2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Eastern Flank Thumper
Air command Public office, 5/10/22, “,” Insight EU monitoring; Allied Air Command Public Affairs Office, , JH
RAMSTEIN, Germany – Since the beginning of Russia’s attack on Ukraine NATO has taken measures to shield its member States along the eastern flank from potential aggression. In the air, Allied Air Command commands and employs military aircraft from the nations and NATO to execute enhanced Vigilance Activities.
NATO has substantially increased the number of fighter jets on alert across Eastern Europe in response to Russia’s unprovoked attack on Ukraine. NATO’s enhanced vigilance is a powerful statement of Alliance resolve and cohesion [that demonstrates] our commitment to protect every inch of NATO territory of all our Allies
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
Gautam Mukherjee 22, commentator on political and economic affairs, “Sweden and Finland may be keen to join NATO, but all’s not well in US-led alliance,” https://www.firstpost.com/opinion/sweden-and-finland-may-be-keen-to-join-nato-but-alls-not-well-in-us-led-alliance-10686951.html/micahw
To admit Sweden and Finland, the existing NATO members must agree unanimously. Western media is talking of American pressure, even sanctions, to force an economically savaged Turkey, with 70 per cent inflation, to fall in line. NATO itself expects to smooth things over with Ankara so that they don’t stand in the way.
It is hoping for a fast tracking that could see both countries as NATO members within this year.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
Susan Fraser 22, Associated Press Correspondent in Turkey, “Why is Turkey wary of Nordic states’ NATO bid?” https://apnews.com/article/turkey-nato-membership-sweden-finalnd-83a191ca8b4052925059b61ddd7e0945/micahw
Turkey is expected to seek to negotiate a compromise deal under which the two countries will crack down on the PKK and other groups in return for Turkish support of their joining NATO. A key demand is expected to be that they halt any support to a Syrian Kurdish group, the Kurdish People’s Protection Units, or YPG. The group is a Western ally in the fight against the Islamic State group in northern Syria but Turkey views it as an extension of the PKK.
Erdogan could also seek to use Sweden and Finland’s membership to wrest concessions from the United States and other allies. Turkey wants to return to the U.S.-led F-35 fighter jet program — a project it was kicked out of following its purchase of Russian S-400 missile defense systems. Alternatively, Turkey is looking to purchase a new batch of F-16 fighter jets and upgrade its existing fleet.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
Thomas O. Falk 22, Senior Political Journalist and Commentor, “Will Turkey block Finland and Sweden from becoming NATO members?” Al Jazeera, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/5/24/will-turkey-block-nato-expansion/micahw
Ultimately, all 30 members must vote unanimously in favour of the historically neutral Nordic nations if they are to join the Washington-led group, so Turkey could – in theory – block an application.
“Turkey has every right to block Sweden and Finland’s ascension to NATO,” Ahmet Erdi Ozturk, associate professor in politics and international relations at London Metropolitan University, told Al Jazeera.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
Barış Seçkin 22, experienced Foreign Correspondent with a demonstrated history of working in the media production industry, 4/3/22, “Cohesion of NATO reinforced by Russian president: Defense College commandant,” Anadolu Agency, , JH
The commandant of NATO Defense College said the cohesion of the alliance has been even reinforced by Russian President Vladimir Putin's recent actions, now that the region sees the Russian threat.
Lt. Gen. Olivier Rittimann told Anadolu Agency in an interview that Ukraine was a partner of NATO and so there is a difference between a partner and an ally.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
The Diplomat 22, The Diplomat is an international online peer-reviewed news magazine covering politics, society, and culture in the Indo-Pacific region based in Washington, D.C, 6/23/22, “Turkey hosts panel discussion on NATO to coincide with the Summit,” The Diplomat, , JH
On Tuesday 28 June from 14:00 to 16:30, the Communications Directorate of the Presidency of the Republic of Turkey will host a panel discussion on ‘NATO, from regional to global: Dialogue, enlargement and cohesion’ at the Mandarin Oriental Ritz Hotel in Madrid.
