2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NON-MILITARY CP/DA UPDATES › 1NC › 1NC---OFF
Reynolds and Maehr 21 [Molly E Reynolds, Senior Fellow - Governance Studies; Naomi Maehr, Research Assistant, Governance Studies - The Brookings Institution; "Amid polarization, bipartisan oversight still exists in Congress"; Brookings; Published: 9-21-2021; Accessed: 6-20-2022; https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2021/09/21/amid-polarization-bipartisan-oversight-still-exists-in-congress/; KL]
Since Democrats assumed unified control of government in Washington last January, many of Congress’s highest-profile investigations have been beset by partisan conflict. The House’s effort to investigate the insurrection at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, for example, is now being led by a select committee that has only two Republican members—both named by Democrats. That move came after the House GOP leadership pulled its entire slate of recommended committee members in response to a refusal by Speaker Nancy Pelosi to empanel several proponents of the “Big Lie” about the 2020 election.
But House committees’ oversight of the executive branch extends far beyond these headline-grabbing issues. Even amid House Democrats’ often contentious oversight of the Trump administration in 2019 and 2020, occasional bipartisan investigations emerged—and an early look at the 117th Congress to date suggests oversight can still be bipartisan even during high partisan conflict.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › Words and Phrases Defense---2NC
Words and Phrases ’4 [Words and Phrases Dictionary; 1904; written by Members of the Editorial Staff of the National Reporter System; Volume 1, “A/Casting Vote,” p. iii]
This compilation represents the first systematic attempt to present in complete and available form the vast quantity of judicial interpretation and construction of the meaning of words and phrases found in the reported decisions of the American appellate courts. It has been over ten years in preparation, and has involved enormous editorial labor and research. The effort has been made to secure all the words judicially defined and all the definitions of each word. In collecting the material recourse has been had in all cases to the opinions of the courts as the original sources, and the work is the result of a page-to-page examination of the reported American cases. A careful search for definitions for words and phrases has also been made in all the latest codes and revisions of statutes, state and federal.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › No Redundancy---2NC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “Surplusage Canon,” Ch. 26]
If possible, every word and every provision is to be given effect (verba cum effectu sunt accipienda1). None should be ignored. None should needlessly be given an interpretation that causes it to duplicate another provision or to have no consequence.
“These words cannot be meaningless, else they would not have been used.”
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › “Include” Does Not Exclude---2AC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “Presumption of Nonexclusive Include,” Ch. 15]
The verb to include introduces examples, not an exhaustive list.
In normal English usage, if a group “consists of” or “comprises” 300 lawyers, it contains precisely that number. If it “includes” 300 lawyers, there may well be thousands of other members from all walks of life as well. That is, the word include does not ordinarily introduce an exhaustive list, while comprise—with an exception that we will discuss shortly—ordinarily does. That is the rule both in good English usage1 and in textualist decision-making.2 Some jurisdictions have even codified a rule about include.3
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › Intent to Exclude Necessary---2AC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “General-Terms Canon,” Ch. 10]
Virtually all the authorities who discuss the negative-implication canon emphasize that it must be applied with great caution, since its application depends so much on context.1 Indeed, one commentator suggests that it is not a proper canon at all but merely a description of the result gleaned from context.2 That goes too far. Context establishes the conditions for applying the canon, but where those conditions exist, the principle that specification of the one implies exclusion of the other validly describes how people express themselves and understand verbal expression.
The doctrine properly applies only when the unius (or technically, unum, the thing specified) can reasonably be thought to be an expression of all that shares in the grant or prohibition involved. Common sense often suggests when this is or is not so. The sign outside a restaurant “No dogs allowed” cannot be thought to mean that no other creatures are excluded—as if pet monkeys, potbellied pigs, and baby elephants might be quite welcome. Dogs are specifically addressed because they are the animals that customers are most likely to bring in; nothing is implied about other animals. On the other hand, the sign outside a veterinary clinic saying “Open for treatment of dogs, cats, horses, and all other farm and domestic animals” does suggest (by its detail) that the circus lion with a health problem is out of luck. (Notice how ejusdem generis [§ 32] also comes into play with this example.) The more specific the enumeration, the greater the force of the canon:
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › Intent To Exclude Unnecessary---2NC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “General-Terms Canon,” Ch. 10]
The expression of one thing implies the exclusion of others (expressio unius est exclusio alterius).
