2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Defense › 2NC---Administrative Costs
Michael A. Diamond 9, family medicine doctor in Miami, Florida and is affiliated with multiple hospitals in the area. 2009. “Con: Single-Payer Health Care Why It's Not the Best Answer” http://www.atsjournals.org/doi/full/10.1164/rccm.200906-0882ED
In the United States, medical costs have been increasing inexorably for many years, as have the numbers of the uninsured; the latter is currently estimated to be as high as 47 million persons. A single-payer system has long been suggested by some as the most logical solution to the current crisis in health care access and affordability (1). Under a single-payer health system, the federal government would ultimately be responsible for reimbursement of most medical services provided by clinicians and hospitals. The hope is that a single-payer system will both improve access to health care and reduce health care costs. By definition, under a single-payer system no one would be without health insurance, and cost savings might be achieved through a reduction in administrative expenses coupled with an emphasis on preventive medicine and the universal adoption of electronic medical records. However, I have substantial concerns over whether these potential benefits can actually be accomplished. It is the history of government bureaus to become large and complex rather than lean and efficient. Furthermore, access to preventive care does not equate to individual adherence to the precepts of such care. Finally, I fear that the ultimate toll of a single-payer system will be a reduction in the quality of health care that Americans may be unwilling to bear.
Proponents of a single-payer system argue that government-sponsored insurance would save money by reducing wasteful administrative costs. Yet comparisons of administrative expenditures between private and government-run insurance programs are misleading (2). For instance, the cost of administering a private insurance plan includes the expense of collecting premium dollars, which also applies to government insurance programs such as Medicare. However, this expense does not register on Medicare's budget insofar as a separate government agency (the Internal Revenue Service) performs this function. Furthermore, many states tax premiums paid to private insurers, and also tax their profits; government programs are not so encumbered. Finally, Medicare spends approximately twice as much on claims than most private insurers (older patients consume more services), and administrative expense is expressed as a percent of claims paid. Thus, Medicare looks more thrifty than it really is (2). Estimates of the bureaucratic cost savings under a single-payer system do not account for the expense of administering a greatly expanded Medicare-like program or the price of collecting new employer and individual taxes.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Defense › 2NC---Costs Solvency
Megan McArdle 17, Bloomberg View columnist, “States Where Single-Payer Health Care Could Work (If It Could Work Anywhere),” https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-05-30/states-where-single-payer-health-care-could-work-if-it-could-work-anywhere
Casual believers in single payer often eyeball European governments, eyeball what the U.S. spends, and conclude that there must be fabulous cost savings to be had from a single-payer system, making it easily affordable even for states on a tight budget. Folks actually charged with designing a single-payer system know the truth: single payer will not make health care cheap. Analyses by single-payer-friendly sources (such as Gerald Friedman of UMass Amherst, and the heavily Democratic California State Senate) tend to indicate that moving to single payer would involve roughly doubling the budgets of even high-tax, high-spending states like New York and California. Less friendly sources suggest that the cost might be substantially higher than that. Unless they find some way to dramatically slash the incomes of health-care workers (not gonna happen), then single-payer advocates are going to have to persuade voters to support breathtaking tax increases. It hardly needs pointing out that this will be difficult.
The second thing to say is that New York and California represent absolutely the best possible scenarios for single payer in this country. If they can’t make it work (and I’m betting they can’t), then single payer cannot be done in this country--full stop, end of story, print as written.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Defense › 2NC---Costs Solvency
Lauren Hall 17, associate professor of political science at Rochester Institute of Technology, 10-5-2017, "Why compassionate people should reject Bernie’s single-payer health care plan," http://www.learnliberty.org/blog/why-compassionate-people-should-reject-bernies-single-payer-health-care-plan/
Senate Democrats are taking advantage of Republican disorganization on health care to push a single-payer platform, and the Dems seem excited about the momentum they’ve gained. The main proposal comes from Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and is formatted as a “Medicare for All” policy that essentially eliminates private insurance, replacing it with federally provided and paid-for coverage.
