Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: Counterforce Fails › 2NC – AT: Missed Nukes

Even if some nukes survive BMD systems mop up the excess

Erik Slavin 14; Reporting on Japan, Asia-Pacific, US Navy for Stars and Stripes. “On Land and Sea, China’s Nuclear Capability Growing” 8-26-2014, http://www.stripes.com/news/on-land-and-sea-china-s-nuclear-capability-growing-1.299381

Chinese military leaders have contended they are so far behind the United States that their current nuclear posture isn’t an effective deterrent to being attacked. Maj. Gen. Yao Yunzhu, China’s director of the Center of America-China Defense Relations for the Academy of Military Science, explained that position in a letter last year to the Pacific Forum of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a think tank. “The Ballistic Missile Defense systems that the United States and its allies have deployed, or are planning to deploy, are capable of intercepting residue Chinese nuclear weapons launched for retaliation after it has already been attacked, thus potentially negating the deterrence effect of the Chinese nuclear arsenal,” Yun wrote. Furthermore, U.S. conventional missile strike systems in development could strike China’s nuclear arsenal, “which, if adopted as an official doctrine, would discredit China’s No First Use policy,” Yun wrote. China’s nuclear arsenal is thought to total about 250 warheads, compared with 2,104 operational U.S. warheads and thousands in reserve, according to Federation of American Scientists figures. If Chinese leaders think their stockpile is in danger of being wiped out by U.S. aircraft, missiles and other conventional means during a hypothetical war, it leaves them with two broad options to protect their nuclear capability: strengthen their potential attack, or abandon the no first-use policy in favor of something more threatening. For now, they appear to have chosen the former option. China has built three Jin-class nuclear submarines capable of carrying the JL-2 missile, which has an estimated range of 4,600 miles. “This will give the China its first credible sea-based nuclear deterrent, probably before the end of 2014,” Pacific Command chief Adm. Samuel Locklear said during congressional testimony in March. Although the deterrent is considered credible, its survivability is debatable. Jin-class subs are noisy — noisier than the Russian Delta II-class submarines built 30 years ago, according to an Office of Naval Intelligence report published in 2009. Noise is a submarine killer, and the U.S. has several ways of listening for them. Although China could develop a noise solution, multiple U.S. analysts think that design flaws in the missile compartments and hatches have left the Jin-class fundamentally flawed. China also has no experience with commanding and controlling nuclear-equipped submarines. However, it does have extensive experience with land-based missiles, which are also the only option capable of striking the continental United States after being launched from somewhere near China. “So from that perspective, modernizing the land-based missiles makes some sense,” said Vipin Narang, an associate professor at MIT and author of a recently published book on nuclear strategy. Besides any conventional strikes, a Chinese nuclear response in a hypothetical war would have to overcome three major U.S. defenses: the Aegis ballistic missile defense, significant parts of which are maintained on ships based in Japan and patrolling the Western Pacific; the ground-based midcourse defense; and a high-altitude area defense. The U.S. missile defense has destroyed 65 of 81 targets in tests conducted since 2001, according to the U.S. Missile Defense Agency.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: Counterforce Fails › 2NC – Subs

2. Gravity gradiometers.

Katarzyna Kubiak 20, a Senior Policy Fellow on nuclear and arms control policy. Previously, she was a Transatlantic Post-Doc Fellow for International Relations and Security at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies (IFS), an associate at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP), a research assistant at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy (IFSH), a field researcher for the National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START) and a fellow in the German Bundestag. December 2020, “Quantum Technology and Submarine Near-Invulnerability,” European Leadership Network.

Gravity gradiometers can detect anything with a mass that distorts gravitational fields specific to any location on Earth. Taking several minutes to filter out local vibrations, existing tools make surveys extremely slow and expensive. However, future quantum gravity gradiometers have the potential to “cut down the impact of vibration, enabling quicker measurements – potentially in no more than a second.”44 This would allow stability under dynamic conditions and enable scanning the ground from a moving vehicle, a very limited capability by existing technology standards.45

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: Counterforce Fails › 2NC – Subs

1. Magnetometers.

Katarzyna Kubiak 20, a Senior Policy Fellow on nuclear and arms control policy. Previously, she was a Transatlantic Post-Doc Fellow for International Relations and Security at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies (IFS), an associate at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP), a research assistant at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy (IFSH), a field researcher for the National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START) and a fellow in the German Bundestag. December 2020, “Quantum Technology and Submarine Near-Invulnerability,” European Leadership Network.

