Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Economy

Post-COVID collapse wrecks geopolitical dominance---that triggers global conflict, EU collapse, and Chinese authoritarian dominance

Kempe 20, best-selling author, prize-winning journalist and president & CEO of the Atlantic Council, one of the United States’ most influential think tanks on global affairs. He worked at The Wall Street Journal for more than 25 years as a foreign correspondent, assistant managing editor and as the longest-serving editor of the paper’s European edition. (Frederick, Updated: 4-21-2021, “Op-ed: How the US can win the post-coronavirus race for global dominance,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/18/op-ed-how-us-can-win-the-post-coronavirus-race-for-global-dominance.html)

Place your bets for the coming race to growth. It will be an epic contest among the world’s most significant economies, with generational and geopolitical consequences. For context, think back to what the United States accomplished after World War II, when it rose as an economic power to shape a better world. The post-COVID19 race could determine whether the U.S. rebounds in a manner that allows it to retain the mantle of global leadership. More likely for the moment, Beijing could leverage its first-mover advantage – alongside a faster economic recovery across Asian markets – accelerating the trend toward a Chinese-centric globalization. Elsewhere, as President Macron this week to the Financial Times, the coming months could determine whether the European Union collapses as a political and economic project. The days ahead also could trigger a dangerous widening of the economic gap between emerging markets and the developed world – with escalating conflict and surging migration. It may seem premature to reflect on which of the globe’s economies is likely to have the most robust and lasting economic comeback – and with what geopolitical impact. After all, this was a week in which the International Monetary Fund a 3% contraction in global GDP for 2020, the most dramatic drop since the Great Depression. Yet it is the details behind that dismal forecast that should raise concerns within the U.S. and Europe. Their steeper economic decline and slower recovery could lay the seeds for a long-lasting shift of global tectonic plates to China’s advantage. The IMF projected a U.S. economic decline of about 6% in 2020 and a contraction of the eurozone of 7.5%. That compares to projected Chinese economic growth for 2020 of 1.2% after a first quarter real decline of 6.7% – far less than the 10%-plus dip many experts had expected. The only group of countries in the world projected to be in positive territory are East Asian, at roughly 1%. Even if one accepts that Chinese coronavirus fatalities likely are greater than their public figures and that the growth decline is likely larger, that doesn’t change the potential for a scenario that Deloitte and Salesforce this week as “Sunrise in the East.” Describing this scenario, as one of four possibilities they list, they write, “The global center of power shifts decisively east as China and other East Asian nations take the reigns as primary powers on the world stage and lead global coordination of the health system and other multilateral institutions.” That comes with the broader acceptance of greater surveillance mechanisms as part of the public good, a faster recovery of East Asian countries with less economic impact from COVID19, and a significant ramping up of Chinese foreign direct investment to burnish its global reputation. Still, the U.S. has a host of incumbent advantages that could serve it well if it uses its economic recovery to also strengthen its infrastructure, if it reverses runaway unemployment quickly, if it can tame political polarization and, most significantly, if it rediscovers its taste for collaborative global leadership. In the economic race, no advantage is greater than the dollar. China may be the world’s second largest economy, but the Chinese yuan only 2% of global payments and reserves while the dollar for roughly two thirds of foreign exchange reserves. The dollar four-fifths of global supply chains. The Economist China could chip away at U.S. economic advantages through three underestimated strengths of its own: as a trusted debtor, an attractive creditor, and increasingly as a tech partner. As a debtor, China’s $13 trillion bond market is the world’s second largest and . Chinese debt 1.3% in the first quarter, vastly better than the 15.5% for other emerging market bonds. Over the same period, the Chinese market added $8.5 billion (60 billion yuan) in net inflows. As a creditor, China has remained willing and generous, an approach that served the U.S. well after World War II. For example, it its willingness to back a G20 deal to suspend bilateral loan repayments by poorer countries, a sizable benefit also at its own cost. On the tech front, few countries were as ready as China for money and people to go entirely online. Tencent and Ant Financial have more than a billion users each for their digital wallets, and they are expanding rapidly throughout Asia. OneConnect, an offshoot of China’s largest insurer, provides financial institutions in sixteen Asian countries with cloud-based services. So, what other advantages can the United States leverage in this race? Never underestimate the brittleness of an authoritarian country under stress. Its broad censorship, it’s opaque legal system, and the nature of its surveillance state are hardly models to emulate. Beyond that, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is not alone that his country relocate high-value supply chains from China. If many countries do the same, the manufacturing foundation of China’s economy could erode. The Financial Times’ Gideon Rachman that the global trust in the dollar is just one of two built-in U.S. advantages that are difficult to dislodge. The other? “Where, outside your home country, would you most like your children to go to university or to work?” he writes. Most significant in this race would be if the United States regained its appetite for political and economic leadership as the world’s premier “convening power.” That need not be done at the cost of China – or anyone else. The race still can be won if U.S. leaders see it as a marathon and recall that much of the world long embraced their global leadership because partners learned they were more likely to win as American partners. This economic rebound from COVID19 will be patchy and uneven. Being first out the gate will be significant, and that is likely to be China. Yet history has taught the United States that it’s victory will be longest lasting if it can achieved alongside partners and allies.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Economy

Prolonged inflation crashes the economy---even without rate hikes.

