Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Competitiveness Impact---XT---!

Competitiveness solves global war---it’s the bedrock of national security and international standing.

Zoë Baird 20. CEO and President of the Markle Foundation. A.B. Phi Beta Kappa and a J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley. “Equitable Economic Recovery Is a National Security Imperative”. https://www.markle.org/sites/default/files/Chapter-13-Baird-Equitable-Economic-Recovery.pdf

Broadly shared economic prosperity is a bedrock of America’s economic and political strength—both domestically and in the international arena. A strong and equitable recovery from the economic crisis created by COVID-19 would be a powerful testament to the resilience of the American system and its ability to create prosperity at a time of seismic change and persistent global crisis. Such a recovery could attack the profound economic inequities that have developed over the past several decades. Without bold action to help all workers access good jobs as the economy returns, the United States risks undermining the legitimacy of its institutions and its international standing. The outcome will be a key determinant of America’s national security for years to come.

An equitable recovery requires a national commitment to help all workers obtain good jobs—particularly the twothirds of adults without a bachelor’s degree and people of color who have been most affected by the crisis and were denied opportunity before it. As the nation engages in a historic debate about how to accelerate economic recovery, ambitious public investment is necessary to put Americans back to work with dignity and opportunity. We need an intentional effort to make sure that the jobs that come back are good jobs with decent wages, benefits, and mobility and to empower workers to access these opportunities in a profoundly changed labor market.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Competitiveness !---XT---Higher Ed Key

Cuts to higher education crush competitiveness

Herbert Allison et al. 7, holds an M.B.A. from the Stanford University Graduate School of Business, “Graduate education: The backbone of American competitiveness and innovation”, http://www.cgsnet.org/portals/0/pdf/ Gr_GradEdAmComp_0407.pdf

For much of the 20th century, the United States enjoyed the benefits of being the world’s leader in research and innovation, resulting in economic progress and unprecedented security for its citizens. However, America’s future success in this regard is not guaranteed. This issue has been highlighted in recent reports warning that our economic leadership is eroding and our primacy in global competitiveness is threatened. The consensus is that strengthening graduate education—the backbone of American competitiveness and innovation— is key to a prosperous and secure future. The highly skilled, creative workforce of tomorrow is developed through our graduate programs. Graduate students become our scientists, researchers, experts, and innovators in a wide variety of fields. Graduate programs are where they acquire innovative research and leadership skills. This report enumerates the key assumptions underlying this vision of the future, assesses the many positive activities underway that contribute to a prosperous future, highlights gaps that need to be addressed, and concludes with six broad recommendations for action and the necessary roles for each stakeholder.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Competitiveness !---XT---Higher Ed Key

Higher education is vital to overall competitiveness.

Mary S. Nabers 22, MBA from The University of Texas at Austin, President/CEO of Strategic Partnerships, Inc, also co-founder of the Gemini Global Group (G3), a firm that works with national and international clients on business development, P3s, and other types of government objectives, “Capital projects at universities essential to U.S. competitiveness”, https://www.spartnerships.com/capital-projects-at-universities-essential-to-u-s-competitiveness/

Throughout history, college campuses have transformed students into global leaders by equipping them with the resources and knowledge required to address the world’s most troubling issues. That’s a critical component of every aspect of our well-being around the world. So, it is important for U.S. colleges and universities to have the talent and the required resources to maintain the nation’s competitiveness. That task, however, is not easy.

Costs for colleges and universities continue to escalate, and wages for instructors and administrators increase. Technology upgrades are required, research labs are needed, and online curriculum demands even more. The pressure to meet critical needs and manage costs has escalated – so much so that the interest in collaborative partnerships with private-sector companies has reached new heights. Here are a few examples of large initiatives that definitely require participation from the private sector.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact---Competitiveness

Competitiveness---both economic and technological---is vital to deterring great power nuclear war.

