Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › China DA › 1NC – Shell

Continuous US-China tensions strain economic capabilities and international relations

Rogers et al. 21 ( John Rogers is a Senior Adviser in the International Finance Division of the Federal Reserve Board. He received his BA from the University of Delaware and PhD in economics from the University of Virginia. John was on the economics department faculty at Penn State University, where he rose to Associate Professor in 1996. He began working on the Fed’s multi-country  model in the Trade & Financial Studies section, and became section chief in 2003, Bo Sun, Bo Sun is a Principal Economist at the Federal Reserve Board. She served on the faculty at Guanghua School of Management of Peking University from 2011 to 2013, and taught courses in corporate finance at undergraduate, Masters, MBA, and Ph.D. levels, Chris Webster, Chris Webster is a senior research assistant at the Federal Reserve Board. He has a B.S. in Physics from the Rochester Institute of Technology, “US-China Tensions” 04-28-21, ml) [BB]

Since 1949, US–China relations have evolved from tense standoffs to a complex mix of intensifying diplomacy, growing international rivalry, and increasingly intertwined economies. Continued escalation of trade disputes and blame over the spread of the coronavirus are emblematic of a significant hardening of positions. US–China tensions extend well beyond trade and stem from a growing number of issues including information security, currency practices, technology innovation, and military buildup. Recent sources of tensions from the US perspective include COVID-19, unfair trade practices, currency manipulation, industrial espionage, Tik Tok, free speech, Hong Kong, and Uyghurs. Tensions from China's perspective include tariffs, protectionism, military adventurism, meddling, guns, and race relations. Investors, corporate executives, and policymakers often cite US–China tension as an important determinant of economic decisions. However, the importance of US–China tension in shaping either macroeconomic outcomes or firm-level decisions over a long time span has not been studied empirically. The main limitation has been the lack of an indicator that can quantify the intensity of US–China bilateral tension and is available consistently over time. In Rogers, Sun, and Webster (2021), we measure the intensity of public concerns over US–China tension (UCT) and quantify its economic consequences. US–China tension has been frequently mentioned in commentaries as a major factor in economic decisions, as it induces risks associated with increased barriers that disrupt bilateral transactions. To our knowledge, our index is the first to quantify the intensity of bilateral tension between the US and China over time.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Cap K › 2NC – Link

Degrowth is just a tool of elites to oppress the working class and prevent them from organizing to fight against class struggle.

Liberation School ’21 [The Party for Socialism and Liberation believes that the only solution to the deepening crisis of capitalism is the socialist transformation of society, “Degrowth: An environmental ideology with good intentions, bad politics,” published July 20,2021.]

In the U.S., degrowth remains an ideology that is relatively socially isolated but gaining influence among environmentalists and some on the left. It’s an ideology of guilt rather than revolutionary action. The ideas from degrowth will not appeal to masses of exploited and oppressed people who actually need more, not less. Imagine, for example, canvassing and talking to people in working-class neighborhoods, trying to get them on board with a degrowth political platform. How do degrowth proponents think workers in oppressed neighborhoods respond if they were told they needed to consume less to fight climate change? Many of us already wait as long as possible in the winter to turn on our heat! As organizers, we would not get the time of day, and we wouldn’t even believe ourselves. Can you imagine organizing homeless and unemployed workers around a program of less consumption? Degrowth is an ideology fit for the privileged, and if they want to consume less, they should.

From the perspective of the practical class struggle, degrowth is particularly problematic. Degrowth has a rhetorical strategy problem. In an unequal country such as the U.S., is the discourse of less and “self-limitation” realistic and inspiring? Is this tactic energizing, does it speak to the needs of the exploited and oppressed, can it mobilize people into action?

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Cap K › 2NC – FW

Injecting anti-capitalist discourse into academic spaces promotes critical thinking and political literacy key for liberation

Ivanchikova and Maclean'22 [Alla; Robert R.; 07/01/22 Alla Ivanchikova is Associate Professor of English and Comparative Literature at Hobart and William Smith Colleges. Robert R. Maclean is an independent scholar.; The Future of Lenin: Power, Politics, and Revolution in the Twenty-First Century, p. 195-199]

The most prominent Black Leninist formation in the United States, at the time and certainly in historiographical attention, was the Black Panther Party. Angela Davis recounts, in her autobiography, that a short while after returning to the United States she found herself immersed in the Black Panther Party’s political education programs, reading Lenin in a radically different context. “When we read Lenin’s State and Revolution,” she writes, there were sisters and brothers in the class whose public school education had not even allowed them to learn how to read. Some of them told me how they stayed with the book for many painful hours, often using the dictionary to discover the meaning of scores of words on one page, until finally they could grasp the significance of what Lenin was saying. When they explained, for the benefit of the other members of the class, what they had gotten out of their reading, it was clear that they knew it all—they had understood Lenin on a far more elemental level than any professor of social science. (192) To draw the obvious contrast: the style of communist pedagogy described here differs radically from what we imagined above, Angela Davis schooling the “white Left.” If we say, echoing Lenin, that the latter is “backward,” what we cannot mean is that they needed to have gone and studied with Adorno (or Marcuse). One of Lenin’s key contributions was to emphasize the “backwardness” of the context from which he was writ‐ ing, namely, late imperial Russia. Relentlessly, he insisted that conditions in Russia could not be measured against those in the central imperialist/ capitalist countries, including arguing in the 1890s that the introduction of capitalism in the countryside would be a progressive development. That Russia’s development was (not just uneven but) “backward” in the context of world capitalism was a crucial insight in organizing Bolshevik revolu‐ tionary cadres. It also became a key putative component of the influence of “Leninism” on anticolonial revolutionaries, for the Russian Revolution demonstrated, against the assumptions of Marx and Engels and the European socialist movement generally, that imperialism could be countered most effectively in its “backwaters,” where it was organizationally and institution‐ ally weakest. For white U.S. leftists at mid‐century, it was not their society but their movement, their (aspiring) “vanguard,” that was backward, in multiple senses: it largely failed to move the masses of workers toward class consciousness and solidarity; it was unable effectively to purge its ranks of chauvinists; it could not properly counter the state’s efforts at infiltration and provocation; while it made ceaseless appeals to Black, colonized, and racialized workers, these did not for the most part produce militant mass organizations or cadre growth, nor offset the appeal of nationalist groups: the prominence of the latter is arguably a key indicator or symptom of the failure of the (white) U.S. Left to overcome its “chauvinism,” or to use a later idiom, its “investment” in “whiteness.”23 Nevertheless, what we can perceive in Davis’s example is not only the gulf separating the quasi‐ and semi‐academic (white) Left from Black revo‐ lutionary struggle, but also the liberatory desire that animates the latter. In the example of reading Lenin with the Black Panther Party—reading Lenin simultaneously as part and parcel of the development of both literacy and political technique—is revealed the universality of revolutionary theory and struggle. Outside of academic—and also outside the para‐academic, civil society, etc.—contexts, the fact that theory can take on material actuality starts to become palpable. The vaunted high points of Black radical his‐ tory—Black Panther Party community political education projects—hide in plain sight the explosive power of theory in the hands of the masses of (Black) people.24