Magnetometers detect anomalies in magnetic fields, such as those caused by a massive piece of metal. Militaries have been using conventional magnetometers to detect magnetic signatures of submarines for decades. Despite continuous efforts towards miniaturization and costeffectiveness,32 however, these remain heavy, expensive and effective only at a relatively short range of less than 10 kilometres. As such, militaries usually pair them with other sensors, like sonars, which “offer longer detection ranges”.33 Magnetic anomaly detection also requires environmental mapping of the Earth’s magnetic field, especially where “variations in seabed magnetism and the presence of sunken ships generate many false alarms.”34 A quantum magnetometer promises an increase in sensitivity over traditional devices by several orders of magnitude.35 Sensitivity defines the detection range. The higher the sensitivity of the quantum magnetometer, the further it can reach into the ocean or the larger its search area can be.36 Among the many quantum magnetometers,37 the so called superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) is most advanced and matured, and promises groundbreaking ultra-sensitivity.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: Counterforce Fails › 2NC – Subs

Simple physics proves sub detection.

Katherine Wright 6-14-22, Deputy Editor of Physics Magazine, “Tracking Nuclear Material Aboard Submarines,” Physics Magazine, https://physics.aps.org/articles/v15/s79

Last year, the United Kingdom and the United States agreed to transfer some of their nuclear-powered submarines to Australia, a country that, at that time, possessed none. On hearing the announcement, Bernadette Cogswell and Patrick Huber of Virginia Tech in Blacksburg say that they were immediately concerned as there is currently no easy way to safeguard a nuclear reactor aboard a submarine. Now, the duo has come up with a technique that could solve that problem [1]. They say that the method could be used to confirm the presence of a submarine’s nuclear core without the need for onboard monitoring.

Most naval nuclear reactors employ uranium that is highly enriched fissile uranium-235 ( 235U), a material also used to make nuclear weapons. For land-based reactors, inspectors keep track of 235U using neutrino detectors placed close to an operating core (see Feature: Neutrino Detectors for National Security). But this technique doesn’t work for the water-submerged cores in submarines at sea. It also fails for the weak signals from powered-down cores, allowing operators to subvert checks of docked submarines.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: No China Rise › 2NC – Modernization

China is increasing its emerging tech to advance its military capabilities

Sameer Patil 22 – (Sameer Patil- Associate Professor, School of Computing, University of Utah. Verified email at utah.edu. Human Computer Interaction (HCI)Usable Privacy, "China’s Military Modernization – Analysis", 7-17-2022, Eurasia Review,

Cyber and space capabilities: China has used the newly established SSF to build advanced space and offensive cyber capabilities. The SSF’s Space Systems Department has consolidated military space functions, including rocket launch, telemetry, tracking, control, satellite communications, space intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance.[57] The Network Systems Department has integrated and strengthened signals intelligence, cyber espionage, computer attack, electromagnetic warfare, and psychological operations, making the SSF a formidable offensive force.[58] According to the U.S. intelligence community, China’s cyber espionage operations have included compromising telecommunications firms like Huawei and ZTE, which have provided opportunities for intelligence collection abroad.[59] For instance, in April 2019, telecommunications company Vodafone Group revealed that it had found security vulnerabilities with Huawei equipment deployed for its fixed-line phone network in Italy. These vulnerabilities probably gave Huawei unauthorized access to the carrier’s internet traffic and call data.[60] Likewise, in August 2020, a report from the Australian government and Papua New Guinea’s National Cyber Security Centre noted that the latter’s National Data Centre, built by Huawei in 2018, was marred by weak cybersecurity which exposed confidential government data to theft.[61] Drones and unmanned aerial and underwater capabilities: China has pursued the research and development of drones and unmanned aerial and underwater capabilities with an eye on its benefits during combat and reconnaissance. It has had some notable successes: the PLAAF recently unveiled its largest drone, the WZ-7 “Soaring Dragon” high-altitude, long-range drone.[62] It has also developed and deployed a fleet of underwater Sea Wing drones in the Indian Ocean for naval intelligence purposes.[63] Currently, China is developing a supersonic drone WZ-8 as well as swarming drone capability. Research initiatives like these funded by China’s tech ecosystem that’s blended with the military system ensure that the PLA has the edge over the other militaries in the region and beyond. Software-first dual-use technologies: In similar vein, through fair means and subterfuge, China has made great strides in software-first dual-use technologies like artificial intelligence, deep learning, and facial recognition. Besides, its own laboratories, the PLA has also utilised its domestic technology giants like Alibaba, SenseTime, and Megvii for developing the needed algorithms.[64] The CCP has deployed these technologies for external defence as well as internal security purposes. For instance, many of these companies have been used for targeted facial recognition, artificial intelligence, big data, and genetic testing against its Uighur population in Xinjiang.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: No China Rise › 2NC – Modernization

