Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Asia Pivot Terminals

US deterrence of China hinges on credible signals and engagement.

Yves-Heng Lim 22. Senior Lecturer at the Department of Security Studies, Macquarie University. "The fragility of general deterrence: The United States and China in maritime East Asia." Comparative Strategy, Vol. 41, Issue 2. 3-21-2022. https://doi.org/10.1080/01495933.2022.2039006. accessed 6-25-2022 //ART

The erosion of US general deterrence in maritime East Asia has attracted significant attention over the last few years. To a certain extent, the discussion has been more focused on how to bolster US deterrence posture –typically through changes to the forces deployed by the US in the area. This approach has generated remarkable insights into the shortcoming of the US position, but it has at the same time pushed the question of the mechanisms of deterrence erosion in the background. This question is, however, important because it clarifies the limits of what could be achieved by changes along one dimension of US deterrence posture. In broad terms, this section argues that the erosion of US general deterrent posture in maritime East Asia can be explained by three primary mechanisms: an enduring local imbalance of interest that favors China, a changing balance of power that has eroded US position in the region and a difficulty in drawing red lines that has been compounded by China’s “circumvention” strategy.

Credibility and the imbalance of interests

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Expulsion Good---Swinland L

Turkey blocks Sweden and Finland

Cropsey 22, founder and president of Yorktown Institute. He served as a naval officer and as deputy Undersecretary of the Navy (Seth, “The Turkish Question on NATO: A larger strategic opportunity in the Black Sea,” The Hill,

The Russian invasion of Ukraine overturned this situation and demonstrated the Atlantic Alliance’s value. Moreover, the geography of the Russia-NATO military rivalry has changed: The Baltic States’ membership in NATO makes a Russia-NATO conflict likely to involve Finland and Sweden, or at least to occur within their territorial waters. Both states would benefit the Atlantic Alliance. Both retain effective militaries focused upon great-power war; neither would need overwhelming American logistical support. Unlike nearly all of NATO’s current members apart from the U.S., Sweden and Finland can pull their own combat weight. Hungarian President Viktor Orban’s positive disposition towards the Kremlin made Hungary a more likely candidate to oppose any NATO expansion. Orban has been restrained, however, focusing instead on opposing EU sanctions on Russian energy exports. Instead, it is Turkey that opposes Swedish and Finnish NATO membership. A single country’s opposition can derail a NATO bid. Greece, for example, kept Macedonia out of NATO until 2019 because it deemed the country’s name to be an affront to Greek culture: it only relented when Macedonia added “North” to its name. Cyprus remains out of NATO primarily because of Turkey’s opposition, based on Turkish-Greek rivalry.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Expulsion Good---LIO

Turkish inclusion undermines the ability to use NATO to save the LIO

GM 19 (Geopolitical Monitor, “Point Counterpoint: Turkey Should Be Expelled from NATO,” https://www.geopoliticalmonitor.com/point-counterpoint-turkey-should-be-expelled-from-nato/)//BB

Third, Turkey’s membership leaves the Alliance in a compromised position on various fronts: namely Erdogan’s authoritarian tendencies; his attempt to exploit the Turkish diaspora to promote his interests in Europe; the persistent occupation of Northern Cyprus; Turkey’s assertive actions in the Eastern Mediterranean; and its frequent violations of Greek airspace. For an organization based upon the principles of democracy and rule of law, which seeks to promote international peace and stability, Turkey’s behavior represents a major contradiction and damages the Alliance’s image.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Expulsion Good---Entrapment

Entrapment risks outweigh any benefits

Saleh 20- Researcher, Political analyst , US foreign policy , Syria conflict, Kurds affairs and the Middle East issues.(John Saleh, “Turkey’s Authoritarian Policy on NATO Principles,” Modern Diplomacy, July 22 2020, https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2020/07/22/turkeys-authoritarian-policy-on-nato-principles/)//mcu