Michele A. Flournoy 22, Chair of the CNAS Board of Directors, Co-founder and Managing Partner, WestExec Advisors, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy under President Bill Clinton and Under Secretary of Defense for Policy under President Barack Obama, also served as served as Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy and Threat Reduction and Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Strategy, “Testimony of Michèle A. Flournoy for the Senate Armed Services Committee”, https://www.armed-services.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/SASC%20Testimony%20Flournoy%20030122.pdf

First, geopolitically, the rise of a more powerful and assertive China, as well as the resurgence of a far more aggressive Russia (as we are witnessing with Putin’s egregious and illegal invasion of Ukraine), is creating a shift in the global balance of power and challenging the post-World War II rules-based order that has been the foundation of international relations for more than 75 years. Authoritarian regimes in Moscow and Beijing are posing new threats to their neighbors and to peace and stability in Europe and the Indo-Pacific. Here in the United States, we are experiencing a profound shift of strategic focus from the post-9/11 wars of the Middle East (Afghanistan, Iraq, and global counterterrorism operations) to the increasingly urgent imperative to deter and defeat aggression by these nuclear-armed strategic competitors.

Looking into the longer-term future, the coming decades will be shaped most profoundly by a multidimensional, strategic competition with China -- one that has political, economic, military, technological and ideological dimensions as well as enormous stakes for the prosperity and security of the United States and our allies and partners.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact---Competitiveness

Specifically, higher education is key to US competitiveness and tech innovation.

Stanley Litow 21, professor at Duke and Columbia universities and a trustee at the State University of New York, previously served as president of the IBM Foundation and is the co-author of Breaking Barriers: How P-TECH Schools Create a Pathway From High School to College to Career, “America Needs Strong Higher Education More Than Ever”, https://www.barrons.com/articles/america-needs-strong-higher-education-more-than-ever-51633626774

Our colleges also play another vitally important role. They are directly connected to innovation via their research, and their innovative research is directly connected to job creation and America’s competitiveness and economic future. A recent article in  argues that federal funding for research is the “bedrock of national innovation and plays an irreplaceable role in steering scientific progress towards the betterment of society.” Congress recently passed the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act, which includes billions in federal funding to spur innovation in areas of economic growth. This is among the largest federal investments in research and innovation since World War II. And unlike the partisan conflict in Washington that has taken place on so many other issues this legislation passed the Senate with 68 votes, reflecting its strong bipartisan support. It now needs to be signed into law and fully funded, as it is directly connected to U.S. competitiveness. 

The legislation directs investment in ways that stimulate a deep and ongoing collaboration between higher-education institutions and business. In one example, it will provide for the creation of a National Semiconductor Technology Center, which will fund research, testing, and workforce development. A nationwide shortage of semiconductors and chips has limited the supply and increased the cost of automobiles, cell phones, and many other electronic devices. It has disadvantaged all Americans. And yet the U.S. now only manufactures only about 12% of the world’s chips, down from 37% in 1990, according to the , forcing us into dependence on China, Taiwan, and South Korea. Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo has  a “national security risk.” Funding under this innovative federal program and the innovations in higher education that will result will address this challenge head on. It will be our higher-education institutions, along with their industry partners, that will create innovative, more powerful, and lower-cost technology. A partnership involving SUNY along with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, and industry partners like IBM is primed to create a U.S.-based domestic laboratory that will invent and manufacture smaller-scale and less-expensive semiconductor chips. It will reduce cost, speed production and perhaps most important, restore America’s role in an entirely vitally important industry. In the process it will create significant numbers of new jobs.  

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---AT: US Not Key

And, if US universities decline, students will go study in China---but that still triggers our impacts, because Chinese colleges are anti-academic freedom---which is vital to solve our impacts!

