Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Internal Links › Readiness Internal Link – Recruitment DA – 2NC

Failing to meet recruitment targets immediately emboldens global great power rivalries

Ryan T. Williams Western State University College of Law 2017 January 13 (last updated) “Size Really Does Matter: How Obesity is Undermining America’s National Security” University of Toledo Law Review, 2016 (originally written March 1 2016) IB

Even the most ardent anti-military advocates and political theorists would have to admit that a forced, substantial reduction in military spending, amidst an already growing troop shortage problem, would likely weaken America for several reasons. First and most basically, America would have fewer troops available to defend itself from future attacks. The necessity of a healthy military, ready to deploy at any time in defense of the nation should not be underestimated. September 11, 2001 showed that people do not fear attacking mainland U.S. Reducing the military to the point where we would not be able to defend the nation could have the domino effect of emboldening America’s enemies, making them more likely to strike while America’s defense are depleted. America will undoubtedly retain enough nuclear weapons to sufficiently destroy/retaliate against any nation that attacks her. Currently, America has approximately 7,100 nuclear weapons available. 104 Thus, this Article is not saying that if America’s military budget is reduced, America would lose if Venezuela invaded and attempted to take over the country. America will likely maintain its nuclear capabilities to discourage/stop such an attack. But nuclear weapons as a primary defense have their limitations. Having the largest nuclear arsenal in the world did not prevent 9/11. Nor has it played a role in, much less ended, the war on terror. Individual groups and/or smaller factions require something less than nuclear bombs to defeat. Asymmetric warfare and on the ground guerilla tactics are often better utilized when fighting terrorist organizations, the type of enemy the U.S. is likely to face in the future. Thus, even though America will likely retain nuclear preeminence in the world, to ward off relatively smaller in scale (but by no means small) attacks and attackers, America will likely need the rest of its military. Keeping nuclear weapons but reducing military spending on almost everything else would not be an effective national security strategy. On the other hand, an obesity necessitated reduction in budget, that leads to significant military cuts from the nuclear weapons program, would also be problematic. It is expensive to properly dispose of, and maintain effective safeguards in so doing, for thousands of nuclear weapons. Without the money to maintain and keep safe track of all of our nuclear weapons, one can imagine a sort of Wild West in which advanced nuclear materials and weapons are siphoned off to the highest bidder. One need only look to what has happened with some of the states in the former Soviet Union and the disorganized dismantling of its nuclear weapons program as a model the U.S. does not want to follow.105 Finally, reducing America’s military would leave the nation with fewer troops to complete or continue the current conflicts of the day. Not only would America be less able to fend off future aggressors, but those currently in conflict with America might suddenly have the upper hand. On the contrary, one could argue that America may be involved in less armed conflict in the future, thus drastically reducing the need for such a vast military. An axiom that has remained constant throughout history, however, is man’s desire for war.106 With the rise of the Islamic State and the continued threat of a nuclear Iran and Al Qaeda associated forces, it is unlikely that America will see a significant reduction in fighting in the future. Moreover, all of the above listed conflicts involve countries or person directly in conflict with America. But those directly at odds with America are not the only instances where the U.S. needs troops or utilizes it’s military. Since the end of the Cold War, the U.S. military has routinely been utilized to combat individuals abroad that were not directly attacking or threatening America.107 For reasons mentioned earlier, it remains highly unlikely that this trend would suddenly change in the future. As such, the U.S. military will continue to be called upon to use force against nations or individuals not directly attacking America, many of which are currently unknown. Because unknown threats are inherently difficult to prepare for, it remains imperative to maintain a fluent and sufficiently funded military to adequately address future, hard to predict situations. In sum, if the nation continues to increase in weight, health care spending will increase significantly, and one of the few places where budget money could come from to pay for these is the military. If that happens, it will make America less safe and more vulnerable to attack.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link

FJG advocates hate the military - they’d cut spending

Haim 21 [Daniel; Levy Economics Institute of Bard College1-19-2021; "What Jobs Should a Public Job Guarantee Provide? Lessons from Hyman P. Minsky"; No Publication; https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3769488;]//LASA-بيلال

What kind of jobs did Minsky envision when he proposed a public job guarantee? He favored:

1) jobs increasing socially useful output, providing all of society better public services andgoods;

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link

The plan destroys unskilled workers economic motives to join the military

The Economist 18 [Economist; May 2018; "A jobs guarantee is a flawed idea"; The Economist; https://www.economist.com/united-states/2018/05/10/a-jobs-guarantee-is-a-flawed-idea;]//LASA-بيلال

Still, a strong economy does not make a jobs guarantee pointless. It would reduce structural unemployment. If recession did strike, more government jobs would both provide a safety net for workers and automatic stimulus to demand. Most important, guaranteed alternative employment would raise the bargaining power of unskilled workers. They could use it as leverage when negotiating with their existing employers. Mr Booker’s plan would offer parental leave, health insurance and pay its participants a wage that would eventually rise to $15 an hour. Private employers would have to compete with this generosity when hiring workers. That appeals greatly to those who fear automation and the gig economy are combining to create a glut of low-paid workers without bargaining power (in Britain, such workers have been dubbed the “precariat”).

