Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › bri turn – 1nc

US security pledges hinder Sino-EU cooperation

Kuo 19 - Mercy Kuo is Executive Vice President at Pamir Consulting. (“Assessing the EU-China-US Triangle,” The Diplomat, November 5th, 2019. ) CTF

***BRI=Belt and Road Initiative: A global infrastructure project China created***

Trans-Pacific View author Mercy Kuo regularly engages subject-matter experts, policy practitioners, and strategic thinkers across the globe for their diverse insights into U.S. Asia policy. This conversation with Dr. Frans-Paul van der Putten – senior research fellow at Clingendael and co-coordinator of the Clingendael China Center in The Hague – is the 211th in “The Trans-Pacific View Insight Series.”

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › climate turn

NATO defense spending trades off with warming – keeping the alliance leads causes them to miss climate marks – the UN is key

Lorincz 19 - Tamara Lorincz is a PhD candidate in the Balsillie School of International Affairs, Wilfrid Laurier University, and member of the Canadian Voice of Women for Peace. (“NATO is a threat to the climate.” Ricochet. December 19th, 2019. ) CTF

Earlier this month, the 29 leaders of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) went to London to celebrate their alliance’s anniversary but snubbed the opening of United Nations climate conference, where the other 164 world leaders and their delegations were meeting in Madrid.

Despite several scientific reports urgently warning about the devastating impacts and security implications of rising carbon emissions, climate change was not even on the NATO agenda.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › china heg turn

China leadership is key to solve warming

Ballard 19 – Eden Ballard is a journalist at The Generation. (“CLIMATE CHANGE AND ECONOMIC HEGEMONY,” The Generation. April 29th, 2019. ) CTF

Where the US is stepping down, China is stepping up. One reason China is motivated to take action when the US is not lies in the fact that China, infamous for its unbreathable air, has already paid dearly for its dependency on coal. The International Energy Agency in Paris reports that fossil fuel emissions in China have close to tripled since 2000. This is mainly a reflection of China’s large population as per person emissions are lower than those in the US. In 2009, 16 of the world’s 20 most polluted cities8 were in China. Today only the bottom four cities on the top 20 list are in China because the government has been investing in sustainable technology such as electric cars, wind and solar energy, as well as implementing emission reducing legislation.

In 2013 and 2014, the Chinese government encouraged several pilot cap and trade programs that generated close to $680 million in the 2017 fiscal year. In December of 2017 China announced a new plan9 for an even more comprehensive nationwide market focusing on their power generation sector to trade emissions credits that allow businesses to buy and sell the credits that allow them to emit planet-warming greenhouse gases. Cap and trade programs10 are one of the most talked about ways to combat climate change using the free market. They incentivize business that use clean energy by limiting the total amount of emissions allowed to all companies and then allowing those that have not used all of the emissions they are allotted to sell them to companies that continue to pollute. Hypothetically, this incentivizes companies to go green by ensuring that eco-friendly policies save them money. The challenge with a cap and trade program is closing the loopholes so that heavy polluters cannot skirt around the issue and do, in fact, take initiative to limit emissions. Though there is room for some refinement, the existing measures are indicative of China’s awareness and sense of urgency around the issue of climate change.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › china heg turn

EU-China cooperation on security and infrastructure is halted by US NATO presence

Peternelj et al. 19 - Boštjan Peternelj researches military and defense reforms, defense planning and military analyses. Petar Kurecic is an Associate Professor and Advisor in Science. Igor Klopotan is an assistant professor at UNC. (“THE PROSPECTS OF DEFENCE COOPERATION BETWEEN THE EUROPEAN UNION, THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA,” Research Gate. February, 2019. ) CTF

The PR China had opened wide door to European military technology to invade into PR China’s defense sector since the economic embargo was lifted to transfer advanced military technology. Financial dynamic invested into PR China’s defense sector had completely changed situation over the past five years into military modernization process of the PR China’s army. Chinese President Xi Jinping has put an end to the practice of making any progress on international security cooperation with Europe conditional on the lifting of the embargo. This is the result of the PR China’s arms industry’s progress (Duchatel, 2018). The PR China had access to critical technologies that had speed up modernization process for ten years, and beside it had created main conditions for advanced innovation and leadership for the next generations of arms toward C4I updated technology. The PR China had paid off for some advanced hi-tech licensed equipment – those are being incorporated into Chinese military helicopters, ships and submarines, and were needed to speed up modernization process of China army but it seems that the EU thoughts ongoing into direction to prevent all transfers of dual-use technology to the PR China as to protect Europe’s critical technology. China’s economic intensions became doubtful about financial influence to invest more money by spending into common hi tech military projects together with Europe champions into defense sector as the PR China tries to increase pressure by lifting economic barriers to arms transfers and export controls. The main barrier to deepening of the EU-PR China defense cooperation is the will of NATO allies and especially of the US to preserve sensitive hi-tech military technology, whilst the PR China is still accused for industrial espionage and steeling military patents. Arms control measures among transferring hi – tech military technology to third states could not be secured by NATO protocol of regime export mil technology or under the PESCO projects carried out by the EDA control. The PR China may use hi-tech military projects to benefit itself to modernize own army into all military branches by following up European modernization process under Horizon 2020 projects. The defense companies from the EU shall take decision, if cooperate or not cooperate into the joint EU-PR China defense cooperation. The PR China had pleased the EU member states to fully participate into the Eurasian megaproject and invest more money to rebuild the Silk Road strategy toward the western part of Heartland. This invitation was referred on the defense cooperation too if EU states did not decide for protectionism. It was likely seen that the EU had been stuck between US and PR China’s economic influence from foreign geoeconomic investments. The PR China, meanwhile, “is leveraging military modernization, influence operations, and predatory economics to coerce neighboring countries to re-order the Indo-Pacific region to their advantage,” the Strategy declares. And the Chinese military modernization program, it adds, is designed to achieve “regional hegemony in the near-term and displacement of the USA to achieve global pre-eminence in the future” (Morgan, 2018).

