Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Disease

Pandemics won’t cause human extinction

Sebastian Farquhar 17. Director at Oxford's Global Priorities Project, Owen Cotton-Barratt, a Lecturer in Mathematics at St Hugh’s College, Oxford, John Halstead, Stefan Schubert, Haydn Belfield, Andrew Snyder-Beattie, 01-23-17, "Existential Risk Diplomacy and Governance", GLOBAL PRIORITIES PROJECT 2017, https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/Existential-Risks-2017-01-23.pdf

1.1.3 Engineered pandemics For most of human history, natural pandemics have posed the greatest risk of mass global fatalities.37 However, there are some reasons to believe that natural pandemics are very unlikely to cause human extinction. Analysis of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) red list database has shown that of the 833 recorded plant and animal species extinctions known to have occurred since 1500, less than 4% (31 species) were ascribed to infectious disease.38 None of the mammals and amphibians on this list were globally dispersed, and other factors aside from infectious disease also contributed to their extinction. It therefore seems that our own species, which is very numerous, globally dispersed, and capable of a rational response to problems, is very unlikely to be killed off by a natural pandemic. One underlying explanation for this is that highly lethal pathogens can kill their hosts before they have a chance to spread, so there is a selective pressure for pathogens not to be highly lethal. Therefore, pathogens are likely to co-evolve with their hosts rather than kill all possible hosts.39

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Disease

Turn---HEMPs reduce the risk of pandemics---at worst there’s no correlation

Cook 10, Nigel B. PhD Computer Programming, BA Physics, “How weapons and war effects exaggerations for disarmament forced Britain to collaborate with evil racist thugs at Munich in 1938, in the name of peace” http://glasstone.blogspot.com/2010/03/lifeboat-analogy-to-civil-defence.html 3/1/10

Dr Stonier's chapter 9, "Pestilence and Plague: The Threat of Epidemics" and the remainder of the book is contrived and deceptive, citing in his bibliography - but ignoring in his text - documentary evidence from nuclear test ecological recovery at Eniwetok Atoll near two megaton yield tests which contradicts his case that the insects will inherit the Earth. He entirely ignores the plague of 1348-50 which killed a third of the population in Western Europe as an example of the human recovery potential after a huge disaster (see Jack Hirshleifer, Disaster and Recovery: The Black Death in Western Europe, RAND Corporation report RM4700, 1966, online PDF linked here). Like his ability to ignore the lack of firestorms in modern London buildings and the limited firestorm intensity even in the wooden two-storey buildings of Hiroshima, and to misrepresent the Hamburg firestorm in 3-5 storey medieval wooden overcrowded buildings as illustrative of the threat to modern concrete, steel and brick cities, Stonier misrepresents plague risks. He delves back selectively through the history of epidemics to find examples that tend to support his thesis (simply ignoring all evidence to the contrary) such as tularemia (a virulent bacterial infection transmitted by tick bites, skin contact, inhalation and ingestion, which concentrating in the lymph nodes, causing weakness and fever but not usually death) outbreak of 1941 in Rostov-on-Don, Russia, where 37,000 people were infected. This outbreak resulted from the wartime conscription, which left the crops unharvested in the fields, allowing field mice to proliferate, spreading tularemia through their droppings and ticks on the hay and grain stored in barns, which were used by soldiers for sleeping quarters. Stonier then studies the second bubonic plague outbreak that began on 14 August 1907 in San Francisco, infecting 167 people of which 89 died, over a year after the city was devastated by the great earthquake and fire of 18 April 1906. This plague was spread by fleas living on rats breeding in the insanitary conditions of the wrecked city, which still lacked functioning sewage disposal systems. Stonier moves on to the more deadly pneumonic plague which broke out in Oakland, California, 1919, when a hunter infected by flea bites from the fur of a groundhog spread plague, infecting 14 cases of which 13 proved fatal. Stonier then discusses the similar mechanism for the larger-scale pneumonic plague outbreak amongst fur-trappers in Manchouli, Manchuria, 1910-11. That plague killed 60,000 because it was spread first in crowded underground inns in Manchouli, and later (as cases appeared) these infected people panicked and fled on the Chinese Eastern Railway to numerous towns throughout the whole country. On page 131 Stonier attempts to glue these historical plague examples to the aftermath of nuclear warfare, by claiming that the birds and mammal predators for insect disease vectors will be killed off by 1,000 roentgens of gamma radiation exposure, whereas adult insects will survive 100,000 roentgens and can reproduce at doses of up to 5,000 roentgens. He points out that conifers like pine trees are about as vulnerable as mammals (spruce seeds are killed by 1,000 roentgens, he states on p. 143), but in general plants can withstand 5,000 roentgens of gamma radiation, while mustard seeds can "absorb 92,000 roentgens and still produce viable plants" (Stonier, p. 131). On page 132 Stonier points out that 13 out of 15 flora species were injured or killed over five years by fallout radiation at the world's most highly contaminated fallout location, Gegen Islet at the northern edge of Rongelap Atoll, giving the island a grey rather than green colour as seen from aircraft five years later. Gegen Islet was the downwind fallout hotspot location 100 miles downwind of the 15 Mt Bravo test, giving a 3,000 rads gamma dose within 48 hours, and thousands more at a slower rate, later on. Moving southward in Rongelap Atoll, the radiation doses were smaller, and the damage less. At Kabelle Island, for instance, only 3 species of flora were killed, including the mangroves, and at Eniwetok Islet in Rongerik Atoll (further downwind) only 2 species of flora were affected by fallout. (References: F. R. Fosberg, "Plants and Fall-out", Nature, v. 183, 1959, p. 1448, and Robert A. Conard, Brookhaven National Laboratory report BNL-609, 1961, pp. 85-6.) Stonier believed that radiation kills off most birds and animals that normally keep eat insects, thus allowing plagues of relatively radiation-resistant insects to breed on the surviving vegetation and spread diseases to surviving humans: "The result: insect plagues. Associated with the spread of insects would be the spread of certain insect-borne diseases." This was based on ecological studies by G. M. Woodwell at Brookhaven National Laboratory, who exposed an oak and pine forest on Long Island, New York, to gamma radiation from cesium-137 (G. M. Woodwell, "Effects of Ionizing Radiation on Terrestrial Ecosystems", Science, v. 138, 1962, pp. 572-7). Stonier observes on p. 135 that "where the oaks received 5 roentgens per day, the defoliation by insects was about five times as great as that observed in control areas." This cesium-137 gamma exposure has no relevance to the overall effects of radioactive fallout, since it ignores the effects of beta radiation (which is easily stopped by tree bark) upon insects. Stonier cites in his bibliography, but chooses to ignore completely in his text (without explanation) the rapid recovery and lack of insect plagues on Bogombogo Island (codenamed "Belle Island" by America) at the North-West of Eniwetok Atoll in the North Pacific, which was selected for detailed ecological studies following two high yield nuclear weapons tests: Dr Ralph F. Palumbo, Radioactivity and Recovery of the Land Plants at Eniwetok Atoll, 1954-1957, University of Washington report UWFL-66, July 1960 (PDF linked here), see the recovery photos linked here. Bogombogo/Belle Island was 2.55 statute miles (4.10 km) from the centre of Elugelab Island, ground zero of the 10.4 megatons IVY-MIKE thermonuclear weapon test of November 1, 1952, and the 1.69 megatons 80% fission CASTLE-NECTAR test was detonated at the same spot on a barge over the IVY-MIKE crater on May 14, 1954. It received heavy blast and thermal damage, water wave flooding, and fallout radiation including extensive beta and gamma irradiation of plants (gamma of over 850 R/hr at 2 hours after IVY-MIKE according to page 34 of of report WT-615, which - from the mean fallout arrival time and peak dose rate time measured under the cloud - suggests an infinite dose of over 8,000 R, and then another 400 R to 6 months after CASTLE-NECTAR and beta doses near contaminated surfaces are about ten times larger, see Stonier p. 143). Dr Palumbo states in his article "Recovery of the Land Plants at Eniwetok Atoll Following a Nuclear Detonation" (Radiation Botany, vol. 1, 1962, pp. 182-9):

