Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves New Threats

MMCC capacity checks CBW impacts

Rico Maderthoner, 5-7-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/certification-exercise-remi-2021-takes-shape-5072222, "Certification exercise REMI 2021 takes shape," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

The Multinational Medical Coordination Centre/European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) in Koblenz reaches the next milestone towards the main event in November.

The framework has been set since February. During a structured planning conference carried out per VTC from 26 to 28 April, the planning team around Lieutenant Colonel Andreas Godau and the participants filled with life the scenario already introduced in February. "One of the future core tasks of MMCC/EMC will be civil-military cooperation in cross-border crisis management, in particular with the organisations and institutions of NATO and the EU nations and establishments." With these words, the Director MMCC/EMC, Brigadier Dr Stefan Kowitz, at the same time describes the framework of the exercise.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves New Threats

MMCC key to address hybrid threats

Rico Maderthoner, 12-7-2020, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/resilient-response-2020-successfully-completed--4882638, "Resilient Response 2020 Successfully Completed," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

From 23 to 27 November 2020, the Multinational Medical Coordination Centre / European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) in Koblenz conducted the exercise Resilient Response 2020 (RERE 20). Fifteen nations had enrolled for the war game. Owed to the current Corona situation, this exercise was carried out only online.

All of the more than 70 participants in exercise RERE 20 agreed that communication is the key to success. During the three-day war game, representatives of international armed forces and authorities simulated their strategies and cooperation in the event of an epidemic/pandemic situation and exercised different responses to the outbreak of a highly contagious virus disease.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

SGD aff mod

Katherine Aguirre,, 6-21-2021, researcher at the Igarapé Institute. Gordon LaForge is a senior researcher at Princeton University and a lecturer at Arizona State University’s Thunderbird School of Global Management. Robert Muggah is a principal at the SecDev Group, a co-founder of the Igarapé Institute, and the author, with Ian Goldin, of Terra Incognita: 100 Maps to Survive the Next 100 Years. Twitter: @robmuggah Anne-Marie Slaughter is the CEO of New America https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/06/21/global-vaccination-covax-gavi-covid-19-pandemic-impact-hubs-public-private-funding-united-nations/, "Three Years Is Too Long to Wait for a Global Vaccine Rollout," Foreign Policy (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Ending the pandemic is just the first step to recovery. COVID-19 has triggered setbacks in virtually every one of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals, from reducing poverty and inequality to improving health and education. The pandemic has also accelerated urgent security challenges, from digital harms to military confrontation. If the current system of global cooperation fails to help the world recover, grievances and mistrust toward the United Nations and member states will intensify. If the world is to build back better—and develop the capability to address the looming crises of the future—then impact hubs are needed.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

MMCC cooperation triggers medical situational awareness

Rico Maderthoner, 3-29-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/milestone-for-future-cooperation-with-nato-5046516, "Milestone for future cooperation with NATO," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

With their signatures, the Directors of the Multinational Medical Coordination Centre / European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) and the NATO Centre of Excellence for Military Medicine (MILMED COE) on 18 March 2021 laid the foundation for the future cooperation of both organisations

The 5-page document outlines the major tasks of both organisations and their respective focus areas and responsibilities.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

US military cooperation will coordinate via MMCC

Rico Maderthoner, 5-25-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/multinational-coordination-element-expands-network-5085080, "Multinational coordination element expands network," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Through its recent agreement with the United States Army 30th Medical Brigade the Multinational Medical Coordination Center/ European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) is tightening its network of international contacts once again.