The EU and China signed a ‘strategic partnership’ in 2003, and adopted 2020 strategic agenda for cooperation in 2013. These agreements resulted from a mutual commitment to cooperation and signal an interest to further advance ties” (Dorussen, 2017: 2). Prominent role from EU states those had invested more money into defense sector into foreign business had cemented economic benefit in the PR China defense sector for some EU defense firms, to expand the global market for selling military goods out of the EU market, that became more relevant on global market inside the EU-PR China defense relation. Solidarity and unity were cracked down into one voice while decision making process inside European NATO pillar had been divided into two political blocks. Atlantic hub encountered against European hub for more centrists reproach toward federalization process to form the EU super state. Political dwindling, dividing and disunity (3D) had brought NATO alliance to crack solidarity and unity apart between Europe and the USA, only media black coverage had been disseminating lies into publicity that was everything fine within the EU-US bilateral cooperation under the NATO alliance but this was false flags signal to sweep rubbish under the political carpet. Those political, economic and defense cooperation for 3D reasons had worsened fragility under the NATO alliance. Otherwise, an alternative was opened as China signaled to EU states as to re-join Silk Road strategy on continent. China is willing to invest more money into EU critical infrastructure to reconnect roads and rails guided from Peking to Europe by transiting Russian territory.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

Russia-NATO nuclear war causes extinction – scientific studies

Lynas 2022 (Mark Lynas s a British author and journalist whose work is focused on environmentalism and climate change. He is a contributor to New Statesman, The Ecologist, Granta and Geographical magazines, and The Guardian and The Observer newspapers in the UK, What the science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war between NATO and Russia?, )//MargaretE

