Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 CNDI Topicality
Resolved – Legal

“Resolved” is legislative

Parcher 1 (Jeff Parcher 1, former debate coach at Georgetown, Feb 2001 http://www.ndtceda.com/archives/200102/0790.html)

Pardon me if I turn to a source besides Bill. American Heritage Dictionary: Resolve: 1. To make a firm decision about. 2. To decide or express by formal vote. 3. To separate something into constiutent parts See Syns at *analyze* (emphasis in orginal) 4. Find a solution to. See Syns at *Solve* (emphasis in original) 5. To dispel: resolve a doubt. - n 1. Firmness of purpose; resolution. 2. A determination or decision. (2) The very nature of the word "resolution" makes it a question. American Heritage: A course of action determined or decided on. A formal statement of a decision, as by a legislature. (3) The resolution is obviously a question. Any other conclusion is utterly inconceivable. Why? Context. The debate community empowers a topic committee to write a topic for ALTERNATE side debating. The committee is not a random group of people coming together to "reserve" themselves about some issue. There is context - they are empowered by a community to do something. In their deliberations, the topic community attempts to craft a resolution which can be ANSWERED in either direction. They focus on issues like ground and fairness because they know the resolution will serve as the basis for debate which will be resolved by determining the policy desirablility of that resolution. That's not only what they do, but it's what we REQUIRE them to do. We don't just send the topic committee somewhere to adopt their own group resolution. It's not the end point of a resolution adopted by a body - it's the preliminary wording of a resolution sent to others to be answered or decided upon. (4) Further context: the word resolved is used to emphasis the fact that it's policy debate. Resolved comes from the adoption of resolutions by legislative bodies. A resolution is either adopted or it is not. It's a question before a legislative body. Should this statement be adopted or not. (5) The very terms 'affirmative' and 'negative' support my view. One affirms a resolution. Affirmative and negative are the equivalents of 'yes' or 'no' - which, of course, are answers to a question.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Resolved – Legal

“Resolved” before a colon reflects a legislative forum.

AOS 4 (5-12, “# 12, Punctuation – The Colon and Semicolon”, http://usawocc.army.mil/IMI/wg12.htm)

The colon introduces the following: a.  A list, but only after "as follows," "the following," or a noun for which the list is an appositive: Each scout will carry the following: (colon) meals for three days, a survival knife, and his sleeping bag. The company had four new officers: (colon) Bill Smith, Frank Tucker, Peter Fillmore, and Oliver Lewis. b. A long quotation (one or more paragraphs): In The Killer Angels Michael Shaara wrote: (colon) You may find it a different story from the one you learned in school. There have been many versions of that battle [Gettysburg] and that war [the Civil War]. (The quote continues for two more paragraphs.) c. A formal quotation or question: The President declared: (colon) "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself." The question is: (colon) what can we do about it? d. A second independent clause which explains the first: Potter's motive is clear: (colon) he wants the assignment. e. After the introduction of a business letter: Dear Sirs: (colon) Dear Madam: (colon) f. The details following an announcement For sale: (colon) large lakeside cabin with dock g. A formal resolution, after the word "resolved:" Resolved: (colon) That this council petition the mayor.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Resolved – Legal

Resolved before a colon means legislative forum

ACC 13 # Army Career College. 12. Punctuation -- The Colon and Semicolon, United States Army, Warrant Officer Career College, Last Reviewed: December 19, 2013, http://usacac.army.mil/cac2/wocc/ColonSemicolon.asp