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: HEMPs

HEMPs are harmless---studies are overhyped and STILL conclude NEG

James 22, Jim James is the author of survival freedom and cites 4 independent studies 2-10-22 , "Can an EMP Harm a Human?," https://survivalfreedom.com/can-an-emp-harm-a-human-what-you-need-to-know/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=can-an-emp-harm-a-human-what-you-need-to-know-Parks

There’s little to no evidence to suggest that EMPs pose a physical threat to humans. One of the main reasons low EMPs may not harm humans directly is that we’re mostly made of water, and our body isn’t very conductive. However, the conclusion from most studies is that EMPs at high levels may directly harm humans. Some of the possible effects on humans include: Cellular mutations Internal burns Nervous system damage Brain damage EMPs may also affect pacemakers and other implanted devices. Because they’re electronic devices, they can become damaged if an EMP occurs. The extent of damage will depend on the level of the EMP and the person’s proximity to it. Long Exposure Could Cause DNA Mutations , assistant professor of clinical neuroscience at Columbia University, exposure to ionizing radiation, such as the one in EMPs, can cause DNA damage and mutations. He also stated that non-ionizing energy from cell phone towers, power lines, and wireless devices might cause structural and functional damage to the nervous system at radio wave frequencies. Temporary Microvascular Leaking Is Possible In on the effects of EMP on the brain microvascular permeability in rats, the researchers found that EMP exposure of 200–400 pulses produced microvascular artery leakage in the brain. This sort of microvascular artery leaking has been linked to mild cognitive and memory issues in humans. Although they were still visible 12 hours after exposure, the effects were relatively transient. EMPs Can Disrupt the Blood-Brain Barrier Besides DNA damage, mutation, and internal burns, EMPs may also disrupt the blood-brain barrier. This barrier is what protects the tissues of your nervous system. When you break down that barrier, you’re destroying another layer of defense for your brain. The effect? Well, according to a , temperature rises of merely 1°C (1.8°F) can have a harmful impact, giving easy access to macromolecules to permeate the blood-brain barrier. High Levels of Emp Could Impact Cognitive Functions Some studies also suggest that high levels of EMP may severely impact the cognitive functions of the left hemisphere of the brain, which is responsible for language and speech. According to , it can briefly short-circuit the . Most Studies Show That Any Effects Are Limited Based on the studies reviewed so far in this article, the conclusion is that you may experience some adverse effects during the first 12 hours of an EMP. However, it’s important to mention that the bulk of these researches includes relatively high levels of microwave radiation exposure during testing – probably much higher than what you’d get from a nuclear detonation or a solar flare in the event of an EMP.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Grid

This is ridiculous not everyone even uses the grid and mutual aid makes extinction impossible

Springer, 17—University of Victoria (Simon, “The limits to Marx: David Harvey and the condition of postfraternity,” Dialogues in Human Geography 2017, Vol. 7(3) 280–294, dml)

Yet since horizontal organizational tactics in anarchism are usually part of a broader class struggle (Solidarity Federation, 2012), it is absurd to suggest that there would ever be a time where anarchists would enter into assembly—federated or otherwise—during a nuclear meltdown or the complex operation of landing an airplane. Indeed, without a discernable hierarchy to oppose, ‘in what possible circumstance would collective struggle be necessary during such risky periods?’ (fkshultze, 2013). Nonetheless, mutual aid in times of disaster—both natural and manufactured—is a recurrent human theme, where people regularly come together and organize themselves effectively around an ensuing crisis in the complete absence of a centralized authority. We saw this with spectacular effect in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, where the state was more concerned with restoring ‘law and order’ and criminalizing desperate people than it was with relief and rescue efforts. In response to the state’s failure, people instead helped themselves and each other, particularly through the formation of the Common Ground Collective. For Kropotkin (2008 [1902]: 137), the tendency for mutual aid ‘has so remote an origin, and is so deeply interwoven with all the past evolution of the human race, that it has been maintained ... notwithstanding all vicissitudes of history’.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Escalation

Even if it does somehow escalate there’s no extinction

James Scouras 19. Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. Summer 2019. “Nuclear War as a Global Catastrophic Risk.” Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 274–295.

