2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Solvency › No Solvency – EU Says No – “Tech Sovereignty”
Franke 2021 – policy fellow at European Council on Foreign Relations
Ulrike Esther Franke January 2021 “Artificial Divide: How Europe And America Could Clash Over Ai” European Council on Foreign Relations
European policymakers have been less vocal about the geopolitical consequences of AI. So far, the debate in Europe has primarily revolved around AI’s economic and social effects. Of the 21 strategies on AI either published or drafted by EU member states, very few touch on the geopolitical implications of AI. The notable exception to this is France, whose national AI strategy was clearly drafted with a geopolitical mindset. It warns that France and Europe need to “avoid becoming just ‘digital colonies’ of the Chinese and American giants”. The strategy’s inclusion of “American giants” is telling and important. It shows that, from a European point of view, the US is the primary ‘other’ that Europe measures itself against on technology – at least for now. This is despite the fact that, in recent years, Chinese acquisitions of European high-tech firms have caused significant concern.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Solvency › 1NC – No Solvency – EU Say No
Franke 2021 – policy fellow at European Council on Foreign Relations
Ulrike Esther Franke January 2021 “Artificial Divide: How Europe And America Could Clash Over Ai” European Council on Foreign Relations
Obstacles to cooperation
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Solvency › Defense – 1NC
Stefano Costalli 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Florence, Italy and Research Fellow of the Michael Nicholson Centre for Conflict and Cooperation, University of Essex. “NATO Decision-Making in the Age of Big Data and Artificial Intelligence” Editors: Sonia Lucarelli; Alessandro Marrone; and Francesco Niccolò Moro. Sonia Lucarelli is Professor of International Relations and European Security at the University of Bologna, and member of the Board of Directors of the Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI). Alessandro Marrone is Head of the Defence Programme of IAI and teaches at the Istituto Superiore di Stato Maggiore Interforze (ISSMI) of the Italian Ministry of Defence. Francesco N. Moro is Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Bologna and Adjunct Professor of International Relations at the Johns Hopkins University Europe Campus. This publication is the result of the Conference “NATO Decision-making: promises and perils of the Big Data age”, organized by NATO Allied Command Transformation (ACT), the University of Bologna and Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI) of Rome. //pipk
A key requisite for all organizational innovations to occur and for Big Data analysis to be effective is the development and incorporation of a Big Data culture. Chief data officers and senior data-related leadership positions will acquire crucial importance in the analysis of information and in the actual decision-making process, but these positions require a special mix of talent and tools that are currently scarce in many large organizations, especially in the public sector. The organizations that are implementing big data analysis seem especially in need of ‘translators’ – professionals that can ensure effective communication between the Big Data analysis unit and other parts of the organization, where workers are not data scientist and may not be ready to work directly on complex models. However, organizations willing to use Big Data are also in need of real data scientists and analysts, because sophisticated techniques and data analysis tools eventually rely on talented humans who know how to manage the tools and interpret data. As a result, attracting new types of talented young workers and retaining them creating new career paths and opportunities will represent both an essential organizational innovation and an important challenge.
In fact, some members of the WG highlighted that it will not even be easy to find many workers with the appropriate knowledge and skills to perform the new tasks in old and complex organizations. It is possible to find computer scientists, but sometimes these individuals do not seem to fit well with large organizations whose main core business has not much to do with computer science. At the moment, it is even more difficult to find translators, since in principle these workers should be social scientists with an expertise in Big Data analysis, but most academic institutions are not ready to forge these profiles. For what concerns NATO and national armed forces, this educational task is not even performed by military academies, even though some experiments are emerging. The ideal profile would include technical awareness, quantitative analytical skills, broad vision, flexibility and open-mindedness – and this explains why it is not easy to produce it.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Solvency › Defense – 1NC
Erik Lin-Greenberg 20, postdoctoral fellow at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perry World House. Texas National Security Review, Vol 3, Iss 2. Spring. "Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making" //pipk
AI can also strain alliance decision-making by fueling uncertainty about information and military actions. Unlike human analysts or military personnel who can be asked to explain and justify their findings or decisions, AI generally operates in a “black box.” 97 The neural networks that underpin many cutting-edge AI systems are opaque and offer little insight into how they arrive at their conclusions.98 These networks rely on deep learning, a process that passes information from large data sets through a hierarchy of digital nodes that analyze data inputs and make predictions using mathematical rules. As data flows through the neural network, the net makes internal adjustments to refine the quality of outputs. Researchers are often unable to explain how neural nets make these internal adjustments. Because of this lack of “explainability,” users of AI systems may have difficulty understanding failures and correcting errors.99
