2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › PC Mechanics › 2NC---AT: Winners Win
Courtney Subramanian and Joey Garrison 3/7/21, both are white house correspondents at USA Today, “'Dinner table' politics: Why Joe Biden ditched bipartisan dealmaking to pass his COVID-19 relief bill,” https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2021/03/07/covid-19-bill-biden-chooses-dinner-table-politics-over-bipartisanship/6892438002/
Despite the relief plan's popularity outside the Beltway, it is unlikely that momentum from its passage will hurtle Biden into future legislative wins, Howell said.
“The idea that a legislative win begets a subsequent legislative win in this environment is probably asking for too much,” he said, noting the prospect of passing COVID-19 relief was higher than more hot-button issues like immigration or health care.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › PC Mechanics › 2NC---Biden PC Real
Peter Baker 6/1, NYT Journalist, 6/1/23, “The calm man in the capital: Biden lets others spike the ball but notches a win,” https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/nation-politics/the-calm-man-in-the-capital-biden-lets-others-spike-the-ball-but-notches-a-win/
In the days since he struck a deal to avoid a national default, President Joe Biden has steadfastly refused to boast about what he got as part of the agreement.
“Why would Biden say what a good deal it is before the vote?” he asked reporters at one point, referring to himself in the third person. “You think that’s going to help me get it passed? No. That’s why you guys don’t bargain very well.”
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Link › 2NC---L---UBI
Ed Kilgore 19. Political columnist for Intelligencer, formerly Vice President for Policy at the Democratic Leadership Council; Communications Director for U.S. Senator Sam Nunn; and a federal-state relations aide to three governors of Georgia. "George McGovern Proposed a Universal Basic Income. It Didn’t Go Well for Him.". Intelligencer. 3-18-2019. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/03/yangs-usd12-000-ubi-was-pioneered-by-george-mcgovern.html
For political observers of a certain vintage, long-shot presidential candidate Andrew Yang’s proposal to give every American adult $1,000 a month brought back a distinct memory from 1972. That year Democratic presidential nominee George McGovern also proposed writing a $1,000 check to every American — $1,000 a year, however (there’s been a lot of inflation since then).
To put it mildly, it did not go over well. Even though McGovern eventually abandoned the proposal, and even though it was similar to the “negative income tax” idea crafted by famed free-market economist Milton Friedman and briefly considered by Richard Nixon, the plan became a potent symbol of the Democrat’s alleged radicalism, fiscal irresponsibility, and wooly thinking. Even before Republicans began mocking him over it, primary rival Hubert Humphrey — hardly a conservative on domestic issues — blasted the proposal with both barrels, claiming it would lead to a massive middle-class tax increase while undermining incentives to work. It probably caused McGovern more grief than anything else he had control over in that campaign, which ended with him losing 49 states to Nixon.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Link › 2NC---L---UBI
John Manning 21, Columnist at International Banker, 4/19/21, "Has the Time for Universal Basic Income Finally Arrived?,” https://internationalbanker.com/finance/has-the-time-for-universal-basic-income-finally-arrived/
But arguably the biggest challenge for UBI as a viable policy is the fierce opposition that it and all proposals of guaranteed-income programmes face in Congress—whether UBI itself, enhanced unemployment benefits or boosted minimum wage. In the US, this opposition has typically come from the Republican side of the political aisle, which has consistently argued that government-allocated income should be distributed only to those who have earned it. According to the Pew Research Center, nearly eight in ten Republicans and Republican-leaning independents (78 percent) oppose the federal government providing UBI of about $1,000 per person, with 62 percent strongly opposed. A smaller 66 percent of Democrats and Democrat-leaners favour a UBI, with just a third supporting the proposal strongly.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › Link › 2NC---L---Single-Payer
John Nichols 17, national affairs correspondent for The Nation, 10/9/17, “Why Do Republicans (and Some Democrats) Vilify Single Payer?” https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/why-do-republicans-and-some-democrats-vilify-single-payer/
Single payer is a bad idea for senators whose political survival is based on banking checks from health-care profiteers. But it is a very good idea for America.
Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell has, through the campaign committees and political-action committees that he guides, collected millions of dollars from Wall Street interests, insurance interests, pharmaceutical interests, private hospital and nursing home interests and “health products” interests over the course of a political career that has seen him go to the mat, again and again, in defense of Wall Street interests, insurance interests, pharmaceutical interests, private hospital and nursing home interests and “health products” interests.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---AT: SNAP
Chris Clayton 23, DTN Ag Policy Editor, 4/25/23, "How the House Debt Ceiling Battle Spills into Plans for the Next Farm Bill,” https://www.dtnpf.com/agriculture/web/ag/news/article/2023/04/25/house-debt-ceiling-battle-spills
Asked if Democrats would agree to some deal to tighten work requirements for SNAP, Costa said, "Well, the Speaker is attempting with his Republican colleagues to attach their Christmas list to the lifting of the debt ceiling."
Costa noted the arguments over finding ways to tighten eligibility for SNAP don't go away. "For those of you who have been in the reauthorization of the farm bill, this is always an issue and a debate we have every five years," he said.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---AT: SNAP
Paul Yeager 6-2, Journalist, with; David Miller, 6/2/23, "Market To Market - June 2, 2023,” https://www.iowapbs.org/shows/mtom/episode/9795/market-market-june-2-2023
Tom Sell is co-founder of Combest, Sell and Associates, a Washington D.C. - based lobbying firm specializing in agricultural issues. Sell believes the bipartisan history of the Farm Bill appears to be alive and well.
Tom Sell/Co-Founder Combast, Sell and Associates: “So now with that taken care of in this debt ceiling deal, I'm hopeful that it just creates this wake or a little pathway for the Farm Bill to go through where we're really going to focus on the farm safety net. That's, that's kind of where the leaders on both sides have said they want to, they want to build consensus.”
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---AT: Overwhelms the Link
Marc Heller 23, E&E Daily, 1/23/23, “Rough road for farm bill as divided Congress takes hold,” https://www.eenews.net/articles/rough-road-for-farm-bill-as-divided-congress-takes-hold/
A chaotic start to the new Republican-led House may spell trouble for the 2023 farm bill.
As Rep. Glenn Thompson begins his new job as Agriculture Committee chair, he faces significant challenges to make the five-year legislation bipartisan while managing pressure from his own party’s right flank.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass
Garrett Downs 22, POLITICO, 11/24/22, “Climate advocates see a path forward in the farm bill: Lining farmers’ pockets,” https://www.politico.com/news/2022/11/24/climate-advocates-farm-bill-00070567
Republicans could be swayed by the argument that regenerative agriculture is better for business. “We were saving one million dollars a year in input costs and we were increasing yield year-over-year in both corn and [soy]beans,” said Rick Clark, an Indiana farmer who transitioned to regenerative agriculture several years ago and testified to its benefits at a recent House Agriculture Committee hearing.
Democrats, for their part, are likely to keep pushing the issue.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass
Max Graham 23, food and agriculture fellow at Grist, 3/30/23, “The next farm bill could be a historic climate law – if Congress can agree on it,” https://grist.org/agriculture/farm-bill-historic-climate-law-split-congress/
And while that act showed bipartisan interest in voluntary farm programs that could curb emissions, a Republican-led House and a narrow Democratic majority in the Senate could stand in the way of more stringent regulations, like Senator Cory Booker’s proposal to ban CAFOs. Representative Glenn Thompson, a Republican from Pennsylvania who chairs the House Agriculture Committee, said last year he wants to “make sure the farm bill doesn’t become the next climate bill.” And Senator John Boozman, a senior Republican on the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee, raised concerns at a committee hearing earlier this month about the climate-specific agriculture funding earmarked in the IRA, which Republicans unanimously opposed. But Republican leaders, including Thompson and Boozman, also have intimated they could be open to climate-beneficial programs with limitations.
