2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – Regulation good
Maliha, 21
[George, MD, is a second-year internal medicine resident at the University of Pennsylvania Health System, 7-13-2021, “To Spur Growth in AI, We Need a New Approach to Legal Liability”, Harvard Business Review, , accessed 7-18-2022, BB]
Granted, a regulatory scheme that attempts to specify an AI system completely will almost certainly hamper innovation. But those costs may be acceptable in particular areas such as drug development, where comprehensive Food and Drug Administration regulatory schemes can replace liability completely.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – Regulation good
Maliha, 21
[George, MD, is a second-year internal medicine resident at the University of Pennsylvania Health System, 7-13-2021, “To Spur Growth in AI, We Need a New Approach to Legal Liability”, Harvard Business Review, , accessed 7-18-2022, BB]
Artificial intelligence (AI) is sweeping through industries ranging from cybersecurity to environmental protection — and the Covid-19 pandemic has only accelerated this trend. AI may improve the lives of millions, but it also will inevitably cause accidents that injure people or parties — indeed, it already has through incidents like autonomous vehicle crashes. An outdated liability system in the United States and other countries, however, is unable to manage these risks, which is a problem because those risks can impede AI innovations and adoption. Therefore, it is crucial that we reform the liability system. Doing so will help speed AI innovations and adoption.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – Regulation good
Stepken, 21
[Axel, chairman of the board of management, October 27, 2021, “AI regulation – why it will boost innovation”, LinkedIn, , accessed 7-18-2022, BB]
Most people tend to flinch automatically at the mention of regulation. However, regulatory agreements and normative requirements are what enable us to benefit from today’s global trade networks. I firmly believe that an assured regulatory framework enhances, rather than impairs, innovation and economic opportunities.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – Regulation good
It’s not a question of “who implements AI first” if American AI is bad
Marcus 22 (Gary Marcus, holds a PhD from MIT, founded Geometric Intelligence, a machine learning company purchased by Uber two years later in 2016; "Artificial General Intelligence Is Not as Imminent as You Might Think", 6-6-2022, Scientific American, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/artificial-general-intelligence-is-not-as-imminent-as-you-might-think1/, DOA: 7-18-2022)//ATJ
To the average person, it must seem as if the field of artificial intelligence is making immense progress. According to the press releases, and some of the more gushing media accounts, OpenAI’s DALL-E 2 can seemingly create spectacular images from any text; another OpenAI system called GPT-3 can talk about just about anything; and a system called Gato that was released in May by DeepMind, a division of Alphabet, seemingly worked well on every task the company could throw at it. One of DeepMind’s high-level executives even went so far as to brag that in the quest for artificial general intelligence (AGI), AI that has the flexibility and resourcefulness of human intelligence, “The Game is Over!” And Elon Musk said recently that he would be surprised if we didn’t have artificial general intelligence by 2029.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – Regulation good
Scharre 21 (Paul Scharre, holds a Ph.D. in War Studies from King’s College London and an M.A. in Political Economy and Public Policy and a B.S. in Physics, cum laude, from Washington University in St. Louis, Vice President and Director of Studies at the Center for a New American Security, previously worked in the Office of the Secretary of Defense; "Debunking the AI Arms Race Theory", Texas National Security Review, vol. 4, iss. 3, summer 2021, 121-132, DOI: 10.26153/tsw/13985, DOA: 4-14-2022)//ATJ
Race to the Bottom on Safety A related risk of a “racing” dynamic among competitors could come from an acceleration, not of the pace of operations on the battlefield, but of the process of fielding new AI systems. AI systems today have a host of safety and security problems that can make them brittle, unreliable, and insecure.29 Because machine learning in particular can create new ways in which systems can fail, militaries face novel challenges in adopting AI systems.30 Militaries will have to adopt new methods to test, evaluate, verify, and validate AI systems (also known as TEVV).31 Such concerns related to autonomy are well known in the U.S. defense community,32 although at present they have not been solved to a satisfactory degree. Machine learning introduces additional challenges with regard to testing, evaluation, verification, and validation. A rush to field AI systems before they are fully tested could result in a “race to the bottom” on safety, with militaries fielding accident-prone AI systems. There