Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › L - MMT

Empirics Prove that MMT practices lead to devastating hyperinflation that worsens poverty

Talgo, 21 --- Chris Talgo is senior editor at The Heartland Institute. (Chris Talgo, "The false promise of modern monetary theory", 3-30-2021, Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/545502-the-false-promise-of-modern-monetary-theory/)//EG

Once upon a time, not that long ago actually, the federal deficit and national debt mattered. In 2008, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama said, “We’re just taking out a credit card from the Bank of China, essentially. We’re borrowing that money. And we’ve added $4 trillion worth of debt since George Bush took office. Keep in mind, just to give you some perspective, the first 42 presidents amassed $5 trillion worth of debt.” During his two terms, Obama added $8.6 trillion to the national debt — more than double his predecessor. President Trump added $6.7 trillion. In one term. As of this writing, the U.S. national debt stands at $28.1 trillion. In 1960, the U.S. national debt was $286 billion. In 1980, it increased to $908 billion. By 2000, it grew to $5.6 trillion. In 2010, it ballooned to $13.5 trillion. Just seven years later, it crossed the $20 trillion threshold. America’s debt-to-GDP ratio is also on an unsustainable trajectory. In 1960, it was 53 percent. In 1980, it decreased to 34 percent. In 2000, it ticked up to 58 percent. As of 2020, it had skyrocketed to 129 percent — exceeding the previous high of 118 percent, set at the end of World War II. This is significant. And ominous. We can blame our debt debacle on many things: decades of out-of-control entitlement spending, the pandemic, costly wars in the Middle East, to name a few. However, let’s not overlook the meteoric rise of modern monetary theory (MMT). For those unaccustomed with MMT, in essence it states that the U.S. government can print and spend money limitlessly. Deficits don’t matter. Neither does the national debt. MMT has several high-profile adherents, from Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) to Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.). Many books have been written on MMT, most famously “The Deficit Myth: Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People’s Economy,” by Stephanie Kelton. In a nutshell, MMT true believers claim that age-old economic dogma is backwards. MMT turns traditional economic theory on its head. According to Investopedia, “The central idea of MMT is that governments with a fiat currency system under their control can and should print (or create with a few keystrokes in today’s digital age) as much money as they need to spend because they cannot go broke.” Actually, governments can and do go broke when they defy the rules of commonsense economics. However, MMT advocates claim they have the secret recipe to avoid the pitfalls of currency debasement and mountains of debt. Once again, as Investopedia explains, “[A]ccording to MMT, large government debt isn’t the precursor to collapse we have been led to believe it is, countries like the U.S. can sustain much greater deficits without cause for concern, and a small deficit or surplus can be extremely harmful and cause a recession since deficit spending is what builds people’s savings. … MMT theorists explain that debt is simply money the government put into the economy and didn’t tax back.” This is ludicrous. Government deficit spending is not an economic boon. It is a hindrance to economic growth that impoverishes future generations. Furthermore, despite what MMT supporters claim, printing huge sums of money will cause inflation. As Jonathan Hartley writes that the claim “ignores the dark history of debt monetization leading to hyperinflation … printing money and monetizing debt — even when that debt was partly denominated in local currency — led to devastating inflation in Austria, Hungary, Poland, and Weimar Germany during the first half of the 20th century.” The same thing has occurred more recently in Brazil, Venezuela and Zimbabwe. Modern monetary theory is far from groundbreaking, let alone modern. It is simply a failed idea that has been tried many times and has led to economic destruction in every case. Although MMT proponents would like us to believe that it is a contemporary economic breakthrough, don’t believe the hype. Commonsense refutes MMT on its face.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › L - MMT

The response to the pandemic and subsequent inflation proves the failure of MMT to better the economy

Smith, 22 – Karl W. Smith is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. Previously, he was vice president for federal policy at the Tax Foundation and assistant professor of economics at the University of North Carolina. (Karl Smith, “No, This Isn’t Modern Monetary Theory’s Moment”, 3/8/22, Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-02-08/high-u-s-inflation-shows-flaw-of-modern-monetary-theory#xj4y7vzkg)//EG

Americans are not happy with the economy, and inflation is their No. 1 concern. It’s odd, then, that proponents of Modern Monetary Theory — a school of economics that advocates the kind of policy that has brought the U.S. economy to this point — are claiming this moment as vindication. To the contrary, the current state of the economy shows that MMT, as it’s known, is less a theory than a disposition. And to the extent it is a theory, it is proving every bit as impractical as its critics charge. Some background: Virtually all economists agree that productive government investments in infrastructure or scientific research can help economic growth. Mainstream economists still debate whether stimulus spending during a recession can be a net boost to the economy, even if it doesn’t pass a traditional cost-benefit analysis. Proponents of MMT go beyond that. They argue the government can spend as much as it wants, whenever it wants, without worrying about the fiscal cost. What matters, they argue, are so-called real resource constraints — a shortage of building materials, for example. When pressed on how those constraints would be managed in practice, proponents of MMT admit that, in theory, too much government spending could lead to inflation. But they quickly add that inflation is unlikely to be truly problematic — and if it is, the government could just stop spending. Granted, the mere mention of unchecked government spending sets some economists’ hair ablaze, and there have been a lot of rash complaints about MMT. But there are also more considered critiques. One is that MMT assumes that central banks such as the Federal Reserve would behave in ways the Fed would never behave. In the real world, these critics said, the Fed would raise interest rates in response to rising inflation — thereby increasing the amount the government had to spend to balance its books. Another critique is that popularly elected governments are not especially well equipped to predict how their spending will affect inflation, nor are they disciplined enough to tailor their budgets to keep inflation in check. Indeed, this lack of expertise and discipline is one of the reasons for central banks in first place. All of which brings us to the present day. In response to Covid, the federal government spent trillions of dollars on relief, and the Fed pushed interest rates to zero. The idea was that these policies would be short-lived. But as the pandemic wore on, they were kept in place. In effect, America was putting MMT into practice. Congress borrowed and spent with little concern for long-term limits, and the Fed supported that borrowing by keeping interest rates at zero. As a result, MMT proponents are fond of pointing out, the U.S. economy bounced back stronger than any of its peer nations. Yes, they admit, the U.S. has also had stronger inflation. But MMT proponents note that they had always acknowledged that possibility, and that inflation was more a result of the unusual circumstances of a pandemic than of any particular aspect of MMT. Both of these answers are unsatisfying. In truth, MMT is failing precisely as its more sanguine critics predicted. First, it’s worth noting that, had the U.S. government adopted some of the policies that MMT proponents favor, inflation would probably be a lot higher. Among other things, they envisioned giving a $15-per-hour government job to anyone who wanted one. If that made it difficult for the private sector to attract talent, then it could just raise wages (and presumably prices). This is a more extreme version of what employers faced when Congress temporarily added a bonus to unemployment insurance. One result was widespread labor shortages and a rise in costs for retailers. The inability of the White House to admit that it might have gone overboard is precisely what critics meant when they accused MMT of being “delusional.” It’s not that there is something particularly dishonest about this administration; it’s that any administration would find it hard to tell its most ardent supporters that their most wished-for programs are wrecking the economy. The best it can do is wait inflation out — which is precisely what President Joe Biden’s administration is doing. Second, the Fed is now planning to raise interest rates, perhaps quite aggressively. This means that consumers and businesses will soon face rising costs of investment, while the federal government will find it more expensive to finance its debt. If Congress raises taxes, that will exacerbate the difficulties facing families and businesses. If the government borrows more money, that will exacerbate the spending problem — which led to inflation in the first place. In other words: Congress can’t easily stop spending too much, and the Fed can’t easily accommodate its failure to do so. The bottom line is that, even in extraordinary circumstances like a pandemic, the government has to be mindful of the consequences of excess public spending. The idea that it could disregard such consequences was always dubious as a theory, and now it has been discredited as a practice.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › MMT Inflation DA 1NC

Declining dollar hegemony drives a laundry list of existential crises.

