Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Central Investment Key

China has advantages in speed, execution, product quality, data, and government support.

Kai-Fu Lee 18, Kai-Fu Lee is the CEO of Sinovation Ventures and author of AI Superpowers. Lee was formerly the president of Google China and a senior executive at Microsoft, SGI, and Apple. Co-chair of the AI Council at the World Economic Forum, he has a bachelor’s degree from Columbia and a PhD from Carnegie Mellon, 10-23-2018,“Why China Can Do AI More Quickly and Effectively Than the US,” , oj

WHEN ENRICO FERMI decided to leave Benito Mussolini’s Italy and emigrate to the United States, he changed the global balance of power. After arriving in the US, Fermi led the world’s first self-sustaining nuclear reaction at the University of Chicago and played an indispensable role in the Manhattan Project, which led to the end of World War II in the Pacific and laid the groundwork for a new world order and America’s prominent role. So it is not surprising that some Americans think the same should be true with AI. Emigrant AI researchers like Geoff Hinton, Yann LeCun, Yoshua Bengio, Andrew Ng, and Fei-Fei Li are the Enrico Fermis of AI and should secure an American (and Canadian) hegemony in AI. Indeed, the US and Canada have 100 percent of the top 10 AI researchers, and 68 percent of the world’s best 1,000 or so researchers. But technological revolutions are not only driven by big discoveries. Often, once a fundamental breakthrough has been published, the center of gravity quickly shifts from a handful of elite researchers to an army of tinkerers—engineers with enough expertise to apply the technology to different real-world problems and customer needs. This is particularly true when the payoff of a breakthrough is diffused throughout society rather than just concentrated in a few labs. Mass electrification exemplified this process. Following Thomas Edison’s harnessing of electricity, the field rapidly shifted from invention to implementation. Thousands of engineers everywhere began tinkering with electricity, using it to power new devices and reorganize industrial processes. Those tinkerers didn’t have to break fundamentally new ground like Edison. They just had to know enough about how electricity worked to turn its power into useful and profitable machines. Our present-day phase of AI implementation fits this latter model. But you might say: A constant stream of headlines about AI breakthroughs (AlphaGo, Stanford beating doctors in cancer diagnosis, Microsoft beating human in speech recognition, etc.) shows that we are still in an age of discovery. In reality, we are witnessing the application of the same fundamental breakthrough—deep learning and related techniques—to many different problems. That’s a process that requires well-trained AI engineers, the tinkerers of this age, to apply and tweak deep learning for each domain. Today, those tinkerers are applying AI’s superhuman powers of pattern recognition to making loans, driving cars, translating text, and powering our Amazon Go and Amazon Alexa. Deep-learning pioneers like Geoffrey Hinton, Yann LeCun, and Yoshua Bengio—the Enrico Fermis of AI—continue to push the boundaries of artificial intelligence. And they may yet produce another game-changing breakthrough, one that scrambles the global technological pecking order. But in the meantime, the real action today is with the tinkerers, those who implement AI and make it solve real-world problems. And this is where China comes in—while the US is the world’s leader in AI discoveries, China is actually the leader in AI implementation. What matters in AI implementation is speed, execution, product quality, data, and government support. Chinese companies are equal to or ahead of their American counterparts in each of these areas. First, let’s look at speed. The Chinese environment is a combination of a huge market, ample capital, and daring entrepreneurs who are the embodiment of “lean startup”: fail fast, fail early, and fail often. Chinese entrepreneurs are fast to find market opportunities, build products, and pivot when needed. For example, after companies like Uber and Didi proved the viability of ride-sharing, China’s startup world caught sharing fever, trying out every possible iteration of it: shared bicycles, shared mopeds, shared concrete mixers, and shared mobile phone chargers. The vast majority of these died off quickly (known as fail fast), but a few rose to become unicorns, such as Mobike, which reached 20 million rides per day and was sold for $2.7 billion three years from founding. This rapid prototyping and tweaking approach have also enabled Chinese AI companies to find winners. For example, Megvii (Face++) is a computer vision company that originally tried face morphing games and face unlock of phones before striking gold on finance fraud avoidance as the killer app (think of credit card companies using face scan instead of customer service “quizzes” on suspicious credit card usage). As mobile payments ballooned to $18.8 trillion in China, this turned out to be the winner. In another example, AInnovation started on AI sales forecast but added hardware products like computer-vision driven vending machines and whole-basket check-out kiosks, all within six months. There are many other examples like this in my book, AI Superpowers. In execution, Chinese entrepreneurs are unafraid of the tedious, messy, and risky tasks, if they help achieve the ultimate result. Chinese CEOs usually have absolute power within the company, which makes execution much more effective. As an example, the “Chinese Groupon” Meituan was tenacious in focusing on users’ needs and found a way to nail that problem. They found that people wanted to eat take-out food, but it had to be delivered with 30 minutes (including cooking time), and the cost must be brought down to about 70 cents per delivery in order to profitably offer “free delivery.” Meituan then maniacally worked on this problem for years, eventually hiring 600,000 people on mopeds, adopting an Uber model, finding riders willing to work during meal hours, tweaking the lowest-cost delivery vehicle (battery-operated mopeds), solving the battery life problem for mopeds, inventing AI matching and routing algorithms. After billions of dollars of losses and many years of iterations, Meituan managed deliver food to any destination within 30 minutes and under 70 cents. That totally changed the way Chinese people eat. And that differentiated it from the US Groupon, Yelp, and OpenTable, which collectively are worth less than one-tenth of the $60 billion valuation. Meituan chose this approach rather than resting on its laurels like Groupon and Yelp, because Chinese entrepreneurs are tenacious and if you have a profitable “light-weight” business, you will find yourself surrounded by entrepreneurs who want a share of your profits. Fierce competition pushes entrepreneurs to improve the product at lightning speed, with incredible work ethic, always pressured to develop impregnable business models. As a result, Chinese products often evolved into better products than their American counterparts (e.g., Wechat vs. Whatsapp, Weibo vs. Twitter, Taobao vs. eBay). The Chinese market rapidly embraces new products and new paradigms. Just within the last 3 years, mobile payments have emerged as the dominant transaction tool, replacing cash and credit cards. Total transaction in 2017 was $18.8 trillion, even larger than China’s GDP. China’s mobile payments are built on the world’s best infrastructure: nearly zero-transaction-fee, micropayment-capable, and peer-to-peer. Over 700 million Chinese users can pay each other, whether for online, offline, loan, or gift, whether to your child, a farmer in a village, or even a beggar. All of this is amplified by China’s enormous market size, which generates the treasure trove of data that fuels AI (AI is usually more improved by more data than better AI engineers). China’s data edge is three times the US based on mobile user ratio, 10 times the US in food delivery, 50 times in mobile payment, and 300 times in shared bicycle rides. All this rich data is used to make Chinese companies’ AI work better. Finally, the Chinese government’s support of AI development will prove important in the age of AI, though not in the way most Western analysts believe. Western narratives trivialize the government’s role as subsidizing winners and protecting them from foreign competition. But actually, sophisticated government support comes in three forms, which are neither blind nor anti-competitive: (1) Central government sets the tone, which can legitimize a burgeoning industry like AI and influence companies and consumers to adopt AI (and smart young people to go into AI); (2) techno-utilitarian policy, which allows unproven technology to be launched early and quickly and adds regulation only if necessary later (enabling a nation-wide displacement of cash and credit cards with mobile payment); (3) infrastructure-building, such as rebuilding cities and highways with special roads with sensors and special lanes or “levels” for autonomous vehicles (contrasted with the US decision to slow down autonomous truck testing due to job displacement concerns). As a result of all of the above, China has the world’s most valuable companies in computer vision, drones, speech recognition, speech synthesis, and machine translation. Sinovation Ventures, my VC company, now has five AI unicorns, with a combined valued of $23B. These companies were founded only two to four years ago. The speed, execution, product focus, access to data, and government support are significantly higher than their American counterparts. So can we conclude that China is the de facto winner of the AI race? No, because researchers worldwide are still plunging ahead. Not long ago, Geoff Hinton made a call for top researchers to abandon deep learning and develop brand-new machine learning algorithms that can come closer to human intelligence. So what can this balance of strengths and weaknesses tell us about international leadership in AI? Here, it helps to zoom in on perhaps the most coveted of all AI-powered products: fully autonomous vehicles. Companies in both countries are feverishly chasing the dream of mass deployment of cars that drive themselves. They’ve made great strides toward this goal, but it still remains an open question which company or country will get there first. That question gets right to the crux of the US-China dichotomy between visionary research and practical implementation. Waymo (an Alphabet company) jumped out to a major lead in autonomous vehicles because it was willing to think big and take risks. Once Waymo demonstrated that this was possible (in large part due to breakthroughs like deep learning), companies in both the United States and China started playing catch-up. At the same time, local Chinese officials began competing with each other to attract autonomous-vehicle startups, pledging to build entirely new public infrastructure projects to facilitate deployment: highways lined with sensors that communicate with vehicles and elevated roads reserved for training autonomous vehicles. The winner in this race will likely depend on whether the final bottleneck is about core technology or implementation details. If the bottleneck is technical—major improvements for core algorithms—then advantage US. If the bottleneck is about implementation—smart infrastructure or policy adaptation—then advantage China. What should the US do in light of the rising Chinese AI capabilities? I have three suggestions. First, move away from trivializing the Chinese approach (e.g., copycat, government protectionism), recognize that the Chinese approach has merit, and be open to learning from it. Second, double down on fundamental research, where the US has a huge lead over the rest of the world. American universities attract top students around the world, who learn AI in the US, and many will choose to stay. Third and most important, recognize that AI development is not the new cold war. AI is more like electricity than nuclear weapons. US and China have much to learn from each other. And the opportunities and challenges from AI are much larger than any threat or competition from any one country to another.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Central Investment Key