On May 11, 30th Medical Brigade Commander Colonel Jason Wieman and MMCC/EMC Director Surgeon General Dr. Stefan Kowitz signed the protocol for the assignment of a United States Army Europe and Africa (USAREUR-AF) Liaison Officer to MMCC/EMC in Koblenz. Brigadier General Mark Thompson, USAREUR-AF Command Surgeon General and functional superior to Colonel Wieman, spoke of an important and future-oriented step. He considers the MMCC/EMC as an important partner for the future of the Theatre Medical Command Europe.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

MMCC cooperation vital to EU/UN solvency layers

Michael Tomelzik, 5-9-2019, Bundeswehr Medical Service https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/closing-ranks-at-ehrenbreitstein-fortress--525906, "Closing Ranks at Ehrenbreitstein Fortress," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Previously, there were two different approaches to the cooperation between the military medical services of NATO and EU. On 3 September 2019, the most senior representatives of the medical services from 14 nations signed a declaration aimed at combining both approaches.

The declaration of Initial Operational Capability (IOC), of the Multinational Medical Coordination Centre/European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) marked the actual go-ahead of cooperation. "The event is so important because with their signature the most senior representatives of the medical services document their attachment and commitment to this important project of the medical services of NATO and EU", said Brigadier, Medical Corps, Dr Stefan Kowitz, Director MMCC/EMC.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

MMCC spurs EU-NATO coordination

Rico Maderthoner, 11-17-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/preparations-for-evaluation-exercise-completed-5264046, "Preparations for evaluation exercise completed," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Together with representatives of its member nations, final arrangements were made during the two-day online conference regarding the process and the coordination tasks to be performed by the MMCC/EMC. The MMCC/EMC will cooperate with military and civilian services of the EU and NATO.

In November, the MMCC/EMC will demonstrate that it can support and relieve its member nations as well as NATO and the EU by performing coordination tasks in the supranational environment.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

NATO resilience supports the EU and the UN

CCOE 2019 Civil-Military Cooperation Centre of Excellence (The Hague), “Resilience through Civil Preparedness A CCOE Info Sheet” https://www.cimic-coe.org/resources/fact-sheets/resilience-through-civil-preparedness.pdf, (ermo/sms, Acc:6-17-2022)

In paragraph 83 of the 2016 NATO Warsaw Summit Communiqué, it is stated that “NATO will continue to pursue cooperative security through partnership with relevant countries and other international organizations”. NATO’s main strategic partners for Resilience through Civil Preparedness are the European Union and the United Nations.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Expands coordination beyond NATO

NATO leadership is vital to civil preparedness and thus resilience

NATO, 7-9-2016, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_133180.htm, "Commitment to enhance resilience," Issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in Warsaw, 8-9 July 2016 (ermo/sms, Acc:6-17-2022)

We now face a broader and evolving range of military and non-military security challenges, which is the context for the Alliance’s long term adaptation. Being resilient against these challenges requires Allies to maintain and protect critical civilian capabilities, alongside and in support of military capabilities, and to work across the whole of government and with the private sector. It also requires the Alliance to continue to engage, as appropriate, with international bodies, particularly the European Union, and with partners.

To complement and enable our military capabilities, we will continue to improve civil preparedness. Noting that civil preparedness is above all a national responsibility, we will strive to achieve the agreed requirements for national resilience. We will protect our populations and territory by strengthening continuity of government, continuity of essential services and security of critical civilian infrastructure; and we will work to ensure that our national and NATO military forces can at all times be adequately supported with civilian resources, including energy, transportation, and communications. This will include NATO support to assess and, upon request, facilitate national progress.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves quickly

NATO coordination solves fast – MMCC wargaming exercises prove

Rico Maderthoner, 5-10-2022, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/largest-simulation-game-of-the-sanitaets-services-5406444, "Largest planning game of the medical services," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

The Multinational Medical Coordination Centre/European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) in Koblenz and the NATO Centre of Excellence for Military Medicine (NATO MILMED COE) in Budapest shared the success of the wargaming exercise, which focused on medical care and wound transport in the context of national and alliance defence.