Convened at an unfortunate time when Europe is once again experiencing war after more than half a century, the NATO Alliance, of which Turkey has been a member for 70 years and Spain for 40, will hold its next summit from 28-30 June in Madrid, bringing together heads of state and government from 30 countries. This summit will also adopt the Alliance’s New Strategic Concept in the face of today’s security challenges. This juncture has already positioned the Madrid Summit as one of the most successful and special meetings in the Alliance’s history.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Thumpers › AT: Turkey hurts cohesion
Mehmet Tosun 22, Dr. Tosun is the Barbara Smith Campbell Distinguished Professor at the University of Nevada, 6/23/22, “Unity, solidarity against common threats key for NATO, Türkiye tells US,” Anadolu Agency, , JH
There must be unity, harmony and solidarity among NATO allies against common security and terrorist threats, Türkiye’s Presidential spokesperson Ibrahim Kalin said in a phone call with US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan on Thursday.
Along with bilateral political and economic ties, the officials held discussions on Türkiye’s role in NATO and contributions to the alliance, the upcoming NATO Madrid summit, Sweden and Finland’s NATO bids, grain shipments through the Black Sea and other regional issues, according to a statement from the Turkish presidential spokesperson.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Overstretch Brinks
Goodman 6/21/22 [Matthew P. Goodman is senior vice president for economics and holds the Simon Chair in Political Economy at CSIS.; “Press Briefing: Previewing the G7 and NATO Summits”; Center for Strategic and International Studies; June 21, 2022; https://www.csis.org/analysis/press-briefing-previewing-g7-and-nato-summits-0]//eleanor
There have been some ad hoc meetings, but this is the first sort of annual meeting of the year for those two summits. So it’s a pretty significant trip because, obviously, this is a chance to affirm and bolster U.S. alliances, to bolster democracy. I think those are going to be the overarching themes across both summits. But, obviously, there’s some pretty significant headwinds here. You know, you have Ukraine bogged down. You’ve got inflation raging, you know, a series of crises from food to energy to health to climate. So this is going to be a pretty challenging set of meetings and I think, you know, the good news is that President Biden has some wind at his back because he was able to mobilize this group of allies and partners to take on the Russia-Ukraine challenge initially. But the question is can he move the ball forward on these two – at these two meetings.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Concept = Cohesion
Lusa 6/22/22, “Portugal: NATO summit will show cohesion between allies at time of conflict – military chief,” Macau News Agency, , JH
The chief of staff of the armed forces (CEMGFA) considered on Tuesday that the NATO summit will show “cohesion” between allies, noting that the new strategic concept will be approved at a time of conflict in Europe.
“In military terms, what I can say is that we will have, from the Madrid summit onwards, a great demonstration of the strength of the Atlantic Alliance in terms of its cohesion and what are the structuring documents to build an auspicious future for this extraordinary alliance which has been extremely relevant in terms of peace guarantees on the European continent,” he said.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Unity Now
VOV 22, News site, 6/23/22, “German Chancellor expect NATO’s cohesion and determination,” VOV World, , JH
(VOVWORLD) - German Chancellor Olaf Scholz on Wednesday spoke to parliament about the upcoming European Union, G7, and NATO summits, where he expects a cohesion and determination from NATO leaders on the issue of the Ukraine conflict.
He promised that Germany and Europe will continue to support Ukraine financially, politically, and with weapons. However, he said, NATO will not become a combatant and he promised Ukraine a "Marshall plan" of long-term support for reconstruction after the war. As G7 President, the German Chancellor wants to convene an international conference to work towards an agreement on investments in Ukraine.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cooperation/Slow Consultation Now
NATO 22 [Nato, 6-17-2022,, Brussels Summit Communiqué issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in Brussels 14 June 2021 NATO, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_185000.htm] Eric
We, the Heads of State and Government of the 30 NATO Allies, have gathered in Brussels to reaffirm our unity, solidarity, and cohesion, and to open a new chapter in transatlantic relations, at a time when the security environment we face is increasingly complex. NATO remains the foundation of our collective defence and the essential forum for security consultations and decisions among Allies. NATO is a defensive Alliance and will continue to strive for peace, security, and stability in the whole of the Euro-Atlantic area. We remain firmly committed to NATO’s founding Washington Treaty, including that an attack against one Ally shall be considered an attack against us all, as enshrined in Article 5. We will continue to pursue a 360-degree approach to protect and defend our indivisible security and to fulfil NATO’s three core tasks of collective defence, crisis management, and cooperative security.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cooperation/Slow Consultation Now
Liptak 22 [Kevin Liptak is a reporter covering the White House. He previously covered President Trump's foreign and domestic policy, campaign politics and the internal dynamics of the administration, 6-25-2022, Biden heads to Europe to keep allies united against Russia as a grinding war in Ukraine takes its toll, CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2022/06/25/politics/what-to-watch-from-biden-at-the-g7-and-nato/index.html] Eric thanks 4rsland
At the start of the war, western leaders rallied behind a sanctions regime to isolate Russian President Vladimir Putin. But months later, how to bring the war to an end — and potentially end the sanctions that are helping drive inflation — have led to strain.