While it is clear that nuclear war is a global catastrophic risk, it is also clear that it is not an existential risk. Yet over the course of the nuclear age, a series of mechanisms have been proposed that, it has been erroneously argued, could lead to human extinction. The first concern3 arose among physicists on the Manhattan Project during a 1942  seminar at Berkeley some three years before the first test of an atomic weapon. Chaired by Robert Oppenheimer, it was attended by Edward Teller, Hans Bethe, Emil Konopinski, and other theoretical physicists.4 They considered the possibility that detonation of an atomic bomb could ignite a self-sustaining nitrogen fusion reaction that might propagate through earth’s atmosphere, thereby extinguishing all air-breathing life on earth. Konopinski, Cloyd Margin, and Teller eventually published the calculations that led to the conclusion that the nitrogen-nitrogen reaction was virtually impossible from atomic bomb explosions—calculations that had previously been used to justify going forward with Trinity, the first atomic bomb test.5 Of course, the Trinity test was conducted, as well as over 2000 (by all nations) subsequent atomic and thermonuclear tests, and we are fortunately still here breathing air After the bomb was used, extinction fear focused on invisible and deadly fallout, unanticipated as a significant consequence of the bombings of Japan that would spread by global air currents to poison the entire planet. Public dread was reinforced by the depressing, but influential, 1957 novel On the Beach by Nevil Shute () and the subsequent 1959 movie version (Kramer, 1959). The story describes survivors in Melbourne, Australia, one of a few remaining human outposts in the Southern Hemisphere, as fallout clouds approached to bring the final blow to humanity. In the 1970s, after fallout was better understood to be limited in space, time, and magnitude, depletion of the ozone layer, which would cause increased ultraviolet radiation to fry all humans who dared to venture outside, became the extinction mechanism of concern. Again, one popular book, The Fate of the Earth by Jonathan Schell (), which described the nuclear destruction of the ozone layer leaving the earth “a republic of insects and grass,” promoted this fear. Schell did at times try to cover all bases, however: “To say that human extinction is a certainty would, of course, be a misrepresentation – just as it would be a misrepresentation to say that extinction can be ruled out” (Schell, ). Finally, the current mechanism of concern for extinction is nuclear winter, the phenomenon by which dust and soot created primarily by the burning of cities would rise to the stratosphere and attenuate sunlight such that surface temperatures would decline dramatically, agriculture would fail, and humans and other animals would perish from famine. The public first learned of the possibility of nuclear winter in a Parade article by Sagan (), published a month or so before its scientific counterpart by Turco et al. (). While some nuclear disarmament advocates promote the idea that nuclear winter is an extinction threat, and the general public is probably confused to the extent it is not disinterested, few scientists seem to consider it an extinction threat. It is understandable that some of these extinction fears were created by ignorance or uncertainty and treated seriously by worst-case thinking, as seems appropriate for threats of extinction. But nuclear doom mongering also seems to be at play for some of these episodes. For some reason, portions of the public active in nuclear issues, as well as some scientists, appear to think that arguments for nuclear arms reductions or elimination will be more persuasive if nuclear war is believed to threaten extinction, rather than merely the horrific cataclysm that it would be in reality (Martin, ). To summarize, nuclear war is a global catastrophic risk. Such wars may cause billions of deaths and unfathomable suffering, as well set civilization back centuries. Smaller nuclear wars pose regional catastrophic risks and also national risks in that the continued functioning of, for example, the United States as a constitutional republic is highly dubious after even a relatively limited nuclear attack. But what nuclear war is not is an existential risk to the human race. There is simply no credible scenario in which humans do not survive to repopulate the earth

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Escalation

Even if we can we won’t

CRS 08, 06-21-08, "High Altitude Electromagnetic Pulse (HEMP) and High Power Microwave (HPM) Devices: Threat Assessments,"

Commission members have stated at hearings that, as time passes without a visible effort to show the world that we are protecting our computer systems and critical infrastructures, the perceived inaction may actually invite a possible EMP attack.15 In the past, the threat of mutually assured destruction provided a lasting deterrent against the exchange of multiple high-yield nuclear warheads. However, a single, low-yield nuclear explosion high above the United States, or over a battlefield, can produce a large-scale, high-altitude EMP *(HEMP) effect resulting in widespread loss of electronics, but possibly without direct fatalities. Therefore, an EMP attack directed against the United States involving no violent destruction, nor instant death for large numbers of U.S. citizens, may not necessarily evoke massive nuclear retaliation by the U.S. military, where, for example, large numbers of innocent civilians of a nation with a rogue leader might be killed. Such a perceived lower risk of assured destruction by the United States, and widespread knowledge about the vulnerability of U.S. civilian and military computers to the effects of an EMP attack, could actually create a new incentive for other countries or terrorist groups to develop, or perhaps purchase, a nuclear capability.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---AT: Escalation

HEMPs ZERO the risk of escalation---the warheads can’t be fired, plus no one would allow it

Peter Pry 22, Dr. Peter Vincent Pry is Executive Director of the EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security, served as the Chief of State of the Congressional EMP Commission, Director of the U.S. Nuclear Strategy Forum, and on the staffs of the Congressional Strategic Posture Commission, House Armed Services Committee, and the CIA. He is author of the books Blackout Warfare(2021) and The Power And The Light(2020) ,02-17-2022, "Russia could win World War III in Europe with EMP nuclear attack," Washington Times, //agb, edited for ableist language*

Russia could win World War III in Europe with a single Super-EMP nuclear warhead. Detonated 70 kilometers high over NATO Headquarters in Brussels, the EMP field would blackout electric grids and paralyze *(make powerless) NATO military forces from Poland to Britain, making a red carpet for a Russian invasion. U.S. troops and 30,000 civilians fleeing Ukraine would become POWs. Russian tanks could reach the English Channel in days. After an EMP attack, the U.S. would discover it has no tactical nuclear weapons. Even if some delivery systems survive the EMP, it is doubtful any host European government would allow a tactical nuclear strike against Russia from its territory, fearing nuclear retaliation.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---Extinction O/W

We don’t need to win much---100 survivors ensure continued survival and save <500 trillion lives

Turchin & Denkenberger 18 Alexey Turchin & David Denkenberger 18. Turchin is a researcher at the Science for Life Extension Foundation; Denkenberger is with the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute (GCRI) @ Tennessee State University, Alliance to Feed the Earth in Disasters (ALLFED). 09/2018. “Global Catastrophic and Existential Risks Communication Scale.” Futures, vol. 102, pp. 27–38.

