Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Georgetown Disadvantage

2AC – !! – AT: Climate

Warming won’t be catastrophic

Dr. Benjamin Zycher 21, Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Doctorate in Economics from UCLA, Master in Public Policy from the University of California, Berkeley, and Bachelor of Arts in Political Science from UCLA, Former Senior Economist at the RAND Corporation, Former Adjunct Professor of Economics at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) and at the California State University Channel Islands, and Former Senior Economist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, “The Case for Climate Change Realism”, 6/21/2021, https://www.aei.org/articles/the-case-for-climate-change-realism/

CLIMATE TRENDS

2022 Georgetown Disadvantage

2AC – I/L – AT: Baltics – Deterrence Fails

Conventional causes Russia Baltics escalation

Kühn, 18 – nonresident scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, and the head of the arms control and emerging technologies program at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy at the University of Hamburg. (Ulrich Kühn, “NATO’s Options – Preventing Escalation in the Baltics,” 3-28-2018, Accessed 06-28-2022, https://carnegieendowment.org/2018/03/28/nato-s-options-pub-75883)//ILake-NoC

DETERRENCE BY DENIAL

2022 Georgetown Disadvantage

2AC – N/I/L – No Tradeoff

Not zero sum – NATO will just increase total resources invested because cyber defense is a priority.

DOD, '18 (U.S. Department of Defense; "News Conference by Secretary Mattis at NATO Headquarters, Brussels, Belgium"; ; https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/1654419/news-conference-by-secretary-mattis-at-nato-headquarters-brussels-belgium/; 10-4-2018, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC

Amid many competing priorities, American lawmakers did not reduce funding for the European Deterrence Initiative by a single cent, instead maintaining the highest levels of commitment since the 1989 fall of the Berlin Wall. We have maintained the number of U.S. troops currently assigned to Europe while adding additional capability.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: nato unsustainable

Russia renews NATO’s purpose – overcomes friction over democracy and unites the alliance

Erlanger 22. Steven, chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe for The New York Times, a position he assumed in 2017. He is based in Brussels. “Fear of Russia Brings New Purpose and Unity to NATO, Once Again” JH-NCP

The talks allowed Mr. Putin to revisit Russian grievances over how the Cold War ended, in hopes of placing them back on the table for renegotiation 30 years later. His deputy foreign minister, Aleksandr V. Grushko, even warned the alliance off a “policy of containment” of Russia and insisted that “free choice does not exist in international relations” — suggesting that Ukraine would have to bow to Russian wishes.

But the more the discussion evoked the Cold War — with its firm dividing line through Europe, and its competing Russian and Western systems and spheres of influence — the more it reminded European and American allies of NATO’s purpose.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: nato unsustainable

Russian invasion unites NATO now – provides a common enemy and security risk

Boot 5/17/22. Max, historian, best-selling author and foreign-policy analyst who has been called one of the “world’s leading authorities on armed conflict” by the International Institute for Strategic Studies. He is the Jeane J. Kirkpatrick senior fellow for national security studies at the Council on Foreign Relations and a columnist for The Washington Post. “Opinion | Thanks, Vladimir Putin, for greatly strengthening NATO” JH-NCP

Less than three years ago, while President Donald Trump was threatening not to defend allies who didn’t pay enough for the privilege, French President Emmanuel Macron was lamenting the “brain death of NATO.” Things hardly seemed to improve when President Biden pulled U.S. troops out of Afghanistan (a NATO mission) after scant consultation with allies. As Kabul was falling, the Wall Street Journal ran an editorial headlined, “How Biden broke NATO.”

It turns out NATO is neither brain dead nor broken. The unprovoked Russian invasion of Ukraine has given the alliance a new lease on life, making it more politically united and militarily formidable than at any time since the end of the Cold War.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: nato unsustainable

NATO is united now – invasion of Ukraine proves cooperation and strength are key

Seçkin 22. Barış, Anadolu Agency şirketinde Rome Bureau Chief, Experienced Foreign Correspondent with a demonstrated history of working in the media production industry. Skilled in Photography, Politics, Turkish, Italian, and Communication. Strong media and communication professional with a Master's degree focused in Cultural Heritage communication from Università degli Studi di Firenze. “Cohesion of NATO reinforced by Russian president: Defense College commandant” https://www.aa.com.tr/en/russia-ukraine-crisis/cohesion-of-nato-reinforced-by-russian-president-defense-college-commandant/2524426 JH-NCP

The commandant of NATO Defense College said the cohesion of the alliance has been even reinforced by Russian President Vladimir Putin's recent actions, now that the region sees the Russian threat. 