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Cap K › 1NC – Shell

The alternative is Black Maoism – a militant praxis that demands revolution

Black Like Mao '20[Black Like Mao;3-2-2020; Black Like Mao is a Black Marxist-Leninist-Maoist journalism creating revolutionary analysis. STL based.; "Possible Specific Characteristics of Protracted War in the United States," ]

As a Maoist, the thesis that the tenets and strategy of Protracted People’s War is universally applicable to all countries, including industrial capitalist countries such as the United States, is a key one. However, I believe that we must realize that PPW is not just a checklist of things that must happen. Let’s be real, there has never been initiation of Protracted People’s War in an industrial capitalist country in the Maoist era. The groups that struggled in the 1960s and ’70s had various applications of the Guevarist-Debrayist focoísmo theory, which we hold is tantamount to armed revisionism because, generally, it does not rely on the masses. What we now know is that the recycling of the Cuban experience will be a mistake and deadly blunder, because focoísm was the hegemonic military line in the imperialist metropole, along with Latin America, for two decades. Nowhere did it lead to victory. It got Che himself killed in Bolivia when he failed to link up with the Bolivian masses and the revisionist Communist Party in that country failed to offer support, leading to the isolation of his guerilla movement. While focoísmo should be studied, we should look at where it got the BLA and others that sought to apply it to the conditions of the United States and Europe. The strategy of protracted people’s war solves the focoísmo conundrum by rooting itself firmly in the masses and also stressing the primacy of the party, which commands the People’s Army. Gonzaloite left deviationists posit the formation of a “militarized party” , which essentially is a militarist (it’s right there in the name) deviation that, for all the crowing about it, did not lead to success in Peru, where the concept was synthesized and applied during the revolutionary armed struggle which took place there from 1980 to the mid 1990s. Gonzaloites position the formation of a militarized, clandestine party as one of the main theses of their odd Peruvian centered “Maoism”, yet in practice this has led to all kinds of weird anarchist/Lyndon LaRouche style shenanigans in the United States and what appears to be nothing but a bunch of “clandestine” committees and blogs in European social democracies like Norway and Germany. Huey P. Newton said that this type of obsession with clandestinity is the epitome of cowardice hiding behind the facade and aesthetic of hyper-militancy.

A word on the Party, and on cadre. The Party must be militant. Having a gun does not equate to militancy, nor does it make one a Communist, or a cadre. A Maoist cadre is defined, mainly, by adherence to the democratic centralism of their Party formation, the ability to forge strong and unbreakable ties to the basic masses (in the United States, this being the colonized proletariat and semi-proletariat), the ability to take information from the masses, synthesize it, and develop mass movements that generate new cadre in the heat of vigorous class struggle (think Ferguson — imagine if Communists had led there!), the ability to creatively apply Marxism-Leninism-Maoism to all aspects of their work and daily life, the ability to develop themselves as an indispensable part of the fabric of their community, constant and deep study of theory and how to apply it, and the ability to put politics in command in all aspects of their life. A lot of formations treat this as some sort of mystery or unscalable mountain, this is an ultraleft, closed doorist view. I have met basic mass organizers who are better cadre and better Communists than those who go back and forth in an arrogant fashion on the internet over who holds the “red line” on an insignificant matter, or who try to lecture those who have led initiations of revolutionary war and who have participated in that process, on what constitutes correct Party development and organization. Cadre development is not reducible to a series of classes, or readings, or anything else that can be knocked out at one blow, however. It is a commitment, a lifelong one. While the attempt to universalize the “militarized” party thesis can accurately be described as the work of a bunch of edgy, self-righteous petit-bourgeois children in the imperialist metropoles who are in love with the aesthetics and idea of violence, we should be careful to avoid the right deviation of rejecting militancy and taking up liquidationism into the mass movement. The Party is composed of those who are consciously building themselves, collectively sharpening theory and practice, and developing Marxist-Leninist-Maoist theory for the US context not through polemics and debates but through practice, which we Maoists know is the true test of correctness or incorrectness. The matter of whether or not Protracted People’s War is truly applicable to the imperialist metropole is not settled through back and forths online or in private, but by, as we say, actually doin’ the damn thing.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Cap K › 1NC – Shell

Degrowth despite trying to be a “progressive” ideology works counteractive to Marxism and oppresses the Working Class.