Protecting Europe from any further expansion of the Soviet Union’s sphere of influence and interference was the main argument for expanding NATO membership, to include Turkey in 1952. Turkey, in turn, sought to be part of the European club and approached the West. That is why the US military presence in Turkey with conventional and nuclear forces was against the Soviet threat as well as against the potential effects of instability and conflicts in the Middle East. Where the strategic interests of the allies always dominate relations between Turkey and NATO, during and after the Cold War. That is why Turkey was under the protection of NATO and its supply of advanced weapons. Turkey is an important member of NATO because of its strategic location between East and West, and its control of the Bosporus and Dardanelles to prevent Russia from reaching the Mediterranean Sea. Also hosting the Turkish Incirlik base for the American forces and the Patriot missiles, Turkey’s contribution to NATO with its soldiers in Kosovo and Afghanistan and supporting NATO’s military and financial tasks. That is why Erdogan takes advantage of all this to use him in his despotic policies and practices that are angering NATO countries and increasing their division. The preamble to the 1949 NATO Treaty states that NATO members are “determined to protect the freedom, shared heritage, and civilization of their people, based on the principles of democracy, individual freedom, and the rule of law.” That is why the member states of NATO are very concerned about the changes taking place in Turkey, but nonetheless NATO seeks to preserve the relationship with Turkey and not leave the alliance. This policy towards Turkey tarnishes the alliance’s image and mission, weakens democracy and the rule of law, and further weakens the alliance. It contributes to encouraging Erdogan to escalate his influence by supporting extremist Islamic movements, ISIS, Al-Qaeda and Al-Nusra Movement, and thus the terrorism industry in the Middle East, and its export to Europe. So, they should deal Turkey practices as a “frenemy” and adopt the term that has been applied to Pakistan. As a result, if NATO remains silent toward Erdogan’s authoritarian policies, which are hostile to liberal and democratic values, and his cooperation with Iran and Russia, we will find NATO implicated and responsible for Turkey’s crimes, where war crimes inside Syria and ethnic cleansing of the Kurds, as well as its interference in Libya. This will send NATO into wars to defend a member of the alliance. This will bring disaster, instability and the possibility of Iran and Russia affecting NATO’s security and military affairs through their relations and strategic cooperation with Turkey.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Expulsion Good---NATO

Turkish expulsion is good --- prevents Russia/China infiltration AND re-establishes NATO as a liberal community

Williamson 5/22- a fellow at National Review Institute, the roving correspondent for National Review (KEVIN D. WILLIAMSON “It’s Time to Boot Turkey from NATO,” National Review, May 22, 2022,

We ought to do Turkish caudillo Recep Tayyip Erdogan the courtesy of being frank with him: A NATO that includes Sweden and Finland but excludes Turkey is preferable to one that includes Turkey but excludes Sweden and Finland. It is time for Turkey to go. As Russian war criminals murder and rape their way through Ukraine, Russia’s long-suffering neighbor, Finland, has finally decided that it is time to formally join NATO. Sweden, though a larger and more powerful country (twice as big by population and by GDP), is following Finland’s lead and is ready to sign the North Atlantic Treaty, as well. Turkey, the odd man out in NATO, plans to veto any move to bring Finland and Sweden into the alliance. At least, that is the official position. Erdogan’s real agenda is something simpler: blackmail. Notionally, this is about the presence of a handful of Kurdish militants in Nordic exile. In reality, this is about the fact that Turkey under Erdogan has come to much more closely resemble Vladimir Putin’s Russia in its fundamental political character than it does any of its fellow NATO members. Turkey has developed close economic and political relations with Russia, and Erdogan has worked hard not to irritate Putin during the Ukraine war. Every political axis needs a third member, and Ankara today fits more easily between Moscow and Beijing than it does between Paris and Berlin. NATO is not only a military alliance. It is also a community of liberal-democratic values — values which Turkey rejects with increasing vigor and openness. The West once hoped — naively, as it turns out — that Erdogan would carry the banners of secularism, democracy, and liberty for the Turkish people, but he has led Turkey in the opposite direction: toward Islamist politics, authoritarianism, and tyranny. It is time to expel Turkey from NATO. This is a possibility that has been considered before. Erdogan’s brutal suppression of dissent beginning in 2016 and his cooperation with Moscow in acquiring Russian air-defense technology both led to calls for NATO to sever ties with Turkey. Booting Turkey out of NATO will be tricky on both the legal and political fronts, not least because the North Atlantic Treaty does not contain an explicit mechanism for expelling a member. The lawyers will no doubt dice it pretty fine if NATO members argue that Turkey is in material breach of its treaty obligations, but as a matter of fact Turkey is undermining NATO in the service of Erdogan’s domestic political needs. Turkey is advancing the interests of Moscow and Beijing and making it more difficult for NATO members to engage in collective self-defense, which is the point of NATO. And morally, Turkey does not deserve to be in NATO. NATO’s job is to defend its members against police states, not to provide a snug harbor in which authoritarianism may be cultivated. NATO’s neighboring bureaucracy in Brussels should also do Erdogan the courtesy of being frank and formally ending all consideration of Turkey as a candidate for membership in the European Union. Turkey was not a very good fit for the European Union at its best, and it is far from at its best today. Beyond its backsliding into soft dictatorship, Turkey is an economic basket case with 70 percent inflation and increasingly irresponsible economic policies. The European Union had a hard enough time with Greece’s financial shenanigans, and Greece is Denmark compared to Turkey. Geopolitics is not a matter of friendship. As Lord Palmerston put it (and here the full quotation is more illuminating than the apocryphal proverb attributed to Charles de Gaulle), “We have no eternal allies, and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual, and those interests it is our duty to follow.” There was a time when it seemed that Turkey was fitted to NATO’s permanent interests. Turkey joined NATO in 1952, when the organization was not yet a decade old and Joseph Stalin was still extant, if only barely that. NATO’s optimism was perhaps excessive, but, at the time, Turkey identified itself very strongly with the West and looked westward toward its future. Today’s Turkey looks eastward, and that fact should be acknowledged. Things did not have to go this way, but Turkey has made its choices — not only the autocratic junta of Recep Tayyip Erdogan but the Turkish people, too. Perhaps that looks like a tragedy when seen from Brussels and like something else when seen from Ankara. But however we feel about them, the facts on the ground are what they are, and it is time for NATO to recognize this and act accordingly.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › Expulsion Good---NATO