Lt. Gen. Olivier Rittimann told Anadolu Agency in an interview that Ukraine was a partner of NATO and so there is a difference between a partner and an ally.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: eu

The EU cannot fill in for NATO – the US is key to European defense capabilities

Meijer and Brooks 21 -- Hugo Meijer is CNRS Research Fellow at Sciences Po, Center for International Studies and the Founding Director of the European Initiative for Security Studies, and Stephen Gallup Brooks is a Professor of Government in the Department of Government at Dartmouth College. Published 2021. “Illusions of autonomy: Why Europe cannot provide for its security if the United States pulls back” DG

The European ambition to seek strategic autonomy amid rising concerns over U.S. commitments to the continent and over Russia’s revisionist behavior raises an important counterfactual question: Could Europeans develop an autonomous defense capacity if there were a complete U.S. withdrawal from Europe? Although a U.S. withdrawal from Europe is unlikely in the short term, it is hardly a far-fetched scenario for the longer term. Examining this counterfactual is useful for two key reasons. First, a complete U.S. withdrawal—one entailing an exit from NATO and the withdrawal of all U.S. conventional and nuclear forces from the continent—is the strongest possible incentive that could drive the Europeans to pursue strategic autonomy, and is therefore the best way to assess their capacity to do so. Second, examination of this counterfactual advances the U.S. grand strategy debate in light of the prominent theoretical argument from U.S. “restraint” scholars such as Barry Posen, who argue that a U.S. withdrawal is warranted on the grounds that Europe can quickly and easily create an effective deterrent to Russia.9 As we explain, Europe is the key fulcrum in the grand strategy debate between these restraint scholars and “deep engagement” scholars, who favor maintaining current U.S. security commitments in Europe and elsewhere.10

Determining whether Europeans could achieve strategic autonomy anytime soon if the United States were to pull back from Europe requires an examination of the historical trajectory and the current and likely future state of European interests and defense capacity. Although existing studies have analyzed important elements of each, a more systematic analysis is needed.11 Regarding interests, this article provides the most comprehensive and thorough coding of national threat perceptions across all of Europe, showing where each country falls across a set of defined categories of threat prioritization. Concerning defense capacity, it adds to existing understandings of Europe’s deficiency by providing novel longitudinal data on European conventional defense capabilities over the past three decades and by outlining a series of four interwoven challenges that would greatly complicate the pursuit of strategic autonomy.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: eu

Turn: The EU is too reliant on Russian energy to effectively deter – without NATO, no deterrence

Vicente 5/4/22 -- Adérito Vicente is PhD researcher in Department of Political and Social Sciences at the European University Institute. Published May 4, 2022. “Why Europe Slept? The Failure to Prevent the War in Ukraine” //DG

Before the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, four key threat perception conclusions emerged: 1) a state geographically close to an adverse nuclear power increases threat perception (e.g. Finland and Sweden); 2) a state geographically far from an adverse nuclear power decreases threat perception (e.g. Portugal and Spain); 3) a shared history of conflict increases threat perception (e.g. the Baltic States and Poland); 4) a non-shared history of conflict decreases threat perception (e.g. Italy). In sum, the different degrees of threat perception of each European state towards Russia undermined the idea of European solidarity and cohesion and, ultimately, the effectiveness of the EU as a political player with regard to Ukraine.

Europe’s energy dependence is another conditioning factor of political divergence within the EU. For example, the impact of Russia’s policy over EU politics towards Ukraine, especially through its bargaining power in the energy sector (namely through Russian business proxies Nord stream and Gazprom), led the Union to become more inactive and less effective. Other Russian activities – such as increased activities of Russian funded media, intensified contact between Brussels and other European countries with Moscow, the spread of disinformation, and the sponsoring of Eurosceptic political forces – impacted the ability of the EU to act effectively in opposition to Russian aggression.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: eu

The EU cannot fill in – failed on Ukraine and are reliant on NATO

Vicente 5/4/22 -- Adérito Vicente is PhD researcher in Department of Political and Social Sciences at the European University Institute. Published May 4, 2022. “Why Europe Slept? The Failure to Prevent the War in Ukraine” //DG

The Russia-Ukraine war has revealed Europe’s inability to protect the Ukrainians and to deter Russia from invading Ukraine, as happened in the 2014 Russian annexation of Crimea. Why did Europe fail to prevent this war?

