Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › NATO says Yes

NATO support is increasing – recent visits prove.

Lawrence and Cordey, 2020 – researchers for The Cyber Project at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs [Christie and Sean, August, The Cyber Project Paper “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence Edited by Lauren Zabierek and Julia Voo https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/2020-08/TransatlanticAI.pdf Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

In recent months, however, interests and political support for greater transatlantic coordination on AI seems to be increasing. This trend was notably demonstrated by a visit from Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan—then Director of the US Department of Defense’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC)—to Brussels in January 2020 and a visit by the European Parliament’s delegation to Washington D.C in February 2020. Both visits included discussions on AI with a variety of key stakeholders, such as NATO, representatives from the US Congress, State Department, Federal Transit Administration (FTA), Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB).34

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › NATO says Yes

NATO would support the plan – they are looking for common ground on ethical principles

Sprenger, 2021 - Europe editor for Defense News [Sebastian, Apr 27, “NATO tees up negotiations on artificial intelligence in weapons” https://www.c4isrnet.com/artificial-intelligence/2021/04/27/nato-tees-up-negotiations-on-artificial-intelligence-in-weapons/ Acc 4/22/22 TA]

NATO is seeking common ground on artificial intelligence in defense applications ahead of a strategy document this summer. (MF3d/Getty Images) COLOGNE, Germany — NATO officials are kicking around a new set of questions for member states on artificial intelligence in defense applications, as the alliance seeks common ground ahead of a strategy document planned for this summer. The move comes amid a grand effort to sharpen NATO’s edge in what officials call emerging and disruptive technologies, or EDT. Autonomous and artificial intelligence-enabled weaponry is a key element in that push, aimed at ensuring tech leadership on a global scale. Exactly where the alliance falls on the spectrum between permitting AI-powered defense technology in some applications and disavowing it in others is expected to be a hotly debated topic in the run-up to the June 14 NATO summit. “We have agreed that we need principles of responsible use, but we’re also in the process of delineating specific technologies,” David van Weel, the alliance’s assistant secretary-general for emerging security challenges, said at a web event earlier this month organized by the Estonian Defence Ministry. Different rules could apply to different systems depending on their intended use and the level of autonomy involved, he said. For example, an algorithm sifting through data as part of a back-office operation at NATO headquarters in Brussels would be subjected to a different level of scrutiny than an autonomous weapon. In addition, rules are in the works for industry to understand the requirements involved in making systems adhere to a future NATO policy on artificial intelligence. The idea is to present a menu of quantifiable principles for companies to determine what their products can live up to, van Weel said. For now, alliance officials are teeing up questions to guide the upcoming discussion, he added. Those range from basic introspections about whether AI-enabled systems fall under NATO’s “legal mandates,” van Weel explained, to whether a given system is free of bias, meaning if its decision-making tilts in a particular direction.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › NATO says Yes

Allies will follow US leadership on AI – they want defense cooperation

Kahn and Horowitz, 2021 – Research and Senior Fellows at the Council on Foreign Relations [Lauren and Michael, The Washington Quarterly 44:4 “Leading in Artificial Intelligence through Confidence Building Measures” TA]

An informal multilateral agreement could be proposed and opened for signature to all nations. If the United States leads, American allies and partners would be likely to sign on, both due to the impact of American leadership in shaping attitudes and the likely perception that following US-led principles would facilitate defense cooperation in this area. One might argue that US leadership in multilateral AI standards could create risks for the United States if it involves commitments that prevent the US deployment and use of militarily important AI-enabled systems. These risks, however, are minimal. The standards the United States would promote involve commitments to international humanitarian law and responsible behavior that the United States already follows when it comes to the development and use of military systems. Thus, it would not require changes in US behavior that might slow down responsible military AI adoption.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Dialogue

Dialogue clarifies Legal Interoperability which is key to cohesive action

Hill and Marsan, 2018 - Director and Senior Assistant, NATO Office of Legal Affairs [Steven and Nadia, 7-18-18 “Artificial Intelligence and Accountability: A Multinational Legal Perspective” https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%20Proceedings/STO-MP-IST-160/MP-IST-160-PP-4.pdf Acc 4/21/22 TA]