Russian leader Vladimir Putin has suggested that he would consider using nuclear weapons if confronted with a NATO military response in Ukraine, or if faced with a direct threat to his person or regime. If the war spreads to a NATO country like Estonia or Poland a direct US-Russia confrontation would take place, with a clear danger of runaway nuclear escalation. The world is therefore arguably now closer to nuclear conflict than at any time since the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis. So what would a full-scale nuclear exchange look like in reality? Is it truly global Armageddon, or would it be survivable for some people and places? Many scientists have investigated this question already. Their work is surprisingly little known, likely because in peacetime no one wants to think the unthinkable. But we are no longer in peacetime and the shadows of multiple mushroom clouds are looming once again over our planet. Current nuclear weapons inventories The latest assessment of Russian nuclear military capability estimates that as of early 2022 Russia has a stockpile of approximately 4,477 nuclear warheads — nearly 6,000 if “retired” warheads are included. The US maintains a similar inventory of 5,500 warheads, with 3,800 of those rapidly deployable. The explosive power of these weapons is difficult to comprehend. It has been estimated that about 3 million tons (megatons or Mt) of TNT equivalent were detonated in World War II. For comparison, each of the UK’s Trident submarines carries 4 megatons of TNT equivalent on 40 nuclear warheads, meaning each submarine can cause more explosive destruction than took place during the entirety of World War II. Hiroshima and Nagasaki In 1945 the US attacked the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki with atomic bombs, giving us two real-world examples of the effects of nuclear weapons on human populations. A total of 140,000 people in Hiroshima and 73,000 in Nagasaki died instantaneously or within five months due to the nuclear blast, intense radiant heat from the fireball and ionizing radiation. Many people caught within 1km of ground zero were carbonized by heat rays, and those up to 1.5km away suffered flash burning with large areas of skin later peeling off. Some, especially those inside buildings, were reduced to white bones as all flesh was vaporized by the intense heat. Many survivors, later to become known as hibakusha in Japanese, suffered acute radiation sickness (ARS) from neutron and gamma rays released by nuclear fission in the blasts. Symptoms included bloody diarrhea, hair loss, fever and intense thirst. Many later died. As well as direct radiation from the fireballs they were also exposed to radioactive fallout from the bomb. The longer-term effects of radiation experienced by the hibakusha have been intensively studied, and include increased levels of leukemia and solid cancers. However, experiencing an atomic bombing was not an automatic death sentence: among the 100,000 or so survivors the excess rates of cancer over the subsequent years were about 850, and leukemia less than 100. Hiroshima and Nagasaki show that — apart from short-term ARS — long-term radiation from fallout will be the least of our problems following a nuclear war. Much more serious will be social collapse, famine and the breakdown of much of the planetary biosphere. ‘Limited’ nuclear conflict – 100 warheads between India and Pakistan Prior to the Ukraine war it seemed very unlikely that the superpowers would confront each other again, so many researchers turned to studying the impacts of more limited nuclear conflicts. One study published two years ago looked at the likely impacts of a nuclear exchange of about 100 Hiroshima-sized detonations (15 kt yield each) on the most-populated urban areas of India and Pakistan. Each detonation was estimated to incinerate an area of 13 square km, with this scenario generating about 5 Tg (teragrams) of soot as smoke from wildfires and burning buildings entered the atmosphere. Direct human deaths in this “limited” nuclear war scenario are not quantified in the study, but would presumably number in the tens to hundreds of millions. The planetary impacts are also severe: as the soot reaches the stratosphere it circulates globally, blocking incoming solar radiation and dropping the Earth’s surface temperature by 1.8C in the first five years. This would be a greater cooling than caused by any recent volcanic eruption, and more than any climate perturbation for at least the last 1,000 years. Rainfall patterns are drastically altered, and total precipitation declines by about 8 percent. (These results come from widely-used climate models of the same types used to project long-term impacts of greenhouse gas emissions.) Food exports collapse as stocks are depleted within a single year, and by year four a total of 1.3 billion people face a loss of about a fifth of their current food supply. The researchers conclude that “a regional conflict using <1 percent of the worldwide nuclear arsenal could have adverse consequences for global food security unmatched in modern history.” A 2014 study of the same scenario (of a 100-weapon nuclear exchange between India and Pakistan) found that the soot penetrating the stratosphere would cause severe damage to the Earth’s ozone layer, increasing UV penetration by 30-80 percent over the mid-latitudes. This would cause “widespread damage to human health, agriculture, and terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems,” the researchers wrote. “The combined cooling and enhanced UV would put significant pressures on global food supplies and could trigger a global nuclear famine.” Full-scale nuclear exchange If global nuclear famine could result from just 100 nuclear detonations, what might be the result of a fuller exchange of the several thousand warheads held in current inventories by the US and Russia? One 2008 study looked at a Russia-US nuclear war scenario, where Russia would target 2,200 weapons on Western countries and the US would target 1,100 weapons each on China and Russia. In total, therefore, 4,400 warheads detonate, equivalent to roughly half the current inventories held each by Russia and the US. Nuclear weapons held by other states were not used in this scenario, which has a 440-Mt explosive yield, equivalent to about 150 times all the bombs detonated in World War II. This full-scale nuclear war was estimated to cause 770 million direct deaths and generate 180 Tg of soot from burning cities and forests. In the US, about half the population would be within 5km of a ground zero, and a fifth of the country’s citizens would be killed outright. A subsequent study, published in 2019, looked at a comparable but slightly lower 150 Tg atmospheric soot injection following an equivalent scale nuclear war. The devastation causes so much smoke that only 30-40 percent of sunlight reaches the Earth’s surface for the subsequent six months. A massive drop in temperature follows, with the weather staying below freezing throughout the subsequent Northern Hemisphere summer. In Iowa, for example, the model shows temperatures staying below 0°C for 730 days straight. There is no growing season. This is a true nuclear winter. Nor is it just a short blip. Temperatures still drop below freezing in summer for several years thereafter, and global precipitation falls by half by years three and four. It takes over a decade for anything like climatic normality to return to the planet. By this time, most of Earth’s human population will be long dead. The world’s food production would crash by more than 90 percent, causing global famine that would kill billions by starvation. In most countries less than a quarter of the population survives by the end of year two in this scenario. Global fish stocks are decimated and the ozone layer collapses. The models are eerily specific. In the 4,400 warhead/150 Tg soot nuclear war scenario, averaged over the subsequent five years, China sees a reduction in food calories of 97.2 percent, France by 97.5 percent, Russia by 99.7 percent, the UK by 99.5 percent and the US by 98.9 percent. In all these countries, virtually everyone who survived the initial blasts would subsequently starve.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

Putin’s main concern is NATO – existence fuels his militarism and it’s a huge risk

Bender 2015 (Jeremy Bender eceived a BA in Middle Eastern Studies and religion from Rutgers University. He went on to teach English at Inonu University in Turkey through the Fulbright Program. He wrote briefly at BuzzFeed before coming to Business Insider, This is the simplest explanation of why Putin is so opposed to NATO, )//MargaretE

For Putin, the peeling away of countries from Russia towards NATO comes as both an existential threat and a personal insult. As a former agent in the KGB and an avowed nationalist, Putin has dreams of resurrecting the glories of Imperial Russia — a goal that is seriously hampered by the inclusion of what Putin would deem rightful Russian lands, such as the Baltics, into the NATO alliance.