William C. Kirby 22, T. M. Chang Professor of China Studies and Spangler Family Professor of Business Administration at Harvard, “Empires of Ideas: Creating the Modern University from Germany to America to China”, https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=62025

The modern university was born in Germany. In the twentieth century, the United States leapfrogged Germany to become the global leader in higher education. Will China challenge its position in the twenty-first? Today American institutions dominate nearly every major ranking of global universities. Yet in historical terms, America’s preeminence is relatively new, and there is no reason to assume that U.S. schools will continue to lead the world a century from now. Indeed, America’s supremacy in higher education is under great stress, particularly at its public universities. At the same time Chinese universities are on the ascent. Thirty years ago, Chinese institutions were reopening after the catastrophe of the Cultural Revolution; today they are some of the most innovative educational centers in the world. Will China threaten American primacy? Empires of Ideas looks to the past two hundred years for answers, chronicling two revolutions in higher education: the birth of the research university and its integration with the liberal education model. William C. Kirby examines the successes of leading universities―The University of Berlin and the Free University of Berlin in Germany; Harvard, Duke, and the University of California, Berkeley, in the United States―to determine how they rose to prominence and what threats they currently face. Kirby draws illuminating comparisons to the trajectories of three Chinese contenders: Tsinghua University, Nanjing University, and the University of Hong Kong, which aim to be world-class institutions that can compete with the best the United States and Europe have to offer. But Chinese institutions also face obstacles. Kirby analyzes the challenges that Chinese academic leaders must confront: reinvesting in undergraduate teaching, developing new models of funding, and navigating a political system that may undermine a true commitment to free inquiry and academic excellence.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---AT: US Not Key

US is key---it’s the global leader in higher education, with the biggest share of top schools and top-tier research programs.

Dana Vioreanu 22, Project Manager at MGMH, “7 Reasons Why Students Think USA Is The Holy Grail of Higher Education”, https://www.mastersportal.com/articles/1216/7-reasons-why-students-think-usa-is-the-holy-grail-of-higher-education.html

The USA has a special allure and has always been drawing talented students like a magnet. Studying abroad in an American university will allow for invaluable academic, professional and personal growth, and open up an infinite number of career opportunities after graduation. But there's more to why students worldwide think that the U.S. is the Holy Grail of international higher education.

Check out these 7 reasons that may give you the courage to pursue a higher education degree in the United States:

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed !---AT: Impact Defense

Higher ed’s key to innovations that prevent extinction

EPSC 16 - European Political Strategy Centre | In-house think tank of @EU_Commission, led by @AnnMettler, "The Future of Universities and Evidence-Based Research," Medium, https://medium.com/shaping-the-future/the-future-of-universities-and-evidence-based-research-190f3a6fa688

Past glories will not sustain us forever. Universities need to change in order to serve the needs of tomorrow’s economy and society. This is not in debate. There is a need for more skills — and more research — in science and technology, for example. Universities will continue to have a central role in the drive for technological innovation.

We face a future in which machine capacity — and machine intelligence, albeit with certain constraints — will far outstrip human capacity. Technology holds immense promise — but this promise is accompanied by threats, and even existential threats. It follows that the need to improve our knowledge of the human and social sciences does not diminish — it increases.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed !---AT: Impact Defense

Higher education prepares a capable citizenry to solve global threats.

Steve Nelson 16, Associate Professor @ Hope College, “First, Do No Harm: Progressive Education in a Time of Existential Risk”, Garn Press, *language edited

I’m not afraid, but I’m sometimes terrified. This terror arises unbidden when I think about my three grandchildren. I imagine them in the path of nuclear incineration. I worry that they might have to navigate a barren world, facing horrible, human-induced climate events or the day when clean water becomes a precious commodity, even in our wealthy nation. I see them helpless in the face of man’s inhumanity to man - genocide, bigotry, cruelty, and indifference. It is the only thing I fear about death - being gone and unable to hold them, love them if the Earth becomes inhospitable and life becomes unbearable. The thought of my grandchildren - all the world’s children - suffering after I’m gone is my only hell.

It is not hyperbole to declare that we are living in a time of grave existential threat. The nuclear threat of 1950’s is mere child's play compared to the world today. Russia, the UK, France, China, North Korea, India, Pakistan, and Israel all have nuclear weapons. Barack Obama has declared a 30-year $1 trillion plan to modernize our deadly nuclear arsenal.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact Overview

Inequality causes nuke war.