Low-paid jobs are concentrated in the food, hospitality and retail industries. Some employers would match the government’s terms. It is easy to imagine, say, restaurants in San Francisco or New York, whose wealthy customers may not balk at higher prices, paying their workers more and passing the costs on to customers. But others, such as those in the beleaguered retail industry, could struggle.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link

The military relies on economic benefits to maintain a working force – a JG would remove incentives to join

Day 18 [Megan; writer, editor, and activist. She is an editor at Jacobin, where she was previously a staff writer. She is the author of the 2016 book Maximum Sunlight and co-author of the book Bigger than Bernie: How We Go from the Sanders Campaign to Democratic Socialism.; 10-19-2018; "Ending Economic Conscription"; Jacobin https://jacobin.com/2018/10/military-recruits-full-employment-welfare-state;]//LASA-بيلال

Working-class support for the military is often overstated, but it is high enough to hamstring any antiwar movement angling for mass support — which is the only kind of antiwar movement that can win. The more recruits the military has, the more deeply it embeds itself in working-class American life. This obviously presents an enormous obstacle to building opposition to war. And it is precisely the working class that must oppose war, because not only are workers the majority of society and the group with the actual leverage to force change, but they’re also the ones who fight and die in the wars themselves. As Eugene V. Debs said, “The master class has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles. The master class has had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject class has had nothing to gain and all to lose — especially their lives.” In order for our society to achieve peace, working people must realize they’re being conned into war. So how do we go about removing the economic incentive for joining the military? Ensuring full employment is a great start. Full employment means that everyone who’s actively looking for a job can easily find one, which forces employers to compete with each other for hires, and gives workers more options and more power in the economy. Although unemployment is pretty low right now, there will inevitably be another economic crisis, and the gains made will evaporate. A better way to achieve full employment for the long haul is a federal job guarantee of some kind.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › GND Link – 2NC

A Green Jobs Guarantee is a nightmare for the military

Steichen and Koshgarian 20 [Lorah; Outreach Coordinator for the National Priorities Project at the Institute for Policy Studies; Lindsay; Program Director of the National Priorities Project; 2020; "Green Jobs and a Just Transition for Workers and Communities"; https://ips-dc.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/No-Warming-No-War_06-Green-Jobs-and-Just-Transition.pdf;]//LASA-بيلال