Bartash 21, citing senior economist Sal Guatieri of BMO Capital Markets and Stanley of Amherst Pierpont (Jeffry, 9-25-2021, "The Fed has bet on a future of low inflation. Here's what could go wrong", MarketWatch, )

Damage to the economy A prolonged bout of high inflation could cause consumer spending — the main driver of the U.S. economy — to slow. Consumers have already cut back on purchases of new cars and other goods because of record prices. A recent survey found that consumers say it’s the worst time to buy a car since the early 1980s. What could also pose a risk to the economy is if the Fed moves to squelch inflation by raising interest rates more rapidly than it plans. A series of rapid interest-rate hikes could choke off U.S. economic growth and sent stock markets plummeting. “That could rattle financial markets and the economy,” said senior economist Sal Guatieri of BMO Capital Markets. Yet the likelihood of the Powell Fed acting so aggressively appears dim, other analysts say. The central bank is more focused on ensuring a strong U.S. jobs market and low unemployment and less worried about a sustained period of high inflation. Stanley of Amherst Pierpont believes the Fed will raise interest rates slowly even if inflation remains elevated, possibly making it harder for the central bank to put the genie back in the bottle. The big risk, he said, is that consumers and businesses lose faith in the Fed’s ability to keep inflation low. Such an outcome could make the U.S. economy more unstable and prone to sharper ups and downs.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/L – Bill Solves Climate

A slimmed down version solves climate and inflation

Faiz Jamil, John Harwood, 6-20-2022 CNN reporters, covering daily news “5 things” CNN, https://www.cnn.com/audio/static/transcripts/5-things/9-am-et-bbb-comeback-juneteenth-shooting-swimmer-t.e97c76d140a7a9dc9e9237971d870ebb.pdf//DG

Could President Joe Biden’s build back better bill be making a comeback? You might remember the $1.9 trillion spending plan that failed to get the support of Democrats Joe Manchin and Kirsten Cinema last year. Now it’s thought the bill could be broken into parts and passed as part of an inflation fighting plan. CNN’s John Harwood has more. John Harwood (reporter hit) 00:00:27 I think there is some belief within the White House and on Capitol Hill that a package that includes some of the prescription drug reforms that they’ve been talking about, some tax incentives to try to accelerate the shift toward renewable energy sources and some revenue raising, more revenue raising than they would spend in the package. And because of that, it would reduce the deficit and in theory, help with inflation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/L – Bill Solves Climate

Also solves by averting interest rate hikes which crush renewables and lock in warming

Bornhauser 19, citing Tobias Schmidt, Professor of Energy Politics. (Martin, 9-9-2019, "Interest rates are a decisive factor for competitive renewables", ETH Zurich, )

Renewable energy is an essential part of efforts to reduce CO2 emissions. Without it – according to all the climate scenarios – the Paris Agreement’s target of limiting global warming to below 2°C relative to the pre-​industrial age will not be achieved. Policymakers have therefore introduced various support measures for renewable energy, in particular in the EU – and not without success: the generation costs of alternative energy in many European countries today are comparable with the (marginal) costs of existing gas or coal-​fired power stations. The last two years have seen the widespread emergence of photovoltaic plants that can survive and hold their own on the market without subsidies – for example, in Spain and Germany. Green electricity’s new-​found competitiveness is based on more mature technology and higher volumes, which bring down costs. In addition – and this is often overlooked – the low cost of capital has also played its part, as low interest rates boost the economic viability of alternative energy sources. Lower costs thanks to low interest rates But what happens if interest rates rise? ETH researchers have explored this question in two studies. As renewable energy is more capital-​intensive than fossil fuels, the costs rise more sharply with rising interest rates, making it less attractive. “Renewable energy is now very cheap, but that won’t necessarily be the case with higher interest rates,” says Tobias Schmidt, Professor of Energy Politics. According to Schmidt, analysis of 133 photovoltaic and onshore wind projects in Germany over the last 18 years shows that – in the case of wind power, for example – lower financing costs account for about 25% of the savings in electricity-​production costs (see article in Nature Energycall_made). “Renewable energy has become cheaper – thanks in part to significant improvements in financing conditions,” says Bjarne Steffen, co-​author of the study. Conversely, rising financing costs will lead to disproportionate increases in the price of renewable energy. Less attractive with rising interest rates In a study published today in Nature Sustainability, the ETH researchers calculated various interest rate scenarios in collaboration with a team from the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK). If interest rates were to return to pre-​crisis levels, electricity production costs in Germany would increase by 11% for solar power plants and 25% for wind power projects – with a knock-​on impact on competitiveness. In a scenario involving a moderate rise in interest rates, the lower costs of solar power plants due to advances in knowledge and technology would be offset by higher interest charges. For wind power stations, it is estimated that electricity generation costs would increase by 9% in such a scenario.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Warming

Extinction.

Kareiva 18, Ph.D. in ecology and applied mathematics from Cornell University, director of the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability at UCLA, Pritzker Distinguished Professor in Environment & Sustainability at UCLA, et al. (Peter, “Existential risk due to ecosystem collapse: Nature strikes back,” Futures, 102)