First and foremost, due to security idiosyncrasies. Europe is not a collective security guarantor. It dismissed this opportunity in 1954 when France refused to establish a European Defence Community (EDC). Thus, despite continuous efforts ever since, Europe does not have an army nor a deterrent capability. It is, in fact, highly dependent on NATO and individual nuclear powers (predominantly the US and, to a lesser extent, the UK and France) to guarantee its collective security.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: eu

EU military fails and can’t

Naumann 19 - Klaus Naumann is a retired German general who served as chief of defense of the Bundeswehr from 1991 to 1996 and as chairman of the NATO Military Committee from 1996 to 1999. (“Even if prudent, there will be no European army any time soon,” The German Times. February 15th, 2019. ) CTF

Concerns are growing in many European countries that they can no longer depend on the United States and the security guarantees enshrined in Article 5 of the NATO treaty. President Trump’s decision to withdraw US forces from Syria marked the end of US reliability. Doubts about America’s trustworthiness have produced a flurry of driveling speeches in 2018 on the idea of a European army. So – what about it?

It is an old idea, which failed first in 1954 when the French National Assembly refused to ratify the European Defence Union treaty. It has since resurfaced from time to time but was never agreed upon and implemented. Will it fare better now, five years after the wake-up call produced by Russia’s illegal seizure of the Crimea from Ukraine?

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: eu

A collective EU defense is impossible

Rühle 18 - Michael Rühle heads the Energy Security Section of NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division. (“Imagining a world without NATO,” Atlantic Council. August 18th, 2018. ) CTF

What would a world without NATO look like? It is a useful question to ask. For the end of NATO would mean far more than merely the disappearance of a bureaucracy at the outskirts of Brussels. The end of NATO would mean the end of a unique institutionalized political and military link between Europe and North America—with consequences that range from merely uncomfortable to outright dangerous.

The end of NATO would be the end of transatlantic collective defense. Europe would have to provide for its security without the United States. Establishing a purely European defense, however, would overwhelm the Europeans politically, financially, and militarily. Not only would it require significantly higher defense expenditures, but also massive investments in defense research and development and much more rationalized defense procurement – just when the United Kingdom, Europe’s biggest defense player, is distancing itself from the EU. It would ultimately require a genuine European security policy, including a consensus on a European nuclear deterrent. In short, it would require a quantum leap in the process of European integration that is utterly unrealistic.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: china deterrence

NATO cohesion key to deter China – aff turns the net benefit

Odgaard 2022 (Lisa Odgaard is a professor at the Norwegian Institute for Defense Studies in Oslo and a non-resident senior fellow at the Hudson Institute focusing on US-China-Europe relations, NATO’s China Role: Defending Cyber and Outer Space, )//MargaretE

The omnipresent character of the China threat demonstrates that it is long overdue for NATO to position itself as a significant player in addressing Beijing’s challenges to transatlantic security. NATO is key to keeping US and European security policies coordinated when applying mechanisms of deterrence and defense against Chinese challenges. If transatlantic unity of purpose is lost, both the US and Europe are far less likely to succeed in addressing China sufficiently.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: climate

NATO is on track to reduce emission and challenge conflicts that arise from warming

IISD 21 – The International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) is a think tank oriented around promoting green growth. (“NATO Adopts Climate Change Actions for 2030,” IISD. June 24th, 2021. CTF

The Heads of State and Government of the 30 members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) have adopted NATO 2030, “a transatlantic agenda for the future,” as well as a Climate Change and Security Action Plan. The Action Plan provides a framework to deliver on the Climate Change and Security Agenda endorsed by NATO Foreign Ministers on 23-24 March 2021. The NATO Deputy Secretary-General said the decisions make the fight against climate change an important task for NATO for the first time.

The leaders gathered for a one-day meeting on 14 June 2021, in Brussels, Belgium, resulting in the Brussels Summit Communique. In the Summit outcome, the leaders identify climate change as a “threat multiplier that impacts Allied security” and say it tests resilience and civil preparedness, affects planning and the resilience of military installations and critical infrastructure, and “may create harsher conditions for our operations.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: bri

BRI has no plan and causes massive debt – it fails to do anything

Wan 19 – Andrew Wan is a research assistant. (“A ROAD TO NOWHERE? PROBLEMS WITH CHINA’S BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE,” Baker Institute. June 27th, 2019. ) CTF

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) may be the most talked-about development plan of the century. Xi Jinping’s signature plan has captured the world’s attention since its announcement in 2013, with comparisons drawn to the ancient Silk Road and the Marshall Plan. But recently, worldwide coverage of the BRI has grown less favorable and more critical. Has BRI lost its luster?