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who visited Kyiv for the second time last week, has positioned himself as a top ally of Zelensky and insists Ukraine “must win.” French President Emmanuel Macron, meanwhile, has warned against “humiliating” Russia. And along with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, he has maintained open channels of communication with the Kremlin.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cohesion Strong
Stavridis 18 [Admiral Stavridis (Ret.), a TIME Contributing Editor, was the 16th Supreme Allied Commander at NATO and is Vice Chair, Global Affairs at The Carlyle Group and Chair of the Board of the Rockefeller Foundation. He is the co-author of . His new nonfiction book is , 7-11-2018, Why NATO Is Essential For World Peace, According to Its Former Commander, Time, https://time.com/5564171/why-nato-is-essential-world-peace/] Eric
For all those harbingers of trouble, though, by many traditional measures, NATO remains extremely healthy.
It is powerful. The 29 nations of NATO produce more than 50% of the world’s gross domestic product, have well over 3 million troops on duty, operate massive combined naval fleets and air forces and together spend over $1 trillion on defense. Indeed, even with all the frustration over European defense spending not hitting the 2% of GDP goal, the collective European defense budget is the second largest in the world after the U.S.’s and is ahead of China’s and Russia’s–combined.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cohesion/Focus Now
NATO citing Geoană 6/10/22 [Mircea Geoană is NATO Deputy Secretary General; “Deputy Secretary General previews NATO’s next Strategic Concept at Copenhagen Democracy Summit”; June 10, 2022; https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_196299.htm]//eleanor
Mr Geoană explained that the new Concept will reflect an era of great power competition, and recognise that Russia has become “one of the most important challenges to our security in Europe and also beyond”. He added that China’s role as a transformative player in world affairs will also be acknowledged. The next Strategic Concept will further highlight the importance of resilience and new technologies for Euro-Atlantic security. Speaking about deterrence and defence, the Deputy Secretary General noted that NATO anticipates “a new generation of our presence in the East”. At the Madrid Summit, leaders will adapt the Alliance’s posture on the eastern flank for the longer term to reflect the new security reality. Mr Geoană said this is likely to include measures for faster and more effective reinforcement. The Copenhagen Democracy Summit is an annual conference bringing together political and business leaders, including current and former heads of government, from the world’s democracies. It is led by Anders Fogh Rasmussen, Founder and Chairman of The Alliance of Democracies Foundation. Mr Rasmussen served as Secretary General of NATO from 2009 to 2014.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cohesion/Focus Now
Thomson and Stacey 6/19/22 [Sir Adam Thomson, former United Kingdom ambassador to NATO, is now director of the European Leadership Network, a not-for-profit network of leaders working for a safer Europe. Sir Graham Stacey, former chief of staff of NATO Transformation, is senior consulting fellow at the European Leadership Network.; “NATO’s next Strategic Concept: Getting modern deterrence right”; The Hill; June 19, 2022; https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/3529051-natos-next-strategic-concept-getting-modern-deterrence-right/]//eleanor
NATO leaders meet in Madrid next week on June 29 – 30. Among other things, they are pledged to agree on a new Strategic Concept, replacing the one that has broadly guided the Alliance since 2010. The Strategic Concept is not the Alliance’s only guiding document, but it does set the tone and direction for many years to come and is referred to almost daily as NATO’s 30 nations struggle to forge consensus. It is important to get it right. Maybe the confrontation with Russia will make this too difficult or premature and leaders will defer the new Concept until 2023 — but all Allies recognize that the 2010 language on Russia is wildly out of date. And so too is the language on deterrence. The Alliance is facing an unstable period of cold war-style dynamics and potential nuclear brinkmanship. Strong defense will be essential. The next Concept will rightly reflect moves already underway towards increased defense expenditure, greater national resilience, and increased consultation and Alliance cohesion. This will include forward deployment of forces and enhanced operational activity along NATO/Russia borders But while strong defense is necessary for deterrence, it does not guarantee it. For effective collective defense in unstable times, the 2022 Strategic Concept must deliver modern deterrence fit for the next decade.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › Uniq --- Cohesion/Focus Now