In summary, six of the nine proposed planetary boundaries (phosphorous, nitrogen, biodiversity, land use, atmospheric aerosol loading, and chemical pollution) are unlikely to be associated with existential risks. They all correspond to a degraded environment, but in our assessment do not represent existential risks. However, the three remaining boundaries (climate change, global freshwater cycle, and ocean acidification) do pose existential risks. This is because of intrinsic positive feedback loops, substantial lag times between system change and experiencing the consequences of that change, and the fact these different boundaries interact with one another in ways that yield surprises. In addition, climate, freshwater, and ocean acidification are all directly connected to the provision of food and water, and shortages of food and water can create conflict and social unrest. Climate change has a long history of disrupting civilizations and sometimes precipitating the collapse of cultures or mass emigrations (McMichael, 2017). For example, the 12th century drought in the North American Southwest is held responsible for the collapse of the Anasazi pueblo culture. More recently, the infamous potato famine of 1846–1849 and the large migration of Irish to the U.S. can be traced to a combination of factors, one of which was climate. Specifically, 1846 was an unusually warm and moist year in Ireland, providing the climatic conditions favorable to the fungus that caused the potato blight. As is so often the case, poor government had a role as well—as the British government forbade the import of grains from outside Britain (imports that could have helped to redress the ravaged potato yields). Climate change intersects with freshwater resources because it is expected to exacerbate drought and water scarcity, as well as flooding. Climate change can even impair water quality because it is associated with heavy rains that overwhelm sewage treatment facilities, or because it results in higher concentrations of pollutants in groundwater as a result of enhanced evaporation and reduced groundwater recharge. Ample clean water is not a luxury—it is essential for human survival. Consequently, cities, regions and nations that lack clean freshwater are vulnerable to social disruption and disease. Finally, ocean acidification is linked to climate change because it is driven by CO2 emissions just as global warming is. With close to 20% of the world’s protein coming from oceans (FAO, 2016), the potential for severe impacts due to acidification is obvious. Less obvious, but perhaps more insidious, is the interaction between climate change and the loss of oyster and coral reefs due to acidification. Acidification is known to interfere with oyster reef building and coral reefs. Climate change also increases storm frequency and severity. Coral reefs and oyster reefs provide protection from storm surge because they reduce wave energy (Spalding et al., 2014). If these reefs are lost due to acidification at the same time as storms become more severe and sea level rises, coastal communities will be exposed to unprecedented storm surge—and may be ravaged by recurrent storms. A key feature of the risk associated with climate change is that mean annual temperature and mean annual rainfall are not the variables of interest. Rather it is extreme episodic events that place nations and entire regions of the world at risk. These extreme events are by definition “rare” (once every hundred years), and changes in their likelihood are challenging to detect because of their rarity, but are exactly the manifestations of climate change that we must get better at anticipating (Diffenbaugh et al., 2017). Society will have a hard time responding to shorter intervals between rare extreme events because in the lifespan of an individual human, a person might experience as few as two or three extreme events. How likely is it that you would notice a change in the interval between events that are separated by decades, especially given that the interval is not regular but varies stochastically? A concrete example of this dilemma can be found in the past and expected future changes in storm-related flooding of New York City. The highly disruptive flooding of New York City associated with Hurricane Sandy represented a flood height that occurred once every 500 years in the 18th century, and that occurs now once every 25 years, but is expected to occur once every 5 years by 2050 (Garner et al., 2017). This change in frequency of extreme floods has profound implications for the measures New York City should take to protect its infrastructure and its population, yet because of the stochastic nature of such events, this shift in flood frequency is an elevated risk that will go unnoticed by most people. 4. The combination of positive feedback loops and societal inertia is fertile ground for global environmental catastrophes Humans are remarkably ingenious, and have adapted to crises throughout their history. Our doom has been repeatedly predicted, only to be averted by innovation (Ridley, 2011). However, the many stories of human ingenuity successfully addressing existential risks such as global famine or extreme air pollution represent environmental challenges that are largely linear, have immediate consequences, and operate without positive feedbacks. For example, the fact that food is in short supply does not increase the rate at which humans consume food—thereby increasing the shortage. Similarly, massive air pollution episodes such as the London fog of 1952 that killed 12,000 people did not make future air pollution events more likely. In fact it was just the opposite—the London fog sent such a clear message that Britain quickly enacted pollution control measures (Stradling, 2016). Food shortages, air pollution, water pollution, etc. send immediate signals to society of harm, which then trigger a negative feedback of society seeking to reduce the harm. In contrast, today’s great environmental crisis of climate change may cause some harm but there are generally long time delays between rising CO2 concentrations and damage to humans. The consequence of these delays are an absence of urgency; thus although 70% of Americans believe global warming is happening, only 40% think it will harm them (http://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us-2016/). Secondly, unlike past environmental challenges, the Earth’s climate system is rife with positive feedback loops. In particular, as CO2 increases and the climate warms, that very warming can cause more CO2 release which further increases global warming, and then more CO2, and so on. Table 2 summarizes the best documented positive feedback loops for the Earth’s climate system. These feedbacks can be neatly categorized into carbon cycle, biogeochemical, biogeophysical, cloud, ice-albedo, and water vapor feedbacks. As important as it is to understand these feedbacks individually, it is even more essential to study the interactive nature of these feedbacks. Modeling studies show that when interactions among feedback loops are included, uncertainty increases dramatically and there is a heightened potential for perturbations to be magnified (e.g., Cox, Betts, Jones, Spall, & Totterdell, 2000; Hajima, Tachiiri, Ito, & Kawamiya, 2014; Knutti & Rugenstein, 2015; Rosenfeld, Sherwood, Wood, & Donner, 2014). This produces a wide range of future scenarios. Positive feedbacks in the carbon cycle involves the enhancement of future carbon contributions to the atmosphere due to some initial increase in atmospheric CO2. This happens because as CO2 accumulates, it reduces the efficiency in which oceans and terrestrial ecosystems sequester carbon, which in return feeds back to exacerbate climate change (Friedlingstein et al., 2001). Warming can also increase the rate at which organic matter decays and carbon is released into the atmosphere, thereby causing more warming (Melillo et al., 2017). Increases in food shortages and lack of water is also of major concern when biogeophysical feedback mechanisms perpetuate drought conditions. The underlying mechanism here is that losses in vegetation increases the surface albedo, which suppresses rainfall, and thus enhances future vegetation loss and more suppression of rainfall—thereby initiating or prolonging a drought (Chamey, Stone, & Quirk, 1975). To top it off, overgrazing depletes the soil, leading to augmented vegetation loss (Anderies, Janssen, & Walker, 2002). Climate change often also increases the risk of forest fires, as a result of higher temperatures and persistent drought conditions. The expectation is that forest fires will become more frequent and severe with climate warming and drought (Scholze, Knorr, Arnell, & Prentice, 2006), a trend for which we have already seen evidence (Allen et al., 2010). Tragically, the increased severity and risk of Southern California wildfires recently predicted by climate scientists (Jin et al., 2015), was realized in December 2017, with the largest fire in the history of California (the “Thomas fire” that burned 282,000 acres, https://www.vox.com/2017/12/27/16822180/thomas-fire-california-largest-wildfire). This catastrophic fire embodies the sorts of positive feedbacks and interacting factors that could catch humanity off-guard and produce a true apocalyptic event. Record-breaking rains produced an extraordinary flush of new vegetation, that then dried out as record heat waves and dry conditions took hold, coupled with stronger than normal winds, and ignition. Of course the record-fire released CO2 into the atmosphere, thereby contributing to future warming. Out of all types of feedbacks, water vapor and the ice-albedo feedbacks are the most clearly understood mechanisms. Losses in reflective snow and ice cover drive up surface temperatures, leading to even more melting of snow and ice cover—this is known as the ice-albedo feedback (Curry, Schramm, & Ebert, 1995). As snow and ice continue to melt at a more rapid pace, millions of people may be displaced by flooding risks as a consequence of sea level rise near coastal communities (Biermann & Boas, 2010; Myers, 2002; Nicholls et al., 2011). The water vapor feedback operates when warmer atmospheric conditions strengthen the saturation vapor pressure, which creates a warming effect given water vapor’s strong greenhouse gas properties (Manabe & Wetherald, 1967). Global warming tends to increase cloud formation because warmer temperatures lead to more evaporation of water into the atmosphere, and warmer temperature also allows the atmosphere to hold more water. The key question is whether this increase in clouds associated with global warming will result in a positive feedback loop (more warming) or a negative feedback loop (less warming). For decades, scientists have sought to answer this question and understand the net role clouds play in future climate projections (Schneider et al., 2017). Clouds are complex because they both have a cooling (reflecting incoming solar radiation) and warming (absorbing incoming solar radiation) effect (Lashof, DeAngelo, Saleska, & Harte, 1997). The type of cloud, altitude, and optical properties combine to determine how these countervailing effects balance out. Although still under debate, it appears that in most circumstances the cloud feedback is likely positive (Boucher et al., 2013). For example, models and observations show that increasing greenhouse gas concentrations reduces the low-level cloud fraction in the Northeast Pacific at decadal time scales. This then has a positive feedback effect and enhances climate warming since less solar radiation is reflected by the atmosphere (Clement, Burgman, & Norris, 2009). The key lesson from the long list of potentially positive feedbacks and their interactions is that runaway climate change, and runaway perturbations have to be taken as a serious possibility. Table 2 is just a snapshot of the type of feedbacks that have been identified (see Supplementary material for a more thorough explanation of positive feedback loops). However, this list is not exhaustive and the possibility of undiscovered positive feedbacks portends even greater existential risks. The many environmental crises humankind has previously averted (famine, ozone depletion, London fog, water pollution, etc.) were averted because of political will based on solid scientific understanding. We cannot count on complete scientific understanding when it comes to positive feedback loops and climate change.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Warming