China’s emphasis on government collaboration is key

Ruqayya Anwer 22, Academic at Riphah International University, Pakistan, Ph.D. holder of media and communication studies, 1-18-2022, “China is winning the power battle in AI race with US,” , oj

There is a widespread belief that China is establishing itself as a new superpower, displacing the United States from the global power structure. China has undeniably become a worldwide economic powerhouse, and it is anticipated to overtake the U.S. as the world's largest economy by 2028. With increased spending on weapons research and the development of multiple covert weapons, China is on the verge of surpassing the U.S. in military capability. Significantly, countries that lead in the research and application of artificial intelligence (AI) will determine the future of the technology and increase their economic competitiveness greatly, while those that fall behind risk losing competitiveness in critical industries. AI is set to revolutionize the world, empowering those countries that fully realize its promise. It will be a key driver of future economic growth and national security. Moreover, AI is sometimes referred to as a general-purpose technology because of its wide range of applications in practically every industry – the GUID Partition Table (GPT). A GPT is a technology with widespread economic implications. Only a few examples exist such as steam engines, electricity and computers. These technologies have had a profound impact on our civilizations by modifying preexisting economic and social systems. AI is the newest brilliant, dazzling object on the technological horizon. It has grown very popular in today's globe. It's the simulation of human intellect in computers that have been programmed to learn and mimic human behavior. AI will have a significant impact on our quality of life as it develops. It has the potential to significantly boost the economy of a developed country. For its technological advancements, China has won the AI battle with the U.S. and is on its way to world supremacy. According to Western intelligence assessments, China, the world's second-largest economy, is expected to dominate many major emerging technologies, including AI, synthetic biology and genetics, within a decade or two. Pentagon official’s words The Pentagon's first chief software officer, Nicolas Chaillan stressed that “in 15 to 20 years, we have no competing fighting chance against China.” It's already decided; “Whether it requires a war or not is kind of anecdotal right now.” He also claimed that several government departments in the U.S. had "kindergarten-level" cyber defenses. Moreover, Chaillan also criticized the reluctance of U.S. firms, such as Google, to collaborate with the government on AI, and extensive ethical disputes over technology for the U.S.’ delayed innovation. While China was destined to rule the world's future, everything from media narratives to geopolitics is under their control. One of the reasons China has been able to move more rapidly than the U.S. is that it is not mired in enormous arguments about AI ethics. But partly because Chinese businesses are compelled to collaborate with the government, whereas many American businesses are wary of working with the Pentagon. Google, for instance, halted working with the Pentagon on AI in 2018 after a dozen employees departed after the business assisted the Department of Defense in developing software that could boost drone attack accuracy. Chaillan, on the other hand, stated that Chinese corporations were obligated to comply with the Chinese government and were making "huge expenditures" in AI without concern for ethical considerations. Notably, the U.S. has attempted to curb China's emergence as a digital power by prohibiting Huawei's 5G network from operating in the U.S. and establishing a virtual embargo on U.S. companies supplying software and components to Chinese tech firms. Whereas China’s President Xi Jinping is pushing China to establish technological self-sufficiency in fields such as microchip manufacturing to wean the country off its reliance on the U.S. Significantly, there will always be economic ups and downs, but the underlying drive that's occurring in Chinese culture right now will continue to create new prospects and growth. China has announced a five-year plan worth $1.8 trillion to dominate AI, robotics, 6G and all other technologies by 2035, releasing a five-year plan worth $1.8 trillion. In comparison to the European Union and the U.S., China's AI capabilities have advanced in several areas. China has surpassed the bloc as the world's largest AI publisher. Moreover, the quality of its AI research has consistently improved over time. Its software and computer services companies have increased their R&D expenditures. China's determination to master AI goes far beyond the recognition that this group of technologies will be the most crucial driver of economic advancement over the next quarter-century. China's data collection and national determination have helped it to close the gap with American leaders in this area over the last decade. China now has nearly twice as many supercomputers ranked in the top 500 for performance as the U.S., even though the U.S. was once the leader in this category. Furthermore, China is likely to maintain its advantage in terms of data generation. Overall, though, China has not dramatically narrowed the AI gap with the U.S., but its steady growth could eventually erode U.S. dominance over the technology. Consequently, countries that lead in the research and application use of AI will determine the future of the technology and increase their economic competitiveness greatly, while those that fall behind risk losing competitiveness in critical industries. As a result, China has taken the lead. The Chinese government, rules and regulations, public attitudes toward privacy and strong collaboration between corporations and the government are all contributing to the country's AI progress. At the same time, American AI confronts significant challenges, including a culture that prioritizes privacy over security, distrusts authority and the government; as such, firms are wary of collaborating with the U.S.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

China’s Artificial Intelligence Strategy Poses a Credible Threat to U.S. Tech Leadership

CFR, 12-4-2017, "China’s Artificial Intelligence Strategy Poses a Credible Threat to U.S. Tech Leadership," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/blog/chinas-artificial-intelligence-strategy-poses-credible-threat-us-tech-leadership

Last month, Eric Schmidt, the chairman of Google’s parent company Alphabet,  a wake-up call: the unchallenged technological supremacy that the United States has enjoyed since the fall of the Soviet Union is over. The future will belong to countries that can surf the technological tidal wave of , and while China’s efforts appear up to the challenge, the United States is swimming in the wrong direction.