McRaven 4/20/22 [William H. McRaven, a Senior Adviser at Lazard, is a retired Navy Admiral and was Commander of the U.S. Special Operations Command from 2011 to 2014. Peter Orszag is the Chief Executive Officer of Financial Advisory at Lazard. He was Director of the Office of Management and Budget from 2009 to 2010 and Director of the Congressional Budget Office from 2007 to 2008. Theodore Bunzel, the head of Lazard Geopolitical Advisory, has worked in the political section of the U.S. Embassy in Moscow and at the U.S. Treasury Department.; “Made in the Alliance”; Foreign Affairs; April 20, 2022; https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/world/2022-04-20/made-alliance]//eleanor
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has reinvigorated the Western alliance and bolstered transatlantic solidarity. After being declared “brain dead” by French President Emmanuel Macron in 2019, NATO has sprung to life, deploying forces to its eastern flank and coordinating the provision of sophisticated weapons that have helped Ukraine impede Russia’s invasion. For the first time in its history, the European Union has financed the purchase and delivery of lethal aid. Western countries have vastly exceeded expectations in implementing coordinated financial sanctions that have crippled Russia’s economy. Even neutral Switzerland joined the fray. But no matter how remarkable this solidarity may be in the short term, there is no guarantee that it will last: if policymakers are complacent, powerful trends predating the Ukraine crisis could overwhelm and ultimately derail it. Protectionist sentiment and self-defeating trade wars have pulled at the seams of Western economic integration. Former U.S. President Donald Trump’s threats to pull out of NATO and the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021 have chipped away at military trust between the United States and Europe. A Marine Le Pen victory later this month in France would pose additional challenges to the alliance, and looming concerns about the 2024 presidential election raise doubts about the United States’ commitment. If not managed intelligently, the reawakening of Europe as a diplomatic and military actor and the reexamination of global economic interdependence catalyzed by Russia’s invasion could result not in a strengthened transatlantic alliance but in a more worrying outcome: the emergence of three distinct blocs, one centered around the United States, a second around Europe, and a third around China (which would include Russia). Such a world—with the United States and Europe often collaborating, but also at odds when their interests diverge—would make the management of China and Russia more difficult, as the two would have opportunities to trigger and exploit U.S.-European tensions. It would also represent a major missed opportunity for the United States and Europe.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › AT: NATO AI Now
Dr. Sharma 5/30/22
(Sanur, Dr Sanur Sharma is Associate Fellow at Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, “NATO’s AI Push And Military Implications – Analysis,” pg online @ //um-ef)
The strategic surge in EDTs is driven by the accelerated investment towards the military adoption and innovation of EDTs and maintaining a sustainable innovation ecosystem that can be achieved through civil–military collaboration. In 2021, NATO endorsed the strategy on EDTs that included AI and machine learning among the seven identified key technologies (Data, AI, Autonomy, Quantum, Space, Biotechnology, and Hypersonic).6 The strategy plans to invest US$ 1 billion in building test centres across Europe and North America, focusing on emerging technologies like AI, Quantum and hypersonics.7
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › AT: NATO AI Now
Burt ‘21
(Peter, “NATO's new AI strategy: lacking in substance and lacking in leadership,” pg online @ //um-ef)
NATO's ethical principles for the responsible use of AI, though welcome, raise several issues. Such statements of principle are now commonplace in the corporate sector and are increasingly being adopted by governments on both a unilateral and multilateral basis. NATO's principles are similar to principles adopted by the US Department of Defense for the ethical use of AI: indeed, in some places the wording is the same as that in the Department of Defense principles. As with many such statements of principle, the NATO principles have no coherent means of implementation or enforcement. Their successful adoption will in many ways depend upon leadership and political and military culture, which is different in each of NATO's 30 member states. Will Turkey, for example, which has been a keen proponent of automated warfare and by some accounts has already developed AI-based loitering munitions with an autonomous capability to identify targets, be willing to follow the same rules as the USA? And would the USA under a second Trump administration follow the same rules as a Biden administration? In the absence of any binding enforcement mechanism NATO's principles may provide useful for public relations purposes but are likely to be less useful in preventing harm to humans, particularly those in the Global South who are already in situations of conflict, and historically marginalised groups. Despite the plethora of corporate statements on ethical principles, those working in the tech sector are sceptical about the prospect that ethical AI design will be adopted