Strong renewable investment solves catastrophic warming

Spiegel 21, *Jeff, Lead of iShares Megatrend and International ETFs; **Karen Schenone, CFA, Fixed Income Product Strategist within BlackRock’s Global Fixed Income Group; ***Sarah Kjellberg, Director at Blackrock and Head of U.S. iShares Sustainable ETFs at BlackRock. (8-24-2021, "Clean and green investing for a low-carbon economy", BlackRock, )

Extreme weather events are calling attention to the costs of climate change and creating urgency around transforming the global economy — a monumental undertaking that could triple annual investment in clean energy by the end of this decade.1 This summer has seen forest fires first sweep across the Western U.S. and Canada, then Southern Europe, while floods inundated parts of Northern Europe and Central China. Recent ecological shocks follow a record year for weather-related damages in 2020.2 The scientific consensus is that the global economy needs to quickly become less carbon-intensive to avoid continued extreme and catastrophic impacts.3 Transitioning away from fossil fuels, which now account for about 80% of the total energy supply, will require major investments in new technologies, infrastructure, and projects designed to reduce the threat.4 By one estimate, meeting current carbon-reduction targets could require installing the equivalent of the world’s current largest solar park every day for the rest of this decade.5 Given the magnitude of the changes we foresee, long-term investors may find opportunities in the technologies and innovations that create renewable energy sources or reduce the carbon intensity of energy production. The role of renewable energy in reaching net zero To help spur the economic transformation, governments and companies are pledging commitments to become “net zero.” Net zero is about reducing greenhouse gas emissions so that over time we can achieve an overall balance between emissions produced, and the emissions removed from the overall atmosphere. So, for every ton of greenhouse gas emitted into the air, a ton needs to be taken out. More than 125 governments around the world and more than 1,000 companies have made or are preparing to make net zero commitments. We expect that number to go up. Attaining net zero will require huge investments, changes in business models, and innovation. Major energy producers say that oil production likely peaked in 2019, and the race is on for cheap, clean ways to produce electricity.6 To reach net zero emissions by midcentury, annual clean energy investment will need to more than triple by 2030 to around $4 trillion.7 Both stocks and bonds will be important to financing the transition to a sustainable, low-carbon economy, and exchange traded funds (ETFs) are a convenient way to target companies and issuers at the forefront of driving the transformation of the energy systems that underpin the global economy. Accessing renewable energy in the stock market We believe more and increasingly restrictive climate-related policies and growing consumer preferences are likely to spark breakthroughs in renewable energy, which should have knock-on effects that enable scaled production and widespread adoption.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/L Inflation Retrenchment