are strong bureaucratic and institutional imperatives for militaries to field systems that are robust and secure. Indeed, designing systems to military specification standards often means making them more robust for a wider range of environmental conditions and shocks than comparable commercial systems, even at the expense of other aspects of performance, such as size, weight, or usability. AI presents novel challenges, however, in achieving the robustness needed for operating in the complex, hazardous, and adversarial environments that often characterize military operations. Certain AI methods today, such as deep learning, remain relatively immature with significant reliability challenges. A 2017 Department of Defense report by the JASON scientific advisory group explained that deep neural networks are immature as regards the “illities”, including reliability, maintainability, accountability, validation and verification, debug-ability, evolvability, fragility, attackability, and so forth. … Further, it is not clear that the existing AI paradigm is immediately amenable to any sort of software engineering validation and verification. This is a serious issue, and is a potential roadblock to DoD’s [Department of Defense’s] use of these modern AI systems, especially when considering the liability and accountability of using AI in lethal systems.33 The Defense Department’s 2018 AI strategy calls for building AI systems that are “resilient, robust, reliable, and secure.”34 Yet, the current state of technology makes achieving this goal particularly difficult for AI systems that incorporate deep learning, a subfield of AI that has seen significant growth and attention in recent years. While there is active research underway to improve AI safety and security, militaries will have to adapt to the technology as it currently is, at least for the time being. An ideal process would be for militaries to engage in experimentation, prototyping, and concept development, but also to subject AI systems to rigorous TEVV under realistic operational conditions before deployment. Taking shortcuts on testing and evaluation and fielding a system before it is fully tested could lead to accidents, which, in some settings, could undermine international stability. In evaluating new technologies, militaries may be relatively accepting of the risk of accidents, which may lead them to tolerate the deployment of systems that have reliability concerns. In building and fielding new capabilities, militaries have to weigh the possibility of an accident occurring against other concerns, such as forgoing valuable military capabilities. The military operational environment is fraught with risk, in both training and real-world operations. Military institutions balance managing this risk with other factors, such as the need for training, developing new capabilities, or accomplishing the mission. Military institutions view casualties from training accidents or testing new capabilities as a tragic but unavoidable part of the business of preparing for war. Militaries expect high performance from their forces, often while they are performing dangerous tasks, but militaries neither demand nor expect accident-free operations in most settings.35 From 2006 to 2020, over 5,000 U.S. servicemembers were killed in non-war related accidents, the majority of which occurred within the United States. Accidents overall accounted for nearly 32 percent of U.S. servicemember deaths during this period, and even accounted for a significant portion of servicemember deaths in Iraq (19 percent) and Afghanistan (16 percent).36 These accident rates are not unusual for the U.S. armed forces. This is business as usual. Accidents draw the attention of senior military and civilian officials when a spate of accidents occur in a short amount of time — such as a series of aircraft crashes,37 ship collisions,38 or training accidents.39 Yet, as one report on naval accidents from 1945 to 1988 notes, “peacetime naval accidents are a fact of life.”40 The same is true of military air and ground operations. Other nations’ militaries may do an even poorer job of managing risk when it comes to accidents than the U.S. military. For example, the Soviet/Russian submarine community has a much higher accident rate than the U.S. submarine community.41 New technologies in particular present an increased risk of accidents, yet militaries may press ahead out of a desire to develop and field what they perceive to be a valuable capability. For example, the V-22 Osprey tiltrotor aircraft suffered four crashes during development, killing 30 U.S. servicemembers in total, yet the Defense Department continued development.42 The V-22 program manager cited a rush to develop the technology as a factor in the accidents, stating, “Meeting a funding deadline was more important than making sure we’d done all the testing we could.”43 Taking shortcuts on testing in particular appears to have been a factor in at least one fatal crash. According to a Government Accountability Office investigation of the V-22 