From 02 April to 08 April 2022, the international wargaming took place in Balatonakarattya, Hungary, with a total of 144 military and civilian participants from 23 nations.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves Deterrence/Assurance

NATO medical cooperation expands interoperability and builds capacity – NATO says yes

Bundeswehr Medical Service, 2022, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/mmcc-emc-, "Multinational Medical Coordination Centre / European Medical Command," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Task of the Multinational Medical Coordination Centre / European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC) is to provide coordinating support to the medical services of NATO and EU. The experience made in the management of large-scale medical emergencies or the Ebola crisis has shown that the interdependencies between public health protection and external and internal security are increasing. A future core task of MMCC/EMC will be civil-military cooperation, in particular with the organisations and institutions of the EU nations and establishments. MMCC/EMC supports in the provision and assessment of the medical situation picture for NATO and EU, which is jointly developed with the nations and NATO/EU organisations.

The task spectrum covered ranges from cross-border crisis management to collective and national defence. A particular focus is on CBRN [chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear] medical defence and on the coordination of strategic, supra-national medical evacuation.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves Deterrence/Assurance

Resilence key to NATO deterrence

NATO, 7-9-2016, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_133180.htm, "Commitment to enhance resilience," Issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in Warsaw, 8-9 July 2016 (ermo/sms, Acc:6-17-2022)

We, the Heads of State and Government of the North Atlantic Alliance, stand united in our resolve to maintain and further develop our individual and collective capacity to resist any form of armed attack. In this context, we are today making a commitment to continue to enhance our resilience against the full spectrum of threats, including hybrid threats, from any direction. Resilience is an essential basis for credible deterrence and defence and effective fulfilment of the Alliance’s core tasks.

Our commitment is rooted in the North Atlantic Treaty. It is based on the indivisibility of our security and underpins our solidarity and our commitment to defend one another.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves Pandemics

NATO cooperation enhances domestic response via solidarity

Giovanna De Maio 2020 visiting fellow at GWU George Washington University, former visiting fellow Center for the United States and Europe (CUSE) at Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/FP_20201028_nato_covid_demaio-1.pdf, "," Brookings Institution (ermo/sms, Acc:6-17-2022)

A military alliance such as NATO is not a first responder in a health crisis, as most tasks must be implemented at the domestic level. However, given the impact and the spillover effects of COVID-19 on the very day-to-day operations of the alliance — military personnel are not immune from viruses — as well as on supply chains, and economies and societies around the world, it was paramount for NATO to take initiative both to protect its member states against malign actors and to offer crucial support in the spirit of solidarity.

In spite of these successful initiatives, the Operations Division of NATO headquarters in Brussels has admitted64 that the alliance was ill-prepared to handle such a crisis. As Rittimann noted, the alliance lacked its own means and political bandwidth to do more.65 For this reason, NATO and its member states should not miss the opportunity that the COVID-19 crisis offers to set up more structured plans to ensure readiness in crisis management. In particular, they should expand the concept of security to include the most pressing non-military global security threats: climate change, health risks, and social resilience against disinformation.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves Pandemics

NATO coordination enable dual use spillover

Rico Maderthoner, 11-19-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.bundeswehr.de/en/organization/bundeswehr-medical-service-/next-step-towards-interoperability-5264984, "Next step towards interoperability," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

This milestone describes the starting point of the implementation phase," says the director of the multinational element, Dr. Stefan Kowitz, looking ahead to the steps ahead. The capabilities for the brigades' medical forces will be built up gradually and in modules. Two lines of development are in the foreground. Building up the personnel capabilities with the appropriate training to operate a highly mobile medical unit as well as the necessary material supplements to enable a treatment outcome in line with NATO and civilian requirements.

Civilian and military usability as a factor

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Solves Pandemics

Collective biosurveillance checks another pandemic

Richard Hatchett, 6-29-2021, CEO of the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovation, CEPI & former BARDA, acting director U.S. Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority, https://www.csis.org/analysis/cepi-20-critical-inflection-point, "CEPI 2.0: A Critical Inflection Point," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Richard Hatchett, M.D.: Well, I think everyone in the world, frankly, has now had this common experience with the pandemic. And it doesn’t matter where you are on the political spectrum, it doesn’t matter, frankly, where you are on the spectrum in terms of the different interventions that we use. We’ve all been hugely impacted by the pandemic. None of us ever wants to see another pandemic again.

