Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Education---1NC

Medicaid cuts deck national education---states will divert money from public schools to make up the shortfall

Bruce Lesley 17. President of First Focus on Children, a bipartisan nonprofit working to make children a priority in federal policy and budget decisions, has more than 30 years of public policy experience at all levels of government, 6-27-2017. "Trumpcare: Shifting Medicaid Cuts and Harm to the States," https://firstfocus.org/blog/trumpcare-shifting-medicaid-cuts-and-harm-to-the-states.

Now is the time for state leaders to stop being “wary” and to express their opposition to Trumpcare legislation moving through Congress with $772–834 billion in cuts to Medicaid between FY 2017–2026. The health of citizens across the country is at stake, and so is the fiscal health of states.

Both Moody’s and Fitch Ratings have sounded the alarm as to what this may mean at the state and local level. According to Fitch Ratings:

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---Food Impact---Turns Case

Turns everything

Sinéad Lehane 17. Research manager for Future Directions International’s Global Food and Water Crises Research program. Her current research projects include Australia’s food system and water security in the Tibetan Plateau region, 2/2/17. “Shaping Conflict in the 21st Century – The Future of Food and Water Security.” www.hidropolitikakademi.org/shaping-conflict-in-the-21st-century-the-future-of-food-and-water-security.html

In his book, The Coming Famine, Julian Cribb writes that the wars of the 21st century will involve failed states, rebellions, civil conflict, insurgencies and terrorism. All of these elements will be triggered by competition over dwindling resources, rather than global conflicts with clearly defined sides. More than 40 countries experienced civil unrest following the food price crisis in 2008. The rapid increase in grain prices and prevailing food insecurity in many states is linked to the outbreak of protests, food riots and the breakdown of governance. Widespread food insecurity is a driving factor in creating a disaffected population ripe for rebellion. Given the interconnectivity of food security and political stability, it is likely food will continue to act as a political stressor on regimes in the Middle East and elsewhere. Addressing Insecurity Improving food and water security and encouraging resource sharing is critical to creating a stable and secure global environment. While food and water shortages contribute to a rising cycle of violence, improving food and water security outcomes can trigger the opposite and reduce the potential for conflict. With the global population expected to reach 9 billion by 2040, the likelihood of conflict exacerbated by scarcity over the next century is growing. Conflict is likely to be driven by a number of factors and difficult to address through diplomacy or military force. Population pressures, changing weather, urbanization, migration, a loss of arable land and freshwater resources are just some of the multi-layered stressors present in many states. Future inter-state conflict will move further away from the traditional, clear lines of military conflict and more towards economic control and influence.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

Those wars go nuclear

Julian Cribb, 10 – author, journalist, editor, and science communicator, principal of Julian Cribb & Associates who provide specialist consultancy in the communication of science, agriculture, food, mining, energy and the environment (Julian, 4/18. “The coming famine: risks and solutions for global food security.” http://www.sciencealert.com/the-coming-famine-risks-and-solutions-for-global-food-security)

Modern wars are often driven by scarcities of food, land and water. Dafour, Rwanda, Eritrea, the Balkans were all destabilized, at root, by squabbles over these resources. Going further back, the French and Russian civil wars both grew out of bread crises. We know that hunger breeds war.

The UK Ministry of Defence (which developed this threat map) America’s CIA, the US Center for Strategic and International Studies and the Oslo Peace Research Institute all identify famine as a potential trigger for conflicts and possibly even for nuclear wars.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

Experts and studies agree

FDI 12 Future Directions International. “International Conflict Triggers and Potential Conflict Points Resulting from Food and Water Insecurity.” May 25th, 2012. http://futuredirections.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Workshop_Report_-_Intl_Conflict_Triggers_-_May_25.pdf

There is little dispute that conflict can lead to food and water crises. This paper will consider parts of the world, however, where food and water insecurity can be the cause of conflict and, at worst, result in war. While dealing predominately with food and water issues, the paper also recognises the nexus that exists between food and water and energy security. There is a growing appreciation that the conflicts in the next century will most likely be fought over a lack of resources. Yet, in a sense, this is not new. Researchers point to the French and Russian revolutions as conflicts induced by a lack of food. More recently, Germany’s World War Two efforts are said to have been inspired, at least in part, by its perceived need to gain access to more food. Yet the general sense among those that attended FDI’s recent workshops, was that the scale of the problem in the future could be significantly greater as a result of population pressures, changing weather, urbanisation, migration, loss of arable land and other farm inputs, and increased affluence in the developing world. Page 9 of 22 In his book, Small Farmers Secure Food, Lindsay Falvey, a participant in FDI’s March 2012 workshop on the issue of food and conflict, clearly expresses the problem and why countries across the globe are starting to take note. . He writes (p.36), “…if people are hungry, especially in cities, the state is not stable – riots, violence, breakdown of law and order and migration result.” “Hunger feeds anarchy.” This view is also shared by Julian Cribb, who in his book, The Coming Famine, writes that if “large regions of the world run short of food, land or water in the decades that lie ahead, then wholesale, bloody wars are liable to follow.” He continues: “An increasingly credible scenario for World War 3 is not so much a confrontation of super powers and their allies, as a festering, self-perpetuating chain of resource conflicts.” He also says: “The wars of the 21st Century are less likely to be global conflicts with sharply defined sides and huge armies, than a scrappy mass of failed states, rebellions, civil strife, insurgencies, terrorism and genocides, sparked by bloody competition over dwindling resources.” As another workshop participant put it, people do not go to war to kill; they go to war over resources, either to protect or to gain the resources for themselves. Another observed that hunger results in passivity not conflict. Conflict is over resources, not because people are going hungry. A study by the International Peace Research Institute indicates that where food security is an issue, it is more likely to result in some form of conflict. Darfur, Rwanda, Eritrea and the Balkans experienced such wars. Governments, especially in developed countries, are increasingly aware of this phenomenon. The UK Ministry of Defence, the CIA, the US Center for Strategic and International Studies and the Oslo Peace Research Institute, all identify famine as a potential trigger for conflicts and possibly even nuclear war.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

High food prices cause instability in every region of the world

Fiona Harvey 11 – environmental correspondent for the Guardian, February 2011, “Failure to act on crop shortages fuelling political instability, experts warn,” http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/feb/07/crop-shortages-political-instability)

World leaders are ignoring potentially disastrous shortages of key crops, and their failures are fuelling political instability in key regions, food experts have warned.