The BRI now includes around 3,000 projects, according to official Chinese sources. The majority of the BRI projects involve constructing infrastructure to facilitate trade, which requires collaborating with partner countries to secure lending agreements and territory rights. BRI’s flagship project and biggest success is the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a road and cable link between Pakistan’s Gwadar port to Xinjiang, China. China’s BRI relies on projects financed by Chinese policy and commercial banks rather than FDI, which requires massive capital flow to partner countries in the form of Chinese loans. This model makes sense when considering China’s industrial overcapacity dilemma; facing economic setbacks, China has already begun consolidating manufacturing companies to prevent defaults on loans. China sees foreign projects as an easy way for its state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to secure contracts and minimize losses.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: finland/Sweden turn

Finland and Sweden already invited into NATO – Turkey dropped its objections

Erlanger and Shear 6/29/22 (Steven Erlanger is the chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe for The New York Times, a position he assumed in 2017. He is based in Brussels, Michael D. Shear is a White House correspondent and two-time Pulitzer Prize winning reporter in the Washington bureau, where he covers President Biden, with a focus on domestic policy, the regulatory state and life at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NATO formally invites Finland and Sweden to join the alliance. )//MargaretE

MADRID — NATO leaders on Wednesday formally invited Finland and Sweden to join the alliance, one day after Turkey dropped its objections to their membership, clearing the way for what would be one of the most significant expansions of the alliance in decades. The historic deal, following Turkey’s agreement to a memorandum with the two Nordic countries, underscores how the war in Ukraine has backfired for President Vladimir V. Putin, subverting Russian efforts to weaken NATO and pushing Sweden and Finland, which were neutral and nonaligned for decades, into the alliance’s arms. After weeks of talks, capped by an hourslong meeting in Madrid, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey agreed to lift his block on Sweden and Finland’s membership in return for a set of actions and promises that they will act against terrorism and terrorist organizations. “As NATO allies, Finland and Sweden commit to fully support Turkey against threats to its national security,” NATO’s secretary general, Jens Stoltenberg, said, providing some details of the agreement. “This includes further amending their domestic legislation, cracking down on P.K.K. activities and entering into an agreement with Turkey on extradition,” he added, referring to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, which seeks an independent Kurdish state on territory partly within Turkey’s borders.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: finland/Sweden turn

Non-UQ: Finland and Sweden already invited into NATO and Turkey doesn’t care

Erlanger et. al 6/28/22 (Steven Erlanger is the chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe for The New York Times, a position he assumed in 2017. He is based in Brussels, Valerie Hopkins is an international correspondent for The New York Times covering the war in Ukraine, as well as Russia and the countries of the former Soviet Union, Anton Troianovski is the Moscow bureau chief for The New York Times, Michael D. Shear is a White House correspondent and two-time Pulitzer Prize winning reporter in the Washington bureau, where he covers President Biden, with a focus on domestic policy, the regulatory state and life at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, In Blow to Putin, Turkey Won’t Bar Sweden and Finland From NATO, )//MargaretE

MADRID — NATO’s top official said Tuesday that Turkey had dropped its objections to the membership of Sweden and Finland, two historically nonaligned nations that, alarmed by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, have asked to join the military alliance. Turkey’s reversal is a blow to President Vladimir V. Putin, who in justifying the invasion of his neighbor bitterly protested previous expansions of NATO — and Ukraine’s efforts to join the alliance — as a threat to his country’s security. Should Finland and Sweden be formally adopted into the alliance, as is widely expected, Russia will look across 800 miles of border with Finland at one of NATO’s newest members. The announcement came after Turkey’s president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, met for four hours with Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson of Sweden and President Sauli Niinisto of Finland, as NATO heads of state gathered in Madrid for an annual summit. The 30-nation alliance operates by consensus, which meant that Turkey effectively held a veto over their membership applications. “I’m pleased to announce that we now have an agreement that paves the way for Finland and Sweden to join NATO,” the secretary-general, Jens Stoltenberg, said Tuesday evening. “Turkey, Finland and Sweden have signed a memorandum that addresses Turkey’s concerns, including around arms exports, and the fight against terrorism

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: finland/Sweden turn

Non unique—Turkey dropped objections to Finland and Sweden’s NATO bids

Aljazeera 6/28 (Aljazeera, “Finland, Sweden on path to NATO membership as Turkey drops veto,” 6/28/2022, LH

NATO ally Turkey has lifted its veto over Finland and Sweden’s bid to join the Western alliance after the three nations agreed to protect each other’s security, ending a weeks-long drama that tested allied unity against Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

The breakthrough came on Tuesday after four hours of talks just before a NATO summit began in Madrid, averting an embarrassing impasse at the gathering of 30 leaders that aimed to show resolve against Russia.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: finland/Sweden turn

Non-unique – Turkey won’t get in the way of Finland joining

Falk 5/18. Thomas, journalist and political commentator. “How long will it take for Finland and Sweden to join NATO?” https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/5/18/finland-and-swedens-fast-tracked-nato-membership

And all NATO members have to vote unanimously in favour of the candidates for this to be possible.