Zoffer 20, (Josh graduated from Harvard University with a B.A. magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa, with highest honors in Social Studies and is currently a student at Yale Law School), "To End Forever War, Keep the Dollar Globally Dominant," New Republic, 2/3/2020, https://newrepublic.com/article/156417/end-forever-war-keep-dollar-globally-dominant // EE

In early 2016, Obama Treasury Secretary Jack Lew cautioned that the dollar’s dominance as a global currency rested, in part, on the U.S. government’s reluctance to fully weaponize it. If foreign markets and governments “feel that we will deploy sanctions without sufficient justification or for inappropriate reasons,” he warned, “we should not be surprised if they look for ways to avoid doing business in the United States or in U.S. dollars.” Lew’s case stemmed from the more fundamental view that the dollar’s international role is “a source of tremendous strength for our economy, a benefit for U.S. companies and a driver of U.S. global leadership”—in other words, a role worth keeping. This view is emblematic of American financial governance since the Second World War. U.S. economic analysts, especially at the Treasury, have jealously guarded the dollar’s role and the many benefits it offers: the ability to run large deficits at low cost and disproportionate influence over the structure of the global economy, among others.

Yet in their recent article in The New Republic, David Adler and Daniel Bessner argue the U.S. should abandon these advantages. In their view, the dollar’s role has encouraged American militarism and should be relinquished to curb such behavior. Dollar hegemony is not without cost, but to renounce it would be a profound mistake. Adler and Bessner’s view neglects the sizable economic benefits the dollar’s role confers on the U.S., as well as its possible use as an antidote to military adventurism. It ignores the enormous good that can be done with deficit spending, much of which has gone to the American military but could instead fund progressive programs. And it elides the inability of the U.S. and its global trading partners to shift away from dollar dominance without creating worldwide financial distress. Adler and Bessner are right that the U.S. has misused its privilege, but Washington should not abandon it; rather, American leaders should seek to transform it.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › MMT Inflation DA 1NC

Economic decline and national debt undercuts US Leaderships-Leads to deterrence and assurance failures

Landry Signé 12[Landry Signé, "The Real National Security Threat: America's Debt",7-10-2012, Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-real-national-security-threat-americas-debt/, 1LEE]

Economic renewal and fiscal reform have become the preeminent issues, not only for domestic and economic policy but for foreign policy as well. As the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Michael G. Mullen, was fond of saying, national debt has become perhaps our top national security threat. And neither major presidential candidate is doing enough about it. This issue needs to be framed as crucial not just for our future prosperity but for international stability as well.

The United States has been running trillion-dollar deficits, resulting in a huge explosion in the country’s indebtedness. Publicly held debt now equals 70% of gross domestic product, a threshold many economists consider significant and highly worrisome. Making matters worse, half of our current deficit financing is being provided by foreigners. We are getting by with low interest rates and tolerable levels of domestic investment only because they find U.S. debt attractive, which may not last.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › MMT Inflation DA 1NC

Inflation causes a shift away from dollar heg.

Kaushal Talukder 23 [Kaushal Talukder, Student at National Institute of Securities Markets, "How us dollar losing its hegemony",4-1-2023, No Publication, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-us-dollar-losing-its-hegemony-kaushal-talukder/, 1LEE]

After World War II, the United States emerged as the largest economy and the most powerful military and political force in the world. In 1944, at the Bretton Woods Conference in New Hampshire, the US and other major countries agreed to establish a new international monetary system based on fixed exchange rates, with the US dollar as the anchor currency. Under this system, other countries could peg their currencies to the US dollar, and the US would guarantee to exchange dollars for gold at a fixed rate of $35 per ounce.

This system worked well for several decades, as the US economy grew and the dollar became the primary currency for international trade and finance. However, in the 1960s, the US began to run large trade deficits and spend more on the Vietnam War, which led to a loss of confidence in the dollar and a rise in inflation. In 1971, President Nixon announced that the US would no longer redeem dollars for gold, effectively ending the Bretton Woods system and leading to a period of floating exchange rates and greater volatility in currency markets.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Inflation DA › MMT Inflation DA 1NC

Empirics prove that printing more money will cause devastating hyperinflation

Hartley, 20 --- Jonathan Hartley is a visiting fellow at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity and a master’s in public policy candidate at the Harvard Kennedy School. (Jonathan Hartley, "The Weakness of Modern Monetary Theory", 2020, National Affairs, https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/the-weakness-of-modern-monetary-theory)//EG

