Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Cyber Security › Neg › General

Cybersecurity is not bipartisan – the plan consumes too much PC

Baksh 22 [Mariam Baksh reports on the development of federal cybersecurity policy for Nextgov. She started covering technology governance in 2014, during the heat of the Net Neutrality debate, and focused her graduate studies at American University on investigative journalism. April 6, 2022. https://www.nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2022/04/partisan-rift-stalls-efforts-secure-critical-infrastructure-cyberattack/364120/]

Senior House Democrats and Republicans disagree on legislation Rep. John Katko, R-N.Y., has proposed that calls on the Department of Homeland Security to identify “systemically important critical infrastructure”—SICI—for prioritizing the government’s efforts to improve the nation’s cybersecurity.  “It is not enough to simply identify these most critical entities, nor is it consistent with what the solarium Commission proposed,” Rep. Yvette Clarke, D-N.Y., chair of the House Homeland Security Committee’s panel on cybersecurity, infrastructure protection and innovation, said during a hearing Wednesday. “We need to be able to answer the question, ‘what do these companies need to do as a result of their designation?’ And ‘what does the federal government need to do for them?’” The Katko bill, and identical legislation proposed by Sen. Angus King, I-Maine, in the upper chamber, draws from a recommendation of the congressionally mandated Cyberspace Solarium Commission. The commission, which was composed of members of Congress from across the political spectrum, executive-branch officials and major private-sector representatives, proposed that entities designated systemically important critical infrastructure be allowed some protection from liability and access to information in exchange for implementing appropriate cybersecurity controls. Katko is ranking member of the House Homeland Security Committee. His legislation, which has –Rep. Abigail Spanberger, D-Va.—who has not been active on cybersecurity policy, covers the first part of the Solarium Commission’s bargain by calling on DHS to identify the entities and outlining benefits they would receive. But it does not approach a discussion of appropriate security controls companies should be required to implement. CISA, meanwhile, has made a point of noting the agency is taking on the work of identifying the entities in question, regardless of whether there is legislation instructing them to do so. “It's clear that CISA's Systemically Important Entities effort is engaged in a rigorous identification process, but the next steps of what to do with the list appear less clear to me than the Solarium Commission's vision of SICI, which calls for specific benefits and obligations to SICI entities,” Rep. Jim Langevin, D-R.I., said.Langevin chairs a key cybersecurity panel on the House Armed Services Committee and is co-chair of the House Cybersecurity Caucus. He and King were both members of the Solarium Commission.   Agreement also broke down along partisan lines regarding the use of regulatory enforcement versus the voluntary approach that has been at the center of cybersecurity policy over the last decade. Rep. Andrew Garbarino, R-NY, who is on Katko’s SICI legislation and is ranking member of the committee’s cybersecurity panel, asked CISA Executive Director Eric Goldstein to speak to the importance of CISA’s voluntary approach in working with the private sector. Katko also noted, regarding CISA’s work with the private sector: “We can't lose sight of the value of those voluntary relationships.” Clarke, in contrast, said, “I think it's time to be candid about the limits of these voluntary partnerships and authorities … The throughline for all these efforts, is that at some point, Congress or the administration, or both, decided to punt on the question of benefits and burdens. That will not happen on my watch." “There are conflicting opinions between my colleagues and myself on the right direction for SICI,” Katko acknowledged. Testifying before the committee, the Government Accountability Office’s Tina Won Sherman said, “The diffuse and voluntary nature of the critical infrastructure landscape continues to pose a range of challenges to this community,” including for implementing security standards.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – GMOs Backlash

Gene drives---they lack any type of institutional support AND require political tradeoffs

Jesse Reynolds, 11-21-2020 Jesse Reynolds is an expert in international environmental policy. He researches and advises on how norms, rules, procedures, and institutions can help manage environmental opportunities and challenges, particularly those involving emerging technologies. “Engineering biological diversity: the international governance of synthetic biology, gene drives, and de-extinction for conservation," No Publication, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877343520300890//DG

The emerging technologies of conservationist synthetic biology present high-stakes risk-risk tradeoffs, with sub-stantial potentials to further sustainability and to cause environmental harm. Governance is vital, but existing mechanisms, institutions, and processes have gaps. The further development of governance is a political process. Although critics often frame emerging technologies as being hyped by firms and boosters, this is not the case with conservationist synthetic biology. Those who advo-cate for its research and development seem to do so despondently [3,19] and emphasize caution over speed [12]. Furthermore, few to no business interests are pro- moting the endeavors. This is likely a consequence of these biotechnologies’ largely nonexcludable character, in which their effects cannot be limited to those who payfor the services [46]. Consequently, there is little poten- tial for profit in providing such public goods (in the economic meaning, not the normative one).