Policymakers have called for the development of more transparent AI systems, and researchers are working to develop explainable AI tools that peer inside the AI black box.100 Yet, many decision-makers remain uncomfortable with the uncertainty surrounding AI-enabled systems. The commander of the U.S. Air Force’s Air Combat Command, for instance, publicly explained that he was not yet willing to rely on AI programs to analyze the full-motion video collected by reconnaissance drones. He argued that although systems are improving, they are still unable to consistently provide accurate analysis.101 So long as the decisions and analysis of AI systems remain opaque, military commanders may be reluctant to trust AI-enabled systems. And if used, AI may contribute to the fog of war, rather than reduce it, making it difficult to make decisions using information delivered by AI technologies.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › War – Democracy – 2NC
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
Before we review our approach in detail, it may be useful to explain why this type of analysis has not been pursued successfully in the past and what makes our effort different from other, broadly related projects. We are not the first to apply an IV framework (more specifically) or multi-equation models (more broadly) to the democratic peace. However, previous attempts suffer from two major problems. First, previous studies have typically used a dyad (country pair) as the unit of observation in analyzing conflict, which requires some summary measure(s) of democracy for a pair of countries rather than the state-level (monadic) democracy measure. 6 Use of a dyadic aggregate to represent regime type creates a discrepancy between the first stage regression (predicting democracy at the country level) and the outcome stage regression (predicting conflict at the dyad level). 7 We avoid this problem by using the directed dyad as the unit of observation in predicting conflict, distinguishing between the potential challenger and target in a dispute. This allows us to connect the first stage equations (predicting the challenger’s and target’s regime types) and the outcome stage equation seamlessly. Doing so has several benefits: the outcome stage model could directly include country-level covariates (such as challenger’s and target’s democracy) without having to convert them to a dyadic summary. This also allows us to estimate the system of equations jointly rather than relying on the “forbidden regression.” 8
Second, a more daunting challenge in applying an IV approach to democratic peace research is the difficulty of finding a plausible instrument for regime type — a variable that is strongly correlated with regime type but is unrelated to war. This is the challenge that has plagued empirical researchers in many fields. For example, a recent study of the effect of regime type on economic growth uses a diffusion-based measure of democracy (i.e., average value of democracies in a given region) as an instrument for democracy (Acemoglu et al. 2019). However, diffusion-based instruments such as this are unlikely to be a valid instrument, due to spatial spill-over, interdependence, and, most importantly, simultaneity (Betz, Cook, and Hollenbach 2018). Recognizing problems with spatial instruments, McDonald (2015) seeks to exploit the very discrepancy between country-level and dyad-level designs as the source of identification. His discussion, however, lacks a clear explanation as to why some determinants of regime type do not influence conflict. 9
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › War – Democracy – 2NC
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
We now turn to the results from the outcome stage, where militarized conflict initiation is regressed on democracy measures and other covariates. The univariate clog-log model 32 that ignores the endogeneity, shown in column (1) in Table 1, successfully replicates the standard, dyadic democratic peace finding that democracies are peaceful, though only toward other democracies. Note that, while individual democracy measures have either a positive or insignificant coefficient, joint democracy has a negative coefficient that overwhelms the positive coefficients of individual democracy measures in the univariate model. As a result, the univariate model produces a result that, while democracy may increase conflict against a non-democracy, it decreases conflict against a democracy.
To illustrate this, we calculate the average treatment effect of joint democracy for the challenger and for the target based on the univariate model. These effects are calculated by comparing the predicted probabilities of conflict initiation when changing the regime type of self (challenger or target) from non-democracy to democracy, holding constant the regime type of the other (target or challenger) as democracy. 33 Gray, hollow circles in Figure 4 show the treatment effects of challenger’s and target’s democracy. We can see that both effects are negative and statistically significant at the 95% confidence level.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › Democracy Bad – 1NC
Dr. Stuart Parker 20, Philosopher and Former Teacher who Lectured on Philosophy and Education at London's Institute of Education, South Bank University, Author of Reflective Teaching in the Postmodern World, “The Problem With Democracy — It's You”, The Article, 10/5/2020, https://www.thearticle.com/the-problem-with-democracy-its-you
So why is our democracy so unfit for purpose? Why is it that we can elect leaders who are little more than self-serving schemers, whose contempt for the electorate renders them incapable of giving straight, honest answers to even the most straightforward, reasonable questions? It’s not as if any of these qualities have been smuggled in under our noses. They are paraded before our eyes every single day. Nobody voting for Johnson or Trump could be blind to the fact [ignore] that they are serial liars. And yet they voted all the same. Why?
***
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › Democracy Bad – 1NC
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 1-2
The fact that the scientific knowledge on the human contribution to climate change entered human society through the most advanced democratic societies should have been a cause for celebration. Given the congruence of climate mitigation and public interests, the problem of climate change should have been considered solved decades ago. Several decades of inaction later, however, arguments are proliferating that democracy is exactly the reason for inaction.