The colon introduces the following: A list, but only after "as follows," "the following," or a noun for which the list is an appositive: Each scout will carry the following: (colon) meals for three days, a survival knife, and his sleeping bag. The company had four new officers: (colon) Bill Smith, Frank Tucker, Peter Fillmore, and Oliver Lewis. A long quotation (one or more paragraphs): In The Killer Angels Michael Shaara wrote: (colon) You may find it a different story from the one you learned in school. There have been many versions of that battle [Gettysburg] and that war [the Civil War]. (The quote continues for two more paragraphs.) A formal quotation or question: The President declared: (colon) "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself." The question is: (colon) what can we do about it? A second independent clause which explains the first: Potter's motive is clear: (colon) he wants the assignment. After the introduction of a business letter: Dear Sirs: (colon)Dear Madam: (colon) The details following an announcement For sale: (colon) large lakeside cabin with dock A formal resolution, after the word "resolved:" Resolved: (colon) That this council petition the mayor.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Resolved – Legal

‘Resolved’ means to enact a policy by law

Words and Phrases 64 (Permanent Edition)

Definition of the word “resolve,” given by Webster is “to express an opinion or determination by resolution or vote; as ‘it was resolved by the legislature;” It is of similar force to the word “enact,” which is defined by Bouvier as meaning “to establish by law”.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Cybersecurity

Office of Management and Budget 2016

Office of Management and Budget, Managing Information as a Strategic Resource, Circular No. A-130, Washington, DC, 2016, p. 28, https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/omb/circulars/A130/a130revised.pdf.

‘Cybersecurity’ means prevention of damage to, protection of, and restoration of computers, electronic communications systems, electronic communications services, wire communication, and electronic communication, including information contained therein, to ensure its availability, integrity, authentication, confidentiality, and non-repudiation.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Cybersecurity

Webster

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cybersecurity Definition of cybersecurity :

measures taken to protect a computer or computer system (as on the Internet) against unauthorized access or attack

2022 CNDI Topicality
Biotechnology

Hilgartner 2001

Biotechnology is an umbrella term for an ever expanding area of research Hilgartner, Stephen. “Biotechnology.” International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2001.

Defining biotechnology poses challenges, for the word is less a tightly-defined, technical

term than a loose umbrella category, or even a slogan, that conveys— sometimes simultaneously—visions of unbounded progress and unregulated tampering with nature. Many authors have tried to capture biotechnology within their own well-crafted definitions, but these attempts cannot neatly contain this expanding network of activities and its increasingly dense connections to diverse social worlds. Although the word has a long history (Bud 1993), in most contemporary contexts biotechnology refers to a novel and growing collection of techniques, grounded in molecular and cell biology, for analyzing and manipulating the molecular building blocks of life. The term also designates products, such as pharmaceuticals or geneticallymodified foods, created using these techniques. At times, it refers not to products or techniques but to an economic sector or area of research.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Biotechnology

NUST ND

Norweigan University of Science and Technology defines biotechnology https://www.ntnu.edu/ibt/about-us/what-is-biotechnology

Biotechnology is technology that utilizes biological systems, living organisms or parts of this to develop or create different products.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Biotechnology

European Federation for Biotechnology – Biotechnology is the integrated use of biochemistry, microbiology, and engineering sciences

Bull Holt and Lilly 1982 A. T., Holt, G., and Lilly, M. D., Biotechnology: International Trends and Perspectives (Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development, 1982).

[Biotechnology is] “the integrated use of biochemistry, microbiology, and engineering sciences in order to achieve technological (industrial) application of the capabilities of micro-organisms, cultured tissue cells, and parts thereof” (3).

Biotech is the use of recombinant DNA methods or broadly defined as anything related to life sciences

2022 CNDI Topicality
Biotechnology

Merriam Webster

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/biotechnology

: the manipulation (as through genetic engineering) of living organisms or their components to produce useful usually commercial products (such as pest resistant crops, new bacterial strains, or novel pharmaceuticals)

2022 CNDI Topicality
Biotechnology

OECD

Oecd Statistics Directorate, 9-25-2001, "OECD Glossary of Statistical Terms," No Publication, https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=219

https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=219#:~:text=OECD%20Statistics,of%20knowledge%2C%20goods%20and%20services.

