Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › Social Security Link---2NC

Expanding social security locks in interparty conflict- results in cuts to other programs

James G. Chappel 23 (Gilhuly Family Associate Professor of History at Duke University; “The Frozen Politics of Social Security”; Boston Review; https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/the-frozen-politics-of-social-security//TMS- Isir)

That moment quickly passed, and in the mid-1970s, thanks to inflation and unemployment, the program entered a fiscal crisis. Social Security has been under assault ever since, with conservatives attacking the system as fundamentally illegitimate and fiscally unsound. The classic clash, and the one we have now, has been between a GOP movement aiming to roll it back and a responsible center seeking to save it. Consider, for an early example, a 1971 debate on Social Security between Cohen and Milton Friedman. The exchange was hosted by the American Enterprise Institute, and it centered on the system’s legitimacy. Friedman was in his element: a happy warrior, making jokes and playing to the audience, even while calling for a form of privatization that would have been a death warrant for many poor and disabled people. It is telling that Cohen served as Friedman’s opponent at all. Friedman was an ideological renegade, leading an insurgent right wing. Leftists had such figures, of course, but none of them cared much about Social Security. Cohen was the best defender the system had at the time. And he’s a good one, too: articulate and well-versed, far more than Friedman, in the minutiae of the program. He was nonetheless outmatched, and any viewer of the debate, knowing nothing about Social Security coming in, would be swayed by the smug charm of Friedman over the disheveled and frustrated bureaucrat. Cohen had nothing to combat Friedman’s rhetorical excesses, and in fact largely accepted the terms of debate. He labored to show that Social Security was compatible with “our free enterprise system.” Social Security, he insisted, “reinforces thrift, reinforces initiative.” And with some tweaks, he insisted, it could remain solvent. The discussion has moved on, some, since the 1970s. Privatization, with some exceptions, has ceased to be a rallying cry for conservatives. George W. Bush tried to do it in his second term with disastrous results. Republicans are more likely, now, to call for benefit cuts and a higher retirement age. Democrats, for their part, are still talking like Cohen: exasperated with Republicans and claiming the moral high ground by fending off Republican cuts. That strategy, fundamentally defensive in nature, may have made sense in an era of bipartisanship and program solvency. It no longer does. Indeed, even as the bipartisan, consensus-seeking spirit of technocracy becomes increasingly irrelevant to U.S. politics, it remains the dominant register for thinking about Social Security. Both Fixing Social Security and The Retirement Challenge exemplify this state of affairs: each presents sensible proposals to reform the retirement system, but each has an air of political unreality about it. Recognizing that Democrats as currently constituted can’t solve the matter on their own, they end up placing the onus of responsibility on the two institutions most incapable of meeting the challenge: congressional Republicans, who have lost touch with legislative reality, and the American family, already ground down by decades of austerity and wage stagnation. The call for Republican action comes from Fixing Social Security, an excellent study of the recent history of Social Security and the reasons for Congressional inaction. Arnold has been thinking and writing about Social Security for decades, and he is a steady guide for anyone seeking to understand the system. He is rightly skeptical of privatization as a workable plan and indeed of the private retirement system as a whole. He clearly believes, too, in the legitimacy of Social Security, and in the idea that robust public support is the only way to create something approaching justice for older Americans. Yet his political analysis remains bound by an outdated pragmatism. He convincingly argues that fixing Social Security, by which he means making it solvent, is not difficult: a series of tweaks to tax rates, retirement ages, and levels of taxable income could do it. The emotional motor of the book is Arnold’s frustration that the U.S. political system can’t deliver these reforms that are so transparently urgent and so transparently popular. (Many of the book’s pages are spent analyzing poll data to this effect.) He does call for a campaign of letter-writing and activism from the AARP. But Arnold is laser-focused on congressional politics, so he gives most of the impetus for solving the problem to Republicans. Because they avoid putting an actual policy on the table, Arnold argues, they have not been forced, as a party, to make the hard choices about taxes and benefits. Once they finally do so, the actual horse-trading with the more reasonable Democrats can begin—and, most likely, end somewhere between the modest expansion of Social Security 2100 and the modest cuts desired by many conservatives. For all of Arnold’s policy expertise, his political analysis remains of a piece with Cohen’s: he sees Social Security as a popular, well-designed policy and is concerned that the American political system is not able to deliver the modest reforms that might keep it solvent. The Retirement Challenge, which is the end result of a star-studded set of conferences on retirement financing, shares much with Arnold’s book. Like Arnold, Baily and Harris believe in incrementalism: “if families, companies, and policymakers all took incremental steps to improve the retirement system,” they insist, “every American could achieve a more secure retirement.” This approach, they conclude, provides “the only realistic path.”

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link---Medicaid & Social Security I/L

UBI requires money from Medicaid and Social Security

Dylan Matthews 17, Senior Correspondent and Lead Writer, “What happens if you replace every social program with a universal basic income,” Vox, 5/30/17, https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/5/30/15712160/basic-income-oecd-aei-replace-welfare-state

An American basic income, funded by cutting everything, would screw the elderly and help almost everyone else

The OECD report is illuminating about the trade-offs posed by replacing existing programs with a UBI — but it concerns countries with larger existing benefit systems than the US has. America has arguably the least generous unemployment insurance and cash welfare programs in the developed world, and offers minimal early retirement support. So funding a large-scale, truly universal basic income out of existing spending would necessarily require using funding not just from working-age cash programs like welfare or unemployment insurance, but in-kind subsidies such as Medicaid and programs for retirees like Social Security and Medicare.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link---Vagueness

Vagueness magnifies the link---Any ambiguity about the funding mechanism means that the Right will pay for it by eliminating the welfare state

Matthews 17 (Dylan is a Senior Correspondent and Lead Writer for Vox in the past he has written for the Washington Post, the New Republic, The American Prospect, and Slate, “What happens if you replace every social program with a universal basic income,” Vox, 5/30/17, )hx