Analysts said this is highly likely despite the latest news that Turkey is opposed to the new potential members.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: finland/Sweden turn

Non-unique or no link – negotiations are taking time but have nothing to do with mistrust

Gumrukcu et al 6/20. Tuvan, and Ali Kucukgocmen; Additional reporting by Anne Kauranen in Helsinki; Editing by Alex Richardson and Angus MacSwan “Turkey says summit is not deadline for talks on Finland and Sweden's NATO bids” https://www.reuters.com/world/turkey-says-talks-finland-swedens-nato-bids-continue-summit-not-deadline-2022-06-20/

ANKARA, June 20 (Reuters) - Discussions between Turkey, Finland and Sweden about the Nordic countries' NATO membership will continue and an alliance summit in Madrid next week is not a deadline, Turkey said after talks in Brussels on Monday. Finland and Sweden applied for NATO membership in response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine. But the bids have faced opposition from Turkey, which has been angered by what it says is Helsinki and Stockholm's support for Kurdish militants and arms embargoes on Ankara. Last week, Turkey said documents it received from Sweden and NATO in response to the earlier written demands it presented the two candidates were far from meeting its expectations and any negotiations must first address Turkish concerns. read more Speaking to reporters in Brussels alongside Deputy Foreign Minister Sedat Onal, Turkish presidential spokesman Ibrahim Kalin said Ankara was expecting Sweden to take immediate steps regarding actions by the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) militant group in its country. Any progress on the Nordic membership bids "now depends on the direction and speed at which these countries will take steps," he said. The talks in Brussels with officials from Sweden, Finland, and NATO were held in an "open and sincere atmosphere," he said. "As we see these steps, we will all have the opportunity to evaluate the direction of this process," he said. Onal said Turkey expected a change of approach from Sweden and Finland, and Ankara needed "binding promises" to address its concerns. "We don't see ourselves limited by any timetable. The speed, scope of this process depends on these nations' manner and speed of meeting our expectations," he said. Petri Hakkarainen, foreign and security adviser to Finland's president and the head of the Finnish delegation at the talks in Brussels, said the sides had made "clear progress" on certain issues. But it would take time to reach an understanding on others, he said. NATO leaders will convene in Madrid on June 29-30. Any NATO membership requires approval of all 30 members of the alliance. Turkey has been a NATO ally for more than 70 years and has the alliance's second biggest army.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › aff › at: russia

Russian aggression not due to NATO

Popova and Shevel 22 -- Maria Popova is Jean Monnet Chair and Associate Professor of Political Science at McGill University. Oxana Shevel is an Associate Professor in the Department of Political Science at Tufts University’s School of Arts and Sciences. Published February 24, 2022. “Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine is Essentially Not About NATO” //DG

In his Feb. 15 Just Security article “Ukraine: Unleashing the Rhetorical Dogs of War,” Barry Posen argued that NATO and Ukraine should have cut a deal with Russia because the Ukrainian military would surely be defeated by Russia without direct U.S./Western military participation and U.S. offers of equipment were only encouraging a potential Ukrainian insurgency against Russian occupation that would be as bloody as it would be futile. The prescription depends entirely on Posen’s assumption that to satisfy Russia, all Ukraine would have had to do would be “to swallow the bitter pill of accepting armed neutrality between NATO and Russia, rather than NATO membership.”

This assumption contradicts events of recent months and the historical record. While Vladimir Putin has claimed that his goal is keeping Ukraine out of NATO, he also insisted that he was just conducting military exercises. Instead, he is invading Ukraine again. He likewise insisted in 2014 that he wasn’t capturing Crimea, despite the presence of his unidentified “Little Green Men” and his subsequent annexation of the peninsula, or that he was not fighting in Ukraine’s Donbas area in the east all these years, despite all evidence to the contrary. There is no reason to take Putin at his word. His Feb. 21 diatribe conferring Russian recognition of independence for the two eastern Ukrainian regions of Donetsk and Luhansk and his order for Russian troops to move in as ostensible “peacekeepers” shows clearly his disdain for diplomatic resolutions.