer prices than the average oil supply shock.

They highlight, that both types of shocks cause monetary policymakers to respond in different ways. A food price shock of 5 percent increases the Federal Funds rate by 24 basis points (a rise in 10 basis points leads to a fall in real GDP between 0.05 percent and 0.1 percent), whereas the rate decreases by 20 basis points, on impact, in response to a 10 percent oil shock. In other words, monetary policy seems to amplify the consequences of food market disruptions on economic activity. The authors estimate that monetary policy response to food market disruptions can potentially explain almost one-third of the effects of the shock.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---! Add-on---Environment

Sustainable ag solves extinction from environmental degradation

Mauricio Quintero-Angel 18. Professor of Agricultural Engineering, Ph.D. in Environmental Sciences, Universidad del Valle-Colombia, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mauricio_Quintero-Angel/publication/322011429_Tendencies_and_challenges_for_the_assessment_of_agricultural_sustainability/links/5a3d43f4458515f6b039bf3d/Tendencies-and-challenges-for-the-assessment-of-agricultural-sustainability.pdf

3. Ecological degradation in food production and the need for new sustainable paradigms in agriculture From the neolithic period, different human groups have developed agriculture, devising processes for the obtention of seeds, sowing, plantation maintenance, harvest and exchange and commercialization of food. In many cases these activities have altered the dynamic balance of ecosystems, and in the Anthropocene, the agriculture is recognized as a primary driver of global change and as the main contributor to environmental risks (Foley et al., 2011). The degradation of ecosystems (their structure, dynamic and evolution) for food production can be explained in two ways: • By the appropriation processes of natural resources and environmental services, where any intervention generates negative impacts on environment; • By disposing residues to the environment. According to González de Molina and Toledo (2014) these emanations should be analyzed by both the quality as well as the quantity of the materials of the residues, meaning if they are recyclable or not by nature or if they surpass or not the natural recycling capacity. Nevertheless, when the appropriation of nature is done disregarding the productive vocation of the ecosystems, its capacity to renovate itself and its existence is threatened. This in turn generates certain changes that end up affecting society (Toledo, 2008). For example, a reduction on crops productivity or the use of agrochemicals to attenuate the loss of soil fertility. In these cases the farmer spends a great amount of time recovering the ecosystem, generating additional negative pay offs causing the producer to overexploit its labor to balance the relation. It could be considered that nature generates penalizations to wrong decisions made by the producer, accumulating in time and space, which could lead to a collapse of the material base and even the disappearance of populations, states or civilizations, requiring sustainable interventions over the ecosystems (González de Molina and Toledo, 2014). Nonetheless, processes such as the circulation, transformation and specially consumption increase the pressure over nature. According to González de Molina and Toledo (2014) in human history the volumes of materials-products that circulate as well as the distances covered before they are consumed, have increased. Going from the non-merchant and non-monetary trade, to the trade mediated by money, private property and markets. The latter results in a vast network of trades that is intimately linked to the transformations where the old relation, direct and almost immediate between appropriation and consumption gets blurred (González de Molina and Toledo, 2014). These authors argue that at a global level and at the beginning of the XXI century, consumption constitutes a powerful factor that demands incentive and even subordinates the other metabolic processes. Examples around the world could explain the important role of consumption. For example, a global increase in the levels of meat consumption, is recognized as one of the greatest threats to tropical ecosystems and biodiversity (Machovina and Feeley, 2014). Livestock production accounts for up to 75% of all agricultural lands (Foley et al., 2011), so that a rise in the consumption of meat products increases the demand for animal feed and consequently changes the land uses with the associated negative environmental impact on ecosystems and biodiversity. Also, it is known that agri-food systems in which higher calories are consumed by humans stem from animal products that have a higher total calorie throughput (Mayer et al., 2015). Likewise, another interesting example is related to commerce between northern and southern countries. After the XX century, the consumption in northern countries and the international commerce with southern countries has been a factor that has promoted the expansion of agricultural border and has contributed to intensifying the exploitation of the soil in southern countries. This represented an increase in volumes of foods and produced agricultural raw materials, as well as in increased productivity by having higher yields per hectare (Pérez, 2006); with associated environmental costs and natural heritage exhaustion. According to Pérez (2006) the increases on productivity are very important in economic terms, but these have associated environmental implications a: i) The ecological footprint caused by the intensive introduction of energetic inputs based on non-renewable resources produce energetically deficient agriculture that is of low ecological sustainable value; and, ii) absolute increments on the use of other natural resources such as water, since the dynamic on the use of the soil has a relation of correspondence in the dynamic of the use of hydric resources for agricultural activity. The strong pressure over nature by conventional agriculture, and also the permanent demand of food by the increasing human population, implies the necessity of new paradigms for an agricultural production in the frame of productive tendency of ecosystems. In relation to this Leff proposes: The environmental crisis takes us to rethink reality, to understand its tracks of complexity and the linking of the complexity of the being and of the thinking process, of reason and passion, of sensitivity and intelligibility, so that from there, open new roads of knowledge and new existential senses for the reconstruction of the world and the reappropriation of nature (Leff, 2006). In this new perspective, the modern world crisis must be considered, especially in the rural sector, as a consequence of the transgression of the biophysical limits of the planet for food production. For Toledo et al. (2009), the way to approach the crisis is through the improvement of the reduced ways in which traditional models as well as the modern ones articulate each other and with nature. Thus, bringing about the concept of sustainable development, which allows perceiving an alternate modernity that is really the adoption of a new method of appropriation of nature. In this sense, sustainable agriculture can be understood as the management and use of agroecosystems in a way that the biological diversity, productivity, regeneration capacity, vitality and functioning capacity are maintained. So that important biological, economic and social functions at a local, national and international level can be met (today and in the future) without damaging other ecosystems (Lewandowski et al., 1999). Sustainability can be reached through agricultural practices based on the adequate and profound knowledge of ecological processes in production units and their context. Therefore, agreeing with Gliessman a greater comprehension and evaluation of the current productive processes is required to focus agricultural production toward social and economic changes that promote sustainability (Gliessman, 1998).