“Civilizational collapse risks” As most human societies are fairly complex, a true civilizational collapse would require a drastic reduction in human population, and the break-down of connections between surviving populations. Survivors would have to rebuild civilization from scratch, likely losing much technological abilities and knowledge in the process. Hanson (2008) estimated that the minimal human population able to survive is around 100 people. Like X risks, there is little agreement on what is required for civilizational collapse. Clearly, different types and levels of the civilizational collapse are possible (Diamond, 2005) (Meadows, Randers, & Meadows, 2004). For instance, one definition of the collapse of civilization involves, collapse of long distance trade, widespread conflict, and loss of government (Coates, 2009). How such collapses relate to existential risk needs more research.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 2NC---AT: War Bad › 2NC---Extinction O/W

Even if they somehow win a large portion of the population dies extinction threatens <500 trillion lives---you should vote neg if we win 1/55-thousand risk of our impacts.

Math (if they win almost everyone dies): 500 trillion/9 billion = .000018 = .0018% = 1/55555 < 1/55k

Baum & Barrett 18, D. Baum & Anthony M. Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “Global Catastrophes: The Most Extreme Risks.” Risk in Extreme Environments: Preparing, Avoiding, Mitigating, and Managing, edited by Vicki Bier, Routledge, pp. 174–184.

A common theme across all these treatments of GCR is that some catastrophes are vastly more important than others. Carl Sagan was perhaps the first to recognize this, in his commentary on nuclear winter (Sagan 1983). Without nuclear winter, a global nuclear war might kill several hundred million people. This is obviously a major catastrophe, but humanity would presumably carry on. However, with nuclear winter, per Sagan, humanity could go extinct. The loss would be not just an additional four billion or so deaths, but the loss of all future generations. To paraphrase Sagan, the loss would be billions and billions of lives, or even more. Sagan estimated 500 trillion lives, assuming humanity would continue for ten million more years, which he cited as typical for a successful species. Sagan’s 500 trillion number may even be an underestimate. The analysis here takes an adventurous turn, hinging on the evolution of the human species and the long-term fate of the universe. On these long time scales, the descendants of contemporary humans may no longer be recognizably “human”. The issue then is whether the descendants are still worth caring about, whatever they are. If they are, then it begs the question of how many of them there will be. Barring major global catastrophe, Earth will remain habitable for about one billion more years until the Sun gets too warm and large. The rest of the Solar System, Milky Way galaxy, universe, and (if it exists) the multiverse will remain habitable for a lot longer than that (Adams and Laughlin 1997), should our descendants gain the capacity to migrate there. An open question in astronomy is whether it is possible for the descendants of humanity to continue living for an infinite length of time or instead merely an astronomically large but finite length of time (see e.g. Ćirković 2002; Kaku 2005). Either way, the stakes with global catastrophes could be much larger than the loss of 500 trillion lives.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Warming

Its try-or-die nuke war is the only way to solve warming---no defense

19, 1-4-2019, Samuel Miller McDonald is a writer and geography PhD student at University of Oxford studying the intersection of grassroots movements and energy transition. "Deathly Salvation — THE TROUBLE.," *edited for ableist language

The global economy is hurtling humanity toward extinction. Greenhouse gas emissions are on track to warm the planet by six degrees Celsius above preindustrial averages. A six-degree increase risks killing most life on earth, as global warming did during the Late Permian when volcanoes burned a bunch of fossilized carbon (e.g., coal, oil, and gas). Called the , that event was, according to New York Magazine, “The most notorious [extinction event…]; it began when carbon warmed the planet by five degrees, accelerated when that warming triggered the release of methane in the Arctic, and ended with 97 percent of all life on Earth dead.”

Mainstream science that we’re on our way there. During the winter of 2017, the Arctic grew warmer than Europe, sending snow to the Mediterranean and Sahara. The planet may have already passed irreversible thresholds that could accelerate further feedback loops like permafrost melt and loss of polar ice. Patches of permafrost even during winter, necessitating a rename (may I suggest ‘nevafrost’?). In the summer of 2018, forests north of the Arctic Circle broke 90 degrees Fahrenheit and in vast wildfires. We’re reaching milestones far faster than scientists have even recently predicted. As Guardian columnist George Monbiot , “The Arctic meltdown […] is the kind of event scientists warned we could face by 2050. Not by 2018.” Mass marine death that rapidly emits uncontrollable greenhouse gasses is another feedback loop that seems ready to strike. The ocean is now than any time in the last 14 million years, killing everything from snails to whales. It’s growing rapidly more acidic. Meanwhile, from the global South to wealthier industrialized countries, people are already dying and being displaced from the impacts of extreme climate change via extreme droughts, floods, wildfires, storms, and conflicts like the Syrian civil war. Authoritarianism is due directly to these climate emergencies and migrations.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Warming

Russia first strikes the west with hypersonic HEMPs if war happens now---This doesn’t kill anyone and guarantees war doesn’t escalate---Russian doctrine AND generals admit it

Pry 21, Dr. Peter Vincent Pry, Executive Director EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security also legit most qualified person ever on this issue, January 2021 The Russian Federation’s Military Doctrine, Plans, and Capabilities for Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack" https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1124730.pdf

Any nuclear weapon detonated in outer space, 30 kilometers or higher, will generate a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP). No blast, thermal, fallout or effects other than HEMP are experienced in the atmosphere and on the ground. A nuclear detonation at 30 kilometers altitude will generate a HEMP field with a radius on the ground of 600 kilometers, damaging all kinds of electronics, blacking-out electric grids and collapsing other life-sustaining critical infrastructures. Detonated at 400 kilometers altitude, the radius of the HEMP field will be about 2,200 kilometers, large enough to cover most of North America.