US is unprepared for military buildup in China- China’s economic leadership allows them to spend more on military

Corbiscello 21- (Nick Corbiscello- Graduate from William Paterson University- The National Political Science Honor Society William Paterson. “THE RISE OF CHINA: THE NEW GLOBAL SUPERPOWER” William Patterson University, June 2021, https://www.proquest.com/openview/a3f8e997e50e56eb0ff2695a5f8678da/1?cbl=18750&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar)//mishelle

China also notoriously uses artificial intelligence to track and control its population (Ioanes 2019, Par. 6). It is also betting that AI (artificial intelligence) like autonomous unmanned systems and intelligent robotics are the future both of economic advancement and warfighting (Ioanes 2019, Par. 6). China’s tactic of military and civil fusion also works here, as advancements in the civilian sector will be easily adapted to military capabilities (Ioanes 2019, Par. 6). As China’s economy is the 2nd largest in the world and on the path to overtake the U.S. by 2030, it gives them the ability to spend far more resources on its military than in previous decades (Ioanes 2019, Par. 7). Between 1996 and 2015, China increased its military spending by 620% (Ioanes 2019, Par. 7). China’s Ministry of Finance said the 2019 defense budget was $177 billion (Maizland 2020, Par. 4). However, analysts’ estimates are often higher than what Beijing reports (Maizland 2020, Par. 4). Defense spending increase more than sevenfold, from $31 billion in 1998 to $239 billion in 2018 (Maizland 2020, Par. 4). For much of its history, the PLA relied on foreign military equipment, especially from Russia (Maizland 2020, Par. 5). But in recent decades, the Chinese government invested heavily in state-owned and private-sector defense companies (Maizland 2020, Par. 5). Xi has pushed to reduce barriers between the two, emphasizing what he calls military-civil fusion (Maizland 2020, Par. 5). Much of the PLA’s equipment is now built domestically (Maizland 2020, Par. 5). China is estimated to be the world’s second-largest arms producer, trailing the U.S. and ahead of Russia (Maizland 2020, Par. 5). After decades of primacy and focusing on conflicts in the Middle East, the U.S. is unprepared for the kind of military power China is building (Ioanes 2019, Par. 8). To counter this, the U.S. should study and exploit weaknesses in China’s military strategy (Ioanes 2019, Par. 8). We should also weaken China’s confidence in their own ability to drive the narrative of conflict and weapons developments by showing our own military prowess and understanding of the Chinese strategy (Ioanes 2019, Par. 8). We must also ensure that U.S. technology, strategy, doctrine, and organizations fit together seamlessly to achieve the American desired end state (Ioanes 2019, Par. 8). Despite China’s military buildup, I believe the U.S. will remain on top in terms of military might. The U.S. has historically devoted a larger share of its economy than many of its allies (“U.S. Defense Spending...” 2020, Par. 1). The U.S spends more on national defense than China, India, Russia, Saudi Arabia, France, Germany, U.K, Japan, South Korea, and Brazil— combined (“U.S. Defense Spending...” 2020, Par. 1). Defense spending accounts for 15% of all federal spending and roughly half of discretionary spending (“U.S. Defense Spending...” 2020, Par. 1). China is still in a distant 2nd place when it comes to defense spending. This still does not mean that the U.S. should let their guard down when it comes to military strength. Total discretionary spending—for both defense and nondefense purposes—represents only about 1/3 of the annual federal budget (“U.S. Defense Spending...” 2020, Par. 2). It is currently below its historical average as a share of GDP and is projected to decline further (“U.S. Defense Spending...” 2020, Par. 2).