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---!---AT: Food Defense

Food is the likely cause of global conflict. Solving it is a conflict dampener.

Sinéad Lehane 17. Research manager for Future Directions International’s Global Food and Water Crises Research program. Her current research projects include Australia’s food system and water security in the Tibetan Plateau region. Shaping Conflict in the 21st Century—The Future of Food and Water Security. February 2, 2017. www.hidropolitikakademi.org/shaping-conflict-in-the-21st-century-the-future-of-food-and-water-security.html

In his book, The Coming Famine, Julian Cribb writes that the wars of the 21st century will involve failed states, rebellions, civil conflict, insurgencies and terrorism. All of these elements will be triggered by competition over dwindling resources, rather than global conflicts with clearly defined sides. More than 40 countries experienced civil unrest following the food price crisis in 2008. The rapid increase in grain prices and prevailing food insecurity in many states is linked to the outbreak of protests, food riots and the breakdown of governance. Widespread food insecurity is a driving factor in creating a disaffected population ripe for rebellion. Given the interconnectivity of food security and political stability, it is likely food will continue to act as a political stressor on regimes in the Middle East and elsewhere. Addressing Insecurity Improving food and water security and encouraging resource sharing is critical to creating a stable and secure global environment. While food and water shortages contribute to a rising cycle of violence, improving food and water security outcomes can trigger the opposite and reduce the potential for conflict. With the global population expected to reach 9 billion by 2040, the likelihood of conflict exacerbated by scarcity over the next century is growing. Conflict is likely to be driven by a number of factors and difficult to address through diplomacy or military force. Population pressures, changing weather, urbanization, migration, a loss of arable land and freshwater resources are just some of the multi-layered stressors present in many states. Future inter-state conflict will move further away from the traditional, clear lines of military conflict and more towards economic control and influence.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---!---AT: Food Defense

Food shortages are the largest proximate cause of conflict---studies overwhelmingly go negative

Ore Koren 16, PhD Candidate in Political Science at U Minnesota, with; Benjamin Bagozzi, Assistant Professor of Political Science & International Relations at U Delaware; 9/15/2016, “From global to local, food insecurity is associated with contemporary armed conflicts,” Food Security, DOI 10.1007/s12571-016-0610-x, http://www.benjaminbagozzi.com/uploads/1/2/5/7/12579534/koren-bagozzi-fs.pdf.