Critics like Sanders have long bemoaned the “capitalist” health care system in the United States as proof that we need a single-payer system and more government involvement in health care. What Sanders’s proposal is missing (in addition to information on what it would cost or how it would be paid for) is an understanding of how government policies since the 1940s have contributed to escalating costs of care. Without revamping the fundamental way the US government invests in health care, a Medicare for All plan is the equivalent of sticking a Band-Aid on a gunshot wound.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Defense › 1NC---Costs Solvency
Jodi Liu 17, associate policy researcher at RAND, “Savings from a Single-Payer Health System Would Not Be Automatic,” 9/26/17, https://www.rand.org/blog/2017/09/savings-from-a-single-payer-health-system-would-not.html
Discussion of single-payer health care systems increased somewhat last week with the introduction by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) of his Medicare-for-all legislation. Polls have shown increasing public support for single payer. Yet there is no agreement on how to set up and pay for a single-payer system in the U.S. or how much that system would cost. Advocates assert that a single-payer system would cost less than the status quo, but the savings are not automatic, and how much it would save is far from clear.
The spending required for a single-payer system depends on the price of care and the services used. When health care is free, people tend to use more health care services, some of which is beneficial and some is not. Under Sanders's Medicare-for-all plan, the use of health care services would almost certainly increase.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Defense › 1NC---Costs UQ
Nicole Rapfogel 22, policy analyst for Health at American Progress; with Emily Gee, senior vice president for Inclusive Growth at American Progress. 2-25-2022, "How the Inflation Reduction Act Reduces Health Care Costs," Center for American Progress,
The Inflation Reduction Act, when passed by the House of Representatives and signed into law by President Joe Biden, will give a lifeline to people struggling with health costs by providing much-needed financial relief for the health coverage and medications they need to survive and thrive. The bill improves health care and affordability by:
Empowering Medicare to negotiate with drug companies to lower prices
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › --AT: Gov Hires Them Back
Michelle Faust 17, health care reporter at KPCC with a focus on health policy. 6/02/17, “If California goes single-payer, what happens to insurance workers?” http://www.scpr.org/news/2017/06/02/72484/if-california-goes-single-payer-what-happens-to-in/
The bill to create a state-run health care system in California would do away with most health insurance, so many of those employed in that industry would need new jobs. But no one seems to know how many people might be affected.
"It’s not a small part of the legislation," says Dr. Nadereh Pourat, director of research at the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research. "This is an impactful part of the legislation and it should be studied, so we actually know exactly what’s going to happen."
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Insurance Industry Jobs
Monica Potts 17, writer and fellow with the New America Foundation Asset Building Program, 9/18/17, “The Single-Payer Problem Liberals Don't Want to Talk About,” https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/3kabqb/the-single-payer-problem-liberals-dont-want-to-talk-about
Indeed, by one measure, administrative costs account for more than 8 percent of spending on healthcare in the United States, more than double the average of industrialized countries around the world. Sanders's plan proposes a more streamlined, government-run system that would put the needs of people first, and he promises to do it in four short years if everything goes his way—which, of course, it won't.
But all of that bloated spending does something else single-payer fans would do well to grapple with: It creates jobs. Often, these are good jobs, especially for people with a modest education. And what happens to those people—who are mostly women—is something Democrats and progressives need to get a handle on if single-payer is ever going to get real traction in Washington.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Insurance Industry Jobs
Daily Kos 15, group blog and internet forum focused on liberal American politics.1/26/15, “The Case In Favor of Universal Health Cover but Against Single Payer” https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2015/1/26/1360024/-The-Case-In-Favor-of-Universal-Health-Insurance-but-Against-Single-Payer
Job loss is a major consideration in choosing a universal health scheme over single payer. Of course there will be some job loss from the private sector when a universal plan is introduced but those losses, by and large, would be quickly absorbed into the government’s health sector.