Expressio unius, also known as inclusio unius, is a Latin name for the communicative device known as negative implication. In English, it is known as the negative-implication canon. We encounter the device—and recognize it—frequently in our daily lives. When a car dealer promises a low financing rate to “purchasers with good credit,” it is entirely clear that the rate is not available to purchasers with spotty credit.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › General Terms---2AC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “General-Terms Canon,” Ch. 9]
General terms are to be given their general meaning (generalia verba sunt generaliter intelligenda).
Without some indication to the contrary, general words (like all words, general or not) are to be accorded their full and fair scope. They are not to be arbitrarily limited. This is the general-terms canon, which is based on the reality that it is possible and useful to formulate categories (e.g., “dangerous weapons”) without knowing all the items that may fit—or may later, once invented, come to fit—within those categories.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Predictability › Plain Meaning---2AC
Scalia ’12 [Antonin Scalia and Bryan Garner; 2012; Justice on the Supreme Court of the United States; American lawyer, lexicographer, and teacher; Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts, “Ordinary-Meaning Canon,” Ch. 6]
Words are to be understood in their ordinary, everyday meanings—unless the context indicates that they bear a technical sense.
“The enlightened patriots who framed our constitution, and the people who adopted it, must be understood to have employed words in their natural sense, and to have intended what they have said.”
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---Broad+Predictble CI---2AC
RWCS ’20 [Real World Cyber Security; April 14; cyber analyst with deep expertise and extensive experience in embedded systems product development and product development security, including hardware security, secure boot, software and firmware security, network and protocol security, operating systems hardening, user interaction and user experience security, industrial design security, data protection and data privacy, cryptographic security, secure software development practices, security test and evaluation, government product security certifications and validation, intellectual property protection, import/export compliance, product liability, supply chain integrity, security in mergers and acquisitions, and corporate security governance; RWCS, “Defining Cybersecurity,” ]
If You Can’t Properly Define Cybersecurity, How Can You Know What It Is?
It’s clear that the cybersecurity industry hasn’t been able to agree upon what cybersecurity is and isn’t. Even NIST, who is responsible for the definition of technical terms used by the U.S. Federal Government, has four different definitions of cybersecurity! At a minimum, there are dozens of different definitions of cybersecurity currently in use. Nearly all are incomplete in scope, some are horridly wrong, and nearly all fail to differentiate between cybersecurity and its information security cousin.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---Excludes Nuclear Weapons---1NC
Lin ’21 [Herbert; Summer; senior research scholar for cyber policy and security at the Center for International Security and Cooperation and Hank J. Holland Fellow in Cyber Policy and Security at the Hoover Institution, both at Stanford University; Texas National Security Review, ]
The Energy Department also depends on computer-controlled fabrication machinery that shapes various components of nuclear weapons, such as the high-explosive components used to compress fissile material to critical mass. But because the shapes must be precisely machined to very tight tolerances, the equipment used to fabricate charges is necessarily controlled by computers. Although these computers would not be connected directly to the internet, it must be possible to program them, and they must access data from appropriate databases to fabricate the components in question. Compromising these programs or data could cause the components to be fabricated in ways that are slightly off from the specification. Such imperfections would likely be caught in subsequent inspections, but their deliberate introduction into the fabrication process would be a definite minus for quality control.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---Excludes Nuclear Weapons---1NC
Von Solms ’18 [Basie and Rossouw; March 12; Academy for Computer Science and Software Engineering, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg, South Africa; School of ICT, Nelson Mandela University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa; Information and Computer Security, “Cybersecurity and information security – what goes where?,” ISSN: 2056-4961]
The definitions and explanations of cybersecurity and cybersecurity governance argued above allow us to present cybersecurity to executive management from the following point of view:
Cybersecurity aims to protect against the risks which arise because one’s organization is connected to the internet in some way or another. The more one is dependent on the internet, i.e. the more services one’s company provides via and using the internet, the bigger the cyber threat and the more comprehensive one’s cybersecurity efforts and commitments should be.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---Excludes Cybercrime---1NC
Graham ’17 [Roderick S. Graham; Oct 18; Assistant Professor of Sociology, Old Dominion University; “The difference between cybersecurity and cybercrime, and why it matters,” https://theconversation.com/the-difference-between-cybersecurity-and-cybercrime-and-why-it-matters-85654]
This story is a cautionary example of a crime that happens online. But most advice for avoiding online dangers – like having long passwords, using two-factor authentication and encrypting data – wouldn’t have helped Amy.