ABSTRACT This paper supports the specialist meeting on Big Data and Artificial Intelligence for Military Decision Making by exploring the legal implications of new technology on NATO decision making. The paper begins by presenting the concept of “legal interoperability,” one of the tools that legal advisers working in NATO seek to promote. It then introduces some of the current legal issues and debates surrounding the development and use of AI, including the difficulty in defining key concepts arising out of the increased use of AI such as “autonomy,” and questions pertaining to accountability. Finally, this paper examines how further dialogue among Allies and with NATO partners can contribute to the development of a reliable approach on accountability issues related to AI-enabled technology. The paper argues that given the rapidly evolving technology and the asymmetric approach and capabilities of nations, efforts within the Alliance should focus on ensuring NATO’s “legal preparedness” so that collective action is not thwarted by legal hurdles and mismatched legal approaches amongst Allies.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Dialogue

NATO dialogue on AI improves its credibility – this is crucial for harmonization and interoperability

Trabucco and Stanley-Lockman, 2022 – prof of Political Science, University of Copenhagen and prof of Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University [Lena and Zoe, The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance, March, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs” https://www.oxfordhandbooks.com/view/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780197579329-e-69 Acc 4/16/22 TA]

Standards and certification To maintain its relevance in a security architecture increasingly concerned with the way that technology shifts power dynamics and scales threats to international security, NATO has an incentive to foster cooperation, promote standards of practice, and incentivize Allied AI harmonization. It is strategically salient to facilitate a dialogue and engagement among Allies on AI, but it is practically important to use NATO’s position to facilitate Allied cooperation regarding standards to project the Alliance’s ability to interoperate in future operations. NATO standards aim to enhance interoperability among partners and successful implementation of strategy. More specifically, standards and certification are used to establish and implement requirements aligned with safe development and responsible use of technology. In addition to purely technical standards, NATO has operational standards that specify “conceptual, organizational or methodological requirements to enable materiel, installations, organizations or forces to fulfil their functions or missions.”51 In line with the definitions from STS and military innovation scholarship, standards can thus be seen as a mechanism to translate responsibility-derived state and organizational AI policy into actionable functions. In fact, NATO has set certain standards for the Allies and these standards subsequently become the norm.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Dialogue

Dialogue is key to collaboration on AI – it is the first step to cooperation because it builds on common grounds.

Fu, 2021 – Professor of Technology and International Development, University of Oxford [Xiaolan, Dec 7, “Artificial intelligence: Can we go from chaos to cooperation?” AEI Panel Discussion - Moderator: Elisabeth Braw https://www.aei.org/events/artificial-intelligence-can-we-go-fromchaos-to-cooperation/ Acc 5/11/22 TA]

And another very important challenge that we have to address, I mean, I think David will mention, is the AI application in defense. And we really need some, you know, global treaty to make sure we demilitarize and de-weaponize the application of artificial intelligence. So, there are a lot of common grounds between countries. Europe — Jonathan will talk about North America. And also, they are the three major leaders in the world in artificial intelligence. So, based on this common interest and the common grounds, I think to collaborate, work together. Elisabeth, I think today’s AI initiative is so great. I really liked the title, you know, “collaboration,” “cooperation” put in the title. So work together to make sure AI used for good, to make good for the society and the community. And we need to take action. Dialogue is the first step and to set up the mechanisms to facilitate the dialogue. And even debates would be very important. Let me finish here. And so, yeah, that’s all from me. Thank you.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Dialogue

Dialogue with allies can overcome differences over the ethical use of AI in defense – discussion moves principles into practical implementation.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