My colleague in the Bush White House, and actually now a CEPI board member, Rajeev Venkayya, has made the point that if we had in front of us an opportunity for $20 or $30 billion, which is probably what a global effort to accomplish the agenda that I talked about would cost over five or 10 years—if we had that opportunity to, you know, stop climate change, to—you know, to secure global temperatures below the 1.5 degree threshold, we would jump at that opportunity. And we would jump at it collectively as the world.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Vaccine focus key to solvency

Vaccine funding includes delivery, requiring a global infrastructure

Julie Gerberding, 6-29-2021, co-chair of the CSIS commission and executive vice president at Merck https://www.csis.org/analysis/cepi-20-critical-inflection-point, "CEPI 2.0: A Critical Inflection Point," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Julie Gerberding, M.D.: Well, we do have to finish the job in front of us. And I think everyone agrees that that has to happen. I think that there are some pieces to this plan that are upstream from where CEPI’s focus is with the G7, and then there’s some pieces that are downstream from there. The upstream pieces are really getting into a mindset, first of all, and then applying our science and technology to better be able to predict where spillovers will occur, and maybe preempt them. Which is very different from mitigation once you have an outbreak and it’s beginning to propagate.

So how do we move upstream? That means improving detection. It means using AI and geo-medicine tools to try to understand the human, animal ecological interface, the one health kind of space here. There’s a lot of science and a lot of collaboration. And it goes missing because the funding mechanisms don’t address the intersection of that space. The downstream piece that’s missing has to do with the deployment of vaccine. And we’re seeing now that even in some resource-limited environments where vaccines have been delivered they can’t be used because there is no infrastructure to get the vaccine into the arms of the people who need them. I mean, the world just doesn’t have adult immunization programs everywhere, like we do in the resource-rich countries.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Vaccine focus key to solvency

Both USA and vaccine focus are critical to solvency

Richard Hatchett, 6-29-2021, CEO of the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovation, CEPI & former BARDA, acting director U.S. Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority, https://www.csis.org/analysis/cepi-20-critical-inflection-point, "CEPI 2.0: A Critical Inflection Point," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

Richard Hatchett, M.D.: Well, I think there’s basically three, you know, areas that there’s good alignment. I mean, there’s good alignment around the scientific agenda. I mean, our adoption of the—you know, focusing on the prototype pathogens, you know, we’ve drawn from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Barney Graham and colleagues at the Vaccine Research Center have evolved that concept and, you know, have promulgated it. And we think they’re right. So the scientific approach, there’s already alignment. We’re ready to work hand-in-hand with the major science funding agencies within the U.S. to divide and conquer what is a very big R&D agenda.

There’s a political aspect, a political moment for the United States in terms of sort of its return to multilateral efforts. And I think, you know, this is a good opportunity for the U.S. to be forward-looking, to, you know, take a progressive and longer-term view, and to do that in a way that invites other global partners to participate. And CEPI, as a—you know, I mean, we aren’t a country. We don’t have a point of view. We’re just trying to solve one particular problem. And I think it’s a good way for the U.S. to join with the 25 or so other countries that are supporting CEPI in a global effort around countermeasures development for epidemic and pandemic threats.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions › Current MMCC isn’t enough

New steps help MMCC capacity

Rico Maderthoner, 11-1-2021, Commander J.G. (OF-3) Germany Navy, https://www.coemed.org/news-and-events/the-main-planning-conference-of-the-vigorous-warrior-22-casualty-move-22-combined-tabletop-exercise-has-been-concluded-in-budapest-hungary, "The Main Planning Conference of the Vigorous Warrior 22," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-20-2022)

The NATO Centre of Excellence for Military Medicine (NATO MILMED COE) and the Multinational Medical Coordination Centre/ European Medical Command (MMCC/EMC – more info at: Multinational Medical Coordination Centre / European Medical Command (bundeswehr.de) ), are combining their expertise and know-how to create a unique training event for the benefit of NATO’s medical realm.