The crime that befell her has nothing to do with cybersecurity. It’s cybercrime, a human-centered crime committed in a digital environment. There are more of these each year: In the U.S. in 2016, 298,728 complainants reported losing more than $1.3 billion in various types of cybercrimes, including romance scams but also involving fraudulent online sales, extortion, violent harassment and impersonation scams, among others. As a social scientist who studies online behavior and as the program coordinator for one of the few cybercrime undergraduate programs in the United States, I find it unfortunate that problems like Amy’s get relatively little national attention, especially compared to cybersecurity.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---CIA Triad---AT: Kosseff is Normative/Unpredictable---2NC
Kosseff ’18 [Jeff; March; Assistant Professor of Cybersecurity Law, United States Naval Academy. J.D., Georgetown University Law Center; M.P.P., B.A., University of Michigan; Iowa Law Review, “Defining Cybersecurity Law,” 103 Iowa L. Rev. 985, lexis]
This Article: has attempted to formulate a definition of "cybersecurity law" that broadly encompasses our modern conception of cybersecurity, and addresses the most significant cyber-threats that the United States currently confronts. Of course, this definition is only one formulation, based on our nation's current cybersecurity threats. This Article: does not advocate for specific policy changes to improve cybersecurity. Rather, it identifies the key areas of cybersecurity law that are not addressed adequately by current U.S. laws. As policymakers and courts continue to address cybersecurity law, it is increasingly important that they use a common taxonomy and have an understanding of all areas that should be covered by their statutes, regulations, and court rulings.
Providing a taxonomy and a proposed set of goals is only the first step toward focusing the U.S. legal system on the actual cyber-threats that the public and private sector face. This common definition and aspiration will allow for coherence and a broad framework as scholars, policymakers, and legislators evaluate our existing laws and consider new policies. Part V of this Article: provides a starting point for discussion as to how U.S. laws could better achieve the ultimate goals of cybersecurity. Future scholarship can use this definition and these goals to propose solutions to evolving cybersecurity threats.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Cybersecurity › Cybersecurity---CIA Triad---1NC
Cybersecurity law promotes the confidentiality, , integrity, and availability of public and private information, systems, and networks
Kosseff ’18 [Jeff; March; Assistant Professor of Cybersecurity Law, United States Naval Academy. J.D., Georgetown University Law Center; M.P.P., B.A., University of Michigan; Iowa Law Review, “Defining Cybersecurity Law,” 103 Iowa L. Rev. 985, lexis]
In late 2015, after years of attempts, Congress passed legislation to enable companies to voluntarily share information about cybersecurity threats - such as attempted hacks - with the federal government and other companies. The bill, entitled the Cybersecurity Act of 2015, was tucked into a massive omnibus appropriations bill as Division N. 1 The Cybersecurity Act occupies 136 of the 2,009 pages in the omnibus bill, and it in detail establishes rules for operators of private networks to defend their networks, monitor possible threats, and collaborate with the federal government. 2 The new law also bolsters the Department of Homeland Security's ("DHS") cybersecurity efforts. The focus of the legislation, not surprisingly, is cybersecurity; indeed, "cybersecurity" appears in the bill nearly 200 times. 3
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Biotechnology › Biotech---AT: Excludes SynthBio---2AC
Melson ‘4 [Ashley; 2004; Associate, The Barkley Law Firm, PC. B.S. P.T., University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, 1997 and J.D., Valedictorian, University of Tulsa College of Law; “Bioterrorism, Biodefense, and Biotechnology in the Military: A Comparative Analysis of Legal and Ethical Issues in the Research, Development, and Use of Biotechnological Products on American and British Soldiers,” 14 Alb. L.J. Sci. & Tech. 497, lexis]
Biology, 1 one of the three primary natural sciences, like its counterpart sciences of chemistry and physics, uses the experimental method 3 Unlike its counterparts, however, the study of biology inherently involves living things, including human beings. 4 Because of this distinction, which implicates both human rights and the Hippocratic Oath, 5 the experimental method becomes legally and ethically unacceptable as a means of studying biology, at least when human subjects are involved. 6 Further, knowledge gleaned in this science does not truly come to fruition until applied and used in the real world through technological innovations, thus the term "biotechnology." 7