Basic income — the idea of just giving everyone in a given country a regular, guaranteed cash payment, no strings attached — is still pretty far from being adopted in the US. But it’s been gaining steam as an idea for a while now, most recently garnering praise from Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg in his widely viewed Harvard commencement speech last week. But no one quite agrees on what the term “basic income” means. And in particular, no one agrees on how such a plan would be funded. Conservative and libertarian proponents tend to want to pay for it by eliminating the entire welfare state, including health programs like Medicare and Medicaid and social insurance programs such as Social Security. More cautious center-left or moderate libertarian proponents — who are loath to cut those aspects of the safety net, endanger people’s retirements, and let uninsured sick people die in the streets — tend to only propose funding through eliminating means-tested programs like food stamps and the earned income tax credit, as well as tax benefits such as the health care exclusion and mortgage interest deduction. The most ambitious lefty proponents want to finance the program entirely through new tax revenue. , As two big new reports on the impact of basic income show, “how would we fund it” is a massively important question. The first, by the OECD (an international organization of developed countries), models a basic income that would "replace most cash benefits for working age households." That includes unemployment benefits, cash welfare, early retirement pensions, child and family allowances, and personal exemptions and standard deductions in income and payroll taxes. They assume no additional tax increases and no changes to programs for retired people, and that "the provision of public services, such as health, education, care, or other in-kind supports … continue[s] unchanged." The report then calculates how the introduction of a budget-neutral basic income, available to every person below retirement age, would affect rich, middle-class, and poor people in four illustrative countries: Finland, Italy, France, and the UK. Effects of revenue-neutral basic incomes in the UK, Italy, Finland, and France OECD The charts in question are slightly confusing, but the important line is the one with blue circles, showing the percentage change in income for each slice of the income distribution. What you see, consistently, is that the poorest people in each country would gain the most as a result of the change. In the UK, existing spending on the cash programs that would be replaced by a UBI is quite low, resulting in small basic income payments; that means poor but not extremely poor people would lose out a bit. But in Finland, Italy, and France, the greater benefits for the poor would be subsidized by benefits and tax breaks lost by higher-income people. AD The biggest losers in each country tend to be the near-elderly; early retirement benefits offered to those below 65 tend to be a great deal more generous than a basic income, so the policy would effectively redistribute that money to people across the age spectrum. And despite high average increases in income for poor people, a UBI financed through existing benefits would do little to cut poverty, the report finds. So would one set at countries’ pre-established welfare benefit level, and funded where necessary by increased taxes (or decreased taxes in Italy, where welfare benefits are below the budget-neutral UBI level). The average effect on income obscures some specific losers from the policy who would fall back below the poverty line in greater numbers than beneficiaries from the policy would climb above it. Poverty changes under a basic income in Finland, France, Italy, and the United Kingdom. OECD In the UK, raising taxes to pay for a more generous basic income makes it reduce poverty mildly. In every other country, though, a truly universal basic income makes poverty worse, not better. "Many of those who are brought out of poverty by unemployment insurance and early retirement benefits would fall into poverty again if they received a BI," the report concludes, since a basic income is less well targeted. An American basic income, funded by cutting everything, would screw the elderly and help almost everyone else The OECD report is illuminating about the trade-offs posed by replacing existing programs with a UBI — but it concerns countries with larger existing benefit systems than the US has. America has arguably the least generous unemployment insurance and cash welfare programs in the developed world, and offers minimal early retirement support. So funding a large-scale, truly universal basic income out of existing spending would necessarily require using funding not just from working-age cash programs like welfare or unemployment insurance, but in-kind subsidies such as Medicaid and programs for retirees like Social Security and Medicare. Four researchers at the American Enterprise Institute — Matthew Jensen, William Ensor, Anderson Frailey, and Amy Xu — used three open source models of American tax and benefit policy to calculate the effects of a UBI funded by repealing "most welfare and transfer programs, including Social Security and Medicare," and "most base-narrowing features of the individual income tax system." They throw everything into the pot: Medicare, Social Security, veterans benefits, the standard deduction, every itemized deduction (including mortgage interest). Basically the only major program not repealed is the employer-paid health care exclusion, and that’s just because there wasn’t data available to model the change. Getting rid of all those programs would finance a UBI of $13,788 for adults and $6,894 for children. So a family of four would get a whopping $41,364. Then again, if they received health insurance through Medicaid or Obamacare subsidies, they’d lose that. Effect of a spending-neutral UBI on people under 65. AEI The researchers find that this policy would, on average, help people under 65 in all but the highest income categories. The middle class would gain the most: A family making $50,000 a year would get a $15,287 boost on average, once you take lost tax and other benefits into account (and when you consider that cash benefits are often more valuable than in-kind ones). People making $200,000 would be held basically harmless, while millionaires would face more than $100,000 a year in increased taxes. Effect of a spending-neutral UBI on people over 65. AEI By contrast, more or less everyone over the age of 65 would lose out — big time. The poorest seniors would lose more than $34,000 worth of benefits in exchange for the UBI. Low- and middle-income people would lose $18,000 to $28,000 each. The rich would lose out for the same reason poor non-seniors would. Despite losing insurance programs like Medicaid, you could imagine this trade being very good for poor non-seniors. For $41,364 a year, a family of four where both parents are in their 20s to 40s could afford a pretty comprehensive health insurance plan, as well as most or all of their rent, food, and transit costs. But what enables a subsidy that large is a wholesale gutting of America’s programs for retired people. Without Medicare, seniors would face very costly insurance premiums given their age and medical risk, and $13,788 is considerably less than the $16,400 average annual Social Security payment to retired workers. Without dependents, most single seniors would get just $13,788, and couples a mere $27,576. That’s not nearly enough to replace the benefits they’d lose.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link Wall---2NC

Political support link---studies prove passage of the plan requires political capital, which forces tradeoffs

Hiilamo 22 — [Heikki Hiilamo works at the Finnish Institute for Health and Welfare, Helsinki, Finland, “A Truly Missed Opportunity: The Political Context and Impact of the Basic Income Experiment in Finland,” Sage Journals, 6-9-2022, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13882627221104501, accessed 7-12-2023] - PG

The Finnish experiment led to unprecedented international interest, with hundreds of reports in foreign media outlets (Kangas et al., 2021). While basic income advocates had tried to revive interest in the policy idea through small pilots – for example, basic income lotteries, which mostly served as demonstration projects – the Finnish experiment was a large-scale project with a solid scientific ground. The expectation was that the results from Finland would bring clarity to the conflicting narratives of the negative tax experiments in the 1970s (e.g., Simpson, 2021). The international interest in the experiment was also a clear sign that despite its shortcomings, basic income addresses problems that many governments struggle to solve: how to find employment for those on the margins of the labour market and how to release even poor individuals’ energy and creativity to promote their own well-being and the well-being of their communities. However, as will be highlighted below, the experiment had a very different narrative in Finnish domestic policymaking (see also De Wispelaere et al., 2019; Halmetoja et al., 2019). The analytical frame in the article is based on the idea of cheap political support developed by De Wispelaere (2016). De Wispelaere argues that much of the support for basic income by individual politicians, political parties, social movements, or interest groups is expressed as sincere preference in favour of basic income without true commitment (money, time, and, above all, political capital) to further the cause. De Wispelaere distinguishes two types of cheap support: a powerful agent speaking of basic income without true commitment, and a less powerful/marginal agent with true commitment but without the capacity to advance the policy. To study government-level political support for basic income in Finland during and after the experiment, it is necessary to identify key moments in governments’ efforts to reform social security. The following analysis will illustrate how the narrative of the political implication of the basic income experiment in Finland will bear resemblance with the story of apostle Peter in the Gospels and Acts, who denied Jesus three times during the events of the crucifixion. In the context of the basic income experiment, four denials are identified: (1) the Social Security 2030 Project; (2) the introduction of a new activation model; (3) the establishment of the Social Security Reform Committee; and (4) the fate of the negative income tax experiment, which was planned after the basic income experiment.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link Wall---2NC

Funding guarantees the link---the only way to pay for it entails disbanding existing welfare programs

Qian 21 (Crystal is the copy editor at The Epic, “A universal basic income is not a utopian solution”, The Epic, 3/12/21,