Liberation School ’21 [The Party for Socialism and Liberation believes that the only solution to the deepening crisis of capitalism is the socialist transformation of society, “Degrowth: An environmental ideology with good intentions, bad politics,” published July 20,2021.]

Proponents of degrowth argue that there are absolute “planetary limits” and a fixed “carrying capacity” that cannot be surpassed by humans if we want to avoid ecological collapse. This is not only pessimistic in that it dismisses the idea that, under socialism, we could figure out new sustainable ways to grow, but it’s also completely devoid of class analysis. There’s no distinction between socially-produced limits and natural limits.

Degrowth is anti-modern, anti-technological, and anti-large scale production and infrastructure. Kallis argues that “only social systems of limited size and complexity can be governed directly rather than by technocratic elites acting on behalf of the populace… Many degrowth advocates, therefore, oppose even ‘green’ megastructures like high-speed trains or industrial-scale wind farms[!]” [13]. 

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Cap K › 1NC – Shell

All capitalism is racial capitalism – global political economy was built and sustained by theft of Indigenous land, superexploitation of Black labor, imperial extraction, and racist devaluation of “disposable” populations. This necroeconomy is terminally unsustainable, culminating in endless war and ecological collapse.

Burden-Stelley, ’20 [Charisse Burden-Stelley, you should totally read HER work for non-debate reasons, assistant professor of Africana Studies and political science at Carleton College, “Modern U.S. Racial Capitalism: Some Theoretical Insights,” published in July 2020, *Footnote 14 is inserted below the paragraph it’s cited in, all others omitted for readability **edited for problematic language //jwc]