Frederick Solt 11, Ph.D. in Political Science from University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Assistant Professor, Departments of Political Science and Sociology, Southern Illinois, July 2011, “Diversionary Nationalism: Economic Inequality and the Formation of National Pride,” The Journal of Politics, Vol. 73, No. 3, pgs. 821-830

One of the oldest theories of nationalism is that states instill the nationalist myth in their citizens to divert their attention from great economic inequality and so forestall pervasive unrest. Because the very concept of nationalism obscures the extent of inequality and is a potent tool for delegitimizing calls for redistribution, it is a perfect diversion, and states should be expected to engage in more nationalist mythmaking when inequality increases. The evidence presented by this study supports this theory: across the countries and over time, where economic inequality is greater, nationalist sentiments are substantially more widespread.

This result adds considerably to our understanding of nationalism. To date, many scholars have focused on the international environment as the principal source of threats that prompt states to generate nationalism; the importance of the domestic threat posed by economic inequality has been largely overlooked. However, at least in recent years, domestic inequality is a far more important stimulus for the generation of nationalist sentiments than the international context. Given that nuclear weapons—either their own or their allies’—rather than the mass army now serve as the primary defense of many countries against being overrun by their enemies, perhaps this is not surprising: nationalism-inspired mass mobilization is simply no longer as necessary for protection as it once was (see Mearsheimer 1990, 21; Posen 1993, 122–24).

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact Overview

Biodiversity collapse kills everyone---invisible threshold.

Dave Goulson 22, professor of biology at University of Sussex, holds a PhD from Oxford Brookes University, was given the Zoological Society of London’s Marsh Award for Conservation Biology in 2013; elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh in 2013; given the British Ecological Society Public Engagement Award in 2014; given Zoological Society of London’s Clarivate Award for Communicating Zoology in 2020, “Industrialized Farming Has Unleashed an Insect Apocalypse”, https://truthout.org/articles/industrialized-farming-has-unleashed-an-insect-apocalypse/

Our planet has coped remarkably well so far with the blizzard of changes we have wrought, but we would be foolish to assume that it will continue to do so. A relatively small proportion of species have actually gone extinct so far, but almost all wild species now exist in numbers that are a fraction of their former abundance, subsisting in degraded and fragmented habitats and subjected to a multitude of ever-changing man-made problems. We do not understand anywhere near enough to be able to predict how much resilience is left in our depleted ecosystems, or how close we are to tipping points beyond which collapse becomes inevitable. In Paul Ehrlich’s “rivets on a plane” analogy, we may be close to the point where the wing falls off.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact Overview

Warming causes extinction.

Dr. Damian Carrington 22, PhD in geology from the University of Edinburgh, where he also did post-doctoral research, Environment Editor at The Guardian, “Climate endgame: risk of human extinction ‘dangerously underexplored’”, *language edited

The risk of global societal collapse or human extinction has been “dangerously underexplored”, climate scientists have warned in an analysis.

They call such a catastrophe the “climate endgame”. Though it had a small chance of occurring, given the uncertainties in future emissions and the climate system, cataclysmic scenarios could not be ruled out, they said.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Higher Ed Impact Overview

Robust higher education frames and filters our response to every global threat. Collapse makes all their impacts non-unique.

Dr. Colin Brock 15, PhD, Honorary Professor of Education at the University of Durham, UK, and Visiting Professor of Geography at the University of Loughborough, UK, “Education as a Humanitarian Response as a Global Objective”, Routledge Handbooks Online, doi: 10.4324/9781315797007.ch3

However, the core book introducing the series, Education as a Global Concern (Brock 2012), takes a much broader and more fundamental view that, in effect, responds to aspects of Article 26 in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, though it was not directly designed so to do. The aim of this chapter is also to take this broader, indeed global, view of education as a humanitarian response to the unprecedented and mostly imminent challenges of the twenty-first century. These are challenges to human and environmental survival and sustainability (Martin 2006). Some are widely known and contended in the wider media, such as climate change and biodiversity survival. Others relate to the equally challenging effects of powerful political and corporate self-interest on educational policy that severely constrain the potential contribution of education, in all its forms, to play its crucial part in reaching the fundamental goal in saving planet Earth and its human populations.