Additionally, differences between allies’ views on responsible and ethical AI in defense may also stem from the extent to which other countries apply civilian AI policy and regulation frameworks to their own defense approaches. Although overviews of government principles and policies for ethical civilian AI are not discussed at length here, they become more visible in other countries, as well as the EU. Some of these aspects are encouraging—for example, German industry’s voluntary compliance with trustworthy AI principles, to the extent they overlap with defense, due in part to the fact that there is no equivalent defense framework they can follow and implement themselves. Other entry points of civilian concepts into the defense realm include the Australian concept of contestability, Canadian DND subjectivity to the algorithmic impact assessment, and the choice of some EU countries to apply the General Data Protection Regulation to their defense sectors. These are both related to accountability as well as privacy, which are key differences that should be tracked even though allies overwhelmingly agree on the importance of ethics and safety for AI in defense. Still, similarities between defense stakeholders include the view that militaries could not only inject new risks into their operating environments, but also expose their own organizations to risk if they leave ethical and legal questions unaddressed. Countries may have different ways to define and measure these ethical risks, as Table 1 implies, and as is detailed in the appendices. Overall, though, there is an implicitly common approach which recognizes that they must contend with the associated technical, legal, political, and moral risks from the front end of AI development. More concretely, they also agree that the way to implement responsible AI involves technical measures tied to safety and security, as well as procedures that make the legal context by which they abide as clear as possible. Overall, pathways for leveraging shared views to advance the implementation of responsible AI should include learning from allies whose views emphasize both human responsibility and responsible state behavior extending beyond minimum legal obligations. Addressing these issues is not only a question of good engineering practices, but is also an exercise of responsible state behavior.188 In a narrow sense, responsible AI can refer to ensuring that AI systems enter into human-centric frameworks that are defined by humans to maintain human agency and responsibility. More broadly, though, it is notable that some allies see preserving freedom of action as part of a vision of responsible AI that encompasses responsible state behavior. Having a legitimate basis for military action is a feature of responsible state behavior, with civilian government oversight of militaries at its core to maintain accountability at home and abroad. This enters into the language of responsibility because operating in coalitions under multinational mandates can also confer international political legitimacy to operations.189

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Global Model

The DOD must lead our allies on AI policy to raise awareness and perception of ethical issues.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

The key takeaways are as follows: • DOD remains the leader in developing an approach to ethical AI for defense. This first-mover position situates the JAIC well to lead international engagements on responsible military AI. • Allies fall on a spectrum from articulated (France, Australia), to emerging (the U.K., Canada), to nascent (Germany, the Netherlands) views on ethical and responsible AI in defense. These are flexible categories that reflect the availability of public documents. • Multilateral institutions also influence how countries perceive and implement AI ethics in defense. NATO and JAIC’s AI Partnership for Defense (PfD) are important venues pursuing responsible military AI agendas, while the European Union and Five Eyes have relevant, but relatively less defined, roles. • Areas of convergence among allies’ views of ethics in military AI include the need to comply with existing ethical and legal frameworks, maintain human centricity, identify ethical risks in the design phase, and implement technical measures over the course of the AI lifecycle to mitigate that risk. • There are fewer areas of divergence, which primarily pertain to the ways that allies import select civilian components of AI accountability and trust into their defense frameworks. These should be tracked to ensure they do not imperil future political cohesion and coalition success. • Pathways for leveraging shared views and minimizing the possibility that divergence will cause problems include using multilateral formats to align views on ethics, safety, security, and normative aspects.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Global Model

Allied approaches to AI Ethics foster global modelling by creating a Responsible AI Ecosystem.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

To facilitate comparisons with allies’ approaches to AI ethics for defense, two taskings of the RAI Working Council are particularly relevant. The first is the broad, overall aim of leading responsible AI globally. To this end, creating a “Responsible AI Ecosystem” is one of the foundational tenets of RAI implementation.32 Here, international components of this ecosystem include allies and partners to enable better multi-stakeholder collaboration and to also advance norm development “grounded in shared values.”33 With the overall aim of leading responsible AI globally, this foundational tenet is the only one that explicitly names international engagement. Yet other foundational tenets are also relevant to assess convergences and divergences, including: governance structures for accountability; trust based on testing, evaluation, validation, and verification (TEVV); and a whole-of lifecycle approach to risk management.34

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Global Model

Ethical principles are key to global modeling – moral claims shape the international environment.