At first blush, the idea of a Universal Basic Income (UBI) may seem appealing in the abstract. After all, who doesn’t want free money? The premise of a UBI is to guarantee monthly payments to every American adult citizen — say, $1,000 per month. The policy has resurfaced and gained renewed popularity during Democratic politician Andrew Yang’s 2020 presidential campaign, in which he ambitiously espoused a $1,000 UBI as a “Freedom Dividend.” Despite resonating and gaining traction among Americans, the UBI is a flawed and largely untested scheme that would ultimately fail in delivering its utopian promise. In truth, a UBI is a policy that manifests itself beautifully on paper, but crumbles to pieces upon contact with anything echoing reality. Widening income disparity, stagnant median income growth and the rise of automation, globalization and technological innovation have propelled the notion of a UBI across the political landscape. Yang made the UBI the cornerstone of his campaign, believing that it would redistribute wealth and create a financial safety net for all Americans. However, the policy is poorly designed starting from its very objective of redistributing income. By dispensing the same sum of money to all recipients, regardless of wealth, the financially vulnerable receive the same monthly handouts as middle and upper class families. Unlike welfare programs specifically tailored to aid low income individuals, a UBI inefficiently strews resources across the widest possible consumer base. This means that dollars targeted toward the lower rungs of the income distribution continuum are instead funneled up the income pyramid, which is counterproductive in addressing income inequality. Perhaps the most formidable obstacle to the successful implementation of a UBI is its staggering fiscal cost. Failing most financial feasibility tests, a UBI would cost an estimated $4 trillion dollars per year, which is close to the entire federal budget and four times the current welfare expenditure. Even if a UBI replaced every anti-poverty program, the government would still be $3 trillion short in funding. The numbers cannot be changed: a guaranteed income that is enough to eliminate poverty is far too expensive. Proponents of a UBI suggest disbanding existing welfare programs, but terminating social programs such as disability insurance, Temporary Assistance to Needy Families and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program would only cover one-fifth of its extortionate cost. Such programs exist to succor the elderly, disabled and children; eradicating those benefits would only exacerbate the plight of the most vulnerable members of society, as all finances will instead have gone to sending checks to every U.S. citizen, millionaires and billionaires included. The idea of abolishing more expensive programs such as Social Security and Medicare, which a UBI simply cannot replace, is far more problematic, both politically and practically. “ There are some programs you could imagine replacing. If you had a UBI, for example, you might not need unemployment insurance. Or maybe food stamps. But there are other programs that UBI just doesn’t come anywhere close to replacing, and those tend to be the expensive programs. You can’t replace Medicare with a UBI. But all of the money is in Medicare — and Medicaid — so if you’re not going to replace those, then you’re not going very far toward paying for the UBI. — Jesse Rothstein, Economist and Professor of Public Policy & Economics at UC Berkeley “There are some programs you could imagine replacing,” said Jesse Rothstein, economist and Professor of Public Policy & Economics at UC Berkeley, at a Q&A session in UC Berkeley’s Opportunity Lab. “If you had a UBI, for example, you might not need unemployment insurance. Or maybe food stamps. But there are other programs that UBI just doesn’t come anywhere close to replacing, and those tend to be the expensive programs. You can’t replace Medicare with a UBI. But all of the money is in Medicare — and Medicaid — so if you’re not going to replace those, then you’re not going very far toward paying for the UBI.” Although a UBI is a substantial departure from conventional welfare programs, the proposal is not completely devoid of pitfalls. Providing every U.S. citizen with a cash grant would likely undermine labor supply incentives and perpetuate the already dwindling labor force participation rate. In other words, individuals are given the freedom to reduce work or cease working altogether, which encourages laziness and other negative behavioral effects. For those who choose to remain in the workforce, a UBI could serve as an excuse for employers to exploit low-wage workers and depress wages even lower than that in a pre-UBI world. Aside from the most obvious stumbling blocks, there are all sorts of logistical wrinkles associated with a national implementation of a UBI. In any case, financing such a large expenditure would demand a massive increase in taxation to a level that exceeds anything in U.S. history. In addition, addressing regional variation tacks on yet another layer of complexity, with the cost of living in states such as California and South Dakota varying disparately. In theory, a UBI offers a charming alternative that combats the legitimate faults of the current U.S. welfare state, but it is imprudent to scrap all functional welfare programs for a policy idea that has not been implemented on a large enough scale to definitively conclude its success. There have been several small-scale trials of a UBI, one of the closest existing analogies being the Alaska Permanent Fund. However, the Alaskan guaranteed income program distributed stipends of less than $2,000 per year, which is nowhere near a life-sustaining $12,000 UBI. Furthermore, the Alaska Permanent Fund was only attempted on a limited scope of 700,000 Alaskan residents, making it a poor indicator of a 331 million U.S. population. The most recent and thorough case study on the topic was conducted in Finland, which discovered that reducing existing benefits to pay for a basic income could yield a negative impact on poverty levels. In the disappointing landmark trial, a UBI did not incentivize employment participation, boost the labor market or activate the indigent to seek self-reliance. Ultimately, there is not enough research to conclusively understand whether a UBI would be advantageous or pernicious to the country. Though touted as an elegant solution for climbing poverty levels, the human-centric policy is neither a panacea for the modern social welfare state nor a reflection of the economy’s practical reality. The potential area for exploration is encouraging, but a UBI’s daunting financing challenges render any effort to secure one quixotic. “Either you have to come up with a whole lot of new money to pay for it or you have to take money away from people who are the neediest people in our society — or some combination of those two,” Rothstein said. “But you can’t talk about how great the program is without thinking about which of those things you’re going to do.”

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link Wall---2NC

UBI triggers cuts to public services---the Right will seize on the plan to justify defunding current programs

King 20 (Adam D.K. is currently a post-Doctoral visitor in the Department of Politics at York University in Toronto, Ontario, union researcher, “UBI And Job Guarantees Aren’t The Leftist Solutions We Need,” The Maple, 5/28/20,

The COVID-19 crisis has many on the left debating how to improve the welfare state and build working-class power post-pandemic. Two ideas receiving attention are a universal basic income (UBI) and a job guarantee (JG). Both function as animating political demands, due in part to their simplicity and ostensibly radical potential. However, the policy specifics of actually instituting a UBI or a JG leave a lot to be desired. We need clarity as much as captivating demands. What Is A Universal Basic Income? Broadly, a UBI is a cash payment issued to every adult citizen and permanent resident. UBI advocates claim the policy could provide an unconditional income free of means-testing or work requirements. Though not technically a UBI, the current Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) has undoubtedly renewed interest in the idea. The first thing to note is that there’s a multiplicity of UBI proposals, from the left, right and centre. While some on the left think UBI could reduce workers’ reliance on waged labour and compensate for unpaid reproductive work, those on the right imagine universal cash payments as a way to cut public services and make people more market dependent. However, one aspect which ties various UBI proposals together is their funding model. UBI proponents — whether right-wingers advocating a negative income tax or leftists proposing a tax and transfer system — imagine a program funded through income taxes. In practice, this would mean that people lower on the wage distribution would be net beneficiaries of the program, while those higher up would be net contributors. Somewhere in the middle would be people for whom the UBI would be ‘revenue neutral,’ meaning they’d pay back in income tax the same amount that they receive as a UBI. Alternatively, others envision pairing UBI with a social wealth fund. UBI payments under this model would draw from the social wealth fund’s returns rather than from tax revenue. Instead of the rich collecting passive income from capital assets, the public would receive a social dividend from the collectively held assets in the fund. At present, socializing ownership in this way — a worthwhile but considerable political task — is not on the radar of Canadian left politics. And even if it was, it’s reasonable to argue that such a fund should finance robust public services before distributing a social dividend. What Do We Really Want from UBI? It’s instructive to take a step back and ask what problems we’re trying to solve through a UBI. Persistently low productivity growth suggests that automation doesn’t pose the threat to jobs that many UBI advocates claim. Really, UBI is directed at two interconnected issues: unemployment and our dependence on paid work. Unfortunately, it would be a poor solution to both. For all the conjecture about its potential to reduce poverty, UBI is primarily about providing cash to people not performing paid work. The majority of people not working, however, are children and the elderly. Canada has income transfers targeted at these populations, which, though they could be improved, are fairly effective at reducing poverty. Therefore, basic income is primarily directed at unemployed working-age adults. It follows that UBI is essentially a universal unemployment benefit that continues even when a person is employed. UBI advocates imagine that because the payment is universal, it will somehow be more sufficient than current unemployment and social assistance benefits. Nonstandard workers, such as freelancers and the solo self-employed, might also find UBI appealing because of its lack of eligibility rules. Liberal and Conservative governments have eroded Employment Insurance (EI), which now covers fewer than half of workers who experience unemployment. The program’s eligibility rules are prohibitive, and its replacement rate of 55 per cent of previous earnings is embarrassing when compared to more generous European unemployment programs. Sweden and Denmark, for example, both offer wage replacement rates of more than 70 per cent of prior earnings. The sorry state of EI necessitated the creation of the CERB during this pandemic as an emergency measure to assist the growing number of workers shut out of unemployment insurance. Provincial social assistance and disability support programs are even more disgraceful — rates are punishingly low, and recipients are often subjected to degrading surveillance and “work-ready” programming. Basic income advocates are right to oppose low rates and stringent means-testing for unemployment and welfare benefits. However, nothing about improving these income support programs necessitates a UBI. Given UBI’s likely enormous cost and the considerable risk that the right could use basic income as a means to cut public services, we’re better off fighting for generous unemployment compensation and higher social assistance rates. Part of UBI’s appeal seems to stem from how susceptible EI and social assistance have been to political attack. However, the claim that UBI would be more politically durable because of its universal appeal is hugely overstated. The capitalist class will be no more generous just because welfare is now called UBI. What about the broader claim that UBI can provide people greater freedom by reducing their dependence on paid work? According to the late sociologist Erik Olin Wright, a UBI set high enough could help achieve the more utopian objective of transcending capitalism’s forced dependence on waged labour. Although a lofty objective, it’s unlikely to materialize. As left critics of UBI point out, under present political conditions, we’re likely only to see a stingy basic income that ensures a ready supply of low-wage, precarious workers. Without struggles to improve the quality and pay of existing jobs, a UBI program could simply be a sop to low-wage employers.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link Wall---2NC