Biotechnology is defined as the application of science and technology to living organisms as well as parts, products and models thereof, to alter living or non-living materials for the production of knowledge, goods and services.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

AI – is four subfields: machine learning, natural language processing, artificial neural networks, computer vision

Hashimoto 2018 [Daniel A et al. “Artificial Intelligence in Surgery: Promises and Perils.” Annals of surgery vol. 268,1 (2018): 70-76. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002693]

Artificial intelligence (AI) can be loosely defined as the study of algorithms that give machines the ability to reason and perform cognitive functions such as problem solving, object and word recognition, and decision-making.1 Previously thought to be science fiction, AI has increasingly become the topic of both popular and academic literature as years of research have finally built to thresholds of knowledge that have rapidly generated practical applications, such as International Business Machine’s (Armonk, NY, USA) Watson and Tesla’s (Palo Alto, CA, USA) autopilot.2 Stories of man-versus-machine, such as that of John Henry working to death to outperform the steam-powered hammer3 , demonstrate how machines have long been feared yet ultimately both accepted and eagerly anticipated. Society proceeded to integrate simple machines into human workflow, and the resulting Industrial Revolution yielded a massive shift in productivity and quality of life. Similarly, AI has inspired awe and struck fear in people who now face a technology that can not only outperform but also potentially outthink its creators. With the Information Age, a shift in workflow and productivity similar to that of the Industrial Revolution has begun; and surgery stands to gain from the current explosion of information technology. However, as with many emerging technologies, the true promise of AI can be lost in its hype.4 It is, therefore, important for surgeons to have a foundation of knowledge of AI to understand how it may impact healthcare and to consider ways in which they may interact with this technology. This review provides an introduction to AI by highlighting four core subfields – 1) machine learning, 2) natural language processing, 3) artificial neural networks, 4) computer vision – their limitations, and future implications for surgeons. Subfields in AI AI’s roots are found across multiple fields, including robotics, philosophy, psychology, linguistics, and statistics.5 Major advances in computer science, such as improvements in processing speed and power, have functioned as a catalyst to allow for the base technologies required for the advent of AI. The growing popularity of AI across many different industries has attracted venture capital investment up to $5 billion in 2016 alone.6 Much of the current attention on AI has focused on the four core subfields introduced below. Machine Learning Machine learning (ML) enables machines to learn and make predictions by recognizing patterns. Traditional computer programs are explicitly programmed with a desired behavior (e.g. when the user clicks an icon, a new program opens). ML allows a computer to utilize partial labelling of the data (supervised learning) or the structure detected in the data itself (unsupervised learning) to explain or make predictions about the data without explicit programming (Figure 1). Supervised learning is useful for training a ML algorithm to predict a known result or outcome while unsupervised learning is useful in searching for patterns within data.7 A third category within machine learning is reinforcement learning, where a program attempts to accomplish a task (e.g. driving a car, inferring medical decisions) while learning from its own successes and mistakes.8 One can conceptualize reinforcement learning as the computer science equivalent of operant conditioning9 and is useful for automated tuning of predictions or actions, such as controlling an artificial pancreas system to fine tune the measurement and delivery of insulin to diabetic patients.10 ML is particularly useful for identifying subtle patterns in large datasets – patterns that may be imperceptible to humans performing manual analyses – by employing techniques that allow for more indirect and complex non-linear relationships and multivariate effects than conventional statistical analysis.11,12 ML has outperformed logistic regression for prediction of surgical site infections (SSI) by building non-linear models that incorporate multiple data sources, including diagnoses, treatments, and laboratory values.13 Furthermore, multiple algorithms working together (ensemble ML) can be used to calculate predictions at accuracy levels thought to be unattainable with conventional statistics.14 For example, by analyzing patterns of diagnostic and therapeutic data (including surgical resection) in the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) cancer registry and comparing data to Medicare claims, ensemble ML with random forests, neural networks, and lasso regression was able to predict patient lung