Success in getting Republicans on board might hinge on how programs are framed. For example, lawmakers from both parties have signaled support for voluntary programs that assist farmers in planting cover crops, while some Republicans have pushed back against requiring growers to engage in climate-friendly practices to get subsidies for crop insurance. “There is a lot of potential for climate targeting — without calling it climate,” Day said.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass/PC Key
Leah Douglas 23, Reuters Journalist, 5/2/23, “Biden administration pledges fight to keep climate-friendly farming funds,” https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/biden-administration-pledges-fight-keep-climate-friendly-farming-funds-2023-05-02/
The Biden administration will defend funding for climate-smart farming in the $430 billion U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) if Republican lawmakers seek to cut it during negotiations for the next farm bill, an official said Tuesday.
The IRA, which aims to cut emissions across the U.S. economy, includes $20 billion to support farmers in implementing carbon-sequestering conservation practices on their land.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass/PC Key
Meredith Lee Hill 23, POLITICO, 5/10/23, “Biden invites lawmakers to White House to discuss farm bill amid looming debt limit crisis,” https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/10/biden-farm-bill-debt-limits-00096190
President Joe Biden is wading into the high-stakes negotiations over the farm bill, amid growing concerns the debt limit stand-off could knock that must-pass piece of legislation off track.
Biden has invited a small, bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House Thursday to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization, according to four people familiar with the plans who were granted anonymity to discuss internal conversations. Congress is aiming to write and pass what is expected to be a $1 trillion-plus bill, which will authorize U.S. food and agriculture spending for the next decade, by this fall. But even senior Senate Republicans are increasingly wary that the mounting debt crisis could derail the traditionally bipartisan farm bill.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass/PC Key
Jim Weisemeyer 5/11, Drovers Journalist covering the beef market, 5/11/23, “Lawmakers Meet with Biden to Discuss Farm Bill 2023,” https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/lawmakers-meet-biden-discuss-farm-bill-2023
President Biden invited a bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House this afternoon to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization. Invitees include Rep. G.T. Thompson (R-Pa.), Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.), Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.), Rep. David Scott (D-Ga.), and USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack.
Stabenow labeled the session as a chance to “have a broader discussion about the farm bill and all the implications for it,” and that it will show “we are working together in a bipartisan way.” She also noted it was a chance for both sides to share their priorities for the bill.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › UQ › 2NC---UQ---Will Pass/PC Key
Leah Douglas 22, Reuters Journalist, 11/18/22, “Analysis: U.S. House Republican farm bill approach may test Biden hunger, climate goals,” https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-house-republican-farm-bill-approach-may-test-biden-hunger-climate-goals-2022-11-18/
U.S. President Joe Biden's pledges to slash emissions from farming and to end American hunger by 2030 may be harder to realize now that Republicans flipped the House of Representatives with a thin majority.
Biden's Democrats, who retain control of the Senate, will start negotiating in the coming months with Republican House leaders over a massive farm spending bill passed every five years that funds U.S. public food benefits and farm commodity programs.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › 1NC › 1NC UBI Link
Rich Whitney 21, Attorney from Carbondale, Illinois, now working as an appellate public defender,, 9/22/21, "How Universal Basic Income Can Help Build a Solidarity Economy,” https://nonprofitquarterly.org/how-universal-basic-income-can-help-build-a-solidarity-economy/
III. UBI would be an immense improvement over existing, means-tested social-welfare programs.
Because it would be universal, UBI would allow government to eliminate a great deal of the wasteful bureaucracy and the time-consuming and often humiliating means-testing practices that accompany most current welfare programs.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › 1NC › 1NC Single Payer Link
Mary Ellen McIntire 18, Staff writer at Roll Call, 11/20/18, “On ‘Medicare-for-All,’ Democrats Tread Lightly,” https://rollcall.com/2018/11/20/on-medicare-for-all-democrats-tread-lightly/
Progressives in the House are calling for a vote on a single-payer “Medicare-for-all” bill in the next Congress, but the expected chairmen who will set the agenda for next year say they have other health priorities.