The Main Planning Conference is a key milestone in the planning process which was demonstrated by the attendance of 64 participants with representatives from NATO and partner nations. During the main planning conference in Budapest, planned by the NATO MILMED COE as host and taking place from Oct. 20-2021 to Oct. 21-2021, both entities set the framework and goals for next year's event. "I am glad that the conference, despite the large number of participants, 64 from NATO and partner nations, worked smoothly and in accordance with the specifications," said the Dutch planning officer of the NATO MILMED COE, Lieutenant Colonel Jos Schepers.

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › NATO Resilience Extensions

CBR shortcomings ensure large-scale bioweapon attacks – the far right has unique access to materials and know-how.

Daniel Koehler and Peter Popella 17. Fellow at George Washington University’s Program on Extremism, Editorial Board Member of the International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) in The Hague and Founding Director of the German Institute on Radicalization and De-Radicalization Studies (GIRDS). Scholar of microbiology and specialist for infectious bacteria and antibiotic resistances, holds a B.Sc., M.Sc. and Ph.D. degree from the Eberhard Karls University Tuebingen, Germany. “BEWARE OF CBRN TERRORISM FROM THE FAR-RIGHT”. Small Wars Journal. Sept 19 2017. https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/beware-of-cbrn-terrorism-from-the-far-right

As the threat from domestic terrorism is clearly increasing, one must ask if violent tactics used by these attackers might develop beyond the use of explosives and guns. The vehicle attack in Charlottesville was an indication of that tactics diversification, even though this was not the first incident of its kind in the United States. As the Oklahoma plot shows, far-right terrorists might see themselves in some kind of competition for public recognition with Jihadist groups like ISIS, which could lead to a further escalation of tactics used for example with the deployment of chemical, biological, radiological or nuclear (CBRN) weapons. In fact, right-wing terrorists have for decades been attempting to develop and use chemical and biological weapons. This article aims to give a short overview on the history of such efforts, the potential for right-wing terrorism to use chemical and biological agents in the future, and how authorities can counter this threat.

A Look at the Cases

2022 SDI Affirmative
MSDI Vaccine Funding Aff › Case › Advantage 2 Biosafety

Food price spikes ends civilization

Ahmed, 15—citing models from Anglia Ruskin University’s Global Sustainability Institute Global Resource Organization Project (Nafeez, , dml)

The report explores the scenario of a near-term global food supply disruption, considered plausible on the basis of past events, especially in relation to future climate trends. The global food system, the authors find, is “under chronic pressure to meet an ever-rising demand, and its vulnerability to acute disruptions is compounded by factors such as climate change, water stress, ongoing globalisation and heightening political instability.” Three steps from crisis Lloyd’s scenario analysis shows that food production across the planet could be significantly undermined due to a combination of just three catastrophic weather events, leading to shortfalls in the production of staple crops, and ensuing price spikes. In the scenario, which is “set in the near future,” wheat, maize and soybean prices “increase to quadruple the levels seen around 2000,” while rice prices increase by 500%. This leads to rocketing stock prices for agricultural commodities, agricultural chemicals and agriculture engineering supply chains: “Food riots break out in urban areas across the Middle East, North Africa and Latin America. The euro weakens and the main European stock markets lose 10% of their value; US stock markets follow and lose 5% of their value.” The scenario analysis demonstrates that a key outcome of any such systemic shock to the global food supply — apart from “negative humanitarian consequences and major financial losses worldwide” — would be geopolitical mayhem as well as escalating terrorism and civil unrest.