Drawing on the intellectual production of twentieth-century Black anticapitalists, I theorize modern U.S. racial capitalism as a racially hierarchical political economy constituting war and militarism, imperialist accumulation, expropriation by domination, and labor superexploitation.14 The racial here specifically refers to Blackness, defined as African descendants’ relationship to the capitalist mode of production—their structural location—and the condition, status, and material realities emanating therefrom.15 It is out of this structural location that the irresolvable contradiction of value minus worth arises. Stated differently, Blackness is a capacious category of surplus value extraction essential to an array of political-economic functions, including accumulation, disaccumulation, debt, planned obsolescence, and absorption of the burdens of economic crises.16 At the same time, Blackness is the quintessential condition of disposability, expendability, and devalorization. [Footnote 14]: Another feature of modern U.S. racial capitalism is property by dispossession. In Theft Is Property! Dispossession and Critical Theory, Robert Nichols draws on the experience of Indigenous peoples in the United States, Canada, and New Zealand to theorize how the “system of landed property” was fundamentally predicated on violent dispossession. While the Anglo-derived legal-political regimes differed in these localities, the “intertwined and co-constitutive” material effects converged in the legalized theft of indigenous territory amounting in “approximately 6 percent of the total land on the surface of Earth.” Such dispossession, Nichols notes, is recursive: “In a standard formulation one would assume that ‘property’ is logically, chronologically, and normatively prior to ‘theft.’ However, in this (colonial) context, theft is the mechanism and means by which property is generated: hence its recursivity. Recursive dispossession is effectively a form of property-generating theft.” As such, theft and dispossession, through property regimes, are an ongoing feature of the Indigenous reality of modern U.S. racial capitalism. Robert Nichols, Theft Is Property! Dispossession and Critical Theory (Durham: Duke University Press, 2020), 50–51. [End Footnote 14] My operationalization of capitalism follows Oliver Cromwell Cox’s explication in Capitalism and American Leadership.17 Modern U.S. racial capitalism arose in the context of the First World War, when, as Cox explains, the United States took advantage of the conflict to capture the markets of South America, Asia, and Africa for its “over-expanded capacity.”18 Cox further expounds upon this auspicious moment of ascendant modern U.S. racial capitalism thus: By 1914, the United States had brought its superb natural resources within reach of intensive exploitation. Under the stimulus of its foreign-trade outlets, the financial assistance of the older capitalist nations, and a flexible system of protective tariffs, the nation developed a magnificent work of transportation and communication so that its mines, factories, and farms became integrated into an effectively producing organism having easy access to its seaports.… [Likewise,] further internal expansion depended upon far greater emphasis on an ever widening foreign commerce.… Major entrepreneurs of the United States proceeded to step up their campaign for expansion abroad. The war accentuated this movement. It accelerated the growth of [modern] American [racial] capitalism and impressed upon its leaders as nothing had before the need for external markets.19 Relatedly, Peter James Hudson argues that the First World War fundamentally changed the terms of order of international finance, allowing New York to compete with London, Paris, and Berlin for the first time in the realm of global banking. This was not least because the Great War “drastically reordered global credit flows,” with the United States transforming from a debtor into a creditor nation.20 In addition to Latin American and Caribbean nations and businesses turning to the United States for financing and credit, domestic saving and investment patterns were altered to the benefit of imperial financial institutions like the City Bank.21 Although the United States is, to use Cox’s terminology, more a “lusty child of an already highly developed capitalism” than an exceptional capitalist power, the nation perfected its techniques of accumulation through its vast natural wealth, large domestic market, imbalance of Northern and Southern economies, and, importantly, through its lack of concern for the political and economic welfare of the overwhelming masses of its population, least of all the descendants of the enslaved.22 Modern U.S. racial capitalism is thus sustained by military expenditure, the maintenance of an extremely low standard of living in “dependent” countries, and the domestic superexploitation of Black toilers and laborers. Cox notes that Black labor has been the “chief human factor” in wealth production; as such, “the dominant economic class has always been at the motivating center of the spreads of racial antagonism. This is to be expected since the economic content of the antagonism, especially at its proliferating source in the South, has been precisely that of labor-capital relations.”23 In a general sense, racial capitalism in the United States constitutes “a peculiar variant of capitalist production” in which Blackness expresses a structural location at the bottom of the labor hierarchy characterized by depressed wages, working conditions, job opportunities, and widespread exclusion from labor unions.24 Furthermore, modern U.S. racial capitalism is rooted in the imbrication of anti-Blackness and antiradicalism. Anti-Blackness describes the reduction of Blackness to a category of abjection and subjection through narrations of absolute biological or cultural difference; ruling-class monopolization of political power; negative and derogatory mass media propaganda; the ascent of discriminatory legislation that maintains and reinscribes inequality, not least various modes of segregation; and social relations in which distrust and antipathy toward those racialized as Black is normalized and in which “interracial mass behavior involving violence assumes a continuously potential danger.”25 Anti-Blackness thus conceals the inherent contradiction of Blackness—value minus worth—obscuring and distorting its structural location by, as Ralph and Singhal remark, contorting it into only a “debilitated condition.”26 Antiradicalism can be understood as the physical and discursive repression and condemnation of anticapitalist and/or left-leaning ideas, politics, practices, and modes of organizing that are construed as subversive, seditious, and otherwise threatening to capitalist society. These include, but are not limited to, internationalism, anti-imperialism, anticolonialism, peace activism, and antisexism. Anti-Blackness and antiradicalism function as the legitimating architecture of modern U.S. racial capitalism, which includes rationalizing discourses, cultural narratives, technologies of repression, legal structures, and social practices that inform and are informed by racial capitalism’s political economy.27 Throughout the twentieth century, anti-Blackness propelled the “Black Scare,” defined as the specter of racial, social, and economic domination of superior whites by inferior Black populations. Antiradicalism, in turn, was enunciated through the “Red Scare,” understood as the threat of communist takeover, infiltration, and disruption of the American way of life.28 For example, in the 1919 Justice Department Report, Radicalism and Sedition Among the Negroes, As Reflected in Their Publications, it was asserted that the radical antigovernment stance of a certain class of Negroes [Black people] was manifested in their “ill-governed reaction toward race rioting,” “threat of retaliatory measures in connection with lynching,” open demand for social equality, identification with the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), and “outspoken advocacy of the Bolshevik or Soviet doctrine.”29 Here, anti-Blackness, articulated through the fear of the “assertion of race consciousness,” was attached to the IWW and Bolshevism—in other words, to anticapitalism—to make it appear even more subversive and dangerous. Likewise, antiradicalism, expressed through the denigration of the IWW and Soviet Doctrine, was made to seem all the more threatening and antithetical to the social order in its linkage with Black insistence on equality and self-defense against racial terrorism. In this way, “defiance and insolently race-centered condemnation of the white race” and “the Negro seeing red” came to be understood as seditious in the context of modern U.S. racial capitalism. The link between my theory of modern U.S. racial capitalism and Robinson’s catholic theory of racial capitalism, beyond his “suggest[ion] that it was there,” is vivified through the prison abolitionist and scholar Ruth Wilson Gilmore, who writes: “Capitalism…[is] never not racial.… Racial capitalism: a mode of production developed in agriculture, improved by enclosure in the Old World, and captive land and labor in the Americas, perfected in slavery’s time-motion, field factory choreography, its imperative forged on the anvils of imperial war-making monarchs.”30 Racial capitalism, she continues, “requires all kinds of scheming, including hard work by elites and their compradors in the overlapping and interlocking space-economies of the planet’s surface. They build and dismantle and reconfigure states, moving capacity into and out of the public realm. And they think very hard about money on the move.”31 Perhaps more than Gilmore, though, my approach aligns with that of Neville Alexander as described by Hudson.32 Like Alexander, who focused on South Africa, I offer a particularistic understanding of racial capitalism, mine being rooted in the political economy of Blackness and the legitimating architectures of anti-Blackness and antiradicalism in the United States. Gilmore qua Robinson offers a more universalist and transhistorical conception. Like Alexander, my theory of modern U.S. racial capitalism is primarily rooted in (Black) Marxist-Leninists and fellow travelers. This is an important epistemological distinction: whereas Robinson finds Marxism-Leninism to be, at best, inattentive to race, my theory of modern U.S. racial capitalism is rooted in the work of Black freedom fighters who, as Marxist-Leninists, were able to offer potent and enduring analyses and critiques of the conjunctural entanglements of racialism, white supremacy, and anti-Blackness, on the one hand, and capitalist exploitation and class antagonism on the other hand.33 Although Robinson draws on scholars like Fernand Braudel, Henri Pirenne, David Brion Davis, and Eli Heckscher to understand European history, socialist theory, and the European working class, the work of Black Marxists like James Ford, Walter Rodney, Amílcar Cabral, and Paul Robeson offer me those same intellectual, historical, and theoretical resources. Finally, I agree with Alexander that the resolution to racial capitalism is antiracist socialism, not a cultural-metaphysical Black radical tradition. In what remains of this essay, I will draw on the work of Black Marxist-Leninists and anticapitalists to explicate the defining features of modern U.S. racial capitalism—war and militarism, imperialist accumulation, expropriation by domination, labor superexploitation, and property by dispossession. In this, I demonstrate that their critiques and analyses offer a blueprint for theorizing modern U.S. racial capitalism. War and militarism facilitate the endless drive for profit. Military conflicts between imperial powers result in the reapportioning of boundaries, possessions, and spheres of influence that often exacerbate racial and spatial economic subjection. War and militarism also perpetuate the endless construction of “threats,” primarily in racialized and socialist states, against which to defend progress, prosperity, freedom, and security. The manufacturing of conflict legitimates the mobilization of extraordinary violence to expropriate untold resources that produce relations of underdevelopment, dependency, extraversion, and disarticulation in the Global South. Moreover, the ruling elite and labor aristocracy in imperialist countries, not least the United States, wage perpetual war to defend their way of life and standard of living against the racialized majority who, because they would benefit most from the redistribution of the world’s wealth and resources, represent a perpetual threat. Here, Du Bois’s 1915 essay, “The African Roots of War,” is instructive.34 Though he does not directly analyze the United States, he nonetheless demonstrates how racism, white supremacy, and the plunder of Africa underpinned the capitalist imperialist war that engulfed the world from July 1914 to November 1918—a war that catapulted the United States into the center of the capitalist world system. Using Du Bois’s own words, Hubert Harrison, the father of Harlem radicalism, makes the direct link: But since every industrial nation is seeking the same outlet for its products, clashes are inevitable and in these clashes beaks and claws—armies and navies—must come into play. Hence beaks and claws must be provided beforehand against the day of conflict, and hence the exploitation of white men in Europe and America becomes the reason for the exploitation of black and brown and yellow men in African and Asia. And, therefore, it is hypocritical and absurd to pretend that the capitalist nations can ever intend to abolish wars.