Inflation triggers fast retrenchment – lower budget requests, continuing resolution contracts and dramatically reduced purchasing power

Daniels 6/21 - associate fellow and associate director for Defense Budget Analysis in the International Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (Seamus P., “Worried about inflation and the defense budget? A continuing resolution could make things worse,” Defense News, 6-21-22, ) //sg

This high rate of inflation poses a threat to the department’s purchasing power. Instead of the real increase in defense spending assumed by DoD, rising prices over 2022 likely means the requested level of funding represents a cut. And the administration’s five-year funding projections could mean an even greater loss in purchasing power — potentially over $300 billion between FY23 and FY27 — should high inflation persist.

Unless the Biden administration intends to scale back the demands it places on an already over-stressed military — which appears unlikely given the conflict in Ukraine and the administration’s recent decision to redeploy troops to Somalia for counterterrorism missions — DoD must work with Congress to mitigate the effects of inflation. In May, Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks expressed the department’s willingness to work with legislators on updating inflation estimates to protect DoD’s buying power in the FY23 request.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › *L T/Case* › L T/SC Solvency

The Link alone turns the case – Politicized fights destroy cooperation effectiveness

Young 2020

Thomas-Durell, phd, Senior Lecturer at the Naval Postgraduate School, “The "Politics" of Security Cooperation and Security Assistance” September 10, 2020, https://www.dasadec.army.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2344014/the-politics-of-security-cooperation-and-security-assistance/dmr

The objective of this article is to argue that administration officials and Congress face two different political challenges related to improving SC and SA. Unless and until U.S. officials formulate solutions to these political problems, both branches of government will struggle to achieve more effective means of reforming partner nations’ key governmental institutions. First—and perhaps the easiest challenge to address—is that SC and SA have unintended political consequences in the government institutions of recipient countries and are not solely technical tasks. No one has expressed this point better than Mara Karlin, albeit she was speaking in reference to weak states: Past experience offers two key lessons for U.S. officials as they seek to strengthen the security sectors of weak states. First, like all state-building endeavors, these are political, not technical, exercises. Instead of focusing narrowly on training and equipment, U.S. policymakers responsible for implementing such programs must address the purpose and scope of the U.S. role and the mission, leadership, and organizational structure of the partner’s military.9 Second, SC and SA are highly politicized; both are inefficient, because of the lack of coordination between the Department of Defense (DOD) and Department of State, and ineffective, because of lack of alignment with national security goals (and/or foreign policy objectives). This important reality needs wider appreciation by these departments, as well as by Congress, if the U.S. Government is to improve its ability to find value for money by improving partner nations’ ability to defend their sovereignty, let alone contribute to expeditionary operations. Recent reforms initiated by Congress, most notably in the fiscal year (FY) 2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), constitute a good first effort at addressing these longstanding problems; however, a review of the evidence shows that this legislation should be augmented to define the problem as largely political in nature, as opposed to accepting the traditional default assumption that it is solely technical, which would have enabled it to call for even deeper reforms within these bureaucracies. This article argues that, due to internal DOD politics and the interorganizational politics within the U.S. Government, suboptimal results ensue from the way the United States plans and executes SC and SA. It then suggests legislative and policy changes that might better take this reality into account. The stakes are high. If U.S. strategy is to bring troops home from the so-called endless wars overseas and let others do the fighting, then its success must be a core priority. But only by reforming the way the United States organizes itself to build allies’ and partners’ armed forces are we likely to meet with any greater success than we have in the past.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › *L T/Case* › L T/SC Solvency

The Link alone turns the case – political fights empirically doom cooperation solvency

Karlin 2017

Mara, Ph.D., was a nonresident senior fellow with the Center for Security, Strategy, and Technology at the Brookings Institution. She was also the director of strategic studies and an associate professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS). Karlin has served in national security roles for five U.S. secretaries of defense, advising on policies spanning strategic planning, defense budgeting, future wars and the evolving security environment, and regional affairs involving the Middle East, Europe, and Asia. She was a commissioner for the congressionally-mandated Syria Study Group and previously worked on the congressionally-mandated National Defense Strategy Commission, “Why military assistance programs disappoint: Minor tools can't solve major problems” November/December 2017, Foreign Affairs, dmr

A HOUSE DIVIDED

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › *L T/Case* › L T/NATO Solvency

The Link alone turns the case – Plan sparks burden sharing fights – that divides member states

Kunz 2021

Barbra, senior researcher at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy at the University of Hamburg. She specializes in European security and the debates surrounding it, with a special emphasis on France and Germany. “’There is No “Europe’: Disagreements Within NATO Are Not Solely Transatlantic and Pertain to the Fundamentals of European Security”, NATO 2030: Towards a New Strategic Concept and Beyond, (157-176), 2021.dmr

