No Russian econ impact---it’s resilient and normal amid Western intervention, and exports to Asia keep oil sales high.

In the spring of 2022, the competent financial managers at Russia’s central bank and finance ministry, forced to deal with unprecedented Western sanctions and a capital flight at almost three times the 2021 rate, drove down the exchange rate with temporary capital controls. An even bigger help was a jump in energy prices caused by Europe’s war-driven fears of a cold winter. Russia reaped its benefits until the actual cold season, which showed Europe could survive almost without Russian gas and with much less Russian oil than it had been using. The second quarter of 2022 saw the third highest exports since 1994, when the central bank started publishing trade balance statistics, but only the 60th highest imports: The massive sanctions hit left Russia’s private and state-owned companies struggling to keep their supply chains going.

Since that first shock, energy prices stabilized and a $60 price cap on Russian oil supplies came into force in December. Russia has found ways to keep oil exports stable and even increase seaborne deliveries despite a Western embargo: More than 70% of Russian crude supplies now go to India and China, compared with less than 20% before the invasion. But the price cap has weakened Russia’s negotiating position in Asia, and the fears of a fuel crisis have subsided. At the same time, exporters found ways to bypass the sanctions, switching to suppliers in China and South Asia and moving Western goods via Turkey and some former Soviet republics. In the first quarter of 2023, Russia’s balance of goods and services trade shrank to $22.6 billion from $91.4 billion in the second quarter of 2022.

Under these circumstances, and with significant Russian assets frozen in Western banks, Russian financial authorities have little reason to waste increasingly scarce foreign exchange resources on propping up the ruble, so they’ve been letting the currency slide. By coincidence, it briefly crossed the 100 ruble per euro level soon after Prigozhin made his move — but it isn’t as though the ruble fluctuated with the Putin regime’s immunity to insurrections by equally imperialist, and arguably even more lawless, domestic players.

On the other hand, the regime’s overall stability does depend on Russia’s economic performance, and above all on the system’s ability to support the passive majority of Russians through both public spending and access to jobs.

The budget has been suffering from the energy sanctions, the near-cessation of pipeline gas supplies to Europe and the accompanying export pivot to Asia. In the first six months of this year, Russian federal budget revenues dropped almost 19% in nominal ruble terms, and oil and gas revenues have halved. These drastic decreases make a devaluation necessary and increase the challenge of funding the public sector, which historically has lent Putin the most support.

“Patriots” have been pushing Putin for more than a year to get rid of his relatively liberal financial managers and move the country to a war footing. Russia, however, simply lacks the resources to make such a shift tolerable for the general population. Keeping vestiges of a free market system and relying on the ingenuity of small and medium entrepreneurs, who have accumulated a lot of experience under extreme conditions since the 1990s, allows the Putin system to avoid a catastrophic drop in living standards. Official unemployment is at 3.3%, a historic minimum. Russia’s large excess mortality from Covid-19 and the involvement of hundreds of thousands of new conscripts in the Ukraine invasion have made workers scarce and kept pay relatively high.

Some Western economists — notably Yale University’s Jeffrey Sonnenfeld and Steven Tian — insist that Putin is testing that resilience by “cannibalizing” Russia’s productive economy in order to fund the war. Tian recently wrote that Russia is “barely breaking even” on oil exports and suffering from an overall drop in commodity prices, which forces Putin to squeeze state companies and oligarchs with surprise windfall taxes. The Russian economy is “imploding,” Tian asserted, claiming that the country is “printing record amounts of money” and “forcing Russian banks and individuals to buy near-worthless Russian debt.”

Indeed, money supply was 25% higher year-on-year in June — another reason the ruble has been depreciating. Central bank data show low levels of government debt holdings by banks, though, and interest rates are far from their historic highs, allowing normal economic and consumer activity. Thanks to the ingenuity of finance officials and entrepreneurs, Russia remains economically resilient and can fund its wartime budget, which in 2022 reached a rather underwhelming 4.4% of GDP, a level it is expected to maintain this year. The agility of private companies in restructuring their supply chains and the strong labor market shouldn’t be underestimated — and since the fighting is only felt in a limited way in Russia’s border regions with Ukraine, most of the country still lives in a business-as-usual mode.