Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Automation Good

Automation alleviates inequality by increasing job efficiency and access to healthcare and education.

Prakash ’23. [ Prarthana is an intern on the news team covering tech, A.I., and other trending stories. She graduated with a master's in business and economic reporting from New York University and has previously worked at Bloomberg and CNBC.] “Bill Gates says the ‘Age of AI has begun’ and it could either reduce inequality or make it even worse.” March 21st. 2023. https://fortune.com/2023/03/21/bill-gates-age-of-a-i-has-begun-inequity-productivity-chatgpt/

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates is famously optimistic about artificial intelligence and its promise to speed up innovation. He considers A.I. tools such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT chatbot to be one of two technologies that have been truly revolutionary (the other example was with graphic user interface, or digital icons and buttons, in computing).  Now Gates says the “age of A.I. has begun” and that it will not just improve productivity but also help fix societal problems like inequity. He thinks the technology can free resources and improve access to healthcare and education in countries that lack it if governments and philanthropies introduce the right policies and direct funds where they are most needed. “I’ve been thinking a lot about how A.I. can reduce some of the world’s worst inequities,” Gates wrote in a blog post Tuesday. “For one thing, they’ll help health-care workers make the most of their time by taking care of certain tasks for them—things like filing insurance claims, dealing with paperwork, and drafting notes from a doctor’s visit.”  Gates pointed out that a number of developing countries struggle with attracting enough doctors, which often worsens inequities between the wealthy and the disadvantaged. If every healthcare professional has access to A.I. tools to better advise patients on the best course of action, a lot more people in need can be served, he says. Meanwhile, in education, A.I. can assist with training students and help them get higher test scores.  Instituting such systems would take years of testing and persistent efforts by governments, philanthropies, and businesses for the A.I. to be part of the solution instead of worsening the problem, Gates said. In that way, the benefits would be accessible to all and not just the well-off who can afford to use such technologies. “Governments and philanthropy will need to play a major role in ensuring that it reduces inequity and doesn’t contribute to it. This is the priority for my own work related to A.I.,” Gates wrote. The potential of A.I. to solve problems affecting entire countries and communities comes with its own set of threats, and Gates acknowledges the technology is still limited. “People will need to see evidence that health A.I.s are beneficial overall, even though they won’t be perfect and will make mistakes,” Gates wrote. “A.I.s have to be tested very carefully and properly regulated, which means it will take longer for them to be adopted than in other areas.” A.I. can sometimes fumble or hallucinate by returning inaccurate or fictitious information and becoming a threat in the hands of wrong people who misuse it, he said. Then, of course, there is the possibility of A.I. running amok and becoming a threat to humans.  Despite these risks, Gates still thinks A.I. technology has great potential. “Entire industries will reorient around it. Businesses will distinguish themselves by how well they use it,” he wrote.  The billionaire philanthropist has long supported A.I. and advocated that its benefits far outweigh its dangers. For one, he doesn’t see A.I. as a threat to jobs. If anything, it could improve how people work by increasing efficiency, he says. As the person who helped to start a computer revolution half a century ago, which also sparked similar concerns about killing jobs, he said A.I. ‘s development is “every bit as important as the PC, as the internet.” Earlier this year, during a Reddit Ask Me Anything session, he touted A.I. as a tool that “gives a glimpse of what is to come.”  It’s normal for people to raise concerns about any revolutionary technology, Gates said, but he added that A.I. is just one such example and that it can be used to accomplish real change.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Populism Low

No inherency: Populism decreasing in the squo—Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has demonized the political movement.

Sierakowski ’23. [ Sławomir Sierakowski, founder of the Krytyka Polityczna movement, is a senior fellow at the German Council on Foreign Relations.] “Russian Aggression is Undermining Populism.” January 17, 2023. https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.project-syndicate.org%2Fcommentary%2Frussia-war-undermine-western-populists-by-slawomir-sierakowski-2023-01%3Fbarrier%3Daccesspaylog 