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – GMOs Backlash

GMOs---proposals are partisan, dividing industries and the public

Adam Chandler, 3-8-2016, Staff Writer at The Atlantic "How the GMO Debate Became a National Nightmare," Atlantic, https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/03/gmo-debate-congress/473664//DG

The battle over GMOs encompasses some of our worst political instincts. The public overwhelmingly fears GMOs and supports labeling. Owing to its partisan nature, the bill to be debated has been given two names: the Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act (SAFE), by those against mandatory labeling, and Deny Americans the Right to Know Act (DARK), by those who support labeling. (Making matters worse, there is also a competing bill that would try to split the difference between supporting state-mandated labeling and attempting to limit label confusion on the national level.)An informal consortium of government organizations and science academies say that genetically modified foods pose no health threat to consumers and yet their interests are associated with pernicious-seeming big agricultural stalwarts like Monsanto and ConAgra. Meanwhile, the FDA isn’t so sure about the environmental impact of genetically engineered crops, which is a different issue altogether that is being lumped within the conversation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – GMOs Backlash

GMO development requires heavy PC expenditure---debates are ferocious

Nathaniel Johnson 1-24-2014, Johnson is a senior staff writer at Grist"OK, GMOs matter," https://grist.org/food/ok-gmos-matter-but-the-noisy-fight-over-them-is-a-distraction//DG

I’ll confess to some sensationalism in claiming in the title of my last piece on the GMO controversy that “none of it matters.” Of course it does matter to some degree, and it matters very much to those who have dedicated their lives to the issue. It would have been more punctilious (and less fun) to instead title the piece: “The ferocity of the GMO debate makes it seem much more important than it really is.” It’s not that we should all resign ourselves to apathy. I’m simply suggesting that — whether your primary concern is the environment, or health, or poverty, or feeding the world — heavy expenditure of political capital on GMOs isn’t going to move you all that far toward your goal. Both Ramez Naam and Tom Philpott take me to task for underplaying the importance of GMOs, and I actually agree with almost all of what they’ve written here. I agree with Naam that we should be pursuing moonshot technologies like C4 and self-fertilization. But we shouldn’t be counting on those big breakthroughs to solve our problems: They may not ever come. I agree with Philpott that GMO crops have been overhyped and that discussion should stick to the facts on the ground.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – GMOs Backlash

GMO investment gets massive backlash---it tanks industries AND catalyzes backlash by appealing to public fears

Kojo Ahiakpa, 6-6-2018, Ahjakpa is an agribusiness advisor and a data analyst "THE POLITICS OF GMOs," No Publication, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/politics-gmos-kojo-ahiakpa?trk=portfolio_article-card_title//DG

Opposition to GMOs and science in general across the world has hitherto been a matter of political interests, usually led by corporate, religious and political actors. Journalist Marc Gunther has highlighted the conspiratorial narrative about GMO technology favoured by some corporate supported anti-GMO activists. Marc Gunther has recounted the extent to which corporate and political sponsorship for anti-GMO activism has driven most of the campaigns across the world. Nonetheless, the introduction of GMOs into any country has its own political and business implications. Those supplying fertilisers to governments, suppliers of pesticides, weedicides and insecticides will be taken out of business. Political actors who may be hunting for avenues to make some political capital, may take advantage of such issues and join the protest without necessarily pointing out cogent reasons for their oppositions.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – Industry Scandals

Biotech projects get associated with pricing scandals---politicians love bashing the industry

Jackson Moses, 10-19-2016, Moses is a venture capitalist and head of partnerships at MainStreet "Biotech Bashing: Pills, Politics, & Endless Potential," No Publication, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/biotech-bashing-pills-politics-endless-potential-jackson-moses//DG