Gilli, 2020 - Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College [Andrea, NDC Research Paper No.15 – December ““NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence” https://www.ndc.nato.int/news/news.php?icode=1514 Acc 4/21/22 TA]

Lead and shape with ethical principles. The proposed Ethics Board could start its work from scratch, defining a new set of guiding ethical principles for NATO and its Allies, or it could take a pragmatic approach and borrow from the important work already done by several institutions, including the OECD and the European Union.109 As recalled above, work has already been done by international organizations such as the European Union and the OECD, national governments, such as the US Department of Defense and the French Ministry of the Armed Forces, private companies like Google and IBM, as well as non-governmental institutions like the Institute for Electrical and Electronics Engineering.110 Having clear and simple ethical principles is important, both internally, as actors at different levels need to be able to make choices, and externally, as NATO and its Allies may want not only to signal their ethical and moral commitments to their own citizenries, including developers and civil society, but also to shape the international environment. The priority is to ensure that NATO Allies adopt clear ethical guidelines which reflect their values – such as democratic representation, civilian control of the armed forces, individual responsibility, the centrality of human life, and compliance with the Laws of War – and that such values inform international norms, practices, agreements and possible future treaties. Leading in this realm means moulding the future security environment, in particular by embedding democratic values into this pervasive technology.111 What ethical principles should NATO adopt when it comes to AI? This will be up to the Ethics Board, if established, or to other authorities. As recalled, there is, however, a general agreement on some principles:112

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Global Model

Without cooperative solutions, NATO will lose its leverage to create global norms for other countries to follow.

Gilli, 2020 - Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College [Andrea, NDC Research Paper No.15 – December ““NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence” https://www.ndc.nato.int/news/news.php?icode=1514 Acc 4/21/22 TA]

The increasing power of processors, accuracy of algorithms, and availability of digital data are driving the dramatic artificial intelligence (AI)-centred technological transformation now in progress. These changes have already turned companies, industries and markets upside down, and we are also starting to see their effects on the battlefield. The employment of unmanned vehicles, reliance on big data for target detection, identification and acquisition, as well as the potentials of machine learning in other critical functions such as logistics and maintenance are only some of the possible examples of how warfare will evolve in the near future. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and its Allies cannot be bystanders during this technological transition. Some countries and organizations have already taken important steps. Others are more hesitant. The Atlantic Alliance has a moral obligation to act, both to preserve and extend its military leadership – and thus the wealth and security of its citizens – and to shape this process in keeping with its democratic principles, freedom-inspired values and commitment to fundamental human rights. As NATO works on its Artificial Intelligence Strategy, which could be published in 2021, this Research Paper aims at contributing to both the policy debate and the public discussion about AI and its implications for the Alliance. The paper offers a series of analyses, lessons learned, proposals, and recommendations, that build on best practices and solutions adopted in the civilian and military fields, on perspectives drawn from the academic literature as well as on ideas generated in the broader AI community. The various parts of the paper are all linked to the single overarching concept of “NATO-mation”, or the idea that NATO has an important role to play so as to prepare for and to shape this technological transformation. NATO Allies need to be proactive: without common, coordinated, cooperative or joint solutions, they will not be able to achieve all their goals effectively and efficiently. The paper thus elaborates on the concept of “NATO-mation” in 11 different building blocks, as summarized below: • Ethical purpose: first and foremost, NATO’s strength comes from its values, which give meaning to its military capabilities and represent the bond between the Allies. As technological progress demands answers to major ethical questions regarding the development, employment and purpose of intelligent machines, NATO and its Allies have the opportunity to shape international norms and behaviour in this respect while simultaneously strengthening their commitment to the Alliance’s founding principles. Setting up an ethical board of experts and adopting some common ethical principles are two starting points.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - CBMs

CBMs prevent accidental lunch during a crisis through information sharing.

Horowitz and Scharre, 2021 - Senior Fellows at the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security [Michael and Paul, Jan 12, “AI and International Stability: Risks and Confidence-Building Measures” TA]

Executive Summary Militaries around the world believe that the integration of machine learning methods throughout their forces could improve their effectiveness. From algorithms to aid in recruiting and promotion, to those designed for surveillance and early warning, to those used directly on the battlefield, applications of artificial intelligence (AI) could shape the future character of warfare. These uses could also generate significant risks for international stability. These risks relate to broad facets of AI that could shape warfare, limits to machine learning methods that could increase the risks of inadvertent conflict, and specific mission areas, such as nuclear operations, where the use of AI could be dangerous. To reduce these risks and promote international stability, we explore the potential use of confidence-building measures (CBMs), constructed around the shared interests that all countries have in preventing inadvertent war. Though not a panacea, CBMs could create standards for information-sharing and notifications about AI-enabled systems that make inadvertent conflict less likely.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - CBMs

CBMs promote the responsible use of AI – they create international norms, gain the attention of leaders, and promote bureaucratic change.