WARSAW – Russia’s war in Ukraine has affected political life in countries around the world, and this influence has been greater in the countries that are politically closest not to Ukraine but to Russia. Because Ukraine is a democracy and Russia is an authoritarian kleptocracy, the war has highlighted a fundamental clash between alternative political systems. This dynamic raises the stakes considerably, because a military defeat for the democracy could be an invitation to dictators elsewhere to pursue their own conquests. Fortunately, as the war has dragged on, the specter of populism has receded in Europe, where it has been overshadowed by the larger threat of a Russia victory. While those populists with pro-Russian leanings have been marginalized, those who have moderated and come out in support of Ukraine have been welcomed back into the fold, despite having spent years undermining democracy at home. For example, before the Russian invasion, Polish President Andrzej Duda was receiving a cold shoulder just about everywhere in the West. Yet his staunch support of Ukraine has turned him into a key participant in major transatlantic and European meetings, and an important partner to anti-populist Western politicians, not least US President Joe Biden. At the same time, Duda himself has become less populist. Never an independent thinker or politician, he now takes his cues from the American embassy, rather than from Law and Justice (PiS) party leader Jarosław Kaczyński, to whom he owes his current position. Duda seems to have concluded that Kaczyński cannot hope to reward him with the kind of international profile that the Americans can. Meanwhile, pro-Russian populists have fallen out of favor almost everywhere. The notable exception is Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, who has long convinced Hungarian voters that their country can occupy the best of all possible economic worlds by juggling relations with Russia, China, and the European Union. But even Orbán has had to soften his position. He has not dared to block the bulk of Western sanctions against Russia, because he knows that he must play nice with the EU to receive COVID recovery-package funds that have been withheld as a result of his rule-of-law violations. Orbán is thus in limbo – neither a pariah nor a partner to leaders in Washington, London, or even Berlin. But the previously ironclad Kaczyński-Orbán axis is finished. Poland is supplying Ukraine with every kind of weapon, including more than 200 tanks; and it has just declared that it will be the first country to furnish German Leopard 2s. By contrast, Hungary not only refuses to help Ukraine, but is also transmitting Russian propaganda through its government-controlled media channels. As a result, relations between Warsaw and Budapest have chilled, with Kaczyński even criticizing Orbán directly. “We can’t cooperate as before,” he complains: “If Prime Minister Orbán says he doesn’t see exactly what happened in Bucza [Bucha, the site of Russian atrocities early in the war], he should be advised to go to an ophthalmologist.” When it comes to military, territorial, or economic bargaining power, Orbán cannot hope to compete with Turkey’s illiberal president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. While Orbán is still grasping for crumbs from larger powers’ tables, Erdoğan’s international standing has grown overnight. Western leaders must give him what he wants to secure Finland and Sweden’s entry into NATO, and the Kremlin must work with him to prevent Turkey from joining the sanctions and embargoes on Russian raw materials, goods, and technologies. Turkey’s relations with Russia do not prevent it from having good relations with Ukraine. It is an open secret that Turkey is providing Ukraine with more military support than it lets on. And it was Turkey that negotiated the prisoner exchanges and limited ceasefires needed to unblock Ukrainian exports through the Black Sea. Importantly, while Ukraine’s defeat is not in Turkey’s interest, a total Russian defeat also is not in its interest. A diminished Russia would reduce Turkey’s clout within NATO, and Turkey is also an economic beneficiary of the sanctions against Russia (despite the loss of millions of regular tourists from Russia and Ukraine). With Erdoğan behaving like a more responsible global actor, he may have markedly improved his chances of winning re-election this spring, despite an economic crisis and rampant inflation that his own bizarre policies helped cause. While individual populists have either moderated their positions or been marginalized, the broader “populist international” has become more fractured with the loss of its Russian patron. Western politicians can no longer walk around in pro-Putin t-shirts, as the Italian nationalist leader Matteo Salvini once did, or borrow money from Russian banks, as the French right-wing leader Marine Le Pen’s party has done. Pro-Russian and anti-NATO views are no longer acceptable. In 2022, the German pro-Russian parties Alternative für Deutschland and Die Linke lost local elections across the board. Populists also suffered losses in elections in the United States and France, and Russia’s war of aggression was certainly one reason. Candidates backed by former US President Donald Trump – an open admirer of Putin – were roundly defeated in the US midterms. And in the French presidential and parliamentary elections last spring, Le Pen and the left-wing leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s sympathies for Russia did not go unnoticed. If the pro-Russian populist former Czech prime minister Andrej Babiš loses this week’s presidential election to Petr Pavel, the former head of NATO’s Military Committee, that, too, will be partly because of Russia’s war. But we should remain only cautiously optimistic. The new year could always bring a trend reversal. If fatigue with the refugee crisis and high inflation deepens, today’s discredited populists will be the natural beneficiaries.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Politics DA › Politics Link