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: No China Rise › 2NC – Economy

China is growing its economic and military power to exceed the US

Corbiscello 21- (Nick Corbiscello- Graduate from William Paterson University- The National Political Science Honor Society William Paterson. “THE RISE OF CHINA: THE NEW GLOBAL SUPERPOWER” William Patterson University, June 2021, https://www.proquest.com/openview/a3f8e997e50e56eb0ff2695a5f8678da/1?cbl=18750&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar)//mishelle

China’s growing economy, growing political influence in the developing world, growing human rights violations, and growing military might show it is a truly rising power meant to compete with the U.S. The United States must face the music that it is not the sole economic, political, and military hegemon of the world anymore. We have re-entered a bipolar world with two competing global powers. Instead of the Soviet Union during the Cold War, it is now China as the main competitor to the U.S. The difference now is that China possesses more resources that the U.S.S.R never had. This competition is quite different and more complex than the U.S. faced during the Cold War. The U.S. must realize this to prevent itself from falling behind. During the Cold War, if a country instituted a political or economic change contrary to American or Soviet interests, the U.S or U.S.S.R would use political/military intervention to reverse it. For China, they are utilizing their economic influence to force political changes in other countries favorable to Chinese interests. To successfully compete with China, the U.S. must use its existing advancements and improve upon them if it wants to successfully compete with the Chinese. In order to compete with China’s broadening economic and geopolitical ambitions, the U.S. needs to articulate a clearer end game for this competition and a corresponding strategy for arriving there (Kroenig 2020, Par. 2)

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: No China Rise › 2NC – Economy

China is in the process of replacing US as the global economic hegemon

Corbiscello 21- (Nick Corbiscello- Graduate from William Paterson University- The National Political Science Honor Society William Paterson. “THE RISE OF CHINA: THE NEW GLOBAL SUPERPOWER” William Patterson University, June 2021, https://www.proquest.com/openview/a3f8e997e50e56eb0ff2695a5f8678da/1?cbl=18750&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar)//mishelle