Still, the progressives’ push could earn more attention over the next two years as Democratic candidates begin vying to take on President Donald Trump in 2020. A handful of potential presidential candidates expected to declare interest have already co-sponsored “Medicare-for-all” legislation, an issue that was also a flashpoint in Democratic primaries over the past year.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › 1NC › 1NC---Farm Bill
Chase Sova 19, Center for Strategic & International Studies Senior Associate (Non-resident), Global Food Security Program, with; Kimberly Flowers and Christian Man, 10/15/19, “Climate Change and Food Security: A Test of U.S. Leadership in a Fragile World,” https://www.csis.org/analysis/climate-change-and-food-security-test-us-leadership-fragile-world
Climate change poses a considerable threat to global food security, with potentially existential economic, political, and social outcomes for humanity. As climate impacts worsen and further stress an already hungry world, the United States should claim the mantle of global leadership in responding to the impacts of climate change, double down on domestic efforts to promote climate-smart agriculture, elevate the issue of climate change and food insecurity in national security circles, and leverage the reorganization of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) to further mainstream climate resilience into U.S. global food security programs.
As people around the world increasingly feel the impacts of climate change, the collective call for action grows louder and louder. The effects of climate change on food production—often neglected in favor of stories on melting glaciers, tropical storms, and sea level rise—are receiving more and more mainstream attention. This brief seeks to summarize the relationship between climate change and food insecurity, highlight salient trends and controversies, and comment on U.S. government global policies and programs that tackle this important issue.
2023
Northwestern
Disadvantage
Neg – Farm Bill Politics DA › 1NC › 1NC---Farm Bill
Maxine Joselow 23, The Washington Post, 2/16/23, “The 2023 farm bill should be a climate bill, Democrats say,” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/02/16/2023-farm-bill-should-be-climate-bill-democrats-say/
Don’t look now, but the divided Congress could pass a major climate change bill.
No, it’s not version 2.0 of the Inflation Reduction Act, the Democrats’ sweeping climate and health-care package. Rather, the farm bill — the five-year reauthorization of hundreds of billions of dollars in agriculture and food programs — could help farmers tackle the climate crisis while feeding the nation.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
AT: Case › AT: Automation Advantage › AT: Liberal Order---XT
G. John Ikenberry 18, Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of Chicago, Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University in the Department of Politics and the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, March 2018, “Why the Liberal World Order Will Survive,” Ethics and International Affairs, Vol. 32, No. 1, p. 24-25
Self-Reinforcing Characteristics of Liberal International Order
The United States has dominated the post-war international order. It is an order built on asymmetries of power; it is hierarchical. But it is not an imperial system. It is a complex and multilayered political formation with liberal characteristics— openness and rules-based principles—that generate incentives and opportunities for other states to join and operate within it.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
AT: Case › AT: Automation Advantage › AT: Liberal Order---Top
G. John Ikenberry 18, Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of Chicago, Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University in the Department of Politics and the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, March 2018, “Why the Liberal World Order Will Survive,” Ethics and International Affairs, Vol. 32, No. 1, p. 19-22
But does this vision of power transition truly illuminate the struggles going on today over international order? Some might argue no—that the United States is still in a position, despite its travails, to provide hegemonic leadership. Here one would note that there is a durable infrastructure (or what Susan Strange has called “structural power”) that undergirds the existing American-led order. Far-flung security alliances, market relations, liberal democratic solidarity, deeply rooted geopolitical alignments—there are many possible sources of American hegemonic power that remain intact. But there may be even deeper sources of continuity in the existing system. This would be true if the existence of a liberal-oriented international order does not in fact require hegemonic domination. It might be that the power transition theory is wrong: the stability and persistence of the existing post-war international order does not depend on the concentration of American power.
In fact, international order is not simply an artifact of concentrations of power. The rules and institutions that make up international order have a more complex and contingent relationship with the rise and fall of state power. This is true in two respects. First, international order itself is complex: multilayered, multifaceted, and not simply a political formation imposed by the leading state. International order is not “one thing” that states either join or resist. It is an aggregation of various sorts of ordering rules and institutions. There are the deep rules and norms of sovereignty. There are governing institutions, starting with the United Nations. There is a sprawling array of international institutions, regimes, treaties, agreements, protocols, and so forth. These governing arrangements cut across diverse realms, including security and arms control, the world economy, the environment and global commons, human rights, and political relations. Some of these domains of governance may have rules and institutions that narrowly reflect the interests of the hegemonic state, but most reflect negotiated outcomes based on a much broader set of interests.