When China released its national  this summer announcing it would lead the world in AI technology by 2025, some in the military and Silicon Valley scoffed. They repeated the same tired cliché that China’s tech industry and scientific researchers , only copy. Schmidt, by contrast, sees China’s AI ambitions as completely believable “You’re crazy to treat them as somehow second class citizens” he said, addressing an  full of American national security officials and AI researchers.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

China should lead the world with it’s advance AI

Graham Allison, 10-31-2018, "Is China Beating the U.S. to AI Supremacy?," Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/china-beating-us-ai-supremacy

Though still in their infancy, AI technologies will be drivers of future economic growth and national security. From facial recognition and fintech to drones and 5g, China is not just catching up. In many cases, it has already overtaken the United States to become the world’s undisputed No. 1. In some arenas, because of constitutional constraints and different values, the United States willfully forfeits the race. In others, China is simply more determined to win.

China’s AI surge is so recent that anyone not watching closely has likely missed it. As late as 2015, when assessing its international competition, American industry leaders—Google, Microsoft, Facebook and Amazon—saw Chinese companies in their rearview mirrors alongside German or French firms in the third tier. But this changed four years ago—in 2016—when leading AI application company DeepMind fielded a machine that defeated world champion Lee Sedol in the world’s most complex board game, Go. Even after several American companies’ machines had bested the chess masters of the universe, most Chinese remained confident that machines could never beat Go champions, since Go is ten thousand times more complex than chess. Thus, DeepMind’s decisive victory became for China a “Sputnik moment”—a jolt as dramatic as the Soviet Union’s launch of the first satellite into space that sparked America’s whole-of nation surge in math and science, nasa’s creation and the original “moon shot.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

Future pandemics cause extinction

Eleftherios P. Diamandis 21 (works for the Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada; Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada; Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. “The Mother of All Battles: Viruses vs. Humans. Can Humans Avoid Extinction in 50-100 Years? 4/13/21 https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202104.0397/v1)//conway

The recent SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, which is causing COVID 19 disease, has taught us unexpected lessons about the dangers of human extinction through highly contagious and lethal diseases. As the COVID 19 pandemic is now being controlled by various isolation measures, therapeutics and vaccines, it became clear that our current lifestyle and societal functions may not be sustainable in the long term. We now have to start thinking and planning on how to face the next dangerous pandemic, not just overcoming the one that is upon us now. Is there any evidence that even worse pandemics could strike us in the near future and threaten the existence of the human race? The answer is unequivocally yes. It is not necessary to get infected by viruses of bats, pangolins and other exotic animals that live in remote forests in order to be in danger. Creditable scientific evidence indicates that the human gut microbiota harbor billions of viruses which are capable of affecting the function of vital human organs such as the immune system, lung, brain, liver, kidney, heart etc. It is possible that the development of pathogenic variants in the gut can lead to contagious viruses which can cause pandemics, leading to destruction of vital organs, causing death or various debilitating diseases such as blindness, respiratory, liver, heart and kidney failures. These diseases could result n the complete shutdown of our civilization and probably the extinction of human race. In this essay, I will first provide a few independent pieces of scientific facts and then combine this information to come up with some (but certainly not all) hypothetical scenarios that could cause human race misery, even extinction. I hope that these scary scenarios will trigger preventative measures that could reverse or delay the projected adverse outcomes.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

R&D key to solve Pandemics

Pandemic Acion Network ’22 (organization driven to create global support and policy making influence to end future pandemcis, “Pandemic R&D Agenda for Action: Fostering Innovation to End This Pandemic and Prepare for the Next One”, 1/25/22) https://www.pandemicactionnetwork.org/news/pandemic-rd-agenda-for-action-fostering-innovation-to-end-this-pandemic-and-prepare-for-the-next-one

As the world commences the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic, the case for investment in research and development (R&D) for medical countermeasures to prevent and combat emerging global health threats is stronger than ever. Despite , systemic gaps in pandemic-related R&D systems, supply chains, manufacturing, and delivery continue to stymie the roll-out of urgently needed technologies to all people who need them, everywhere, and are prolonging the pandemic. COVID-19 and its variants have that pose barriers to timely and effective pandemic R&D. Not only do these persistent gaps threaten to undo progress achieved through the scientific breakthroughs, but they also that leave the most vulnerable and disadvantaged people around the globe without access to lifesaving medical countermeasures and essential health services, and perpetuate gross power imbalances between high- and low-income nations. COVID-19 has also unleashed a multitude of actors in pandemic-related R&D across the innovation spectrum and across the globe, underscoring the growing need for more purposeful alignment, coordination, information-sharing, and transparency. The world urgently needs a fit-for-purpose, proactive, and resilient pandemic R&D ecosystem. There is broad consensus that R&D is a vital component of building a world better equipped to prevent, prepare for, and respond to pandemic threats. Yet new investments in innovation will fail to meet their promise to save lives, prevent future global health emergencies, and build a healthier, safer world for all unless governments, international institutions, and industry are willing to heed the hard lessons of this pandemic and work together to fix these systemic failures and challenges. Produced by Global Health Technologies Coalition and Pandemic Action Network with contributions by members of the Pandemic Action Network’s Pandemic Preparedness Working Group, this policy brief calls on world leaders to prioritize action in four key areas to close the critical R&D, manufacturing, and delivery gaps necessary to end the acute COVID-19 crisis and build a more resilient, equitable pandemic R&D ecosystem for the future

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

Combining with the new 5G, China’s AI has the potential to lead in healthcare – solves disease and aging crisis – promotes quality of life

Ye 21 (Sally Ye, health care technology analyst at the Healthcare Technology division of Omdia, 10-18-2021, "China's medical Artificial Intelligence market continues to grow," Omnia Health Insights, https://insights.omnia-health.com/artificial-intelligence/chinas-medical-artificial-intelligence-market-continues-grow)

On September 22nd, Airdoc Technology, a fast-growing start-up offering an AI-driven system that takes and analyses photographic images of the retina, passed listing hearing which means it is going to be the first public-listed medical AI company in China. 

Shukun Tech, another AI-focused start-up focusing on assisting cardiovascular disease diagnosis, filed for IPO on September 21st, joining the growing list of Chinese medical AI companies going public this year.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 2nc – Disease !