cancer staging by using International Classification of Diseases (ICD)-9 claims data alone with 93% sensitivity, 92% specificity, and 93% accuracy, outperforming a decision tree approach based on clinical guidelines alone (53% sensitivity, 89% specificity, 72% accuracy).15 Natural Language Processing Natural language processing (NLP) is a subfield that emphasizes building a computer’s ability to understand human language and is crucial for large scale analyses of content such as electronic medical record (EMR) data, especially physicians’ narrative documentation. To achieve human-level understanding of language, successful NLP systems must expand beyond simple word recognition to incorporate semantics and syntax into their analyses.16 Rather than relying on codified classifications such as ICD codes, NLP enables machines to infer meaning and sentiment from unstructured data (e.g. prose written in the history of present illness or in a physician’s assessment and plan). NLP allows clinicians to write more naturally rather than having to input specific text sequences or select from menus to allow a computer to recognize the data. NLP has been utilized for large scale database analysis of the EMR to detect adverse events and postoperative complications from physician documentation17, 18, and many EMR systems now incorporate NLP – for example, to achieve automated claims coding – into their underlying software architecture to improve workflow or billing.19 In surgical patients, NLP has been used to automatically comb through EMRs to identify words and phrases in operative reports and progress notes that predicted anastomotic leak after colorectal resections. Many of its predictions reflected simple clinical knowledge that a surgeon would have (e.g. operation type and difficulty), but the algorithm was also able to adjust predictive weights of phrases describing patients (e.g. irritated, tired) relative to the postoperative day to achieve predictions of leak with a sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 72%.20 The ability of algorithms to self-correct can increase the utility of their predictions as datasets grow to become more representative of a patient population. Artificial Neural Networks Artificial neural networks, a subfield of ML, are inspired by biological nervous systems and have become of paramount importance in many AI applications. Neural networks process signals in layers of simple computational units (neurons); connections between neurons are then parameterized via weights that change as the network learns different input-output maps corresponding to tasks such as pattern/image recognition and data classification (Figure 2).7 Deep learning networks are neural networks comprised of many layers and are able to learn more complex and subtle patterns than simple one or two-layer neural networks.21 Clinically, ANNs have significantly outperformed more traditional risk prediction approaches. For example, an ANN’s sensitivity (89%) and specificity (96%) outperformed APACHE II sensitivity (80%) and specificity (85%) for prediction of pancreatitis severity six hours after admission.22 By using clinical variables such as patient history, medications, blood pressure, and length of stay, ANNs, in combination with other ML approaches, have yielded predictions of in-hospital mortality after open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair with sensitivity of 87%, specificity of 96.1%, and accuracy of 95.4%.23 Computer Vision Computer vision describes machine understanding of images and videos, and significant advances have resulted in machines achieving human-level capabilities in areas such as object and scene recognition.24 Important healthcare-related work in computer vision includes image acquisition and interpretation in axial imaging with applications including computer-aided diagnosis, image-guided surgery, and virtual colonoscopy.25 Initially influenced by statistical signal processing, the field has recently shifted significantly towards more data-intensive ML approaches, such as neural networks,26 with adaptation into new applications. Utilizing ML approaches, current work in computer vision is focusing on higher level concepts such as image-based analysis of patient cohorts, longitudinal studies, and inference of more subtle conditions such as decision-making in surgery. For example, real-time analysis of laparoscopic video has yielded 92.8% accuracy in automated identification of the steps of a sleeve gastrectomy and noted missing or unexpected steps.27 With one minute of high-definition surgical video estimated to contain 25 times the amount of data found in a high-resolution computed tomography image28, video could contain a wealth of actionable data.29, 30 Thus, while predictive video analysis is in its infancy, such work provides proofof-concept that AI can be leveraged to process massive amounts of surgical data to identify or predict adverse events in real-time for intraoperative clinical decision support (Figure 3).

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

AI for the purposes of NATO means data analytics, control, and decision support systems.