program, “schedule pressures” led the program to conduct only 33 of 103 planned tests of an aerodynamic phenomenon called a “vortex ring state,”44 a phenomenon that later caused an April 2000 crash that killed 19 servicemembers.45 Absent competitive dynamics, militaries may be able to manage the challenges of fielding safe AI systems to a more-or-less satisfactory degree, albeit with some risk of an accident occurring. However, out of a desire to field AI capabilities ahead of competitors, militaries may be more willing to accept risk than they might otherwise be and to field systems that are prone to mishaps.46 Similar competitive dynamics may have played a role in accidents with self-driving cars and commercial airline autopilot technology, as companies rushed to beat others to market.47 These dynamics, while not an arms race, could lead militaries to engage in a “race to the bottom” on safety. This risk could become particularly acute in wartime. Managing these risks is challenging because assessing them can be difficult, especially when it comes to new technologies. Accident rates may be well-known for mature technologies, but they are unknown for technologies still in development. In the case of the V-22 Osprey development, for example, it is not as though the Defense Department knew that developing it would lead to multiple crashes and 30 fatalities but decided that achieving the capability was worth the cost. Engineers, testers, and program managers are flying in the dark when it comes to new technologies — that is, after all, the point of testing new systems. The concern is not only that organizations may take measured risks to field new capabilities, but also that institutional and bureaucratic imperatives may lead organizations to distort their own perceptions of risk, further contributing to accidents. This sociological phenomenon has been cited as a cause in the 1986 Space Shuttle Challenger explosion, for example.48
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – No China AI Lead
Greene 21 — Tristan Greene, editor and technology reporter at TNW, 2021 (“Here’s why the US continues to beat China in the AI race,” TNW, June 2nd, Available Online at , Accessed 07-18-2022)
The global AI race was supposed to be a sprint. Back in 2017 when driverless cars and domestic robots were thought to be just around the corner, the promise of deep learning made it seem like we were mere months away from living in an AI-powered utopia.
As it turns out, the global AI race is more of a marathon. And the US has a huge lead that’ll be difficult to overcome for any country, but especially China.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – No China AI Lead
Cooper and Kompella 22 — James Cooper, professor of law and director of International Legal Studies at California Western School of Law, research fellow at Singapore University of Social Sciences, J.D. from the University of Toronto (Canada), LL.M. from the University of Cambridge (U.K), and Kashyap Kompella, technology industry analyst and CEO of RPA2AI, a global artificial intelligence advisory firm, Masters in Business Laws from National Law School of India University (India), 2022 (“No, China is not winning the AI race,” The Hill, February 3rd, Available Online at , Accessed 07-19-2022)
The global competition between the United States and China continues apace. Technology is rightly seen as providing unique leverage to win this geopolitical race. The U.S. long has been the global technology powerhouse, but not surprisingly, we have heard much about the Chinese government’s ambition to dominate high-tech industries such as 5G telecommunications, autonomous vehicles, blockchain, and semiconductor chips.
In this light, as a horizontal technology that can be applied across all sectors, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a strategic priority and the Chinese focus on superiority in this field is touted as something about which the U.S. should be concerned. Some have gone so far as to conclude that the West has already lost the AI race.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – No China AI Lead
O.I. 22 (Oxford Insights; "Government AI Readiness Index 2021", January 2022, Oxford Insights, https://static1.squarespace.com/static/58b2e92c1e5b6c828058484e/t/61ead0752e7529590e98d35f/1642778757117/Government_AI_Readiness_21.pdf, DOA: 7-18-2022)//ATJ
Figure : the US firmly leads the AI index, with China coming in at 15th.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Affirmative › 2AC – No China AI Lead
Ghi et al. 21 (Trung Ghi; Abhishek Srivastava; Arthur D. Little; "The Global AI Arms Race – How Nations can Avoid being Left Behind", January 2021, PRISM, https://www.adlittle.com/sites/default/files/prism/Global%20AI%20article.pdf, DOA: 7-18-2022)//ATJ
There are several country rankings of AI strength across the world. Those that focus on metrics such as patents and research publications tend to list China first, followed by the US, with third place disputed between European and Asian countries including South Korea, Japan and India.