Analyses of transatlantic relations, and security relations in particular, often focus on differences between the United States and its European allies. This clearly is an important factor. Given Europe’s dependence on US security guarantees, the United States’ continued willingness to engage in the continent’s security is the condition sine qua non for NATO’s survival. US dissatisfaction with European engagement and defense spending has consequently been a key item on intra-Alliance agendas since 1949. US concerns about NATO and its European allies’ engagement were indeed voiced openly long before Donald Trump.1 Debates about burden sharing also trickle down to domestic politics in member states and thus contribute to shaping the general climate within the Alliance, as for instance the 2 percent objective that has featured in several German electoral campaigns.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › *L T/Case* › L T/NATO Solvency

The Link alone turns the case –GOP will fight the plan – that undermines US-NATO cooperation

Binnenkijk and Townsend 2021

Hans Binnenkijk, distinguished fellow at the Atlantic Council, former senior official at US Senate Foreign Relations Committee, National Security Council, State Department, and the National Defense University; Jim Townsend Jr. adjunct senior fellow in the CNAS Transatlantic Security Program, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense (DASD) for European and NATO Policy. "The Future US Role in NATO," NATO 2030: Towards a New Strategic Concept and Beyond, (131-156), 2021.dmr

But the populist political force that brought Trump to the presidency was more powerful and ran deeper in the US body politic than those of an earlier period. Organized by social media and fed by conspiracy theories of news outlets, the Trump electoral base was deep and included extremist movements that helped make the current US populist movement strong and active. While the grievances held by US populists are not as focused on US foreign policy as on domestic themes, wary allies see the political power and resilience of the US populist movement and are reluctant to assume the US political storm has blown over and that US internationalism is safe.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › L – Including Turkey

Blowback link---ferocious advocacy against cooperation and tech/resource transfers driven by fears of Turkey-Russia and Turkey-China collaboration

Laura Kelly, 5-13-2022, Staff Writer for The Hill "Advocacy groups press Congress to reject Biden weapons sale to Turkey," Hill, https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/3487453-advocacy-groups-press-congress-to-reject-biden-weapons-sale-to-turkey//DG

More than half a dozen organizations advocating American interests in the Middle East, Mediterranean and Caucasus are pressing Congress to overturn the administration’s planned sale of weapons and military equipment to Turkey. The Biden administration last month asked Congress to approve the sale of advanced weapons and other equipment for Turkey’s fleet of F-16 fighter jets, The Wall Street Journal reported this week.  But seven advocacy organizations are raising alarm that Congress should apply strict scrutiny and oversight to any potential sales or transfer of fighter jets or major weapons systems to Turkey, which is an ally of the United States in NATO.  Separate letters were sent Friday to Senate and House lawmakers by the Hellenic American Leadership Council; Armenian National Committee of America; the American Jewish Committee; In Defense of Christians, the Middle East Forum; American Friends of Kurdistan and the International Coordinating Committee — Justice for Cyprus (PSEKA). The letters were sent to the chairs and ranking members of the House Foreign Affairs and Armed Services committees, and the Senate Foreign Relations and Armed Services committees. The organizations raised “alarm” over the Biden administration’s request that Congress approve the sale of 80 modernization kits for its existing warplanes, air-to-air missiles and radar/avionics upgrades. “We ask that you ensure that any American arms sales to Ankara come with narrowly defined statutory conditions and bilaterally agreed upon restrictions, including guarantees that U.S. weapons will never be deployed against Armenians, Syriac-Assyrians, Greeks, Cypriot, the Kurds or domestic civilian populations,” read the letter from the Armenian National Committee of America. President Biden has sought to normalize relations between Washington and Ankara that have been strained for years over a number of crises. Biden met with Turkish President in Europe in June 2021 in  a “positive and productive meeting.”  Administration officials have publicly praised Turkey’s role in opposing Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. It has buttressed security in the Black Sea, provided key weapons to Kyiv and served as a strategic intermediary with Moscow. “Turkey is proving itself to be a key, helpful and strategic ally of the U.S.,” Assistant Secretary of State for Europe and Eurasia Affairs Karen Donfried told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee during a hearing on Thursday.  But Erdoğan on Friday voiced opposition to expanding NATO to allow Finland and Sweden to join. Both are being welcomed as future members by the U.S. and other NATO allies.  Washington and Ankara have had tense relations for years. The U.S. kicked Turkey out of its F-35 fighter jet program in 2019 following Ankara’s purchase of the Russian S-400 missile defense system. The U.S. also imposed sanctions on Turkey in 2020 under a federal law, called CAATSA, for the continued possession of the Russian missile defense system.  The American Jewish Committee in its letter urged Congress to prevent the weapons sales unless Turkey can be proven to be in compliance with CAATSA and “assurances can be made that advanced American technology will not be left vulnerable to Russian and Chinese systems.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT Plan is Executive

XO’s link to politics---encourage Congressional budget battles

Christenson 15, Associate Professor of Political Science and the Director of Advanced Programs @ Boston U (Dino, “Political Constraints on Unilateral Executive Action,” Case Western Law Review, 65.4)//BB

