← SearchGeorgetown2024Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Perm: do the plan and mandate free access of standards.

Rosen 16 – former Professor of Law at Georgetown University, Director of the Administrative Law and Regulatory Practice Section at the American Bar Association, J.D. from Harvard Law School.

Jeffrey A. Rosen, “Report to the House of Delegates,” American Bar Association, https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/house_of_delegates/ebook-of-resolutions-with-reports/2016_hod_annual_meeting_electronic_report_book1.pdf#page=403

The resolution is intended to advance the general principle that citizens in a democratic society must be able to consult the laws that govern them. A corollary of that principle is that all citizens should have access in full to binding federal regulations. Regulations themselves are published in the Federal Register and are freely available online and at all federal depository libraries. Under present law as implemented, however, affordability problems often undermine the principle of public access with respect to material that has been included in such rules through incorporation by reference (IBR). The legislation proposed in the resolution would provide for a common baseline of availability by requiring agencies to provide an online source at which IBR material in such rules may be consulted without charge. The legislation would also provide for access without charge to material incorporated by reference into proposed rules while those rules are under consideration, so that citizens may comment on those proposals.

At the same time, federal law recognizes the valuable contributions that voluntary consensus standards make to the nation's regulatory system. Moreover, the purposes and public interest served by copyright laws also deserve recognition and support. Recognizing these concerns, the resolution's proposed legislation is aimed at ensuring meaningful citizen access without unduly impairing the ability and incentive of organizations to produce standards that can be incorporated by reference into federal regulations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.