Food prices have hit record levels in recent weeks, according to the United Nations, and soaring prices for staples such as grains over the past few months are thought to have been one of the factors contributing to an explosive mix of popular unrest in Egypt and Tunisia.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

US shocks cause global conflict and destabilize the international order

Isabel DoCampo 17. Research associate for the Chicago Council’s Global Food and Agriculture Program, 2/8/17. https://www.thechicagocouncil.org/blog/global-food-thought/food-secure-future-warding-instability-and-conflict

Food Insecurity and Price Shocks can Spark Violence and Political Instability

We have learned time and again that food supply shocks—like food price spikes—lead to instability, violence, and even regime collapse. In 2007 and 2008, when global food prices spiked dramatically, the governments of Haiti and Madagascar fell in the wake of food price-related protests. In 2010 and 2011, food prices were again implicated in the destabilizing uprisings of the Arab Spring. More recently, severe food shortages and soaring inflation have sparked rioting and lootings throughout Venezuela, as 90 percent of Venezuelan families struggle to afford food.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

Food shortages cause WWIII

Carolyn Heneghan 15, Reporter, citing UN experts, Global Harvest Initiative Report, 1/22/2015, Where food crises and global conflict could collide, http://www.fooddive.com/news/where-food-crises-and-global-conflict-could-collide/350837/

World War III is unimaginable for many, but some experts believe that not only is this degree of global conflict imminent, but it may be instigated not by military tensions, oil and gas, or nuclear threats, but instead by, of all things, food. As it stands, countries across the globe are enduring food crises, and the U.N.’s Food & Agriculture Organization (FAO) estimates that about 840 million people in the world are undernourished, including the one in four children under the age of 5 who is stunted because of malnutrition. Assistant director-general of U.N. FAO Asia-Pacific Hiroyuki Konuma told Reuters that social and political unrest, civil wars, and terrorism could all be possible results of food crises, and “world security as a whole might be affected.” Such consequences could happen unless the world increases its output of food production 60% by mid-century. This includes maintaining a stable growth rate at about 1% to have an even theoretical opportunity to circumvent severe shortages. These needs are due to the growing global population, which is expected to reach 9 billion by 2050 while demand for food will rise rapidly. Where the problems lie Exacerbating this issue is the fact that the world is spending less on agricultural research, to the dismay of scientists who believe global food production may not sustain the increased demand. According to American Boondoggle, “The pace of investment growth has slowed from 3.63 percent per year (after inflation) during 1950–69, to 1.79 percent during 1970–89, to 0.94 percent during 1990– 2009.” Decreased growth in agricultural research and development spending has slowed across the world as a whole, but it is even slower in high-income countries. Water scarcity is another problem, including in major food-producing nations like China, as well as climate change. Extreme weather events are having a severe effect on crops, which have been devastated in countries like Australia, Canada, China, Russia, and the U.S., namely due to floods and droughts. An Intergovernmental Panel on Climate change recently warned that climate change may result in “a 2% drop each decade of this century,” according to RT. Rising food costs also contribute to poor food security across the world as prices remain high and volatile. Higher food costs inhibit lower socioeconomic people’s access to food, which contributes to the FAO’s disturbing figure of global malnutrition. In addition to an inability for people to feed themselves, poverty can also reduce food production, such as some African farmers being unable to afford irrigation and fertilizers to provide their regions with food. Still another issue for decreased food production is the fact that many farmers are turning crops like soy, corn, and sugar into sources for biofuel rather than edible consumption, which means these foods are taken away from people to eat. Could these shortages lead to a major global conflict? Studies suggest that the food crisis could begin as early as 2030, just a short 15 years from now, particularly in areas such as East Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. Both regions have significant problems with domestic food production. Some experts believe that, to secure enough food resources for their populations, countries may go to war over the increasingly scarce food supply. This could be due in part to warring parties blocking aid and commercial food deliveries to areas supporting their enemies, despite the fact that such a practice breaks international humanitarian law. Conflict also leads to lack of food supply for populations as people become displaced and forced from their homes, jobs, and income and thus cannot buy food to feed themselves. Displaced farmers are also unable to produce their normal crops, contributing still more to food shortages in certain countries. Food insecurity is a major threat to world peace and could potentially incite violent conflict between countries across the world. Thus, the U.N. and other governmental bodies are desperately trying to find ways to solve the problem before it becomes something they cannot control.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

Food insecurity incentivizes people to join terrorist groups and allows them to delegitimize the state

Alexander 22 — [Rayna Alexander, “Food Insecurity and Terrorism: What Famine Means for Somalia,” Foreign Policy Research Institute, 8-16-2022, https://www.fpri.org/article/2022/08/food-insecurity-and-terrorism-what-famine-means-for-somalia/, accessed 12-30-2022] - PG