The Blame Game: How Tit-For-Tat Thinking Is Sinking Biotech Long the ire of Clinton, Warren, Sanders, and (now) Trump, Mylan's EpiPen pricing scandal provided politicians a prime excuse to attack the biotech sector for all healthcare-related problems. After news broke of Mylan's 500% EpiPen price hike, seasoned politicians (Democrat and Republican) took to , bashing the biotech industry for egregious price-gouging practices. As such, in an attempt to curb her impending PR nightmare, Mylan CEO Heather Bresch responded to media accusations by stating annual EpiPen price hikes were justified due to ongoing R&D costs (strike one), discounted public school rates (strike two), and Obamacare's failed incentive structure (strike three). Unsurprisingly, the aforementioned rationale didn't resonate with middle-class voters. The American public had quickly reached a populous conclusion, which also established a dangerous precedent: corporate greed is a punishable offense. The message was clear, if U.S. Representatives wanted to remain employed, Congress would hold "greedy" executives accountable for their private sector "crimes." Rightfully realizing the rare opportunity to acquire significant political capital, Hillary Clinton  the following: "EpiPens can be the difference between life and death. There's no justification for these price hikes." She then released an official follow-up statement and demanded "Mylan immediately reduce the price of EpiPens." Market participants responded by dumping Mylan stock to the tune of 10%.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – Biotech Investment

Biotech investment---congress has backed off BECAUSE of fears of inflation and price controls

Alex Keown, 6-15-2022, Keown is a journalist for Biospace with 20 years of experience in the field of biotechnology "Biotech Industry Seeks Congressional Greenlight for NOL Sales," BioSpace, https://www.biospace.com/article/biotech-industry-seeks-congressional-greenlight-for-nol-sales-as-source-of-income//DG

The San Francisco Business Times reported that industry lobbyists are  that will allow companies that are not yet generating revenue from the sales of their assets to be allowed to sell net operating loss carryforwards to larger companies. In other words, the biotech companies are looking to sell their losses to larger companies to provide them with a tax credit that would allow them to lower their tax burden.   Currently, net operating loss (NOL) carryforwards allow businesses that have suffered financial losses within a fiscal year to deduct them from profits in future years. This will enable businesses to be taxed on average profitability. The plan floated by biotech leaders would certainly be appealing to some of the larger companies. As the Business Times explained, NOL carryforwards are attractive to merger and acquisition specialists because of their practical applications in decreasing tax burdens. But, those are NOLs that are gained through an acquisition. The current plan seeks to give small companies the ability to sell those losses on the open market without going through the M&A process.  If a company gains a commercial revenue stream, it can take up to a decade and hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue that can offset those net operating losses.  While the sale of NOLs is not an option across the country as a whole, there are places where the practice is already in place. For years, the state of New Jersey has allowed tech and life sciences companies to sell up to $20 million in state net operating losses or R&D tax credits to buyers, which the purchasers can use to reduce taxable income. California has also reinstated the sale of NOLs as the state faced a budget deficit of $34 billion. It appears to have been successful as the state is now projected to have a surplus. But, at the federal level, the idea of NOL sales has not seen much movement.  This plan would allow early-stage companies with a new source of capital, mainly if they have been unsuccessful at finding significant funding from venture capitalists. The Business Times report comes the same day that Third Rock Ventures announced a new $1.1 billion fund aimed at supporting startup companies. The approach would provide a new source of funding for these early-stage companies. The supporters of the plan also noted that larger companies would benefit through a new tax-reduction tool.  The Business Times speculated that these NOLs are worth hundreds of millions of dollars. If the carryforward sale is allowed, the biotech industry hopes this could also serve as a catalyst for investors to return to supporting these early-stage companies to drive the development of new therapies, diagnostics and medical devices.  Investors have largely backed away from biotech and pharma over the past year due to market uncertainty caused by inflation, supply chain disruptions, the ongoing war in Ukraine and continuing talks about drug price controls. Since the start of the year, the Nasdaq Biotechnology Index has been down nearly 30%.  