Amy Ertan Maggie Gray 2021 “An Overview of NATO Member States’ Strategies and Deployment” https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2021/12/Strategies_and_Deployment_A4.pdf

NATO’s Science and Technology Organisation (STO) defines AI relatively broadly, as ‘the ability of machines to perform tasks that typically require human intelligence’.8 The STO and the US’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) categorise AI innovation in several waves,9 including ‘first-wave’ or ‘knowledge-based’ AI and ‘second-wave’ or ‘data-based’ AI.10 → ‘First-wave’ AI (sometimes called ‘knowledge-based’ or ‘expert systems’) has existed for decades and is already integrated into a number of systems, both military and commercial. Knowledge-based AI systems rely on rules-based decision-making, facilitating automation by using expert knowledge hand-crafted by humans and a number of if-then statements to dictate their actions.11 Knowledge-based systems cannot reason about situations outside of their carefully crafted if-then knowledge, nor can they learn from their experiences, making them incredibly brittle.12 → ‘Second-wave’ or ‘data-based’ AI systems solve specific problems by using statistical models that are trained on large, sometimes pre-labelled data sets.13 Data-based AI includes machine learning (ML) and its sub-set deep learning (DL), which have seen considerable growth in recent years, in large part because of advances in deep learning neural networks. Machine learning algorithms include supervised, unsupervised, and reinforcement learning.14 Data-based AI models are entirely reliant on the data they are trained on. For example, a drone equipped with second-wave AI data analytics and surveillance technology may be able to identify a mobile intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) base from a photo by using a statistics-based image recognition15 model trained on pre-labelled images of mobile ICBM bases. Throughout this report the terms ‘autonomous’ and ‘AI’ will both be used. The authors acknowledge that to many familiar with the technical terminology, ‘autonomy’ and ‘artificial intelligence’ may be considered distinct terms. Agreement on what the terms ‘autonomy’ and ‘AI’ mean varies within academic literature, often in inconsistent ways. For instance, some no longer consider ‘first-wave’ systems, which do not use ML, to be AI. Scharre and Horowitz (2015) propose a basic definition of autonomy when writing about autonomous weapons. They write that ‘autonomy is the ability of a machine to perform a task without human input’, though they point out that this may or may not involve aspects of artificial-intelligence technology.16 Some also make a distinction between ‘autonomous’ systems and ‘automated’ or ‘automatic’ systems. For example, NATO’s Allied Command Transformation differentiates between ‘autonomous’ systems and ‘automated’ systems in the following way: → autonomous functioning refers to the ability of a system, platform, or software to complete a task without human intervention, using behaviours resulting from the interaction of computer programming with the external environment. Tasks or functions executed by a platform, or distributed between a platform and other parts of the system, may be performed using a variety of behaviours, which may include reasoning and problem solving, adaptation to unexpected situations, self-direction, and learning. Which functions are autonomous – and the extent to which human operators can direct, control, or cancel functions – is determined by system design trade-offs, mission complexity, external operating environment conditions, and legal or policy constraints. This can be contrasted with automated functions, which (although they require no human intervention) operate using a fixed set of inputs, rules, and outputs, the behaviour of which is deterministic and largely predictable. Automatic functions do not permit the dynamic adaptation of inputs, rules, or outputs.17 Given the frequent conflation of the terms ‘autonomy’, ‘autonomous systems’, and ‘AI’ in documents reviewed for this report, the authors’ terminology follows the tendency of a number of NATO members to define AI and autonomy as technologies capable of going further than automated behaviour. Within this report, the word ‘autonomous’ will generally be used to describe first-wave-like systems that physically operate on their own and respond to their external environments. The term ‘AI’ will be used to describe second-wave data analytics, control systems, and decision support systems. When describing specific military systems, the authors use the same terms used by the manufacturers or by third-party experts describing the system (for example, L3Harris describes its MAST-9 ASV as ‘autonomous’, so the authors describe the MAST-9 as ‘autonomous’). Within this scope, autonomous systems do not necessarily represent or contain AI-enabled or ML capabilities.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