Education is not a panacea, yet much of the widespread conventional wisdom thinks it is. But in its different forms, it is an essential dimension of survival. In this holistic sense, it has to be humane to play its vital part. This is the wider scenario of education as a humanitarian response.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Higher Ed I/L

Cuts to Pell Grants decimate higher ed

Maria Carrasco 23. NASFAA Staff Reporter, 3-21-23. "ED: GOP’s Proposed Budget Cuts Would Have ‘Damaging’ Impact for Students, Economy," https://www.nasfaa.org/news-item/30255/ED_GOP_s_Proposed_Budget_Cuts_Would_Have_Damaging_Impact_for_Students_Economy.

The Department of Education on Friday sent a letter to Rep. Rosa DeLauro (D-Conn.), ranking member of the House Appropriations Committee, outlining the potential impact that funding cuts would have on higher education and financial aid.

In January, DeLauro asked federal agencies to describe how House Republicans’ reported fiscal year (FY) 2024 budget proposal to cut discretionary spending back to the FY 2022 enacted level and would impact their agencies. According to DeLauro, the reported proposal would cut at least 22% for essential programs.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Higher Ed I/L

Pell Grants are the cornerstone investment in higher ed---cutting them is a disaster

Megan Mcclean Coval 17. Vice President of Policy and Federal Relations at the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators, 9-14-2017. "Why Congress shouldn't cut the Pell Grant reserve fund (essay)," https://www.insidehighered.com/views/2017/09/15/why-congress-shouldnt-cut-pell-grant-reserve-fund-essay.

For decades, the federal Pell Grant program has provided much-needed financial assistance to students around the country who struggle to pay for a college education. Each year nearly eight million students -- the majority of whom come from extremely low-income backgrounds -- benefit from those funds.

Yet the program is again under attack in federal spending proposals. While it boosted the value of the maximum Pell Grant award, the Senate Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies Appropriations Committee's funding bill for fiscal year 2018 proposes rescinding $2.6 billion from Pell Grant reserve funds, while the House FY 2018 bill proposes a cut of nearly $3.3 billion. The president proposed axing $3.9 billion in his FY 2018 budget proposal. Because of the way the program operates, cutting from the reserves could put the future of the program at risk and harm deserving college students down the road.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Pell Grants Impact---Higher Ed---1NC

Extinction---vibrant higher education institutions filter all impacts.

Adrian Parr et al. 22, PhD, Professor of Planning, Public Policy, and Management at the University of Oregon, Senior Fellow at the Design Futures Council, “Knowledge-driven actions: Transforming higher education for global sustainability”, a report published in 2022 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, Paris

Universities and, more broadly, higher education institutions (HEIs), need to use the knowledge they produce and their education of new professionals, to help solve some of the world´s greatest problems, as addressed by the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) set out by the United Nations (UN). Humanity is facing unprecedented challenges, most strikingly so in relation to climate change and loss of nature and biodiversity, as well as inequality, health, the economy, and a suite of issues related to the 2030 Agenda. Given this new reality in which the future of humans, along with other species, is at stake, it is time for HEIs and their stakeholders to systematically rethink their role in society and their key missions, and reflect on how they can serve as catalysts for a rapid, urgently needed and fair transition towards sustainability. The complexity of the issues at stake means that solutions should be part of a radical agenda that calls for new alliances and new incentives.

It is also time for HEIs to make sustainability and SDG literacy core requisites for all faculty members and students. Sustainability education should bring students into contact with real-world problems and immersive experiences. Appreciating the greater good of both people and planet, and contributing to values beyond mere monetary gain will further enthuse and inspire students and faculty mentors alike. Ultimately, the educational culture at universities and HEIs needs to encourage students to learn via experimentation and critical thinking from multiple perspectives.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Pell Grants Impact---Higher Ed---1NC

Pell Grants are key to higher education broadly

Spiros Protopsaltis 17. Visiting Associate Professor and Fellow, College of Education and Human Development, George Mason University and served as the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Higher Education and Student Financial Aid at the U.S. Department of Education from 2015 to 2017, with Sharon Parrott, 7-27-2017. "Pell Grants — a Key Tool for Expanding College Access and Economic Opportunity — Need Strengthening, Not Cuts," https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-budget/pell-grants-a-key-tool-for-expanding-college-access-and-economic.