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Biotech › Neg › L – Biotech Investment

Biotech investment draws political controversy – picking favorites perceived as undermine public efforts and a corporate handout

Servick 19 [Kelly Servick is a staff writer at Science, "Controversial U.S. bill would lift Supreme Court ban on patenting human genes", Science, https://www.science.org/content/article/controversial-us-bill-would-lift-supreme-court-ban-patenting-human-genes] GBS-HW

A congressional proposal that would overturn a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that barred the patenting of human genes and ease other restrictions on patenting software and biomedical inventions is drawing fierce criticism from some scientific societies and patient advocates. Yesterday, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) in Washington, D.C., along with more than 100 other signatories from research institutes and advocacy groups, released a letter to lawmakers arguing the changes would stifle medical research and hinder patients' access to diagnostic tests.

The draft bill "would result in a quagmire of patent claims and legal impediments to the normal scientific exchange," said Harold Varmus, a cancer biologist at Weill Cornell Medicine in New York City and former director of the National Cancer Institute, in a press conference yesterday. "It's in the interest of virtually everyone to keep ideas and basic discoveries about the laws and products of nature in the public domain."

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 2AC – No PC – Approval

No PC – lowest approval rates in 40 years from key young populace, and gaining support requires taking down Republicans

Davis 7/15 – works in political data in Washington DC. He worked on the data team for the Bernie Sanders 2020 campaign. (“Democrats are facing asymmetrical warfare. It’s time to wake up and fight back,“ 7-15-2022, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jul/15/democrats-are-facing-asymmetrical-warfare-its-time-to-wake-up-and-fight-back)// STC

The New York Times recently published a poll that marks an exclamation point on months of bad news for the rapidly faltering Biden presidency. Biden’s meager 33% approval rating is in line with other polls, but the shocking and worrying number for the White House is that fully 64% of Democrats believe he should not run for another term in 2024. That number rises to an absurd 94% among Democrats under 30.

While younger voters have consistently given Biden lower marks than other cohorts this year, that number now stands at a miserable 19%. Young voters are not a group that can be ignored as flighty non-voters: they are the backbone of the Democratic party’s recent wins. In 2020, the youth vote surged to record numbers, and young voters gave Biden a 24-point margin. Without both high turnout and high margins from young voters, Biden would have easily lost every swing state. Increased turnout among the young also provided much of the margin for Democrats in the 2018 midterms.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 2AC – No PC – Nuclear Plans

No PC – bipartisan fights over Biden’s nuclear rollback

Ukenye and O’Brien 7/6 – Laurence Ukenye is an editorial intern covering defense. Connor O’Brien is a defense reporter covering Congress. (“Congress poised to shoot down Biden’s nuclear rollback,” POLITICO, 7-6-2022, https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/06/congress-biden-nuclear-rollback-00044344)// STC

Progressives were already disappointed with President Joe Biden’s plans for the nation’s nuclear arsenal. Now they’re poised to lose one of the few things about the White House’s blueprint that they liked.

In recent weeks, Democrats have joined Republicans in adding money back into the Pentagon budget to continue developing a sea-launched nuclear cruise missile that former President Donald Trump initiated in 2018. Biden proposed canceling the missile, which arms control advocates say is redundant, costly and potentially destabilizing.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 2AC – No Link – Congress Wants Nukes

No link – Congress wants nukes despite Biden’s disapproval and the Navy’s budget denial

Gault 6/27 – contributing journalist and editor at Vice focused on conflict and politics. (Matthew, “Congress Wants to Spend $45 Million on Nukes the Navy Said it Doesn’t Need,” Vice, 6-27-2022, https://www.vice.com/en/article/akedz4/congress-wants-to-spend-dollar45-million-on-nukes-the-navy-said-it-doesnt-need)// STC

The House Armed Services Committee (HASC) added an amendment to the 2023 military budget that would continue to fund the development of sea-launched nuclear cruise missiles. This despite the Navy’s own budget zeroing out the item, saying it didn’t need the nukes, and the Biden White House saying the weapons were unnecessary.