According to the most recent Global Terrorism Index report, sub-Saharan Africa is the global epicentre of terrorism, accounting for 48 percent of terrorism-related/caused deaths worldwide. Somalia ranks first in Africa and third globally as the most impacted by terrorism. Numerous groups in Somalia, including Islamic State-Somalia, Hizb al Islam, and Ahlu Sunna, could exploit the growing food crisis. However, al-Shabaab, Somalia’s largest terrorist threat (responsible for almost 90 percent of Somalia’s terror-related deaths in 2021), is the most worrisome. Al-Shabaab, or “the youth” in Arabic, controls more than 20 percent of the country, primarily in the south and central regions (an area the size of Texas). An estimated 7,000 of al-Shabaab’s members govern rural areas, extort taxes, and provide health, educational, and judicial services, undermining the state government’s legitimacy and emboldening the group as a source of de facto authority. Throughout Somalia, al-Shabaab exploits businesses, real estate, and construction, as well as local schools, clinics, mobile courts, and police departments. According to one business owner who pays the militants $4,000 annually, “the Shabab are like a mafia group. You either have to obey them or close your business. There’s no freedom.” Food and water inaccessibility and increased commodity prices are related to insurgent activity and the potential for a social uprising. In 2011, for example, food prices were related to the mobilization of farmers in Tunisia that ignited the Arab Spring. The drought in the Horn of Africa and subsequent drinking water shortages may increase competition and lead to communal violence. In turn, militant groups will have an opportunity to provide resources and further legitimize their intervention, undermining state actions (or lack thereof). Acute food insecurity may also increase social grievances and mobilize disaffected individuals to join terrorist organizations. In one study, the Network for Religious and Traditional Peacemakers found more than half of former al-Shabaab members cite economic factors as their primary motivation to join (see below). One recruit concluded, “all one had to do was carry around a gun and patrol the streets. It was an easy job compared to other jobs such as construction work.” Disadvantaged Somalis may see al-Shabaab membership as a source of income. Recruits are offered a monthly salary and financial benefits. Given the current socio-economic status of many Somalis and the lack of economic opportunity in the agricultural sector, al-Shabaab may become more enticing for individuals with limited opportunities. Al-Shabaab recruits are as young as fourteen, and 70 percent are younger than 24 years old. In Somalia, where the median age is 17 years old, recruitment trends are a cause for concern. In May 2022, the UN Refugee Agency reported a total of 2.97 million were displaced Somalis due to drought, food shortages, and violence. Mass internal migration has resulted in overcrowded refugee sites where many lack adequate shelter and water. Overcrowded sites can also be used as safe havens, as they are commonly isolated from authorities, allowing terrorists to operate undetected. Terrorist training networks are also common in refugee communities where displaced peoples are directly or involuntarily recruited. Worsening conditions force internally displaced peoples to turn to all sources of aid. Attacks and aid worker kidnappings deter agencies from reaching communities in occupied territories (some 900,000 Somalis). However, trained militants are able to exploit government grievances and impose order in disorganized camps. For al-Shabaab, control of camps is viable and demand for compensation and recruits is opportune. Conversely, the Somali government’s inability to provide physical and economic security delegitimizes the political establishment, contributing to a vicious cycle of weak governance and militant influence and insurgence. Propaganda further legitimizes terrorist activity. Al-Shabaab argues international humanitarian aid weakens the country and results in dependency on “infidels.” News and radio outlets that distribute pro-al-Shabaab propaganda claim militants are the superior authority alternative to international intervention and failed state governance.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

Food riots and internal civil strife spills up to cause nuclear war

Kleyn 12 — [Gary Kleyn is an Australian writer for the Independent Strategic Analysis Australia’s Global Interests and has published multiple articles about international conflict scenarios in the globe, “International Conflict Triggers and Potential Conflict Points Resulting from Food and Water Insecurity,” Future Directions International, 05-25-2012, https://apo.org.au/sites/default/files/resource-files/2012-05/apo-nid29595.pdf, accessed 7-14-2023] - PG

There is a growing appreciation that the conflicts in the next century will most likely be fought over a lack of resources. Yet, in a sense, this is not new. Researchers point to the French and Russian revolutions as conflicts induced by a lack of food. More recently, Germany’s World War Two efforts are said to have been inspired, at least in part, by its perceived need to gain access to more food. Yet the general sense among those that attended FDI’s recent workshops, was that the scale of the problem in the future could be significantly greater as a result of population pressures, changing weather, urbanisation, migration, loss of arable land and other farm inputs, and increased affluence in the developing world. In his book, Small Farmers Secure Food, Lindsay Falvey, a participant in FDI’s March 2012 workshop on the issue of food and conflict, clearly expresses the problem and why countries across the globe are starting to take note. . He writes (p.36), “…if people are hungry, especially in cities, the state is not stable – riots, violence, breakdown of law and order and migration result.” “Hunger feeds anarchy.” This view is also shared by Julian Cribb, who in his book, The Coming Famine, writes that if “large regions of the world run short of food, land or water in the decades that lie ahead, then wholesale, bloody wars are liable to follow.” He continues: “An increasingly credible scenario for World War 3 is not so much a confrontation of super powers and their allies, as a festering, self-perpetuating chain of resource conflicts.” He also says: “The wars of the 21st Century are less likely to be global conflicts with sharply defined sides and huge armies, than a scrappy mass of failed states, rebellions, civil strife, insurgencies, terrorism and genocides, sparked by bloody competition over dwindling resources.” As another workshop participant put it, people do not go to war to kill; they go to war over resources, either to protect or to gain the resources for themselves. Another observed that hunger results in passivity not conflict. Conflict is over resources, not because people are going hungry. A study by the International Peace Research Institute indicates that where food security is an issue, it is more likely to result in some form of conflict. Darfur, Rwanda, Eritrea and the Balkans experienced such wars. Governments, especially in developed countries, are increasingly aware of this phenomenon. The UK Ministry of Defence, the CIA, the US Center for Strategic and International Studies and the Oslo Peace Research Institute, all identify famine as a potential trigger for conflicts and possibly even nuclear war.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Food Impact---AT: Defense