One factor that gives evidence of China’s establishment of economic hegemony is their goal of surpassing the United States as the largest economy in terms of nominal gross domestic product (GDP). I believe that China will surpass the nominal GDP of the U.S. GDP refers to the total value of everything produced in a country, regardless of if its citizens or foreigners produced it (Amadeo 2020, Par. 1). It can be calculated 2 ways: nominal or PPP. China has already surpassed the GDP of the U.S. in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP). PPP refers to the comparison of currencies of different countries through a ‘basket of goods’ approach (Hall 2020, Par. 1). According to the concept, 2 currencies are in equilibrium-when a basket of goods is priced the same in both countries, taking into account the exchange rates (Hall 2020, Par. 1). China is on course to be the world’s largest economy by 2030 (Kennedy 2018, Par. 1). According to U.K. based financial services firm, Standard Chartered, the U.S. will drop to 3rd place in the global ranking of the world’s largest economies, falling behind China and India (Paton 2019, Par. 1). The projections suggest China’s GDP will stand at $26 trillion in 2030, up from $14.1 trillion today (Kennedy 2018, Par. 1). The U.S. will see its GDP rise more slowly to $25.2 trillion from $20.4 trillion (Kennedy 2018, Par. 1). China is in the process of replacing the U.S. as the engine of the global economy, providing by far the largest contribution to growth in recent years and pulling along the world’s smaller economies in its train (Kemp 2019, Par. 1). China accounted for 28% of all growth worldwide in the 5 years between 2013 to 2018 (Kemp 2019, Par. 1). This was more than twice the share of the U.S., according to the International Monetary Fund (Kemp 2019, Par. 1). The IMF predicts China will account for a similar share of growth over the next 5 years between 2019 and 2024 (Kemp 2019, Par. 1). China, India, Indonesia, Russia, and Brazil collectively will account for more than half of all global growth through 2024 (Kemp 2019, Par. 2). There is no scenario where the global economy can achieve healthy growth unless these 5 economies, especially China, see their output and incomes rise strongly (Kemp 2019, Par. 2). Between the 1970s and 1990s, it was common to characterize the U.S. as the locomotive of the world economy (Kemp 2019, Par. 3). U.S. fiscal and economic policy usually played a decisive role in the development of the global economic cycle via trade and financial links to smaller countries (Kemp 2019, Par. 3). The U.S. is still important, and the Federal Reserve still remains at the center of global markets (Kemp 2019, Par. 4). Despite this, the U.S. economy is no longer large enough or growing fast enough to act as the sole locomotive for the world economic train (Kemp 2019, Par. 4). China on its own, and the other major emerging markets collectively, are now more important drivers of the global economy (Kemp 2019, Par. 4). China and the other major emerging markets are themselves increasingly interdependent since China is both a major importer of raw materials and supplier of manufactured products and onward investment (Kemp 2019, Par. 4). China’s cyclical position is also important because its rapidly growing middle class is at the stage of economic development where demand for oil, cars, air travel, tourism and other industries is booming (Kemp 2019, Par. 5).

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › AT: No China Rise › 2NC – China First Strike

China’s getting ready to first strike us!

David Sanger and William Broad 22, David E. Sanger is a White House and national security correspondent; William J. Broad is a science journalist and senior writer at The New York Times, “As China Speeds Up Nuclear Arms Race, the U.S. Wants to Talk,” , cy

The Pentagon thinks Beijing may build 1,000 or more weapons by 2030. But it’s the new technologies that worry strategists.

The United States has no nuclear hotline to Beijing. The two countries have never had an in-depth, serious conversation about American missile defenses in the Pacific, or China’s experiments to blind U.S. satellites in time of conflict.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › China Revisionist › 2NC – Ukraine Proves

Ukraine proves China is the core threat to the international order.

Tom McTague 22, staff writer at The Atlantic based in London, 4/4/2022, "The Weakness of the Despot," https://www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/stephen-kotkin-putin-russia-ukraine-stalin, sg

Defenders of the west have a tendency to gaze wistfully at the past, lamenting how far today’s leaders have fallen. Where America and its allies used to build things, create institutions, and win wars, now they seek only to hold ground, conserve what they have, and escape conflicts.

Such nostalgic longing isn’t hard to understand. Immediately after World War II, Europe was in ruins, its industries and infrastructure destroyed. Without American intervention, much more of Europe could well have fallen under Soviet control. But in the space of a few years, the United States financed Europe’s recovery, committed to its defense, and pushed the continent toward ever-closer union. It was an extraordinary age.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › China Revisionist › 2NC – Surveillance

China will never be incorporated into the LIO – surveillance, censorship, human rights violations

Dan Negrea 22, senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, 1/1/2022, "China is the new evil empire," https://spectatorworld.com/topic/china-new-evil-empire/, sg

History does not repeat itself, but it does rhyme. In the 1980s, the gravest threat to America’s freedoms came from the Soviet Union, which President Ronald Reagan called the Evil Empire. That rhymes with today’s equally serious threat from Communist China, the New Evil Empire.

Xi Jinping rules China with absolute power, like an emperor. He has complete control over China’s sole political party, the CCP, the government, the economy, the military, the police, the judiciary, and the media. Even over religion: Christian churches must display Xi quotes instead of the Ten Commandments.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › China Revisionist › 2NC - Navy

Institutional hijacking, covert influence projects, maritime claims.