However, taking a broader approach using a composite AI-readiness index (from Oxford Insights) that factors in governance, skills and education, infrastructure and data, and government/public services reveals the top three countries to be Singapore, the UK and Germany. (See Figure 1.)
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 2NC – Generic Link
Gönenç Gürkaynak 18, Founding Partner of ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, LL.M. from Harvard Law School, İlay Yılmaz, Partner at ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, and Güneş Haksever, LLM from Istanbul Bilgi University, Attorney at IBM Turkey, “Stifling Artificial Intelligence: Human Perils”, Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 32, Issue 5, 12/12/2018, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3285264
Although scientists have calculated the significant positive welfare effects of Artificial Intelligence (AI), fear mongering continues to hinder AI development. If regulations in this sector stifle our active imagination, we risk wasting the true potential of AIs dynamic efficiencies. Not only would Schumpeter dislike us for spoiling creative destruction, but the AI thinkers of the future would also rightfully see our efforts as the ‘dark age’ of human advancement. This article provides a brief philosophical introduction to artificial intelligence; categorizes artificial intelligence to shed light on what we have and know now and what we might expect from the prospective developments; reflects thoughts of worldwide famous thinkers to broaden our horizons; provides information on the attempts to regulate artificial intelligence from a legal perspective; and discusses how the legal approach needs to be to ensure the balance between artificial intelligence development and human control over them, and to ensure friendly artificial intelligence.
Our technology, our machines, is part of our humanity. We created them to extend ourselves, and that is what is unique about human beings. – Ray Kurzweil1
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 2NC – Uniqueness [China]
Bourne 22 (Jacob Bourne, analyst on the Connectivity & Tech Briefings team at Inside Intelligence, formerly covering Engineering; "Collaborations falter as US, China compete for AI dominance", 5-31-2022, Insider Intelligence, https://www.insiderintelligence.com/content/collaborations-falter-us-china-compete-ai-dominance, DOA: 7-18-2022)//ATJ
Why it’s worth watching: Despite the US’s early dominance and continued academic research lead in AI, China’s ultra-competitive tech industry and greater access to big data to train AI systems is positioning it as a global leader for AI implementation.
AI is a pivotal technology across industries, including defense, prompting Russian President Vladimir Putin to say in 2017 that AI is “the future, not only for Russia, but for all humankind. … Whoever becomes the leader in this sphere will become the ruler of the world.”
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 1NC – DA [Russia]
Jain 19—(senior fellow with the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, where he oversees the Atlantic Council’s Democratic Order Initiative and D10 Strategy Forum). Ash Jain and Matthew Kroenig. 10/30/2019. “Present at the Re-Creation: A Global Strategy for Revitalizing, Adapting, and Defending a Rules-Based International System.” Stowcroft Center for Strategy and Security. Atlantic Council Strategy Papers. . Accessed 7/27/21.
The system must also be adapted to deal with new issues that were not envisioned when the existing order was designed. Foremost among these issues is emerging and disruptive technology, including AI, additive manufacturing (or 3D printing), quantum computing, genetic engineering, robotics, directed energy, the Internet of things (IOT), 5G, space, cyber, and many others. Like other disruptive technologies before them, these innovations promise great benefits, but also carry serious downside risks. For example, AI is already resulting in massive efficiencies and cost savings in the private sector. Routine tasks and other more complicated jobs, such as radiology, are already being automated. In the future, autonomous weapons systems may go to war against each other as human soldiers remain out of harm’s way.