With this in mind, it is easy to see why Putin signed off on Russia's new military doctrine in December 2014. The doctrine, which placed explicit focus on NATO being Moscow's main existential enemy and threat, called on the further militarization of three geopolitical frontlines: the Russian Baltic Sea exclave of Kaliningrad near Poland, the annexed Crimean peninsula, and the Arctic.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO cooperation worsens deterrence and provokes Russia war

Carpenter 2022 (Ted Galen Carpenter is senior fellow for defense and foreign policy studies at the Cato Institute. Carpenter served as Cato’s director of foreign policy studies from 1986 to 1995 and as vice president for defense and foreign policy studies from 1995 to 2011, “NATO Security Dependents Are Not Useful Allies”, )//MargaretE

SINCE THE end of World War II, U.S. officials have had an unduly expansive concept of what constitutes worthwhile strategic allies for the United States. In too many cases, the “allies” that Washington touts are small, weak, often militarily useless dependents. Worse, some of them are on bad terms with more powerful neighboring states. Under those circumstances, the so‐​called allies are major liabilities rather than assets to the United States. Indeed, they are potential snares, ones that can entangle America in unnecessary military confrontations.

Washington would do well to become far more selective about which nations it includes in its roster of allies, and U.S. leaders should stop elevating security dependents to the status of allies. When U.S. officials described the regimes that Washington installed through military force in Afghanistan and Iraq as allies, it became clear that they had lost even minimal understanding of the concept. That point became abundantly evident when their Afghan client collapsed almost overnight in the face of the Taliban military offensive. It’s time for U.S. policymakers to do better.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO expansionism since the end of the Soviet Union led up to the war in Ukraine

Carpenter 2/24/22. Ted Galen, Senior fellow in security studies at the Cato Institute, is the author of 12 books and more than 900 articles on international affairs. “Ignored Warnings: How NATO Expansion Led To The Current Ukraine Tragedy” https://www.19fortyfive.com/2022/02/ignored-warnings-how-nato-expansion-led-to-the-current-ukraine-tragedy/ JH-NCP

George Kennan, the intellectual father of America’s containment policy during the Cold War, perceptively warned in a May 2, 1998  New York Times interview about what the Senate’s ratification of NATO’s first round of expansion would set in motion. ”I think it is the beginning of a new cold war,” Kennan stated. ”I think the Russians will gradually react quite adversely and it will affect their policies. I think it is a tragic mistake. There was no reason for this whatsoever.  No one was threatening anybody else.”

He was right, but U.S. and NATO leaders proceeded with new rounds of expansion, including the provocative step of adding the three Baltic republics. Those countries not only had been part of the Soviet Union, but they had also been part of Russia’s empire during the Czarist era. That wave of expansion now had NATO perched on the border of the Russian Federation.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO expansionism and blundering made Putin feel surrounded and caused him to lash out

Ullman 5/18/22. Harlan K., Ph.D, is senior adviser at Washington, D.C.’s Atlantic Council and the primary author of “shock and awe.” “Did NATO cause the war in Ukraine?” https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/3484182-did-nato-cause-the-war-in-ukraine/ JH-NCP

In an interview last week with the Italian newspaper Corriere Della Sera, Pope Francis said that “NATO barking at Russia” caused the Kremlin “to react badly and unleash the conflict.” Yet, entirely dismissing the pope’s stunning remark might be short-sighted because, certainly, some U.S. and NATO actions did indeed cause the Kremlin to “react badly.” 

Over the past 22 years in particular, several of America’s policies, miscues and miscalculations towards Russia have backfired. None can be used as an excuse for Russian President Vladimir Putin’s illegal and horrific war in Ukraine. But a brief review of U.S.-Russian relations underscores the power of unintended consequences.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO caused European instability, violates ILaw, and refuses to enforce democracy – it fails at every goal

Mahbubani 1/1 - Kishore Mahbubani is a Distinguished Fellow at the Asia Research Institute. (“Asia, Say No to NATO,” Springer Link. January 1st, 2022. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-16-6811-1_15) CTF