Horowitz and Scharre, 2021 - Senior Fellows at the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security [Michael and Paul, Jan 12, “AI and International Stability: Risks and Confidence-Building Measures” TA]

CBMs may be a useful tool for managing risks relating to military AI applications. There are a number of possible CBMs that states could adopt that may help mitigate the various AI-related risks previously outlined. These include broad CBMs applicable to AI as a category, CBMs designed to address some of the limitations of AI, and CBMs focused on specific missions for which militaries might use AI.49 Broad CBMs These CBMs focus broadly on mechanisms for dialogue and agreement surrounding military uses of AI, rather than the specific content of agreements. Given that a key goal of CBMs is to enhance trust, mechanisms that serve as a building block for more substantive dialogue and agreement can, in some cases, be an end in themselves and not just a means to an end.50 These could include promoting international norms for how nations develop and use military AI systems, Track II academic-to-academic exchanges, direct military-to-military dialogues, and agreements between states regarding military AI, such as a code of conduct or mutual statement of principles. Promoting Norms In 2019, the U.S. Defense Innovation Board proposed a set of AI principles for the U.S. Defense Department, which DoD subsequently adopted in early 2020. While these principles no doubt have domestic audiences in the U.S. defense community and tech sector, they also serve as an early example of a state promulgating norms about appropriate use of AI in military applications. The DoD AI principles included a requirement that DoD AI systems be responsible, equitable, traceable, reliable, and governable.51 (The full set of DoD AI principles is included in the Appendix). Similarly, the DoD’s unclassified summary of its AI strategy, released in 2019, called for building AI systems that were “resilient, robust, reliable, and secure.”52 A focus of the strategy was “leading in military ethics and AI safety.”53 There is value in states promoting norms for responsible use of AI, including adopting and employing technology in a way that reflects an understanding of the technical risks associated with AI systems. While stating such principles is not the same as putting in place effective bureaucratic processes to ensure their compliance, there is nevertheless value in states publicly signaling to others (and to their own bureaucracies) the importance of using AI responsibly in military applications. While these norms are at a high level, they nevertheless signal some degree of attention by senior military and civilian defense officials to some of the risks of AI systems, including issues surrounding safety, security, responsibility, and controllability. These signals may aid internal bureaucratic efforts to mitigate various AI-related risks, as bureaucratic actors can point to these official documents for support. Additionally, to the extent that other nations find these statements credible, they may help signal to other nations at least some degree of awareness and attention to these risks, helping to incentivize others to do the same.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - CBMs

A statement of ethical principles is a Confidence Building Measure for AI – it signals our allies and values, which helps improve understanding

Horowitz and Scharre, 2021 - Senior Fellows at the Technology and National Security Program at the Center for a New American Security [Michael and Paul, Jan 12, “AI and International Stability: Risks and Confidence-Building Measures” TA]

Code of Conduct Nations could agree to a written set of rules or principles for how they adopt AI into military systems. These rules and principles, even if not legally binding, could nevertheless serve a valuable signaling and coordination function to avoid some of the risks in AI adoption. A code of conduct, statement of principles, or other agreement could include a wide range of both general and specific statements, including potentially on any or all of the confidence-building measures listed above. Even if countries cannot agree on specific details beyond promoting safe and responsible military use of AI, more general statements could nevertheless be valuable in signaling to other nations some degree of mutual understanding about responsible use of military AI and help create positive norms of behavior. Ideally, a code of conduct would have support from a wide range of countries and major military powers. However, if this were not possible, then a multilateral statement of principles from like-minded countries could still have some value in increasing transparency and promulgating norms of responsible state behavior.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Public Support

Collaboration builds trust which prevents a political backlash that threatens NATO operations.

van Weel, 2021 – Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges, NATO [David, Dec 7, “Artificial intelligence: Can we go from chaos to cooperation?” AEI Panel Discussion - Moderator: Elisabeth Braw https://www.aei.org/events/artificial-intelligence-can-we-go-fromchaos-to-cooperation/ Acc 5/11/22 TA]