The Military is the Only Major Federal Jobs Program in the U.S. Understanding that climate disruption is an outcome of our broken economic system, climate threats cannot be separated from other forms of insecurity that people experience in their daily lives. Vast economic insecurity and inequality are outcomes of the financially extractive, fossil-fueled economy. The U.S. military has long capitalized on economic precarity, recruiting poor people who lack other options and middle-class populations faced with significant debt and instability. As a matter of practicality, the prevalence of militarized jobs in communities remains a key political blockade to reducing military funding. As such, solutions to the climate crisis must also address the absence of an adequate number of well-paying jobs, poverty, inequality, and other prevalent socioeconomic concerns of our time. At the same time, we must convert a major share of U.S. manufacturing and engineering from building weapons of war to building a 100% clean energy economy by 2030. GREEN JOBS AND A JUST TRANSITION While official estimates are known to be too low, the Bureau of Labor Statistics counted about six million people as unemployed and actively seeking work in 2019—a figure now rendered obsolete by the coronavirus crisis, but indicative of our economy under “good” circumstances.96 This figure does not include all working age people who are unemployed and more comprehensive methods of calculating unemployment often double the standard unemployment rate. Even in the best of times, unemployment rates also vary drastically by geography, race, and age; rural workers, Black workers, Latinx workers, and young people all have higher than average rates of unemployment. In normal times, forty percent of the U.S. workforce is employed in insecure positions, such as temporary, part-time, and “on-call” workers, contractors, and the self-employed. 97 While employment statistics can help illustrate the economic crisis, they can also minimize the lived-realities for the tens of millions of people living in poverty in the United States. In the richest country in the world, even prior to the coronavirus pandemic and its associated economic implosion, there were 140 million poor and low-wealth people. That’s over 43% of the population of the United States. Low pay, job scarcity or inaccessibility, and attacks on unionization work together to keep people in poverty. Do We Have a Poverty Draft in the United States? Mandatory military service ended in 1973, and by the 1980s the term “poverty draft” gained prominence as a term used to describe “the belief that the enlisted ranks of the military were made up of young people with limited economic opportunities.”98 In the context of vast economic precarity in the United States, military service often functions as a “draft-like system” that attracts low-income and other marginalized groups into enlisting because of a lack of other job, income, and educational opportunities available in their communities. Half of all young people who join the military do so as a means to pay for future education.99 Military recruiters have historically recruited among middle and lower classes. Reporting by the Seattle Times in 2005 found, for example, that nearly half of new recruits came “from lower-middle-class to poor households.”100 Native Americans, who have the highest poverty rate of any racial or ethnic group in the United States, also serve in the country’s armed forces at the highest rate of any ethnic group in the country.101 Despite such vast economic insecurity, the military is the only major federal jobs program in the United States. Over 1,300,000 Americans are on active military duty and over 800,000 more are in the military reserves. Another 1,600,000 Americans work for companies contracted by the U.S. military not only to supply weapons of war, but also the goods and services that support military operations. 102 The Department of Defense calls itself America’s largest employer - larger than Walmart, even.103 Since the military industrial complex is spread across the United States, some members of congress justify military spending by the jobs it provides their states or districts. War spending is often perceived as an effective way to increase employment, but there are far better ways besides a massive military jobs program to employ Americans. Funding Green Jobs and the Care Economy Yields Net Benefits In fact, compared to alternative uses for those funds, military spending is one of the least effective sources of job creation. According to Brown University’s Cost of War Project, a total of 6.9 jobs are created per $1 million of federal military spending. By comparison, GREEN JOBS AND A JUST TRANSITION spending the same amount in wind creates 8.4 good-paying jobs and in solar 9.5. For the same level of spending, clean energy and infrastructure create over 40% more jobs. Investing the same amount in energy efficiency retrofits creates nearly twice the level of job creation by military spending.104 Across the board, funding the green economy instead of a bloated military budget would be a net job creator. Shifting excess military spending to green manufacturing in particular creates opportunities for targeted job creation in regions of the United States that have been hardest hit by declines in manufacturing over the last two decades. If we shift $125 billion from military spending to green manufacturing, an additional 250,000 jobs would be created.105 In order to rapidly transition to a green economy, we must fund millions of jobs to dramatically scale-up clean energy production and transition to one hundred percent renewable energy, overhaul the U.S. transportation systems to build and run mass public transportation, and prepare communities on the frontlines of the climate crisis to adapt to the realities of a warming planet. Then there’s the care economy. The lowest carbon jobs are those that don’t extract anything from the land or create waste and have a limited environmental impact. Jobs that include teaching, nurturing, and caring, often referred to as care work, are invaluable to our society and to the economy at large. The National Domestic Workers Alliance describes care work as, “the work that makes all other work possible.” Direct public investment in these jobs also has a greater impact on the economy than military spending. Compared to the 6.9 jobs created in the military, $1 million dollars in education produces an average of 15.2 good-paying jobs.106 A dramatic expansion of these jobs, and ensuring that the standards and conditions of this work are raised, is a critical component of the transition away from extractive, destructive, and often violent work and towards an economy of care. Endeavoring to address the climate crisis and economic inequality simultaneously, a federal jobs guarantee is a key component of the Green New Deal. A federal jobs guarantee promises a job—at a living wage and with full benefits—to anyone who wants one. A public job guarantee isn’t a new concept, in fact it was a key demand of the Civil Rights Movement. In the Forward to the 1966 publication A “Freedom Budget” for All Americans, Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. states, “We shall eliminate unemployment for Negroes when we demand full and fair employment for all.” The first of the seven demands outlined in the Freedom Budget was “To provide full employment for all who are willing and able to work, including those who need education or training to make them willing and able.”107 Direct public investment in a program that competes for labor with competitive wages and good benefits isn’t unheard of in the United States. A jobs guarantee could look a lot like the military does currently, an expense we deem necessary that serves A total of 6.9 jobs are created per $1 million of federal military spending. By comparison, spending the same amount in wind creates 8.4 good-paying jobs and in solar 9.5. For the same level of spending, clean energy and infrastructure create over 40% more jobs. A jobs guarantee could look a lot like the military does currently, an expense we deem necessary that serves the public good. GREEN JOBS AND A JUST TRANSITION the public good. While providing alternatives to low-paid work in carbon-intensive supply chains, a federal jobs guarantee could offer better-paying jobs that improve communities while supporting a Just Transition to a green economy. We Need a Just Transition for Workers and Communities The fossil fuel and military sectors mirror each other in the way that workers frequently end up funneled into lethal work due to limited options. Communities across the United States depend on employment in the military and various sectors of the military industrial complex. Like the workers who extract, process, transport and use fossil fuels will need to transition into new jobs, there must be alternative pathways to good employment for individuals and communities whose livelihoods are tied to the military. The leadership of labor unions, which have long organized to advance the interests of low-income workers, is critical to advancing a worker-led Just Transition movement. When the peace and climate justice movements stand in solidarity with organized labor, the possibility of a powerful, coordinated, and truly transformative movement emerges. The Green New Deal has been described as an “all hands on deck” kind of policy. If we do it right, the Green New Deal will be a mass mobilization that would radically restructure the fossil-fueled economy as we know it. This kind of comprehensive program will require a wide range of jobs not only in manufacturing and the energy sector, but across the economy. For those who will lose work in the fossil fuel industry or military industrial complex, a job guarantee provides an employment safety net during economic transition. A job guarantee is one measure among many that can be taken to phase out extractive industries with care and prevent adverse and unjust outcomes for workers and communities relying on those industry jobs. Such outcomes can be prevented if we plan and invest federal resources accordingly. As articulated by the climate justice movement, “Just Transition to us represents a set of aligned strategies to transition whole communities toward thriving economies that provide dignified, productive and ecologically sustainable livelihoods that are governed directly by workers and communities.”