For 45 years, the federal Pell Grant program has been the cornerstone of financial assistance for students from low- and moderate-income families, helping millions go to college. Pell Grants are awarded to students solely based on financial need and serve as the foundation of an eligible student’s financial aid package upon which other forms of aid are layered, including loans and state and institutional aid. Pell has been by far the single largest source of grants for postsecondary education, expanding college access and economic opportunity over the past 40 years. Last year alone (academic year 2015-16), Pell provided more than $28.5 billion to support 7.7 million students,[2] or nearly 40 percent of undergraduate students.[3]

By expanding college access, Pell Grants help narrow the postsecondary achievement gap between low- and moderate-income students and those of greater means. They boost college enrollment, reduce drop-out rates, and improve student outcomes. By enabling students to work less and take more courses, they also help accelerate graduation and improve college completion rates. Nor, despite widespread claims to the contrary, do Pell Grants do much if anything to fuel tuition increases at colleges. That is, in general, colleges don’t raise tuition on the assumption that Pell Grants will cushion the blow.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Education K2 Democracy

Public education makes democracy vibrant

Brendan Lee 23. History instructor at Utah State University. His research focuses on the history of American education, politics and social movements in the 19th and 20th centuries, 2-14-23. "Public educations passes civilization down to future generations.," https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2023/02/14/brendan-lee-long-troubled-history/.

The history of education in the United States can best be described as a story of social progress in the face of cultural, political and generational opposition. Progressive educator John Dewey described education in 1906 as a tool of “social renewal” in which the older generation, having lived their lives and gained experience, passes on knowledge to the rising youth.

This has been a pattern familiar to our collective history. After all, this is how humans learned not to eat poisonous plants, the process of hunting or gathering food effectively or how civilizations are built by people working together. Over time, the youth take these lessons, gather their own experience and continue the pattern forward with better and improved knowledge.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Education---1NC

Democracy caps existential risk.

Francis M. Lappé 22, the Andrew W. Mellon Distinguished Fellow in Environmental Studies at Colby College in Maine, Associate Fellow at the Tellus Institute, recipient of 20 honorary doctorates from distinguished institutions, founder of the Small Planet Institute, and member of the World Future Council, “Democracy's Peril and Promise: Let the Ukraine Crisis Awaken Action”, https://www.smallplanet.org/single-post/democracy-s-peril-and-promise-let-the-ukraine-crisis-awaken-action

The attack on Ukraine focuses the mind on a most critical question for humanity: In our fast-changing world, what is democracy's future?

Certainly, a strong argument can be made that democratic governance is more important than ever as humanity faces at least two unprecedented challenges: the existential threats of the global climate crisis and a global pandemic. Attacks on civil and human rights continue as well—challenges that can only be met with democratic governance.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Education---1NC

Public education is key to democracy

Brendan Lee 23. History instructor at Utah State University. His research focuses on the history of American education, politics and social movements in the 19th and 20th centuries, 2-14-23. "Public educations passes civilization down to future generations.," https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2023/02/14/brendan-lee-long-troubled-history/.

Once again, Americans are forced to confront the words of Thomas Jefferson. At the very basic level, public education provides equal opportunity and access to education for all — it is where democracy is practiced among our children. It becomes a space in which students of all racial, religious, sexual and cultural backgrounds come together to learn about our shared history and develop the tools needed to work together and move our country forward as future leaders.

When we have political debates about where school funding should go, we must consider the generational impact of our investment as a practice of social renewal. Over the next 50 years, what will increased investment in private education with separate curriculum standards, separate oversight and separate practices of inclusion do to the social understanding of our children? Will they learn to value the open society and democracy in a system that restricts how and what they learn, who is allowed to sit next to them, and how civil discourse and social advocacy are allowed to take place?