… For white folk to insist upon the right to manage their own ancestral lands, free from the domination of tyrants, domestic and foreign, is variously described as “democracy” and “self-determination.” For Negroes, Egyptians and Hindus to seek the same thing is impudence.… Truly has it been said that “the problem of the 20th century is the problem of the ‘Color Line.'” And wars are not likely to end; in fact, they are likely to be wider and more terrible—so long as this theory of white domination seeks to hold down the majority of the world’s people under the iron heel of racial oppression.35 For Du Bois, the imperialist rivalry for the booty on offer in Africa drove Berlin’s efforts to consolidate its place in the sun by displacing London in particular. While Vladimir Lenin understood that “the war [was] a product of half a century of development of world capitalism and of billions of threads and connections,” Du Bois expanded this analysis by providing a critique of the racial foundations of capitalist expansion.36 He held that the struggle to the death during the Great War for African resources and labor had begun to “pay dividends” centuries earlier through the enslavement of African peoples, the subsequent conflation of color and inferiority, and the reduction of what was routinely referred to as the “Dark Continent” to a space of backwardness ideally suited for dispossession. He further noted that “with the waning possibility of Big Fortune…at home, arose more magnificently the dream of exploitation abroad,” especially in Africa—a dream shared by white labor and the ruling class.37 In other words, this “democratic despotism” allowed for the white working class to “share the spoil of exploiting ‘chinks and niggers,'” and facilitated the creation of “a new democratic nation composed of united capital and labor” that perpetuated racial capitalism across class lines.38 Moreover, this national unity was strengthened through the disrespect and dehumanization of the racialized toilers and peasants in the plundered colonies that mitigated the exploitation and impoverishment of the white working class in imperial countries. This superexploitation allowed white workers to get a share, however pitiful, of “wealth, power, and luxury…on a scale the world never saw before” and to benefit from the “new wealth” accumulated from the “darker nations of the world” through cross-class consent “for governance by white folk and economic subjection to them”—a consensus solidified through the doctrine of “the natural inferiority of most men to the few.”39 Given the entanglement of racialization and capitalist exploitation, Du Bois averred, “Racial slander must go. Racial prejudice will follow…the domination of one people by another without the other’s consent, be the subject people black or white, must stop. The doctrine of forcible economic expansion over subject people must go.” Insofar as this admonishment applied as much to the United States as to European imperialists, beyond the international proletariat, it was the darker peoples and nations of the world who would challenge racial capitalism, not least “the twenty-five million grandchildren of the European slave trade…and first of all the ten million black folk in the United States.”40 Imperialist accumulation denotes the rapacious conscription of resources and labor for the purpose of superprofits through violent means that are generally reserved for populations deemed racially inferior. On the precipice of the Great Depression, the prominent Black communist James Ford beautifully explicated imperialist accumulation. In his 1929 report on the Second World Congress of the League Against Imperialism, he explained that the extant political economy constituted the consolidation of Africa’s partition and the “complete enslavement of its people”; the arresting of its industrialization, which hindered the development of the “toiling masses”; and the relegation of the continent to a source of raw material, a market for European goods, and a dumping ground for accumulated surplus capital. In the U.S. South, the Black poor were dehumanized by Wall Street, “white big business,” and the “rising Negro [Black] bourgeoisie” whose condition of possibility was the subjection of the Black working class. This oppression was exacerbated by rigid racial barriers, disenfranchisement, and lynching. Ford further argued that the West Indies, subjected to U.S. militarism and occupation on behalf of Wall Street, were largely transformed into a marketplace for U.S. goods. Moreover, throughout Africa, the U.S. South, and the Caribbean, Black workers were impressed into forced labor, laying railroads, building roads and bridges, and working in mines; were entrapped on plantations through peonage; and were subjected to convict leasing. In addition, they suffered intolerable working conditions and routinized violence.41 Expropriation by domination designates the seizure and confiscation of land, assets, property, bodies, and other sources of material wealth set to work by relations of economic dependence. This relationship exists both between nations and between groups. A quintessential enunciation of expropriation by domination between groups is We Charge Genocide: The Historic Petition to the United Nations for Relief from a Crime of the United States Government Against the Negro People, edited by the Black Communist William Patterson (with significant help from his wife and comrade Louise Thompson Patterson) and submitted to the United Nations by the Civil Rights Congress in 1951.42 The petition meticulously documented the past and present expropriation of Black people by the ruling class of modern U.S. racial capitalism through consistent and persistent discrimination in employment, unfair wages, forced ghettoization, inequitable and inferior accommodation and services, and the denial of justice in the courts. It further argued that this process was sustained by genocidal terror, white supremacist law, and the drive of monopoly capitalists for superprofits. Importantly, We Charge Genocide noted that, for primarily economic reasons, the historical and geographical locus of anti-Black genocide was the “Black Belt” of the Southern United States, a region expropriated by the Northern industrial capitalists and by Southern landowners alike. This was due in large part to plantation systems of sharecropping and peonage—legacies of slavery—in which Black political and economic rights were virtually nonexistent, Black laborers were inexorably tied to the land through debt, and the threat of violence and death precluded demands for justice. For Patterson, such expropriation by domination was the basis of “racist contamination that has spread throughout the United States.”43 We Charge Genocide further conveyed that expropriation by domination, a central element of modern U.S. racial capitalism, was more than a domestic concern because such practices “at home must inevitably create racist commodities for export abroad—must inevitably tend toward war.”44 Labor superexploitation can be understood as an economic relationship in which the intensity, form, and racial basis of exploitation differs little from slavery. Its effects are so extreme that it pushes racialized, particularly Black, labor effectively below the level of sheer physical subsistence. As Harrison explained, in the context of modern U.S. racial capitalism, Black workers “form a group that is more essentially proletarian than any other American group” because enslaved Africans were brought to the “new world” to be ruthlessly exploited. This reality fixed their social status as the most despised group, which in turn intensified their subjection.45 Likewise, organizations like the American Negro Labor Congress and the Anti-Imperialist League analyzed that the racial capitalist superexploitation of Black nations like Haiti in the first quarter of the twentieth century for the purposes of consolidating Wall Street control over land, commercial relations, and production was accompanied by the brutalization of Black labor, the export of Jim Crow practices, military occupation, and political repression.46 In effect, superexploitation results from the conjuncture of white supremacy, racialization, and the “badge of slavery,” which exacerbates the conditions of exploitation to which white working classes are subjected. As the Black Marxist Harry Haywood argued in 1948, “the stifling effects of the race factor are most strikingly illustrated by the drastic differences in the economic and cultural status of Negroes and whites.… Beyond all doubt, the oppression of the Negro, which is the basis of the degradation of the ‘poor whites,’ is of separate character demanding a special approach.”47 Superexploitation, he explained further, constitutes a combination of direct exploitation, outright robbery, physical violence, legal coercion, and perpetual indebtedness. It stifles “the free economic and cultural development” of the Black masses “through racist persecution as a basic condition for maintaining” virtual enslavement.48 The entrapment of Black women in domestic labor throughout the twentieth century—a function of their “triple oppression”—is perhaps the most glaring example of labor superexploitation under modern U.S. racial capitalism. In 1936, the lifelong Black radical Louise Thompson explained that Black women’s superexploitation in the capitalist mode of production was based on their race, sex, and subordination in the labor market.49 That same year, Black militants Marvel Cooke and Ella Baker published an article titled “The Bronx Slave Market” in which they studied triple oppression as it related to Black domestic workers. Cooke and Baker explained that the entanglements of racism, sex-based labor subordination, and structural poverty were deeply intensified by the Great Depression and forced Black domestic workers to pauperize their labor for the abysmal wage of less than thirty cents an hour. This form of labor exploitation was unique to the female sex because domestic work was conventional “women’s work,” and it was racialized insofar as the denigration of Black people fitted this group of women for low-wage, unprotected, and contingent labor.50