Degrowth is political suicide – Even modest policies require drastic reduction in income to most of the population, receive no support

Branko Milanovic, 2-23-2021, Branko Milanovic obtained his Ph.D. in economics (1987) from the University of Belgrade with a dissertation on income inequality in Yugoslavia. He served as lead economist in the World Bank’s Research Department for almost 20 years, leaving to write his book on global income inequality, Worlds Apart (2005). He was a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington (2003-2005) and has held teaching appointments at the University of Maryland (2007-2013) and at the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University (1997- 2007). He was a visiting scholar at All Souls College in Oxford, and Universidad Carlos III in Madrid (2010-11)."Degrowth: Solving the Impasse by Magical Thinking," Global Policy Journal, https://www.globalpolicyjournal.com/blog/23/02/2021/degrowth-solving-impasse-magical-thinking

Now degrowers are not irrational people. The reason why they are pushed in this magical corner is because when they try to “do the numbers” they are led to an impasse. They do not want to allow for significant increase in world GDP because it will, even if decoupling (of which they are skeptical) happens, drive energy emissions too high. If one wants to keep world GDP more or less as now one must (A) “freeze” today’s global income distributions so that some 10-15% of the world population continue to live below the absolute poverty line, and one-half of the world population below $PPP 7 dollars per day (which is, by the way, significantly below Western poverty lines). This is however unacceptable to the poor people, to the poor countries, and even to degrowers themselves.

Thus they must try something else: introduce a different distribution (B) where everybody who is above the current mean world income ($PPP 16 per day) is driven down to this mean, and the poor countries and people are, at least for a while, allowed to continue growing until they too achieve the level of $PPP 16 per day. But the problem with that approach is that one would have to engage in a massive reduction of incomes for all those who make more than $PPP 16 which is practically all of the Western population. Only 14% of the population in Western countries live at the level of income less than the global mean. This is probably the most important statistic that one should keep in mind. Degrowers thus need to convince 86% of the population living in rich countries that their incomes are too high and need to be reduced. They would have to preside over economic depressions for about a decade, and then let the new real income stay at that level indefinitely. (Even that would not quite solve the problem because in the meantime, many poor countries would have reached the level of $PPP 16 per day and they too would have to be prevented from growing further.) It is quite obvious that such a proposition is a political suicide. Thus degrowers do not wish to spell it out.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › ICCAT CP › 1NC

Iccat solves – They’re the only agency recognized by Japan and other prominent fishing countries

David Jolly and John M. Broder, 3-18-2010, has more than 1,600 bylined articles at nytimes.com and countless more from AP-Dow Jones. Has worked as an editor with top reporters at International Herald Tribune, New York Times and Bloomberg BNA. joined the editorial board at the start of 2018. He most recently served as deputy climate editor and director of news surveys, with responsibility for overseeing the New York Times Poll and polling analysis served as the Los Angeles bureau chief, Washington editor and White House correspondent during the Clinton administration. "U.N. Rejects Export Ban on Atlantic Bluefin Tuna," New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/19/science/earth/19species.html?src=sch&pagewanted=all

The rejection of the bluefin proposal was a clear victory for the Japanese government, which had vowed to go all out to stop the measure or else exempt itself from complying with it. Japan, which consumes nearly 80 percent of the bluefin catch, argued that the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas, or Iccat, should be responsible for regulating the fishery, not the United Nations. European Union nations, whose fleets are most responsible for the overfishing of bluefin, abstained from voting in the second round after their own watered-down proposal was rejected.

American officials expressed disappointment in the vote, but said they would keep trying in various international forums to protect the tuna and the bears.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › ICCAT CP › 1NC

Japan key to bluefin tuna – They consume the vast majority of it, and must be part of efforts at conservation

Justin McCurry, 4-1-2017, Tokyo Correspondent for The Guardian and other news orgainization "Japan to exceed bluefin tuna quota amid warnings of commercial extinction," Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/apr/24/japan-criticised-exceed-bluefin-tuna-fishing-quota

Conservation groups have called on Japan to abide by international agreements to curb catches of Pacific bluefin tuna after reports said the country was poised to exceed an annual quota two months early – adding to pressure on stocks that have already reached dangerously low levels.