China’s AI is future of R&D leading the globe, aiding in healthcare, and spurring economic growth

Shen et al ’22 (Responsible for 4x China Analytics practice to ~100 data scientists, developers and business translators in ~2 years, “The next frontier for AI in China could add $600 billion to its economy,” QuantumBlack AI by McKinsey, 6/7/22) https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/quantumblack/our-insights/the-next-frontier-for-ai-in-china-could-add-600-billion-to-its-economy

Healthcare and life sciences: In recent years, China has stepped up its investment in innovation in healthcare and life sciences with AI. China’s “14th Five-Year Plan” targets 7 percent annual growth by 2025 for R&D expenditure, of which at least 8 percent is devoted to basic research. 13 One area of focus is accelerating drug discovery and increasing the odds of success, which is a significant global issue. In 2021, global pharma R&D spend reached $212 billion, compared with $137 billion in 2012, with an approximately 5 percent compound annual growth rate (CAGR). Drug discovery takes 5.5 years on average, which not only delays patients’ access to innovative therapeutics but also shortens the patent protection period that rewards innovation. Despite improved success rates for new-drug development, only the top 20 percent of pharmaceutical companies worldwide realized a breakeven on their R&D investments after seven years. Another top priority is improving patient care, and Chinese AI start-ups today are working to build the country’s reputation for providing more accurate and reliable healthcare in terms of diagnostic outcomes and clinical decisions. Our research suggests that AI in R&D could add more than $25 billion in economic value in three specific areas: faster drug discovery, clinical-trial optimization, and clinical-decision support. Rapid drug discovery. Novel drugs (patented prescription drugs) currently account for less than 30 percent of the total market size in China (compared with more than 70 percent globally), indicating a significant opportunity from introducing novel drugs empowered by AI in discovery. We estimate that using AI to accelerate target identification and novel molecules design could contribute up to $10 billion in value. 14 Already more than 20 AI start-ups in China funded by private-equity firms or local hyperscalers are collaborating with traditional pharmaceutical companies or independently working to develop novel therapeutics. Insilico Medicine, by using an end-to-end generative AI engine for target identification, molecule design, and lead optimization, discovered a preclinical candidate for pulmonary fibrosis in less than 18 months at a cost of under $3 million. This represented a significant reduction from the average timeline of six years and an average cost of more than $18 million from target discovery to preclinical candidate. This antifibrotic drug candidate has now successfully completed a Phase 0 clinical study and entered a Phase I clinical trial. Clinical-trial optimization. Our research suggests that another $10 billion in economic value could result from optimizing clinical-study designs (process, protocols, sites), optimizing trial delivery and execution (hybrid trial-delivery model), and generating real-world evidence. 15 These AI use cases can reduce the time and cost of clinical-trial development, provide a better experience for patients and healthcare professionals, and enable higher quality and compliance. For instance, a global top 20 pharmaceutical company leveraged AI in combination with process improvements to reduce the clinical-trial enrollment timeline by 13 percent and save 10 to 15 percent in external costs. The global pharmaceutical company prioritized three areas for its tech-enabled clinical-trial development. To accelerate trial design and operational planning, it utilized the power of both internal and external data for optimizing protocol design and site selection. For streamlining site and patient engagement, it established an ecosystem with API standards to leverage internal and external innovations. To establish a clinical-trial development cockpit, it aggregated and visualized operational trial data to enable end-to-end clinical-trial operations with full transparency so it could predict potential risks and trial delays and proactively take action. The future of AI in China: Clinical-decision support. Our findings indicate that the use of machine learning algorithms on medical images and data (including examination results and symptom reports) to predict diagnostic outcomes and support clinical decisions could generate around $5 billion in economic value. 16 A leading AI start-up in medical imaging now applies computer vision and machine learning algorithms on optical coherence tomography results from retinal images. It automatically searches and identifies the signs of dozens of chronic illnesses and conditions, such as diabetes, hypertension, and arteriosclerosis, expediting the diagnosis process and increasing early detection of disease.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

Food shortages cause China to escalate towards Taiwan.

Chaudhury 20, Dipanjan Roy Chaudhury covers Foreign Affairs .A US State Department IVLP fellow in 2015, Dipanjan has been on fellowships to Germany and Taiwan, 9-26-20, “Food shortages in China might push Xi Jinping to take drastic actions against Taiwan and elsewhere,” , oj

NEW DELHI: China is believed to be on the brink of a major food shortage, which might trigger a strategic contest over food security and push Chinese President Xi Jinping already under intense pressure, toward drastic measures, potentially spelling trouble for Taiwan and other parts of the world. China has encountered a perfect storm of disasters this year. On top of disruption due to the COVID-19 pandemic, torrential rains have caused catastrophic flooding in the Yangtze River basin, China’s largest agricultural region. Floodwaters are estimated to have already destroyed the crops on 6 million hectares of farmland, according to an editorial in The Taipei Times. The situation has been further compounded by plagues of locusts and fall armyworm infestations in other regions, where fields have been stripped bare, and three huge typhoons last month making landfall in northeastern China, the editorial alleged. Food prices increased 13 percent in July, with pork prices rising by an eye-watering 85 percent, Chinese government data showed. There are reports of farmers hoarding crops, expecting even higher prices. After initially trumpeting “bumper harvests,” Chinese state media have switched from cover-up to behavior control, touting a national “Clean your plate” campaign on food wastage, according to the editorial. Last month, Xi called on the Chinese public to “cultivate thrifty habits, and foster a social environment where waste is shameful and thriftiness is applaudable.” “The propaganda has shades of Mao Zedong’s call for Chinese citizens to eat only two meals a day at the onset of the Great Famine of 1959 to 1961,” the editorial pointed out. “All the signs point to a significant fall in domestic agricultural output, and it is uncertain whether China will be able to plug the gap with imports, while also keeping a lid on soaring prices.” “Food shortages look to be more than just a short-term blip. As China has become more affluent, diets — and waistlines — have expanded, putting a strain on supply and demand. The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that China’s domestic supply of rice, wheat and corn will fall short of demand by 25 million tonnes by the end of 2025. This raises the question, how can China feed its 1.4 billion people in the long term?,” the editorial quipped. “If there is a serious food shortage, which requires rationing, or even a famine, Xi would need the mother of all distractions — and a small border war with India probably would not cut it,” The Taipei Times alleged. “Chinese military aircraft are on an almost daily basis probing Taiwan’s air defense identification zone. Xi might be trying to goad Taiwan into a first strike. A significant danger point for Taiwan is the US presidential election in November. Due to the extreme polarization of US politics, the result is likely to be bitterly contested.” If the US is thrown into chaos with a protracted court battle to settle the election’s outcome, Xi could view this as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to solve the “Taiwan problem.” With mass protests after the election, the US might in Beijing’s eyes appear historically weak, even on the brink of a civil war, alleged the editorial. The US has of course been there before during the mid-1960s and recovered — but there is a real possibility of a miscalculation on Xi’s part. To top it off, there is a big date coming up: July 31 next year marks the centenary of the founding of the Chinese Communist Party. With Xi under scrutiny at home for myriad policy failures, he will need something to show for it — and the clock is ticking, according to Taipei Times.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

Chinese tech increases food security.