as a norm over the next decade. A non-random poll conducted by the Pew Research Centre in early 2021 found that 68% of experts in the field thought that ethical principles focused primarily on the public good will not be employed in most AI systems by 2030. Their concerns recognised that the main developers and deployers of AI are focused on profit-seeking and social control, and that global competition will matter more to the development of AI than any ethical issues. This latter factor will very much influence NATO's future adoption of AI. Although NATO's ethical AI principles are stated to have been developed on the basis of “Allied approaches and relevant work in applicable international fora”, it is not clear whether they draw on views from the wide range of professional disciplines necessary to develop a representative and rounded view of the ethical pitfalls and risks associated for AI, or from a diversity of perspectives. There has certainly been no open consultation on their formulation, 4 and it is possible that the principles may only represent the perceptions of a relatively narrow range of predominantly white male technocrats and military planners drawn from within NATO, member governments (notably the USA), and the arms industry. Ordinary people, particularly marginalised groups and those in the Global South, will ultimately face the consequences and impacts of NATO's decisions on AI systems, yet the public have certainly not been involved in making decisions on this strategy, which will set the framework for NATO's future AI choices. NATO's AI strategy does not discuss the development of AI-driven autonomous weapon systems – a significant omission, given the ethical issues that this application of AI would raise and the challenges to human rights that such weapons would pose. As a bare minimum, the strategy could—and should—have endorsed the 'Guiding Principles' on emerging technologies in the area of lethal autonomous weapons which have recently been adopted by consensus by High Contracting Parties to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW). Despite increasing pressure for a ban on the development and use of lethal autonomous weapons, key NATO states including the USA and UK have been lukewarm about the need for a ban, arguing that current laws of war are adequate to regulate any such weapons. This seems optimistic, given the rapid development of AI technology and the push by some states over recent years to redefine the rules that govern use of armed force to suit their own purposes. To date no NATO member states have supported the call for a ban on lethal autonomous weapons. If NATO members were serious about ensuring that the military use of AI adheres to international humanitarian law and human rights law, they would call for and engage in negotiations on a legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems at the CCW; which is expected to take a historic decision on this issue at its Review Conference in December 2021. Investment and innovation in artificial intelligence is being led by the private sector, and not by the world’s militaries. Recognising this, NATO's AI strategy places a premium on engaging with “start-ups, innovative small and medium enterprises, and academic researchers that either have not considered working on defence and security solutions, or simply find the adoption pathways too slow or restrictive for their business models”. NATO wants to “make defence and security a more attractive sector for civilian innovators to partner with”. Aiming to capture the civilian tech sector in this way risks increasing the influence of the military-industrialpolitical complex to an even greater extent than is already the case. Will this really help advance NATO's liberal and democratic values? Conclusion Although NATO's AI strategy contains a few worthwhile nuggets, on balance it is tame and unambitious. It is depressingly clear that NATO sees AI as basically another way of using technology to wage war more effectively, and is not willing to show any real leadership to mitigate the risks that AI poses to human rights and dignity. War is, after all, the highest area of risk when it comes to the potential for human rights abuses, yet NATO's strategy says nothing about measures to effectively govern military AI and autonomous weapon systems. AI has the potential to help humanity tackle intractable 'wicked problems' such as climate change and unsustainable development, and tackle the course of dangerous behaviour which is threatening the survival of our species. But this will only happen if it is employed under wise and decisive human leadership, otherwise it may dramatically compound the problems we face, threatening international security and human rights even more. NATO, unfortunately, seems unwilling to provide that leadership. Acknowledgement: The author would like to thank Wanda Muñoz for advice and comments on an earlier draft of this paper. Author: Peter Burt is a researcher at Drone Wars UK working on issues relating to artificial intelligence and autonomy and their role in the future development of drones. Before moving to Drone Wars UK Peter was Director for the Nuclear Information Service for six years, and he is also a Trustee the Nuclear Education Trust.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › AT: EDT Now