Japan, by far the world’s biggest consumer of Pacific bluefin, has caused “great frustration” with its failure to abide by catch quotas intended to save the species from commercial extinction, said Amanda Nickson, the director of global tuna conservation at Pew Charitable Trusts.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › Impact

Miscalc, escalation inevitable once war starts – US and China cross escalation thresholds to pressure the other even if they try to limit conflict, causes nuclear war

Fiona S. Cunningham, 10-31-2020, Fiona Cunningham is Assistant Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania. She is also a Faculty Fellow at Perry World House and affiliated with the Center for the Study of Contemporary China and the Christopher H.. Browne Center for International Politics at the University of Pennsylvania. Fiona received her Ph.D. in Political Science from MIT in 2018. She holds a Bachelor of Arts from the University of New South Wales and a Bachelor of Laws from the University of Sydney, both with first class honors. "The Maritime Rung on the Escalation Ladder: Naval Blockades in a US-China Conflict," Security Studies, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09636412.2020.1811462

Even if both China and the United States intend to fight a limited war only, they may cross salient escalation thresholds to pressure each other to negotiate an end to the war and avoid a stalemate. Salient escalation thresholds include using nuclear weapons, attacking each other’s homelands, involving third parties, and mobilizing all available resources of the conflict, among others.Footnote35 Crossing those thresholds would push a limited war closer to an unlimited war that would cause disproportionate destruction, given the stakes for the United States.Footnote36 PLA writings suggest Chinese leaders are sensitive to the cost of achieving their limited war aims as well, although it is unclear whether China views thresholds other than nuclear use as salient.Footnote37 Washington might cross these escalation thresholds to coerce Beijing to accept a US victory, Beijing might cross them to prevent an imminent defeat or vice versa. Either country might cross these thresholds to pressure the other to the bargaining table.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › I/L

US industrial base key to deterrence – DoD investment in missile stockpiles prevents war with China

Stacie Pettyjohn and Hannah Dennis, 6-28-2023, Stacie Pettyjohn is a Senior Fellow and Director of the Defense Program at CNAS. Her areas of expertise include defense strategy, posture, force planning, the defense budget, and wargaming. Prior to joining CNAS, Pettyjohn spent over 10 years at the RAND Corporation as a political scientist. She was a volunteer on the Biden administration’s defense transition team. PhD and an MA in foreign affairs from the University of Virginia and a BA in history and political science from the Ohio State University. Hannah Dennis is a Research Associate for the Defense Program at CNAS where she also supports the CNAS Gaming Lab. Before CNAS, Dennis worked as a research assistant for Dr. Thomas G. Mahnken while she pursued her master’s degree at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS). Dennis interned in the Office of the Secretary of Defense and the Department of Commerce Bureau of Industry and Security while studying international relations at American University. “Production Is Deterrence”, Center for a New American Security, https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/production-is-deterrence

To deter and—if deterrence fails—defeat China, the DoD needs large stockpiles of standoff missiles, maritime strike weapons, and layered air and missile defenses. The authors conclude that after years of underinvestment, the DoD is buying more long-range and medium-range missiles, which would be essential in a China war fight. While historically the Pentagon has overinvested in bombs and missiles to attack targets on the land and neglected antiship weapons, the FY24 budget saw a notable uptick in air-launched antiship weapons. For the past decade, the DoD has consistently invested in air defenses, but its purchases have focused on expensive ballistic missile defense interceptors, while neglecting cruise missile defenses. The FY24 budget reverses this trend.

Additionally, the DoD is investing in PGMs to arm Ukraine and replenish American and allied stores of weapons that are needed to counter Russia. Except for surface-to-air missiles, the weapons for Ukraine are relatively short-range land-attack PGMs that U.S. forces do not need in the Indo-Pacific. A large portion of the funding for these weapons is coming from Ukraine supplemental appropriations, not the base defense budget. Supplemental appropriations are also resourcing significant investments in U.S. production lines, but the DoD has made only moderate progress rebuilding American stockpiles of the PGMs given to Ukraine.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › I/L

Chinese overconfidence causes miscalc, war – Narrative of “American decline” leads to greater confrontation between China and US