NATO definition - short

Amy Ertan Maggie Gray 2021 “An Overview of NATO Member States’ Strategies and Deployment” https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2021/12/Strategies_and_Deployment_A4.pdf

NATO’s Science and Technology Organisation (STO) defines AI relatively broadly, as ‘the ability of machines to perform tasks that typically require human intelligence’.8 The STO and the US’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) categorise AI innovation in several waves,9 including ‘first-wave’ or ‘knowledge-based’ AI and ‘second-wave’ or ‘data-based’ AI.10 → ‘First-wave’ AI (sometimes called ‘knowledge-based’ or ‘expert systems’) has existed for decades and is already integrated into a number of systems, both military and commercial. Knowledge-based AI systems rely on rules-based decision-making, facilitating automation by using expert knowledge hand-crafted by humans and a number of if-then statements to dictate their actions.11 Knowledge-based systems cannot reason about situations outside of their carefully crafted if-then knowledge, nor can they learn from their experiences, making them incredibly brittle.12 → ‘Second-wave’ or ‘data-based’ AI systems solve specific problems by using statistical models that are trained on large, sometimes pre-labelled data sets.13 Data-based AI includes machine learning (ML) and its sub-set deep learning (DL), which have seen considerable growth in recent years, in large part because of advances in deep learning neural networks. Machine learning algorithms include supervised, unsupervised, and reinforcement learning.14 Data-based AI models are entirely reliant on the data they are trained on. For example, a drone equipped with second-wave AI data analytics and surveillance technology may be able to identify a mobile intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) base from a photo by using a statistics-based image recognition15 model trained on pre-labelled images of mobile ICBM bases.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

Cornell Law Definition – AI requires algorithms.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/artificial_intelligence_%28ai%29

Artificial intelligence or AI is the use of machine learning technology and  (the automated computational application of rules) to perform tasks, to make rules and/or predictions based on existing datasets. According to the notes of   artificial intelligence is defined as:

“Any artificial system that performs tasks under varying and unpredictable circumstances without significant human oversight, or that can learn from experience and improve performance when exposed to data sets.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

OECD and UN – AI is acquiring and applying knowledge and carrying out intelligent behavior.

https://www.unescap.org/sites/default/files/ESCAP_Artificial_Intelligence.pdf

There is no universally agreed definition of AI. According to OECD1 and UNCTAD2 , AI is defined as the ability of machines and systems to acquire and apply knowledge, and to carry out intelligent behaviour. This includes a variety of cognitive tasks (e.g. sensing, processing oral language, reasoning, learning, making decisions) and demonstrating an ability to move and manipulate objects accordingly. Intelligent systems use a combination of big data analytics, cloud computing, machineto-machine communication and the Internet of Things (IoT) to operate and learn. AI is a software and generally algorithm based although its functions (e.g. talking or playing a game) need to be reflected by physical substance (such as robots). In this sense, AI is like a human brain. To date, AI development has been generally focused on a selection of specific domains (see Table 1).

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

Applied use of AI can be extra T

Samoili et al 2020 [Sofia, Montserrat Lopez Cobo, Emilia Gomez, Giuditta De Prato, Fernando Martinez-Plumed, and Blagoj Delipetrev. "AI Watch. Defining Artificial Intelligence. Towards an operational definition and taxonomy of artificial intelligence." (2020).]

