Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---AT: Not CYBERCOM

CYBERCOM oversees all cyber operations, including with allies.

Todd Lopez 19, DOD News, 5/14/19, “Persistent Engagement, Partnerships, Top Cybercom’s Priorities,” https://www.defense.gov/Explore/News/Article/Article/1847823/persistent-engagement-partnerships-top-cybercoms-priorities/, Marsh

Persistent engagement also involves persistent presence -- the sharing of information to enable partners -- and persistent innovation of technology and techniques with partners that include other government agencies, allied nations and industry, Luber said. Both are critical to Cybercom’s success as it moves into its second year.

Persistent Engagement With Persistent Force

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---AT: Not CYBERCOM

CYBERCOM is normal means for cybersecurity cooperation with NATO.

CYBERCOM 20, U.S. Cyber Command, 12/03/2020, “Estonia, U.S. Conduct Joint Defensive Cyber Operation,” https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/2434474/estonia-us-conduct-joint-defensive-cyber-operation/, cc

U.S. Cyber Command, in cooperation with U.S. European Command and NATO allies, continuously works to deter malicious cyber activity in the region.

The two countries have ongoing cooperation at various levels within Cybercom, U.S. European Command, the Maryland National Guard and the Sixteenth Air Force — U.S. Air Forces Cyber.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---AT: Not CYBERCOM

Recent Security Cooperation with NATO allies proves.

DoD News 18, 10/2/2018, “U.S., Montenegro conduct groundbreaking cyber defense cooperation,” https://www.cybercom.mil/Media/News/News-Display/Article/1651540/us-montenegro-conduct-groundbreaking-cyber-defense-cooperation/, Marsh

U.S. Cyber Command, in cooperation with U.S. European Command, has worked closely with partners from Macedonia in conducting Cyber Defense Security Cooperation to increase interoperability and deter malign influence on the democratic processes of the U.S., our allies and our partners.

“This is part of an ongoing effort to support NATO allies and European partners by building their cyber defense capabilities while learning from one another,” said a U.S. Cyber Command spokesperson. “These efforts serve to deter foreign malign influence on the democratic processes of our allies, partners, and the U.S.”

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---AT: Not CYBERCOM

Title 10 cyber ops are led by CYBERCOM.

Keith Alexander 10, former commander of United States Cyber Command, 9/23/2010, “U.S. CYBER COMMAND: ORGANIZING FOR CYBERSPACE OPERATIONS,” https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-111hhrg62397/html/CHRG-111hhrg62397.htm, cc

General Alexander. Well, for the--for the Title 10, they operate under the CYBERCOM hand. Cyber Command operates under Title 10 authorities to this committee, the House Armed Services Committee.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---General

Resources are finite.

Joseph Marks 17, Senior Correspondent for Nextgov, 5/23/17, “CYBERCOM Budget Request Focused on Elevation to Full Command”, https://www.nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2017/05/cybercom-budget-request-focused-elevation-full-command/138109/, Marsh

Outdated computer and technology systems across DOD and the services make the military vulnerable to cyberattacks, Rogers said, partly because defense acquisition has historically prioritized purchasing new weapons systems, ships, planes and other hardware over shoring up cyber vulnerabilities in existing systems.

“In a world of finite resources, you’ve got to make those resource tradeoffs,” Rogers said, “and in general, the acquisition world hasn’t historically always been incentivized for cybersecurity outcomes as its primary metric.” 

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---General

No link turns---even creative ways of garnering funds trigger the link.

Allan Friedman 11, Fellow and Research Director, Center for Technology Innovation The Brookings Institution, 3/16/2011, “Defense Challenges and Future Operations,” The 21st Century Defense Initiative’s Second Annual Military and Federal Fellow Research Symposium, https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/20110316_defense_challenges_panel_2.pdf, Marsh

Besides these characteristics, there are some constraints that impact DOD's command-and-control in cyberspace. First of all is personnel. It is a relatively small pool of cyber-experts within DOD. So trying to divide those up and place them all around the world dilutes the pool, and dilutes efficiencies.

Secondly, for the most part, personnel is a zero-sum game. If you want to create more cyber wars, you've got to take it from somewhere else. We're not going to expect to see an increase in N-strength within DOD, personnel N-strength, in order to make up a cyber force. While DOD may come up with some creative ways to bring on some civilians and Reserve Guard capability, there's still a cost there that will affect the choice of a command-and-control structure.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Link---General

CYBERCOM resources are zero-sum---new programs sacrifice old ones.