The HASC amendment is $45 million dollars and Rep. Jim Cooper of Tennessee sees it as a compromise option between people who want the program cut entirely and those who want it bolstered. “We all know there are lots of pros and cons about actually deploying these on attack submarines,” Cooper said, according to Breaking Defense. “No one can tell in an uncertain world what we will need, but it’s important to keep this option available.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 2AC – No Link – Bipartisan Report

No link – Congress has called on the DoD to win the AI race to counter Russia and China – tech development, budget spending, and military integration

Seck ’20 – award-winning investigative and enterprise reporter who has been covering military issues since 2009. (Hope Hedge, “Congress Wants a 'Manhattan Project' for Military Artificial Intelligence,“ Military.com, 9-29-2020, https://www.military.com/daily-news/2020/09/29/congress-wants-manhattan-project-military-artificial-intelligence.html)// STC

A new bipartisan congressional report calls for the Defense Department to get a lot more serious about the race to acquire artificial intelligence and autonomous capabilities, modeling efforts to become dominant in these spheres after the "Manhattan Project" initiative to test and develop nuclear weapons in the 1940s.

On Tuesday, the House Armed Services Committee released the results of a yearlong review, co-led by Reps. Seth Moulton, D-Mass., and Jim Banks, R-Ind., aimed at assessing U.S. military capabilities and preparedness to meet current threats. The 87-page Future of Defense Task Force Report contains some expected findings -- China and Russia are identified as the top security threats to the U.S. and modernization is described as an urgent need -- but there are surprising points of emphasis.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 1AR – No Link – AT: Luria = Skeptic

Luria provides constructive criticism while garnering Republican support – Navy budgets, Taiwan, and proposals prove

Gould 7/13 -- senior Pentagon reporter for Defense News, covering the intersection of national security policy, politics and the defense industry. (Joe, “Elaine Luria wants to fight for a stronger Navy — but first she has to get reelected,” Defense News, 7-13-2022, https://www.defensenews.com/congress/2022/07/13/elaine-luria-is-fighting-for-a-stronger-navy-but-first-she-has-to-get-reelected/)// STC

Luria is one of the House Armed Services Committee’s most biting inquirers, especially when it comes to Navy matters. Less than a year into office, she grilled service officials on complex issues, often with coolly withering or rapid-fire questions, rarely glancing at her notes.

At a naval readiness hearing in 2019, Luria peppered the three-star chief of Naval Sea Systems Command with questions about maintenance delays for carriers.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 1AR – No Link – AT: Luria Loses

Luria generates support to win – appeals to local issues, military advocacy, and Republican distress – prefer recency

Weisman 6/7 -- congressional correspondent, veteran Washington journalist for over 30 years. (Jonathan, “The Jan. 6 Inquiry’s Only Endangered Democrat Prepares Herself for a Fight,” The New York Times, 6-7-2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/07/us/politics/elaine-luria-jan-6-hearings.html)// STC

But if voters regard their ballots as a choice between two political parties — one trying but failing, the other veering dangerously toward extremism — those losses could be mitigated. In the coming weeks — with the Jan. 6 hearings, an expected overturning of Roe v. Wade by the Supreme Court and the new focus on gun violence — Democrats are hoping that choice will be crystallized.

A new ABC News-Ipsos poll found that while voters still broadly rate inflation and gas prices as huge issues, their single most important concerns are diffuse. Inflation was chosen by 21 percent and the economy more broadly by 19 percent, but gun violence was the top priority of 17 percent and another 12 percent cited abortion.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Aff › 2AC – No Link – Luria Shields

No link – Luria fights for the Navy and protects Democratic majority, especially in light of Taiwan and midterms

Gould 7/13 -- senior Pentagon reporter for Defense News, covering the intersection of national security policy, politics and the defense industry. (Joe, “Elaine Luria wants to fight for a stronger Navy — but first she has to get reelected,” Defense News, 7-13-2022, https://www.defensenews.com/congress/2022/07/13/elaine-luria-is-fighting-for-a-stronger-navy-but-first-she-has-to-get-reelected/)// STC

WASHINGTON — Rep. Elaine Luria is one of the U.S. Navy’s staunchest proponents — and one of its most ruthless critics.