Sonne 21 [Paul Sonne, 2-16-2021, Biden administration takes more cooperative approach to its first high-level NATO meeting, Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/nato-meeting-biden-trump/2021/02/16/b42d00d0-709f-11eb-a4eb-44012a612cf9_story.html] Eric thanks 4rsland
The Biden administration is preparing to strike a more cooperative tone at the first meeting of senior NATO officials since President Donald Trump departed office, as the alliance faces difficult questions about how to proceed with a frayed and when to withdraw the remaining forces from Afghanistan. The change in approach by Washington comes as the 72-year-old military alliance looks to find its footing after a tumultuous four years dealing with Trump. The challenges are vast — from defending against Russia, evolving to consider threats posed by China, and extricating forces from Afghanistan without prompting a collapse of the nation’s NATO-backed government and military force. Senior U.S. defense officials, in a briefing with reporters, signaled that Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin wouldn’t offer any U.S. decisions on Afghanistan at the virtual two-day NATO meeting for defense ministers that begins Wednesday, as the Biden administration reviews its policy ahead of a May 1 deadline for the full withdrawal of U.S. troops set out in the . The senior officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss the thinking of Pentagon leaders ahead of the NATO meeting, underscored that violence must be reduced in Afghanistan and said the Biden administration was reviewing the peace agreement in particular. One of the senior officials said the Taliban’s compliance with the deal — which U.S. officials have criticized — would be a key part of the review. “It will play into how our government comes to a conclusion on where we should go,” one of the senior defense officials said, noting that the United States looked forward to consulting with NATO allies on the issue in the days and weeks to come. The deliberations within the U.S. government over Afghanistan come as NATO faces an array of challenges, including in Iraq, where a NATO training and advisory mission, welcomed by the Biden administration, has continued amid attacks that Iraqi and Western officials have blamed on Iran-backed militias. On Monday night, coalition forces in Irbil were struck in an that left a civilian contractor dead and a U.S. service member injured. Other challenges await: Russia is launching increasingly sophisticated cyber campaigns, including the most recent SolarWinds hack. Turkey, a NATO member, is blocking work and picking fights inside the alliance. And the United States, according to the senior U.S. defense officials, wants NATO to put China on its priority list. Most notable at this week’s meeting is likely to be the change in style by the new U.S. administration toward its fellow NATO members. Trump often threatened NATO allies about their defense spending and used a bullying approach that led some world leaders to and his freewheeling news conferences. But at NATO, worries about Washington extended beyond Trump’s tone. European diplomats said they would sometimes wake up at 3 a.m. to check Trump’s Twitter feed to see if he had announced a sudden shift in U.S. military posture. They would spend weeks carefully laying out strategic plans with lower-level U.S. officials, only to have everything upended by a new pronouncement from the Oval Office. Sometimes, U.S. officials would come to them to try to find ways to work around Trump’s anger toward the alliance. President Biden has said he will take a far different approach to NATO and has gone out of his way to signal support for the alliance, including by recording a video of a friendly phone call to NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg last month. After Austin became defense secretary, the Pentagon scheduled Stoltenberg as his first call, and Biden has already halted a partial withdrawal of U.S. troops from Germany that Trump ordered, as the Pentagon evaluates what forces should be stationed where. Some four weeks into the new administration, NATO diplomats are still sorting out the rules of the game inside the glassy alliance headquarters in Brussels. Trump’s ambassador to NATO, Kay Bailey Hutchison, is gone, replaced for now by her former deputy, Chargé d’Affaires Douglas Jones. Biden has yet to announce his nominee for the post. One significant shift so far, diplomats said, is that the Biden administration appears interested in hearing the views of allies on issues including operations in Afghanistan, where in addition to , 8,000 forces from allied and partner nations remain. Earlier this month, officials from the White House, State Department and Pentagon joined a conference call with NATO ambassadors, who detailed their countries’ positions on deployments and the security situation. A number of diplomats said it was a departure from Trump-era practice — and that they were delighted. Stoltenberg signaled his eagerness to move on from the acrimony of the Trump era. “It’s no secret that over the last four years, we had some difficult discussions inside