Erica Lonergan 21, Assistant Professor in the Army Cyber Institute and a Research Scholar in the Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies at Columbia University; and Lauren Zabierek, Executive Director of the Cyber Project at Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center, 12/16/2021, “Cyber Command Is in the Ransomware Game—Now What?,” https://www.lawfareblog.com/cyber-command-ransomware-game%E2%80%94now-what, cc

Finally, over the summer we warned about the twin risks of mission creep and prioritization against a backdrop of finite resources and personnel to tackle the diverse and growing set of missions that have fallen within Cyber Command’s purview. How trade-offs will be made between new activities, like counter-ransomware operations, and existing missions remains underspecified. In fact, this issue was implicit in Nakasone’s remarks; at the same time that he discussed the military’s role in ransomware, he also highlighted its role in election defense and conveyed that Cyber Command was already preparing to defend the inevitable next round of election interference. This begs the question: What is being sacrificed or put on the backburner when the military is used to counter ransomware, and what is the process that governs decision-making around shifting prioritizations?

As we argued in our previous post, there is a compelling case for the military to get involved in counter-ransomware operations that reach the threshold of significant risk to national security—and we stand by that argument. However, making this case demands greater transparency and clarity around how military authorities and resources are utilized, and how they relate to other governmental authorities and capabilities. As military cyber operations are possibly ongoing, as we brace for the likelihood of further attacks, and as the cyber force is likely to grow, now is the time to address these concerns.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Uniqueness---Ukraine

Ukraine ops were small-scale AND shrouded in secrecy---can’t vote for a thumper you know nothing about!

Sean Lyngaas 6/2, CNN’s cybersecurity reporter, 6/02/2022, “US confirms military hackers have conducted cyber operations in support of Ukraine,” , cc

"We've conducted a series of operations across the full spectrum; offensive, defensive, [and] information operations," General Paul Nakasone said in an interview with Sky News. A spokesperson for the command did not dispute the accuracy of the article but declined to elaborate on what the command's operations in Ukraine have entailed.

It's a rare public acknowledgment from US military officials of hacking operations that are often shrouded in mystery.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Uniqueness---Resources

CYBERCOM has enough resources to operate.

Joshua Rovner 20, John Goodwin Tower Professor of International Politics and National Security at Southern Methodist University John Goodwin Tower Professor of International Politics and National Security at Southern Methodist University, 9/14/2020, “More Aggressive and Less Ambitious: Cyber Command’s Evolving Approach,” https://warontherocks.com/2020/09/more-aggressive-and-less-ambitious-cyber-commands-evolving-approach/, Marsh

This year, U.S. Cyber Command celebrated its tenth birthday. It has much to celebrate: It achieved the status of a unified combatant command, its budget is healthy, and its commander, Gen. Paul Nakasone, is popular on both sides of the aisle. Nakasone’s more aggressive posture in cyberspace — what the command calls persistent engagement — has won the support of policymakers and legislators who wanted to see action against those who had been targeting U.S. interests. Before, U.S. cyber forces had shown restraint even in the face of repeated cyber attacks. Now, they will reach out into cyberspace to discover and mitigate threats before they could reach U.S. networks and damage U.S. interests.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Uniqueness---Resources

They’re gaining more autonomy now but skate on thin ice.

Lauren Williams 22, Senior Editor at FCW, 3/30/2022, “Cyber Command’s acquisition growing pains,” https://fcw.com/acquisition/2022/03/cyber-commands-acquisition-growing-pains/363836/, Marsh

U.S. Cyber Command is still getting its footing when it comes to steering acquisitions, but more resources are needed especially as the command gains more autonomy over its buying and budget power. 

A Government Accountability Office report released March 30 found that while the command responsible for DOD’s cyberspace operations has matured its Joint Cyber Warfighting Architecture, it doesn’t yet have the metrics needed to justify acquisitions of new capabilities. 

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 2NC---Uniqueness---Resources

CYBERCOM’s budget is tight, but sufficient to cover its current tasks.

Michael S. Rogers 18, former United States Navy admiral who served as the second commander of the United States Cyber Command giving a statement for a House Hearing, “HEARING ON NATIONAL DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2018 AND OVERSIGHT OF PREVIOUSLY AUTHORIZED PROGRAMS BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON ARMED SERVICES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTEENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION,” https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-115hhrg25869/html/CHRG-115hhrg25869.htm, cc

As we begin the process of looking at the 2018 budget, I am interested to know to what extent you were able to factor in strategy and threats and sort of strategic thinking about what needs to be done as you put together the budget for Cyber Command and to what extent you have still been hamstrung by the BCA and by those cap numbers.

