Vaello Madero is net good—it will cost more for Puerto Ricans if overturned.
Romoser’21[James Romoser was the editor of SCOTUSblog from June 2020 to March 2023. He also wrote "Case Studies," a weekly column on legal affairs for National Journal. He came to SCOTUSblog with experience as both a legal journalist and a litigator.]James Romoser In equal-protection challenge, court will review Puerto Rico’s exclusion from federal safety-net program Nov 9, 2021 https://www.scotusblog.com/2021/11/in-equal-protection-challenge-court-will-review-puerto-ricos-exclusion-from-federal-safety-net-program/HZ
Finally, the justices undoubtedly will be thinking about how a ruling in Vaello-Madero’s favor might affect the numerous other federal laws that carve out differential treatment for Puerto Rico and other territories. The government argues that applying strict scrutiny in this case would disrupt numerous longstanding policies — including the handful of policies (such as exemptions from most federal income taxes) that benefit, rather than harm, Puerto Rico residents.