A growing number of studies of environmental stressors and social conflict posit that future wars will be fought over diminishing resources (Miguel et al. 2004; Burke et al. 2009;O ’ Loughlin et al. 2012; Scheffran et al. 2012 ). Building on insights from these studies, as well as other suggestive accounts (e.g. Brinkman and Hendrix 2011 ;Hendrix and Brinkman 2013 ; Messer and Cohen 2006 ;Prunier 2008 ), the present study demonstrates empirically, for the first time, the existence of a systemic relationship between conflict on the one hand, and food (in) security on the other, both globally and locally. Specifically, highly disaggregated cropland-based measures of food insecurity are shown to produce a significant effect on the incidence of inter and intra-state armed conflict worldwide. Unlike the majority of previous studies, which rely primarily on country-level indicators (Miguel et al. 2004 ; Burke et al. 2009 ; Scheffran et al. 2012 ;Buhaug 2010 ) or focus specifically on sub-Saharan Africa (Miguel et al. 2004 ; Burke et al. 2009;O ’ Loughlin et al. 2012;Buhaug 2010; Fjelde and Hultman 2014 ), the present approach uses geographic factors to estimate the regional sub-state distribution of conflict globally. Two agricultural output measures, the percent of cropland in a given region and the amount of cropland per capita within agricultural regions, are used to proxy for the demand and supply aspects of food security, respectively (Barrett 2010 ). Using logistic regression (i.e., logit) models, these measures are then paired with a large number of political, economic, and climatic indicators in order to estimate the direct effects of food security on violent conflict. Evidence suggests that conflict occurs in areas with higher access to, but lower availability of, food resources. Together these findings imply that food insecurity produces an independent effect on contemporary social and political conflict. While relatively little research directly addresses the relationship between food insecurity and conflict specifically, numerous studies have implied that such a relationship exists. For instance, in their analysis of the relationship between climate variability and conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa, Burke et al. found that B [t]emperature variables are strongly related to conflict incidence over our historical panel ^ (2009 , 20,670. See also Miguel et al. 2004 ; Koubi et al. 2012 ). They further hypothesize that, B [t]emperature can affect agricultural yields both through increases in crop evapotranspiration (and hence heightened water stress in the absence of irrigation) and through accelerated crop development...reducing African sta- ple crop yields by 10 % – 30 % per °C of warming ^ (ibid. 20,672). Somewhat more cautiously, O ’ Loughlin et al. conclude that, B [o]ur study and other studies question the evidence that climatic variability is uniformly driving up the risk of conflict in sub-Saharan Africa, ^ while also noting that B the positive association between instability and temperature may result from the harmful effects of high temperatures on food products such as maize ^ (2012, 18,347). While these conclusions were supported by subsequent studies (Raleigh and Kniveton 2012; Hendrix and Salehyan 2012 ;Hsiangand Meng 2014 ), other scholars question the validity of these findings and show that the incidence of conflict is primarily related to political and economic conditions (e.g. Buhaug 2010 ). In common with all these studies, however, is the insight that a major mechanism by which climate change increases the likelihood of conflict is through its effects on food supplies.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---!---Nuke War

Climate change threat multiplication goes nuclear

Jürgen Scheffran 16, Professor at the Institute for Geography at the University of Hamburg and head of the Research Group Climate Change and Security in the CliSAP Cluster of Excellence and the Center for Earth System Research and Sustainability, et al., April 2016, “The Climate-Nuclear Nexus: Exploring the linkages between climate change and nuclear threats,” http://www.worldfuturecouncil.org/file/2016/01/WFC_2015_The_Climate-Nuclear_Nexus.pdf

Climate change and nuclear weapons represent two key threats of our time. Climate change endangers ecosystems and social systems all over the world. The degradation of natural resources, the decline of water and food supplies, forced migration, and more frequent and intense disasters will greatly affect population clusters, big and small. Climate-related shocks will add stress to the world’s existing conflicts and act as a “threat multiplier” in already fragile regions. This could contribute to a decline of international stability and trigger hostility between people and nations. Meanwhile, the 15,500 nuclear weapons that remain in the arsenals of only a few states possess the destructive force to destroy life on Earth as we know multiple times over. With nuclear deterrence strategies still in place, and hundreds of weapons on ‘hair trigger alert’, the risks of nuclear war caused by accident, miscalculation or intent remain plentiful and imminent.

Despite growing recognition that climate change and nuclear weapons pose critical security risks, the linkages between both threats are largely ignored. However, nuclear and climate risks interfere with each other in a mutually enforcing way.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---IL---Global Food Security

Food security faces imminent risks from climate change---farm bill key

Ben Lilliston 6/13, director of rural strategies and climate change at the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy, 6/13/23, “Climate change is disrupting food supplies. Can the Farm Bill help?” https://www.iatp.org/climate-change-disrupting-food-supplies-can-farm-bill-help

This year, drought is contributing to the largest abandonment of winter wheat acres since 1917 and the shrinking of the U.S. cattle herd, now the smallest in 60 years. In addition to increased drought, climate change is driving rising temperatures, wildfires and torrential rains, and is already affecting food production in the U.S. Yet, as Congress works on a new five-year Farm Bill, there are few signs that members grasp the urgency of the climate crisis and the need for dramatic policy shifts to address escalating challenges for both farmers and consumers.