Kirana Aisyah 21, Kirana is a content producer at Opengovasia and specializes in AI, cyber, IoT, tech, and more. She has a Bachelor’s degree at the University of Indonesia, 10-4-2021, “Technology to Ensure Food Security in China,” , oj

According to the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences (CAAS), China will improve efforts to create higher yields and higher quality production of major food crop varieties, and self-sufficiency in major livestock and poultry varieties by 2030 by deploying technology. China released an action plan to promote the national seed industry late last month in Sanya, South China’s Hainan province, where the Nanfan Scientific and Research Breeding Base is located. The plan lays out the necessary theoretical, scientific and technological developments for the industry to improve seed varieties and grain yields, and ensure the protection of national germ plasm resources. Since the beginning of the 13th Five-Year Plan (2016-2020), China’s ability to innovate in breeding technology has continued to rise. However, China is still in the process of developing breeding theories and key technologies. Yields of corn and soybeans have not reached those of developed countries, while the availability of some vegetable seeds remains dependent on imports. The need to become self-reliant in terms of science and innovation-driven technology is urgent. – Zhang Hecheng, CAAS official In recent years, CAAS has made significant breakthroughs in key technologies including genome-wide selection, ploidy breeding (a process useful in plant breeding), and genetically modified organisms, which has laid a solid foundation for future research. China will introduce 50 major tasks focused on key crop and livestock varieties, and three specific actions involving innovative research, seed enterprises and the creation of a science and technology platform. China will strive to achieve high-yield, high-quality self-sufficiency in food crop varieties by 2030, and ensure the absolute security of the country’s rice and wheat. By 2030, the self-sufficiency rate of vegetable varieties, such as broccoli, carrots and spinach, will rise from the current 10% to more than 50%. Moreover, a platform will be built to boost seed industry technology, integrating basic research, technological innovation, variety creation, big data, and industry incubation. China will reinforce the underpinning role of science and technology in agricultural production. In light of the national conditions and people’s needs, science-based and result-oriented efforts will be made to shore up the areas of weakness. Mechanisms will be improved to fully mobilise market forces and promote collaboration on innovation between research institutes and universities, and enterprises and farmers. A sound commercial breeding system will be established, and enterprises in the seed industry will be nurtured and expanded. The research, development and extensive application of practical and efficient farming machinery and equipment will be supported. Quality and efficiency in the agricultural sector will be promoted through technological innovation. As reported by OpenGov Asia, digital technology is bound to play a bigger role in the country’s steps toward rural vitalisation and agricultural modernisation. The digitalisation of rural industries is key to developing the countryside, and it is a new driver of a sustainable rural economy. Integrating new technology like big data, Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the Internet of Things (IoT) with crop and livestock production will be central to developing smart agriculture. The involvement of digital technologies across the supply chain will help increase efficiency while reducing costs. The push toward digital agriculture is the result of a plan released in January last year aimed at improving smart agriculture and providing support for rural vitalisation in the years leading up to 2025. Jointly released by the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs and the Cyberspace Administration of China, the plan proposed building a basic data system for rural areas to facilitate targeted management and services. The plan highlighted research into and the use of intelligent agricultural machinery as well as the development of smart agriculture based on the internet of things, sensors, location systems, and robots.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

CCP diversionary war goes nuclear

Polina Tikhonova 15, Russia expert at ValueWalk, citing Zhang Baohui, Prof @ Political Science and Director of the Centre for Asian Pacific Studies @ Lingnan, “US Faces Nuclear War Threat Over South China Sea – Chinese Professor,” 11/28, http://www.valuewalk.com/2015/11/us-nuclear-war-south-china-sea/

China is willing to start a nuclear war with the United States over the South China Sea, according to a Chinese professor. Beijing’s rhetoric after an incident with a U.S. warship sailed to the South China Sea suggests that Chinese decision-makers could resort to more “concrete and forceful measures” to counter the U.S. Navy, according to Zhang Baohui, Professor of Political Science and Director of the Centre for Asian Pacific Studies at Lingnan University in Hong Kong. “If so, a face-off between the two navies becomes inevitable. Even worse, the face-off may trigger an escalation towards military conflicts,” the professor wrote in a piece for RSIS Commentary. But, according to Baohui, the U.S. military is “oblivious” to this scenario, since Washington decision-makers think America’s conventional military superiority discourages China from responding to such “provocations” in the South China Sea militarily. However, this “U.S. expectation is flawed, as China is a major nuclear power,” the professor wrote. “When cornered, nuclear-armed states can threaten asymmetric escalation to deter an adversary from harming its key interests,” he added. Baohui then refers to the military parade in Beijing that took place on Sept. 3 and revealed that China’s new generation of tactical missiles – such as the DF-26 – are capable of being armed with nuclear warheads. Moreover, according to the latest reports, China’s air-launched long-range cruise missiles can also carry tactical nuclear warheads. U.S. could provoke nuclear war with China And while the U.S. does not have its core interests in the South China Sea, the disputed islands present China’s strategic interests, which is why this kind of asymmetry in stakes would certainly give Beijing an advantage in “the balance of resolve” over Washington, according to the professor. And if the South China Sea situation escalates and starts spiraling into a nuclear confrontation between the U.S. and China, Washington will face a choice of either backing down first or fighting a nuclear-armed power and the world’s largest military force with a strength of approximately 2.285 million personnel. “Neither option is attractive and both exact high costs, either in reputation or human lives, for the U.S.,” Baohui wrote. So it would be unwise for the U.S. to further provoke China in the disputed area, since China’s willingness to defend its interests, reputation and deterrence credibility could easily escalate the conflict into a military confrontation that would ultimately harm U.S. interests, according to the professor.China will join Russia in nuclear war with NATO With NATO member state Turkey downing a Russian jet in its airspace, there is already a high risk of military confrontation in the world. And with China being so close and allied with Russia, Beijing decision-makers could see the incident with the Russian warplane as an opportunity to avenge the West for the South China Sea provocations.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

American tech companies are selling, manipulating, and stealing consumer data

Beens ’21 (Robert E.G. Beens is Co-Founder and CEO of , the world’s most private search engine, “,” Fast Company, 1/28/21) https://www.fastcompany.com/90597583/data-privacy-startpage-founder