MONEY PRINTING AND INFLATION MMT proponents argue that central banks can print money without triggering dangerous levels of inflation. This claim not only overlooks the theoretical considerations outlined above, it also ignores the dark history of debt monetization leading to hyperinflation. As Thomas Sargent famously documented in his 1982 classic, The Ends of Four Big Inflations, printing money and monetizing debt — even when that debt was partly denominated in local currency — led to devastating inflation in Austria, Hungary, Poland, and Weimar Germany during the first half of the 20th century. Austria and Hungary — two states formed through the dissolution of the Austro-Hungarian Empire — found themselves greatly diminished in both size and power following WWI. Since Austria-Hungary was deemed an aggressor of the war, its successor states owed the Allies substantial amounts in war reparations. To pay off the reparations while alleviating large-scale food shortages and unemployment, the Austrian government ran significant deficits — which it financed by selling treasury bills to the Austrian section of the liquidated Austro-Hungarian bank. At the same time in Hungary, political turmoil led to considerable budget shortfalls, which the government financed by borrowing heavily from the Hungarian section of the bank and increasing the volume of low-interest loans issued to private entities. As a result, both the Austrian crown and the Hungarian krone depreciated rapidly while domestic prices rose. This led to flight from each currency by domestic actors and foreign investors alike and, ultimately, to hyperinflation in both countries. Poland, meanwhile, emerged from WWI as an independent nation after over a century of foreign rule. Cobbled together from portions of Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia, Poland inherited inflated currencies from these three partitioning powers — each of which had financed their respective participation in WWI through the printing press — and an empty treasury. The fighting in Poland did not end in 1918, either, as the nation found itself in a second war with Soviet Russia that lasted until the fall of 1920. In order to settle this and other border disputes, and to rebuild after the devastating WWI occupation, Poland amassed substantial debt. Like both Austria and Hungary, Poland financed its deficit spending by printing massive amounts of currency. In 1918, one U.S. dollar was equivalent to nine Polish marks; by the end of 1923, that same dollar was worth 6,375,000 Polish marks. Of the four post-WWI cases of hyperinflation Sargent covers, none looms larger in the historical imagination than that of Weimar Germany. Germany had financed its war effort through deficit spending and suspension of the gold standard, believing that it would be able to achieve a swift, decisive victory and pay off its debt by annexing wealthier territories and imposing reparations on its defeated enemies. What occurred was very much the opposite: Over four long years of fighting, Germany accumulated considerable war debt while significantly devaluing its currency, the German mark. And since Germany was on the losing side of the war, instead of being paid reparations, it owed staggering levels of reparations to the Allies at the war's end. Making matters worse, the Reparations Commission demanded Germany pay 132 billion gold marks as part of the London Payment Plan. The German government responded by printing more German marks to pay what it owed, which only devalued its currency further. In 1922, Germany failed to pay an installment it owed to France, which prompted the French occupation of Germany's primary industrial region to ensure repayment. The German government responded by calling for what amounted to a strike, then offered the workers financial support — again, financed by printing more currency and issuing loans at interest rates far below the rate of inflation. By 1923, German currency was worthless: One U.S. dollar at the time was equivalent to 4,210,500,000,000 German marks. But hyperinflation is not just a phenomenon of the distant past. In fact, instances of hyperinflation have occurred over recent decades in countries like Brazil, Zimbabwe, and Venezuela. Brazil experienced hyperinflation in the final decades of the 20th century. This resulted from its decision to pay down high external debt but avoid raising taxes. Instead, the country turned to printing money. By 1990, inflation reached a monthly rate as high as 82.4%. Hyperinflation in Brazil was only resolved when it created a separate unit of account, the Unidade Real de Valor, or URV, to exist parallel to its existing currency, the cruzeiro. Ultimately, this new unit of account became the Brazilian real, replacing the cruzeiro and quashing the inflationary spiral. For Zimbabwe, the trouble began in the late 1990s, when the government adopted several spending plans — including the compulsory government purchase of white-owned commercial farms and generous pension plans for veterans of the country's war of independence — without budgeting for them. This triggered panic among foreign investors, who pulled capital from the Zimbabwean markets, thereby causing a crash of the country's currency. Subsequent unwise military ventures drove Zimbabwe further into debt. Meanwhile, the forced seizure of farmland and resulting violence nearly halted all agricultural production. Since the Zimbabwean economy was too fragile to grow its way out of debt, and imposing new taxes to raise revenue was a political non-starter, monetary and fiscal authorities began to monetize the country's debt by printing more money. This ultimately led to hyperinflation so extreme — at an estimated 79,000,000,000% per month in November 2008 — that Zimbabwe was effectively forced to substitute its own currency with the U.S. dollar shortly thereafter through a process economists call "dollarization." The seeds of Venezuela's ongoing struggles with hyperinflation were sown in the early 2000s, when the nation's economy and the value of its currency, the bolívar, became heavily dependent on revenues from oil exports. The rise in oil prices that largely coincided with President Hugo Chávez's term in office — from 1998 until his death in 2013 — ensured a steady stream of foreign revenue into government coffers. This allowed the Chávez regime to increase deficit spending in pursuit of its socialist policy agenda. Then in 2014 — a year after Chávez's successor, Nicolás Maduro, took office — the global price of oil collapsed, leading to a steep decline in government revenues. Foreign demand for the bolívar to purchase Venezuelan oil fell, contributing to a decline in the currency's value. The Venezuelan economy was already in recession at the time, but instead of pulling back on Chávez's generous social-welfare programs or increasing taxes, Maduro's regime responded by ramping up deficit spending and printing more currency to finance the government's debts. By 2016, hyperinflation had set in. At the end of 2018, inflation rates in Venezuela reached an estimated 80,000% per year. As these examples demonstrate, the correlation between currency printing and hyperinflation is undeniable, the causal relationship intuitive. Yet MMT proponents continue to contest it. In their canonical MMT textbook Macroeconomics, William Mitchell, L. Randall Wray, and Martin Watts state that "[n]o simple proportionate relationship exists between rises in the money supply and rises in the general price level." Wray, a Bard College professor and one of MMT's key proponents in academia, has gone on to say "there is no empirical evidence to support the belief that raising interest rates fights inflation." Stephanie Kelton, author of The Deficit Myth and former advisor to Senator Bernie Sanders's presidential campaign, argues that inflation is the result, not of monetary policy, but of "overspending" — spending beyond what it takes for an economy to reach "full employment" (which she defines not according to the mainstream economic concept of "natural rate of unemployment," but as the 0% unemployment rate that would occur under a government jobs guarantee). Such claims fly in the face of both historical evidence and traditional macroeconomic theory. And it's worth remembering, too, that hyperinflation often hurts the poor the most, since consumption makes up a greater fraction of their incomes.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC - Productivity

A carbon tax generates a productive economy by concentrating activity and incentivizing immigration

Conte et al, 22 --- Bruno Conte is an Assistant Professor at Alma Mater Studiorum – Università di Bologna. Klaus Desmet is a Ruth and Kenneth Altshuler Centennial Interdisciplinary Professor at SMU. Esteban Rossi-Hansberg is a Glen A. Lloyd Distinguished Service Professor, Kenneth C. Griffin Department of Economics. (Bruno Conte, Klaus Desmet, Esteban Rossi-Hansberg, "On the Geographic Implications of Carbon Taxes", 11-18-2022, BFI, https://bfi.uchicago.edu/insight/research-summary/on-the-geographic-implications-of-carbon-taxes/)//EG

A carbon tax rebated locally can, if not too large, increase the size of an economy by concentrating economic activity in its high-productivity, non-agricultural core, and by incentivizing immigration; these predictions hold for the United States and the European Union. Carbon taxes, which are levied on the carbon emissions required to produce goods and services, are considered an optimal solution to combat climate change because they help bridge the gap between the private and social costs of carbon. Is one company or industry producing an inordinate amount of carbon? Tax them at a rate to bring their carbon emissions—and the aggregate emissions of the country—in line with global goals. And therein lies the rub. How do you get countries around the world to agree on a global carbon tax plan? How do you prevent companies from moving to countries with no carbon tax? And, if you cannot get all countries (or at least the biggest polluters) to agree on a carbon tax, does it even make sense for countries to go it alone? According to conventional wisdom, the answer to that last question is No. However, this new research argues that this reasoning is incomplete and misleading because it ignores how unilateral carbon taxes (or those issued by one country or group of countries) interact with the forces that shape the economic geography of the world. The authors show that the spatial response (or that within and among countries) to a unilateral carbon tax can lead to a local expansion of the region introducing the tax, and to global welfare gains. Before describing the authors’ findings, a very brief note about their model (please see the working paper for more details), which features a realistic world economy divided into more than 17,000 locations. In this world, a carbon tax that mitigates global warming also affects the geography of absolute and comparative advantage because sectors differ in their energy intensity (non-agriculture emits more carbon than agriculture). Also, people in this world have the possibility to move. Migration and trade patterns adjust to carbon tax rebates, which benefits locations specialized in sectors with a higher effective carbon tax. The authors’ quantitative policy analysis focuses mainly on the European Union (EU), which has plans for a region-wide carbon tax, though they show very similar results for a carbon tax introduced by the US. The authors’ analysis offers the following predictions: A hypothetical uniform carbon tax of 40 US$ per ton of CO2 introduced by the EU and rebated locally can increase the size of the EU economy by further concentrating economic activity in its high-productivity non-agricultural core, and by attracting more immigrants to Europe. This, in turn, leads to a more efficient global distribution of population, so that world welfare improves. What explains this result? The answer lies in how a carbon tax acts to shift economic activity across space. This may seem counterintuitive. Readers might expect an EU carbon tax to weaken Europe’s comparative advantage in non-agriculture. Indeed, the higher energy intensity of non-agriculture implies costs are pushed up more by a carbon tax, leading to a relative drop in nonagricultural output. If carbon tax revenue were lost, this would be the case: The EU would shrink, and global welfare would decline. However, when carbon tax revenue is locally rebated, the results are reversed. The higher relative tax burden in non-agriculture is only partly passed on to wages, so once local rebating is added, regions specializing in non-agriculture experience a relative gain in income. The authors formally prove how the introduction of a carbon tax in a single location can generate a positive income effect on its economy. Importantly, this tax must be relatively moderate; if too high, these benefits are lost due to standard distortionary effects. In the case of the EU, this income effect generates migration from agricultural to non-agricultural regions, causing non-agricultural output to increase relative to agricultural output. This effect is further amplified because businesses tend to cluster close to each other and in high population areas, a phenomenon known as agglomeration forces. A sort of positive feedback loop develops. As Europe’s non-agricultural core grows, the EU attracts more immigrants, and its economy becomes larger. And although real income per capita in the EU drops, the reallocation of population and economic activity from less productive areas of the world improves global efficiency and welfare. This suggests that in the absence of a carbon tax there is too little geographic concentration in the EU core and there are too few people in Europe. As such, an EU carbon tax with local rebating acts as a place-based policy that subsidizes Europe’s non-agricultural core and attracts more people to move to the European Union. This point bears stressing: Not only does a unilateral EU carbon tax lower global carbon emission, thus mitigating planet warming, it also increases Europe’s weight in the world economy while improving global welfare and efficiency. If a unilateral carbon tax is introduced by the United States (US), instead of by the EU, the global welfare gains are similar. Bottom Line: For policymakers, this research reveals that a modest unilateral carbon tax can be globally welfare-improving while also expanding a local economy. Local rebating subsidizes highly productive non-agricultural regions and incentivizes people to move to these regions in the EU or the US. With more people living in the developed world, global efficiency and global welfare improve, while planet warming ebbs.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC - Productivity

A carbon tax will boost productivity by preventing the devastating effects of climate change.