Although not officially defined until 1919 by Hungarian engineer, Karl Ereky, 8 the first example of biotechnological innovations noted in literature dates back well before Ereky's time to the selective breeding of livestock and growing of crops during the Agricultural Revolution. 9 Today, a sort of "biotechnological age" is being realized, 10 as the United States (U.S.) Government, alone, invested over $ 18 billion in biotechnology research and development (R&D) for fiscal year 2000. 11 This figure is dwarfed by the R&D budgets of large pharmaceutical companies and other commercial investors. 12
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Biotechnology › Biotech---AT: Excludes SynthBio---2AC
Dieulis ’18 [Diane; Nov 27; Senior Research Fellow at the Center for the Study of Weapons of Mass Destruction and leads studies on biosecurity, biodefense and the synthetic biology industry, a biologist by training and served for over two decades in various capacities at the Department of Health and Human Services and the Office of Science and Technology Policy at the White House; War on the Rocks, “Biotechnology for the Battlefield: In Need of a Strategy,” https://warontherocks.com/2018/11/biotechnology-for-the-battlefield-in-need-of-a-strategy]
If today’s technology headlines are any indication, the science fiction of comic books is becoming science reality. Impenetrable skin and resilience to gamma rays are no longer just for superheroes. For instance, scientists have recently discovered ways to create spider silk, an innovative biotechnology that can lead to lighter, more flexible, and stronger body armor. And microscopic animals nicknamed “water bears” are showing promise to protect soldiers from the health effects of radiation exposure by boosting capacity for DNA repair or even preventing damage to DNA in the first place.
Biotechnology — a broad term used to describe technological innovation based on biology — has become an increasingly agile platform for developing new types of soldier enhancements. As such, the field offers novel opportunities for improving warfighter survivability on the battlefield. Despite recent developments, however, the Department of Defense has yet to strategically guide the development of these new technologies at the national level. Recently, War on the Rocks published an article outlining concerns about the lack of coordinated policy for developing synthetic biology – a branch of biotechnology – while preventing its misuse by adversaries. The article rightly pointed to the need to think strategically about the risk of proliferating synthetic biology capabilities, but this is only one part of the picture. Current national strategies encourage policymakers to view advances in biology through a narrow lens of risks to national security and the development of countermeasures to protect against those risks, which, while crucial, neglects the promise for using the same science to develop life-saving or other advanced tools for warfighters. The Pentagon’s current efforts to take advantage of synthetic biology as a platform for defense lack internal cohesion and external direction, and biological innovation faces further challenges given the absence of agile business models to fully harness emerging biotechnologies for the battlefield. Greater coordination between those in the Defense Department whose work relates to biotechnology and improved relationships with the private sector are important first steps toward using this burgeoning area of science not just to mitigate security risks, but also to benefit soldiers on the battlefield.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Artificial Intelligence › AI---AT: “AI Approximates Humans”/Full Autonomy---2AC
Carchidi ’22 [Vincent; May 16; Master of Political Science from Villanova University specializing in the intersection of technology and international affairs, with an interdisciplinary background in cognitive science; War on the Rocks, “Is Artificial Intelligence Made in Humanity’s Image? Lessons for an AI Military Education,” https://warontherocks.com/2022/05/is-artificial-intelligence-made-in-humanitys-image-lessons-for-an-ai-military-education]
Artificial intelligence is not like us. For all of AI’s diverse applications, human intelligence is not at risk of losing its most distinctive characteristics to its artificial creations.