It causes war AND the scenario is uniquely dangerous

Kemmerling 22 — [Birgit Kemmerling has a PhD at University of Leipzig; MA in Geography at University of Cologne (minors Social Anthropology and Political Sciences, “The logics of war and food (in)security,” June 2022, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211912422000256, accessed 12-30-2022] – PG

The world is witnessing an increasing number of people living in food insecurity. Many of the current food crises are affected by or have an impact on violent conflicts. The most visible impact of violent conflicts on food security is the destruction of agricultural land, irrigation schemes, and infrastructure. In addition, displacement and mass starvation due to violent conflict have adverse and often long-term effects on the food security of affected populations. Chronic food insecurity, in turn, can become a decisive factor in prolonging or intensifying violent conflicts, instigating a vicious circle of violence and hunger (Martin-Shields and Stojetz, 2019). Several food crises over the past decades have revealed the weaknesses of the international community in governing food (in)security in conflict settings. While national governments or belligerents are often unable or unwilling to respond adequately to food crises, humanitarian relief operations face the challenges of reaching those people in need of a food supply, while simultaneously avoiding exacerbating the conflict. This has left many affected communities having to find their own responses to food insecurity. Most recently, the United Nations Food Systems Summit in 2021 has been declared as a “people's”- and “solutions”- centered summit, which brought together a wide range of experts and institutions to provide solutions for advancing the transformation of food systems (United Nations, 2021a). While the summit acknowledged that transformation in the global food system will directly lead to progress on the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), the links between food crises and violent conflict, unfortunately, played only a minor role. However, achieving food security, ending hunger and malnutrition, and enabling sustainable agricultural production, as addressed by SDG 2, “Zero Hunger”, largely depends on the progress made on SDG 16, “Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions”, in promoting peaceful and inclusive societies. (Civil) wars and violent conflicts are a drastic setback for every type of sustainable development. Conflict-affected countries are far from reaching the milestones of all SDG targets such as food security. Preventing and overcoming (civil) wars is, therefore, the necessary framework condition for being able to achieve SDG 2 and related SDGs, such as SDG 1, “No poverty”, or SDG 10, “Reduced inequalities”, in the first place. Food security, in turn, is necessary to achieve progress on SDG 16. Against this background, the aim of this review article is to shed light on the manifold interlinkages between food insecurity and violent conflicts and to discuss how policy action can face the challenge to improve conditions of food security in violent settings, especially in civil wars. The paper is organized in the following way: first, we provide an overview of recent global trends and regional correlations of food insecurity and violent conflicts. Second, we conduct a comprehensive literature review on the correlations between food insecurity and violent conflicts. We identified four logics of how violent conflicts and war have an impact on food (in)security: a) destruction, b) conflict-induced displacement, c) control, and d) hunger as a “weapon of war”. In the third part of the paper, we identify four key areas that policy actions and research should address for coping with food crises in violent conflicts, providing concrete examples to demonstrate how these actions can improve food security in protracted conflicts.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals K2 Ag

Rural care is key to US ag exports

Irv Lichtenwald 16. CEO of Medsphere Systems Corporation, 2/22/16. “Is CMS Efforts Enough to Transform Rural Healthcare?”

The scenario is far from unrealistic. For the most part, non-urban healthcare organizations are not doing well. In fact, almost every rural hospital in the country is operating near the margin or in the red. According to iVantage Health Analytics Senior Vice President Michal Topchik, speaking to Health Data Management, 67 rural hospitals have closed since 2010, and 283 were vulnerable to closure last year. Already in 2016 iVantage has identified 673 vulnerable rural hospitals, with 210 at very high risk.

While only about 15 percent of the American population, roughly 46 million people, live in rural areas, they do some of the nation’s most essential work. Mostly, they grow food, produce energy or provide services to the people that grow food and produce energy.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals K2 Ag

Rural hospitals key to agriculture and energy production

CHQPR 20. Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform. “1. The Importance of Rural Hospitals.” https://ruralhospitals.chqpr.org/Importance.html

Small rural hospitals provide most or all of the healthcare services in the small communities they serve. Small rural hospitals deliver not only traditional hospital services such as emergency care, inpatient care, and laboratory testing, but also rehabilitation, long-term care, maternity care, home health care, and even primary care. The majority of the communities they serve are at least a half-hour drive from the nearest alternative hospital, and many communities have no alternate sources of healthcare.

Small rural hospitals are struggling to survive and rural communities are being harmed. The majority of small rural hospitals are losing money delivering patient services. More than 130 rural hospitals have closed in the past decade, and most of these were small rural hospitals. In most cases, the closure of the hospital resulted in the loss of both the emergency department and other outpatient services, and residents of the community must now travel much farther when they have an emergency or need other healthcare services. This increases the risk of death or disability when accidents or serious medical conditions occur, but it also increases the risk of health problems going undiagnosed or inadequately treated due to lack of access to care.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals K2 Ag

Rural health key to U.S. ag – that’s key to global food security

Jane N Bolin 15, JD from the University of Oregon PhD in Health Services Research from Penn State, Professor in Health Policy and Management at Texas A&M University, 5/7/2015, “Rural Healthy People 2020: New Decade, Same Challenges”, The Journal of Rural Health, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jrh.12116/full