Now, in doing so, we have to bridge a gap of distrust. So, I’ve been on panels quite a lot where people say, “Well, please, I don’t trust the defense use of artificial intelligence.” And that’s something we need to address. We are a trusted user. We, NATO, all the 30 allies, we all subscribe to the democratic values, and we all subscribe to the same values that our societies are built upon. And we’re there to protect it. So in using AI, in developing AI, we have to ensure and make clear to both the private sector and to our societies that we are a trusted user of artificial intelligence, that we intend to use AI by the standards that we adhere to — all our weapons systems and the use of force in defending ourselves. And that’s why the AI strategy that we just devised came up. And that’s why we made it public to a large extent. We are not known at NATO for publishing a lot. We try to keep secrets a lot. In this case, I really advocated that that is kind of against the whole purpose of having this AI strategy. The purpose of this AI strategy is to gain a better understanding of what’s out there, to prove that we are willing to engage with this innovative new ecosystems, in order to look at the defense purposes of AI. Also, look at the threats of the misuse of AI by adversaries, making sure that certain technology doesn’t leak away to those who might not adhere to the same standards that we have. And then developing this all in a responsible way.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Public Support

NATO discussions are key to overcome lack of public knowledge about AI policies – this addresses concerns about AI weapons.

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

A related caveat is that some allies are either in the midst of constructing, or choosing to not publicize, their approaches to ethical and responsible AI. As such, allies’ formulations of responsible military AI should be seen as evolving processes. The narrow availability of information on AI ethics beyond autonomy in weapons may reflect political sensitivities, including cultural differences around how transparent defense ministries and armed forces are. As such, the hope is to fill this gap by addressing how allies conceive of AI ethics for defense.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Cooperation

NATO cooperation is necessary for an ethical response – coordination builds public support and addresses important details.

Gilli, 2020 - Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College [Andrea, NDC Research Paper No.15 – December ““NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence” https://www.ndc.nato.int/news/news.php?icode=1514 Acc 4/21/22 TA]

It is worth noting that NATO’s role in the AI ethics sphere differs from that of many other organizations, such as national governments and the European Union, because NATO is not a regulatory body. NATO complies with existing laws and regulations, including the Laws of War, which nations and the international community created. This means that regulatory and normative questions such as the development and deployment of autonomous weapons systems will not be determined at NATO level. Nevertheless, there is still room for NATO to play a clear role. Indeed, given doubts and worries about the adoption of AI for military purposes, NATO can help generate more public support and engagement by clearly defining ethical boundaries and moral guidelines. The uses of AI in military operations – ranging from logistics to maintenance, from recruitment to retainment, from intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance to medical tests and medical evacuation, and more90 – go beyond the discussions on lethal autonomous weapons systems that have dominated European debate about AI in military affairs. Accordingly, the range of ethical questions relevant to NATO extend beyond focusing on the tip of the spear. Seemingly mundane uses of AI, such as in human resources or decision support, can still pose distinct ethical questions the Alliance should be prepared to handle. Addressing security risks,91 minimizing bias in systems,92 developing trust,93 and respecting privacy are fundamental tasks for the Alliance to ensure the future effectiveness of AI, whether in battle or in other functions. The age of intelligent machines requires the Alliance to reiterate its commitment to values as new moral and ethical questions emerge, because algorithms do not have a conscience, personal preferences or moral agency. These statistical machines have no understanding of good and bad, or fair and unjust.94 All an algorithm can do is achieve its human-defined reward function, not provide any context or information on whether the right question is being asked.95 Instead of giving moral agency to algorithms, humans and organizations can view AI as a “moral entity”. This means that we humans are dutybound to adhere to our moral code of conduct when interacting with the systems, rather than shirking human responsibility to computers.96 At the organizational level, this means that the design, development and deployment of AI should be “ethically aligned” with the Alliance’s values and goals.97

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Cooperation

Empirically – NATO cooperation can overcome the challenges AI poses to the alliance.