Admiral Rogers. So like any entity, it is all about prioritization for us. So we spend a lot of time figuring out with finite resources, even with growth, with finite resources how are we going to prioritize.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 1NC CYBERCOM DA

Democracy solves extinction

Daniel Twining 21, PhD and President of the IRI, 10/10/2021, “America must double down on democracy,” https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/575693-america-must-double-down-on-democracy?rl=1, Marsh

Democracy is under assault. China and Russia are pursuing strategic campaigns to undermine liberal values and U.S. leadership. Authoritarians from Belarus to Burma brutalize their citizens to stay in power. The debacle of U.S. troop withdrawal from Afghanistan and our national soul-searching in the wake of the 20th anniversary of 9/11 led some to wonder if support for democracy should remain a component of American foreign policy. 

The hard truth is that a world that is less free is one that is less secure, stable and prosperous.  The greatest dangers to the American way of life emanate from hostile autocracies. There are no quick fixes, but the best antidotes to the challenges of great-power conflict, terrorism and mass migration of desperate refugees lie in the building of inclusive democratic institutions — and working with allied democracies to sustain the free and open order that China, in particular, wishes to replace with a world that’s safe for autocracy.  

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 1NC CYBERCOM DA

Election integrity is vital to democracy---maintaining robust cyber defense and resources is key.

Carrie Cordero 20, Robert M. Gates Senior Fellow and General Counsel at CNAS, 11/12/2020, “How Cybersecurity Saved U.S. Democracy,” https://www.cnas.org/publications/commentary/how-cybersecurity-saved-u-s-democracy, Marsh

According to a 12 November 2020 joint statement of U.S. election officials, the 2020 U.S. presidential election “was the most secure in American history.” That success was a result not of accident, but instead of deliberate, sustained, and comprehensive efforts at the local, state, and federal levels to ensure that it was secure from foreign interference. Those efforts to secure the election were borne out of the attempts by the Russian government to influence the outcome of the 2016 U.S. presidential election. In the end, however, the efforts to enhance the cybersecurity of the U.S. electoral infrastructure in 2020 ended up protecting the integrity of the election not only from malign foreign activities, but also from domestic anti-democratic and illiberal efforts to undermine confidence in the 2020 presidential election.

In 2020, the threats compounded as compared to 2016.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 1NC CYBERCOM DA

The plan trades-off and hinders future cyber developments.

Ben FitzGerald 14, adjunct senior fellow at CNAS; Lt Col. Parker Right some military bro, 4/1/2014, “Digital Theaters: Decentralizing Cyber Command and Control,” Center for a New American Security, pp 16-18, JSTOR, Marsh

Meeting military service cyber requirements is key to sustaining critical service investment in the development of cyber capability. The military services provide the trained cyber forces that USCYBERCOM employs. Although part of the joint cyber team, the services nonetheless expect that their service requirements and those of their service components at the combatant commands will be met in kind with their joint force contribution. If service cyber requirements are underserviced, the services will question their investment. For the services, cyber is a zero-sum game. Every additional unit of cyber costs them another unit of capacity elsewhere in the force. A theater cyber C2 structure that obscures service contributions or weakens the link between the service, its operational cyber units and its various service component requirements risks losing service interest and investment in developing cyber.

2022 Michigan Negative
CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › CYBERCOM Tradeoff DA › 1NC CYBERCOM DA

CYBERCOM is securing election integrity now, but resources are key.

Malbot 5/5, Malware News, 5/05/2022, “Nakasone to remain at helm of NSA, Cyber Command for at least one more year,” https://malware.news/t/nakasone-to-remain-at-helm-of-nsa-cyber-command-for-at-least-one-more-year/59887, Marsh

The command, in particular, saw its authorities and responsibilities greatly expanded by the Trump administration and Congress.