Abstract Purpose The health of rural America is more important than ever to the health of the United States and the world. Rural Healthy People 2020's goal is to serve as a counterpart to Healthy People 2020, providing evidence of rural stakeholders’ assessment of rural health priorities and allowing national and state rural stakeholders to reflect on and measure progress in meeting those goals. The specific aim of the Rural Healthy People 2020 national survey was to identify rural health priorities from among the Healthy People 2020's (HP2020) national priorities. Methods Rural health stakeholders (n = 1,214) responded to a nationally disseminated web survey soliciting identification of the top 10 rural health priorities from among the HP2020 priorities. Stakeholders were also asked to identify objectives within each national HP2020 priority and express concerns or additional responses. Findings and Conclusions Rural health priorities have changed little in the last decade. Access to health care continues to be the most frequently identified rural health priority. Within this priority, emergency services, primary care, and insurance generate the most concern. A total of 926 respondents identified access as the no. 1 rural health priority, followed by, no. 2 nutrition and weight status (n = 661), no. 3 diabetes (n = 660), no. 4 mental health and mental disorders (n = 651), no. 5 substance abuse (n = 551), no. 6 heart disease and stroke (n = 550), no. 7 physical activity and health (n = 542), no. 8 older adults (n = 482), no. 9 maternal infant and child health (n = 449), and no. 10 tobacco use (n = 429). The health of rural America is more important than ever to the overall health of the United States.[1] Rural populations and regions serve the nation not only as an “agricultural and resource basket” providing people with needed crops and raw resources for an increasingly hungry nation and the world,[2] but they also provide important recreational and historic opportunities and cultural experiences. According to the 2010 US Census Bureau data, 59 million people, or 17% of the US population, live in rural or remote communities. Yet, only 9% of doctors and 16% of registered nurses practice in rural areas.[3, 4] Rural America also has a documented undersupply of nurse practitioners, dentists, pharmacists, and limited access to specialty care, including but not limited to general surgery and obstetrics.[3] Rural hospital closures that left many rural counties without a hospital in the 1980s had slowed with the passage of federal legislation creating special categories of rural hospitals (eg, critical access hospitals [CAHs]) with special protections. However, rural hospital closures appear to be on the rise again due to cutbacks in Medicare reimbursement, reduced funding, and imminent deadlines for instituting electronic medical records.[5] At the same time, relative to urban America, mortality and longevity rates are falling behind in rural America, particularly for females.[6, 7] In the decade since the publication of Rural Healthy People 2010,[8] rural Americans have continued to cobble together scarce resources to address the needs of their local and regional public health infrastructure. Often these challenges are more severe, and sometimes insurmountable, for rural racial and ethnic minorities or disabled persons living in rural areas. Some rural regions, such as the US-Mexico border and rural Appalachia, face third-world living conditions leading to significantly higher rates of preventable vector borne diseases and preventable or avoidable chronic diseases.[9, 10] It would be a mistake to characterize rural America as exclusively white, when in fact rural communities reflect the diversity of cultures, tribes, and sects that have settled in towns, counties, and regions across the country. Rural communities in the Deep South are very different from those in the Midwest or in the Southwest. For example, rural West Virginia is very different from rural Arizona. Even within states such as Texas, rural populations east of Interstate Highway-35 are different from rural communities west of I-35, and both are quite different from rural counties along the US-Mexico border. The diversity of rural populations reflects the migration patterns of various ethnic groups, both historically and more recently those seeking political or religious asylum, that have come (or been brought) to the United States and settled across the nation with their values, cultures, and beliefs. No matter where they live, rural residents are far more likely to face significant challenges and disparities. According to US Census Bureau data, poverty rates among rural black, non-Hispanic (32.2%), and Hispanic (27.8%) populations were significantly higher than those same populations living in urban/metro areas.[11] Moreover, the poverty rate for children living in rural areas (23.5%) is somewhat higher than for children living in poor inner city urban areas (20.2%). Overall poverty rates are also higher in rural areas (16.6%) compared to urban (13.9%) areas. Nationally, two-thirds of rural counties have poverty rates at or above the national average of 14.4%.[12] Poverty is a major risk factor for poor health outcomes and is more prevalent in rural and inner city areas than suburban areas.[13] Although the population of rural America overall has continued to grow, 750 rural counties experienced a natural decrease (deaths exceeding the number of births) over this last decade, 36% versus 22% in the last decade of the 20th century.[14] In Florida, poverty in rural counties is now at a historically high level (20.3%). Poverty rates are higher among rural minority populations, especially in the rural Southeast and along the border, while many in rural Appalachia, and the Colonias along the Texas-Mexico border, still live without running water or electricity.[9, 10] In a rather provocative piece, Galambos,[15] argued that rural health disparity has been a “neglected frontier.” During the past decade, the percent of rural elderly was greater than urban elderly (15% compared to 12%). Moreover, in a quarter of nonmetropolitan counties the percent of rural elderly was 18% or greater.[16] Growth in the number of rural elderly is the result of 2 forces, 1 attributed to outward migration of young people and, the other, the inward migration of elderly retirees. These forces are felt differentially across America because those elderly retirees migrating into rural are more likely to be healthier physically and better-off economically than those rural elderly that are aging-in-place. Although aging is associated with an increase in chronic illness, the prevalence is likely to be lower among the former. Rural America is also becoming more diverse. The 2010 census showed minorities accounting for 82.7% of the increase in nonmetropolitan populations, even though they represented just 21% of the rural population.[16] McGuire et al argued that place (setting) and race (composition) combine to account for the use of health services, even when controlling for medical needs.[17] The health status of rural minorities is not only worse than rural whites, but rural minorities are also poorer than their urban counterparts. It is well documented that living in a rural area brings higher risk of substantial health disadvantages in comparison to both urban and suburban areas.[18, 19]