UBI gets horse-traded---the Left is on the defensive, which makes progressive visions impossible. Link alone turns the case.

Ikebe 16 (Shannon is a PhD candidate in sociology at the University of California, Berkeley, studies social democracy and labor movements in Europe, “The Wrong Kind of UBI,” Jacobin, 1/21/16,

Universal basic income (UBI) has the air of an idea whose time has come. Basic income, defined as a regular income paid to all members of a society on an individual basis without work requirements, has rapidly gained attention and support in recent years, in spite of a political climate that remains largely hostile to the Left.

Finland has received international attention for its basic income experiment. A basic income initiative in Switzerland has collected enough signatures for a nationwide referendum. The Greens and some left parties and figures have long supported a UBI, including Die Linke co-leader Katja Kipping.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › UBI Link Wall---2NC

UBI forces tradeoffs---new social welfare triggers cuts to existing means-tested programs

James Jarvis 19, reporter at Rappahannock Media, writing at The Hill, “Universal basic income advocates warn Yang’s ‘Freedom Dividend’ would harm low-income Americans,” The Hill, 10/15/19, https://thehill.com/policy/finance/465906-universal-basic-income-advocates-warn-yangs-freedom-dividend-would-harm-low-income-americans/

Advocates of universal basic income (UBI) are cautioning against Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang’s proposed “Freedom Dividend,” saying it would hurt low-income Americans.

In interviews with economists and organizations that promote UBI in the United States, experts said Yang’s version could do more harm than good because some Americans would need to choose between accepting $1,000 a month and receiving certain public assistance benefits.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › FJG Link---Social Security I/L

Social Security will be raided to pay for a jobs guarantee

Patel 20 (Prateek, Master of Public Administration, “The Federal Job Guarantee: A Hopeful Plan That’s Too Expensive to Deliver,” The Public Purpose Journal, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020)