Turkish inclusion degrades NATO into an inviable force

Ben-Meir 17, American expert on Middle East politics and affairs, specializing in peace negotiations between Israel and the Arab states. For the past twenty five years, Ben-Meir has been directly involved in various Track II diplomatic negotiations and is a staunch advocate of the Arab Peace Initiative (Alon, “It’s Time to Kick Turkey Out of NATO,” )

Sadly, the European community and the US are betraying their democratic values. They continue to treat Erdogan with kid gloves because he is presumably an important player against ISIS, and because he is allowing the US and its allies to use Turkey’s Incirlik Air Base to launch air attacks against ISIS. To be sure, Erdogan has been successful in blackmailing the West. He skillfully uses his leverage to control the flow of Syrian refugees to Europe, and to cement Turkey’s geostrategic position as the hub for the transfer of oil and gas to Europe. NATO cannot allow one of its member states to erode the alliance from within, and still expect it to be a viable force that can maintain and protect European security and its moral values. No country led by a dictator that attacks US allies — such as the Kurds in Syria — should remain a member of NATO, and no country that sells weapons to ISIS should be a member of NATO. No country that cozies up to and buys weapons from America’s enemy — Russia — should continue to be a member of NATO, and no country which is being transformed into an extremist Islamic state by a zealous leader should maintain its place as a member of NATO. Finally, no country that has violated every tenet of democracy, engages in gross human rights abuses, and wreaks havoc on its population deserves to stay in the NATO alliance.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › U---On Brink

The counterplan signifies Turkey is no longer wanted as a NATO ally. That solves, even without a treaty-exit provision

Shipley 21, senior editor @ Bloomberg responsible for the editorial page (David, “Biden Should Cut the Gordian Knot With Turkey,” Bloomberg,