Jude Blanchette and Seth Jones, 1-6-2021, Jude Blanchette holds the Freeman Chair in China Studies at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). His book, China’s New Red Guards: The Return of Radicalism and the Rebirth of Mao Zedong, was published by Oxford University Press in 2019. Seth G. Jones is Senior Vice President and Director of the International Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). His most recent book, Three Dangerous Men: Russia, China, Iran, and the Rise of Irregular Warfare, will be published in 2021 by W.W. Norton, "Beijing’s New Narrative of U.S. Decline," Center for Strategic and International Studies, https://opensource.csis.org/features/beijing-narrative-us-decline/

But the consolidation of the "American decline" narrative in China, coupled with the increasingly restrictive public square and state-controlled media, means that space to challenge or refine this perspective is shrinking. The more this view becomes official dogma, the more likely Beijing is to overestimate U.S. decline.

The U.S. economy has already started to rebound, with some economists projecting 4.3 percent growth in 2021 following a contraction of 2.5 percent in 2020. As of June 24, 2021, more than 46 percent of the U.S. population has been fully vaccinated, whereas China is not expecting to reach that percentage for at least another month. In addition, the United States continues to outspend China on defense ($738 billion for the United States compared to $193 billion for China in 2020) and research and development (3.1 percent for the United States compared to 2.2 percent for China in 2019)—hardly signs of U.S. decline. A flurry of high-level U.S. meetings over the past several months, most recently at the G7 Summit in the United Kingdom, also indicate that the United States is strengthening its relations with partners in Europe and Asia, including through the Quad, which includes the United States, Japan, India, and Australia.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › Link

Degrowth fails and causes war – Implementation in a single country can’t solve and leads to geopolitical upheaval

Matthias Schmelzer et al, Aaron Vansintjan and Andrea Vetter, 2022, economic historian, social theorist and climate activist. He works at Friedrich-Schiller University of Jena, co-founder of Uneven Earth, a website focusing on ecological politics. He has been published in The Guardian, Briarpatch Magazine, Red Pepper, Truthout, Open Democracy, and The Ecologist, transformation researcher, activist and journalist, using degrowth, commons and critical eco-feminism as tools. She teaches transformation design at Braunschweig University of Art. She is editor of the magazine Oya and lives in and is co-founder of the House of Change, a transregional rural space for art, learning and co-creation in Eastern Germany, "The Future is Degrowth: A Guide to a World Beyond Capitalism", Verso Books, https://leftychan.net/leftypol/src/1667398158427.pdf

The combination and interplay of interstitial strategies, implementing nonreformist reforms, and building counter-hegemony is our humble proposal as to how we might best conceptualize the transformation to a degrowth society. A common feature in these strategies is that proponents of degrowth are not waiting for a distant future ‘after the revolution’ but aiming to change things here and now. Another common feature is that the diversity of approaches is not seen as a problem but as enriching and complementary. 51 But the challenges are enormous, especially in view of the increasingly acute socio-ecological crises and the growing threat from authoritarian nationalist movements, which promise false solutions to the problems of the growth society. Not only is this transformation diametrically opposed to the interests of capitalist enterprises and the richest groups and individuals, as well as to fossil capital and the fascist movements defending it – since it aims to drastically limit or abolish the possibilities for exploitation and accumulation; it also contradicts the interests of national governments, which are fundamentally geared to and existentially dependent on strengthening competitiveness and economic growth. And, finally, not only is the monopoly over the legitimate use of force – held by growth-oriented states – an enormous challenge; potential upheavals in geopolitical relations also present a serious problem. If degrowth were implemented in a single country, it would likely lead to capital flight, capital strikes, geopolitical tensions, and possibly even armed conflicts.52

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › UQ

US-China deeply interdependent – Trillions of dollars across every sector bind the two economies together

Ryan Hass, 8-12-2021, Director – John L. Thornton China Center, Senior Fellow – Foreign Policy, Center for East Asia Policy Studies, John L. Thornton China Center, Chen-Fu and Cecilia Yen Koo Chair in Taiwan Studies "The “new normal” in US-China relations: Hardening competition and deep interdependence," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-new-normal-in-us-china-relations-hardening-competition-and-deep-interdependence/

At the same time, bilateral competition between the United States and China also is intensifying. Even so, rising bilateral friction has not – at least not yet – undone the deep interdependencies that have built up between the two powers over decades.