In The Collapse of Western Civilization, historians Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway travel to the future to look back and offer a forensic analysis on the climate-induced Great Collapse of Western Civilization of 2074 (2014: 63). The future historians’ forensic report states that “[a]s the devastating effects of the Great Collapse began to appear, the nation-states with democratic governments… were at first unwilling and then unable” to deal with the crisis. These democratic governments realized that they had no “infrastructure and organizational ability to quarantine and relocate people” as “food shortages and disease outbreaks spread and sea level[s] rose.” In China, where there was centralized government, the crisis was handled much more adequately, leading to survival rates exceeding 80%, a development that “vindicated the necessity of centralized government” (2014: 51–2). The gist of The Collapse of Western Civilization is not about critiquing democracy per se but a warning against the stubborn inaction mandated by market fundamentalism that has hijacked Western democracies.1 In their previous book, Merchants of Doubt, Oreskes and Conway documented the way that climate deniers sowed the seeds of doubt about climate change and successfully staved off implementations of mitigation measures. For the authors, the anticommunist ideology that had kept actors vigilant about government encroachment in the marketplace occupied a central place in climate denial (2014: 69). Ironically, this sort of ideology-informed calculation meant that preventative action was blocked, increasing the risk that disruptive climate disasters would eventually necessitate the suspension of democracy and legitimating the sort of heavy-handed authoritarian interventions that the conservatives most abhorred (2014: 52; 69).
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › Democracy Bad – 1NC
Charles A. Ray 21, Member of the Board of Trustees and Chair of the Africa Program at the Foreign Policy Research Institute, Former U.S. Ambassador to the Kingdom of Cambodia and the Republic of Zimbabwe, “Does Africa Matter to the United States?”, Foreign Policy Research Institute, 1/11/2021, https://www.fpri.org/article/2021/01/does-africa-matter-to-the-united-states/
Africa matters in terms of size, population, and rate of population growth. It is the continent currently most affected by climate change but is also a continent that can have a devastating impact on climate change globally because of the importance of the Congo Basin rainforest, which is the second-largest absorber of heat after the Amazon rainforest. The destruction of this important ecosystem could further accelerate global warming. As residents of the region come into increasing contact with the animals of the rainforest, this region could be the origin of the world’s next viral pandemic. Violent extremism and terrorism are increasing in Africa, and while now mostly localized, the danger has the potential to spread beyond the continent. Crises—natural and man-made—cause massive relocations of populations, both on the continent and abroad, which can have negative economic, social, and political impacts.
Why Africa Matters
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › Democracy Bad – 1NC
Dr. Moses E. Ochonu 19, Cornelius Vanderbilt Chair in History and Professor of African History at Vanderbilt University, PhD and MA in African History from the University of Michigan, BA in History from Bayero University, Graduate Certificate in Conflict Management from Liscomb University, “Why Liberal Democracy is a Threat to Nigeria’s Stability”, Logos: A Journal of Modern Society & Culture, May 2019, http://logosjournal.com/2019/liberal-democracy-is-a-threat-to-nigerias-stability/
In 2015, Nigeria, a country of about 190 million, spent $625 million to conduct federal and local elections. By comparison, India, with a population of 1.2 billion, spent $600 million on its 2015 election, according to figures released by the Electoral Commission of India (ECI).[1]
In 2019, the election budget of Nigeria’s Independent Electoral Commission (INEC) rose to $670 million. This represents about 2.5 percent of Nigeria’s $28.8 billion budget for 2019, a portion of which is being financed through borrowing. To put the electoral spending in context, more than half of the country subsists on about a dollar a day, and the country recently acquired the dubious distinction of being named the poverty capital of the world, with more people living in extreme poverty there than in any other country.[2] Key infrastructures and services such as roads, railway, electricity, water supply, healthcare, and education are severely inadequate, requiring urgent investments and interventions.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › Democracy Bad – 1NC
Dr. Daina Chiba 21, Associate Professor of Political Science in the Department of Government and Public Administration at the University of Macau, Ph.D. in Political Science from Rice University, LL.M in Jurisprudence and International Relations from Hitotsubashi University, and Dr. Erik Gartzke, Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, PhD in Political Science from the University of Iowa, “Make Two Democracies and Call Me in the Morning: Endogenous Regime Type and the Democratic Peace”, 2/19/2021, https://dainachiba.github.io/research/make2dem/Make2Dem.pdf
The democratic peace—the observation that democracies are less likely to fight each other than are other pairings of states—is one of the most widely acknowledged empirical regularities in international relations. Prominent scholars have even characterized the relationship as an empirical law (Levy 1988; Gleditsch 1992). The discovery of a special peace in liberal dyads stimulated enormous scholarly debate and led to, or reinforced, a number of policy initiatives by various governments and international organizations. Although a broad consensus has emerged among researchers regarding the empirical correlation between joint democracy and peace, disagreement remains as to its logical foundations. Numerous theories have been proposed to account for how democracy produces peace, if only dyadically (e.g., Russett 1993; Rummel 1996; Doyle 1997; Schultz 2001).