Something very dangerous happened a few weeks ago when the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) held its meeting in Brussels. In its communique after the meeting on June 14, it identified China as a “systemic challenge” to areas “relevant to Alliance security”. The implicit message was clear: NATO would like to expand its tentacles beyond the Atlantic to the Pacific Ocean. All of us who live close to the Pacific Ocean, especially in East Asia, should be deeply concerned. If NATO comes to the Pacific, it only means trouble for us. Why? Three reasons. First, NATO is not a geopolitically wise organization. It did a brilliant job in the Cold War, deterring Soviet expansion into Europe. During the Cold War, it was careful and restrained, building up military capabilities and avoiding direct military conflicts. The Cold War ended 30 years ago. In theory, after “mission accomplished”, NATO should have shut down. In practice, it desperately looked for new missions. In the process, it destabilized Europe. It bears remembering that relations between Russia and NATO used to be much better, so much so that in 1994, Russia officially signed up to the Partnership for Peace, a program aimed at building trust between NATO and other European and former Soviet countries. But things fell apart because NATO rejected Russia’s repeated requests to refuse to accept new members in its “backyard”. Then, in April 2008, NATO pushed things further, opening the door to membership for Georgia and Ukraine at the Bucharest summit. As US commentator Tom Friedman noted: “There is one thing future historians will surely remark upon, and that is the utter poverty of imagination that characterized US foreign policy in the late 1990s. They will note that one of the seminal events of this century took place between 1989 and 1992—the collapse of the Soviet Empire Thanks to Western resolve and the courage of Russian democrats, that Soviet empire collapsed without a shot, spawning a democratic Russia, setting free the former Soviet republics and leading to unprecedented arms control agreements with the US. And what was America’s response? It was to expand the NATO Cold-War alliance against Russia and bring it closer to Russia’s borders.” The result was inevitable. Russia had tried to be a friend of the NATO countries after the Cold War ended. Instead, it was slapped in the face with NATO expansion. Many Western media reports portray Russia as a “belligerent, aggressive actor”. They fail to mention that NATO actions generated this response. A truly dangerous moment surfaced in 2014 when it looked as if NATO was about to encroach into Ukraine with the ouster of its pro-Russian president Viktor Yanukovych by Western-supported demonstrators. For President Vladimir Putin, that was the last straw, and soon after came the seizure of Crimea, which the Russians consider part of their cultural heartland. The dangers of Western expansion into Ukraine were well known. Dr Henry Kissinger had pointed out that the Ukrainians “live in a country with a complex history and a polyglot composition. The Western part was incorporated into the Soviet Union in 1939 when Stalin and Hitler divided up the spoils. Crimea, 60% of whose population is Russian, became part of Ukraine only in 1954, when Nikita Khrushchev, a Ukrainian by birth, awarded it as part of the 300th-year celebration of a Russian agreement with the Cossacks. The west is largely Catholic; the east is largely Russian Orthodox. The west speaks Ukrainian; the east speaks mostly Russian. Any attempt by one wing of Ukraine to dominate the other—as has been the pattern—would lead eventually to civil war or break-up. To treat Ukraine as part of an East–West confrontation would scuttle for decades any prospect to bring Russia and theWest—especially Russia and Europe—into a cooperative international system”. Sadly, since 2014, Ukraine has become a divided country. If NATO had shown greater geopolitical restraint, these problems could have been avoided. The second major weakness of post-Cold War NATO is that its behavior reflects the old adage: If you are a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. Curiously, during the Cold War, NATO dropped very few bombs on foreign countries. Since the end of the Cold War, NATO has dropped a massive amount of bombs on many countries. Between March and June 1999, NATO bombing campaigns were estimated to have killed 500 civilians in the former Yugoslavia. NATO also dropped several thousand cluster bombs there, despite their use being illegal under the 2010 Convention on Cluster Munitions Treaty. NATO airstrikes in Libya in 2011 resulted in 7700 bombs dropped, and killed an estimated 70 civilians. Many of the bombing missions were illegal under international law. I vividly remember having dinner at the home of a former Canadian diplomat in Ottawa when NATO decided to bomb Yugoslav forces in 1999. This Canadian diplomat was deeply worried. Since this military campaign was neither an act of self-defense nor authorized by the United Nations Security Council, it was clearly and technically illegal under international lawIndeed, Ms Carla Del Ponte, a former special prosecutor in the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia, tried to investigate whether NATO committed war crimes in the former Yugoslavia. Even though most NATO countries believe in the sanctity of international law, they applied so much political pressure that Ms Del Ponte could not carry out her investigations. Even worse, NATO has often started a military campaign and then walked away from the disastrous consequences of its intervention. Libya is a classic example of this. The NATO countries were exultant when Muammar Gaddafi was removed from Libya. However, after the country split apart and became caught up in a civil war, NATO just walked away. Many years ago, a wise former US secretary of state, Mr Colin Powell, warned against such military interventions by citing a common statement in crystal shops: “If you break it, you own it.” NATO failed to own the wreckage it left behind. This leads to the third danger: East Asia has developed, with the assistance of ASEAN, a very cautious and pragmatic geopolitical culture. In the 30 years since the end of the Cold War, NATO has dropped several thousand bombs on many countries. By contrast, in the same period, no bombs have been dropped anywhere in East Asia. This is therefore the biggest danger we face in NATO expanding its tentacles from the Atlantic to the Pacific: It could end up exporting its disastrous militaristic culture to the relatively peaceful environment we have developed in East Asia. Indeed, if NATO was a wise, thinking, and learning organization, it should actually be studying the East Asian record—especially the ASEAN record of preserving peace—and learning lessons from it. Instead, it is doing the opposite, thereby creating real dangers for our region. In view of the risks to East Asia through the potential expansion of NATO culture, all of East Asia should speak with one voice and say no to NATO.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

Pro-democracy NATO movements tilted Russia – it set the floor for the war

Mearsheimer 14, John J. Mearsheimer is a political scientist and IR specialist who started the offensive realist school of thought. (“Why the Ukraine Crisis is the West’s Fault,” Hein Online. August 18th, 2014. https://www.mearsheimer.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Why-the-Ukraine-Crisis-Is.pdf) CTF

According to the prevailing wisdom in the West, the Ukraine crisis can be blamed almost entirely on Russian aggression. Russian President Vladimir Putin, the argument goes, annexed Crimea out of a long-standing desire to resuscitate the Soviet empire, and he may eventually go after the rest of Ukraine, as well as other countries in eastern Europe. In this view, the ouster of Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych in February 2014 merely provided a pretext for Putin’s decision to order Russian forces to seize part of Ukraine.