Michael Schuman 21, contributing writer at The Atlantic, and the author of Superpower Interrupted: The Chinese History of the World and The Miracle: The Epic Story of Asia’s Quest for Wealth, 12/9/2021, "China Wants to Rule the World by Controlling the Rules," https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2021/12/china-wants-rule-world-controlling-rules/620890/, sg

In the U.S. and much of the liberal West, the concept of the “rule of law” is vital to a properly functioning society—the idea (at least in theory) that the law is impartial, independent, and applied evenly and consistently to all, and that it serves to protect the innocent, including from the state. China’s leaders, however, follow the concept of the “rule by law,” in which the legal system is a tool used to assure Communist Party dominance; courts are forums for imposing the government’s will. The state can do just about anything it wants, and then find some helpful language in the “laws” to justify it.

To see these differing perspectives in action, consider the case of Meng Wanzhou, the chief financial officer of the Chinese telecom giant Huawei Technologies, who was arrested in Vancouver in late 2018 on behalf of the U.S. Justice Department, which indicted her for bank fraud. From the American point of view, the case was a matter of law enforcement: The Justice Department accused Meng of lying to a major international bank about Huawei’s business in Iran, causing financial transactions that violated Washington’s sanctions on that country. Prosecutors were vindicated when Meng confirmed the substance of the case in an agreement reached in September that allowed her to avoid a U.S. trial and return to China.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › China Revisionist › 2NC – Generic

Beijing is actively repositioning economic and governmental priorities towards a new Chinese led order.

TarıK OğUzlu 19, Associate Professor in the Department of International Relations at Bilkent University with a Ph.D. degree in IR, 7/23/2019, "Understanding China's challenge to the international order," https://www.dailysabah.com/op-ed/2019/07/23/understanding-chinas-challenge-to-the-international-order, sg

The liberal world order, which came into being at the end of World War II under American leadership, has been going through a radical transformation in recent years mostly owing to China's spectacular rise. In parallel to its increasing material power capability, China is also posing fundamental challenges to the normative fabric of the liberal world order.

What are the key characteristics of China's challenge to the liberal world order and whether the growing confrontation between the established hegemon, the United States, and the aspiring hegemon, China, will result in the global Armageddon requires serious attention.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › China Revisionist › 2NC – Generic

China is joining international initiatives to destroy the order them from the inside.

Malcolm Jorgensen 20, Research Associate and Lecturer at Leuphana University of Lüneburg and a Non-Resident Fellow of the Kolleg-Forschergruppe, 8/1/2020, "China is overturning the rules-based order from within," https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/china-overturning-rules-based-order-within, sg

Persistent debates over the meaning of the “liberal” or “rules-based” international order demonstrate a point of agreement among scholars and policymakers: the real power of the concept when employed as a metaphor for a disrupted global order.

Less well understood in comparison is the architecture of the order as a hierarchy of rules, with the most authoritative and determinate being the rules of international law at its foundation. That structure demonstrates the flaw in frequent reassurances that China’s contestation of basic rules of international law shows a commitment to work within rather than “overturn” the order. By subverting the meaning of the most foundational rules on which the order is based, China may already be overturning the order from within.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Strategic Stability

Nuclear war – East Asia is uniquely escalatory

Hal Brands 17; PhD in History @ Yale, Henry A. Kissinger Distinguished Professor of Global Affairs at the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies, Senior Fellow at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments and the Foreign Policy Research Institute. Peter D. Feaver – PhD @ Harvard, Professor of Political Science and Public Policy at Duke University, Director of the Triangle Institute for Security Studies, Director of the Duke Program in American Grand Strategy, “What Are America’s Alliances Good For?,” Summer 2017, The US Army War College Quarterly Parameters, https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=803998