Russia has what they term “Super-EMP” weapons, nuclear warheads specialized for HEMP attack. Super-EMP warheads have very low explosive yield (10 kilotons or less) but very high gamma yield, which is what generates HEMP. According to Russian military and technical sources, Super-EMP weapons can generate HEMP fields of 100,000 volts/meter or higher, greatly exceeding the U.S. military hardening standard for HEMP (50,000 volts/meter).

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Warming

Studies prove 12 degrees warming is coming now---only a radical shift can solve

EcoWatch 19, 02-26-2019, "'A World Without Clouds': New Study Details Possibility of Devastating Climate Feedback Loop," EcoWatch, //barn * edited for clarity

As people across the globe mobilize to demand bold action to combat the climate crisis and scientific findings about looming “environmental breakdown” pile up, a startling new study published Monday in the journal Nature Geoscience warns that human-caused global warming could cause stratocumulus clouds to totally disappear in as little as a century, triggering up to 8°C (14°F) of additional warming.

Stratocumulus clouds cover about two-thirds of the Earth and help keep *it [Earth] cool by reflecting solar radiation back to space. Recent research has suggested that planetary warming correlates with greater cloud loss, stoking fears about a feedback loop that could spell disaster.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Nano

Otherwise, nanotech becomes self-replicating and destroys the Universe

Hu 18 – Jiaqi Hu, Humanities Scholar and President and Chief Scientist of the Beijing Jianlei International Decoration Engineering Company and 16Lao Group, Graduate of Dongbei University, Elected as the Chinese People’s Consultative Conference Member for Beijing Mentougou District, Saving Humanity: Truly Understanding and Ranking Our World's Greatest Threats, p. 208-210

As a unit of measurement, a nanometer is 10^9 meters (or one billionth of a meter); it is roughly one 50,000th of a strand of hair and is commonly used in the measuring of atoms and molecules. In 1959, Nobel Prize winner and famous physicist Richard Feynman first proposed in a lecture entitled "There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom" that humans might be able to create molecule-sized micro-machines in the future and that it would be another technological revolution. At the time, Feynman's ideas were ridiculed, but subsequent developments in science soon proved him to be a true visionary. In 1981, scientists developed the scanning tunneling microscope and finally reached nano-level cognition. In 1990, IBM scientists wrote the three letters "IBM" on a nickel substrate by moving thirty-five xenon atoms one by one, demonstrating that nanotechnology had become capable of transporting single atoms. Most of the matter around us exists in molecule forms, which are composed of atoms. The ability to move atoms signaled an ability to perform marvelous feats. For example, we could move carbon atoms to form diamonds, or pick out all the gold atoms in low-grade gold mines. However, nanotechnology would not achieve any goals of real significance if solely reliant on manpower. There are hundreds of millions of atoms in a needle-tip-sized area—even if a person committed their life to moving these atoms, no real value could be achieved. Real breakthroughs in nanotechnology could only be produced by nanobots. Scientists imagined building molecule-sized robots to move atoms and achieve goals; these were nanobots. On the basis of this hypothesis, scientists further postulated the future of nanotechnology; for example, nanobots might be able to enter the bloodstream and dispose of cholesterol deposited in the veins; nanobots could track cancer cells in the body and kill them at their weakest moment; nanobots could instantly turn newly-cut grass into bread; nanobots could transform recycled steel into a brand new-car in seconds. In short, the future of nanotechnology seemed incredibly bright. This was not the extent of nanotechnology's power. Scientists also discovered that nanotechnology could change the properties of materials. In 1991, when studying C60, scientists discovered carbon nanotubes (CNTs) that were only a few nanos in diameter. The carbon nanotube became known as the king of nano materials due to its superb properties; scientists believed that it would produce great results when applied to nanobots. Later, scientists also developed a type of synthetic molecular motor that derived energy from the high-energy adenosine triphosphate (ATP) that powered intracellular chemical reactions. The success of molecular motor research solved the core component problem of nano machines; any molecular motor grafted with other components could turn into a nano machine, and nanobots could use them for motivation. In May 2004, American chemists developed the world’s first nanobot: a bipedal molecular robot that looked like a compass with ten-nanometer-long legs. This nanobot was composed of DNA fragments, including thirty-six base pairs, and it could "stroll" on plates in the laboratory. In April 2005, Chinese scientists developed nano-scale robotic prototypes as well. In June of 2013, the Tohoku University used peptide protein micro-tablets to successfully create nanobots that could enter cells and move on the cell membrane. In July 2017, researchers at the University of Rome and the Roman Institute of Nanotechnology announced the development of a new synthetic molecular motor that was bacteria-driven and light-controlled. The next step would be to get nanobots to move atoms or molecules. Compared to the value produced by a nanobot, they are extremely expensive to create. The small size of nanobots means that although they can accomplish meaningful tasks, they are often very inefficient. Even if a nanobot toiled day and night, its achievements would only be calculated in terms of atoms, making its practical total attainment relatively small. Scientists came up with a solution for this problem. They decided to prepare two sets of instructions when programming nanobots. The first set of instructions would set out tasks for the nanobot, while the second set would order the nanobot to self-replicate. Since nanobots are capable of moving atoms and are themselves composed of atoms, self-replication would be fairly easy. One nanobot could replicate into ten, then a hundred, and then a thousand . . . billions could be replicated in a short period of time. This army of nanobots would greatly increase their efficiency. One troublesome question that arises from this scenario is: how would nanobots know when to stop self-replicating? Human bodies and all of Earth are composed of atoms; the unceasing replication of nanobots could easily swallow humanity and the entire planet. If these nanobots were accidentally transported to other planets by cosmic dust, the same fate would befall those planets. This is a truly terrifying prospect. Some scientists are confident that they can control the situation. They believe that it is possible to design nanobots that are programmed to self-destruct after several generations of replication, or even nanobots that only self-replicate in specific conditions. For example, a nanobot that dealt with garbage refurbishing could be programmed to only self-replicate around trash using trash. Although these ideas are worthy, they are too idealistic. Some more rational scientists have posed these questions: What would happen if nanobots malfunctioned and did not terminate their self-replication? What would happen if scientists accidentally forgot to add self-replication controls during programming? What if immoral scientists purposefully designed nanobots that would not stop self-replicating? Any one of the above scenarios would be enough to destroy both humanity and Earth. Chief scientist of Sun Microsystems, Bill Joy, is a leading, world-renowned scientist in the computer technology field. In April of 1999, he pointed out that if misused, nanotechnology could be more devastating than nuclear weapons. If nanobots self-replicated uncontrollably, they could become the cancer that engulfs the universe. If we are not careful, nanotechnology might become the Pandoras box that destroys the entire universe and all of humanity with it. We all understand that one locust is insignificant, but hundreds of millions of locusts can destroy all in their path. If self-replicating nanobots are really achieved in the future, it might signify the end of humanity. If that day came, nothing could stop unethical scientists from designing nanobots that suited their immoral purposes. Humans are not far from mastering nanotechnology. The extremely tempting prospects of nanotechnology have propelled research of nanobots and nanotechnology. The major science and technology nations have devoted particular efforts to this field.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Nano