Most notably, Cyber Command — backed by intelligence from the NSA — has taken a central role in keeping U.S. elections free of foreign interference. In 2018, the military launched a campaign called Operation Synthetic Technology to protect the midterm elections that year.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Midterms DA › AFF – AT: 7 states

Beasley will win North Carolina

Crowd Wisdom 7-25 (In-depth Analysis and Insights on Election Polls, Crypto Price Predictions, Stock Forecasts and Sports Odds. “2022 North Carolina Senate Race Polls: Cheri Beasley to win North Carolina Senate Race?”,

North Carolina Senate Primary 2022 Date The North Carolina Senate Race will be held on November 8th, 2022 to elect the representative. The Primaries were due to be held on May 17th, but a ruling by the North Carolina Supreme Court has delayed them indefinitely over a challenge to the congressional maps passed by the GOP-held legislature earlier in 2021. The Current incumbent of North Carolina is Richard Burr, who will not seek another term in 2022. The maps are being challenged by Democratic-aligned groups partisan and racial gerrymanders. In the last decade, North Carolina’s map was struck down 3 times so this is not without precedent. 2022 North Carolina Senate Race Polls: Google Search Data Google Trends has turned out to be one of the efficient tools for forecasting an election. The latest trends are highly in the favor of Cheri Beasley. Ted Budd has to up his ante to stop Cheri Beasley’s Juggernaut. Democratic vote strength comes from minorities and urban areas especially the research triangle and the Charlotte metro area. Joe Biden won Mecklenburg county – home to 1.1m people – by 35 points, while Clinton only won it by 29. Republican strength is centered in the exurban county around Charlotte and Sandhill area.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Midterms DA › AFF – AT: 7 states

Dems win New Hampshire – Republicans don’t even have a contender

Treene 7-18 (Alayna Treene, is a congressional reporter at Axios. She is a co-author of the weekly Axios Sneak Peek newsletter and covers Capitol Hill, the Biden administration and elections. “Maggie Hassan's lucky break”, https://www.axios.com/2022/07/19/new-hampshire-maggie-hassan-senate-republicans)LR

Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-N.H.) was initially seen as one of the most vulnerable Senate Democrats up for re-election this year. But as New Hampshire's Sept. 13 primary draws closer, there's still no clear Republican frontrunner to take her on in November. Why it matters: The GOP establishment's failure to coalesce around one viable candidate after its initial favorite — New Hampshire's current Gov. Chris Sununu — decided not to enter the race has helped clear the way for Democratic incumbent. "Sununu's decision to forego the Senate race turned the race from a slam dunk into a coin toss," Ken Spain, a Republican strategist and former GOP campaign official, told Axios. "New Hampshire falls into the growing category of races where Republicans are relying on the political environment to carry some of their candidates across the finish line." Driving the news: Hassan raised $5 million in the second quarter of 2022, with roughly $7 million in the bank, according to her campaign. That's more than five times the combined amount raised by the three main Republican candidates backed by the GOP establishment: Chuck Morse, president of the New Hampshire Senate; Kevin Smith, former director of a conservative advocacy group, and Don Bolduc, a retired Army general. Morse in particular has been name-dropped by Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) and Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.), chair of Senate Republicans' campaign arm. By the numbers: The leading Republicans in the primary all raised less in the second quarter of 2022 than they did in the first quarter. Morse’s campaign raised $538,000 in Q2, $100,000 of which he personally gave to his campaign, according to his latest FEC filing. That's more than $200,000 less than what he brought in during Q1. Morse has $975,000 cash on hand. Smith raised $318,000 in Q2, nearly $100,000 less than last quarter. He has roughly $349,000 cash on hand. Bolduc raised $84,000 in Q2, roughly $15,000 less than what he raised in Q1. His campaign has $65,000 in the bank. Meanwhile, Bitcoin millionaire Bruce Fenton is leading in Q2 fundraising numbers, but that's because he donated more than $1 million to his campaign. He raised roughly $20,000 in Q2 and has more than $1.6 million cash on hand. Vikram Mansharamanni, a businessman, brought in the second highest Q2 total. He raised $831,000, roughly $250,000 of which he personally contributed. The bottom line: "The race depends on a couple of things. One is, do the Republicans nominate an electable candidate? And there's no guarantee that that would happen," Tom Rath, former attorney general of New Hampshire and adviser to several GOP presidential candidates, tells Axios.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Midterms DA › AFF – AT: 7 states

Nevada – Cortez will win by narrow margin

Lemon 6/16 (Jason, BA in Spanish Studies and Liberal Studies @ Andrews University. MA in Media Studies @ America University of Beirut. “Adam Laxalt's Chances of Beating Catherine Cortez Masto in Nevada: Polls”, https://www.newsweek.com/adam-laxalts-chances-beating-catherine-cortez-masto-nevada-polls-1716584)LR