But this account is wrong: the United States and its European allies share most of the responsibility for the crisis. The taproot of the trouble is NATO enlargement, the central element of a larger strategy to move Ukraine out of Russia’s orbit and integrate it into the West. At the same time, the EU’s expansion eastward and the West’s backing of the pro-democracy movement in Ukraine -- beginning with the Orange Revolution in 2004 -- were critical elements, too. Since the mid-1990s, Russian leaders have adamantly opposed NATO enlargement, and in recent years, they have made it clear that they would not stand by while their strategically important neighbor turned into a Western bastion. For Putin, the illegal overthrow of Ukraine’s democratically elected and pro-Russian president -- which he rightly labeled a “coup” - - was the final straw. He responded by taking Crimea, a peninsula he feared would host a NATO naval base, and working to destabilize Ukraine until it abandoned its efforts to join the West.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO’s global expansionism forces Russia’s hand – leads to Russian expansionism and conflict

Achcar 6/23/22. Gilbert, professor at SOAS, University of London. “NATO From Bad to Worse” https://www.thenation.com/article/world/nato-china-russia-us/ JH-NCP

Supporters of NATO’s eastward expansion wanted the US empire to encompass a large chunk of the former Soviet empire in the belief that, sooner or later, post-communist Russia would seek to revive its long imperial tradition. It was therefore necessary to preempt this inevitable development by securing US control of as much of the former Soviet empire as possible. Since Putin’s regime has indeed engaged in predatory behavior since 2008 in what has traditionally been regarded by Russia as its imperial “near abroad”—intervention in Georgia in 2008, annexation of Crimea and intervention in Donbas in 2014, attempted invasion for “regime change” in Ukraine in 2022, and ongoing efforts to occupy the whole of Donbas and adjacent areas—one would be tempted to believe that those who advocated NATO’s enlargement have been proven right.

The truth is, however, that this outcome is precisely what those who opposed the enlargement had cautioned against. They rightly predicted that the Russians would see NATO’s eastward expansion as a hostile gesture and that it would therefore breed revanchist attitudes among them. In other words, they warned that enlarging NATO in preemption of Russia’s return to imperial behavior would actually act as a self-fulfilling prophecy.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

Integrated NATO escalates Ukraine war – western neoliberal expansionism into Russia’s backyard forces Putin to lash out.

Awan 5/31/22. Zamir Ahmed, Prof. Engr. Zamir Ahmed Awan, Sinologist (ex-Diplomat), Non-Resident Fellow of CCG (Center for China and Globalization), National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST), Islamabad, Pakistan. “NATO EXPANSION IS THE ROOT CAUSE OF UKRAINE CRISIS” https://strafasia.com/nato-expansion-is-the-root-cause-of-ukraine-crisis/ JH-NCP

NATO expansion is the root cause which triggered Russia’s attack on Ukraine. The Eastern European countries which had formerly been party to the Warsaw Pact and had remained poor under USSR influence were tempted with lucrative incentives offered by NATO. In fact, NATO was encircling Russia and squeezing it from all possible directions, having deployed their defense forces and weapons around Russian territory and creating a genuine concern for the latter.

Russia had been trying to convince the US, UK, and EU to refrain from deploying NATO forces in its neighborhood. It tried to resolve situation peacefully and through diplomatic channels for eight years, but the West did not bother with it. The Second Minsk Agreement was a document aimed at resolving the armed conflict in eastern Ukraine. It was agreed to on February 11-12, 2015 at a summit in Minsk by the leaders of Germany, France, Ukraine and Russia in the Normandy Four format, and was signed by the Contact Group for the Peaceful Settlement of the Situation in Eastern Ukraine, consisting of representatives of Ukraine, Russia, the OSCE and the unrecognized Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics. Later, the Minsk agreements were approved by a special resolution of the UN Security Council. However, since the signing of the Minsk agreements, not one of their points has been implemented by the Ukrainian side.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = russia expansionism

NATO expansionism led to the conflict in Ukraine – experts

Boyle 3/8. Francis A., professor of international law at the University of Illinois. “NATO expansion triggered Russia-Ukraine conflict” https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202203/08/WS6227091ba310cdd39bc8b3d0.html edited for gendered language JH-NCP

Given the United States’ numerous illegal invasions of other countries, especially its invasion of Iraq, based on lies conjured up by the US administration and institutions, it is in no position to lecture other countries on protecting human rights or abiding by international law.