2.2.1 AI taxonomy The proposed taxonomy addresses political, research and industrial perspectives and aims to cover and classify the AI landscape, which consists of economic agents with R&D or industrial AI related activities. Therefore, this taxonomy is able to detect correspondingly a wide range of core AI related scientific subdomains (e.g. knowledge representation and reasoning, machine learning) and transversal topics such as applications of the former (e.g. robots, automated vehicles, etc.) or ethical and philosophical considerations. The taxonomy is presented as a reduced list of abstract high level domains and their related subdomains. These are meant to encompass the main theoretical AI branches, as well as AI related non-technological issues. The AI subdomains are represented by a list of keywords (see subsection 2.2.2), these will enable us to capture the AI activities carried out by economic agents, for further analysis of the AI landscape from a techno-economic perspective.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

National Defense Authorization Act – AI has five tenets (inclusive of all five tenets).

John S. McCain National Defense Authorization Act, Section 1051 for Fiscal Year 2019 https://www.nscai.gov/about/authorization-act/

(f) DEFINITION OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.—In this section, the term ‘‘artificial intelligence’’ includes each of the following:

(1) Any artificial system that performs tasks under varying and unpredictable circumstances without significant human oversight, or that can learn from experience and improve performance when exposed to data sets.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

HLEG definitions – AI is software and can include hardware that seeks to accomplish a goal by perceiving the environment through data acquisition and independent reasoning using such data.

Samoili, Sofia, Montserrat Lopez Cobo, Emilia Gomez, Giuditta De Prato, Fernando Martinez-Plumed, and Blagoj Delipetrev. "AI Watch. Defining Artificial Intelligence. Towards an operational definition and taxonomy of artificial intelligence." (2020).

HLEG definition of AI "Artificial intelligence (AI) systems are software (and possibly also hardware) systems designed by humans(2) that, given a complex goal, act in the physical or digital dimension by perceiving their environment through data acquisition, interpreting the collected structured or unstructured data, reasoning on the knowledge, or processing the information, derived from this data and deciding the best action(s) to take to achieve the given goal. AI systems can either use symbolic rules or learn a numeric model, and they can also adapt their behaviour by analysing how the environment is affected by their previous actions."

2022 CNDI Topicality
Artificial Intelligence

Minimum – threshold interpretation

Samoili, Sofia, Montserrat Lopez Cobo, Emilia Gomez, Giuditta De Prato, Fernando Martinez-Plumed, and Blagoj Delipetrev. "AI Watch. Defining Artificial Intelligence. Towards an operational definition and taxonomy of artificial intelligence." (2020).

Despite the multiple facets of AI, and consequently the lack of a common definition, there are a number of commonalities that we observe in the analysed definitions. This expression of common aspects suggests that they may be considered as the main features of AI: — Perception of the environment, including the consideration of the real world complexity (HLEG, 2019; European AI Strategy, 2018; EC JRC Flagship report on AI, 2018; Tsinghua University, 2018; Nakashima, 1999; Nilsson, 1998; Poole et al., 1998; Fogel, 1995; Wang, 1995; Albus, 1991; Newell and Simon, 1976). — Information processing: collecting and interpreting inputs (in form of data) (HLEG, 2019; European AI Strategy, 2018; EC JRC Flagship report on AI, 2018; Kaplan and Haenlein, 2018; Tsinghua University, 2018; Nakashima, 1999; Nilsson, 1998; Poole et al., 1998; Wang, 1995). — Decision making (including reasoning and learning): taking actions, performance of tasks (including adaptation, reaction to changes in the environment) with certain level of autonomy (HLEG, 2019; OECD, 2019; European AI Strategy 2018; EC JRC Flagship report on AI 2018; Kaplan and Haenlein 2018; Tsinghua University, 2018; Nilsson, 1998; Poole Mackworth and Goebel, 1998; Fogel, 1995; ISO/IEC 2382- 28, 1995; Wang, 1995; Albus, 1991; Newell and Simon, 1976). — Achievement of specific goals: this is considered as the ultimate reason of AI systems (HLEG 2019; OECD, 2019; European AI Strategy, 2018; Kaplan and Haenlein, 2018; Poole at al., 1998; Fogel, 1995; Albus, 1991; Newell and Simon, 1976).