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals I/L

Lack of Medicaid means people don’t go to hospitals – This devastates already struggling rural organizations

Tolbert and Drake 22 — [Jennifer Tolbert is Director of State Health Reform and Associate Director with the Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured at KFF. She directs research and policy analysis focusing on Medicaid eligibility and enrollment policies, access to and affordability of coverage for low-income populations, including people who are uninsured, and consumer assistance. Patrick Drake is a Senior Data Analyst with KFF’s Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured (KPMU). Patrick works to promote data accessibility and use to inform health policy on KFF’s State Health Facts Website. Prior to joining KPMU, Patrick studied maternal and infant health as a Statistician at the United States National Center for Health Statistics and built data platforms for Global Public Health at the Global Fund to Fight HIV, Tuberculosis, and Malaria. Patrick holds a Master’s in Biostatistics from the University of Michigan, and a bachelor’s in mathematics and music from Lake Forest College., “Key Facts about the Uninsured Population,” KFF, 12-19-2022, https://www.kff.org/uninsured/issue-brief/key-facts-about-the-uninsured-population/, accessed 7-14-2023] - PG

Health insurance makes a difference in whether and when people get necessary medical care, where they get their care, and ultimately, how healthy they are. While the COVID-19 pandemic affected health care utilization broadly, uninsured adults are far more likely than those with insurance to postpone health care or forgo it altogether because of concerns over costs. The consequences can be severe, particularly when preventable conditions or chronic diseases go undetected. Studies repeatedly demonstrate that uninsured individuals are less likely than those with insurance to receive preventive care and services for major health conditions and chronic diseases. Although, overall, people reported lower utilization of health care services during the pandemic and fewer barriers due to cost, disparities between those who lack health coverage and those with coverage persisted.13 In 2021, nearly half (46.7%) of nonelderly uninsured adults reported not seeing a doctor or health care professional in the past 12 months compared to 18.2% with private insurance and 13.1% with public coverage. Just over one in five (20.7%) nonelderly adults without coverage said that they went without needed care in the past year because of cost compared to 5.0% of adults with private coverage and 6.1% of adults with public coverage. Part of the reason for poor access among the uninsured is that many (40.9%) do not have a regular place to go when they are sick or need medical advice (Figure 8).

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals I/L

Medicaid cuts have a catastrophic ripple effect- it devastates healthcare in rural areas

ED BARBER 23 (journalist at Newport Vermont daily; “The Ripple Effect of Medicaid Cuts-full”; NewPort Vermont Daily; https://www.newportvermontdailyexpress.com/the-ripple-effect-of-medicaid-cuts-full/article_a6d67558-e7a1-11ed-85ad-7be7a94878a3.html//TMS-Isir)

During the Covid pandemic eligibility for Medicaid services increased. The population of Vermonters eligible under those pandemic rules will lose coverage under the House of Representatives plan. An estimated 21 million people will lose their benefits. Medicaid funds provide medical insurance and a wide variety of services. Dental care, mental health care, substance abuse counseling, long term care services and supports, medical equipment, hospice services, home health aids, developmental disability support, eye care, transportation, rural health clinic services, as well as hospital inpatient and outpatient services. There are optional services including prescription drugs, clinic services, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech, language and hearing disorder services. "Ninety-two million people are enrolled in Medicaid programs," Congresswoman Jan Schakowsky of Illinois stated. She was one of the architects of President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act. Congress has tied the cuts in Medicaid to enforcing a work requirement. The bill requires those on Medicaid that are under 55 to work a certain number of hours per month, or perform community service if eligible. There are exemptions, such as if the individual is pregnant, has dependent children, are disabled, in a substance program, or are in school. "Most Medicaid people are working, taking care of children and seniors, are attending school or have health issues," Schakowsky said. "Most people, if they can, want to work." Language in the bill requires Medicaid recipients to have a physician providing their care to certify the person can't work. All Medicaid patients are required to furnish proof they are unable to work on an annual basis. Last week Congress passed the Limit, Save, Grow Act of 2023 by a margin of 217 in favor and 215 opposed. Four Republicans voted against the bill. The measure will lift the debt ceiling by $1.5 trillion, but is tied to spending cuts of $4.5 trillion. Medicaid is a popular federal program. At Senator Welch's press conference a recent poll was cited, indicating 58 percent of voters oppose cutting Medicaid for those in need. Eighty-nine percent of those polled do not want Congress to cut Medicaid funding. "It's a very draconian bill," Welch said. "This is not as much about Medicaid; it's tied to paying our bills. Where this bill will go, I don't know." Senator Welch said the bill is not supported in the Senate where the Democrats hold a razor thin margin. Welch said there are Republicans who have indicated they will not support Medicaid spending cuts. The cuts will impact health care services for Vermont's veterans. Welch said there's an immense amount of anxiety among the populations affected by Medicaid cuts. The ripple effect will increase the financial strain on the health care infrastructure, especially hospitals. The financial strain on community hospitals and Vermont's tertiary care medical center was tenuous prior to the Covid pandemic. The situation is even more dire now and Welch is concerned Medicaid cuts could devastate health care in rural communities. "Medicaid cuts are a federal way to stick it to the states," the Senator said. The United States is one of two countries that have limits on the debt ceiling. Welch said this is a budget process; do you pay your bills or stick it to someone? "The ripple effect is catastrophic," Welch said. The debt crisis isn't a result of Medicaid spending. It’s from lost revenue from the Trump tax cuts, the Covid pandemic, and unfunded conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, he claimed.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › ---XT---Rural Hospitals I/L

Medicaid cuts devastate rural hospitals.