Lin-Greenberg, 2020 - member of the MIT Security Studies Program [Erik Vol 3, Iss 2 Spring, Texas National Security Review “Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making” http://dx.doi.org/10.26153/tsw/8866 Acc 4/22/22 TA]

States are racing to achieve superiority in the AI domain, and AI research and development is flourishing: In early 2019, the U.S. Department of Defense unveiled its AI strategy.5 Meanwhile, China has pledged to develop a $150 billion AI sector by 2030,6 and Russian President Vladimir Putin famously asserted, “whoever becomes the leader in [AI] will become the ruler of the world.”7 AI development promises to bring enhanced accuracy and efficiency to complex and dangerous tasks, but policymakers and scholars have yet to fully explore how these benefits compare with potential risks — particularly in the context of multinational military operations.8 To be sure, decision-makers have expressed concerns about the reliability of AI technologies and the ethical implications of delegating military operations to computers.9 These AI-specific challenges, however, may magnify the coordination and commitment challenges that frequently plague military operations conducted by multinational alliances and coalitions. Drawing from theories of alliance politics and analysis of emerging AI technologies, I map out two areas where AI could hamper multinational military operations. First, AI could pose challenges to operational coordination by complicating burden-sharing and the interoperability of multinational forces. Not all alliance or coalition members will possess AI capabilities, raising barriers to military cooperation as AI-enabled warfare becomes increasingly common. States with AI technologies will also need to overcome political barriers to sharing the sensitive data required to develop and operate AI-enabled systems. At the same time, rivals can stymie multinational coordination by using AI to launch deception campaigns aimed at interfering with an alliance’s military command-and-control processes. Second, AI could hamper alliance and coalition decision-making by straining the processes and relationships that undergird decisions on the use of force. By increasing the speed of warfare, AI could decrease the time leaders, from the tactical to strategic levels, have to debate policies and make decisions. These compressed timelines may not allow for the complex negotiations and compromises that are defining characteristics of alliance politics.10 Decision-making may be further hampered if the “black box” and unexplainable nature of AI causes leaders to lack confidence in AI-enabled systems. And, just as adversaries could use AI to interfere with command and control, they could also use AI to launch misinformation campaigns that sow discord among allies and heighten fears that allies will renege on their commitments. To be sure, barriers to multinational military cooperation are not new, but AI may intensify these difficulties.11 To help overcome these obstacles to coordination and decision-making challenges, alliance and coalition leaders can draw lessons from past cases of successful cooperation and a growing corpus of national-level AI strategies to develop international agreements and standards that streamline the integration of AI into multinational operations.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency - Cooperation

NATO sets the Standards for AI Ethics - cooperation is key to setting Operational Norms for responsible AI.

Trabucco and Stanley-Lockman, 2022 – prof of Political Science, University of Copenhagen and prof of Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University [Lena and Zoe, The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance, March, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs” https://www.oxfordhandbooks.com/view/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780197579329-e-69 Acc 4/16/22 TA]

NATO’s Mechanisms to Govern AI NATO’s increasing interest in EDTs introduces the need to consider how governance priorities can help reinforce the Alliance’s influence. The STS and military innovation literature provide the theoretical foundations for NATO’s stewardship of AI as they place attention on “the role that institutions play in shaping technological trajectories.”45 As AI development continues, the actions that NATO and its members take will have important implications for their capacity to adopt, respond to, and shape their future operating environment. Particularly for democracies, this confers to military stakeholders a dual responsibility to prevent and manage risks, as well as to proactively shape their approach to technological development anchored in democratic values and security. As a multinational alliance with an incentive to drive cooperation and alignment, NATO is situated to define and operationalize norms, as well as promote standards that help shape the contours of future military effectiveness and technological competition. In a RRI framework, not only is this an institutional role, but it also becomes an institutional responsibility. To apply this responsibility to NATO’s stewardship of AI, the institutional interplay between technology, structure, and concepts is a form of socio-technical system with important implications for AI governance because they link the ways that an institution uses its power to adopt and shape AI trajectory to its respective ends. Already, several mechanisms are built into military bureaucracies to ensure that technology is adopted in alignment with responsible engineering practices and responsible state behavior.46 The Alliance is organized to harmonize between Allies so that their contributions enhance military effectiveness and political cohesion between like-minded democracies. We argue that these effectiveness-centric mechanisms likewise empower NATO to exert its influence in technology governance. More specifically, this entails the Alliance helping steward technological development for a more predictable strategic environment and enhanced democratic clout around the exploitation of technology reinforcing rule of law. For NATO, we focus on strategic and policy planning, as well as standards and certification because they reflect the Alliance’s particular strengths and interests in S&T. These practices are relevant to governance insofar as they exemplify an institution’s power to shape the trajectory of technological development—but this selection is by no means exhaustive.47

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – AI Ethics Aff – UM22 Starter Packet › Case Extensions › Solvency – Interoperability

Legal interoperability is key to NATO cohesion and operational interoperability - different legal viewpoints make it impossible to coordinate militarily.