Last week, the Campaign for Family Farms and the Environment (which includes family farm groups in Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, and South Dakota, plus IATP and Food & Water Watch), published a new report outlining how the Farm Bill could help protect the country’s food supply, stabilize agriculture markets with fair prices for farmers and promote greater climate resilience in our food system. The report examines proposed farm policies that include grain reserves, a price floor and ceiling, and a set aside program to better manage supplies of key agriculture commodities like wheat, corn and soybeans. When integrated with popular conservation programs that support practices, such as more diverse crop rotations, perennial grasses, regenerative grazing or cover crops, these policies would make progress toward protecting the food system against incoming climate shocks. These proposed policies also would remove a critical subsidy in the form of cheap, below-cost feed to a high greenhouse gas emitting factory farm system of animal and dairy production.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---IL---Global Food Security

Climate-smart farm bill is key to US global leadership on sustainable ag

Chase Sova 19, Center for Strategic & International Studies Senior Associate (Non-resident), Global Food Security Program, with; Kimberly Flowers and Christian Man, 10/15/19, “Climate Change and Food Security: A Test of U.S. Leadership in a Fragile World,” https://www.csis.org/analysis/climate-change-and-food-security-test-us-leadership-fragile-world

Support domestic efforts to promote climate resilience in food systems: The credibility and potency of our leadership at global levels begins with our commitment to change and improve our own priorities. Very public controversies around the alleged suppression of research regarding the impact of climate change on food production from the Agricultural Research Service at the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has brought into question the administration’s ability to lead by example. For continued progress in reducing agriculture’s global greenhouse gas footprint and improving adoption of climate-smart agricultural practices, the United States must walk the walk here at home. Climate-smart interventions are not limited to developing country contexts. In the United States, cover cropping, for example, has increased considerably, but the practice still represents only a small percentage of planted area. These and other regenerative practices are being rolled out in the United States thanks, in part, to USDA’s 10 regional Climate Hubs, led by the Agricultural Research Service and the Forest Service. In this same spirit, the United States should continue and expand its leveraging of domestic university research programs for developing global climate solutions in agriculture. U.S. universities, through the Feed the Future Innovation Labs, are currently involved in research on climate resilient sorghum, wheat, millet, cowpea, chickpea, and beans.64 Finally, recent years have seen the emergence of several mechanisms that compensate U.S. farmers for storing carbon in their agricultural soils, including in California and several non-profit and private sector initiatives. These initiatives require federal support to be sustainable in the long run, a step that should be explored within USDA’s existing authorities or in the next Farm Bill cycle.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---IL---Farm Bill K2 Climate-Smart

The farm bill will allocate billions in Inflation Reduction Act funds towards climate resilience---the GOP wants to kill it

Sarah Graddy 23, Environmental Working Group, Advocacy Non-Profit, June 2023, “Funding for climate-smart agriculture critical to tackling the climate emergency,” https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2023/06/funding-climate-smart-agriculture-critical-tackling-climate-emergency

How to avoid dealing with the climate emergency, step 2: Use the Inflation Reduction Act as a slush fund

Because baseline funding in this farm bill will likely stay as it was in the 2018 Farm Bill, any increases in support for one program will have to come from another.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Impact › 2NC---IL---Farm Bill K2 Climate-Smart

Farm bill climate-smart provisions solve ag resilience

Joanna Foster 5/23, Contributing Writer, Environmental Defense Fund, 5/23/23, “Not just about cows: Why everyone should care about the farm bill,” https://www.edf.org/article/not-just-about-cows-why-everyone-should-care-about-farm-bill

“The farm bill is a massive omnibus authorization and spending bill that comes up every five years,” says Ben Thomas, who directs EDF’s agriculture policy work. “It sets all federal food, agriculture and nutrition support policy and touches almost every aspect of our lives.”

It's also critical for climate reasons: Agriculture is responsible for around 10% of greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S. and ensuring that farmland is resilient to the impacts of climate change is vital to securing the future of our food supply.

2023 Northwestern Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › PC Mechanics › 2NC---AT: Winners Win

Popular policies don’t generate further support. Biden can only go down---not up.

Perry Bacon Jr. 21, a senior writer for FiveThirtyEight, “Why Republicans Don’t Fear An Electoral Backlash For Opposing Really Popular Parts Of Biden’s Agenda,” https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/why-republicans-dont-fear-an-electoral-backlash-for-opposing-really-popular-parts-of-bidens-agenda/

Republicans in the U.S. House last week unanimously opposed President Biden’s economic stimulus bill, even though polls show that the legislation is popular with the public. The U.S. Senate will consider the bill soon — and it looks like the overwhelming majority of Republicans in that chamber will oppose it as well. And it’s not just the stimulus. House Republicans also last week overwhelmingly opposed a bill to ban discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity. And the GOP seems poised to oppose upcoming Democratic bills to make it easier to vote and spend hundreds of billions to improve the nation’s infrastructure. All of those ideas are popular with the public, too.

“Duh,” you might say. Of course, the party out of power opposes the agenda of the party in power. Democrats did that during former President Donald Trump’s four years. Republicans did it during former President Barack Obama’s two terms. The parties just disagree on a lot of major issues.