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Productivity Good

Productivity is good for the economy and allows for workers to use their excess energy

CRS 1/3 (Congressional Research Service is the research institute of Congress, “Introduction to US Economy: Productivity,” 1-3-23, https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10557)[MO]

Productivity growth is a primary driver of long-term economic growth and improvements in living standards. As productivity increases, society can produce more goods and services with the same level of resources, which, all else equal, increases incomes and access to goods and services, including additional leisure time.

Policymakers are also interested because government policies, institutions, and the regulatory environment can impact productivity growth. For example, strong and enforceable patent laws likely encourage companies to invest more in research and development, which contributes to productivity growth, because the laws enable companies to profit from their new technologies and products.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › UBI Unsustainable

UBI unsustainable and has a negative impact on the economy

Doar 18 (Robert Doar is a Morgride Fellow in Poverty Studies, “Universal Basic Income Would Undermine the Success of Our Safety Net,” Spring 2018, https://www.bushcenter.org/catalyst/are-we-ready/doar-universal-basic-income)[MO]

Universal Basic Income (UBI) would be an unaffordable way to undermine our social safety net’s successes. UBI would transfer money away from those who need it most, change the distinctly American relationship between citizen and government, and sharply raise taxes or the national debt (or both). And critically, it would fail to improve upon our current safety net’s biggest weakness: UBI would destroy – not improve – incentives to work.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Degrowth Bad

Degrowth causes mass implosion of the economy.

Tokic, Damir [Ph.D. Assistant Clinical Professor of Finance University of Texas RGV Editor-in-Chief Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance  “The Economic and Financial Dimensions of Degrowth.” Ecological Economics, vol. 84, Elsevier BV, Dec. 2012, pp. 49–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.09.011.]

Next, we turn our attention to  illustration of degrowth in  and critically evaluate the underlying assumption that the degrowth phase is sustainable. More specifically, we analyze whether it would even be possible to steer the economy to a stable 2–3% negative GDP growth rate for a lengthy period of time, as the proponents of degrowth suggest. Our analysis starts with the proposition that fundamental stock market valuation would significantly decrease given the expectations of the degrowth scenario. As a result, given that the stock market is forward-looking, investors would sell their stocks to protect their wealth well in advance of the proposed degrowth scenario, which would essentially cause the stock market to crash—a significant loss of value in a relatively short period of time. Next, we propose that the stock market crash would cause further deleveraging by investors, corporations, and consumers, which would likely create a credit crisis and invigorate deflationary pressures. Finally, we propose that the resulting deflationary pressures are likely to turn into a vicious cycle of deflation, significantly affecting the real economy via delayed consumption and production, which would result in high unemployment rates. It is important to note that these economic events (the stock market crash, deleveraging, and deflation) can happen very quickly due to market contagion. As a result, we suggest that the real economy would implode, or sharply correct in a relatively short period of time, even with a slight indication of the degrowth scenario.