Here, we take a different tack and emphasize the informal political∂ costs of unilateral action. Specifically, we argue that presidents consider∂ more than just whether Congress or the courts will act affirmatively to∂ overturn a unilateral presidential order. Rather, presidents consider the∂ longer-term political costs that unilateral action may entail. These∂ political costs can take many forms, two of which are particularly∂ important. First, when presidents act unilaterally, they may burn∂ bridges with members of Congress opposed to the action on political,∂ ideological, or even constitutional grounds. To be sure, in almost all∂ circumstances, presidents will be able to carry the day and beat back∂ any legislative effort to undo what they have done unilaterally.∂ However, the ill will so generated on Capitol Hill may prove politically∂ costly the next time the president’s policy wishes require action that∂ only Congress can take. For example, despite being a rather blunt∂ instrument, Congress retains the power of the purse and therefore,∂ ultimately, the power to support or de-fund most policies that∂ presidents begin unilaterally.40 This echoes Neustadt’s moral from the∂ “three cases of command”—Truman’s firing of General Douglas∂ MacArthur and seizure of the steel mills during the Korean War, and∂ Eisenhower federalizing the Arkansas National Guard to integrate∂ Central High School. In each case, the president succeeded in achieving∂ his immediate policy objective. Yet, in each case, Neustadt argues the∂ victory was a pyrrhic one, coming at a high political cost. Truman’s∂ actions, in particular, only intensified ongoing battles with Congress on∂ both the foreign and domestic fronts and likely hindered Truman’s∂ efforts to extract concessions from Congress on other key elements of∂ his legislative agenda.41

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT Plan is Executive

Biden gets the blame for agency action

Kovacs 18, Professor at the University of Rutgers School of Law, JD from Georgetown University Law Center, BA in Psychology from Yale University (Kathryn E., “Rules About Rulemaking and The Rise of the Unitary Executive,” Administrative Law Review, 70 Admin. L. Rev. 515, Lexis)

Clearly, there are other reasons for this phenomenon: among them, the President's desire to take political credit or, on the flip side, his recognition that, whatever the outcome, he will be saddled with the political blame. The American public seems to equate the President with the Fourth Branch. Advances in technology and media may be exacerbating this effect. This phenomenon, however, cuts both ways. The President may be inclined to make policy decisions himself so that he can take the credit if the outcome is politically popular, but he may prefer to leave policymaking to his subordinates so that he can distance himself if the outcome is not politically popular. This does not, therefore, account fully for the dramatic [*557] rise in presidential direct action described below.

[FOOTNOTE]

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT Plan is Executive

Unilateral action ensures backlash from both sides of the aisle

Sensiba 20 -- Jennifer Sensiba, journalist. [Don’t Encourage Biden To Waste Political Capital, 11-6-20, https://cleantechnica.com/2020/11/06/dont-encourage-biden-to-waste-political-capital/]

Executive Power Is Expensive While Trump abused executive power frequently, don’t be tempted by calls for Biden to take revenge and do the same thing. The short term gains may be enticing, but the longer term costs are much bigger than they might appear to be at first. Trump found out the hard way that pushing for things like the border wall, fights against LGBT rights, and attempts to prop up the failing coal industry alienates reasonable people. It’s easy to say “Trump did it! We can too!”, but don’t forget that was part of his undoing. The worst thing a President Biden could do is use unconstitutional executive orders for something divisive like gun control. Yes, Trump actually did this, because he thought it would make him look good after the Las Vegas shooting, but it divided his own supporters. Loyalists made excuses or claimed it was part of some elaborate game to “beat the libs,” while people who really believed in gun rights deeply lost trust in Trump. Make no mistake, a Democratic president doing this would quickly earn the hostilities of both camps and suffer a deeper cost than Trump did. That’s just one example. There are many other little regulatory things a President Biden could do to put the screws to Republicans, but in most cases it simply isn’t worth it when we need real legislation to get the job done.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT Plan is Executive

Executive action magnifies the link

Christenson 15, Associate Professor of Political Science and the Director of Advanced Programs @ Boston U (Dino, “Political Constraints on Unilateral Executive Action,” Case Western Law Review, 65.4)//BB

Moreover, other institutions, particularly Congress, may play an∂ important role—even when presidents know that efforts to overturn an∂ executive action will fail—by engaging in the political debate and∂ mobilizing public pressure against the president should he act unilaterally∂ contra congressional preferences. Decades of political science scholarship∂ have demonstrated that the public lacks systematic knowledge∂ of politics and therefore relies heavily on heuristics when forming their∂ political judgments.48 Political elites thus become key cue-givers who∂ help inform and shape public opinion.49 Finally, citizens acquire most∂ of their knowledge about politics from the mass media. Scholars have∂ long noted that the media depend on official Washington sources for∂ information. However, a robust literature in political communications∂ goes further and argues that the media tend “to ‘index’ the range of∂ voices and viewpoints in both news and editorials according to the∂ range of views expressed in mainstream government debate about a∂ given topic.”50 When other political actors, particularly members of∂ Congress, object and criticize presidential actions in the public sphere,∂ they are all but assured of receiving considerable media coverage, and∂ they are well-positioned to influence public opinion against the∂ executive branch.51∂ In essence, we argue that while the statutory and legal constraints∂ on presidential unilateral power are weak, the political constraints are∂ quite robust.52 Unilateral actions that could provoke public ire and∂ erode the president’s political capital, thereby undermining later efforts∂ to pursue other aspects of the president’s programmatic agenda, may∂ fail a simple cost-benefit calculation. The informal political costs of∂ acting—even when Congress and the courts are almost certainly∂ unwilling or unable to strike down the action—may outweigh the policy∂ benefits of acting unilaterally. These political costs, which are not∂ accounted for in most extant models of unilateral politics, are tangible∂ and substantial; indeed, they may explain why presidents fail to act∂ unilaterally as aggressively and on as many issues across the gamut of∂ policy as formal models suggest they should.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT No Congress – Export Control