At the same time, peace appears likely to foster or maintain democracy (Thompson 1996; James, Solberg, andWolfson 1999). A vast swath of research in political science and economics proposes explanations for the origins of liberal government involving variables such as economic development (Lipset 1959; Burkhart and Lewis-Beck 1994; Przeworski et al. 2000; Acemoglu and Robinson 2006; Epstein et al. 2006) and inequality (Boix 2003), political interests (Downs 1957; Bueno de Mesquita et al. 2003), power hierarchies (Moore 1966; Lake 2009), third party inducements (Pevehouse 2005) or impositions (Peceny 1995; Meernik 1996), geography (Gleditsch 2002b), and natural resource endowments (Ross 2001), to list just a few examples. Each of these putative causes of democracy is also associated with various explanations for international conflict. Indeed, some as yet poorly defined set of canonical factors may contribute both to democracy and to peace, making it look as if the two variables are directly related, even if possibly they are not.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › 2NC---Good AI---Link
Gönenç Gürkaynak 18, Founding Partner of ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, LL.M. from Harvard Law School, İlay Yılmaz, Partner at ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, and Güneş Haksever, LLM from Istanbul Bilgi University, Attorney at IBM Turkey, “Stifling Artificial Intelligence: Human Perils”, Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 32, Issue 5, 12/12/2018, [note – ‘ANI’ = ‘artificial narrow intelligence’]
3. Protecting human dominance through regulation or setting tailored goals to maintain human existence
Having a timeless and robust definition of AI is of paramount importance when thinking of regulating AI. One cannot regulate a certain subject without establishing a robust definition of what it regulates. The ambiguity of the definition of AI is mainly due to the “I”, “intelligence” of the AI. Concepts like “intelligence”, “consciousness”, “free will” and “soul” accompanying it are yet to have deterministic definitions although the greatest minds of our planet have tackled them for thousands of years (Burkeman, 2015).21
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › AI Governance Bad – 1NC
Chris Reed 18, Professor of Electronic Commerce Law at Queen Mary, University of London, LLM from the University of London, “How Should We Regulate Artificial Intelligence?”, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, Volume 376, Issue 2128, 9/13/2018, https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2017.0360
Using artificial intelligence (AI) technology to replace human decision-making will inevitably create new risks whose consequences are unforeseeable. This naturally leads to calls for regulation, but I argue that it is too early to attempt a general system of AI regulation. Instead, we should work incrementally within the existing legal and regulatory schemes which allocate responsibility, and therefore liability, to persons. Where AI clearly creates risks which current law and regulation cannot deal with adequately, then new regulation will be needed. But in most cases, the current system can work effectively if the producers of AI technology can provide sufficient transparency in explaining how AI decisions are made. Transparency ex post can often be achieved through retrospective analysis of the technology's operations, and will be sufficient if the main goal is to compensate victims of incorrect decisions. Ex ante transparency is more challenging, and can limit the use of some AI technologies such as neural networks. It should only be demanded by regulation where the AI presents risks to fundamental rights, or where society needs reassuring that the technology can safely be used. Masterly inactivity in regulation is likely to achieve a better long-term solution than a rush to regulate in ignorance.
This article is part of a discussion meeting issue ‘The growing ubiquity of algorithms in society: implications, impacts and innovations'.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › AI Governance Bad – 1NC
Gönenç Gürkaynak 18, Founding Partner of ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, LL.M. from Harvard Law School, İlay Yılmaz, Partner at ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, and Güneş Haksever, LLM from Istanbul Bilgi University, Attorney at IBM Turkey, “Stifling Artificial Intelligence: Human Perils”, Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 32, Issue 5, 12/12/2018, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3285264
Although scientists have calculated the significant positive welfare effects of Artificial Intelligence (AI), fear mongering continues to hinder AI development. If regulations in this sector stifle our active imagination, we risk wasting the true potential of AIs dynamic efficiencies. Not only would Schumpeter dislike us for spoiling creative destruction, but the AI thinkers of the future would also rightfully see our efforts as the ‘dark age’ of human advancement. This article provides a brief philosophical introduction to artificial intelligence; categorizes artificial intelligence to shed light on what we have and know now and what we might expect from the prospective developments; reflects thoughts of worldwide famous thinkers to broaden our horizons; provides information on the attempts to regulate artificial intelligence from a legal perspective; and discusses how the legal approach needs to be to ensure the balance between artificial intelligence development and human control over them, and to ensure friendly artificial intelligence.