Under the resolution, Senator Sanders plan will guarantee a job or training paying $15 an hour with health-care benefits to every American worker that is currently unemployed (Stein, 2017). Based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates, the current unemployment rate is around 4.1. The total labor costs per each individual worker will cost roughly $37,440 per year, with this program. This means there are around 13 million unemployed Americans, making the initial labor costs around $486.72 billion per year (Stein, 2017). But we need to factor in workers that make less than $15/hour and disgruntled or uninterested workers not in the labor force. The labor force participation rate measures the active labor force in the United States. This number is computed by dividing the number of people participating in the labor force by the total number of people eligible to participate in the labor force. The last census shows that 63% of our current population is in the workforce or 163,351 million Americans are in our current labor force. Among the 37% of the people not within the current Labor Force calculations, such as: stay-at-home parents, recent immigrants, illegal immigrants based upon state-laws, or retired people may wish to re-enter the workforce. Many of these individuals have not been calculated within the financial estimates, however these individuals will potentially participate in the program for $15/hour with health benefits. The financial costs also fail to measure the current labor force that makes less than $15/hour that the Federal Job Guarantee Plan promises. According to the Economic Policy Institute, as of May 2018, around 54 million people earn $15/hour or less; around 39% of the current workforce. This workforce will now have an incentive to quit their current job if possible and join a federal program that promises at-least a $15/hour wage. Obviously, the location and movement will play a factor, but these failed cost measurements, does undervalue the overall cost of the Federal Job Guarantee program. Income and Social Inequality Demands Income Redistribution According to Thomas Piketty and Emmanuel Saez, Income Inequality in the United States 1913– 1998’s article published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in 2003, our country’s share of income and wages have represented a U-shaped pattern (Piketty, T., & Saez, E., 2003). This U-shaped pattern represents the current wealth gap, where members of the top 1% are not paying their fair share in the current income distribution. In order to solve some of the income inequity issues, the authors suggest that a more progressive income tax and a corrective estate tax is needed to reduce the overall inequality among the top and the bottom (Piketty, T., & Saez, E., 2003). The progressive income tax will ensure that Americans that hold the highest of wealth will provide higher levels of tax revenue, which will then be shifted onto funding welfare policies that will address social inequality. This tax should be coupled with a corrective estate tax because the top wage shares have been dropping since the 1960s. Due to this, a majority of the rentiers in the country, do not represent the majority of the country, only members at the top of the income distribution (Piketty, T., & Saez, E., 2003). In order to meet the demands proposed by social and income inequalities, we need to possess a safety net that will directly assist the lowest amount income individuals and the unemployed elderly to make ends THE PUBLIC PURPOSE JOURNAL, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020 114 meet (Adamy, 2019). Many of these plans cost trillions of dollars, but if these programs help improve family incomes and improve child achievement, they pay for themselves by creating a more egalitarian society. In the current US system, we have many cash-transfer income support programs, which try to reduce this divide among the wealthy top 1% with everybody else. Current Income-Support Welfare Policies that may be Altered The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a tax-refund for the working poor based on their income levels and number of children. In the policy, your family must make a certain amount of earned income to qualify. According to Nada Eissa and Jeffrey Liebman’s Labor Supply Response to the Earned Income Tax Credit (1996), they discuss the benefits and drawbacks of the EITC on the labor force. The policy provides you a refund if you make a certain amount of money and claim qualified children. With this the EITC affects labor force participation rate and the number of hours worked by people both positively and negatively (Eissa and Liebman, 1996). With the Labor Force Participation Rate, the EITC rewards additional workers, and obtaining a job will potentially add to the tax refund. This policy encouraged low-income and single mothers to join the labor force from 1990 to 1996. However, with the increase in the Labor Force Participation Rate, the number of hours worked by low-income families were negatively impacted (Eissa and Liebman, 1996). According to the EITC, you must make between a certain bracket to continually qualify for the tax refund. If the Head of Household generates more income, which is the anticipated goal of EITC, it disqualifies them from EITC income bracket. This may lead them to pay more in taxes and receive a slimmer EITC refund. This perception has kept many families to remain in similar income brackets, because losing their EITC refund may be much more costly than the benefits of generating higher levels of income. According to Gordon Dahl and Lance Lochner’s The Impact of Family Income on Child Achievement: Evidence from the Earned Income Tax Credit, their research found that there are short-term impacts on childhood test scores and maternal labor market participation. However, there is little evidence that the effect of income lasts very long (Dahl and Lochner, 2012). The EITC negatively impacts second earners in married homes and has produced a negative work effect, where if the spouse starts to work, the level of EITC benefits may decline based on household income (Dahl and Lochner, 2012). This policy has created a higher level of reliance on the government, because people care more about their EITC benefit than actually making enough income to not qualify for EITC (Edward and De Rugy, 2015). With the current EITC policy, taxpayers on average lose $90 billion dollars to pay for the $60 billion in EITC refunds. These additional taxes can negatively impact middle-class Americans and create deadweight losses that may alter their decision-making. EITC recipients are now reliant on the refunds that the government is providing them Edward and De Rugy, 2015). In many cases, this will deter them from working additional hours because this may cost them more. Social Security Under Social Security, everyone after the age of 65, receives a cash payment generally funded by FICA Taxes and administered by the SSA (Social Security Primer, 2018). Under this payroll tax system, the tax rate for both employers and employees are around 7.65%, from which 6.2% goes to Social Security. There is also a 15.3% tax for self-employed Americans and a tax applied on earned income up to $132,9000 (Social Security Primer, 2018). In 20 years, the Social Security Fund is projected to be depleted (Dickstein, 2015). Two-thirds (⅔) of the Elderly get half of their income from Social Security and private pensions only account for 18%. Birthrates have fallen to such a degree since the 1950s that the number of workers supporting each retiree has gone down from 30 in the 1950s to below 5 in 1990 (Social Security Primer, 2018). By 2030, the number of workers supporting each retiree will be below 3 (Social Security Primer, 2018). Higher levels of immigration can combat these dwindling birth rates by bringing more people into the system to help outlast these projections and help provide more tax-revenue to further finance the program (Social Security Primer, 2018). THE PUBLIC PURPOSE JOURNAL, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020 115 Unemployment Insurance Policies According to Daron Acemoglu and Robert Shimer’s Efficient Unemployment Insurance," in the Journal of Political Economy in October 1999, they discuss how the unemployment insurance has helped provide insured workers, high-wage jobs with high unemployment risk (Acemoglu and Shimer, 1999).According to their research, an economy with risk-averse workers have the ability to maximize their overall output and increase risk-sharing. These unemployment insurance plans help with risk aversion and helps economies find levels closer to equilibrium (Acemoglu and Shimer, 1999). Unemployment Insurance provides compensation for all workers that are unemployed that are not employed for a specific period of time until they find a new job (USA Gov, 2019). Each state usually has a state unemployment insurance program that provides certain benefits based upon eligibility for unemployment insurance. Generally, these state unemployment compensation details are available on your local state unemployment office website. These compensation amounts depend on the amount you earned while working and how many weeks you worked (USA Gov, 2019). These unemployment benefits are paid for up to 26 weeks, but this maximum amount will differ from state to state (USA Gov, 2019). As of 2019, there are no federal unemployment benefit programs, and all of these programs are offered in a state by state basis (USA Gov, 2019). However, whenever someone is laid off, the first thing newly unemployed people should do is file for unemployment and generally it might take up to three weeks before you receive a check (USA Gov, 2019). The following circumstances will disqualify you, depending on state law, from you receiving unemployment benefits. These include being fired for misconduct, quitting without good cause, attending school, self-employment, quitting to get married, resigning because of illness (disability laws will vary), or being involved in a labor suit (USA Gov, 2019). However, in order to receive unemployment benefits, the filer must register with a state job service and actively seek work. The job service may require active job applying, submitting resumes, and being willing to work. The state will help you receive suitable employment, but the standards for suitable employment will vary on the state (USA Gov, 2019). Under the Job Guarantee Plan, if everyone has a job, then it can be assumed that these unemployment insurance plans would be gradually dismantled. Such policies can help finance the implementation of the Federal Job Guarantee legislation and utilize similar resources to assist with future job growth (USA Gov, 2019). Labor Dynamics Impact On Private Sector Market from Job Guarantee Plan According to Vincenzo Caponi’s “The Effects of Public Sector Employment on the Economy,” he examines the impact on public sector employment on the economy as a whole. Whenever the public sector creates jobs by hiring citizens to provide goods and services, it has both positive and negative effects on the labor market (Caponi, 2017). His research showed that the unemployment rate decreased in the short-term, creating more stabilizing effect in economy. Along with this, certain demands in inequity were met in places that had higher levels of poverty in comparison to others. Plus, with the higher levels of public sector jobs, many employers were encouraged to employ disadvantaged and marginalized Americans (Caponi, 2017). At the same time, the reduction of short-term unemployment by expanding public sector jobs were not efficient, because wages in the public sector are flexible and not fixed. This expansion of public sector jobs created a crowding-out effect of private sector, where many people left their low-paying private sector jobs to work for the public sector that provided higher levels of stability. To add to this, wages are unresponsive