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

2018 proves – unemployment’s good for military recruitment

Philipps 18 [Dave; National correspondent for The New York Times covering the military; September 21 2018; "As Economy Roars, Army Falls Thousands Short of Recruiting Goals"; New York Times; https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/21/us/army-recruiting-shortage.html;]//LASA-بيلال

COLORADO SPRINGS — The Army fell thousands of troops short of its recruiting goals this year, the first time it has done so since the height of the Iraq war 13 years ago.

The shortfall is due in part to a hot job market that has lured away many recruits at a time that President Trump and Congress seek to expand the military, and have raised the number the Army needs to meet.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

Specifically – the plan undermines military benefits

Asch 19 [Beth J.; Senior economist at the RAND Corporation. Her areas of study include labor economics and defense manpower. She has led numerous studies on compensation design in the military and in the federal civil service, on the workforce implications of state and local pension reform, and on military recruiting and personnel supply to the armed forces. Her most recent work includes analysis and redesign of the military pay table, military retirement reform, state and local pension reform, enlistment supply and recruiting resource effectiveness, and retention and compensation in the federal civil service. Asch's research has been widely disseminated as reports, briefings, and journal articles among the policy community, the media, and the academic community - Ph.D. and M.A. in economics, University of Chicago; B.A. in economics, University of California, Los Angeles. 2019; "Navigating Current and Emerging Army Recruiting Challenges"; RAND; https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR3107.html;]//LASA-بيلال

Studies estimate a pay elasticity of between 0.70 to 1.15 for the Army (Table 1). Elasticity is defined as the percentage change in high-quality enlistments associated with a 1-percent change in a given variable—in this case, military pay relative to civilian pay. Using FYs 2000–2008 data, Asch et al. (2010) estimated an elasticity of high-quality contracts with respect to relative military pay of 1.15. This implies that if the level of military pay was to rise by 10 percent relative to civilian wage opportunities, enlistment of high-quality youth would rise by 11.5 percent. Consistent with the trends shown in Figure 5, it is unsurprising that studies consistently find a relationship between high-quality contracts and the civilian unemployment rate, all else being equal (Table 1). For example, Knapp et al. (2018) estimate an elasticity of high-quality contracts with respect to the unemployment rate to be about 0.3 using Army data from 2012 to 2015, implying that halving the civilian unemployment rate (e.g., from 10 to 5 percent) would reduce high-quality enlistment by 15 percent, all else equal. On a base of 50,000 high-quality enlistments annually in the Army, that would mean about 7,500 fewer individuals would need to be recruited. The range of estimates in the table reflects different time periods, analytic approaches, and unit of analysis.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

It's statistically proven – unemployment rates are consistent with recruitment rates

Asch 19 [Beth J.; Senior economist at the RAND Corporation. Her areas of study include labor economics and defense manpower. She has led numerous studies on compensation design in the military and in the federal civil service, on the workforce implications of state and local pension reform, and on military recruiting and personnel supply to the armed forces. Her most recent work includes analysis and redesign of the military pay table, military retirement reform, state and local pension reform, enlistment supply and recruiting resource effectiveness, and retention and compensation in the federal civil service. Asch's research has been widely disseminated as reports, briefings, and journal articles among the policy community, the media, and the academic community - Ph.D. and M.A. in economics, University of Chicago; B.A. in economics, University of California, Los Angeles. 2019; "Navigating Current and Emerging Army Recruiting Challenges"; RAND; https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR3107.html;]//LASA-بيلال