Luria first drew attention in 2018 as one of seven Democrats with national security backgrounds who flipped red House seats to blue. But the Virginian at times finds herself aligned with Republicans, as she champions defense spending hikes, even flatly saying earlier this year President Joe Biden’s defense budget “sucks.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Neg › 2NC – L – Congress Blocks

Republicans obstruct the Navy from investing in new ships – they’d rather fix existing LCSs

--LCS = littoral combat ship

Burke 7/14 – Washington correspondent covering Congress. (“U.S. House debates future of littoral combat ships including the USS Detroit,” Detroit News, 7-14-2022, https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/politics/2022/07/14/house-debates-future-littoral-combat-ships-uss-detroit/10055378002/)// STC

Washington — U.S. House lawmakers debated Wednesday whether to keep or retire a troubled class of warships that includes the USS Detroit, ultimately rejecting a measure that would have let the Navy retire nine of them.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Neg › 2NC – L – Congress Blocks

Congress blocks Navy requests to decommission ships for new updates – lawmakers focus on growing gap between US and Chinese fleets

Oren Liebermann et al. 22 -- CNN Pentagon correspondent. Ellie Kaufman is a Producer in CNN's Washington DC bureau. Brad Lendon is the Senior Global Military Affairs Writer for CNN Digital Worldwide. (“US Navy chief defends plan to scrap troubled warships even though some are less than 3 years old,” CNN, 5-12-2022, https://www.cnn.com/2022/05/12/politics/us-navy-scrap-warships/index.html)// STC

(CNN)The chief of the US Navy defended the service's plans to scrap nine relatively new warships in the coming fiscal year even as the service tries to keep up with China's growing fleet. Three of the littoral combat ships slated for decommissioning are less than three years old.

Chief of Naval Operations Admiral Michael Gilday told the House Armed Services Committee Wednesday that the anti-submarine ships could not perform their primary mission.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Neg › 2NC – L – Infighting

The plan only further tensions between the White House and Congress – funding and decommissions

Harris 7/13 – Congress reporter covering U.S. foreign policy and national security. (Bryant, “White House wrangles with Congress over ship, aircraft retirements,” Defense News, 7-13-2022, https://www.defensenews.com/smr/budget/2022/07/13/white-house-wrangles-with-congress-over-ship-aircraft-retirements/)// STC

WASHINGON — The White House on Tuesday doubled down on a brewing fight with Congress over legislative efforts that would prevent the retirement of several ships and aircraft as well as the scrapping of a nuclear modernization program.

With the House set to vote on the National Defense Authorization Act later this week, the White House’s Office of Management and Budget released a statement that said it “strongly opposes” congressional efforts to block its retirement and divestment plans.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Neg › 1NC – L – Infighting

Replacing existing submarines for modern ones like the plan ignite fights in congress

Donnelly and Clevenger 22 [John M. Donnelly and Andrew Clevenger, John M. Donnelly is a senior writer for CQ Roll Call who specializes in defense. He has served as president of the Military Reporters & Editors Association, chairman of the National Press Club board of governors, and secretary of the Standing Committee of Correspondents in Congress. Andrew is a defense policy writer for Roll Call, 5-11-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, Roll Call, "Tensions rise in House over Navy shipbuilding - Roll Call", https://rollcall.com/2022/05/11/tensions-rise-in-house-over-navy-shipbuilding/ mimou]

Sharp divisions over the adequacy of President Joe Biden’s fiscal 2023 request for the Navy’s shipbuilding budget emerged at two House hearings Wednesday.

The differences, which fell largely along party lines, were manifest at a House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense budget hearing with the Pentagon top brass and a House Armed Services Committee hearing with the leaders of the Navy and Marine Corps.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AI Subs › Neg › 2NC – L – Unpopular

//Plans for new AI submarines are widely unpopular

Gooding 22 [Mike Gooding, Mike is the senior military and political reporter at 13news now, 5-13-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, 13newsnow.com, "Navy 'not sized' to handle two wars at once: CNO", https://www.13newsnow.com/article/news/national/military-news/chief-naval-operations-says-navy-not-prepared-to-handle-two-wars-at-once/291-89e465f9-1f34-4748-b1a6-a2980ace86c1 mimou]

The current fleet stands at 298 ships. However, Gilday told the Senate Armed Services Committee on Thursday that he supports the Biden Administrations' proposal to reduce the fleet to 280 ships by 2027.

Gilday said it's smarter to invest now in newer, more sophisticated and more lethal ships, rather than wasting money on older, less capable vessels.