Eliminating all private health insurance, on the other hand, would instantly dump hundreds of thousands of jobs on the employment market, too many for the government sector to absorb at once and too many for which the government has no need such as those workers from accounts and promotion departments. A government health plan for all is not going to be sending out accounts to any of its clients nor will it have any need to promote itself in the market when it already encompasses everyone.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Deficit Link
Justin Bogie 8/16, is a senior policy analyst in fiscal affairs at The Heritage Foundation. 8/16/17, “America Is Heading Straight Into Its Most Avoidable Crisis Ever” http://dailysignal.com/2017/08/16/america-is-heading-straight-into-its-most-avoidable-crisis-ever/
The consequences of Washington’s excessive spending will manifest in several ways.
For one, such a massive federal debt stifles economic growth. Interest rates could rise more steeply, either at the behest of creditors seeking protection from the risk associated with investing in a country with an unsustainable debt trajectory, or simply because the government is attempting to sell more bonds than people are willing to buy at current rates.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Deficit Link
Avik Roy 16, the President of the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity. Non-partisan, non-profit think tank. 1/18/16, “Sanders Adviser: Berniecare Would Increase Total Federal Spending by 55 Percent (at Least)” http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/429951/bernie-sanders-single-payer-health-care-plan-would-increase-total-federal-spending-55
Nonetheless, if you take Friedman’s rosy scenario for granted, you’re still looking at an astounding 55 percent increase in total federal spending from 2017 to 2026. That’s because under current law, “only” 31 percent of U.S. health-care spending is run through the federal government, while 19 percent goes through state and local governments, 21 percent through businesses, and 29 percent through households. So if the federal government were to assume responsibility for all U.S. health-care spending, even with some rationing and price controls, federal spending would increase by $28 trillion from 2017 to 2026. Of that, $14 trillion would be paid for by taxes, and the rest would increase the deficit.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Tax Link
Yevgeniy Feyman 16, is a fellow and deputy director of health policy with the Manhattan Institute. 2/11/16, “The Single-Payer Sacrifice: 11.6 Million Jobs” http://www.realclearpolicy.com/blog/2016/02/11/single-payer_sacrifice_116_million_jobs_1551.html
Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders recently released his health-care plan: a government-run single-payer system for the U.S., similar to what many European countries have. Criticism of the plan has so far focused on its lack of political feasibility, but there is an even more important reason to be wary: Accounting for costs and tax increases, it would reduce labor supply by 11.6 million. In a struggling economy, with tepid wage growth, hurting employment should be the last thing on any politician’s agenda.
The plan truly promises everything under the sun. Not only will everyone be able to get any medical treatment needed — with no cost at the point of service — but the plan won’t require a terribly high tax increase. The funding mechanism boils down to an increase in payroll taxes: an “income-based premium” of 2.2 percent for individuals and a tax of 6.2 percent on employers. Because economists, as well as the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office and the Joint Committee on Taxation, recognize that the "employer share" of payroll taxes is mostly borne by workers in the form of lower wages, this translates to an 8.4 percentage point increase overall.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Tax Link
Sally C. Pipes 16, president, CEO, and Thomas W. Smith fellow in health care policy at the Pacific Research Institute. 1/21/16, “The Ugly Reality of Single-Payer” https://www.usnews.com/debate-club/is-single-payer-health-care-a-good-idea/the-ugly-reality-of-single-payer
Late Sunday night, just hours before the fourth Democratic presidential debate, Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders unveiled what's probably the purest expression to date of his unreconstructed 1970s radicalism: a plan for "universal" single-payer health care in the United States.
Proudly titled "Medicare-for-All," the Sanders scheme would eliminate the private insurance industry and establish a single, federally run insurance pool open to all.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Economy UQ
The Economist 23, Published since September 1843 to take part in “a severe contest between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our progress.” 4-13-23, "America’s economic outperformance is a marvel to behold," The Economist, https://www.economist.com/briefing/2023/04/13/from-strength-to-strength
American economic declinism is a broad church. Voices on the right claim that big government has stifled the frontier spirit and that soaring debt has condemned future generations to poverty. The left worries that inequality and corporate power have hollowed out the economy. In a rare display of unity, all parts of the ideological spectrum bemoan the death of American manufacturing and the crushing of the middle class.