Following (or ideally during) the economic implosion (which happens quickly), we would logically expect a fiscal and monetary policy intervention as explained by . As a result, assuming that Bernanke is correct, the extraordinary monetary policy intervention would eventually create positive inflation and stabilize the economy and asset prices. Consequently, given pent-up consumer demand during the crisis and the lean inventories following the deflationary “scare”, we would expect a new long-term cycle of positive economic growth to resume. Thus, our key argument is that a gradual long-term negative GDP growth (as illustrated in ) is unsustainable and not possible to achieve in a market economy. Rather, we argue that it is more likely that the economy would quickly adjust to long term negative GDP growth expectations, or implode, which would be followed by another long-term growth cycle, given the policy intervention during the implosion.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Degrowth Bad

A stock market crash causes mass deflation and increases unemployment.

Tokic, Damir [Ph.D. Assistant Clinical Professor of Finance University of Texas RGV Editor-in-Chief Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance  “The Economic and Financial Dimensions of Degrowth.” Ecological Economics, vol. 84, Elsevier BV, Dec. 2012, pp. 49–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.09.011.]

The most lethal effect of the stock market crash and the resulting deleveraging on the real economy (due to the expectations of the degrowth scenario) could potentially emerge in the form of a vicious cycle of deflation. Deflation is a state of economy characterized by chronic negative inflation, resulting from the general collapse of demand, as explained by . As we previously discussed, a stock market crash usually leads to forced deleveraging, which causes falling prices of commodities and reductions in consumer and business credit, all of which translate into falling goods prices. The falling goods prices cause delayed consumption (why buy a car now if you can buy it cheaper in a few months?), which contributes to collapsing demand and starts the vicious cycle of deflation. Specifically, delayed consumption leads to reductions of inventories and companies are forced to cut and delay production, which causes more layoffs and increases the unemployment rate. The increase in unemployment further deteriorates consumer demand, which magnifies the credit crunch and results in even lower prices, and the vicious cycle of deflation continuous.

The current Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke explained the dangers of deflation in a 2002 speech and the extraordinary policy response necessary to combat deflationary pressures. In his view, fiscal policies can be used by governments to increase public sector demand by spending on social programs, jobs creation, infrastructure projects, and others. However, the key policy tools against deflation are at the disposal of the central banks via the extraordinary monetary policy tools. Specifically,  mentions that the Fed can always generate a positive inflation rate, even when the nominal short term rates reach zero percent, by engaging in quantitative easing (money printing press) and possibly by intervening in foreign currency markets and devaluing the domestic currency via other currencies and real assets, both of which generate positive inflation. In fact, the Fed can engage in asset purchases and essentially buy assets with the newly-created money to boost asset prices and break the deflationary spiral, which is essentially the last line of defense for capitalism. However, even  acknowledges that these extraordinary policy responses to deflation are only theoretical and unproven in practice, and thus, deflation should be avoided at all costs.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Degrowth Bad

The stock market crash- reduces value of assets and forces corporations to sell assets causing a recession.

Tokic, Damir [Ph.D. Assistant Clinical Professor of Finance University of Texas RGV Editor-in-Chief Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance  “The Economic and Financial Dimensions of Degrowth.” Ecological Economics, vol. 84, Elsevier BV, Dec. 2012, pp. 49–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.09.011.]

The stock market crash in response to the degrowth scenario would have a significant and immediate effect on other financial assets, physical assets, and the broader economy primarily due to massive deleveraging, which we define as the forced repayment of debt by liquidating equity (a form of market contagion). For example, investors and speculators buying stocks on margin (with borrowed money) would be forced to sell their stocks as well as other equity in their accounts to maintain their required initial margins. Specifically, brokerage firms allow investors to purchase stocks with 50% cash collateral and 50% margin, while futures brokers allow traders to speculate in stock index futures with 5–10% cash collateral. In both cases, as the value of stocks (account equity) falls below the required level (the maintenance margin), margin investors receive a margin call to either liquidate their positions or deposit more funds into their accounts. Since investors rarely respond to margin calls and deposit more cash, all their positions can be forcefully liquidated, which includes their positions in other asset classes such as commodities (energy, metals, agriculture), risky bonds, and even high-yielding currencies. As a result, the stock market crash, and the resulting forced deleveraging, are likely to cause sharp price declines in all risky assets. Second, public corporations might also be forced to deleverage as the falling stock prices significantly increase their market debt-to-equity ratios, primarily due to the collapse of their market equity value (collateral). As a result, corporations might be forced to sell some of their assets to prepay some of their debt, which essentially creates a fire-sale scenario and reduces values of commercial assets such as commercial real-estate, property, plants, equipment and other. Third, local and national governments also might be forced to liquidate some of their assets (landmarks, islands, land) to prepay some of their debt if the stock market crash results in lower tax revenues or falling prices of other assets held in their portfolios. The common theme among these different forms of deleveraging is that lenders (brokers, banks, bondholders) face increased credit risk due to the falling prices of the borrower's collateral, which can actually lead to a systemic credit crunch, whereby any form of new financing becomes limited and expensive. The broad economic implications of a credit crunch extend to individuals via the reduction of credit limits on consumer credit cards, higher interest rates, higher standards of lending, and larger down-payments, which essentially results in consumer deleveraging and, thus, potentially has the most significant effect on the real economy.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Degrowth Bad

Degrowth causes a market crash.

Tokic, Damir [Ph.D. Assistant Clinical Professor of Finance University of Texas RGV Editor-in-Chief Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance  “The Economic and Financial Dimensions of Degrowth.” Ecological Economics, vol. 84, Elsevier BV, Dec. 2012, pp. 49–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.09.011.]