There is a curious trend afoot these days. As profits among tech’s biggest players have risen, so too have . Their trajectories nearly mirror each other: up, and to the right. This is no coincidence, of course. User data, that digital treasure craved by hackers and businesses alike, is wildly lucrative. Big tech is using our data in privacy-invasive ways to source targeted ads, in a way that allows them based on where they live or who they are. In addition, companies are using our images to , which tie into predictive policing and can unjustly put people in jail. For hackers, data can be held ransom or manipulated for financial gain. For users? These days most of our online data is sold, manipulated, stolen, or in many cases all of the above. Often we’re left with annoying ads that follow us around or worse, our data exposed on the open web or used in malicious ways without our approval. There certainly aren’t any profits coming our way. In this all-digital age, we often forget all that data is actually ours. This precious online data—banking information, photos, what we search for, what we buy—is created by and unique to each of us. Without us online, this entire ecosystem does not exist. Big Tech’s profits would tumble, as would the number of data breaches. It’s concerning then that we users hold the keys to a door we can’t truly access. This is the terrifying state of online privacy in 2021. We’re at a tipping point in history. Waiting for foolproof legislation or big tech companies to suddenly have a change of heart will not work. Meanwhile, hacks, breaches, and rampant misuse of our data are reaching catastrophic levels. We have a decision to make: We can either take collective action to regain control of our online privacy, or we can continue down our current path of least resistance and lose it for good. The cascade of events that have led to this privacy tipping point stretches back millennia. Before the development of modern technology, the original privacy violators were largely governments and politicians. In ancient Rome, top political players built their own surveillance networks of cohorts that would alert them to the schemes of their rivals. In the Middle Ages, the Roman Catholic Church had its own powerful surveillance network to track and crack down on hearsay. In the late 18th century, the French Revolution saw half a million French nobles targeted by the new government’s “committees of surveillance,” who arrested those considered suspicious. And in the 1930s, IBM, perhaps the first “big tech” company, helped facilitate the Nazis’ genocide through the generation and tabulation of punch cards on national census data. The dawn of the digital age in the 1990s saw the swift rise of tech companies whose shiny new offerings came at a hefty price: our data. In contrast to the authoritarian surveillance practices employed by history’s governments, tech companies originally positioned their relationship with users as mutually beneficial. Their products and services were mostly free, which users gobbled up, which quickly led to the massive growth and user bases tech companies craved. We didn’t think too much about it. But what appeared to be a genuine and transparent relationship with Big Tech turned out to be anything but. A decade or so later we would learn that we’d been paying them since day one with our behavioral data—lucrative information about how we move around the internet and interact with digital services—and had already lost our privacy. The price we pay for their wares is not in dollars and cents, but in our data, our privacy, and our freedom, sold by Big Tech to the highest ad bidder. Big Tech has thus asked more and more from users over the years, and most of us have been giving them our most valuable currency (our data) with little or no thought. We , we fail to use the on the market, and the we use to protect ourselves is most often varying lengths of the numbers 1 through 10. The result: Far too much of our personal data sits outside of our control and in the hands of those who sell it, manipulate it, or steal it for profit. Consumers, you must take matters into your own hands. Legislation and hoping for a change of heart will not tip online privacy rights back into your favor. Neither will sitting idly by, either unmotivated or unaware of the assault taking place every second we’re online. We are at a critical tipping point in time. We know what happens with our data, we know the consequences, and we have the resources and tools to wrest back control of what is rightfully ours. In this most critical year, we can take two paths: One is easy and familiar but devastatingly costly. The other is harder but leads to true freedom and choice.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

American AI is unethical – they’ll establish a terrible global norm

Snider ’20 (Technology reporer of USA Today, “Clearview AI, which has facial recognition database of 3 billion images, faces data theft,” USA Today, 2/26/29) https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2020/02/26/clearview-ai-data-theft-stokes-privacy-concerns-facial-recognition/4883352002/

Facial recognition software firm Clearview AI, which has been criticized for scraping together a database of as many as 3 billion online images, has been hit with a data breach. The firm, based in New York, apparently saw its list of customers, which includes numerous law enforcement agencies, stolen, , which first reported the incident. The news site reported that it had obtained a notice sent to Clearview's customers that an intruder had “gained unauthorized access” to its customer list, the number of searches customers have conducted and other data. Clearview said in the notice that the company’s servers were not breached and that there was “no compromise of Clearview’s systems or network.” However, Clearview's attorney, Tor Ekeland, said in a statement sent to USA TODAY, "Security is Clearview's top priority. Unfortunately, data breaches are part of life in the 21st century. Our servers were never accessed. We patched the flaw, and continue to work to strengthen our security." Facial recognition spurs privacy concerns: The issue of facial recognition technology and privacy has been controversial lately. Student uproar over . An editorial in student newspaper described the plan as "a major breach of students’ privacy" that makes "students feel unsafe on a campus they are supposed to call home." Clearview attracted attention after that the startup had built a database of more than 3 billion images gathered from social media sites such as Facebook, YouTube, as well as payment site Venmo and other online destinations. The company notes on that it searches the open web – not private social media accounts – and markets its investigative tool only to law enforcement agencies and "is NOT available to the public." Federal and state law enforcement officials told The Times that they had used Clearview's app in solving cases from shoplifting to murder and child sexual exploitation cases. Clearview was founded by Australian technologist Hoan Ton-That and Richard Schwartz, an aide to then-New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, the Times reported, and counts Silicon Valley venture capitalist Peter Thiel among its investors. Clearview faces criticism: Since the report's publication, Google, Facebook, Twitter and Venmo demanding the company stop using its platforms for gathering imagery. “YouTube’s Terms of Service explicitly forbid collecting data that can be used to identify a person,” YouTube spokesman Alex Joseph said in a statement. “Clearview has publicly admitted to doing exactly that, and in response we sent them a cease and desist letter.” The New Jersey attorney general has banned police from using Clearview's app, , and the company also faces class action lawsuits in Illinois and Virginia. And Clearview is coming under scrutiny by some in the U.S. Congress. Rep. Patrick McHenry, R-N.C., has called for House Financial Services Committee chair Maxine Waters, D-Calif., to schedule a hearing on the company's data collection practices, . Sen. Edward Markey, D-Mass., who last month expressed concerns about Clearview's technology, strengthened his unease after Wednesday's report: "Clearview’s statement that security is its ‘top priority’ would be laughable if the company’s failure to safeguard its information wasn’t so disturbing and threatening to the public’s privacy,” he said in a statement. While the company said it had not been hacked, the incident raises concerns, he says. “If your password gets breached, you can change your password. If your credit card number gets breached, you can cancel your card. But you can’t change biometric information like your facial characteristics if a company like Clearview fails to keep that data secure," Markey said. "This is a company whose entire business model relies on collecting incredibly sensitive and personal information, and this breach is yet another sign that the potential benefits of Clearview’s technology do not outweigh the grave privacy risks it poses.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

US is the ultimate double standard with cybersecurity – violating democracy, power balance and privacy

Blunden and Cheung 14 (Bill Blunden, independent investigator, Violet Cheung, professor of psychology at the University of San Francisco, “Behold a Pale Farce”, Trine Day, ProQuest, April 17, 2014)//SW

NSA has been coming out with all these charges against China going after our secrets, our information, and so forth. It’s caused the Congress to give enormous amounts of money to NSA, this money for defensive use against the Chinese and so forth. What never comes out is the U.S. offensive capability against the rest of the world. The U.S. – there’s nobody that can even compare to the U.S. We’ve got an enormous Cyber Command. They’re expanding NSA’s secret city by a third to accommodate 14 new buildings, 10 parking garages, a new enormous supercomputer center – all this for this new, very secret Cyber Command. And it’s dedicated largely to offensive, to creating wars, not preventing wars. 21 Our leaders tend to paint the United States as being an innocent victim. However, more often than not the United States is a perpetrator. As the documents leaked by Ed Snowden confirmed, the focus of CYBERCOM isn’t on deterring attacks, it’s about launching them. In many instances these attacks are launched to acquire a strategic economic advantage and impose U.S. dominion abroad. In the end, it’s probably safe to assume that everyone is spying on everyone else. They always have and probably always will. Though at the same time, it’s also important to recognize that not all espionage programs are the same, and that scale matters. Given the amount of tax money our leaders throw at it, the United States, with its army of private sector contractors, steals secrets on a level both domestically and internationally that is unsurpassed. When it comes to breaking into networks and collecting sensitive information the United States is admittedly in a class all by itself. Journalist Glenn Greenwald elaborates on the repercussions of this fact: That the U.S. government – in complete secrecy – is constructing a ubiquitous spying apparatus aimed not only at its own citizens, but all of the world’s citizens, has profound consequences. It erodes, if not eliminates, the ability to use the Internet with any remnant of privacy or personal security. It vests the U.S. government with boundless power over those to whom it has no accountability. It permits allies of the U.S. – including aggressively oppressive ones – to benefit from indiscriminate spying on their citizens’ communications. It radically alters the balance of power between the U.S. and ordinary citizens of the world. And it sends an unmistakable signal to the world that while the U.S. very minimally values the privacy rights of Americans, it assigns zero value to the privacy of everyone else on the planet. 22 This double standard has serious consequences. It illustrates that U.S. leaders are unwilling to adhere to the values and principles that they claim to represent. Whistleblowers have exposed our political elite as untrustworthy. Having lost its moral authority in this domain, the United States cannot hope to name and shame cyber offenders. The ethereal bindings of soft power have dissolved, leaving only a dangerous example that other nations can follow.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