Former Nevada Attorney General Adam Laxalt, a Republican, aims to unseat Democratic Senator Catherine Cortez Masto to flip her seat red in November, and recent polls show a potentially close race. Laxalt, who was endorsed by former President Donald Trump, won the GOP primary on Tuesday with well over 50 percent of the vote. Meanwhile, Cortez Masto handily beat her Democratic opponents with about 90 percent support. Recent polls suggest the incumbent has an edge in the race, but Nevada has been leaning toward the GOP, giving Republicans hope of winning the seat in November's midterm race. Polling and news analysis site FiveThirtyEight's average of recent polls for the Nevada Senate contest gives Cortez Masto a 4.3 percent lead. The Democrat has the support of about 43.4 percent of Nevada voters, compared with approximately 39.1 percent who back Laxalt. Meanwhile, FiveThirtyEight also assesses that Nevada has a 2.5-point lean in favor of Republicans, compared with the rest of the country. However, the most recent poll carried out in Nevada shows Cortez Masto with a wide double-digit lead over her Trump-backed challenger. The survey, conducted by the University of Nevada, Reno from May 17 to 27, showed the Democrat 21 points ahead of Laxalt. Cortez Masto was backed by 48 percent of respondents, compared with just 27 percent who supported the Republican contender. The poll had a margin of error of plus or minus 3.5 percent and surveyed 1,048 Nevadans. An early-April poll by Reno Gazette-Journal/Suffolk showed Laxalt leading Cortez Masto by 3 points. The survey of 500 likely voters had the Republican at 43 percent and the Democrat at just 40 percent. It had a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 percent. Another April survey, from The Nevada Independent and OH Predictive Insights, showed Cortez Masto in the lead by 8 points. The Democrat had the backing of 43 percent of registered voters, compared with 35 percent who supported Laxalt. The poll included 748 registered voters and had a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 points.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Midterms DA › AFF – AT: 7 states

GOP loses Georgia lol – Warnock will win again

Murphy, Bluestein, and Mitchell 7-25 (Patricia Murphy joined the AJC’s politics team in 2020 from CQ Roll Call, where she was a nationally syndicated political columnist. Previously, she was the Capitol Hill Bureau Chief for Politics Daily, founder and editor of Citizen Jane Politics, and a contributor to The Washington Post’s She the People blog. Before working in journalism, Patricia was a staffer for three senators. She graduated from Vanderbilt University and holds a master’s degree in journalism from Columbia University. Greg Bluestein is a political reporter and author who covers the governor's office and Georgia politics for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. He writes for the front-page of the AJC, contributes to the Political Insider blog and morning Jolt newsletter, hosts the Politically Georgia podcast and is a frequent guest on local and national TV and radio programs. He's an MSNBC and NBC News contributor and the author of "Flipped," a book on Georgia's epic 2020 election. He's a proud graduate of the University of Georgia with degrees in journalism and political science. Tia Mitchell is the AJC’s Washington correspondent. In this role, she writes about Georgia’s congressional delegation, campaigns, elections and the impact that decisions made in D.C. have on residents of the Peach State. Before that, she served as the AJC’s DeKalb County reporter. Prior to joining the paper in 2017, Tia spent her entire career in Florida covering local and state government for publications like the Tampa Bay Times and The Florida Times-Union. Tia is a graduate of Florida A&M University and is originally from Louisville, Ky. She currently serves as chair of the Political Task Force for the National Association of Black Journalists. “The Jolt: Sen. Raphael Warnock keeps distance from Joe Biden as president’s ratings sink”, https://www.ajc.com/politics/politics-blog/the-jolt-sen-raphael-warnock-keeps-distance-from-joe-biden-as-presidents-ratings-sink/IXWQC3Z4MVBKTFNVNDTV2A4SWI/)LR

With President Joe Biden’s approval rating in Georgia hovering in the low 30’s, Democrats and Republicans know tying U.S. Sen. Raphael Warnock to Biden and the White House is GOP Senate hopeful Herschel Walker’s best bet to win in November. That may be why Warnock is taking new steps to put daylight between himself and Biden’s administration. The senator’s weekend rally in southwest Atlanta offered only the latest example. At the event, he stressed his bipartisan work with the likes of Republican U.S. Sens. Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio and Tommy Tuberville. As he’s said at other rallies, “I’ll work with anyone to get things done for Georgia.” But he drew a finer line when our AJC colleague Shannon McCaffrey pressed him after the event on whether he thinks Biden is doing a good job as president. Warnock, who campaigned on a promise to promote Biden’s agenda, essentially deflected when asked about his performance. “I’m focused on the job that I’m doing standing up for the people of Georgia,” Warnock said. He repeated himself when asked a second time. “I am standing up for the people of Georgia. I’m going to fight for them every single day. When that means standing with this person, it’s based on what it does for Georgia.” It’s not the first time Warnock has distanced himself from the administration. He helped buck a White House plan earlier this year to close a Savannah military installation and has pressed Biden to forgive student debt. He also badgered Biden to support a proposed federal gas tax holiday after months of lobbying. Clearly, the prospect of Walker dodging another debate — he refused to participate in showdowns ahead of the GOP primary — is one that Warnock‘s campaign expects to come back to haunt the Republican.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Midterms DA › AFF – AT: 7 states