Yet, AI is also transforming economies and societies, and generating new security challenges. Automation will lead to widespread unemployment. The final realization of driverless cars, for example, will put out of work millions of taxi, Uber, and long-haul truck drivers. Populist movements in the West have been driven by those disaffected by globalization and technology, and mass unemployment caused by automation will further grow those ranks and provide new fuel to grievance politics. Moreover, some fear that autonomous weapons systems will become “killer robots” that select and engage targets without human input, and could eventually turn on their creators, resulting in human extinction. The other technologies on this lisgt similarly balance great potential upside with great downside risk. 3D printing, for example, can be used to “make anything anywhere,” reducing costs for a wide range of manufactured goods and encouraging a return of local manufacturing industries.61 At the same time, advanced 3D printers can also be used by revisionist and rogue states to print component parts for advanced weapons systems or even WMD programs, spurring arms races and weapons proliferation.62 Genetic engineering can wipe out entire classes of disease through improved medicine, or wipe out entire classes of people through genetically engineered superbugs. Directed-energy missile defenses may defend against incoming missile attacks, while also undermining global strategic stability.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 1NC – DA [Russia]
Konaev et al. 19 (Margarita Konaev; Samuel Bendett; "Russian AI-Enabled Combat: Coming to a City Near You?", 7-31-2019, War on the Rocks, https://warontherocks.com/2019/07/russian-ai-enabled-combat-coming-to-a-city-near-you/, DOA: 4-19-2022)//ATJ
It should be clear by now that Russia aims to master the psychological dimension of information operations, focused on undermining the state institutions and belief systems of its adversaries. And technological advances in AI have the potential to “hyperpower Russia’s use of disinformation.” It’s well known that Russian influence operations and election interference campaigns leveraged machine learning to tailor propaganda to specific audiences based on race, ethnicity, ideology, demographics, and geographic location. Yet, while the thousands of fake and stolen social media accounts deployed during these operations were manufactured manually, AI can be used to automate, accelerate, and scale synthetic accounts and content. Another worrisome example of an emerging technology the Russian defense establishment could potentially use in information operations entails recent developments in text-generation technology that mimics how humans write. Experts are concerned that this technology will allow governments and non-state actors to spread disinformation on a tremendous scale, as well as that disinformation campaigns can evade detection by generating subtly different content. In this sense, developments in AI could make Russian information operations more efficient, far-reaching, and widespread.
Russia has a long history of waging information warfare. But modern technology not only furthers its reach and magnifies its impact but also arguably renders its democratic adversaries — with their open societies and free flows of information — more vulnerable than ever before. Looking ahead, Russia is likely to continue leveraging machine learning and advances in natural language processing to refine its micro-targeting of malicious content and to construct emotionally sophisticated and relevant propaganda for more effective information operations in future conflicts, including, and especially, those conflicts that entangle Western forces in urban fighting.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 1NC – DA [Russia]
Tadjdeh 21 (Yasmin Tadjdeh; "Algorithmic Warfare: Russia Expanding Fleet of AI-Enabled Weapons", 7-20-2021, National Defense, https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2021/7/20/russia-expanding-fleet-of-ai-enabled-weapons, DOA: 4-19-2022)//ATJ [language edited]
The nation [Russia] wants to use AI for electronic warfare, intelligence, surveillance, reconnaissance and strategic decision-making processes as leaders pursue information dominance on the battlefield, Groen said.
While Russia is not a leader in commercial and academic AI research — as the United States and China are — it would be a grave mistake for the Pentagon to take its eyes off the threat, he said
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 1NC – DA [China]
Jain 19—(senior fellow with the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, where he oversees the Atlantic Council’s Democratic Order Initiative and D10 Strategy Forum). Ash Jain and Matthew Kroenig. 10/30/2019. “Present at the Re-Creation: A Global Strategy for Revitalizing, Adapting, and Defending a Rules-Based International System.” Stowcroft Center for Strategy and Security. Atlantic Council Strategy Papers. . Accessed 7/27/21.