Our technology, our machines, is part of our humanity. We created them to extend ourselves, and that is what is unique about human beings. – Ray Kurzweil1
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › Cooperation Advantage › AI Governance Bad – 1NC
Robert A. Freitas 22 Jr., JD from the University of Santa Clara (Santa Clara, CA), School of Law, Research Fellow at the Institute for Molecular Manufacturing, Won the 2009 Feynman Prize in Nanotechnology for Theory, BS in Physics and Psychology from Harvey Mudd College, “Molecular Manufacturing: Too Dangerous to Allow?”, Nanotechnology Perceptions, Volume 2, Number 1, Republished at The Lifeboat Foundation, https://lifeboat.com/ex/molecular.manufacturing
Attempts to block or “relinquish” [3, 12] molecular manufacturing research will make the world a more, not less, dangerous place [13]. This paradoxical conclusion is founded on two premises. First, attempts to block the research will fail. Second, such attempts will preferentially block or slow the development of defensive measures by responsible groups. One of the clear conclusions reached by Freitas [4] was that effective countermeasures against self-replicating systems should be feasible, but will require significant effort to develop and deploy. (Nanotechnology critic Bill Joy, responding to this author, complained in late 2000 that any nanoshield defense to protect against global ecophagy “appears to be so outlandishly dangerous that I can’t imagine we would attempt to deploy it.” [12]) But blocking the development of defensive systems would simply insure that offensive systems, once deployed, would achieve their intended objective in the absence of effective countermeasures. James Hughes [13] concurs: “The only safe and feasible approach to the dangers of emerging technology is to build the social and scientific infrastructure to monitor, regulate and respond to their threats.”
We can reasonably conclude that blocking the development of defensive systems would be an extraordinarily bad idea. Actively encouraging rapid development of defensive systems by responsible groups while simultaneously slowing or hindering development and deployment by less responsible groups (“nations of concern”) would seem to be a more attractive strategy, and is supported by the Foresight Guidelines [10]. As even nanotechnology critic Bill Joy [14] finally admitted in late 2003: “These technologies won’t stop themselves, so we need to do whatever we can to give the good guys a head start.”
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › NATO Advantage › ! D – 2NC
Jon Lindsay and Erik Gartzke 14, Jon R. Lindsay is an assistant research scientist at the University of California Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation and an assistant adjunct professor at the University of California, San Diego School of International Relations and Pacific Studies, AND Erik Gartzke is Professor and Director of cPASS at the Department of Political Science @ UCSD, Lindsay, Jon R., and Erik Gartzke. “Coercion through Cyberspace: The Stability-Instability Paradox Revisited.” The Power to Hurt: Coercion in the Modern World, Oct. 2014.
The combination of cross domain deterrence and voluntary connection to the internet gives rise to a variant of the classic stability-instability paradox. In Glenn Snyder’s original articulation of the paradox, mutually assured destruction could deter nuclear war. However, MAD was not credible for, and might even encourage, limited conventional war.56 Or as Robert Jervis puts it, “To the extent that the military balance is stable at the level of all-out nuclear war, it will become less stable at lower levels of violence.”57 Cyber capacity is a poor substitute for nuclear weapons, myths of paralysis notwithstanding, yet there is a similar logic constraining the distributions of harms which are possible via information technology. To extend this logic to the cyber domain, there are a variety of deterrent mechanisms contain the most disruptive types of cyber attacks yet fail to contain, and even enable, a wide variety of online espionage, subversion, symbolic protest, and criminal predation. In cyberspace we observe a rather stable damage contest (i.e., no “paralysis” and limited “disruption”) but a very unstable intelligence-counterintelligence contest (lots of “espionage” and “fraud” vying with efforts at “control” and “mobilization”). Thus the actors that have the ability to carry out highly destructive cyber attacks (mainly state actors for now) lack the motivation to attack; by contrast, these same actors as well as many different actors have both the ability and motivation to inflict irritant aggression with little fear of suffering consequences By and large, cyber options fill out the lower end of the conflict spectrum where deterrence is not as credible or reliable. The very few cases of physically disruptive cyber attack we do observe—mainly powerful states conducting covert action or battlefield support operations against militarily weaker opponents—have notably involved stronger actors who not only have the capacity to plan and conduct a sophisticated attack but also have the ability to deter retaliation against their use of cyber attack. This cyber variant of the stability-instability paradox has a slightly different logic, however. In the nuclear realm, actors cannot disconnect from the threatened harm, and this is what makes the threatened destruction both mutual and assured. When there are many missiles with many warheads, the chance of intercepting them on the ground through a disarming counterforce strike or in the air through ballistic missile defense with any confidence becomes vanishingly small. Not so in cyberspace, where connection to the internet or acceptance of connections through it is voluntary. There is “no forced entry in cyberspace” in Libicki’s phrase, and so the hundredth cyber attack against a closed vulnerability is as ineffective as the first. Attackers thus rely on deception to exploit vulnerabilities and ensure that they stay open. However, offensive deception can fail in the “fog of cyberwar” and defenders can be deceptive as well, both of which are more likely against high-reward targets (where cross domain deterrence also more credible). The need to preserve internet connections to facilitate ongoing and future deception as well as the need to preserve stealth to avoid the consequences of getting caught imposes discipline on attackers. Actors cannot enjoy the substantial