NATO, but now we look to the future,” he told reporters Monday ahead of the defense ministers’ meeting. “And the future is that we now have an administration in the United States, in Washington, which is strongly committed to the transatlantic bond, to NATO, to Europe and North America working together.” One of the senior U.S. defense officials underscored the point on Tuesday. “Consultation is really kind of the name of the game here,” the official said, describing the expected tone of the meeting. The task of repairing the U.S. relationship with members of the alliance is significant, after some policymakers said their bandwidth was consumed by catering to Trump’s whims and acting as if he hadn’t upended the military organization. “The level of anxiety is still high after four years of trauma,” a senior NATO diplomat said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal alliance conversations. “It’s been four years of denial and sort of faking things, repeating over and over again, ‘This is a strong NATO, we can become even stronger.’ ”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › General › AT: EDT Now
Warrell ‘21
(Hellen, “Nato allies need to speed up AI defence co-operation,” pg online @ //um-ef)
Nato is proposing a new tech innovation centre bringing together military personnel with industry to foster digital defence start-ups. Some of these might be financed by a separate initiative, also set to be debated: a venture capital fund for innovation which member states could choose to opt in to. The efforts are belated, as Nato secretary-general Jens Stoltenberg himself acknowledged. “For decades, Nato allies have been leading when it comes to technology, but that’s not obvious any more,” he told the Financial Times in an interview last week. “We see China especially investing heavily in new, disruptive technologies like artificial intelligence, autonomous systems, big data, and they implement them into new advanced weapon systems, drones, submarines, aircraft and so on.” He is not the first to sound the alarm. Eric Schmidt, the former Google chief executive who now chairs the US’s National Security Commission on AI, warned earlier this year that Beijing was planning to undermine conventional military forces by “leapfrogging” to new technologies. The commission’s report, published in March, raised concerns that China would use AI for “reconnaissance, electromagnetic countermeasures and co-ordinated firepower strikes”. Part of the problem is that western defence institutions have been slow to recognise the potential of innovation beyond their own industry. “For decades, a lot of technological development would happen within the defence sector — the internet, nuclear, GPS, all of that was developed by the defence industry and then shared with the civilian sector,” Stoltenberg said. “Now, it goes the other way around. It’s a civilian sector which is leading in the development of artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and many of the new disruptive technologies.” Some Nato members are ahead of others. The US and France have published military AI strategies, while the UK announced this year that it is to establish a centre for defence AI. For the first time, Britain’s intelligence agency, MI6, is recruiting from the private sector for a new head of its “Q” branch — the technical lab made famous in the James Bond films. Establishing a new Nato hub — known as an “accelerator” — in which tech companies and members of the armed forces can experiment with new ideas has advantages, according to Professor Fiona Murray, co-director of MIT’s innovation initiative. Start-ups and investors do not always have the time to tackle defence challenges when solutions are “hard to test, markets are fragmented and procurement is slow”, Murray said. Working together would create a wider market for new products and enhance collective security, she noted. It was “not enough” for countries to be handling this individually, she said. The US has started marshalling allies on the policy implications of using new technology. The Pentagon’s “AI Partnership for Defense”, comprising 13 countries (including Nato members Canada, Denmark, Estonia, the UK, France and Norway) met virtually for the first time last year to agree joint military standards on AI. Schmidt’s commission has called on the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance (the US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand) to work more closely on developing AI systems. Ulrike Franke, an expert in military technology at the European Council on Foreign Relations, argues that Nato’s tech centre will be most effective if it prioritises systems designed to facilitate joint military operations. The alliance should look at areas such as AI-enabled command and control, she said, which could give members a unified picture of the battlefield across multiple regions, using intelligent data analysis to sift information. Franke said that in the vast arena spanning drones to quantum computing, there was a temptation to cover too much. “It makes massive sense for Nato to look more at this [technology]”, she said. “The question is, what exactly are they focusing on? There’s a danger of Nato spreading itself too thin.”