The system must also be adapted to deal with new issues that were not envisioned when the existing order was designed. Foremost among these issues is emerging and disruptive technology, including AI, additive manufacturing (or 3D printing), quantum computing, genetic engineering, robotics, directed energy, the Internet of things (IOT), 5G, space, cyber, and many others. Like other disruptive technologies before them, these innovations promise great benefits, but also carry serious downside risks. For example, AI is already resulting in massive efficiencies and cost savings in the private sector. Routine tasks and other more complicated jobs, such as radiology, are already being automated. In the future, autonomous weapons systems may go to war against each other as human soldiers remain out of harm’s way.
Yet, AI is also transforming economies and societies, and generating new security challenges. Automation will lead to widespread unemployment. The final realization of driverless cars, for example, will put out of work millions of taxi, Uber, and long-haul truck drivers. Populist movements in the West have been driven by those disaffected by globalization and technology, and mass unemployment caused by automation will further grow those ranks and provide new fuel to grievance politics. Moreover, some fear that autonomous weapons systems will become “killer robots” that select and engage targets without human input, and could eventually turn on their creators, resulting in human extinction. The other technologies on this lisgt similarly balance great potential upside with great downside risk. 3D printing, for example, can be used to “make anything anywhere,” reducing costs for a wide range of manufactured goods and encouraging a return of local manufacturing industries.61 At the same time, advanced 3D printers can also be used by revisionist and rogue states to print component parts for advanced weapons systems or even WMD programs, spurring arms races and weapons proliferation.62 Genetic engineering can wipe out entire classes of disease through improved medicine, or wipe out entire classes of people through genetically engineered superbugs. Directed-energy missile defenses may defend against incoming missile attacks, while also undermining global strategic stability.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
DA – AI Arms Racing › Negative › 1NC – DA [China]
Michael Auslin 18, 10-19-2018, [MICHAEL AUSLIN is the Williams-Griffis Fellow in Contemporary Asia at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University, Can the Pentagon Win the AI Arms Race?, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2018-10-19/can-pentagon-win-ai-arms-race, accessed 6-27-2022//BMNT]
When the stingray-shaped object took off and landed lightly on the deck of the USS George H. W. Bush in July 2013, some hailed it as a moment in aviation history to rank with the first heavier-than-air powered flight, at Kitty Hawk, in 1902. The X-47B drone flew itself, decided its own flight path, and completed on its own a mission given to it by humans. The dawn of autonomous weapons systems seemed undeniable. Yet the drone was hardly independent, as humans still programmed all its possible decisions, leaving it to choose from a menu of options. Half a decade later, experts are making new claims that the future of warfare is about to change. Today, artificial intelligence (AI) is the new frontier of military competition, and with China and Russia making headway in the field, the Pentagon is starting to rush, some say belatedly, into the new era.
THE NEXT WAVE OF AI
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › AT Russia Impact
Gardner 2/23 (Frank, “Russia-Ukraine crisis: How likely is it to escalate into broader war?” Feb. 23, 2022)
Let's cut right to the chase here: are we witnessing the prelude to World War 3?
Because let's face it, that is what a lot of people are understandably asking and thinking in the light of the Kremlin's recent actions over Ukraine - actions and statements that have triggered a deluge of denouncements and sanctions from the West.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › AT Russia Impact
Dhanesha 2/25 (Neel, reporter for Vox. “How to think about the risk of nuclear war, according to 3 experts” Feb 25, 2022)
The main reason, Bunn said, is that the United States and its NATO allies have made it clear that they will not send troops to Ukraine. Without the threat of military intervention, Putin has little reason to use his nuclear weapons, especially since Russia has a staggering numbers advantage over the Ukrainian military.
“His objective is not to bring the world to nuclear war,” said , senior lecturer in global studies at Boston University. “His objective is to simply swallow Ukraine — and restore not just the [power of the] Soviet Union, but the Tsarist empire.”