That war stops nanotech research.

Baum & Barrett 18, Seth Baum & Anthony Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “A Model for the Impacts of Nuclear War.” SSRN Electronic Journal. Crossref, doi:10.2139/ssrn.3155983.

Another link between nuclear war and other major catastrophes comes from the potential for general malfunction of society shifting work on risky technologies such as artificial intelligence, molecular nanotechnology, and biotechnology. The simplest effect would be for the general malfunction of society to halt work on these technologies. In most cases, this would reduce the risk of harm caused by those technologies. It is also conceivable that in the absence of a functional society, safety measures would decay, resulting in the release of harmful technologies (or substances developed via the technologies). For example, stores of dangerous pathogens could escape their laboratories. However, this is a speculative possibility and may be unlikely or impossible, depending on the details of how the technologies/substances are stored.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---Nano

Russia first strikes the west with hypersonic HEMPs if war happens now---This doesn’t kill anyone and guarantees war doesn’t escalate---Russian doctrine AND generals admit it

Pry 21, Dr. Peter Vincent Pry, Executive Director EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security also legit most qualified person ever on this issue, January 2021 The Russian Federation’s Military Doctrine, Plans, and Capabilities for Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack" https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1124730.pdf

Any nuclear weapon detonated in outer space, 30 kilometers or higher, will generate a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP). No blast, thermal, fallout or effects other than HEMP are experienced in the atmosphere and on the ground. A nuclear detonation at 30 kilometers altitude will generate a HEMP field with a radius on the ground of 600 kilometers, damaging all kinds of electronics, blacking-out electric grids and collapsing other life-sustaining critical infrastructures. Detonated at 400 kilometers altitude, the radius of the HEMP field will be about 2,200 kilometers, large enough to cover most of North America.

Russia has what they term “Super-EMP” weapons, nuclear warheads specialized for HEMP attack. Super-EMP warheads have very low explosive yield (10 kilotons or less) but very high gamma yield, which is what generates HEMP. According to Russian military and technical sources, Super-EMP weapons can generate HEMP fields of 100,000 volts/meter or higher, greatly exceeding the U.S. military hardening standard for HEMP (50,000 volts/meter).

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---AI

Otherwise were doomed---outweighs nukes

Turchin & Denkenberger 18, Alexey Turchin & David Denkenberger. Turchin is a researcher at the Science for Life Extension Foundation; Denkenberger is with the Global Catastrophic Risk Institute (GCRI) @ Tennessee State University, Alliance to Feed the Earth in Disasters (ALLFED). 05/03/2018. “Classification of Global Catastrophic Risks Connected with Artificial Intelligence.” AI & SOCIETY, pp. 1–17.

According to Yampolskiy and Spellchecker (2016), the probability and seriousness of AI failures will increase with time. We estimate that they will reach their peak between the appearance of the first self-improving AI and the moment that an AI or group of AIs reach global power, and will later diminish, as late-stage AI halting seems to be a low-probability event. AI is an extremely powerful and completely unpredictable technology, millions of times more powerful than nuclear weapons. Its existence could create multiple individual global risks, most of which we can not currently imagine. We present several dozen separate global risk scenarios connected with AI in this article, but it is likely that some of the most serious are not included. The sheer number of possible failure modes suggests that there are more to come.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---AI

That stops AI research.

Baum & Barrett 18, Seth Baum & Anthony Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “A Model for the Impacts of Nuclear War.” SSRN Electronic Journal. Crossref, doi:10.2139/ssrn.3155983.

Another link between nuclear war and other major catastrophes comes from the potential for general malfunction of society shifting work on risky technologies such as artificial intelligence, molecular nanotechnology, and biotechnology. The simplest effect would be for the general malfunction of society to halt work on these technologies. In most cases, this would reduce the risk of harm caused by those technologies. It is also conceivable that in the absence of a functional society, safety measures would decay, resulting in the release of harmful technologies (or substances developed via the technologies). For example, stores of dangerous pathogens could escape their laboratories. However, this is a speculative possibility and may be unlikely or impossible, depending on the details of how the technologies/substances are stored.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG › 1NCs › 1NC---AI

Russia first strikes the west with hypersonic HEMPs if war happens now---This doesn’t kill anyone and guarantees war doesn’t escalate---Russian doctrine AND generals admit it

Pry 21, Dr. Peter Vincent Pry, Executive Director EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security also legit most qualified person ever on this issue, January 2021 The Russian Federation’s Military Doctrine, Plans, and Capabilities for Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack" https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1124730.pdf

Any nuclear weapon detonated in outer space, 30 kilometers or higher, will generate a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP). No blast, thermal, fallout or effects other than HEMP are experienced in the atmosphere and on the ground. A nuclear detonation at 30 kilometers altitude will generate a HEMP field with a radius on the ground of 600 kilometers, damaging all kinds of electronics, blacking-out electric grids and collapsing other life-sustaining critical infrastructures. Detonated at 400 kilometers altitude, the radius of the HEMP field will be about 2,200 kilometers, large enough to cover most of North America.