After 2009, recruiting conditions improved. The economy stalled as a result of the Great Recession that began in fall 2008, thereby improving the attractiveness of Army service relative to recruits’ opportunities in the civilian workplace. Research shows an increase in high-quality enlistments when the unemployment rate rises (Asch et al., 2010; Knapp et al., 2018). The strong relationship between the strength of the economy and high-quality recruits is shown in Figure 4.7 In addition, the number of Army deployments fell markedly after 2010, and the Army accession mission began to decline as did the overall enlisted force size. Military pay, as measured by regular military compensation (RMC), was also relatively constant from 2010 to 2016 (Hosek et al., 2018). 6 Table 1.1 summarizes estimates from recent studies. 7 Note that Figure 1.4 does not adjust for other factors that might have changed over time (e.g., it does not hold other factors, such as recruiting resources, accession requirements, or deployment frequency and length, equal). Unemployment rates over time for age subgroups also follow a similar pattern as for the overall adult unemployment rate, although the unemployment rate for young adults ages 16–24 is uniformly higher (Statista, 2019). 5 Figure 3. Enlisted Military Pay Relative to Median Civilian Pay for Male and Female High School Graduates, Ages 18–22 SOURCE: Hosek et al., 2018. NOTE: Military pay is measured as RMC for an E-4 with four years of service. The ratio is for RMC relative to the median civilian pay for 18- to 22-year old workers with high school (and without additional education) who had more than 35 hours of work in the year and more than 35 usual weekly hours of work. M_predicted refers to the trend line for males, and F_predicted refers to the trend line for females. Figure 4. High-Quality Army Enlisted Accessions and Adult Unemployment Rate The Navy, Air Force, and Marine Corps responded to the improved recruiting conditions in 2009 by increasing recruit quality and specifically the percentage of recruits who are scored as AFQT Categories I–IIIA (Figure 5), sustaining percentages that exceeded 70 percent Categories I–IIIA through 2016. U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) guidelines are that 60 percent of recruits are AFQT Categories I–IIIA and 90 percent are Tier 1. The other services well exceeded the DoD guideline after 2009. 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 RMC/Wage Ratio Males M_predicted Females F_predicted 40% 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8% 9% 10% 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Fiscal Year Adult civilian unemployment rate Army Percentage High Quality 6 In contrast, the Army responded to the improved recruiting conditions by cutting resources and chose to reduce the percentage of recruits in AFQT Categories I–IIIA down to the 60 percent DoD guideline. Knapp et al. (2018) show that the percentage of Army recruits receiving bonuses, average bonus amounts, and Army advertising expenditures dropped dramatically in 2009. Furthermore, Army-enlisted recruits with prior military service (Figure 2, right) and those receiving medical or conduct waivers dropped considerably in 2009 compared with 2008. The Army also increased Tier 1 recruits dramatically in 2009 (Figure 2, left) and kept the percentage Tier 1 at or above 90 percent thereafter. Even with fewer recruiting resources, the Army met its overall accession mission between 2009 and 2017 and even substantially exceeded it in 2010 and 2012. Figure 5. AFQT Categories I–IIIA Enlisted Accessions by Service SOURCE: Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness, 1997–2016. NOTE: A high-quality accession is defined as Tier I recruits in AFQT Categories I–IIIA. The Army’s differing strategy when recruiting conditions improved suggested that the Army focused on reducing recruiting costs while achieving its overall recruiting mission and meeting DoD benchmarks of 90 percent Tier 1 and 60 percent AFQT Categories I–IIIA recruits. The other services focused on achieving their overall mission while increasing recruit quality above the benchmarks. The different strategies raise the question of what level of recruit quality is appropriate: Are the DoD benchmarks still relevant, should recruit quality increase, or should recruiting costs decrease when recruiting conditions improve? Put differently, how should the services, and the Army specifically, reap the benefits of a less-challenging recruiting market? The Army’s approach would be more appropriate than the other services if the DoD benchmarks are still relevant. On the other hand, if higher recruit quality is required, increasing the higher recruit quality produced by the other services would be more appropriate, although as discussed 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85% 90% 95% 100% 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Percent AFQT I-IIIA Army Navy Marine Corps Air Force 7 in more detail in the following section, research shows that increasing resources other than military pay might be a more cost-effective means of increasing recruit quality. Recruiting has become more challenging in recent years, however. The Army’s total recruiting mission has increased from 57,000 in 2014 to 76,500 in 2018. Furthermore, the economy has dramatically improved. The adult unemployment rate reached a high of 9.6 percent in 2010, but, by 2014, had fallen to 7.4 percent, as shown in Figure 4. In June 2019, adult unemployment was 3.7 percent. As mentioned earlier, research shows that Army high-quality recruits fall, given no other changes, when the economy improves. Tools developed at the RAND Corporation (discussed in the following section), such as the Recruiting Resource Model (RRM), can help the Army assess the relative efficiency of different resource mixes when conditions such as the strength of the economy are changing. Understanding the Decision to Enlist Fundamental to successful recruiting is understanding the factors affecting the decision of young people, especially high-quality young people, to enlist. These decisions are typically modeled within an occupational choice framework, where individuals are assumed to enlist if the expected value of joining the military exceeds the opportunity cost of not doing so. The decision involves comparing the compensation and nonmonetary benefits available in the military with what is expected in the civilian sector. The opportunity cost is the expected value of alternative civilian pursuits, such as civilian employment or pursuing additional education. Army service is relatively arduous and involves the exposure to risk and potential loss of life, but it also offers many nonmonetary benefits, including patriotism and pride in service to country, the opportunity to travel, acquiring training and generally having access to stable employment. Military service can also be a stepping stone to better future civilian opportunities, if skills acquired in the military are highly transferable to civilian employment. Research supports this, showing that greater college aspirations among recent high school graduates is associated with a higher likelihood of joining the military compared with directly entering the civilian labor market (Kleykamp, 2006). Put differently, attending college and military service could be complementary career aspirations with military service operating as a pathway toward college enrollment. Military service also provides monetary benefits, including basic pay and allowances and, if qualified, special and incentive pays, bonuses, and ultimately retirement pay. The importance of pay, patriotism, and meaningful work is revealed in DoD surveys of young adults and new recruits. The top factors reported as the number one considerations in selecting a job in the spring 2016 DoD Youth Poll were having a higher-than-average income, maintaining a good work-life balance, and finding meaningful work (JAMRS, 2017b). In the March 2018 New Recruit Survey, the top five reasons Army recruits wanted to join the Army were pride or self-esteem/honor (67 percent), travel (66 percent), life betterment (64 percent), gain experience or work skills (59 percent), and pay or money (56 percent). The majority of new 8 Army recruits (62 percent) in the 2018 survey also indicated that they view the Army as a stepping stone for their future career outside the Army.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