Similarly, US alliance guarantees in the Asia-Pacific were designed, in part, to create a climate of security in which Japan could be revived economically without threatening its neighbors, just as the expansion of NATO after the Cold War helped prevent incipient rivalries and territorial irredentism among former members of the Warsaw Pact.41 US alliances keep things quiet in regions Washington cannot ignore, thereby fostering a climate of peace in which America and its partners can flourish. Fourth, US alliances impede dangerous geostrategic phenomena such as nuclear proliferation. As scholars such as Francis Gavin have emphasized, US security guarantees and forward deployments have played a critical role in convincing historically insecure, technologically advanced countries—Germany, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, among others—to forego possession of the world’s absolute weapon. In several of these cases, moreover, the United States has used the security leverage provided by alliance guarantees to dissuade allies from pursuing the bomb after they had given indications of their intent to start down that path.42 If, as seems likely, a world with more nuclear powers is likely to be a more dangerous world in which crises more frequently take on a nuclear dimension and the risk of nuclear conflict is higher, then the value of American alliances looms large indeed. In sum, as the framers of the post-World War II order understood, phenomena such as massive instability, arms racing, and violence in key regions would eventually imperil the United States itself.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Strategic Stability

Waiting causes a Chinese race to parity – that collapses strategic stability and east Asian alliances

Bradley A. Thayer 20 (Thayer is professor of political science at the University of Texas, San Antonio, and co-author of “How China Sees the World: Han-Centrism and the Balance of Power in International Politics.” “Get Ready For a New Arms Race: Why Nuclear Strategic Stability Won’t Work With China”, The National Interest, may 21, 2020, https://nationalinterest.org/feature/get-ready-new-arms-race-why-nuclear-strategic-stability-won%E2%80%99t-work-china-156676)

First, while the common estimate of China’s nuclear weapons is approximately three hundred, due to China’s lack of transparency, it is possible that China has significantly more than this estimate. This month, there have been calls within China for expanding its nuclear arsenal to one thousand strategic warheads, to say nothing of nuclear weapons on intermediate-range or other forces. While the United States has taken a “strategic holiday,” the People’s Republic of China (PRC) has used the opportunity to expand their arsenals, as well as cyber and conventional capabilities. When one reflects upon the considerable effort to create strategic systems, as well as cyber and conventional capabilities, inescapable conclusions are, first, that the causes of their expansion is rooted in their own grand strategic objectives of achieving hegemony and, second, the decision to expand their forces was sown long ago. China has used our strategic passivity to expand.  What Reagan’s Secretary of Defense Casper Weinberger said in the Soviet context remains true today: "When we build, they build, when we stop, they build.”  The growth of Chinese arsenals cannot be divorced from other evidence of China’s expansion. They are expanding their bases, for example, in Djibouti and Gwadar, and alliance networks including through the Belt and Road Initiative and “debt diplomacy,” the creation of new international institutions to supplant extant ones, and aggressive intelligence operations.  These measures indicate that China is a non-status quo great power but is a revisionist—and one that seeks change immediately. This bodes ill for strategic stability. Most concerning is that China’s build-up might allow it to race to parity or superiority with the United States, which would result in an intense arms race. China’s actions make it a threat to strategic stability. To maintain strategic stability requires modernizing U.S. strategic systems, including missile defenses, and conventional capabilities.  Not to do so invites a direct and existential strategic challenge to the security of our allies and ourselves. Second, the form of China’s build-up is notable. Always secretive, the Chinese have occluded their nuclear expansion as they do not want to provoke a premature reaction from the United States or its allies. More damning is that the Chinese are secretly “preparing the battlefield” to ensure that they have the ability to damage the United States through other, nonnuclear, means. These nonnuclear avenues of attack include cyber, control of space, supply chain dominance, economic influence, technological mastery of 5G and increasingly artificial intelligence, soft power, and the continued legal and illegal access to America’s knowledge, intellectual property, finance, and technology to facilitate Beijing’s growth. This would ensure the United States could be damaged sufficiently—in effect, a near equivalent of a major nuclear attack—to cause U.S. political leaders to yield in a crisis or limited war without the employment of nuclear weapons. China might launch one or more cyber attacks on the electrical grid and on the ability of the United States to recover and rebuild its electrical grid after a significant cyber attack. This is likely to be a direct attack in the cyber realm but the damage might also be inadvertent due to the unintended consequences of an attack against another target. Moreover, the risks of electromagnetic pulse (EMP) to the U.S. electrical grid is also a possibility. The vulnerability of America electricity to EMP—whether from deliberate EMP attack, cyber attack, or solar activity—and the ability to recover the electrical grid in the wake of an event is an issue that must be solved now.  Third, China rejects arms control in practice and in principle. Thus far, Beijing will not unilaterally reduce or limit its arsenal or enter into arms control talks. That is a worrisome sign and suggests that U.S. assumptions about the causes of stability in a great power relationship are only its own, and not shared by China. A major objective of arms control is that it can promote stability in the relations between states. The state willingly abandons or limits a class of weapons to demonstrate to other actors that its ambitions are limited and it supports strategic stability. By entering an arms control regime, China could show that it accepts the value of arms control and seeks confidence-building measures, which aids stability while demonstrating that China is a status quo power. Fundamentally, it would allow China to signal its peaceful intentions, and, in turn, have an important stabilizing effect on states concerned with China’s increasing power. The fact that China rejects arms control is troubling and suggests, first, it is a revisionist power, and second, that it wants to be unfettered as it expands its arsenal. These developments mean that strategic stability is unlikely to obtain. China is likely to race for superiority, and that is destabilizing, and the United States must ensure this never occurs and must prepare itself for the return of an arms race. Given the PRC’s unprecedented expansion, the United States must respond by modernizing its capabilities to deter them from threatening the homeland, U.S. military, and its alliance commitments. These are critical steps to deter them from the temptation to race to parity or superiority, which could result in the collapse of U.S. credibility and alliances. Lastly, the United States must ensure that its vulnerability to non-nuclear forms of major economic and societal damage to the U.S. homeland is addressed.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Strategic Stability