Russia has what they term “Super-EMP” weapons, nuclear warheads specialized for HEMP attack. Super-EMP warheads have very low explosive yield (10 kilotons or less) but very high gamma yield, which is what generates HEMP. According to Russian military and technical sources, Super-EMP weapons can generate HEMP fields of 100,000 volts/meter or higher, greatly exceeding the U.S. military hardening standard for HEMP (50,000 volts/meter).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Framework › 2NC --- Fairness

Disability justice can only be achieved through attempts to promote fairness through policy engagement. Only policy can engage the algorithms of AI and correct ableist notions behind AI.

Tilmes 22 – Nicholas Tilmes is in the field of bioethics and researches the intersection of philosophy, psychology, and biology at Cornell University. He is passionate about applying philosophical insights to concrete ethical dilemmas posed by emerging technologies, such as genetic engineering and functional brain imaging, and the relationship between official medical knowledge and the lived experiences of patients. (Nicholas Tilmes, “Disability, fairness, and algorithmic bias in AI recruitment”, Ethics of Information Technology, Springer Link, Article No. 21, 19 April 2022, ) || PZ

Disability justice Rather than attempting to promote fairness solely through technical adjustments to training data and input–output relations, data scientists should take up a disability justice approach. This view acknowledges that factors such as error rates and accuracy are necessary but insufficient to understand, identify, and address algorithmic bias. Disability justice serves as a framework for reasoning about how ableist structures and norms subtly configure and restrict the ostensibly objective aspects of AI design. A deeper analysis of disability and capacity not only draws attention to the value-laden nature of design processes but illuminates how data analytics and machine learning help to define and redefine those concepts. Instead, a disability justice approach suggests drawing a wider circle of considerations relevant to AI ethics; centering analysis of assumptions and values in design; closing gaps between stakeholders; and pursuing policies that empower further activism. Disability justice calls into question fair-ML’s dogged quest for objectivity and failure to confront broader socio-political norms, demanding that data scientists attend to the subjective choices intrinsic to algorithm design. This shifts from a sole focus on technical aspects of design—such as input–output relations and training data—and expands the problem space to include the social responses and outcomes that algorithms generate. While data scientists need not abandon technical considerations, these decisions must follow from an analysis of the normative choices that go into, e.g., generating classifications, formulating problems, labelling data, and selecting proxy variables. That is, designers should take a broader socio-technical perspective, which considers systems as not merely technological but enmeshed with embodied, organizational, social, and political factors (Simon et al., ; van der Bijl-Brouwer & Malcom, ). By considering how these dynamics interact and affect AI design together instead of assessing them in isolation, data scientists can better conceptualize, identify, and respond to biased algorithms. For instance, by reflecting on values woven into targets like ‘fit,’ one can parse out legitimate indicators of employability, such as word choice, from ones steeped in ableist norms and unrelated to performance, such as speech patterns and tone. Widening the circle of factors considered relevant to ethical AI design beyond data and input–output relations not only alters design processes but also renders thinkable a wider range of alternatives. Looking beyond the optimization of technical fairness criteria intervenes in solutionism and reveals a variety of other mechanisms for combatting bias and promoting social transformation. Notably, this gives us the tools to situate algorithms in a socio-technical context and raise the question of whether algorithms are appropriate instruments to measure and shape certain domains in the first place. For instance, given concerns about algorithms’ ability to capture shifting, contextual aspects of disability, what amount of discretion should they have over disabled people’s hiring outcomes, if any? While simply omitting groups from algorithmic models would exacerbate inequality, there may be reason to be much more skeptical of their inferences. Already, protests by Google employees about collaboration with the Departments of Defense and Homeland Security on Projects JEDI and MAVEN (Wakabayashi & Shane, ) and pledges by computer science students to refuse work at Palantir in light of its cooperation with Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (Birnbaum, ) point to the ways in which data scientists can affect change beyond the algorithm itself. As such, disability justice indicates that we ought to expand the scope of AI ethics and situate algorithms in their socio-technical context. Moreover, a disability justice approach suggests that data scientists should critically analyze the ways in which disability is defined, measured, and labelled. Given that most data about disability are medical, inferences from them typically are limited to the medical model, reducing disability to a biological dysfunction. Yet, by drawing on disability scholarship, we can uncover the ways in which these categories shift and trace their roots to ableist assumptions. For instance, consider proposals to increase the amount and quality of disability data by drawing from people’s electronic health records. While well-intentioned, these efforts would further entrench the medical model of disability, leave little room for self-identification, and underrepresent disabled people who lack access to health care. Making explicit the ways in which algorithms model disability creates space to imagine it differently through methods like value-sensitive design (Friedman & Hendry, ; Simon et al., ). Such an approach melds conceptual, empirical, and technical elements, e.g., assessing models of disability in terms of their assumptions, impact on data gathering, relationship to outcomes, and so on. In so doing, data scientists could better attend to the ways that different models influence people’s claims about their disabilities and how those claims are mediated by intersecting hierarchies of class, race, and gender. By investigating how different definitions and measures of disability shape who ‘counts’ as disabled, data scientists can intervene in these ongoing omissions. This requires altering how disabilities are operationalized so they are defined not solely as medical diagnoses but also in terms of how people navigate institutions, norms, and each other. While fair-ML idealizes abstraction so that data can be applied across contexts, (in)capacities emerge from a multitude of contextual factors like competing values and built environments. Instead, a disability justice framework suggests that an algorithm’s accuracy does not always trade off with its ability to accommodate contingency because many disabilities are intrinsically situational and resist quantification. Implementing this approach might involve, e.g., assigning more weight to contextual factors, assessing how aspects of a given disability shift over time, and designing scales that are sensitive to social values and attitudes. For example, some researchers have demonstrated that disability data can be disaggregated to more easily study the variables that cooccur with certain