Low Recruitment rates stem from constrained labor markets

Ryssdal 23 [Kai; American radio journalist and the host of Marketplace, a business program that airs weekdays on U.S. public radio stations. He also co-hosts the spinoff podcast Make Me Smart with Kimberly Adams. Marketplace is produced and distributed by American Public Media; 4-12-2023; "U.S. Army brings back "Be All You Can Be" amid lagging recruitment"; Marketplace; https://www.marketplace.org/2023/04/12/u-s-army-brings-back-be-all-you-can-be-amid-lagging-recruitment/;]//LASA-بيلال

Besides the television spots, the Army is hoping to take advantage of new tech infrastructure known as MarTech, which allows the service to track which marketing efforts actually lead to enlistments. Maj. Gen. Alex Fink, the Army’s chief of enterprise marketing, spoke with “Marketplace” host Kai Ryssdal about the technology.

Alex Fink: The nirvana within marketing is to be able to actually see a sale and then trace that sale back to a marketing activity. In fact, in 2019, we probably contracted around 120,000 soldiers across all three components, the Army, Army Reserve and the Army National Guard. We can only make an attribution of about 500 of those, so insignificant.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

Rises in unemployment are good for retention

Warner 12 [John T; DM, PMP is an experienced sales, product management and strategic marketing executive with 25+ years in the automotive industry.; 2012; "The Effect of the Civilian Economy on Recruiting and Retention"; Department of Defense; https://militarypay.defense.gov/Portals/3/Documents/Reports/SR05_Chapter_2.pdf;]//LASA-بيلال

Business Cycle Influences on Retention The state of the economy has a strong influence on recruiting. Evidence that retention may also depend on the state of the economy is indicated in Figure 2. Army enlisted continuation prior to the 20-year point was generally higher in FY 2009, when the civilian unemployment rate averaged 8.5 percent, than either FY 2001 or FY 2005, with unemployment rates of 4.3 and 5.2 percent, respectively. Civilian unemployment roughly doubled between FY 2001 and FY 2009. How much do studies predict retention to have increased as a result? Unfortunately, Simon et al. (2010) provide the only estimates of the retention effects of civilian unemployment based on post-drawdown data. The unemployment rate measure in this study is the unemployment rate in an individual’s home state at the time of reenlistment. This study estimates that a 1 percentage point rise in the civilian unemployment rate increases Army first-term retention by 0.5 percentage points, Navy retention by 0.8 percentage points, Air Force retention by 0.9 percentage points, and Marine Corps retention by 0.7 percentage points. These estimates imply that the approximate doubling of civilian unemployment between FY 2001 and The Eleventh Quadrennial Review of Military Compensation 89 The Civilian Economy, Recruiting and Retention FY 2009 would increase first-term retention by somewhere between 2 percentage points (Army) and 3.6 percentage points (Air Force). These effects are modest and may be due to the fact that the study included year effects along with the unemployment rate in the individual’s home state to control for other time-related effects on retention. These time effects no doubt capture in part effects of economy-wide movements in unemployment. Goldberg and Warner (1982) provide a study of the retention effects of civilian unemployment based on Navy data from the FY 1974–1980 period. They estimate larger unemployment effects that are roughly double those estimated by Simon et al. (2010).12 Based on these estimates, the observed rise in civilian unemployment between FY 2001 and FY 2009 would raise first- and second-term retention rates by about 8 percentage points. The larger estimates of unemployment effects obtained in this study may be due to the fact that it did not include time effects in the estimated models.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