Williams 15, -- Rob Williams studies both environmental policy and tax policy, with a particular focus on interactions between the two. In addition to his role at the University of Maryland, he is the Chief Economist for the Climate Leadership Council, a University Fellow at Resources for the Future and a Research Associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research. He was previously an associate professor at the University of Texas, Austin; a visiting research scholar at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research; and an Andrew W. Mellon Fellow at the Brookings Institution. Williams has served as a coeditor of both the Journal of Public Economics and the Journal of Environmental Economics and Management. (Roberton Williams, “Macroeconomic Effects of Carbon Taxes”, IMF eLibrary, 3/1/15, https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781138825369/ch005.xml0//EG

A third channel through which carbon taxes may affect the economy is via their environmental effects (primarily in mitigating potential damage from climate change, but also reducing emissions of other pollutants). Climate change is predicted to have a wide range of effects that might influence the economy. Climate can directly affect economic productivity, particularly for agriculture. Sea level rise can damage coastal property and/or require defenses to protect it. To the extent that imposing a carbon tax can mitigate those and other effects, it can influence the economy.22 While the impact of environmental quality on economic growth is difficult to model, there is a small body of research addressing this issue. Williams (2002) outlines the theory behind the relationship between environmental improvements and economic growth. Pollution can reduce productivity, and hence economic activity, for two reasons. The first and more obvious reason is that the lower productivity leads directly to lower economic output. In addition, that lower productivity implies lower returns to labor and capital, and thus reduces incentives to work and to save. In effect, reduced productivity caused by pollution acts like a tax (but with the “revenue” simply being lost, rather than going to the government). This change in incentives magnifies the effect of pollution on economic activity. Effects on human health can also change incentives to save and invest. Thus, to the extent that a carbon tax reduces future damages from climate change, that could affect the economy. Practical magnitudes of the macroeconomic effects of pollution are difficult to estimate. The leading work in this area is Barrage (2013), which uses a simple model of the world economy linked together with a simple model of the climate. The paper considers four different ways in which climate change potentially affects economic growth – via effects on mortality, morbidity, labor productivity, and health care expenditures. Its results suggest that climate change could have a significant negative effect on the economy – and thus that mitigating climate change could be beneficial for the economy. Again, future research in this area could be very valuable.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Leakage

Taxation solves.

Weisbach and Blum 21.( , Walter J. Blum Professor of Law, University of Chicago Law School and , James Burrows Moffatt Professor of Economics, Yale University Department of Economics. “A Solution to the Leakage Problem.” Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago. December 4th 2021. https://epic.uchicago.edu/area-of-focus/a-solution-to-border-adjustment-tax-leakage/)

Broadening the carbon tax base increases its effectiveness, including through policy that expands U.S. exports. Expanding the tax base to other countries, even those outside the taxing coalition, further reduces emissions and leakage. The United States can do so by imposing border taxes on imports of goods and developing export policy that seeks to expand, rather than just maintain, its export margin. It should do so through a policy of tax rebates and if necessary, subsidies, for exports so that it exports more with the carbon policy in place than without. The figure illustrates what a model suggests is ‘optimal’ policy: the combination of taxes and subsidies that maximizes domestic well-being. It combines an extraction tax, border adjustments (at a lower rate) on energy, a border adjustment on imports of goods, and a policy for the export of goods that expands exports through a combination of taxes and subsidies on exported goods. Expanding exports in this way expands the carbon price and allows greater emissions reductions. It is the environmentally best policy and the policy that is best for the United States but would be complex from an implementation and legal standpoint.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Leakage

Carbon export taxes and border adjustments prevent leakage.

Weisbach and Blum 21.( , Walter J. Blum Professor of Law, University of Chicago Law School and , James Burrows Moffatt Professor of Economics, Yale University Department of Economics. “A Solution to the Leakage Problem.” Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago. December 4th 2021. https://epic.uchicago.edu/area-of-focus/a-solution-to-border-adjustment-tax-leakage/)

The traditional approach of taxing domestic emissions and imposing border adjustments to control leakage suffers from a fundamental flaw. The key to controlling leakage and to tax system design is moderating the effects of the tax on the price of energy. A tax on domestic emissions and that tax combined with border adjustments, however, both push the price of energy in the same direction: down. As a result, these policies do not, and cannot, perform well on a global basis. Moreover, border adjustments are complex and legally questionable. A better approach is to tax domestic extraction and to combine that with border adjustments (at a lower rate than the extraction tax) on energy and possibly goods or a subset of goods. It takes advantage of the offsetting effect on the price of energy from extraction taxes and either production or consumption taxes. This approach is simpler to administer, achieves much better outcomes, and is clearly legal. Even better results can be reached by adding border adjustments on the import of goods and an export policy that retains or expands U.S. exports. Whether these additions are desirable depends on how much complexity and legal uncertainty they would introduce. Pricing carbon is the most efficient way to reduce emissions and address climate change. The design of the pricing system, particularly in light of the potential for leakage, however, can make important differences in how well it functions. As the incoming Biden administration and the new Congress consider new carbon pricing proposals, they should keep these insights for their design in mind.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC- Carbon Tax= Regressive

A Carbon Tax is key to economic redistribution.

Shi Ling 21 (Hsu, Shi-Ling. Shi-Ling Hsu is the D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law” Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality.” Harvard Law & Policy Review. January 5, 2021.  or  https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3760667)

But there is good reason to question whether carbon taxation is truly regressive after all. Relatively recent economic research has delved more deeply into higher-order economic effects of a carbon tax.59 In addition to considering the immediate budgetary effects on households, a more sophisticated economic analysis must also consider the effect of carbon taxation on demand for fossil fuels, adjustments made by consumers and producers, the effects on intermediate industries, and the effects on shareholder income caused by a decrease in demand for fossil fuels. As it turns out, a carbon tax that decreases the demand for fossil fuels also reduces the returns to capital, which would represent losses to the high-income households that own stock.60 This is especially true of investments in fossil fuel industries, such as power plants, pipelines, and refineries, which are large, expensive, and cannot be repurposed for some other use.61 Fossil fuel industries could try to pass the added cost of carbon taxation onto consumers, but consumers can find ways to avoid the tax by reducing their carbon footprint. Gasoline consumers drive less.62 Homeowners adjust their thermostats and conserve electricity.63 Fossil fuel consumers buy more efficient appliances, vehicles, and lighting.64 By contrast, fossil fuel industries and fossil fuel-intensive industries tend to be heavily invested in expensive brick-and-mortar machinery, making adjustment difficult.65 The price elasticity of supply and demand, the capacity of producers and consumers to change their behavior in response to changing prices, are central in determining whether producers or consumers will bear the added cost of a tax.66 In the case of fossil fuels, it would appear that consumers have the upper hand.