benefits of interconnection without accepting some risk of exploitation (hacking to spy) and attack (hacking to disrupt). Thus the successful “lockout” of the internet, with advantage accruing exclusively to one political group or another, is not realistic. Moreover, because these harms share similar techniques, the observed abundance 39 of the former represents a latent potential for the later. The latent escalatory potential of even minor irritants leads to rampant fears of unrestrained catastrophe, to be sure. Yet this latent potential is difficult to harness for targeted coercion because the threat is self-effacing. Declared cyber threats that highlight the vulnerability to be exploited are readily mitigated. Instead, the ineradicable threat of cyber catastrophe (ineradicable as long as the internet continues to be useful) creates a general if diffuse deterrent effect among all parties who value their connection to the internet. No one who wants to make money on the internet really wants to have a cyberwar, and this includes states as well as criminals. Which types of actors are most able to benefit through internet coercion and which are most vulnerable to coercion? Large powers like the U.S. are highly dependent on the internet but also highly skilled at inflicting harm, both through cyber and traditional military force. Poor powers across the digital divide may have little vulnerability at all, while medium powers may have vulnerability but lack a range of forces to deter attacks. This might imply a “curvature” to the utility of cyber coercion. Big-capable countries are vulnerable to cyber harm but can deter through other military instruments. Poor states are not vulnerable. It may be the prosperous small or digitally developing who are in trouble, since they cannot credibly deter and have high dependence on the internet. The information revolution is often thought to be a boon to non-state actors, and indeed it is, but mainly in the irritant class of cyber operations. Moreover, the increasing ubiquity and sophistication of information technologies can be expected to have something of a democratizing effect on intelligence and counterintelligence techniques whereby firms and citizens will have access to and be concerned about the types of things that were historically the purview of obscure state intelligence agencies. However, it would be a mistake to use the increasing ferment of low-intensity information contests to infer the shape of higher 40 intensity activity. On the contrary, the traditional logic of war will continue to dominate the expression of cyber aggression. Because threatened internet harms depend on voluntary connections in the first place, and as many actors have alternative means to inflict (cross domain) harm in retaliation, the coercive utility of cyberspace is actually somewhat limited. At the same time an ever increasing variety irritants and more temperamental adjuncts becomes available for global political interaction. The “net” result is that opponents have strong incentives to impose costs via the internet but also to keep those costs low enough to preserve interconnection and avoid retaliation. Therefore, contests in damage will remain relatively stable while contests in intelligence will be increasingly unstable. The human-built world is becoming more complex, to be sure, but it is not necessarily more dangerous. As long as it is desirable to connect to the internet tomorrow, there will be only limited harm via the internet today.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › NATO Advantage › ! D – 2NC
Jon Lindsay and Erik Gartzke 14, Jon R. Lindsay is an assistant research scientist at the University of California Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation and an assistant adjunct professor at the University of California, San Diego School of International Relations and Pacific Studies, AND Erik Gartzke is Professor and Director of cPASS at the Department of Political Science @ UCSD, Lindsay, Jon R., and Erik Gartzke. “Coercion through Cyberspace: The Stability-Instability Paradox Revisited.” The Power to Hurt: Coercion in the Modern World, Oct. 2014.
Perhaps the simplest form of cross domain response to cyber threats is to forgo the use of the cyber domain altogether. While it is hard if not impossible to limit exposure to nuclear weapons and even a determined conventional assault, the risk of cyber attack can be completely eliminated by disconnection from digital networks. The internet is an artificial environment and connection to it is voluntary. Individuals, organizations, and states retain the ability to unplug completely, limit their online transactions, or erect various barriers to connection. Obviously disconnection is not very feasible commercially, socially, and militarily today, but this is more of an indicator of how positive the benefits of interconnection are compared to the perceived risks. If the risks were perceived as extreme, then firms and states could go back to making a living as they did before 1991 (when WWW went public). This is a cross-domain threat because it entails exiting the cyber domain altogether to leverage more traditional economic and military transactions. The threat of disconnection follows from the more general logic of international organizations, where contracts must be self-enforcing.44 On the internet as in institutions, ties among egoistic actors under anarchy must be mutually beneficial. If the internet is a bad deal for actors, they can throw up boundaries or exit cyberspace altogether. If repeated exposure to adversarial exploitation causes states to lose more than they gain from being online, then they can undermine the attacker’s very means for accessing the victim. The threat of voluntary disconnection is especially relevant for repeated interactions, or repeated exploitation, rather than a one-shot “bolt from the blue” cyber attack (which is better countered with cross-domain retaliation). The threat of disconnection is implicit in the voluntary nature of connection to the internet, and the potential loss of the ability to make future attacks exercises a deterrent effect on attacks in the present. An aggressor who does not want to lose the cyber adjuncts for espionage and disruption it has invested so much in developing will show restraint in their employment. This does not mean that coercion cannot take place online, but it is bounded by excess value. One implication is that the countries that can be most coerced on the internet will be those that have the most to lose by leaving it.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › NATO Advantage › ! D – 2NC