People should understand the root cause behind the Russia-Ukraine conflict. The bid to expand NATO poses is a serious threat to Russia. A couple of days ago the Ukrainian leadership even called for immediately making Ukraine a NATO member so it can get direct military support from the cross-Atlantic alliance and acquire nuclear weapons, which would effectively reverse the 1994 Budapest Memorandum that facilitated the accession of Ukraine to the Treaty on Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons as a non-nuclear state.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato = freeloading

NATO’s bad – European countries freeload on US defense capabilities BUT the alliance is fine without the US

Kazianis 18. Harry J., Senior director at the Center for the National Interest, a Washington, D.C.-based national security think tank founded by President Richard Nixon. He also serves as executive editor of its publishing arm, The National Interest. In the past, Harry served as a foreign policy adviser to the 2016 presidential campaign of Sen. Ted Cruz and as editor-and-chief of The Diplomat. “Trump is right -- NATO is obsolete, and he's delivering that message loud and clear” https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/trump-is-right-nato-is-obsolete-and-hes-delivering-that-message-loud-and-clear JH-NCP

President Trump continued his criticism of NATO Tuesday before he headed to Europe for a meeting of leaders of the 29-nation alliance Wednesday, trading barbed tweets with European Council President Donald Tusk. The testy exchange was further evidence that the president is right when he says that NATO – created in 1949 – has become obsolete.

The U.S. president understands one of the great cardinal rules of geopolitics that others seem to have forgotten: no alliance lasts forever. After almost 70 years, America and its NATO partners in Europe may be heading for a new relationship, while still remaining friends.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato unsustainable – collapse

NATO’s fracturing – spending, beef with Turkey, and American dominance all cause friction

Kulikov 20. Valery, “NATO in danger of falling apart” JH-NCP

However, a significant number of European politicians today are more inclined to reduce the military budget of their countries, especially given the current financial and economic problems. In addition, an increasing number of politicians (especially in the Baltics) who recently started to actively offer their countries for the deployment of American troops, naturally at the expense of ‘American security guarantees’, see in this an opportunity to reduce their national military spending and to transfer budget funds to other domestic expenses instead. Thus, according to err.ee., an Estonian information resource, the Minister of Finance of the country Martin Helme (Conservative People’s Party, EKRE) recently proposed to cut the state’s military spending by € 50 million.

Alliances and security guarantees were once viewed as the most serious obligations a state can undertake. Today, however, Washington is handing out security guarantees like a hotel administrator — candy to its guests: everybody gets one, plus an extra piece to anyone who asks for it. However, it is believed that such obligations are worthless, notes The National Interest.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato unsustainable – collapse

The US is drifting apart from European NATO allies – tensions over spending, Chinese tech, and American focus pivot to Asia

Caroll 20. Richard, holds two degrees, one in Economics and another in the Liberal Arts. Richard is a retired economist from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and a retired soldier. His focus was in administration and intelligence. “The End of NATO?” https://intpolicydigest.org/the-end-of-nato/ edited for gendered language JH-NCP

NATO was founded in April of 1949. NATO was formed as a counterweight to the growing political and military power of the then Soviet Union. From 1949 until the fall of the Soviet Union, the purpose of NATO had been to prevent an invasion of Western Europe by the Soviet Union. With the collapse of the Soviet Union in October of 1991 the rationale behind NATO rendered the organization moot. Yet, like all large bureaucracies, NATO lived on.

The main impetus that the United States became involved in NATO had been the threat of communism. With the collapse of the Soviet Union, and the subsequent fall of communism worldwide as a threat against the capitalistic United States, the new economic, political and military situation no longer justifies the expenditure of funds and military resources by the United States as was necessary during the Cold War.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato unsustainable – collapse

Lack of European military spending and shifting US focus collapse NATO

Olsen 21. Henry, Washington Post columnist and a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. “The crisis in Afghanistan is shaking NATO. Its foundation was already weakening in Europe.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/27/crisis-afghanistan-is-shaking-nato-its-foundation-was-already-weakening-europe/ JH-NCP

The problem comes when pollsters dig a bit deeper. The central feature of any military alliance is that all members come to the aid of one another in case of attack. That unified stance — collective defense in strategic parlance — is what makes the alliance credible. If one or more parties won’t defend other members, the whole enterprise falls apart. Indeed, that is what many European leaders fear as the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan raises questions about its ability to live up to its commitments.

Whether that fear is justified or not, the fact is that majorities in most European nations already oppose the use of their troops to aid a NATO ally. That startling finding comes from a February 2020 Pew Research poll. The survey asked respondents from 16 NATO nations whether that nation should use military force to defend a NATO ally in a serious military conflict with Russia. Majorities of only five nations — the United States, Britain, Canada, the Netherlands and Lithuania — answered yes. Pluralities or majorities in every other nation surveyed opposed coming to the ally’s assistance, with opposition rising to 60 percent among Germans.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › withdrawal = collapse

US Withdrawal causes NATO collapse – follow on

Monov 2019 (Lyubomir Monov works for the ministry in defense in Sofia, Bulgaria, “NATO Under Pressure”, https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1702&context=jss )//MargaretE