In addition, it is worth noticing, as these researchers have, that many poor households receive government benefits that are indexed to inflation, so that an increase in energy prices (atleast energy from fossil fuels) caused by a carbon tax would be largely invisible to most government transfer recipients.67 Not all government transfers are indexed. In fact, indexing is a complicated matter, as parts of some programs are indexed and some are not. Most benefits under Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare, and the Children's Health Insurance Program, which make up about for 85% of government assistance programs68 are indexed,69 and therefore protect their recipients from increased energy prices. On the other hand, unemployment insurance, public assistance, and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits are not indexed,70 and are more likely to be more targeted at needy households, so those recipients remain vulnerable to higher energy costs caused by a carbon tax. On the whole, however, the effect of indexing of government benefits would offset, for a good number of poor households, increased energy prices brought on by a carbon tax. All this is to say that a carbon tax is likely not regressive as widely believed. It turns out that a carbon tax would impose a fair amount of economic pain on fossil fuel industries and on fossil-intensive industries, which would in turn impose a measure of economic pain on rich households that depend on investment income that, at least in part, depends upon those industries. If by "regressive" one means that the poor bear a disproportionate amount of the economic pain, it would appear to merit a more complicated discussion.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Green Paradox

Only a small green paradox would occur, and it is outweighed by a long-term divestment

Bauer 18 (Bauer, N., McGlade, C., Hilaire, J. et al. Christophe is a senior energy analyst in the Directorate of Sustainability, Technology and Outlooks of the International Energy Agency.” Divestment prevails over the green paradox when anticipating strong future climate policies. “Nature Climate Change. January 19th 2018. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-017-0053-1)

Without any explicit CO2 taxes (the ‘baseline’), global annual CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion and industry grow from 32 Gt  in 2010 to around 60 Gt in 2050 (Fig. ). When CO2 taxes are announced, the divestment effect dominates the green paradox effect in both models in all tax cases regardless of the implementation delay (Fig. ). The green paradox occurs in the period immediately following announcement of the CO2 tax, and is largest for the low-tax case when the implementation lag is extended to 2040. However, even at its annual maximum level, it never exceeds 1 GtCO2, and its cumulative impact during the implementation lag remains smaller than that of the divestment effect. The divestment effect increases with the tax level: in the low-tax cases, cumulative emission reductions during the implementation lag are 5% below the baseline. For the medium tax, this increases to 5–10% and to 10–20% in the high-tax case. When the tax is actually introduced, annual emissions are well below the baseline. For example, with the medium tax introduced in 2030, annual emissions are 8–9 GtCO2 lower than the baseline (and within the range of NDC estimates Fig. ).

These impacts on total CO2 emissions can be understood by examining the balance of the counteracting effects on the individual fossil fuel markets (Fig. ). For all tax cases, both models display a strong divestment effect in coal use while the green paradox is generally observed in oil markets (Fig. ). A green paradox effect does occur in coal markets in the period immediately following announcement of a CO2 tax but only if the tax implementation is delayed to 2040. The increase in coal consumption is marginal: it is largest in the low-tax case, but annual consumption is never more than 4% above the baseline level. As the implementation date approaches, while coal prices are much lower than in the baseline, the divestment effect outweighs the green paradox and coal consumption drops below the baseline. In the oil market, the strongest green paradox effect occurs in REMIND for the high-tax case starting in 2040: oil output in 2030 is 21 EJ per year (9%) greater than in the baseline scenario, but since annual coal use is more than 77 EJ below the baseline level in that period, CO2 emissions are lower compared with the baseline. Gas markets react very differently in both models. In TIAM-UCL, gas demand grows to substitute coal, which increases gas prices. This substitution partly neutralizes the divestment effect in the coal market. In REMIND, a small green paradox effect in 2020 is followed by a notable divestment effect in later periods.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Solvency

A Carbon tax is the only way to solve for climate change no other policy solves.

Shi Ling 21 .Hsu, Shi-Ling. Shi-Ling Hsu is the D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law” Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality.” Harvard Law & Policy Review. January 5, 2021.  or  https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3760667

Carbon taxation has become a central, if understated component of a comprehensive program to address climate change. A carbon tax is a unitary tax on emissions of carbon dioxide, and potentially other greenhouse gases that warm the climate, targeted almost exclusively on the combustion of fossil fuels. While economists have universally endorsed the idea of a carbon tax,1 it remains politically challenging for lawmakers to enact one.2 Besides opposition from those denying the significance of climate change,3 there is surprisingly tepid support from progressive groups concerned with social and economic justice, in addition to climate change.4 Progressive ambivalence about carbon taxation is both understandable and misplaced. It is understandable because carbon taxation is widely believed to be regressive.5 It has become standard fare that a carbon tax increases energy costs, which makes up a larger portion of a poor household's budget than a rich one.6 As it turns out, this is probably a misperception : carbon taxes actually hurt fossil fuel industries, which are owned by relatively wealthy shareholders, more than they injure consumers.7 Moreover, carbon tax revenues can, and should, be redistributed in such a way that overcompensates most poor households for increased energy costs (resulting from carbon taxation) and undercompensates most rich households, in which case some progress can be made towards economic equality. All that said, however, that redistribution would be fairly modest at the carbon tax levels that are currently under discussion – on the order of a few hundred or a few thousand dollars per household, annually.8 So at best, carbon taxation can only advance modest gains towards greater equality.

At the same time, progressive ambivalence about carbon taxation is also misplaced because climate change itself is the ultimate un-equalizer, amplifying economic inequality to potentially apocalyptic extremes. The most important policy that can be adopted to stave off climate change, as much as possible, is a carbon tax. Without a broad price in the form of a carbon tax, it will be impossible to induce the uncountably many changes that must be made to wean humankind off fossil fuel usage. Conventional environmental laws and regulations can accomplish much, and in any case are needed to fill the gaps left by a carbon tax. But without a policy foundation in the form of a carbon price, the necessary scale of changes will not occur. Carbon taxation is thus a critically important component for economic justice, just by virtue of being the most important policy to minimize climate change. While carbon taxation has only modest potential to advance economic justice, it is critical for minimizing the backsliding that would inevitably occur in a climate-changed future. The case for a carbon tax for the sake of economic justice is thus compelling, if nonobvious. It is important to recognize, as some justice advocates seem to recognize or intuit, that the core goals of carbon taxation and economic justice seem to point in different, though not opposite directions: the preservation of human civilization and the reform of human civilization. However, both of those goals require economic reform, and it so happens that carbon taxation is effective reform for advancing policy in both of those directions. Most importantly, reforming human civilization to achieve economic justice depends upon saving human civilization from climate change. Without that there is no justice for anyone at all.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Solvency

A Carbon Tax is essential to solving for the worst effects of Climate change. \

Shi Ling 21 .Hsu, Shi-Ling. Shi-Ling Hsu is the D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law” Carbon Taxes and Economic Inequality.” Harvard Law & Policy Review. January 5, 2021.  or  https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3760667

The likely effects of climatic changes are broad, frightening, and well-documented.9 The most troubling consequence of climate change may be the exacerbation of inequality. Climate change will be costly for everyone, but it will be catastrophically costly for the poor, and probably even for the middle classes. Among nations, within countries, and even within regions, the gap between rich and poor will grow much larger; the rich will become poorer, but the poor will become much poorer. For the poor in the United States, an increase in the number of extremely hot days (which will be hotter than before) could be fatal for some who lack access to airconditioning or cool spaces.10 Neighborhoods redlined in the past to the disadvantage of communities of color, remain more vulnerable to extreme heat than affluent ones, even within the same part of a city.11 Climate change exacerbates the effects of air pollution,12 which are disproportionately endured by disadvantaged groups.13 And finally, even in a technologically rich future, some work will still need to be performed outdoors. Those tasks will, as they always have, fall upon socioeconomically disadvantaged groups, but will be more dangerous in a climate-changed future.