Rick Schmitt 17, CVA (Certified Valuation Analyst) and ASA (Accredited Senior Appraiser, President of Gordon Brothers Valuation Practice, Bob Maroney, May 207, “Changes, Challenges Are Sole Certainties in Healthcare’s Uncertain Future”,

The future of healthcare in America has never been so uncertain. Amid continuing political tensions, payer and patient pressures, and changes in the way that care is delivered, there doesn’t appear to be a clear and distinct path forward. And there may not be for quite some time, given Congress’ recent unsuccessful attempt to replace the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Fear of the unknown is creating a great deal of stress for individuals, hospitals, and healthcare providers alike. What is known, however, is that the healthcare industry will face significant change and challenges in 2017 and beyond. Most of these challenges will continue to stem from reimbursement cuts, the continuing shift from inpatient to outpatient services, and rising costs to maintain or update technology to meet industry standards. A number of factors contribute to this overwhelming feeling of uncertainty, starting with the future of the ACA. As most know, the ACA is a primary reason that hospitals have been seeing higher volumes of insured patients. If the law is eventually repealed or replaced, those volumes would drop significantly and adversely impact payments. The repercussions on providers would be substantial, especially since one of the ACA’s primary objectives is to reward quality of care as opposed to quantity of care—a change that has impacted hospitals serving Medicare patients the most. Regardless of how everything works out, the shift in payments will force providers with high Medicaid/Medicare patient populations to determine the best way to move forward with lower reimbursements. In addition to reduced reimbursements, necessary investments in personnel, equipment, and technology have also led to significant margin compression in the traditional hospital setting. And maintaining compliance with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act, as well as keeping up with a host of anti-kickback and medical malpractice guidelines, has created financial pressures that are simply unavoidable. Changes in consumer behavior, specifically consumer reactions to high-deductible plans, are creating further uncertainty for hospitals in projecting patient volume and revenue. Patients are now considering all options for care, and rightfully so, given the high out-of-pocket costs typically associated with a traditional hospital setting. Convenience is no longer the primary consideration when it comes to seeking care; hence the rise of specialized outpatient services. And consumers have taken notice. Specialty providers, such as orthopedic clinics and urgent care clinics, provide the speed, availability, and affordability that hospitals can’t. These consumer-friendly outpatient services have created a surplus of traditional hospital beds, leading to an increasing number of hospital consolidations and closures, particularly for rural and community hospitals. Survival has become increasingly difficult for smaller hospitals, forcing many of them to align with larger healthcare systems to remain profitable. Impact on the Industry These financial challenges have led to a steady increase in healthcare bankruptcies and consolidations over the last three years, a trend that initially began in Q4 2014. According to data compiled by CapitalIQ, the number of distressed M&A deals involving healthcare providers in the U.S. increased an astounding 86 percent from 2013-2014 to 2015-2016. This impact is most acutely seen in rural America, as more than 80 hospitals in rural areas have closed since 2010, according to the National Rural Health Association. This trend is likely to continue, particularly since the reduction in Medicaid/Medicare reimbursements and the increasing availability of alternative outpatient options have the greatest impact on hospitals in rural areas. The failure of some states to expand or opt out of Medicaid makes this problem even worse. Rural hospitals also continue to suffer from an inability to attract and retain top medical talent, especially in primary care and specialized areas, such as cardiology and oncology. This not only contributes to the consolidation and closure of rural hospitals, but it also has an adverse impact on the communities in which those hospitals operate. And, if the ACA is repealed or replaced and Medicaid funding is cut even further, this would almost certainly exacerbate the problem. In addition, and this impacts hospitals and communities of all sizes, independently employed physicians are leaving private practice in favor of hospitals and healthcare systems. Larger entities offer the technology, equipment, and economies of scale that private practice does not. This is also a way for independently employed physicians to relieve their own financial obligations, especially since the growth of retail clinics has severely hampered their ability to remain profitable. These retail clinics, which are found in pharmacies such as CVS, Rite Aid, and Walgreens, meet the needs of the consumer in ways that private practices cannot. The clinics are usually closer, have extended hours, and are staffed by nurses and nurse practitioners like those that a patient would see at a physician’s office. They also typically offer greater financial incentive for most patients in the form of lower cost flat-rate care. In fact, according to Accenture, there will be more than 2,800 retail clinics by 2018, a 47 percent increase over the number operating in 2014. Competing with this model will prove difficult if traditional service providers don’t make changes in the way in which they provide care. The expansion of clinic offerings and the creation of partnerships with retail clinics are two options to counteract this trend. Surviving the Uncertainty So what’s the best way to ensure survival in a time when there is no clear indication of what’s next? There are multiple considerations, of course, but none is more important than an honest and careful evaluation of the business plan. At a minimum, healthcare providers must make sure their core services are supported and the business model provides room for continued growth and sustainable margins. Disposing of nonessential and nonstrategic facilities or expansions that don’t make practical or financial sense is a given, especially if they don’t support the provider’s long-term vision. At the same time, providers should consider expanding service line offerings and specialty programs, especially those that generate long-term revenue streams. For some, that could mean treating cancer and other serious illnesses or injuries. Given the nature of the illness or condition, these types of services require extended outpatient care and/or rehabilitation in a hospital setting. While not all providers are equipped to deliver all potential service lines, they should consider those that they’re best-suited to handle and that help them avoid relying on competitive streams that go head to head with low-cost retail clinics. Providers might also consider taking advantage of less common and nontraditional avenues, such as asset-based lending facilities, especially since hospitals are asset-intensive and typically have major investments in machinery and equipment. One way or another, the coming months will reveal more about the future of healthcare in America. Outside of the new administration’s approach to policymaking and regulatory matters, which everyone is watching closely, there are certain indicators that may provide clues on where the industry is headed. Some of these signs include bankruptcies, reported cash flows from major hospitals and clinics, reports from major manufacturers and industry associations on reinvestments in equipment, and hospital facility expansion. Questions about reimbursements, incentives, and the insured pool will persist. And healthcare providers will continue to face pressure from consolidation. One thing that can be controlled, however, is education on the issues and working with trusted advisors to plan and prepare for next steps in the face of change, wherever that change takes the healthcare industry.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Rural Hospitals---1NC