There is just one snag. On a whole range of measures American dominance remains striking. And relative to its rich-world peers its lead is increasing.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Economy UQ
Myles Udland 5/23, Yahoo Finance's Head of News. 5-23-2023, "US economic output reaches a 13-month high in May," Yahoo Finance,
The US economy is growing at the fastest pace since April 2022.
That's according to new data from S&P Global released Tuesday morning.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 2NC---Economy UQ
Benjamin Harris 23, Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy, with Deputy Assistant Secretary for Macroeconomic Policy Tara Sinclair. 6-5-2023, "The U.S. Economic Recovery in International Context,"
U.S. ECONOMIC RECOVERY FASTEST AMONG COMPARABLE ADVANCED ECONOMIES
For many advanced economies, real GDP it is at, or above, where it was in the fourth quarter of 2019, prior to the start of the pandemic. However, there is considerable variability across countries. Not all G7 economies have fully recovered to their pre-pandemic size; by contrast, U.S. real GDP is now 5.4 percent above the level at the end of 2019.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 1NC---Economy Turn
Chad Terhune 17, works for the Kaiser Health News, a nonprofit health newsroom. 4/25/17, “In bid to revamp health care, Trump could hurt one of U.S.'s biggest job creators” http://money.cnn.com/2017/04/25/news/economy/health-care-jobs-trump-obamacare/index.html
In many ways, the health care industry has been a great friend to the U.S. economy. Its plentiful jobs helped lift the country out of the Great Recession and, partly due to the Affordable Care Act, it now employs one in nine Americans — up from one in 12 in 2000.
As President Donald Trump seeks to fulfill his campaign pledge to create millions more jobs, the industry would seem a promising place to turn. But the business mogul also campaigned to repeal Obamacare and lower health care costs — a potentially serious job killer.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 1NC---Economy Turn
Margot Sanger-Katz 16, domestic correspondent for The New York Times, where she writes about health care. 5/16/16, “A Single-Payer Plan From Bernie Sanders Would Probably Still Be Expensive” https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/17/upshot/why-single-payer-health-care-would-probably-still-be-expensive.html
The Sanders plan would require a huge reorganization of the country’s health care system. Overnight, it would put the private insurance industry out of business, along with many other businesses that support it. It would shift billions of dollars of spending from individuals, workers and states into the federal budget. Doing that might well reduce some of the country’s health care spending that is going toward insurer profits and paper-pushing.
But more than 80 percent of the dollars we currently spend on health care actually go toward health care. And making big cuts all at once to doctors and hospitals could cause substantial disruptions in care. Some hospitals would go out of business. Some doctors would default on their mortgages and student loans. Even if the country decided that medicine should become a more middle-class profession — not an obvious outcome, given the substantial public support for the medical professions — it would be difficult to get there at once.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Economy Advantage---Offense › 1NC---Economy Turn
Michael Tanner 17, senior fellow at the Cato Institute. 6/7/17, “Embracing the Hard Realities of Health-Care Reform” http://www.nationalreview.com/article/448350/health-care-reform-reality-check-single-payer-model-economically-ruinous
The utopian fantasy of a single-payer system is attractive to many voters, but it would destroy the American economy.