Inequality inflamed by climate change could be darker still. If, as models suggest, climate change will constrict the supply of resources,15 it is hard to imagine that they will not be hoarded by those with the means to do so.16 Climate change could bring about water shortages, and while water cannot be physically hoarded, water rights can be bought up. In an economy riven by inequality, it is entirely conceivable that the allocation of water determined by market forces could result in a concentration of water rights that threatens access for disadvantaged populations. The degree of economic inequality in the United States and in the world is so great that it is entirely conceivable that wealthy households could maximize their utility by buying up water rights in excess of immediate subsistence needs, paying prices that are well out of the reach of disadvantaged groups. Water need not be physically acquired to be hoarded; buying land with appurtenant water rights is a means of obtaining access to water which could increase the effective price of water.17 Harvard University, with its $50 billion endowment,18 began buying up California vineyards in 2019, with a view towards obtaining groundwater rights as a hedge against rising water prices.19 It is quite plausible to imagine, if California were to suffer another prolonged drought, that fear of water scarcity could trigger a wave of Harvard-like acquisitions, and possibly remove a significant fraction of California water rights from supply.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP › 2NC-Solvency

Carbon Tax is key to create jobs, and cut emissions, only the CP solves.

Marilyn A. Brown, and Majid Ahmadi 19. (Marilyn A. Brown is a professor of sustainable systems at the Georgia Institute of Technology's School of Public Policy, and Majid Ahmadi is a Ph.D. student in the Georgia Institute of Technology's School of Public Policy. “Would a Green New Deal Add or Kill Jobs?” Scientific America. December 17th, 2019. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/would-a-green-new-deal-add-or-kill-jobs1/)

Some pundits say we cannot save the planet without stalling economic growth. Yet there is mounting evidence that both environmental and economic goals can be met. At the center of this argument are several proposals falling under the banner of a green new deal, as well as the Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act (EICDA) of 2019. Our independent review of a Green New Deal (GND) proposed by the U.S. Green Party suggests it is possible to rapidly lower CO2 emissions while also expanding employment over the next three decades by an additional 35 million job years (one job for one year). Yet a more moderate tax on carbon could be economically more attractive.

A FALSE CHOICE BETWEEN CLIMATE AND JOBS

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › Carbon Tax CP

The USFG should implement a progressive federal carbon tax.

Hanlon et al 19 (Seth Hanlon, Alexandra Thornton, Sara Estep, Galen Hendricks. Seth Hanlon is a senior fellow, Alexandra Thornton is senior director of tax policy, Sara Estep is a research assistant, and Galen Hendricks is a special assistant on the Economic Policy team at the Center for American Progress. America Can Do Big Things A Budget Plan for A Better Future. Center for American Progress, June 2019. https://www.americanprogress.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2019/06/PetersonSolutions-report1.pdf)

To reduce carbon emissions, CAP’s plan proposes a progressive, budget-neutral carbon tax. Set at the social cost of carbon emissions, or roughly $52 per metric ton, the carbon tax would shift public and private investment away from carbon-intensive energy sources and toward renewable and lower-carbon energy sources.16 Because low and moderate-income households spend a higher share of their incomes on energy costs and other forms of consumption, a carbon tax can have a regressive distributional effect, including increasing hardship for those with low incomes. The CAP plan therefore proposes to rebate all of the net revenue from the carbon tax to middle- and low income Americans. Such a progressive rebate system can be implemented in a number of ways, including through the combination of lump sum rebates and tax cuts on labor income, which CAP proposed in 2016.17

Establishing a price on carbon emissions is an important step toward confronting climate change—but given the urgency and magnitude of the challenge, it is not sufficient. There’s also a need for substantial public investments. U.S. investment in climate science and clean energy research and development are critical to both domestic and global efforts to understand and combat climate change. To strengthen these critical foundations, the plan doubles federal spending on climate science; clean energy research and development; and programs supporting advanced manufacturing.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › States

States can act as monetary sovereigns by creating common currency to fund jobs guarantees.

Forstater 2018. (Mathew Forstater is an associate professor of economics and black studies and director of the Center for Full Employment and Price Stability at the University of Missouri-Kansas City. “Complementary Currencies in the Solidarity Economy: The Local Job Guarantee.” Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity. . 2018. )

While a second-best solution, because they will still be operating within the constraints of the monetary union, we proposed communities consider issuing a form of complementary currency (CC) quite consistent with neo-chartalist principles, and that a local job guarantee (JG) program be implemented to employ the unemployed in community service jobs. In fact, the general idea of alternative currencies is not one that is new in Europe. In addition, the proposal is one that could be applied in other contexts where a full-blown national JG is not possible, either due to the constraints of some type of fixed exchange rate (whether a peg to another country’s currency or a monetary union) or because of political obstacles. In the USA, for example, proposals for a job guarantee have been put forward as national policies due to the flexibility the federal government has in paying for the program. This flexibility stems from the ability of the Treasury and the Central Bank to work in cooperation to implement fiscal and monetary policies. There are many obstacles, however, to government policies at the federal level, including political, administrative, legislative, and ideological. An alternative route to job creation at the local level would be to use a complementary currency to pay for community service employment. In this way, cities, counties, or states that are currency users in terms of dollars can become currency issuers in terms of the complementary currency. In addition, this form of local financing dovetails nicely with the focus of most job guarantee proposals on local administration and management of JG activities by local governments, non-profits, and NGOs. There are numerous other potential benefits of the local solution for individuals, families, neighborhoods, communities, and regions (Forstater 2013). It is possible that the benefits of a well-managed local currency may mean its implementation is desirable even in communities within a nation operating a neo-chartalist monetary system and managing its budgets according to the principles of functional finance (including a job guarantee), and during prosperous times and not only in the event of a crisis.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › States

States solve—they’ve already stepped in and are best suited to green jobs creation

Crunden 19’ [E. A. Crunden: B.A. in Government (International Relations), Smith College, 4-2-2019, ThinkProgress, “Cities and states are modeling what a Green New Deal could look like,” https://archive.thinkprogress.org/cities-states-green-new-deal-ocasio-cortez-b87147b4b47d/]//LA