They’re on the cusp of second-strike capabilities – it’s now or never!

John A. Tirpak 21, Editorial Director of Air Force Magazine, 11-3-2021, "China’s Nuclear Development Outstrips Predictions; 1,000 Warheads by 2030," , cy

China is building new nuclear weapons much faster than previously predicted, already has a “nascent nuclear triad,” and will field more than 1,000 nuclear warheads by 2030, according to the Pentagon’s 2021 report on China’s military power, released Nov. 3.

According to a Pentagon briefing paper highlighting changes from the 2020 edition of the report, “the accelerating pace of the [People’s Republic of China’s] nuclear expansion may enable [it] to have up to 700 deliverable nuclear warheads by 2027, … [and] at least 1,000 warheads by 2030, exceeding the pace and size” that the Defense Department previously projected. China is also shifting to a “launch on warning” posture for its nuclear weapons.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Lasers

That erases all hope for life in the universe.

Sebastian Kettley 21, 6-29-2021, "'Bubble of doom' Cosmologist explains vacuum decay," , cy

The Universe is going to end one day, that much is certain, though scientists still argue over how it will happen. One theory suggests the world will end in "heat death" - a state in which the Universe becomes too cold to sustain life. Other hypothetical models predict the Universe will literally tear itself apart at the subatomic level in the "Big Rip", driven by dark energy and the expansion of space.

Another interesting theory about the end of the world has been given some credence in recent years after physicists discovered the elementary Higgs Boson particle at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN in 2012.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Lasers

China is on the brink of developing super lasers – they’ll break the quantum vacuum literally next year.

Dave Makichuk 21, veteran writer and copy-editor with 35 years' media experience, 5-12-2021, "China on brink of laser-matter breakthrough," , cy

Nuclear weapons have already shown that it is possible to convert matter into large amounts of heat and light, but doing it the other way around, converting heat and light into matter, is much more difficult — but this is exactly what laboratories in China and the UK hope to achieve.

If the intended objective is reached, it could open up a whole a new branch of physics, called nuclear photonics, full of technological potentialities still unimaginable.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Neg › War Now > War Better › 2NC – Hypersonics

Chinese hypersonic development ensures World War 3.

Brandon J Weichert 21, author of Winning Space: How America Remains a Superpower, 10-18-2021, "China’s high-tech weapons out-fly America’s alliances," , cy

Beijing, meanwhile, has been undeterred by these Western machinations.

Contrary to what Washington thinks, China’s primary threat is economic and technological. Its military is starting to achieve parity with the West in key areas. Yet the focus in China for challenging the West continues to be all measures short of war.