Anything perceived as loosening standards sparks a massive controversy over national security concerns

Kate O’Keeffe, 10-25-2021, WSJ reporter that writes about U.S-China issues "House Republicans Call for Tougher Controls to Keep U.S. Tech From China," WSJ, https://www.wsj.com/articles/house-republicans-call-for-tougher-controls-to-keep-u-s-tech-from-china-11635159601//DG

Republican China hawks in Congress are pressuring the Commerce Department to fortify export controls to keep critical American technology from falling into Beijing’s hands. Republicans on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, in a letter to Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo last week, urged action to address 10 issues of “immediate concern”—from strengthening  and jet engines to updating the list of technologies earmarked for protection from foreign rivals. The letter, from the committee’s top Republican, Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas, and signed by 16 other Republicans, follows a move this month by Republican Sens. Tom Cotton of Arkansas and Bill Hagerty of Tennessee to hold up confirmation of Alan Estevez, President Biden’s nominee to lead the Commerce unit . A spokeswoman for the Commerce Department said it is dedicated to “promoting U.S. exports and technology leadership for the benefit of U.S. companies and workers.” She also said the agency seeks to protect U.S. national security and promote democratic values. Under the Biden administration, it has put export controls on  for their support of China’s military, and 14 other Chinese entities that have enabled the country’s human-rights abuses, she added. Commerce’s policies toward China—and Mr. Estevez’s nomination—are emerging as tests for Republicans who want the Biden administration to maintain a hard-nosed approach to China. The House Republicans in their letter backed the hold on Mr. Estevez until, they said, Ms. Raimondo acts on their requests because “these actions are critical to stemming the flow of technology into our foremost foreign adversary.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT No Congress – Export Control

Export Control Act requires congressional reauthorization for the plan

INS, Impact News Service, 5-13-2019"Analyst in Security Cooperation and Assistance and the Global Arms Trade". https://advance-lexis-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/api/document?collection=news&id=urn:contentItem:5W3T-25M1-JDG9-Y12Y-00000-00&context=1516831.

Applicants must be able to execute analytical research projects to address congressional requests in the areas of U.S security cooperation and assistance policies/programs, including Title 10 and Title 22 “train and equip” programs and authorities, arms transfers, and end-use monitoring, among other issues. The position requires knowledge of security assistance and arms transfer issues from end to end-- from policy issues related to the U.S defense industrial base to those associated with foreign recipients. This position also focuses on the respective roles of the Departments of State and Defense and the Intelligence Community in the conception and implementation of such policies/programs. It further includes knowledge of Congress’ role in authorizing, appropriating funding for, and overseeing U.S security cooperation and assistance, including under the Foreign Assistance Act, the Arms Export Control Act, and annual national defense authorization measures, as well as U.S defense-related technology transfer policies.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT No Congress/Plan Covert

DoD required to keep lawmakers in the loop about SC

Department of Defense 16 – (“DoD Directive 5132.03: DoD Policy and Responsibilities Relating to Security Cooperation,” DoD Open Government, 12-29-16, https://open.defense.gov/portals/23/Documents/foreignasst/DoDD_513203_on_Security_Cooperation.pdf) //sg

f. DoD will maintain a robust program of assessment, monitoring, and evaluation of security cooperation to provide policymakers, planners, program managers, and implementers the information necessary to evaluate outcomes, identify challenges, make appropriate corrections, and maximize effectiveness of future security cooperation activities

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › Link Mechanics › AT No Congress/Plan Covert

SC requires statutory authority

Quinn 19, judge Advocate, United States Army. Presently assigned as Assistant General Counsel, National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency; LL.M., 2019, The Judge Advocate General's School, United States Army; J.D., 2009, George Mason University School of Law; B.S., 2005, University of Northern Colorado. Previous assignments include Deputy Staff Judge Advocate, Special Operations Command Europe, Stuttgart, Germany, 2016-2018; Contracts Attorney, 409th Contracting Support Brigade, Kaiserslautern, Germany, 2014-2016; Chief, Administrative Law, 4th Infantry Division and Regional Command (South), Kandahar Airfield, Afghanistan, 2013-2014; Chief, Contract and Fiscal Law, 4th Infantry Division, Fort Carson, Colorado 2012-2013; Trial Counsel, 43d Sustainment Brigade, Fort Carson, Colorado, 2011-2012; Tax Center OIC, 4th Infantry Division, Fort Carson, Colorado, 2010-2011; Administrative Law Attorney, 4th Infantry Division, Fort Carson, Colorado. 2010. (Jason, “OTHER SECURITY FORCES TOO: TRADITIONAL COMBATANT COMMANDER ACTIVITIES BETWEEN U.S. SPECIAL OPERATIONS FORCES AND FOREIGN NON-MILITARY FORCES,” 227 Mil. L. Rev. 336, Lexis)

Pre-crisis, pre-conflict CT shaping activities are deliberately broken into two categories: (1) security cooperation and (2) military engagement. 118 Security cooperation is focused on building partner capacity and capabilities 119 and typically requires express statutory authority, regardless of whether the security cooperation activity is being conducted with a military or non-military force. 120 Military engagement, [*359] on the other hand, is a "routine" activity "to build trust and confidence, share information, coordinate mutual activities, maintain influence, build defense relationships, and develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations." 121Critically, as part of overall military engagement efforts, joint doctrine calls for CT forces to engage with military and with other security forces. 122