Valeriano and Maness 15 – co-authors of Cyber War versus Cyber Realities, AND *Senior Lecturer in Social and Political Sciences at the University of Glasgow, AND **Visiting Fellow of Security and Resilience Studies at Northeastern University (Brandon and Ryan C., The Coming Cyberpeace: The Normative Argument Against Cyberwarfare, Foreign Affairs, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2015-05-13/coming-cyberpeace)
The era of cyberconflict is upon us; at least, experts seem to accept that cyberattacks are the new normal. In fact, however, evidence suggests that cyberconflict is not as prevalent as many believe. Likewise, the severity of individual cyber events is not increasing, even if the frequency of overall attacks has risen. And an emerging norm against the use of severe state-based cybertactics contradicts fear-mongering news reports about a coming cyberapocalypse. The few isolated incidents of successful state-based cyberattacks do not a trend make. Rather, what we are seeing is cyberespionage and probes, not cyberwarfare. Meanwhile, the international consensus has stabilized around a number of limited acceptable uses of cybertechnology—one that prohibits any dangerous use of force. Despite fears of a boom in cyberwarfare, there have been no major or dangerous hacks between countries. The closest any states have come to such events occurred when Russia attacked Georgian news outlets and websites in 2008; when Russian forces shut down banking, government, and news websites in Estonia in 2007; when Iran attacked the Saudi Arabian oil firm Saudi Aramco with the Shamoon virus in 2012; and when the United States attempted to sabotage Iran’s nuclear power systems from 2007 to 2011 through the Stuxnet worm. The attack on Sony from North Korea is just the latest overhyped cyberattack to date, as the corporate giant has recovered its lost revenues from the attack and its networks are arguably more resilient as a result. Even these are more probes into vulnerabilities than full attacks. Russia’s aggressions show that Moscow is willing to use cyberwarfare for disruption and propaganda, but not to inflict injuries or lasting infrastructural damage. The Shamoon incident allowed Iran to punish Saudi Arabia for its alliance with the United States as Tehran faced increased sanctions; the attack destroyed files on Saudi Aramco’s computer network but failed to do any lasting damage. The Stuxnet incident also failed to create any lasting damage, as Tehran put more centrifuges online to compensate for virus-based losses and strengthened holes in their system. Further, these supposedly successful cases of cyberattacks are balanced by many more examples of unsuccessful ones. If the future of cyberconflict looks like today, the international community must reassess the severity of the threat. Cyberattacks have demonstrated themselves to be more smoke than fire. This is not to suggest that incidents are on the decline, however. Distributed denial-of-service attacks and infiltrations increase by the minute—every major organization is probed constantly, but only for weaknesses or new infiltration methods for potential use in the future. Probes and pokes do not destabilize states or change trends within international politics. Even common cyber actions have little effect on levels of cooperation and conflict between states.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › NATO Advantage › Heg Bad – 1NC
Zuckerman ‘16 (June 7, 2016, at 4:21 p.m., Mortimer Zuckerman is the chairman and editor-in-chief of U.S. News & World Report and the publisher of the New York Daily News, Cites William Perry – former sec of Defense under Clinton, https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2016-06-07/four-paths-to-nuclear-disaster)//AP
The third current nuclear threat, the danger of nuclear war through miscalculation, most seriously with the Russians, is, Perry warns, complex but quite credible. The story begins at the end of the Cold War when prospects seemed promising for a crucial cooperative atmosphere with the Russians, perhaps eventually a pan-European security system. Indeed, because of the considerable diplomatic effort led by Perry, the Russians had joined their military forces with NATO's operating in Bosnia, a remarkable and hopeful development. But the present situation is marked by Russia's continuing aggressive statements about their ongoing dependence on nuclear weapons, their robust program to modernize those forces (which seems to mirror U.S. modernization programs) and their aggression in Ukraine and elsewhere in their neighborhood. It has been an especially bitter development for Perry, for it started after the Cold War ended. So what happened? After the Cold War ended, and under Perry's leadership, the Partnership for Peace was formed as an interim organization which Eastern European nations, including Russia, could join as a step to eventual NATO membership, the key idea being that the transition would be gradual. Understandably, there was little patience among the outside nations in waiting to join. Perry emphasized that traditional Russian sensibilities and concerns about its regional security mandated a carefully staged, gradual expansion of the security organization. He was opposed by Richard Holbrooke, then an assistant secretary in the State Department, who argued to promptly move to the Eastern European "partnership" members into NATO. After all, what could the Russians do? Perry asked Clinton to hold a decisive National Security Council meeting where he could make the case for delay. There Vice President Al Gore argued for immediate inclusion and Perry lost the day. Clinton agreed to membership at once for Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic, delaying for a while the membership of the Baltic States. Perry nearly resigned, but decided not to do so in the hopes he could help mitigate the increasing lack of trust by the Russians who claimed NATO had no concern for their priorities. But it was not possible; NATO expansion turned out to be the first slip down a slick slope leading to the hostile relations we have today. Russia today genuinely feels threatened and concerned regarding what it believes is U.S. pursuit of military superiority and political and economic hegemony. It views our actions as inconsistent with traditional notions