Food insecurity causes conflict and war

Continued US leadership is key and no one fills the vacuum

Flowers, director of the Global Food Security Project and the Humanitarian Agenda at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), ‘18

(Kimberly, “Keeping it Stable: The Connection Between Hunger and Conflict,” January 31,

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Rural Hospitals---1NC

Rural hospital closures cause massive food spikes

Alemian 16 — [David Alemian is a journalist and a writer for the Medical Economics Paper, “Rural Healthcare Is a Matter of National Security,” Medical Economics, 11-8-2016, https://www.medicaleconomics.com/view/rural-healthcare-is-a-matter-of-national-security, accessed 7-14-2023] - PG

Value-based healthcare has made the problem of talent retention and recruitment in rural America a matter of national security. Talent shortages make it nearly impossible for rural health organizations to successfully transition to value-based healthcare. Without the needed high quality talent, rural health organizations will be unable to deliver high quality healthcare. As a result, Medicare and Medicaid would financially penalize them. Rural health organizations are already struggling with enormous turnover rates and costs that run up into the millions of dollars each year. The additional financial burden of penalties from Medicare and Medicaid will put many rural health organizations at risk of going out of business. If too many rural health organizations go out of business, it then becomes a matter of national security and here’s why: In most rural communities, the healthcare organization is the largest employer. When the largest employer goes out of business, the community collapses and people move away. What was once a thriving community then becomes a ghost town. Rural America produces the food that feeds the rest of the country. What will happen when our amber waves of grain turn to desert wastelands because there is no one to work our great farmlands? As the source of food dries up, and store shelves empty, the price of food will go through the roof. As food prices go up, hyperinflation will become a reality, and our printed money will become worthless. Almost overnight, Americans will begin to go hungry because they won’t be able to afford to put food on the table.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Impacts › Medicaid Impact---Rural Hospitals---1NC

Medicaid cuts wreck rural hospitals

Andy Schneider 17. Research Professor at the Georgetown University McCourt School of Public Policy, 6-9-2017. "Connecting the Dots: Capping Medicaid, Closing Rural Hospitals, and Stranding Rural Children and Families," https://ccf.georgetown.edu/2017/06/09/connecting-the-dots-capping-medicaid-closing-rural-hospitals-and-stranding-rural-children-and-families/.

So it is completely mystifying that the Senate, according to all reports, is seriously considering capping federal Medicaid payments to states starting in 2020 and each year thereafter in perpetuity. A cap on Medicaid would almost certainly lead to a large federal disinvestment from health care in rural America, leaving rural communities without health care infrastructure and children and families without geographic access to care.

Allow me to connect the dots:

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › Social Security Link---2NC

Social Security is controversial – makes horsetradfing inevitable

Eli Lehrer 18 ( writer for the National Affairs; “A Politics of Public Goods”; National Affairs; https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/a-politics-of-public-goods//TMS-Isir)

First and most important, the provision of public goods provides an alternative to the socially corrosive identity politics of modern progressivism that many academics and other influential cultural elites robustly promote. While a degree of group identity is healthy and, indeed, necessary for social progress, it is nearly impossible to build social solidarity upon the basis of group characteristics that are more or less immutable. Indeed, the enthusiastic embrace of identity politics by so many on the left has proven inconsistent with either improving the existing American welfare state or accomplishing progressivism's overriding goals, such as reducing income inequality. So long as group identity exists, it will be difficult to avoid the observation that certain aspects of the welfare state disproportionately benefit some groups over others. This makes the social insurance provided by the state far more controversial than it otherwise would be, and likely degrades the quality of the programs themselves. As America's inability to reform Social Security and Medicare shows, the groups that benefit most will try to define their benefits as somehow "earned" and "deserved," while denigrating those provided to others. Even if America theoretically could build social solidarity and increase confidence in a national project on the basis of a vastly larger social-insurance state, no current political force is interested in doing so in the short term: The left is too concerned with identity politics, while a large — if shrinking — part of the right opposes a significantly larger welfare state, believing that it would smother much of what makes America unique and prosperous. Second, public goods are more unifying for the population because they are "needed" by everyone, while the benefits of a social-insurance state are not. The overwhelming majority of able-bodied people living in a developed, stable democracy will never slip into long-term poverty regardless of whether they are involved in a social-insurance system. But nobody can provide clean air or national defense alone, and there is by definition no market demand for true basic science. Physical-infrastructure projects (which are not core public goods, in any case) can be distributed unequally and can be excludable through tolls and user fees. But they cannot practically be built by any individual alone. Governments can also take on the long-term debt necessary to finance such projects at lower interest rates than the private sector can. The horse-trading involved in our political system and the unique role of the states have resulted in large infrastructure projects that have, indeed, had widespread benefits. Both the interstate highway system and the rollout of broadband internet infrastructure, for instance, involved "over-investments" in rural areas relative to their populations, and therefore enjoy widespread support. And while it is certainly possible to exclude certain citizens from the benefits of quasi-public goods (in fact, the Jim Crow system existed primarily to do just this), doing so has not only proven quite difficult to sustain in the long term, but it is deeply inconsistent with the principle of individual liberty and the maintenance of a true liberal democracy.