Yet, when AI applications are brought to bear on matters of national security, they are often subjected to an anthropomorphizing tendency that inappropriately associates human intellectual abilities with AI-enabled machines. A rigorous AI military education should recognize that this anthropomorphizing is irrational and problematic, reflecting a poor understanding of both human and artificial intelligence. The most effective way to mitigate this anthropomorphic bias is through engagement with the study of human cognition — cognitive science.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Artificial Intelligence › AI---Broad Interp---2AC
Chiles ’19 [John and Clara Reyes; 2019; Partner at Burr & Forman LLP; Assistant Professor of Law and Director of R&D at Michigan State Law School and Faculty Associate at Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University; “Robot Loans: Artificial Intelligence and Its Place in Consumer Finance?,” 73 Consumer Fin. L.Q. Rep. 205, WestLaw]
John: Carla is an Assistant Professor of Law and Director of R&D at Michigan State Law School. She's a Faculty Associate at Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School. Or is it at the university?
Carla: University.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Artificial Intelligence › AI---Includes Narrow/Strong AI---2AC
Jensen ’16 [Benjamin and Ryan Kendall; September 2; Major in the US Army Reserve currently serving as a Fellow in the Office of the Chief of Staff of the Army, Strategic Studies Group; Lieutenant Colonel in the US Army currently serving in the Chief of Staff of the Army, Strategic Studies Group;
War on the Rocks, “Waze For War: How The Army Can Integrate Artificial Intelligence,”
Artificial intelligence is commonly defined as the theory and development of computer systems able to perform tasks that normally require human intelligence, such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making, and translation between languages. It can range from weak forms, such as narrow artificial intelligence, that processes big data to answer basic questions and generate predictions (e.g., think of Waze helping you drive home or ad placements online) to strong forms such as “Artificial General Intelligence” and “Artificial Super Intelligence” that exceed human intelligence, creativity, and adaptability. Military applications range from finding optimal human-machine symbiosis, the centaur Deputy Secretary of Defense Robert Work speaks about, to using increased computer processing power to replace people on the battlefield with autonomous attack swarms.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Artificial Intelligence › AI---Full Autonomy---1NC
Ware ’19 [Jacob; September 24; holds a master’s in security studies from Georgetown University and an MA (Hons) in international relations and modern history from the University of St Andrews; War on the Rocks, “Terrorist Groups, Artificial Intelligence, and Killer Drones,” https://warontherocks.com/2019/09/terrorist-groups-artificial-intelligence-and-killer-drones/]
In 2016, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) carried out its first successful drone attack in combat, killing two Peshmerga warriors in northern Iraq. The attack continued the group’s record of employing increasingly sophisticated technologies against its enemies, a trend mimicked by other nonstate armed groups around the world. The following year, the group announced the formation of the “Unmanned Aircraft of the Mujahedeen,” a division dedicated to the development and use of drones, and a more formal step toward the long-term weaponization of drone technology.
Terrorist groups are increasingly using 21st-century technologies, including drones and elementary artificial intelligence (AI), in attacks. As it continues to be weaponized, AI could prove a formidable threat, allowing adversaries — including nonstate actors — to automate killing on a massive scale. The combination of drone expertise and more sophisticated AI could allow terrorist groups to acquire or develop lethal autonomous weapons, or “killer robots,” which would dramatically increase their capacity to create incidents of mass destruction in Western cities. As it expands its artificial intelligence capabilities, the U.S. government should also strengthen its anti-AI capacity, paying particular attention to nonstate actors and the enduring threats they pose. For the purposes of this article, I define artificial intelligence as technology capable of “mimicking human brain patterns,” including by learning and making decisions.