US-led AI destroys democracy, creates a fascist system—rise of far right groups in the US intensify

Ünver 18 – Dr. Unver is a member of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Digital Democracy Network, which is a global scientific community of leading scholars of technology and politics. Previously, he served as a social science fellow at Britain's national data science laboratory Alan Turing Institute, Oxford University's Center for Technology and Global Affairs, social sciences mentor at Oxford University's Cyber Security Doctoral Training Program, Jean-Monnet fellow at the University of Michigan, and the Ertegun Chair of Middle Eastern Studies at Princeton University. Prof. Ünver is the coordinator and director of the Summer Institute in Computational Social Science (SICSS) Istanbul, the oldest and longest-running social data science summer training program in Turkey.. He holds a Ph.D. in International Relations from the University of Essex and is currently a Governing Council Member of the International Studies Association (ISA). (Ünver, H. Akın. Artificial Intelligence, Authoritarianism and the Future of Political Systems. Centre for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies, 2018. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep26084. Accessed 13 Jul. 2022.)

The most immediate impact of A.I. that might reinforce the feudalistic tendencies of the digital space is to create a production system mimicking corporatism - namely, the reconfiguration of power relations through sectoral alliances between coder syndicates and guilds. This would entail the control of algorithm-building and maintaining structures that both state and private actors rely on, and the foundation of the future economic system. The corporatization of A.I. could reinforce power-centralization through the combination of corporations that monopolize modes of code and coder production that will disproportionately influence politics, military and science affairs. This will effectively generate a feudal network that minimizes political participation and representation, leading to the eradication of democracy. The Habermasian ‘algorithmic enclosures’ that are obscure and inaccessible will establish robust control mechanisms on the society and in turn, empower coder oligarchies and corporations in charge of them. The second alarmist trend in the popular mainstream is the idea that the A.I. will create a ‘fascist system’28 Cyber Governance and Digital Democracy 2018/9 over-centralized A.I.-based decision-making will create a hierarchy of repression in which control-oriented, top-down practices will restrict expression, engagement, oversight and political information-seeking behavior. These fears have been intensified with the rise of the far-right groups in the US and Europe in the last years, bolstered by Internet trolls, fake news, and bots. According to the conceptualization of Foucault29 and Canguilhem30, the way technology and science are deployed by fascist regimes snowball into a social force, bursting their initial utilitarian origins and take on a life of their own. Technologism then determines the bounds of rights and freedoms in a society, becoming the real political ideology in fascist regimes. In ‘techno-fascism,’ all aspects of social life are controlled with the purpose of maximizing scientific progress and technological advances that are in turn, used to exert newer forms of sectoral control over social life. Views that don’t conform or fully converge to the hegemonic ideology are taken out of the equation through imprisonment and death. Totalitarianism is different from authoritarianism in this context since the latter denotes the centralization of political power without the need to control thoughts and actions of all citizens through a revolutionary mechanism to change the human nature or the world at whole. An ‘A.I. fascism’ or totalitarianism, therefore, has to entail a bid to change human relations and social interactions; merely political control and centralization are not enough on their own

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

CCP economic decline leads to multiple scenarios for war

Carpenter, 15 [Ted Galen, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and a contributing editor at The National Interest, The National Interest, “Could China's Economic Troubles Spark a War?”, 9/6/15, , 6/24/16]JRO

Global attention has focused on the plunge in the Shanghai stock market and mounting evidence that China’s economic growth is slowing dramatically. Moreover, the contagion appears to be spreading, characterized by extreme volatility and alarming declines in America’s own equity markets. Those worries are compounded because there always have been doubts about the accuracy of Beijing’s official economic statistics. Even before the current downturn, some outside experts believed that Chinese officials padded the results, making the country’s performance appear stronger than it actually was. If China is now teetering on the brink of recession, the political incentives for officials to conceal the extent of the damage would be quite powerful. The focus on the possible wider economic consequences of a severe Chinese economic slowdown is understandable, since the ramifications could be extremely unpleasant for the U.S. and global economies. But we should also be vigilant about how such economic stress might affect Beijing’s diplomatic and military behavior. It is not unprecedented for a government that feels besieged to attempt to distract a discontented public by fomenting a foreign policy crisis. In Henry IV, Shakespeare pithily described that process as the temptation to “busy giddy minds with foreign quarrels.” China’s leaders likely feel increasingly uncomfortable. The implicit bargain that has been in place since the onset of market-oriented reforms in the late 1970s has been that if the public does not challenge the Communist Party’s dominant political position, the Party will deliver an ever-rising standard of living for the people. The bloody Tiananmen Square crackdown in 1989 was a graphic reminder of what happens if the Party’s position is challenged. However, until now, the economic portion of the bargain seemed secure, characterized by breathtaking, often double digit, rates of growth. It is uncertain what happens if the Party can no longer maintain its part of the implicit bargain, but it is likely that a dangerous degree of public discontent will surface. Beijing might refrain from deliberately provoking a major foreign policy crisis, since the Chinese economy depends heavily on export markets, and access to those markets would be jeopardized by war. However, the need to preserve and strengthen national unity and distract the public from mounting economic troubles is likely to impel Chinese leaders to adopt very hardline policies in at least three areas. And all of those situations entail the danger of miscalculations that could lead to war. One issue is the South China Sea. Beijing has made extraordinarily broad territorial claims that encompass some 90 percent of that body of water. China is pressing its claims with air and naval patrols and the building of artificial islands. Those policies have brought Beijing into acrimonious disputes with neighbors such as Vietnam and the Philippines, which have rival territorial claims, and with the world’s leading maritime power, the United States, which resists any manifestation of Chinese control over the South China Sea and the crucial commercial lanes that pass through it. The conditions are in place for a nasty confrontation. Chinese leaders have already stressed the country’s alleged historical claims to the area, and made it clear that it will not tolerate being subjected to humiliation by outside powers. Such arguments are designed to gain domestic support by reminding the Chinese people of the country’s long period of weakness and humiliation in the 1800s and early 1900s. A second issue is Taiwan. Beijing has long argued that Taiwan is rightfully part of China and was stolen from the country in the Sino-Japanese war in 1895. Although Chinese leaders have exhibited patience regarding the issue of reunification, relying in large measure on growing cross-strait economic ties to entice Taiwan to eventually accept that outcome, Beijing has also reacted very sharply whenever Taiwanese officials have pushed an agenda of independence, as during the administration of Chen Shui-bian from 2000 to 2008. The danger or renewed confrontation is rising, since public opinion polls indicate that the nominee of Chen’s old party, the pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party, will be Taiwan’s next leader. A new crisis in the Taiwan Strait would be extremely serious, since the United States has obligated itself to consider any Chinese efforts at coercion as a “grave breach of the peace” of East Asia. Yet there is little doubt that there would be widespread domestic support on the mainland for a stern response by the Beijing government to a Taiwanese attempt to enhance its de-facto independence. Indeed, there might be more political danger to the regime if it did not take a strong stance on that issue. The third possible arena for crisis is the East China Sea. China is increasingly adamant about its claims to the Diaoyu/Senkaku islands, which are under Japanese control. From China’s perspective, those islands were stolen by Imperial Japan at the same time that Tokyo took possession of Taiwan following the 1895 war. And ginning up public anger against Japan is never difficult. China just finished celebrating the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II, which is touted in China as “the Chinese People’s War of Resistance Against Japanese Aggression and the World Anti-Fascist War.” Recalling Japan’s invasion of China, and the resulting atrocities, was a prominent theme of the various commemorative events. But the animosity is not based solely on historical grievances. Anger at Japan over the ongoing East China Sea dispute and other matters has already produced anti-Japanese riots in Chinese cities, characterized by attacks on Japanese businesses and automobiles. There is a powerful incentive for Chinese leaders to take an uncompromising stance on the Diaoyu/Senkaku feud, confident that the Chinese people will back such a stance. All of this suggests that the United States and its allies need to proceed cautiously about dealing with China, especially on these three issues. Now is not the time to press a Chinese leadership that likely feels beleaguered by the country’s economic woes. The last thing we should do is give those leaders further temptation to distract the Chinese people with a foreign policy confrontation. Such a strategy entails the grave risk of miscalculation and escalation, and that would be a tragedy for all concerned.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – CCP Collapse !