Turkey has long since abandoned the West. Its president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, has aligned his country with an axis of powers openly hostile to Western interests: China, Russia and Iran. This is his prerogative as a popular, elected leader. But Erdogan also craves the protection of the West’s military partnerships and membership in its economic associations. He wants Turkey to remain within the North Atlantic Treaty Organization even as he buys weapons systems that undermine the alliance’s security and hurls insults at heads of member states. And he seeks “mutual trust” with the European Union even as he threatens to flood it with millions of migrants. The West should respond by demonstrating that its tolerance for Turkish truculence is at an end. The best forum to do so is NATO, where patience for Erdogan is already wearing thin. The alliance’s first summit since President Joe Biden’s swearing-in takes place next week, and he is scheduled to meet Erdogan on June 14. Erdogan has deployed especially bellicose oratory against the U.S. Such hostility was met with amused tolerance by President Donald Trump, who showed little interest in American leadership. Now that Biden has said he will resume that responsibility, he should make it clear to Erdogan that Turkey can’t have it both ways. Biden has had plenty of opportunities to size Erdogan up over the years, and he has clearly concluded that the Turkish leader is an autocrat. Turkey, he has said, has “got to understand that we’re not going to continue to play with them the way we have.” Turkey is already testing this assertion by ratcheting up the rhetoric. Interior Minister Suleyman Soylu has openly accused the U.S. of ordering a failed 2016 coup attempt against Erdogan, and claimed Europe was enthusiastic in its support. This goes well beyond previous accusations, some aired by Erdogan himself, that the U.S. had sided with the coup plotters. In fact, Biden was vice president at the time of the coup attempt, and flew to Turkey to assure Erdogan of American support. Although Ankara has conducted exhaustive investigations into the events, and arrested thousands of people, it has not provided a shred of evidence that the U.S. or Europe were in any way involved. Yet Erdogan hasn’t thought to correct his minister’s charges, much less chastise him. As for NATO, Turkey has brushed aside its repeated warnings against acquiring Russian missile-defense systems, and is in fact proposing to buy even more. It has ratcheted up disputes with alliance members Greece (over hydrocarbon exploration) and France (over the Libyan civil war). More recently, it used its membership to further Moscow’s agenda by insisting that NATO water down its criticism of Belarus for the forced landing of an airliner and seizure of a dissident on board. NATO’s founding charter doesn’t allow for members to be expelled, but Turkey can be told in various ways that it’s no longer wanted as a member. A good start would be to reduce the alliance’s footprint on Turkish soil, starting with the withdrawal of nuclear weapons and other strategic assets. The group can also coordinate punitive measures against Turkey, including the suspension of arms sales and economic sanctions. The European Union should underline the message by confirming it has no intention of reviving the long-stalled talks over Turkey’s accession. Biden could back NATO with unilateral American measures. His administration has already indicated it may extend sanctions on Turkey’s defense industry and will uphold the country’s suspension from the F-35 fighter program. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has said even tougher penalties would be considered. This would be welcomed by Congress, where a bipartisan consensus on punishing Turkey had been frustrated by Trump’s tendency to cut Erdogan ever more slack. The site where Alexander ran his sword through the Gordian knot is an hour’s drive from modern Ankara. Cutting Turkey loose from the West should be a more straightforward undertaking.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › U---On Brink

Expulsion is on the brink

Candar 6-22 (Cengiz Candar is a columnist for Al-Monitor's Turkey Pulse. A journalist since 1976, he is the author of seven books in the Turkish language, mainly on Middle East issues. He is also the author of Turkey's Mission Impossible, War and Peace with the Kurds (Lexington, 2020). Currently, he is a Distinguished Visiting Scholar at Stockholm University Institute for Turkish Studies (SUITS) and a Senior Associate Fellow at the Swedish Institute of International Affairs (UI). AL-Monitor, June 22, 2022, “How Turkey's opposition to Sweden, Finland joining NATO could backfire,” ; accessed 6/25/2022) ng