Hill and Marsan, 2018 - Director and Senior Assistant, NATO Office of Legal Affairs [Steven and Nadia, 7-18-18 “Artificial Intelligence and Accountability: A Multinational Legal Perspective” https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%20Proceedings/STO-MP-IST-160/MP-IST-160-PP-4.pdf Acc 4/21/22 TA]

1.0 THE NATO CONTEXT: LEGAL INTEROPERABILITY NATO is an Alliance of values, and one of the core values that the Alliance defends is the rule of law. The commitment to respect the rule of law is enshrined in the preamble to the 1949 North Atlantic Treaty and is reaffirmed in declarations by NATO Heads of State and Government at their regular Summit meetings. It is a key element of NATO and NATO-led operations and is necessary to ensuring legitimacy and securing public support. Compliance with international law is an essential component of NATO’s success in all of its endeavours and activities. Correspondingly, the demand for legal advice from over 70 legal offices that make up the NATO legal community has never been higher. The scope of issues on which the typical NATO legal adviser is called to advise on can be daunting and guidance on Allied views is not always available, especially in an easy-to-access consolidated format. This is especially true in the context of emerging technologies such as the security impact of AI-enabled tools. Under the auspices of the NATO Office of Legal Affairs, NATO has launched and reinvigorated a number of legal dialogues, including with Allies, partner nations and international organisations. Such legal dialogues are essential to understanding Allies’ potentially conflicting legal postures. NATO Allies each have their sovereign domestic legal systems and are bound by different international legal obligations. Allies also often have their own understanding on what international law obligations are applicable to them and under what conditions. As an alliance of 29 nations, NATO takes all decisions by consensus and the main challenge in such a multilateral environment is enabling Nations to act together in line with the individual legal obligations of each, taking account of the differences in applicable legal parameters. A key technique that legal advisers use to help achieve consensus despite these legal differences is “legal interoperability”. “Legal interoperability” is derived from the military concept of interoperability of forces, whereby the military forces of the 29 Allies are able to work together to achieve common objectives. NATO doctrine defines the interoperability of forces as “[t]he ability of the forces of two or more nations to train, exercise and operate effectively together in the execution of assigned missions and tasks.”4 In the Warsaw Summit Communiqué, Allied Heads of State and Government referred to the need for interoperability to accomplish NATO’s goals. Within NATO, there is often a diversity of legal views on core issues of international law. Let us take, for example, the laws of war, where 27 of NATO’s 29 Allies are party to the Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions. This challenge is also reflected in International Criminal Law as the Rome Statute establishing the International Criminal Court is likewise adopted only by 27 Allies. As a military Alliance founded on the rule of law, these sometimes different legal obligations can be challenging. The challenges are especially daunting when there is a need for a rapid decision by Allies based on collective consensus and requiring legal justification. NATO’ raison d’être is collective defence, and legal interoperability is one of the key enablers for the Alliance. From a legal perspective, interoperability refers to the need for Nations to work together in a variety of contexts despite the application of differing legal frameworks and obligations. As one observer of NATO operational law defined it, “‘[l]egal interoperability’ is understood … as the ability of the forces of two or more nations to operate effectively together in the execution of assigned missions and tasks and with full respect for their legal obligations, notwithstanding the fact that nations concerned have varying legal obligations and varying interpretations of these obligations.” 5 Legal interoperability relies on a broad understanding of those areas of legal divergence amongst Allies, which requires careful analysis of the legal positions expressed by the relevant Nations. In the case of new technologies, this understanding is difficult to acquire, in part because Nations have not had the opportunity to set forth their legal views or have refrained from doing so in order to prevent the loss of a potential technological edge. Within NATO, legal interoperability has proven to be indispensable to rapid decision-making and is facilitated by Allies’ pragmatism when faced with questions of collective security, emphasizing and relying on those elements that are common to all rather than on those elements of divergence.