In the economic realm, trade and investment ties remain significant, even as both countries continue to take steps to limit vulnerabilities from the other. For example, Chinese regulators have been asserting greater control over when and where Chinese companies raise capital; Beijing’s recent probe of ride-hailing app Didi Chuxing provides but the latest example. China’s top leaders have been emphasizing the need for greater technology “self-sufficiency” and have been pouring billions of dollars of state capital into this drive. Meanwhile, U.S. officials have been seeking to limit American investments from going to Chinese companies linked to the military or surveillance sectors. The Security and Exchange Commission’s scrutiny of initial public offerings for Chinese companies and its focus on ensuring Chinese companies meet American accounting standards could result in some currently listed Chinese companies being removed from U.S. exchanges. Both countries have sought to disentangle supply chains around sensitive technologies with national security, and in the American case, human rights dimensions. U.S. officials have sought to raise awareness of the risks for American firms of doing business in Hong Kong and Xinjiang.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › 1NC

US-China War goes nuclear – Quickly escalates due to miscalc, existential risk

Max Boot, 4-17-2023, "In the U.S.-China competition, the real ‘existential’ danger is nuclear war," Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/04/17/china-united-states-nuclear-conflict-danger/

But Gallagher is right that the United States and China are locked in an existential struggle, because this new cold war, like the original Cold War with the Soviet Union, has the potential to turn into a nuclear conflict. This is a danger that China hawks — and the U.S. public in general — do not pay sufficient attention to. President Biden, for example, repeatedly says that the United States will defend Taiwan if it’s attacked, without any mention of the potential consequences of a conflict with China.

“It seems odd that war with China over Taiwan seems a comfortable assumption for so many when the U.S. and NATO remain cautious about Russia’s war in Ukraine precisely because of the perceived risk of nuclear escalation,” John K. Culver, a CIA veteran and former national intelligence officer for East Asia, told me.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › 1NC

US weakness causes war – Lack of capability invites miscalc and nuclear war

Grady Means, 8-30-2021, economist in the Office of the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, served in the White House as Assistant to Vice President Nelson Rockefeller, and led the Food and Nutrition Task Force to reform the Food Stamp program, served as White House oversight to the National Health Insurance Experiment, chaired working groups on environmental protection and civil rights, and helped draft the bicentennial State of the Union Message of 1976."Biden brings the world closer to nuclear war" Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/white-house/569732-biden-brings-the-world-closer-to-nuclear-war/

Over the past six months, the world has edged closer to nuclear war than it has been since the Cuban Missile Crisis. The Doomsday Clock is ticking toward midnight. The global power balance has been dramatically reshuffled, and the potential for disastrous miscalculation hasn’t been so high in 80 years. The match and fuse for this is instability — an exaggerated sense of U.S. weakness and lack of capability and resolve — that could lead to huge, aggressive military miscalculations and mistakes by our enemies. The Biden administration has set the table for such a catastrophe.

The timing could not be more dangerous. China has changed strategic direction and has been building its nuclear stockpile and delivery systems. China also has continued to develop hypersonic weapons, including stand-off “carrier killers,” space weapons and cyber capabilities to blind opponents’ strategic and conventional systems. Russia has been advertising (mostly for domestic consumption, but nonetheless worrying) its “unstoppable” delivery systems, and has a very capable nuclear stockpile and military. Iran will continue to move forward with building nuclear weapons. Pakistan and India both have significant nuclear capability in an increasingly unstable part of the world. Nuclear-armed North Korea is again assuming a more belligerent posture. Israel has a full nuclear triad (land, air, subs) to respond to existential aggression. The U.K. and France have significant nuclear deterrents. The world is a powder keg.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › 1NC

Degrowth reduces international trade – Reliance on trade is a tenet of growth, degrowth necessarily challenges it

Filka Sekulova, 8-30-2016, Filka holds a Bachelor Degree in Psychology from the Sofia University St. Kliment Ohridski and in Economics and Business from the Universiteit van Amsterdam, a Masters in Environmental Economics and Transport from Vrije Universiteit, and a PhD in Climate Change Economics and Happiness from the Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona. She is a member of the academic think-tank Research & Degrowth, “What are the degrowth implications for long-distance trade?”, Degrowth Conference Budapest 2016, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-1qiYMSeYE