Unemployment upholds military recruitment – provides incentives and fallback for citizens

Syeed 18 [Nafeesa; Assistant Op-Ed editor at the Los Angeles Times - visiting scholar at UCLA's International Institute; 3-13-2018; "Low U.S. Unemployment Is Making Army Recruiting Harder"; Bloomberg; Accessed via Archive.ph @ https://archive.ph/Hu721;]//LASA-بيلال

Working against the military is the U.S. jobless rate. Initial jobless claims were at the lowest in almost five decades last month. The U.S. economy added 313,000 jobs in February, while the unemployment rate held steady at 4.1 percent. Though the Pentagon has managed to meet its recruiting targets in recent years, unemployment rates below 6 percent -- the norm since late 2014 -- are seen as a key factor undermining those efforts.

To meet Trump’s goals, the Army has added 400 recruiters to the 9,000-strong force it already employs. Hundreds of millions more dollars are also going toward offering perks to lure recruits. There’s even a “quick-ship bonus” for those willing to go to basic training within a month. People ready to take on hard-to-fill jobs in engineering and cybersecurity can also get more money.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › Links › Unemployment Links – 2NC

Unemployment is key to maintaining military recruitment.

Peter 09 [Tom A; journalist based in Kabul, Afghanistan where he covers news and features throughout the country. He has also reported for The Monitor from Iraq, Yemen, Jordan, and throughout the United States. Christian Science Monitor; 11-12-2009; "High unemployment means high military recruitment"; ; https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Military/2009/1112/p17s01-usmi.html;]//LASA-بيلال

Economic hard times are a driving force in what the Department of Defense is calling the best recruitment year since 1973.

"We're pleased to report that for the first time since the advent of the all-volunteer force, all of the military components, active and reserve, met their number as well as their quality goals.… [T]hat's the first time that's been achieved for every component since the start of the all-volunteer force in 1973," said Bill Carr, head of personnel for the Department of Defense. In his October report on 2009 recruitment, he attributed part of the success to high unemployment rates in the US, in addition to increased spending on recruits and better military salaries.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Unemployment will peak this year while labor participation remains low – charts!!

CBO 23 [Congressional Budget Office; February 2023; "The Economic Outlook for 2023 to 2033 in 16 Charts"; https://www.cbo.gov/publication/58957;]//LASA-بيلال

Reflecting the expected slowdown in economic growth, the overall rate of unemployment is projected to rise from 3.6 percent in the fourth quarter of 2022 to 5.1 percent by the end of 2023, averaging 4.7 percent for 2023 as a whole. Thereafter, the unemployment rate is projected to decline gradually beginning in the second quarter of 2024, falling to 4.5 percent by the end of 2027.

Percent

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Effects from COVID and Europe remain – that’ll kill employment

Sonola 22 [Olu; Head of U.S. Regional Economics at Fitch Ratings; November 21 2022; "Significant Job Loss Expected in 2023 as U.S. Labor Market Rebalances"; Fitch Ratings; https://www.fitchratings.com/research/corporate-finance/significant-job-loss-expected-in-2023-as-us-labor-market-rebalances-21-11-2022;]//LASA-بيلال

Fitch Ratings-New York/London-21 November 2022: U.S. labor market imbalances are currently adding to wage and inflation pressures, but labor demand will fall significantly next year as Fed tightening weighs on economic activity, according to Fitch Ratings.

Labor demand – as measured by employment plus job openings – currently exceeds labour supply by around 5 million. This imbalance is unlikely to recede through a labor supply recovery, but the economic downturn expected in 2023 will likely result in lower labor demand through both job losses and falling job openings.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Unemployment is making a comeback

Cox 6-8 [Jeff; economics editor for CNBC.com where he covers the latest data, the Federal Reserve and how the developments impact financial markets. His stories are routinely among the most-read items on the site each day as he interviews some of the smartest and most well-respected economists and analysts in the financial world; 6-8-2023; “Jobless claims increase more than expected to their highest since October 2021”; CNBC; https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/08/jobless-claims-increase-more-than-expected-to-their-highest-since-october-2021.html;]//LASA-بيلال

First-time jobless claims rose sharply last week in a potential sign that the labor market is softening up after more than a year of interest rate hikes.