It is an old joke among health-policy wonks that what the American people really want from health-care reform is unlimited care, from the doctor of their choice, with no wait, free of charge. For Republicans, trying to square this circle has led to panic, paralysis, and half-baked policy proposals such as the Obamacare-replacement bill that passed the House last month. For Democrats, it has led from simple disasters such as Obamacare itself to a position somewhere between fantasy and delusion.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Disease Advantage---Defense › 2NC---Disease Defense
Fareed Zakaria 9, Editor of Newsweek, BA from Yale, PhD in pol sci, Harvard, on the board of Yale University, The Council on Foreign Relations, The Trilateral Commission, and Shakespeare and Company, “The Capitalist Manifesto: Greed Is Good,” 13 June 2009, http://www.newsweek.com/id/201935
Note—Laurie Garrett=science and health writer, winner of the Pulitzer, Polk, and Peabody Prize
It certainly looks like another example of crying wolf. After bracing ourselves for a global pandemic, we've suffered something more like the usual seasonal influenza. Three weeks ago the World Health Organization declared a health emergency, warning countries to "prepare for a pandemic" and said that the only question was the extent of worldwide damage. Senior officials prophesied that millions could be infected by the disease. But as of last week, the WHO had confirmed only 4,800 cases of swine flu, with 61 people having died of it. Obviously, these low numbers are a pleasant surprise, but it does make one wonder, what did we get wrong? Why did the predictions of a pandemic turn out to be so exaggerated? Some people blame an overheated media, but it would have been difficult to ignore major international health organizations and governments when they were warning of catastrophe. I think there is a broader mistake in the way we look at the world. Once we see a problem, we can describe it in great detail, extrapolating all its possible consequences. But we can rarely anticipate the human response to that crisis. Take swine flu. The virus had crucial characteristics that led researchers to worry that it could spread far and fast. They described—and the media reported—what would happen if it went unchecked. But it did not go unchecked. In fact, swine flu was met by an extremely vigorous response at its epicenter, Mexico. The Mexican government reacted quickly and massively, quarantining the infected population, testing others, providing medication to those who needed it. The noted expert on this subject, Laurie Garrett, says, "We should all stand up and scream, 'Gracias, Mexico!' because the Mexican people and the Mexican government have sacrificed on a level that I'm not sure as Americans we would be prepared to do in the exact same circumstances. They shut down their schools. They shut down businesses, restaurants, churches, sporting events. They basically paralyzed their own economy. They've suffered billions of dollars in financial losses still being tallied up, and thereby really brought transmission to a halt." Every time one of these viruses is detected, writers and officials bring up the Spanish influenza epidemic of 1918 in which millions of people died. Indeed, during the last pandemic scare, in 2005, President George W. Bush claimed that he had been reading a history of the Spanish flu to help him understand how to respond. But the world we live in today looks nothing like 1918. Public health-care systems are far better and more widespread than anything that existed during the First World War. Even Mexico, a developing country, has a first-rate public-health system—far better than anything Britain or France had in the early 20th century.
2023
Northwestern
Affirmative
Case › Disease Advantage---Defense › 2NC---Disease Defense
Ian York 14, head of the Influenza Molecular Virology and Vaccines team in the Immunology and Pathogenesis Branch of the Influenza Division at the CDC, PhD in Molecular Virology and Immunology from McMaster University, M.Sc. in Veterinary Microbiology and Immunology from the University of Guelph, former Assistant Prof of Microbiology & Molecular Genetics at Michigan State, “Why Don't Diseases Completely Wipe Out Species?” 6/4/2014, http://www.quora.com/Why-dont-diseases-completely-wipe-out-species
But mostly diseases don't drive species extinct. There are several reasons for that. For one, the most dangerous diseases are those that spread from one individual to another. If the disease is highly lethal, then the population drops, and it becomes less likely that individuals will contact each other during the infectious phase. Highly contagious diseases tend to burn themselves out that way.¶ Probably the main reason is variation. Within the host and the pathogen population there will be a wide range of variants. Some hosts may be naturally resistant. Some pathogens will be less virulent. And either alone or in combination, you end up with infected individuals who survive.¶ We see this in HIV, for example. There is a small fraction of humans who are naturally resistant or altogether immune to HIV, either because of their CCR5 allele or their MHC Class I type. And there are a handful of people who were infected with defective versions of HIV that didn't progress to disease. ¶ We can see indications of this sort of thing happening in the past, because our genomes contain many instances of pathogen resistance genes that have spread through the whole population. Those all started off as rare mutations that conferred a strong selection advantage to the carriers, meaning that the specific infectious diseases were serious threats to the species.