Are there any scenarios for dissolution of NATO? Peter Schwartz and Doug Randall consider this question in their essay “Ahead of the Curve: Anticipating Strategic Surprise”. They insist than in the future the fundamental strategic interests of the US and Europe will diverge. The Americans will not be willing to pay billions for the protection of rich European countries. The Europeans will refrain from participating in peacekeeping operations in places such Africa. Europe’s main goal will be to deter the rising power of America. The United States will withdraw their forces from Europe. The United Kingdom is suspicious of its continental allies and generally follows the United States. Consequently, without America and Great Britain, NATO will collapse. 24 The collapse of NATO may be a sequential result from several correlated events. They might include partisan actions from the U.S. leadership and responses from the European states that will increase political and military disparity. For instance, a reason for possible dissolution of NATO could be the difference between America's national interests and those of the European allies especially with regard to military interventions outside the Euro-Atlantic area. America is likely to feel frustrated by the lack of reciprocity, considering the fact that during the last seventy years the United States invested enormous funds in the reconstruction of the European continent. Americans might have some additional disappointments based on the probability that European partners will delay or will not implement the commitment to provide 2 percent of their GDP to mutual defense. Consequently, the probable European failure to commit to the common security may increase the financial responsibility and may raise the military burden on the United States. The latter may increase the level of dissatisfaction with NATO from U.S. citizens. The possibility of a continued lack of European investment in the area of defense will widen the technological gap and will affect the ability of Allied Forces to act as one entity. Conceived in this way, these factors combined with the traditional American rhetoric about isolationism may lead to the withdrawal of the United States from NATO. Canada without the American military machine will not be able to ensure the survivability of the transatlantic link, which means the effective disintegration of NATO. 25 Richard Jordan from the conservative website the Federalist asserts that the Alliance will crumble slowly and gradually. The author claims the world no longer needs the Cold War’s NATO. Furthermore, he insists that NATO has had a privilege to behave irrationally, there are no reasons for its existence, and there is no force, which might transform it. Nowadays the world is in a different paradigm–America is not willing to pay any price and bear any burden. The current Administration sees the world through the prism of realism, which general assumption is that each party acts only in their own narrow interests. Since the United States has a number of domestic political differences and external economic concerns, Washington does not want to invest resources and efforts to subsidize the luxurious European lifestyle. In five to ten years, the writer proclaims, Europe will experience a crisis, which Europeans will not manage to solve. In addition, Jordan thinks that, due to exhausted political patience the United States might not support Europe which ultimate result is a collapse of NATO.

2022 Georgetown Counterplan
nato withdrawal cp › neg › nato collapse good – top level

NATO credibility hurts the Global South and wrecks chances for success

Rogers 5/21/22 (Paul Rogers is Emeritus Professor of Peace Studies in the Department of Peace Studies and International Relations at Bradford University, and an Honorary Fellow at the Joint Service Command and Staff College. He is openDemocracy’s international security correspondent, The Ukraine war has given NATO renewed credibility. That’s a problem, )//MargaretE

It is assumed that good times will continue to roll for the military-industrial complexes of Europe, as with the latest kit, even if the abject failure of the Russia armed forces hardly suggests that bigger budgets are needed. Not everything fits neatly into place, though, and two very troubling issues lie ahead. The first is that in the past two decades, NATO has been anything but a success. In Afghanistan, it was in charge of the from 2003 to 2014 and then the smaller, non-combat force, ‘Resolute Support Mission’, from 2015 through to the end of the disastrous war last year. In 2011, Libya was another NATO failure, where the bloc was said to be involved in a humanitarian intervention but ended up overseeing regime change, leaving a failed state in its wake. Beyond these, though, is the much bigger issue: NATO is well-nigh irrelevant when it comes to the main global security challenges, climate breakdown and the widening socioeconomic divide. Africans support the Ukrainian people, but centuries of experience also make us wary of ‘solutions’ by our former colonisers. We are currently seeing an impact of the . Records are being broken daily but the remarkable thing that sets this apart from other serious heatwaves is that it is happening than would be expected. We are also seeing warnings of , stemming in part from climate factors but also fuelled by market impacts of the Ukraine war. As in the world food crisis of the 1970s, though, it is also down to socioeconomic factors. Now, as then, there are enough grain reserves to go around, but hundreds of millions of people simply cannot afford to pay the soaring prices. Both the heatwave and the food crisis are early signs of what is to come if economic reform and radical decarbonisation are not implemented, and they mean that we are heading for a deeply unstable and insecure world. If the Ukraine war does end soon, NATO will emerge as an increasingly strong and confident alliance, yet it will be close to irrelevant when it comes to the real global challenges. More than that, given its performance in Afghanistan and Libya, NATO will be seen increasingly as a negative influence across the Global South, an alliance dominated by white Western states committed to protecting their own security. commented on the attitude to the Ukraine war in lower-income countries, with tepid support for the West mixed with a ‘plague on both your houses’ mood. If NATO is to be relevant in a fractured world, it will have to evolve very quickly into a different kind of alliance. This must be part of a global transformation of understanding about security that is becoming more and more urgent. It is a lot to hope for, but if NATO doesn’t change, it won’t just be irrelevant, it will be an increasing part of the problem.