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › AT Authoritarianism
Ganesh ’20 [Janan Ganesh was a Researcher at the Policy Exchange and is the principal political columnist with the Financial Times, “Bonhomie but no brotherhood: The authoritarian bloc that never was,” 4-22-20, https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/us/bonhomie-but-no-brotherhood-the-authoritarian-bloc-that-never-was-1.4235287]
Bill Hicks, the late comic and grouch, dreamt of a political party for “people who hate people”. He just couldn’t get them to come together in the same room. The great egoist movement was undone by its central principle. I think of the skit whenever the world brotherhood of jingoist authoritarians is talked up. US president Donald Trump is in this group, with, among others, the leaders of China (Xi Jinping), Russia (Vladimir Putin), India (Narendra Modi) and Brazil (Jair Bolsonaro). Trump and Xi are superpower rivals, America cancelled India’s preferential trading status, and still the idea of a Nationalist International survives. It should not survive the coronavirus pandemic. Recent months have further teased out the differences between these conflated governments. Their domestic autocracy is real enough, but their coherence as a bloc is overstated. Liberalism is not confronted by anything like a unified opponent. The most vivid case in point is the US-China blame-game. It is also the least surprising. Relations were dire before the virus, and it should not be news that nativists feud more easily than they collude across national lines. World war allusions have flowed too cheaply of late, but it is hard not to think of the autocrats who mercifully failed to act in concert for long in the previous century. Leaders who believe in the separateness of nations above all else will always have trouble co-ordinating. As long as this is true, the position of liberal democracy is less exposed than it sometimes looks. What its enemies have in numbers and geographic spread they lack in togetherness. At present, they cannot agree on the efficacy of the World Health Organisation. The prospect of a new world order built around their shared preferences seems far off. As telling as the diplomatic schisms between nationalists is their range of antivirus policies. Mainstream governments have converged on much the same strategy, couched in much the same language. It is true enough that some were quicker than others and some were better prepared to begin with. As lives are at issue, the stragglers should be held to eventual account. Free-for-all But as time passes, what distinguishes the approaches of, say, France, Canada and Ireland, lies in the details. Given how many countries fall into the non-populist category, true outliers such as Sweden, with its minimal lockdown, are amazingly few. Compare this with the free-for-all inside the populist world. Modi has kept the second-largest population on Earth at home for a month. Binyamin Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister, took measures against the virus relatively early. At the opposite end, there is the laxity of Trump and Bolsonaro. The crisis has exposed how little connects these leaders beyond a surface bonhomie. Some pretend to be serious about the business of government, some do not. A club that encompasses them all is likely to be meaningless. Notice, too, how gaping are its exit doors. By embracing a shutdown, however tardily, and not talking up a relaxation, Boris Johnson is viewed ever more as a “normal” leader. At least before his illness, the UK premier was counted unambiguously among the nativists. Scott Morrison, the Australian prime minister, after tackling the virus seriously, has undergone a similar reassignment. The nationalist team roster has thinned in a few weeks, which tells you how much rigour the idea ever had. And this is not just about personalities. There are theoretical contradictions within populism. This is a creed that cannot decide what it thinks about personal freedom. It resents technocratic bossiness while brooking no checks and balances in the protection of the homeland. Trump claims “total authority”, yes, but to loosen restrictions on people, not to tighten them (except for would-be immigrants). If this tension is evident in one leader, imagine its permutations for policy across several governments across several continents across several issues. Even according an “-ism” to such a disparate bunch is to flatter them. It is understandable that we do. We are a pattern-recognising species, and sometimes a pattern-inventing one. It is consoling to detect some kind of shape to the world. But the point is to not make the pattern itself more frightening than anarchic reality. No doubt, the momentum has been with authoritarians in recent times. The question is whether they add up to a cohesive front against democracy. An empire of illiberalism, on which the sun never sets, assumes more unity than could feasibly exist among national egoists. It just took a crisis to show it.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › AT Authoritarianism
Leong ’19 [Ho Wai Clarence Leong holds an MSc from the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism and an MA in English and Modern History from the University of St. Andrews, is the Asia newswire editor for Dow Jones, “In an age of authoritarianism, the world sees glimmers of hope,” 3-19-19, ]