Reminding us that degrowth implies before all challenge to profitability of maximization as the primary driver of human material, of human behavior implies also challenge to the hope the quality of standardization of the high consumption lifestyle that we are having. Challenge the idea of the dependence on market transactions as something intermediary all human relations and implies living giving less room to economic and market transaction and more to be human interventions and human reality is part and parcel of the growth driven imaginary: trade for growth and growth of trade so then so the international trade now become a goal in itself it's done for its own sake and it's also kind of questionable toward extending contributes to the to the types of well-being and social justice. On the contrary if international trade is viewed from an ecological and cultural perspective to be the most efficient colonizer of imaginary. This fantasy we use: producer countries traded in others if they create imaginary of what are the goods that we want to have in our livelihoods.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › 1NC

Economic interdependence prevents war – Empirics of US-China relations prove

Mina E. Tanious, 11-23-2018, General Authority for Investment and Free Zones (GAFI), Giza, Egypt and Faculty of Economics and Political Science, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt "The impact of economic interdependence on the probability of conflict between states The case of “American–Chinese relationship on Taiwan since 1995” " Review of Economics and Political Science, https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/REPS-10-2018-010/full/pdf?title=the-impact-of-economic-interdependence-on-the-probability-of-conflict-between-states-the-case-of-american-chinese-relationship-on-taiwan-since-1995

5.4 The impact of economic interdependence over conflict on Taiwan

Oneal and Russett tested a three independent variables (Economic Interdependence, democracy, and Joint Intergovernmental Organization membership) against the dependent variable conflict, Oneal and Russett found that independently, democracy, economic interdependence and joint IGO membership all reduce conflict (Clarke, 2008, p. 60).

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › China DA › 1NC

Economic interdependence high now – US and Chinese economies exchange hundreds of billions of dollars a year

Kenneth Gatten, 23, US International Trade Commission International Trade Analyst, "U.S.-China Relations: Short and Long-Term Implications for the Global Economy – School of Public Policy," Pennsylvania State University, https://publicpolicy.psu.edu/faculty-and-research/policy-perspectives/u-s-china-relations-short-and-long-term-implications-for-the-global-economy/

Financially, however, neither country has seriously moved to decouple.

In possession of $1.05 trillion of low-return U.S. Treasury securities, China’s central bank has tried to diversify its portfolio but must continue buying these securities to create demand for the dollar, which boosts its value relative to the renminbi, making Chinese exports more competitive and preserving the value of its central bank’s dollar-denominated holdings.

2023 DDI Negative
DA Links › DA Links › To cut Misc

https://www.economist.com/united-states/2018/05/10/a-jobs-guarantee-is-a-flawed-idea

https://www.americanprogress.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2019/06/PetersonSolutions-report1.pdf

To reduce carbon emissions, CAP’s plan proposes a progressive, budget-neutral carbon tax. Set at the social cost of carbon emissions, or roughly $52 per metric ton, the carbon tax would shift public and private investment away from carbon-intensive energy sources and toward renewable and lower-carbon energy sources.16 Because lowand moderate-income households spend a higher share of their incomes on energy costs and other forms of consumption, a carbon tax can have a regressive distributional effect, including increasing hardship for those with low incomes. The CAP plan therefore proposes to rebate all of the net revenue from the carbon tax to middle- and lowincome Americans. Such a progressive rebate system can be implemented in a number of ways, including through the combination of lump sum rebates and tax cuts on labor income, which CAP proposed in 2016.17 Establishing a price on carbon emissions is an important step toward confronting climate change—but given the urgency and magnitude of the challenge, it is not sufficient. There’s also a need for substantial public investments. U.S. investment in climate science and clean energy research and development are critical to both domestic and global efforts to understand and combat climate change. To strengthen these critical foundations, the plan doubles federal spending on climate science; clean energy research and development; and programs supporting advanced manufacturing. The budget plan would dramatically accelerate the transition to a 100 percent clean energy electricity sector through direct investments that will improve equity and assist low-income and rural communities. This includes updating outdated transmission infrastructure to better integrate renewables and storage technologies; repairing and replacing outdated natural gas distribution pipelines to reduce methane leakage; improving energy efficiency and reducing costs for low-income households through an expanded Weatherization Assistance Program (WAP); and updating energy systems in municipal buildings, schools, universities, and hospitals by funding the U.S. Department of Energy’s State Energy Program for the next 10 years at the levels from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009.18 For the 56 percent of the United States landmass served by rural electric co-ops, CAP’s plan vastly expands funding available through the Rural Utilities Service to both forgive outstanding debts on fossil fuel assets owned and op

https://www.filesforprogress.org/misc/Data-for-Progress_Civis_092019_climate_policies.pdf