to productivity differences, so if workers are less or more productive in the public sector, they do not see salary increases or decreases (Caponi, 2017). With the crowding-out effect leading to labor shortage and lack of overall productivity in public-sector jobs, Caponi’s research suggests that there is a reduction in the overall productivity of the economy, coupled with the negative effects of the resource reallocation from the private to the public sector. When it comes to the Federal Job Guarantee plan, Caponi’s discussed impacts show how a massive public sector work project can have many drawbacks to the private sector. In Greg Ip’s Wall THE PUBLIC PURPOSE JOURNAL, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020 116 Street Journal article titled The Problem with a Federal Jobs Guarantee (Hint: It's Not the Price Tag), Ip discusses the challenges that the private sector will face with wages, inflation, and technology after the implementation of the Federal Job Guarantee plan. First in order to keep many of the workers that make less than $15/hour, the private sector will see massive salary increases. Employers will be forced to raise the salaries of their workers, because they do not want to lose their labor, similar to a $15 minimum wage effect (Ip, 2018). This will lead the companies to potentially raise the private sector causing rise in customer costs to offset their short-term losses in revenue. This raised cost on customers will negatively impact certain businesses more than others (Ip, 2018). Policies such as this will positively impact labor in big firms like Wal-Mart that can afford offering health benefits or wage increases (Ip, 2018). But these policies will hurt smaller firms to a mega scale, that cannot offer the same benefits as the public sector would with Job Guarantee. Overall this may intensify the oligopoly market that we have in the country, because many small businesses or start-ups, will be unable to meet labor or revenue demands to stay afloat (Edwards, 2016). This would make many argue that the Job Guarantee plan will not be very positive for the private sector as a whole. It may force labor or employment changes against the market need, that may help some, but forced changes have mixed effects from unequal benefits. Whenever we add money to the market or change wage floors, we see various inflationary pressures that will reduce the value of the dollar in the short-term. The rise in salaries will see a shortterm rise in the cost of goods (Edwards, 2016). This will trickle to make the overall cost of goods and services increase to offset the additional increase in wages. In order to combat these issues, the government will need to alter the current tax rates and federal interest-rate to offset the inflated cost of the dollar (Edwards, 2016). Plus, private-Sector low-income jobs may be replaced by technology, as certain jobs would be much more efficient with machinery over people (Edwards, 2016). With wage changes and cost increases, companies will need to shift more towards technology making the product cheaper and more affordable. Therefore, in order to maximize efficiency while minimizing costs, many more lowincome private-sector jobs will be lost. This includes jobs like hamburger flippers, baristas, or waiters, that there is a demand for, but can easily be replaced by technologies. There can also be a potential public-sector spillover with the use of technology, because when citizens are paying for each additional job, their tax dollars value efficiency (Caponi, 2017). Job Guarantee Plan in India The only country that has a similar population to the United States to test out a federal plan like the Federal Job Guarantee proposal was India. B Sasi Kumar and Kalarani Rengasamy from Alagappa University in Tamil Nadu analyzed the successes and drawbacks of the Job Guarantee plan in India, within their article, “Participation of Rural Workers in the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act in India.” The Government of India provides funds to the Indian states to meet the full cost of wages and up to 75% of the material cost of work including wages to skilled and semiskilled workers (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). Within the program, District Officers need to meet with Delhi (Capital of India) to give updates on how funds are being used (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). The government meets full cost of employment wages and in addition funds equal to 50% of wages are given towards all other costs (including material components, staff etc.). This simple pattern of funding would dispense the need for getting from states details of expenditure on material, staff etc. or having to calculate the wage-material ratio (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). The Government of India will then be concerned with maintaining only state-wise accounts and not nearly 600 accounts for the districts (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). The positives of this program are that they say increased earnings for low-income households by 13.3 percent (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). Ninety percent of that increase is due to higher wages and increased work in the private sector, not the job guarantee program itself. Just as job guarantee advocates would predict, the program bid up wages everywhere. On the flipside, there were many negative effects to this program as well (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012). Many unskilled jobs such as digging potholes or moving rocks sparked high demand by lower income people. According to S. Baskar Reddy, head of agriculture at the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) said, “It is deskilling THE PUBLIC PURPOSE JOURNAL, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020 117 our people at a time when we should be training them for new skills (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012).” The policy also caused there to be an extreme demand by workers outpacing skilled jobs demand. Generally similar pay for lower-income jobs. “The jobs program was meant to be a measure of last resort for the poorest. Instead, it has become the preferred work because it is easy money and a little bit of digging here and there (Kumar and Rengasamy, 2012).” In my personal opinion, it is extremely difficult to compare an Indian Job Guarantee program with an American Federal Job Guarantee. India is a completely different market, with a current minimum wage of 160 rupees or $2.25 per day. They have actual overlying issues with properly paying labor, which has led various companies to outsource their jobs there. India is a third-world economy with 1.2 billion people without a safety net, so initiating a program like this deters from investment in skilled jobs. They have little to no safety nets and have 2.59 trillion dollars in their GDP to finance the growth of 1.2 billion Indians. The United States may have an income gap, but we produce much 17 trillion dollars more in GDP regardless of our income inequalities in the United States. Plus, poverty in India and poverty in America cannot be compared, because our safety nets may not solve all of the underlying issues of racism, homelessness, poverty, educational inequality, healthcare, or the income gap. But in many cases, in comparing to India, the United States does make substantial effort irrespective of whatever party is in power. We have policies that allow everyone in the country to get a K-12 Education, have policies that deter racism, and push to reduce poverty whether through welfare reforms like EITC or even with Affordable Housing policies. So, for India, the Federal Job Guarantee program has at least created something to allow people to escape poverty without pure capitalistic virtues. However, the cost of them having one-billion-dollar welfare program does not necessarily equate to the United States expenditures. Job Guarantee Proposal Analysis with Economic and Political Forecasts In terms of the Federal Job Guarantee program, the idea itself has many merits from a capitalistic standpoint. Economists have stated that by improving the overall levels of income that people have, they will have more opportunity to take risks. Risk-taking will allow them to potentially increase their revenue flow and potentially improve the life-quality of their family members. Such policies have many benefits, but the asymmetric information and the lack of details, makes this policy too big of a risk. Certain information still needs to be learned such as: what kind of jobs will the people be doing, how much does the job-creation itself cost, how many hours will they be working, how long will the program lasts, and what about the non-unemployed people that may wish to join the program. Currently our federal GDP is at $19.37 Trillion, and we spend $27 trillion on entitlements, and the Federal Job Guarantee plan will only add to it. According to the Budget and Economic Outlook: 2019 to 2029. “In 2018, the current 3.9 percent of G.D.P., compared with an average deficit of 2.1 percent of G.D.P. over the previous 70 years (Budget and Economic Outlook, 2019).” This budget deficit will increase to 4.6 percent of G.D.P. in 2023, and no more than that based on continued economic growth and no major military conflict (Budget and Economic Outlook, 2019).” The Federal Job Guarantee proposal is a $486.72 billion-dollar investment only factoring in the 4.1% unemployment rate. But there will still be some unemployed people who will opt out of the program, making the policy look financially optimal. However, you will also have potential private-sector low-income or part-time employees that will join the program, along with some people not factored in the labor force. In order for Job Guarantee to work, we may need to curtail our investments in current running entitlement programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit, reduce Social Security payments, and Eliminate Unemployment Insurance. Conclusion The policy will have a direct impact on the private market, will increase our national debt, and contribute to the rising costs of our entitlement spending, which will further rise over time. Much of these things, make taking on another extremely expensive program not really feasible. Personally, the idea of a Federal Job Guarantee is great from both a capitalistic and an inequity standpoint. Because this policy, will not only increase the revenues for many low-income Americans but will also allow them to THE PUBLIC PURPOSE JOURNAL, Vol. XVII, Fall 2020 118 contribute more to the GDP. However, the potential inflationary pressures coupled with the lack of information on the number of Americans that will take part in the program, makes this policy too risky. We have never created a full-on job creation policy within the public sector and are unaware of the exact impact that it will have on the private sector in particular. Plus, with our historical problems in solving social issues by increasing our financial pressures, makes me argue that we need to first solve some of our pending spending priorities, before moving to another potential trillion-dollar policy. We need more information on how the Job Guarantee Program will work and until these semantics are determined, the policy remains a question mark. The more money that people have, the higher our overall GDP rises, and this policy can eventually create a permanent 100% full employment. If these details were provided, the procedures were spelled out, and if we had more examples of this policy in implementation, than the Federal Job Guarantee proposal could be an excellent idea. However, with the amount of information that we have to work with, and the unanticipated explicit costs of implementing this program makes the policy too risky. So, it would be wise to recommend the plan at the moment, because of the lack of information and its anticipated effects on the market