However, Erdogan’s Turkey is in no hurry to see a strengthened NATO. Erdogan’s Turkey could be closer to Putin’s Russia in spirit than it is to the democratic nations of the Western world. The affinity between authoritarian leaders and autocracies should not be underestimated. The strengthened and reinvigorated NATO does not seem to be a priority for Erdogan. Erdogan's preconditions to withdraw Turkey’s veto are not only unrealistic but impossible for the two Nordic countries to implement. They range from the extradition of certain Swedish citizens or residents of Kurdish and Turkish origins to banning their activities in Sweden and terminating Sweden’s relations with the Syrian Kurdish groups. Turkey considers a major force within the Syrian Democratic Forces — a top ally in US-led fight against the Islamic State — to be a terrorist organization. SDF remains under the American security umbrella in northern Syria, where they can survive thanks to the American military presence in the region. Finland and Sweden would have to change their laws on freedom of demonstration and freedom of expression to comply with Ankara’s demands. This, in turn, almost amounts to upending Finland and Sweden’s democratic governance. “Mainstream Turkish politicians, as well as many humbler Turks, see the PKK purely as a security threat and criticize the West for not taking their concerns about the group seriously," the Economist summarized in a June 16 article, using the acronyms for the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party, which has been fighting the Turkish government for almost 40 years. "Turkey equates PKK and the Syrian Kurdish groups. … Westerners meanwhile, tend to believe that Turkey bears much of the blame for the PKK’s emergence by refusing to grant the country’s Kurds the rights they demand.” Ankara’s position has also unleashed a debate over Turkey’s NATO membership. “Turkey is a member of NATO, but under Mr. Erdogan, it no longer subscribes to the values that underpin this great alliance,” a Wall Street Journal op-ed said on May 18. "Article 13 of the NATO charter provides a mechanism for member states to withdraw. Perhaps it is time to amend Article 13 to establish a procedure for the expulsion of a member nation that meets neither the principled nor the practical requirements for membership." Almost a month after the WSJ article, The Economist echoed a similar sentiment, underscoring the mounting frustration among Western capitals. “Erdogan’s move to block Sweden’s and Finland’s accession to NATO further damaged Turkey’s standing in the alliance,” the article said. “Obstructing Finland’s and Sweden’s membership while war rages in Europe is bound to have consequences, even if Erdogan backs down. … Western countries will try to work round Turkey’s veto by providing Finland and Sweden with security guarantees. This may leave Turkey sidelined within the alliance,” it added. Currently, the text of the North Atlantic Treaty doesn't allow member states to expel or suspend another member state under any circumstances. The 2004 EU summit where Turkey secured a date to start negotiations with the European bloc is a distant memory. Erdogan’s brinkmanship may not work in Madrid. Even if the Madrid summit ends without a compromise, Sweden and Finland will likely become NATO members one way or another. If NATO leaders fail to find a face-saving formula at the summit, Erdogan's veto may backfire. Furthermore, it looks like Madrid would not be a cost-free enterprise for Turkey regardless of the outcome. It will be difficult for NATO to forget the bitter taste that Erdogan left in the alliance's ranks.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › EXPULSION N-B › L---CP Leads to Turkish Expulsion

By limiting cooperation to exclusively actors who are following the charter tenets, the counterplan identifies Turkey as in material breach---that results in Turkish exclusion from NATO, even without an exit clause

Sari 19 - Dr. Aurel Sari is an Associate Professor of Public International Law at the University of Exeter, Director of the Exeter Centre for International Law, a Fellow of Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe and a Fellow of the Allied Rapid Reaction Corps. His work focuses primarily on international conflict and security law and the law relating to military operations and is one of the principal experts on the legal aspects of hybrid warfare. He has spoken and written extensively on the subject, including at the invitation of the Council of Europe, NATO, the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats, U.S. EUCOM and U.S. AFRICOM. (Aurel Sairi, “Can Turkey be Expelled from NATO? It’s Legally Possible, Whether or Not Politically Prudent.” Just Security, 10/15/2019,