Arizona deadlocked between same party face off, dooms GOP win

Rehighlight Medina, or say Medina concedes party divides

Smith 7-22 (Allan Smith is a political reporter for NBC News. B.S in Journalism @ Ohio University. “Arizona's GOP governor primary brawl tries to define the 'real' Republican”,

QUEEN CREEK, Ariz. — The closing days of Arizona’s close, contentious GOP primary for governor have turned into an all-out slugfest over which candidate is the most authentically Republican. Kari Lake, a former newscaster backed by former President Donald Trump, says opponent Karrin Taylor Robson’s unwillingness to fully embrace Trump’s stolen election lie makes her the RINO, or “Republican in name only.” Taylor Robson, a real estate developer who worked in former President Ronald Reagan’s White House, says it’s Lake who’s the fake, given her more recent turn to hard-line Trumpism. While it’s hardly new for a GOP primary to feature allegations of being a “RINO,” or for candidates to litigate issues of political authenticity, the contest provides one of the purest tests yet of how highly Republican voters prize fealty to Trump and allegiance to his claims of a stolen election. More broadly, the contest will reveal who can credibly lay claim to the mantle of “Republican” in a party where Trump is still the most dominant and influential figure. It’s a debate playing out not just in Arizona, but nationwide and tested in primaries spanning from state Senate contests to congressional races. Here in the Grand Canyon State, one that has reliably elected Republicans to statewide office for decades but in which Democrats have recently turned their fortunes around, how the conservative mantle is defined could go a long way in determining which party controls the governor’s mansion in what is now a critical presidential swing state. Former Rep. Matt Salmon, an Arizona Republican who ran for governor but dropped out and endorsed Taylor Robson last month, said after a recent Taylor Robson campaign event here that Lake and Taylor Robson are both talking about similar issues like undocumented immigration, inflation and supporting law enforcement on the stump, but Lake is building her case for being a true Republican solely off of her stance on 2020, hoping voters ignore other contradictions from her past. “But what people are looking for is, ‘OK, who’s the real deal?’” Salmon, a co-founder of the House Freedom Caucus, said. “And you got one candidate that says that they had a born-again experience, a come-to-Jesus moment, and now is the most conservative thing since sliced bread. The problem is, you can’t find one conservative thing that candidate ever did before she announced her governorship.” Whether Lake or Taylor Robson is successful in convincing more voters that they are the true Republican will have major implications for both Trump’s standing in the party and his continued efforts to overhaul how elections are conducted in one of the most pivotal presidential swing states. The Arizona primary is the latest in a series of high-stakes gubernatorial contests taking place in states he needs to win in 2024 and where he has sought to make 2020 the defining issue of the campaign. So far he’s had mixed results. But her standing as a conservative has been increasingly called into question as years-old social media clips and photos that contradict positions she now takes have surfaced. Taylor Robson calls her a “fake” and an “actress.” Taylor Robson, who polling suggests is within striking distance, is winning over more traditional Republicans in the state and has the backing of Republican Gov. Doug Ducey and former Vice President Mike Pence. (Pence and Trump are holding dueling Arizona rallies for their preferred candidates Friday.) Her path to victory is twofold: convincing enough voters who worry Lake won’t govern as she promises to come join her side while maintaining a more moderate base that is worried Lake will. But in recent weeks, Taylor Robson and other conservatives have highlighted a number of past positions and statements that don’t line up with how Lake is campaigning now. A donor to former President Barack Obama’s first presidential campaign, Lake, who has repeatedly cast doubt on the legitimacy of her state’s elections, expressed support for voting by cell phone in 2016. Now attacking “the transgender movement” and “woke gender activists,” Lake previously offered sympathetic views of gender transition as a reporter, calling one story “inspiring.” And though she has blasted drag performers as dangerous for kids, a local drag queen said Lake allowed her daughter to attend a drag show. (Lake’s campaign said the drag queen was performing as an impersonator rather than in drag.)