Initial filings for unemployment benefits totaled a seasonally adjusted 261,000 for the week ended June 3, an increase of 28,000 from the upwardly revised level of the previous period, the Labor Department reported Thursday.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Unemployment coming now

CBS 23 [Columbia Broadcasting System; February 15 2023; "Unemployment likely to surge this year, CBO says"; No Publication; https://www.cbsnews.com/news/unemployment-could-surge-to-5-1-percent-2023-cbo/;]//LASA-بيلال

The U.S. jobless rate just hit its lowest level since 1969, but the Congressional Budget Office is projecting a stagnant economy that may push unemployment to its highest since September 2021, when the nation was recovering its footing from the pandemic.

The unemployment rate could jump to 5.1% this year from its January level of 3.4%, the lowest in more than a half century, according to the nonpartisan organization, which provides independent analyses of budget and economic issues to Congress. A jump in unemployment of that size would imply that hundreds of thousands of people who are currently employed would lose their jobs.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Unemployment rises are coming – specifically for the most likely to join the military

Zahn 22 [Max; Business and tech reporter at ABC News – MA in Journalism at CUNY; 9-24-2022; "The Fed says unemployment will rise. Here's who economists say would lose their jobs first."; ABC News; https://abcnews.go.com/Business/fed-unemployment-rise-economists-lose-jobs/story?id=90375709;]//LASA-بيلال

The Federal Reserve escalated its fight against inflation this week, instituting a major rate increase and saying more will likely follow. The moves will cause a jump in the number of unemployed Americans by the end of next year, the central bank said.

The Fed has put forward a series of aggressive interest rate hikes in recent months as it tries to slash price increases by slowing the economy and choking off demand. But the approach risks tipping the United States into a recession and causing widespread joblessness.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Unemployment Rising – 2NC

Unemployment is rising now

Rugaber 6-2 [Christopher; Federal Reserve and Economy Reporter, Associated Press. Washington, D.C.. Business and Finance; 6-2-2023; "Both U.S. hiring and unemployment jumped last month. Here's what that says about the economy"; PBS NewsHour; https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/both-u-s-hiring-and-unemployment-jumped-last-month-heres-what-that-says-about-the-economy;]//LASA-بيلال

Overall, the report painted a mostly encouraging picture of the job market. Yet there were some mixed messages in the May figures. Notably, the unemployment rate rose to 3.7 percent, from a five-decade low of 3.4 percent in April. It’s the highest unemployment rate since October. (The government compiles the unemployment data using a different survey than the one used to calculate job gains, and the two surveys sometimes conflict.)

Is the labor market as strong as the gain of 339,000 jobs suggests?

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Recruitment High – 2NC

New initiatives are increasing recruitment

Sztalkoper 6-6 [Kamil; Public Affairs Officer with the United States Army who is committed to telling the story of Soldiers, Veterans, and family members. Over 17 years of experience in peacekeeping operations, leadership, team building, social media, media relations, and community relations in multiple stateside and overseas locations; 6-6-23; "Army launches ‘app’ to increase engagement with recruits"; army.mil; https://www.army.mil/article/267318/army_launches_app_to_increase_engagement_with_recruits;]//LASA-بيلال

WASHINGTON - U.S. Army Recruiting Command and the Army Recruiting and Retention Task Force (ARTF) have partnered to launch a new program, the Prep for Success Digital Engagement Experience. This program aims to enhance the recruit-recruiter experience by helping future soldiers prepare for basic training while streamlining the recruitment process. Applications designed to serve as training aides and information guides are easily downloaded directly onto the cell phones of recruits at no cost. At the same time, Recruiters get a new tool making it easier for them to do their mission.

Late in the Fall of 2022, the ARTF held a design-thinking workshop which included Army recruiters, Army Reserve officers, other members of the Army’s accessions enterprise and even some members of the Air Force. During the workshop the need for an enhanced engagement experience between recruiters and prospective recruits became glaringly obvious.

2023 DDI Negative
Recruitment DA › UQ › UQ – Recruitment High – 2NC

New Programs

Lacdan 22 [Joe; Writer-Editor at Defense Media Activity; September 12 2022; "Army leaders implement measures to bolster recruiting"; army.mil; https://www.army.mil/article/260123/army_leaders_implement_measures_to_bolster_recruiting;]//LASA-بيلال

In August, the service introduced its Future Soldier Preparatory Course at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, to help potential recruits meet the academic and physical standards required to enlist. The 90-day pilot program features training focused on achieving required body fat composition and necessary academics before recruits enter basic combat training.

“We want to help them meet the standards of the United States Army,” McConville said.