The Senate Committee on Foreign Relations also addressed the matter in its report on the treaty. Once again, the relevant passage is worth quoting in full: The treaty has been criticized in some quarters because it contains no provision for expulsion or the suspension of rights of a recalcitrant member which might fail to carry out its obligations as a result, for example, of its succumbing to communism. Given the nature of the pact and the close community of interests of the signatory states, the committee believes that such a provision would be both unnecessary and inappropriate. Obviously, however, if a member persistently violates the principles contained in the pact, the other members will no longer be obligated to assist that member. Clearly it would fail “to safeguard the freedom * * *” of its people, “founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty, and the rule of law” as set forth in the preamble, and to strengthen its “free institutions” as provided in article 2. Presumably it would also decline to participate in “mutual aid” (art. 3), and might well violate its undertakings in article 8 “not to enter into any international engagement in conflict with this treaty.” A country suffering such a fate would be in no position either to carry out its own obligations under the treaty or to expect assistance from the other parties.(The Vandenberg Resolution and the North Atlantic Treaty: Hearings, page 379.) “Material Breach” under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties These passages confirm that maintaining and furthering the principles on which the Alliance is based — democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law — forms part of the object and purpose of the North Atlantic Treaty. This, in turn, suggests that a failure to comply with these principles may amount to a material breach of the treaty within the meaning of Article 60 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. Pursuant to Article 60, a material breach consists of: (a) a repudiation of the treaty not sanctioned by the present Convention; or (b) the violation of a provision essential to the accomplishment of the object or purpose of the treaty. To constitute a material breach pursuant to sub-paragraph (a), the violation of the principles underlying the treaty would have to be so extensive in scope, so severe and so persistent as to effectively “disavow” or repudiate the treaty (cf. Namibia Advisory Opinion, para. 95). Turning to sub-paragraph (b), there can be little doubt that continued compliance with the values set out in the preamble and Article 2 is essential for the accomplishment of the object and purpose of the treaty. Official statements issued by the member states, including at the Brussels Summit in 2018 and more recently on the occasion of NATO’s 70th Anniversary, repeatedly affirm these principles. A member nation that violated them in a systematic and egregious manner would thus cast doubt on the very resolve of the allies to “unite their efforts for collective defence and for the preservation of peace and security” (preamble, North Atlantic Treaty). Should the conditions for the existence of a material breach be satisfied, NATO’s member states would be entitled, by unanimous agreement, to suspend the operation of the treaty in whole or in part or to terminate it either in their relations with the defaulting state or among them all (Article 60(2) of the Vienna Convention). For these purposes, a unanimous decision of the North Atlantic Council, excluding the defaulting state, would suffice. No further procedural requirements apply, including those laid down in Article 65 of the Vienna Convention. Whether or not Turkey is in material breach of its commitments under the North Atlantic Treaty is therefore a question to be determined by the other members of the Council. As Klaus Kress has observed, there is a “very serious possibility that Operation ‘Peace Spring’ could constitute a manifest violation of the prohibition of the use of force.” Coupled with President Erdoğan’s threat to “open the gates” for Syrian refugees to migrate to Europe, a threat fundamentally at odds with the unity and solidarity of the Alliance, characterizing these developments as a material breach is not entirely far-fetched. In any event, they entitle other NATO nations to suspend or scale back their military cooperation with Turkey, even without declaring Turkey to be in material breach. Although Article 3 of the North Atlantic Treaty commits the parties to maintain and develop their individual and collective capacity to resist armed attack, this obligation is meant to pursue the objectives of the treaty. The duty to develop military capabilities and to cooperate to this end therefore does not override the commitment to further the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law. A number of Allies, including France, Germany and Norway, as well as official NATO partner Finland, are reported to have suspended the sale of military equipment to Turkey. Overall, the absence of a suspension and expulsion mechanism in the North Atlantic Treaty does not prevent the North Atlantic Council from suspending or terminating the membership of an ally found to be in material breach of the treaty. However, with the 70th anniversary of the treaty just past, this is a sorry position for the Council to be in by any measure. Suspending, let alone terminating, a nation’s membership of NATO would be an extreme measure to be contemplated only once other attempts to restore unity and respect for the Alliance’s founding principles have been exhausted.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT CP Illegitimate

2-Education. This counterplan focuses the debate on an “obviously critical” foreign policy question.

Bergmann and Schmitt 21, *senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, where he focuses on European security and U.S.-Russia policy. From 2011 to 2017, he served in the U.S. Department of State in a number of different positions, including as a member of the secretary of state’s policy planning staff, where he focused on political-military affairs and nonproliferation; special assistant to the undersecretary for arms control and international security; speechwriter to then-Secretary of State John Kerry; and senior adviser to the assistant secretary of state for political-military affairs. Prior to serving in the State Department, he worked at CAP as a military and nonproliferation policy analyst and at the National Security Network as the deputy policy director. Bergmann received his master’s degree from the London School of Economics in comparative politics and his bachelor’s degree from Bates College, **senior policy analyst on the National Security and International Policy team at the Center. She previously worked on U.S. foreign policy advocacy at Human Rights Watch and received her Master in Public Policy from the Harvard Kennedy School (Max and Alexandra, “A Plan To Reform U.S. Security Assistance,” Center for American Progress, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/plan-reform-u-s-security-assistance/)

While this report calls for realigning U.S. assistance toward democratic allies and partners, it avoids diving into the specific policy debates over what countries should or should not receive security assistance. Those are obviously critical foreign policy debates, but the authors focus on improving the ability of U.S. officials to make coherent policy decisions by first creating an effective management and organizational structure of security assistance. This will also require major reform to the State Department’s own security assistance programs, which routinely and without deliberation provide billions in aid to nondemocracies. Security assistance should not be a diplomatic handout or entitlement; it should serve U.S. foreign policy and be flexible enough in its administration to align with U.S. foreign policy objectives and values. That not only requires consolidating security assistance programs in one place, but also demands significant reforms to the decision-making structure and security assistance system at the State Department.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---Collective Noun