Lawmakers in Washington, D.C., have spent the past two months engaged in a war of words over the Green New Deal resolution. Many argue its ambitious goals aren’t feasible within the short timeframe it lays out. Others say there’s simply no alternative. While they’ve been sparring, however, cities and states across the country have been moving forward with their own ambitious plans, showing how elements of the radical proposal could take shape at a local level. “I think at the state and local level, we’ve got the capacity to do it,” Alan Webber, mayor of Santa Fe, New Mexico, told ThinkProgress. Webber’s city has been moving swiftly on climate action over the past few years. Part of that is necessity: New Mexico already suffers from water shortages, something the 2018 National Climate Assessment (NCA) warns will only grow worse in the Southwest as climate change intensifies droughts. With no time to waste, Santa Fe is jumping in head first. “We are on land that belongs to the Pueblo,” Webber said, noting that indigenous communities in the area have paved the way for the “sustainable life” Santa Fe is now pursuing. Last November, Santa Fe adopted a sustainability plan putting the city on the road to carbon neutrality by 2040. That’s 10 years later than the Green New Deal proposes, but it’s still a rapid timeline. And it’s one that includes a host of factors — moving to renewable energy, upgrading buildings and street lighting, water conservation, and local food production, in addition to more run-of-the-mill actions like recycling. “It’s a comprehensive approach to having a sustainability roadmap,” said Webber. What is unfolding in Santa Fe is an accelerated version of the conversation taking place on the national level. Once a topic pushed to the side by Republicans and Democrats alike, climate change has been catapulted to the top of the political agenda in recent months. After two years of deadly wildfires and hurricanes across the country, polling shows that most Americans accept the science behind climate change and that many feel it is already impacting their lives directly. And they are demanding action. Congressional newcomers like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), joined by activist groups like the youth-led Sunrise Movement, have led the charge. In February, Ocasio-Cortez and Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA) introduced the Green New Deal resolution, a blueprint for overhauling the entire U.S. economy and transitioning to emissions-neutral energy sources within a decade. Short on specifics, the resolution is meant to serve as an aspirational blueprint for eventual legislation in Congress that would emphasize rapidly transitioning the United States away from fossil fuels, in line with the latest science, all while investing in job creation, education, and health care. Ambitious climate legislation akin to the Green New Deal faces gridlock in Congress and staunch opposition from the White House, making it essentially a non-starter right now. But that isn’t true of cities and states. As of March, at least 19 states are considering or have already set 100 percent clean or renewable electricity targets, according to EQ Research, a policy group that works on issues like energy efficiency and renewables. Not all of those efforts resemble the full spectrum of changes called for under the Green New Deal, however, as they focus predominately on electricity goals. But several of the plans incorporate language about jobs and social justice, with some directly referencing the Green New Deal as a source of inspiration. That’s significant because, without federal support, ground-up implementation could be how the Green New Deal ultimately becomes a reality. Ambitious energy targets alone are notable in several areas. Hawaii and California have enacted legislation to hit a 100 percent clean or renewable electricity target by 2045, while Washington, D.C., is aiming for 2032. And already this year, 10 more states have followed suit, introducing their own legislation to reach a clean electricity standard by 2050 or earlier. This marks a dramatic change of pace compared to a few years ago, according to Ben Inskeep, a research analyst with EQ Research. “We definitely do see a lot of examples at the state level where we see [decarbonization targets] ratcheting up,” Inskeep told ThinkProgress. According to an alarming U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report released last fall, the world only has around a decade left before crossing a dangerous global warming threshold. Reaching 1.5 degrees Celsius of global warming above pre-industrial levels would, the report warns, mean devastating climate impacts on a scale the world is not prepared to address. This is why the Green New Deal resolution emphasizes the importance of serious, widespread action by 2030, in keeping with established climate science. Many cities and states, however, are operating within the 2050 deadline, which proponents of the Green New Deal may view as unambitious. But Inskeep says such criticism might be missing the point. The fact that local officials are announcing significant emissions reduction goals by 2050 is remarkable, he said, arguing the chief takeaway is less about the timeframe and more about growing momentum. “Some folks might say 2050 is too far in the future… [or] down the road,” he said. “[But] certainly none of us were having this conversation even three years ago… we’re seeing already that ratcheting up.” There was a time when 2050 seemed like an impractical goal, Inskeep explained. Now, it’s relatively average for most middle-of-the-road ambitions, viewed as achievable in part thanks to the rapidly-dropping costs of wind and solar power, in addition to advancements in technology. If lawmakers now see 2050 as an achievable deadline, that indicates just how much policymakers and officials have adjusted their expectations, and perhaps could ramp up ambitions even more down the road. “A few years ago, it would’ve been very surprising to see any kind of 100 percent proposal introduced… now, we have 10 more states introducing legislation… that’s a tremendous growth,” he said. In Santa Fe, action to implement the city’s sustainability plan is already in full swing. Last month, the city sold the state’s first-ever “green bonds,” which allow investors to finance environmental projects. That sale is translating to a $15 million city wastewater upgrade, which includes the construction of an anaerobic digester. Through the new system, microorganisms will break down biodegradable waste from the city. In the process, they will reduce emissions and generate clean energy. With the help of solar power and the digester, almost 95 percent of the plant’s power will be produced onsite. The energy savings are projected to eliminate some 3,100 metric tons of carbon dioxide, the equivalent of taking nearly 750 cars off of the road. Such projects are a good example of how cities can be innovative as they seek to lower their emissions. But the city’s mayor is thinking bigger. “We tend to think of policies in silos but people don’t live in silos, they live their lives,” Webber said. In addition to committing Santa Fe to carbon neutrality, he’s also interested in job creation through renewable energy, something the Green New Deal emphasizes. He moreover sees other social efforts as being key components of any long-term plan, like protecting the city’s undocumented members, as well as low-income communities and people of color impacted by pollution. “There’s a renewable energy piece, a transportation piece, a land-use planning piece, a social equity piece, a jobs and inclusivity piece,” he said. Santa Fe is part of a larger story unfolding in New Mexico. On March 22, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham (D) signed the Energy Transition Act, which would require the state’s electricity grid to be completely carbon-free by 2045. It also earmarks funds for communities impacted by the transition away from fossil fuels, including coal workers. “This is a state that is not in climate denial,” the governor declared. “We are clear that we have basically a decade to begin to turn things around and New Mexico needs [to] and will do its part.” The legislation comes as New Mexico struggles with hard choices. The state is a poor one, and it is also a leading fossil fuel producer. The Permian Basin, which straddles West Texas and southeastern New Mexico, is the leading oil and gas reserve in the country. And more than half of New Mexico’s electricity comes from coal. Lujan Grisham has said she wants to work with the fossil fuel industry to reduce emissions, but environmental advocates worry that flies in the face of New Mexico’s lofty climate goals. The Santa Fe-based New Energy Economy (NEE), which advocates for addressing climate change and shifting away from fossil fuels, has been critical of the Energy Transition Act. The environmental group has argued that the law provides too much assistance to Public Service Company of New Mexico, or PNM, the utility operator behind the failing San Juan Generating Station coal plant. According to NEE, the law amounts to a polluter “bailout” and was passed without the support of a number of tribal leaders. Others feel differently. Navajo Nation President Jonathan Nez backed the law, as did many other stakeholders and a slew of environmental groups. That split in support indicates the challenges that others might also encounter as they look to pass similar legislation. Efforts in New Mexico are nonetheless notable in the components they bring together. Namely, they go beyond advocating for a shift away from fossil fuels, and also work to grow jobs and protect impacted communities. That’s language that has made the Green New Deal resolution so popular for some and so divisive for others. But such small-scale efforts will also be a test of whether a bigger and bolder endeavor might succeed. Some state proposals are in the early development stage. In Rhode Island, a tiny state threatened by sea level rise and overly vulnerable to financial crisis, the state is looking to begin researching its own version of a Green New Deal. Historically, Rhode Island has been among the first states to fall into recessions and the last to leave them — something a stimulus centering green jobs could help avoid. Others are further along. Last month, Illinois introduced the Clean Energy Jobs Act, which would push hard for job expansion as the state shifts away from fossil fuels. It also emphasizes increased solar distribution in vulnerable communities and the importance of creating energy-related jobs in low-income and pollution-impacted areas. And many local leaders are leaning into the language popularized by Ocasio-Cortez and young activists. Los Angeles city council members have used the language of the Green New Deal to push for an end to natural gas generation in the city. And in Holyoke, Massachusetts, the city’s shift from coal to solar power has been similarly marketed by activists and officials. Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) of New York also wasted no time in labeling the climate components of the state’s 2019 executive budget as a Green New Deal. That budget seeks to put New York on the road to “economy-wide carbon neutrality” by 2040, while ensuring a “just transition to clean energy.” New York has already banned fracking, committed to phasing out coal by 2020, and set a 50 percent renewable power target by 2030. And thanks to the potential of offshore wind, state officials are feeling confident about New York’s energy transition. They’re also hopeful that the state can be a model for others, said Alicia Barton, president and chief executive of the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA). “New York is very focused on developing a plan for economy-wide decarbonization that we can deliver on as we progress toward achieving the state’s nation-leading goals,” Barton told ThinkProgress. She said she hopes the state’s “leadership” will help national efforts by “driving the clean energy transition faster than anyone thought.” City and state-level efforts remain different from federal action in that they are much smaller scale and thus easier to implement. However, virtually every official who spoke to ThinkProgress indicated that assistance from Congress and the White House would help, either with funding or with general guidance. But the polarized nature of Washington is proving challenging in that regard, as is evident by the Green New Deal’s failure to gain bipartisan support. Webber, of Santa Fe, sees an opening there. “I think particularly with the federal government frozen in so many ways, the level of engagement is shifting to the cities and the states,” he said. And in some ways, they may be better equipped to address some problems. Cities and states, Webber says, are “closer to the problem and also closer to the people affected by the issues, like closing down a coal mine.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › States