of strategic stability. Thus Russia presently is an unlikely partner in the process of nuclear disarmament. Perry makes the case that it is in U.S. and Russian interest to change our present momentum toward a new Cold War and he emphasizes that this process requires listening carefully to the concerns of others. Failing that, the germinating threat is evident today: Look, for example, to Russia's action in the Ukraine and the Baltics, where President Vladimir Putin has pursued an aggressive policy based on the stated belief that his country bears a responsibility to protect ethnic Russians in those countries. This policy has already led to warfare in the Ukraine; if it were applied to any of the Baltic nations, all of which have a substantial number of ethnic Russians, it could lead to a military conflict between Russian and NATO troops. Clearly the greatest danger is an escalation to the use of nuclear weapons, either by foolish design or miscalculation. The expressions by the Russian government of its dependence on nuclear weapons make this danger all the more pressing. Neither the Russian nor NATO leadership would want this outcome of course; but the escalation could occur beyond their control, especially with the Russian emphasis on "tactical" nuclear weapons whose management might be in the hands of battlefield military commanders, as it was during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
2022
UTNIF
Negative
NEG – AI – Neg vs. AI Aff – Case Debate › NATO Advantage › Heg Bad – 1NC
Kroenig ’16 (Matthew; June 2016; Associate Professor in the Department of Government and School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, Senior Fellow in the Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security at The Atlantic Council; National Bureau of Asian Research, No. 58 “Approaching Critical Mass: Asia's Multipolar Nuclear Future,”)
The most important reason to be concerned about nuclear weapons in Asia, of course, is the threat that nuclear weapons might be used. To be sure, the use of nuclear weapons remains remote, but the probability is not zero and the consequences could be catastrophic. The subject, therefore, deserves careful scrutiny. Nuclear use would overturn a 70-year tradition of nonuse, could result in large-scale death and destruction, and might set a precedent that shapes how nuclear weapons are viewed, proliferated, and postured decades hence. The dangers of escalation may be magnified in a multipolar nuclear order in which small skirmishes present the potential to quickly draw in multiple powers, each with a finger on the nuclear trigger. The following discussion will explore the logic of crisis escalation and strategic stability in a multipolar nuclear order.14 First and foremost, the existence of multipolar nuclear powers means that crises may pit multiple nuclear-armed states against one another. This may be the result of formal planning if a state’s strategy calls for fighting multiple nuclear-armed adversaries simultaneously. A state may choose such a strategy if it believes that a war with one of these states would inevitably mean war with both. Alternatively, in a war between state A and state B, state A may decide to conduct a preventive strike on state C for fear that it would otherwise seek to exploit the aftermath of the war between states A and B. Given U.S. nuclear strategy in the early Cold War, for example, it is likely that a nuclear war between the United States and the Soviet Union would have also resulted in U.S. nuclear attacks against China, even if China had not been a direct participant in the precipitating dispute. In addition, conflicts of interest between nuclear powers may inadvertently impinge on the interests of other nuclear-armed states, drawing them into conflict. There is always a danger that one nuclear power could take action against a nuclear rival and that this action would unintentionally cross a red line for a third nuclear power, triggering a tripartite nuclear crisis. Linton Brooks and Mira Rapp-Hooper have dubbed this category of phenomena the “security trilemma.”15 For example, if the United States were to engage in a show of force in an effort to signal resolve to Russia, such as the flushing of nuclear submarines, this action could inadvertently trigger a crisis for China. There is also the issue of “catalytic” war. This may be the first mechanism by which Cold War strategists feared that multiple nuclear players could increase the motivations for a nuclear exchange. They worried that a third nuclear power, such as China, might conduct a nuclear strike on one of the superpowers, leading the wounded superpower to conclude wrongly that the other superpower was responsible and thereby retaliate against an innocent state presumed to be the aggressor. This outcome was seen as potentially attractive to the third state as a way of destroying the superpowers and promoting itself within the global power hierarchy. Fortunately, this scenario never came to pass during the Cold War. With modern intelligence, reconnaissance, and early warning capabilities among the major powers, it is more difficult to imagine such a scenario today, although this risk is still conceivable among less technologically developed states. In addition to acting directly against one another, nuclear powers could be drawn into smaller conflicts between their allies and brought face to face in peak crises. International relations theorists discuss the concept of “chain ganging” within alliance relationships, the dangers of which are more severe when the possibility of nuclear escalation is present.16 Although this was a potential problem even in a bipolar nuclear order, the more nuclear weapons states present, the greater the likelihood of multiple nuclear powers entering a crisis. A similar logic suggests that the more fingers on the nuclear trigger, the more likely it is that nuclear weapons will be used. Multipolar nuclear crises are not without historical precedent.17 Several Cold War crises featured the Soviet Union against the United States and its European nuclear-armed allies, Britain and later France. The 1973 Arab-Israeli War involved the United States, the Soviet Union, and a nuclear-armed Israel. The United States has been an interested party in regional nuclear disputes, including the Sino-Soviet border war of 1969 and several crises in the past two decades on the Indian subcontinent. Indeed, many of these crises stand out as among the most dangerous of the nuclear era.