“The NATO” is the whole body, not constituent members

Dr. Loreto Todd 5, Professor and Reader in International English at the University of Leeds & Author of More Than 20 Books on Linguistics & English Usage, International English Usage, Ed. Hancock and Todd, p. 133---from UM starter packet

The term collective noun refers to a singular noun that has a plural implication (e.g. [for example,] government) and is used when the whole body (and not the constituent members) is being considered. The category collective nouns is not discrete, and it can be argued that some usages are midway between collective and mass nouns. For example, team is clearly a collective noun and butter is clearly a mass noun but it is not so easy to decide the status of such nouns as: hair linen royalty.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---Collective Noun

NATO is a collective noun referring to the 30 members

NATO 22 – North Atlantic Treaty Organization

NATO "10 things you need to know about NATO," North Atlantic Treaty Organization, 5-10-2022,  T File

10 things you need to know about NATO

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---“The”---xt: Kotila

1nc ev is from Kotila. That decision was precise.

Supreme Court of Kentucky 6 (“Matheney v. Commonwealth,” 2002-SC-0920-MR, Lexis)//BB

[**32] [*612] Following Hayward and the first rule of statutory construction, i.e., "the language of the statute itself," United States v. Health Possibilities, P.S.C., 207 F.3d 335, 338-39 (6th Cir. 2000), Katila then applied an elementary principle of English grammar: The word "the" is "used as a function word before a plural noun denoting a group to indicate reference to the group as a whole." Kotila, 114 S.W.3d at 237 (quoting Webster's Third New Int'l Dictionary of the English Lang. Unabridged 2369 (1993)). Noting that KRS 446.080(4) directs us to construe our statutes "according to the common and approved usage of language," we then concluded that "the chemicals or equipment" meant "all of the chemicals or all of the equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine." Id. Unlike today's majority opinion, Kotila was not hastily decided; it was the culmination of a year of draft opinions and memoranda, including one opinion that was actually rendered, then withdrawn on petition for rehearing. It was ultimately rendered as an "Opinion of the Court" [*613] because it consisted of sections written in part by four different [**33] Members of the Court as it was then comprised, i.e., Chief Justice Lambert and Justices Graves, Keller, and Cooper.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---“The”

“the” denies individuality

Sanchez 16, analyst @ NT (Aaron, “The History of Donald Trump’s Definite Article,” News Taco, )

*When you add the word “the” before you mention a group of people – like Donald Trump does with “the Mexicans” – they are no longer individual, they aren’t people, they are problems that must be dealt with. VL

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---“The”

It denotes the entire group

Supreme Court of Wisconsin 53 (“De Witte v. Kearney & Trecker Corp.,” No Number in Original, Lexis)//BB

In the instant case the words used in the letter are "the small group of officers of the EIU." The complaint states that for the entire period of time referred to in the letter, the four plaintiffs were the officers of the EIU. Four persons would certainly constitute a "small group" and the use of the word "the" denotes the entire group or all the officers. The persons who received the letter are all members of the union of which plaintiffs were the officers and it may be [***9] presumed they knew who their officers were. Under such [*138] circumstances it requires no innuendo to identify the plaintiffs as constituting the small group of officers to whom the letter referred. The plaintiffs being definitely ascertainable as the persons to whom the defamatory statements referred, the complaint must be held sufficient in stating a cause of action by each. See annotations under "Public boards or groups of officers" in Anno. 97 A. L. R. 283, 287, 288.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › COMPETITION/THEORY › AT Perm Do CP---“The”

The only possible interpretation of “the” is all, not some nor any

United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit 15 (“Gillie v. Law Office of Eric A. Jones, LLC,” File Name: 15a0087p.06, Lexis)//BB

Turning from "authorized by law," we find another reason to disqualify special counsel as officers under the plain meaning of the Dictionary Act. Mainly, that

Headnote 13

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › SOLVENCY › AT Other Countries Spoil

They’re just building on Turkey’s playbook

Basu ’5-18 — Zachary; national security reporter at Axios. "Strongmen spoilers in Turkey and Hungary threaten Western unity"; Axios; https://www.axios.com/2022/05/18/turkey- NATO-finland-sweden-hungary-russia; //CYang

Why it matters: Critics have accused Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan of employing a "hostage-taking" tactic also practiced by Hungary, which for weeks has been singlehandedly blocking the European Union from imposing an embargo on Russian oil.