disabilities or contexts (Brown & Broido, ; Peña et al., ). Others have called for analyzing how people’s capacities expand and contract in relation to built accessibility, office culture, and the type of labor at hand (Bennett et al., ). This suggests that data scientists could model disability differently by altering processes of data collection, label generation, and proxy selection so as not to abstract away its context. In addition, disability justice demands more fundamental shifts in access, communication, and ownership across the AI design pipeline. Indeed, the biases that hiring algorithms exhibit are inseparable from developers’ sole focus on employer values and widening asymmetries between firms and applicants. Although applicants’ ability to secure jobs is shaped by these AI, they cannot examine or offer input on them easily, if at all. Expanding opportunities for these engagements and removing barriers to access is essential to designing more equitable algorithms. Already, initiatives like Access Computing offer accessible training in computer science (Trewin et al., ) and groups like (Dis)Ability in AI provide support to disabled people at conferences about AI (Whittaker et al., ). Despite efforts to increase disability representation at design forums and in training datasets, the mere presence of disability is not enough to transform existing institutions and restore trust. That is, vendors must design with disabled people, not merely for them. As the scope of design expands, data scientists ought to draw insights from other disciplines, including disability studies and socio-technical design, and team up with a wider range of stakeholders. This process cannot simply tack on these perspectives but must integrate and consult with them throughout the design pipeline. By collaborating with a diverse array of disciplines and voices, data scientists could better identify stakeholders in AI hiring, explore their values and needs, study how AI might implicate them, and involve them in design processes. This bears similarities to a participatory design perspective, in which workers are empowered by directly influencing the design of technologies they will take up (Korsgaard et al., ). Using a variety of techniques—from prototyping and mock-ups to future-oriented workshops and scenarios—stakeholders reflect on the situation, imagine innovative solutions, and transform those speculative approaches into realistic, concrete alternatives. This might involve, to give an example, asking stakeholders to evaluate whether automated interviews that assess affect and gestures align with their values, what they communicate about disabled applicants, and how they might be navigated. In parallel, insights from disability studies suggest granting disabled people’s perspectives significant weight in debates about, e.g., generating labels and selecting proxies for disability status. For instance, developers might look to data platform co-ops operated by people with rare disabilities, in which they oversee the use of their data and share profits (Scholz, ; Treviranus, ), to inform their own decisions about responsible data use. By working alongside these other disciplines and voices from the start of the design process, data scientists could help bridge gaps in knowledge, foster a common conceptual language, and develop new research methods. Beyond expanding the scope of AI ethics concerns, redefining design values, and changing stakeholder dynamics, a disability justice approach suggests pursuing policy measures that can empower data activism. While legislation often lags behind advances in computing, existing regulatory uncertainty allows AI vendors to selectively endorse transparency and fairness criteria in ways that preserve existing arrangements. Greater transparency could help promote the conditions necessary for activists and data scientists alike to study, uncover, and contest algorithmic bias. Despite the explanatory difficulties associated with the black box, policies ought to be introduced mandating that AI developers regularly audit and disclose the purview, inputs and outputs, and limitations of their algorithms. For example, some have suggested requiring employers to make public the automated inferences they make about applicants (Hoffman, ) and tasking them with retaining detailed records of their bias mitigation procedures (Hoffman, ). Developing legislation to establish minimum standards for data transparency and disclosure of bias mitigation measures—even for opaque machine learning AI—is necessary to identify and make claims against discriminatory algorithms. In addition to setting baselines for transparent design and implementation, recognizing how ableist structures can affect people’s identification with and disclosure of disability status highlights the importance of more robust privacy regulations. Existing protections are ill-equipped to grapple with the ethical risks posed by automated hiring tools or predictions of disability status. The ADA (1990) only shields those who are disabled, treated as disabled, or were disabled, while GINA (2008) and HIPAA (OCR, ) protect health data while it is being stored, transferred, and analyzed by certain classes of covered entities. However, since these laws neither cover AI vendors and data brokers nor explicitly forbid discrimination based on inferred risk factors for disabilities, AI can circumvent them (Givens & Morris, ). Similarly, while the ADA prohibits discrimination in places of public accommodation, it does not explicitly include algorithms, social media platforms, and so on (Rothstein, ). Expanding existing privacy protections would help make disability disclosure less precarious and, in so doing, assist efforts to gather more representative datasets.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Neg › Environmental Justice CP › 1NC --- Solvency

Environmental impacts are uniquely magnified against disabled bodies – only a critical intersectional lens towards political processes can identify vulnerability

Jampel, 18 (Catherine Jampel), “Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice.” Environmental Sociology. . Accessed 7-22-2021. ALS

Vulnerability. People whose bodies diverge from the ‘normal’ or ‘standard’ may face greater exposure to environmental injustice than other people. For some people, their bodily differences may also make them especially vulnerable to the effects of certain environmentally unjust conditions. For example, people who are immunosuppressed or have biological variations such as ‘slow acetylation’ bear a greater burden when exposed to air pollution, pesticides, industrial chemicals and a host of other toxic trespasses, a phrase Sandra Steingraber (2010, 279) uses to describe involuntary human exposure to a pollutant. As she explains, people who are slow acetylators have low levels of the enzymes that detoxify aromatic amines, a class of organic compounds used in pesticides and strongly associated with bladder cancer (2010, 268). Slow(er) acetylation becomes a disability when high level of aromatic amine exposure is part of society and culture. Biological variation compounded with racialized, classed and gendered exposures to toxics demonstrates how disability status ends up being created and then exacerbated through a political– economic context. As mainstream discourses shape an understanding through which the most ‘vulnerable populations’ are ‘expected’ to be further impaired or harmed (Fjord 2007), a critical and intersectional EJ lens can direct attention toward the political processes that lead to unnecessary occupational and everyday exposures to compounds such as the aromatic amines used in dyes, pesticides and plastics.