In the past year, citizens of Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic, and Ethiopia have taken to the streets to demand accountability from their governments, while voters in Malaysia and the Maldives ousted corrupt governments at the ballot box. Countries with a strong civil society or decent-sized middle class continue to push back against autocrats, even though the headlines are more often about the threats to democracy. That’s not to say democracy has nothing to worry about. A new paper published this month found that the world has been in “a wave of autocratization” since 1994, and as many as 75 democracies have seen a reversal to autocracy. Modern-day autocrats know better than to blatantly shore up power, but do so gradually and under a legal facade, making it harder to detect, researchers say. Autocrats pit authoritarianism against democracy, promoting it as a more efficient form of governance and spreading the technology that strengthens control. Social media amplifies the spread of misinformation, clouding voters’ judgment. Global freedom, which is composed of political rights and civil liberties, has been in decline for the 13th year in a row, according to a new report from Freedom House. But the same report also notes significant improvement in accountability for corruption in Angola, Armenia, and other nations. Political participation in most parts of the world has seen a continuous upward trend, reports The Economist. And while autocrats threaten democracies, they are also “fueling a powerful counterattack,” Human Rights Watch notes in its latest annual report. “Those who are bemoaning this authoritarian turn in the world were overstating the case,” says Steven Levitsky, a political scientist at Harvard and co-author of “How Democracies Die.” The euphoric expansion of democracy in the 1990s led to the over-optimistic belief that authoritarianism was a thing of the past, and now that expectation has been dashed, he says. But “there’s yet to emerge a real, viable, truly legitimate alternative to democracy in the world.” That doesn’t discount the fact that people are disillusioned with traditional political parties and losing confidence in democracy. But rather than disengaging from it, that dissatisfaction is driving citizens to participate in political processes, according to The Economist. Voter turnout and membership of political parties rose, reversing a downward trend. A larger proportion of the world’s population is now willing to engage in lawful demonstrations. The Economist also notes a particularly striking area of progress coming from female participation in politics. “Women have become much more active, not just in [the] U.S. but around the world,” says Steven Leslie, lead analyst at The Economist Intelligence Unit. “There is an ongoing surge of female participation in politics and in activities that are essential to democracy.” Barriers like discriminatory laws and socioeconomic obstacles are gradually being removed. In Rwanda and Ethiopia, half of the cabinet ministers are women. New legislation in Japan encourages gender parity in parliament. In the United States, the voters in the November midterms elected the highest number of women to Congress in history – though they still make up only 23.7 percent. Still, the international atmosphere has become less favorable to the expansion of democracy. Not only is the totalitarian state of China spreading its influence, but cracks are appearing in decades-old alliances such as the European Union and NATO. In the EU, both Italy and Turkey saw their rankings in The Economist’s democracy index fall by at least 10 places. Meanwhile, on the other side of the Atlantic, the U.S. is becoming more isolationist, analysts say. “America’s commitment to the global progress of democracy in its foreign policy has been seriously compromised,” says Sarah Repucci, senior director for research and analysis at Freedom House. In one example, when the U.S. withdrew from the council on human rights at the United Nations, it left “a huge vacuum of power,” says Rosa Freedman, a professor of law, conflict, and global development at the University of Reading in England and author of several books on the U.N. Despite the downward trends, however, countries are forming new alliances to put pressure on repressive regimes, reports Human Rights Watch. It points to the example of the EU and a group of Muslim-majority countries working together to create a mechanism at the U.N. to collect evidence on the ethnic cleansing of Rohingyas, which could be used in future trials of the Myanmar government. A group of Latin American countries led a resolution in the Human Rights Council to condemn the severe persecution of Venezuelans under President Nicolás Maduro. Other human rights mechanisms have sprung up in unexpected places, adds Joseph Saunders, deputy program director at Human Rights Watch. For example, the organizing bodies of big sports tournaments, such as the World Cup and the Olympics, will scrutinize the bidders and hosts’ human rights records. “These are obviously dark times,” says Mr. Saunders. “But [you] miss a large part of the picture if you don’t see the pushback that is also happening.”