States solve best for GND goals—dozens of examples of state and local legislation prove

Sierra Club No Date [The Sierra Club is an American environmental organization with chapters in all 50 states, Sierra Club, No Date, “A Green New Deal Is Already Underway in States and Cities,” https://www.sierraclub.org/trade/green-new-deal-already-underway-states-and-cities]//LA

The policy changes envisioned in the Green New Deal resolution are not hypothetical. In fact, many are already happening at the state and local level, where broad local coalitions of labor, environmental, and racial justice groups are winning pro-climate, pro-jobs, pro-equity policies that help lay the groundwork for a national Green New Deal. In addition to more than 100 cities nationwide that have already committed to 100 percent clean, renewable energy, here are just a few examples of state and city initiatives that offer models and momentum for a nationwide Green New Deal. NEW YORK CITY The New York City Council recently passed a job-creating bill that takes aim at the city's largest source of climate pollution: inefficient buildings. The new policy, cited as part of the city's own Green New Deal, will require about 50,000 large buildings to meet ambitious targets for reducing climate pollution. The building retrofits required by the policy are expected to create about 8,000 jobs each year. To protect low-income residents, the policy includes terms to prevent rent increases in rent-regulated buildings. MAINE Maine recently enacted a new "Act To Establish a Green New Deal for Maine." The law will create a task force of labor, youth, climate science, and other representatives to craft a strategy for achieving 80% renewable energy in Maine by 2040, creating good jobs in renewable energy and manufacturing, and ensuring low-income households have access to affordable solar power. The Maine AFL-CIO has praised the policy, saying that workers must "have a seat at the table in crafting bold climate protection policies." LOS ANGELES In April 2019, Los Angeles Mayor Garcetti released an update to the Sustainable City pLAn, calling it "L.A.'s Green New Deal." The plan lays out the most ambitious and achievable climate goals for the city to date. It would invest in L.A.'s local workforce and economy by creating good union jobs for thousands of technicians, electricians, engineers, and other clean energy workers. Critically, the plan tackles the ongoing poor air quality that Los Angeles and other Southern California communities continue to breathe as the worst region for smog pollution in the country. ILLINOIS The Future Energy Jobs Act gives low-income families priority access to solar panels, while providing solar-installation job training, particularly for formerly incarcerated people and communities fighting environmental injustice. The law also sets new energy-efficiency standards that are slated to further reduce air and climate pollution, create over 7,000 new jobs each year to retrofit buildings, and cut $4 billion in energy costs for Illinois families. CALIFORNIA In addition to committing to 100 percent clean energy by 2045, California’s Buy Clean policy helps stimulate clean manufacturing by requiring that tax dollars be spent on goods manufactured under conditions that protect our climate. The law will help ensure that when the state government buys steel for bridges or glass for offices, it sends tax dollars to manufacturers that are slashing their climate pollution and creating good jobs. NEW MEXICO New Mexico has enacted a historic law to transition to 100 percent carbon-free electricity by 2045. The bill sets interim milestones for clean energy adoption and invests heavily in NM communities, accounting for retiring an existing coal-fired generating plant while pursuing a just and equitable transition to a clean energy future for NM workers and families. PORTLAND In 2018, after a grassroots campaign led by communities of color, voters in Portland overwhelmingly approved a ballot referendum that will raise $30-70 million per year, via a fee on big retailer profits, for energy efficiency, renewable energy, job training, affordable housing, regenerative agriculture, and green infrastructure projects. A new task force of city stakeholders will be tasked with deciding annually the beneficiaries of the fund, with at least half of the revenue going toward investments in low income communities and communities of color. SEATTLE In August 2019, the Seattle city council unanimously passed a resolution calling for a city-level Green New Deal, which seeks to eliminate Seattle’s climate pollution by 2030, address historical and current injustices, and create thousands of good, green, well-paying, unionized jobs. The effort is being led by local environmental justice organizations and frontline communities of color, and includes a "Healthy Homes, Healthy Businesses" ordinance that would require new buildings in the city to run on clean electricity rather than gas appliances. PITTSBURGH Pittsburgh United's Clean Rivers Campaign has been pushing for job-creating green infrastructure projects that could drastically reduce flooding in some of the city’s vulnerable neighborhoods. They are one of many local coalitions across the country calling for, and often securing, public investments in green spaces to absorb rainwater, replacement of lead pipes, and other infrastructure upgrades to increase climate resilience and ensure clean water. DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA The Clean Energy DC Omnibus Act of 2018 requires DC to transition to 100 percent clean, renewable electricity sources by 2032. It also sets stronger, job-creating building performance standards to reduce energy use and make buildings more energy efficient and requires buses and large private vehicle fleets to transition away from dirty fuel and toward electric vehicles.

2023 DDI Negative
OFF › States

State governments are best situated to provide green job guarantees—they have stepped in absent federal action

Gunby 19’ [Jennifer Gunby is the Senior Manager for State & Local Advocacy at the US Green Building Council. U.S. Green Building Council. 9-17-19. “State and local governments offer their own New Deal policy solutions” https://www.usgbc.org/articles/green-new-deal-policy-packages-offer-solutions-all-levels]//LA

State and local governments can capitalize on the benefits provided by Green New Deal-style legislation. There has been a great deal of attention following the November 2018 elections, and the announcement of the “Green New Deal.” At the federal level, a Green New Deal was introduced in February 2019 (House Resolution 109 and Senate Resolution 59). The resolution has spurred conversation and action from states and local governments to address economic inequality and climate risks. Absent federal action, state and local governments can move forward with solutions. Not only can they more nimbly address the challenges, they are also spending significant amounts of taxpayer money on the consequences of lack of action—increased rates of asthma, vector-borne diseases, heart disease and cancer; impacts of extreme weather events; and diminished air and water quality. Several states and cities have already moved forward with solving these challenges by introducing their own versions of a “Green New Deal,” and many others passed complementary policies that well aligned with the tenets of the Green New Deal. Those packages that specifically use Green New Deal terminology include: California: AB 1276, introduced in February Los Angeles, California: Green New Deal / pLAn 2019 Connecticut: HB 6452, introduced in January Maine: LD 1282, introduced in March; passed and signed in June Minnesota: HF 2836, introduced in April New York, New York: The Climate Mobilization Act, passed and signed in April; see also OneNYC 2050 North Carolina: H737, introduced in April New York: A08429 / S06599, introduced in June; passed and signed in July Rhode Island: H 5665, introduced in February, and RI S 0659, introduced in March Virginia: HJ 724, introduced in January These bills would put a significant portion of the country on the path toward net carbon neutrality and an improved economy. However, the majority are introduced bills and resolutions—they are not yet passed, actionable legislation. Moving forward in the meantime An alternate path forward for state and local governments to take realistic action without a jurisdiction-wide Green New Deal is to remedy their own impacts and lead by example. A Green New Deal policy package that is customizable to emphasize local concerns can lead by example, focusing on government-owned buildings, infrastructure and assets, as well as incentives to guide the private sector in following suit. Such a package should be ambitious, cover transportation and buildings, and have an aggressive time frame. While the exact policy package would vary based on the goals of each jurisdiction, a typical package could include: All existing government buildings meeting high-performance standards All new government buildings achieving net zero Electrification of fleets Clean energy mandates Incentives for green industrial practices Residential weatherization grants and training Increased minimum wage for projects receiving public funds State and local governments are well positioned to capitalize on the many economic and quality of life benefits provided by Green New Deal-style legislation. In the absence of federal action, USGBC believes it is imperative that local leaders take this opportunity to create better communities while addressing economic inequality and climate change.