2023 DDI Negative
DA Links › DA Links › To cut Misc

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-dangerous-fantasy-of-a-jobs-guarantee-1542239737

for a moment about “Medicare for All.” A proposal is gaining steam on the left that would overhaul the U.S. economy in a far more radical way. Known as a federal job guarantee, the plan would require the government to provide work on demand to any American at a minimum of about $12 an hour plus full benefits.

Three senators and rumored 2020 presidential candidates, Kirsten Gillibrand, Cory Booker and Bernie Sanders, have publicly supported the idea. Their visions for the program vary, but the fundamentals of a job guarantee were fleshed out most fully in a proposal released in March by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. I sized up that plan in a critical study last month, which had two major findings: The sky-high cost alone makes the job guarantee a bad idea, and the changes it would force on the labor market are an even greater danger.

The plan’s authors estimate an annual price tag of about $543 billion. Defense is the only discretionary federal expense comparable in size, at about $639 billion last year. Some funding for the job program would be offset by cuts to other government programs. But there’s good reason to believe the authors significantly underestimate the number of participants it would draw, a major component of its cost.

2023 DDI Negative
DA Links › DA Links › Ptx

MMT would alienate republicans

Wray 21 (Larry, is a professor of Economics at Bard College and Senior Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute. 08-2021 “What Is MMT’s State of Play in Washington?” https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/e_pamphlet_2.pdf pg.3)//BH-NB//

Yet there is some evidence that leads to a more optimistic assessment of MMT’s success. In the fall 2019 I was invited by Representative John Yarmuth’s (D, KY-03) office to testify on budget deficits before the House Budget Committee.5 Previous to and after the hearing I was told by the congressman as well as his staff that at least the Democrat side of the committee was genuinely interested in and actively considering the MMT approach to fiscal policy. It turned out that was true on the Democrat side, but the Republican side merely parroted talking points proclaiming that the US federal government ought to balance its books just like any household or firm and that MMT’s prescriptions would lead to rack and ruin.

2023 DDI Negative
DA Links › DA Links › Ptx

Republicans hate MMT and Job Guarantees

Moller 19 (Zach,  earned a Bachelor’s degree in Economics from the University of Florida and a Master’s degree in Economics from the University of Virginia. 07-18-2019 “What Is MMT, and Why Isn’t It Practical?” https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-mmt-and-why-isnt-it-practical)//BH-NB//

Enter a new far-flung theory, this time from the far left. Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) promises that we should stop obsessing over how to pay for policies such as Medicare for All, a federal jobs guarantee, a universal basic income, free college—anything really. Imagining a world without federal budget constraints is politically attractive to some progressives because they’ve rightfully felt short-changed by blatant Republican hypocrisy. Republicans screamed about the national debt when Obama was in office trying to save the economy from the great recession, and then passed a huge tax cut for high-income and wealthy individuals and corporations in the midst of an economic expansion.

2023 DDI Negative
DA Links › DA Links › Ptx

The green new deal has no congressional support and would cost massive political capital.

Davis 19 (Susan, is a political correspondent for NPR and has covered Congress, elections, and national politics since 2002. 03-26-2019 “Senate Blocks Green New Deal, But Climate Change Emerges As Key 2020 Issue” https://www.npr.org/2019/03/26/705897344/green-new-deal-vote-sets-up-climate-change-as-key-2020-issue)//BH-NB//

The Senate failed to move forward with Democrats' "Green New Deal," but the partisan clash over the controversial environmental plan is likely to be a continuing theme ahead of the 2020 election. The measure needed 60 votes to advance but was blocked when all Senate Republicans and four Senate Democrats opposed it. The rest of the chamber's Democrats voted "present." Senate Republicans forced a vote on the proposal Tuesday as part of an ongoing effort to turn the provocative climate change resolution into a wedge issue in the 2020 elections. Democrats say the GOP gambit carried its own political risk of mocking an issue that is a priority for ag number of Americans.