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link Wall---2NC

Political economy link---Federal jobs guarantee will be used to undermine the right to welfare

Thomas Palley 18, independent economist living in Washington DC. He founded Economics for Democratic & Open Societies, “Job Guarantee Programs: Careful What You Wish For,” Social Europe, 9/14/18, https://www.socialeurope.eu/job-guarantee-programs-careful-what-you-wish-for

A second political economy concern is workfare. Not only may the JGP be used to undermine the character of public sector employment, it can also be used to undermine the right to welfare. Thus, the right to welfare can be made conditional on accepting a guaranteed employment job. In this fashion, a JGP can become a double-edged sword, cutting upward against the public sector and downward against the welfare system. That is not an outlandish speculation in the context of US political economy, where the large prison population is already being exploited to work for near-free for the benefit of politically connected labor-intensive private industry.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link Wall---2NC

Funding link---the money will come from cuts to social assistance, even assuming raised revenue

Bhandari 19 — [Ryan Bhandari was the Former Senior Policy Advisor, Economic Program, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It? – Third Way,” Third Way, 3-25-2019, https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-the-federal-jobs-guarantee-and-what-are-people-saying-about-it, accessed 7-11-2023] - PG

The cost is enormous. A federal jobs guarantee will cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars per year and much more during a recession when the employment rolls for the government would naturally increase. Here are the cost estimates from both plans based on people participating in the jobs guarantee:

With annual federal outlays at roughly $4.5 trillion, we’re talking about anywhere from a 10-20% increase in spending to pay for the jobs guarantee. As for how to pay for it, advocates are split on whether it should be paid for at all. Paul et al. provide a few possible tax increases but don’t devote much attention to the matter. Stephanie Kelton says, “What the models show is you can do this without creating an inflation problem and therefore why would you pay for it with tax increases of one kind or another?” Even though the cost of the program could be partially offset through decreasing social assistance costs, it’s still very uncertain how and when these savings would materialize. What we’re left with is a new program taking up funding that could be used instead for things like increased childcare, training support, expanded health care coverage, and more. Inflation would rise. A sudden increase in the cost of labor for businesses will lead to inflation throughout the economy because of higher business costs that will need to be passed on to consumers. In addition, when only those at the bottom of the income distribution get a defacto raise to $15, there are upstream consequences. Workers who were making $15 an hour may demand $20 an hour now. Workers making $20 an hour might want $25 an hour and so on. This may seem like a benefit, but “this is a story of serious wage-price spiral, unless we introduce other measures,” warns progressive economist Dean Baker. We have been very fortunate that inflation has been well under control for the last few decades. A federal jobs guarantee could change that pretty quickly.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Links › Jobs Guarantee Link Wall---2NC

Political concessions link---passage of a jobs guarantee requires giving up liberal priorities

Lowrey 18 — [Annie Lowrey is the author of Give People Money, which was shortlisted for the Financial Times and McKinsey Business Book of the Year Award. Prior to joining The Atlantic, she was a staff writer for The New York Times and New York magazine, as well as the Moneybox columnist for Slate. At The Atlantic, she writes about the economy and politics, “A Promise So Big, Democrats Aren’t Sure How to Keep It,” Atlantic, 5-11-2018, https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/05/the-democratic-party-wants-to-end-unemployment/560153/, accessed 7-12-2023] - PG

Then there is the question of how the government would go about creating all those jobs. State and local governments tend to keep a long backlog of shovel-ready infrastructure projects. But few have lists of hundreds of thousands of menial temp jobs, permanent care positions, teaching positions, and ecological restoration projects on hand—along with an infrastructure for job training and job matching, as a jobs guarantee would require. Granted, there is some existing infrastructure. “Local unemployment offices have basically been rebranded today as a local job centers or one-stop career centers,” Kelton said. “There are like more than 2,500 of these things spread all over the country.” Still, a jobs guarantee would mean the government hiring tens of thousands of bureaucrats to locate make-work and manage training and employment programs across the country—in every part of the country. There is also the cost. “It would take a level of funding for which we would have to very much alter our fiscal outlook,” Jared Bernstein, who was former Vice President Joe Biden’s chief economist and is now at CBPP, told me. Small pilot programs aimed at stopping recidivism might pay for themselves. But a true jobs guarantee would cost something like $400 to $700 billion a year now, and vastly more during a downturn. For some Democratic policy wonks, the trade-offs in both economic and political capital seem the most salient. What do you give up by implementing a jobs guarantee? What comes first: a public option for health insurance, or a major jobs plan, or an expansion of the Earned Income Tax Credit, or a universal child allowance, or a major educational debt-relief plan, or postal banking—all of which are ideas being pushed by Democratic presidential aspirants right now? “How much in life do you spend money on the last mile?” Gene Sperling, who was the director of the National Economic Council under Obama, asked me. “There are big, long-term unemployment problems, right? That’s complicated. Those are people who need a lot of help. They need a lot of support. Is that really the issue, or is the issue that the working poor are not making enough money to support their families? If you’re going to spend a trillion dollars on something huge …There’s an element here of people not thinking about what they’re actually trying to do.”

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › UQ---No Cuts Now---Welfare

No welfare cuts now---strong support

John Halpin et al, Karl Agne, Nisha Jane, 12-11-2020, senior fellow and co-director of the Politics and Elections program at the Center for American Progress, founding partner of GBAO Strategies, vice president at GBAO. "Americans Want the Federal Government To Help People in Need," Center for American Progress, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/americans-want-federal-government-help-people-need/

The current research marks the continuation of CAP and GBAO’s ongoing examination of public attitudes on poverty dating back to 2013. The new survey confirms many of the major findings of this earlier work, highlighting broad-based support across partisan lines for government actions that ensure that all people have access to good jobs and are able to meet basic needs such as housing, education, and health care. Although worries about dependency, fraud, and abuse of such assistance are prevalent among a small sector of voters, these concerns do not outweigh the overall desire for ongoing government assistance for those in need.

Major findings on U.S. economic policies and conditions facing American voters

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › AT: Something Else Cut----Social Security

Social security is first on the chopping block---it’s wielded as a political weapon

Laura Haltzel 23. Senior fellow with The Century Foundation, 3-16-2023. "Social Security Is Essential. So Why Do Some Want to Cut It?," https://tcf.org/content/report/social-security-is-essential-so-why-do-some-want-to-cut-it/.

Members of Congress are once again discussing possible cuts to Social Security as they contemplate increases to the debt limit. Instead of viewing Social Security through the lens of what the American public needs, they are viewing it as a political weapon to be wielded, with arguments that it must be cut now, despite the fact that Social Security does not contribute to the publicly held debt, and despite the existence of a $2.9 trillion reserve of assets as of the end of 2021.1

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › UQ---No Cuts Now—Social Security

No Social Security cuts or privatization now

Sabrina Jacobs, 02-13-2023, staff writer at Data for Progress, B.A. from Emerson College in Visual and Media Arts, MSc from the London School of Economics and Political Science in Political Sociology, former research fellow on Cory Booker’s presidential campaign, and former law clerk in Associate Attorney General Gupta’s office, "Voters Across Party Lines Support the Social Security Expansion Act," Data For Progress, https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2023/2/13/voters-across-party-lines-support-the-social-security-expansion-act

In response, members of Congress have proposed the Social Security Expansion Act. The bill would extend the solvency of Social Security for 75 years and increase benefits for all recipients by $2,400 per year. This would greatly help retirees and disabled individuals keep up with the rapidly increasing cost of living, significantly benefit millions of Americans who are struggling to make ends meet, and help grow our economy.