China is winning the AI race now, BUT a sustained edge over the US is key – it’s key to the Chinese economy

Shen et al ’22 (Responsible for 4x China Analytics practice to ~100 data scientists, developers and business translators in ~2 years, “The next frontier for AI in China could add $600 billion to its economy,” QuantumBlack AI by McKinsey, 6/7/22) https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/quantumblack/our-insights/the-next-frontier-for-ai-in-china-could-add-600-billion-to-its-economy)

By 2030, AI could disrupt transportation and other key sectors in China, adding significant economic value—but only if strategic cooperation and capability building occur across multiple dimensions. In the past decade, China has built a solid foundation to support its AI economy and made significant contributions to AI globally. Stanford University’s AI Index, which assesses AI advancements worldwide across various metrics in research, development, and economy, ranks China among the top three countries for global AI vibrancy. 1 On research, for example, China produced about one-third of both AI journal papers and AI citations worldwide in 2021. In economic investment, China accounted for nearly one-fifth of global private investment funding in 2021, attracting $17 billion for AI start-ups. 2 Today, AI adoption is high in China in finance, retail, and high tech, which together account for more than one-third of the country’s AI market (see sidebar “Five types of AI companies in China”). 3 In tech, for example, leaders Alibaba and ByteDance, both household names in China, have become known for their highly personalized AI-driven consumer apps. In fact, most of the AI applications that have been widely adopted in China to date have been in consumer-facing industries, propelled by the world’s largest internet consumer base and the ability to engage with consumers in new ways to increase customer loyalty, revenue, and market valuations. So what’s next for AI in China?In the coming decade, our research indicates that there is tremendous opportunity for AI growth in new sectors in China, including some where innovation and R&D spending have traditionally lagged global counterparts: automotive, transportation, and logistics; manufacturing; enterprise software; and healthcare and life sciences. (See sidebar “About the research.”) In these sectors, we see clusters of use cases where AI can create upwards of $600 billion in economic value annually. (To provide a sense of scale, the 2021 gross domestic product in Shanghai, China’s most populous city of nearly 28 million, was roughly $680 billion.) In some cases, this value will come from revenue generated by AI-enabled offerings, while in other cases, it will be generated by cost savings through greater efficiency and productivity. These clusters are likely to become battlegrounds for companies in each sector that will help define the market leaders. Unlocking the full potential of these AI opportunities typically requires significant investments—in some cases, much more than leaders might expect—on multiple fronts, including the data and technologies that will underpin AI systems, the right talent and organizational mindsets to build these systems, and new business models and partnerships to create data ecosystems, industry standards, and regulations. In our work and , we find many of these enablers are becoming standard practice among companies getting the most value from AI. To help leaders and investors marshal their resources to accelerate, disrupt, and lead in AI, we dive into the research, first sharing where the biggest opportunities lie in each sector and then outlining the core enablers to be tackled first.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – Democracy !

Chinese development of AI is key – western led AI innovation will lead to economic devastation and imperialist wars

Feng 18 – Professor of law at Tsinghua University and one of China’s most prominent legal scholars. He spoke at the Berggruen Institute’s China Center workshop on artificial intelligence in 2018 in Beijing. (Xiang, The Washington post, “AI will spell the end of capitalism”, 5-3-2018, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theworldpost/wp/2018/05/03/end-of-capitalism/)//mj

BEIJING — The most momentous challenge facing socio-economic systems today is the arrival of artificial intelligence. If AI remains under the control of market forces, it will inexorably result in a super-rich oligopoly of data billionaires who reap the wealth created by robots that displace human labor, leaving massive unemployment in their wake.

But China’s socialist market economy could provide a solution to this. If AI rationally allocates resources through big data analysis, and if robust feedback loops can supplant the imperfections of “the invisible hand” while fairly sharing the vast wealth it creates, a planned economy that actually works could at last be achievable.

2022 Michigan Evidence
NEG – China AI Leadership Good – Classic HJV › 1nc – Democracy !

China is surpassing the US in AI dominance now – the plan flips the script

Smith 22, Aaron Smith, 1-6-2022, "How China surpassed the U.S. in the race for AI supremacy," USC Global Policy Institute, https://uscgpi.com/2022/01/06/how-china-surpassed-the-u-s-in-the-race-for-ai-supremacy/, accessed 7-15-2022

Nick Chaillan, the U.S. Department of State’s first-ever software chief,  in September 2021. He claimed that the United States had “no competing fighting chance against China in the next 15 to 20 years.”

China is currently winning the race toward global dominance in artificial intelligence. But how did China get so far ahead?

2022 Michigan Counterplan
Aff › AT: Ukraine CP › AT: Ukraine CP

A neutral Ukraine is not good

Aron 22[Leon, Leon Aron is the author of Roads to the Temple, Yeltsin, and many other books and essays. He is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute., “A Neutral Ukraine Is a Dangerous Idea”, 4/5/22, ]

But dropping sanctions under that circumstance would be a costly mistake. Unlike the Soviet Union’s rules for Finland during the Cold War, Putin’s conditions for the cessation of hostilities will not end with Ukraine’s neutrality.

After World War II, Moscow allowed Finland to keep its Western-style democracy and market economy in exchange for an implicit but inviolable pledge not to join NATO or Western economic and political bodies. Not coincidentally, Finland entered the European Union only after the fall of the Soviet Union. But relations between Finland and the Soviet Union during the Cold War differed enormously from those between Ukraine and Putin’s Russia today.