The outsized influence of single-member states in the EU and NATO has drawn increased scrutiny in recent years, especially as both Hungary and Turkey have drifted toward authoritarianism and strengthened their ties with Russia.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › SOLVENCY › AT CP Hurts US-Turkey Relations

Turkey won’t recommit to the NATO alliance

Erdemir 12-3-2021, *Turkey Program Board of Advisors, **Sinan Ciddi, Nonresident Senior Fellow, ***John Hardie, Research Manager and Senior Research Analyst (Aykan, Collusion or Collision?, FDD, https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2021/12/03/collusion-or-collision/)//BB

In Washington, some still believe Ankara remains a bulwark against Russian expansionism on NATO’s southeastern flank.11 While areas of fruitful cooperation with Turkey do still exist, this report demonstrates that under Erdogan, Turkey’s drift from the West and tilt toward Russia reflect a fundamental transformation of Ankara’s foreign and security policy. Just as Moscow and Ankara will not soon become stalwart allies, Erdogan’s Turkey is equally unlikely to be a steadfast member of the Western alliance. Rather, Ankara likely will aim to leverage the two camps against one another. Washington and its transatlantic allies therefore must take urgent and coordinated action to clarify their strategy toward Turkey. The West should pursue cooperation with Turkey where interests align, such as countering Russia in the Black Sea region and promoting alternatives to Russian energy supplies. But the West should also seek to contain challenges from Turkey by imposing firm consequences for further aligning with Russia or otherwise undermining NATO, while providing incentives if Ankara does the right thing.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › SOLVENCY › AT CP Hurts US-Turkey Relations

Turkey-US relations are impossible

Dalay 21, research director @ Brookings (Galip, “US-Turkey relations will remain crisis-ridden for a long time to come,” Brookings,

At this stage, there is limited room for progress on the above-mentioned five main areas of contention in relations. A mutually acceptable formula on the S-400 systems is unlikely to be found anytime soon, and this issue is set to become a long-lasting irritant in the relationship. On the Eastern Mediterranean, at best, the crisis can be refrozen, which means launching bilateral talks between Turkey and Greece and both sides refraining from sending ships into contested waters for exploration. Plus, on the Eastern Mediterranean, we are likely to see more policy coordination between the U.S. and Europe. The future of Turkey’s policy towards the Syrian Kurds is intimately linked with the future of the ruling coalition in Turkey, and political developments inside Turkey. As long as Erdoğan’s coalition with the far-right MHP remains in place, the prospect for a policy recalibration is limited. And the Biden administration will likely be more vocal on high-profile, politically-motivated cases such as against the former co-chairman of the pro-Kurdish Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) Selahattin Demirtaş, philanthropist Osman Kavala, and novelist Ahmet Altan. Similarly, the Halkbank case will continue to cast a shadow over bilateral ties. All these feuds will make crisis a permanent fixture of U.S.-Turkey relations.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
TURKEY PIC › SOLVENCY › AT Unanimity Key

France will leave NATO if Turkey is appeased

Antonopoulos ’20 — Paul; Doctorate researcher based in Athens. He has a special interest in international relations, with a particular focus on multipolarity and the geographic space between ancient civilizational countries stretching from Greece to India. June 30, 2020; “NATO’s Appeasement to Turkey Is Pushing France Out of the Alliance”; Global Research; ; //CYang

French President Emmanuel Macron created a stir last November when he said that NATO is experiencing a “brain death.” This single comment created a flurry of reactions as Member States attempted to justify the existence of NATO. Macron’s comments must be taken seriously when we consider that France in 1959 withdrew its Mediterranean Fleet from NATO command and in 1966 the French military left NATO’s integrated military command and demanded all foreign NATO soldiers to leave France. US Secretary of State Dean Rusk attempted to guilt the highly independent French President Charles de Gaulle for his decision to kick out foreign soldiers by asking if “the bodies of American soldiers in France’s cemeteries” who died in the two world wars also had to leave.

It was the Anglo-American hegemony that de Gaulle resisted, and it can be argued that Macron is attempting to re-establish France’s independence after former French President Nicolas Sarkozy reintegrated France into NATO in 2009. A clear indicator that Macron is following in the steps of de Gaulle is when he furthered the former president’s famous phrase that Europe stretches “from Lisbon to the Urals” in Russia by saying Europe’s territory stretches all the way to Vladivostok near the Chinese and North Korean borders.