Data for Progress finds an overwhelming majority of likely voters (78 percent) are in favor of the Social Security Expansion Act. This includes 85 percent of Democrats, 75 percent of Independents, and 72 percent of Republicans.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › UQ---No Cuts Now—Social Security

Social Security won’t face cuts now---but McCarthy is itching for them

Keith Speights, 6-17-2023. Began writing for the Fool in 2012 and focuses primarily on healthcare investing topics. His background includes serving in management and consulting for the healthcare technology, health insurance, medical device, and pharmacy benefits management industries. "Social Security Benefit Cuts on the Table Again: Here's What Could Be on the Way," https://www.fool.com/retirement/2023/06/17/social-security-benefit-cuts-on-the-table-again-he/.

Social Security was spared in the recent budget ceiling deal, but the story isn't over yet.

After all the political wrangling, the U.S. debt ceiling was raised again with overwhelming support. The deal struck between the Biden administration and Republicans avoided an economic crisis. It also pushed to the side dealing with the thorniest budgetary issues -- including Social Security.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › UQ---No Cuts Now---Pell Grants

Biden’s protecting Pell Grants now.

Michael T. Nietzel 23. Former university president who writes about higher education, 3-10-2023. "Biden Prioritizes Pell Grants, Free Community College And Research In 2024 Budget Plans," https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2023/03/10/pell-grants-free-community-college-research-funding-among-higher-ed-priorities-in-biden-fy-2024-budget/?sh=2c4891103ce8.

President Joe Biden proposed a budget Thursday that would increase Pell Grants, renews his call for free community college, and significantly boosts federal research spending for fiscal year 2024.

Under Biden’s budget blueprint, which, owing to a divided Congress, has no chance of being passed in its current form, the U.S. Department of Education would receive $90 billion in discretionary spending, representing nearly a 14% increase over the current year. Biden has proposed an overall budget of $6.8 trillion for the federal fiscal year beginning October 1.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › AT: Something Else Cut---Medicaid

Any chance they get, Republicans will choose to cut Medicaid

Scott 5/12 — [Dylan has covered health care policy since 2011, when he was a staff writer at Governing magazine. He wrote for Talking Points Memo, National Journal, and STAT before coming to Vox. He is a graduate of Ohio University, “The Republican plan to sneakily cut Medicaid, explained,” Vox, 5-12-2023, https://www.vox.com/policy/2023/5/12/23712447/medicaid-work-requirements-us-debt-ceiling, accessed 7-15-2023] - PG

The Republican proposal to require people to work in order to receive Medicaid benefits poses an existential question about the very nature of government assistance: Do you need to do something to earn it? For years, the GOP’s answer has been yes, some people should. These days, they have very specific people in mind: The 19 million Americans, most of them childless and nondisabled adults, who were not eligible for Medicaid until the Affordable Care Act expanded eligibility a decade ago. House Republicans are so serious about imposing these new rules that they are trying to make them a condition of lifting the federal debt limit and averting an economic crisis. They don’t seem likely to succeed, given the Biden administration’s clear objections, but the mere demand reveals that the party remains as serious as ever about shrinking the social safety net. They seek to do so by dividing the deserving — in the case of Medicaid, pregnant women, children, those who are elderly or disabled — from the undeserving, who have to work to earn benefits. “Assistance programs are supposed to be temporary, not permanent,” House Speaker Kevin McCarthy said in a speech on Wall Street outlining his party’s demands in the debt-limit talks. “A hand up, not a handout. A bridge to independence, not a barrier.” Work requirements for various social programs — housing assistance, food stamps, cash welfare, and Medicaid — have been a policy goal for Republicans since the 1980s. And they have succeeded, sometimes with the help of Democrats, in imposing them. SNAP, the food-stamp program, already has work requirements, which Republicans want to expand, in spite of evidence that they do not significantly increase employment. But Medicaid, by far the largest of these social programs, has long been the white whale for conservatives in their work requirement crusade. Twice as many people receive Medicaid benefits (about 90 million) as receive food stamps (about 42 million). Briefly, under President Donald Trump, Congress tried to implement them. But the results were disastrous and a federal judge blocked the requirements as counter to the purpose of the Medicaid program. States are required to cover some people through Medicaid, such as pregnant women and the disabled, but they also have discretion about who is eligible for the program. Some states have used that discretion to expand coverage (in California, for example, Medicaid covers many undocumented immigrants) while others have kept their eligibility requirements much more stringent. The Affordable Care Act was a critical turning point for the program. Under the law, 40 states have expanded Medicaid eligibility to the childless, nondisabled adults living in or near poverty who historically have been excluded from the program. About 20 million Americans have been covered by Medicaid expansion in the past decade. But that has presented an ideological problem for conservatives. The bigger Medicaid grows, the more popular and therefore difficult to cut it becomes. An effort to repeal the Affordable Care Act failed. And so, with the Trump administration in power, Medicaid work requirements became their backdoor way to try to erode the gains of Medicaid expansion. In early 2018, the Trump health department told states they would, for the first time, approve state proposals requiring work for some Medicaid beneficiaries. Several states lined up and two — Arkansas and Kentucky — had their plans approved.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › Uniqueness › UQ---No Cuts Now---Medicaid

Biden’s committed to maintaining Medicaid

White House, 3-9-2023, "FACT SHEET: President Biden’s Budget Advances Equity," https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023/03/09/fact-sheet-president-bidens-budget-advances-equity/

Advances Maternal Health and Health Equity. The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate among developed nations, and rates are disproportionately high for Black and American Indian and Alaska Native women. The Budget includes $471 million to support implementation of the White House Blueprint for Addressing the Maternal Health Crisis to reduce maternal mortality and morbidity rates and address persistent disparities; expand maternal health initiatives in rural communities; implement implicit bias training for healthcare providers; create pregnancy medical home demonstration projects; and address the highest rates of perinatal health disparities, including by supporting the perinatal health workforce. In addition, the Budget requires all States to provide continuous Medicaid coverage for 12 months postpartum, eliminating gaps in health insurance at a critical time.

Expands Access to Quality, Affordable Health Care. The Budget invests $150 billion over 10 years to improve and expand Medicaid home and community-based services, such as personal care services, which would allow older Americans and individuals with disabilities to remain in their homes and stay active in their communities as well as improve the quality of jobs for home care workers. And because community health centers—which provide comprehensive services regardless of ability to pay—serve one in three people living in poverty and one in five rural residents, the Budget puts the Health Center Program on a path to double its size and expand its reach. To bolster the health care workforce, the Budget provides a total of $966 million in 2024 to expand the National Health Service Corps, which provides loan repayment and scholarships to healthcare professionals in exchange for practicing in underserved areas, and a total of $350 million to expand programs that train and support the nursing workforce.

2023 DDI Disadvantage
Horsetrading DA---DDI 23 › 1NCs---Need Impacts › Horsetrading 1NC---Social Security

Privatization dismantles Social Security---stock market volatility decimates benefits

Max Richtman 18. President and Ceo Of The National Committee To Preserve Social Security And Medicare, 3-26-18. “Privatization is really a plan to dismantle Social Security,” https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/26/privatization-is-really-a-plan-to-dismantle-social-security.html.

As I began writing this column, the stock market was in the midst of another sell-off, this time in response to the announced departure of Trump economic adviser Gary Cohn and fears of an impending trade war. The Dow has dropped more than 300 points (or 1.3 percent) — and it’s only lunchtime.

In February wage inflation and concerns that the Federal Reserve would raise interest rates spooked the market, kicking off a month of volatility not seen since the crash of 2008, when Americans’ retirement funds lost trillions of dollars in value.