In a more detailed analysis, we specifically evaluate the reaction of the stock market to the degrowth scenario and evaluate the implications for the broader economy. We ask ourselves a question: how would the stock market react to a scenario where the forecast for global GDP growth is a negative 2–3% +for a very long time, followed by flat growth indefinitely, as illustrated by ? Our approach (analysis) is based on a fundamentally-oriented investor's long-term view of stock market valuation. Specifically, we assume that a rational long-term investor would invest in the stock market if the expectation of the long-term rate of return is positive (and attractive compared to the risk-adjusted returns of other investment assets). Further, we assume that a rational fundamentally-oriented long term investor estimates the potential rate of return by calculating the intrinsic value of a stock (computing the present value of future cash flows) as the valuation theory suggests (), and comparing the intrinsic value to the market price. There are many variations of the fundamental stock market valuation models. For example, Gordon's constant dividend growth model () is the textbook valuation model, which assumes that the dividend growth rate is constant (positive), and thus, the stock price reflects: 1) the current dividend level; 2) the constant dividend growth rate; and 3) the cost of equity. The seminal study by  provides a great overview of several stock market valuation models, with assumptions of constant growth, excess growth, and variable growth of different types of cash flows (dividends, earnings, and free cash flows). Essentially, these different fundamental stock market valuation models have a common principle, that the stock market value is estimated as the present value of future cash flows (for example, earnings E), and the expected GDP growth rate is the key valuation input as a proxy of growth (g), while (k) represents the discount rate (the cost of equity or expected rate of return on equity), as illustrated in Eq. .(1)

We can demonstrate the application of this simple valuation model in Eq.  to estimate the price of the broad stock market index, the S&P 500, which includes the largest 500 companies in the U.S. In this applied example, an investor first finds the current combined earnings per share (EPS) for all companies included in the S&P 500 index, which is reported by analysts and generally available to the public. For the purpose of this example we assume the combined EPS for S&P 500 companies to be $100/share. Next, an investor has to determine the long-term growth rate of these earnings, which is a long-term GDP growth rate () estimated at around 3%. Next, an investor has to estimate the long term rate of return on the market (k), which historically has been around 9% ().

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille = Fascist

Bataille’s philosophy emphasizes the destruction of war and conflict

Wolin, 2006 [Richard, Distinguished Professor of History at the  Graduate Center, “Left Fascism: Georges Bataille and the German Ideology”Constellations vol. 2 issue 3, pp. 397-428] //LS

Moreover, the cultural attitudes of both Spemgler and Bataille are linked by an aesthetics of violence that is highly characteristic of the “front generation.” In a key passage in The Decline of the West, Spemgler, depicting the “life-world” of blood and instinct that had been repressed by the Faustian spirit of modernity, observes: “War is the primary politics of everything that lives and so much so that in the depths battle and life are one, and being will-to-battle expire together.”28 Similarly, for Junger, “War is an intoxication beyond all bonds. It is a frenzy without cautions and limits comparable only to the forces of nature.”29 Bataille (the meaning of his name in French should be recalled), too, is convinced that “conflict is life. Man’s value depends on his aggressive strength. A living man regards death as the fulfillment of life; he does not see it as misfortune. ...I MYSELF AM WAR.”30 As Jay observes in this connection: “on a deeper level, the war [World War I] seems to have exercised a certain positive fascination [on Bataille]. For it is striking that many of Bataille’s obsessive themes would betray an affinity for the experiences of degradation, pollution, violence, and communal bonding that were characteristic of life in the trenches.”

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille = Fascist

Bataille celebrates the glorification of war—his ideas are the foundation of facism

Wolin, 2006 [Richard, Distinguished Professor of History at the  Graduate Center, “Left Fascism: Georges Bataille and the German Ideology”Constellations vol. 2 issue 3, pp. 397-428] //LS

In the worldview of both Bataille and that of German young conservatives, war plays an essential, positive role. It serves as a means of dissolving the principium individuationis: the principle of a bourgeois subjectivity, on which the homogenous order of society - a world of loneliness and fragmentation – depends. For, according to Bataille, “the general movement of life is... accomplished beyond the demands of individuals.”32 It is in precisely this spirit that he celebrates the non-utilitarian nature of “combat” or “war” as a type of aestheticist end in itself: “Glory...expresses a movement of senseless frenzy, of measureless expenditure of energy, which the fervor of combat presupposes. Combat it glorious in that it is always beyond calculation at some moment.”33 For the same reasons, Bataille eulogizes those premodern “warrier societies in which pure, uncalculated violence and ostentatious forms of combat held sway.”34 For under such conditions, war was not made subservient to the vulgar ends of enterprise and accumulation, as is the case for modern-day imperialism, but served as a glorious end in itself. Yet in the early 1930s, it was precisely this aestheticist celebration of “violence for violence’s sake,” or “war for war’s sake,” that Benjamin viewed as the essence of modern fascism. As he remarks in a well known passage: “Fiat ars – pereat mundus,” says fascism, and, as Marinetti admits, expects war to supply the artistic gratification of a sense pereption that has been changed by technology...Mankind, which in Homer’s time was an object of contemplation for the Olympian gods, now is one for itself. Its self-alienation has reached such a degree that it can experience its own destruction as an aesthetic pleasure of the first order. This is the situation of politics which fascism is rendering aesthetic.35 In Bataille’s thought war serves as the harbinger of a cultural transfiguration in which the primacy of self-subsistent subjectivity would be replaced by the values of an “unavowable” or “ecstatic community”: that is, a community that would no longer be governed by the goals of a “visual culture” – transparency, self-identity, etc. – but instead, those of self-laceration, difference, and finitude. In fact this Bataille-inspired program of an ecstatic community has been quite explicitly carried forth and explored in the political writings of Maurice Blanchot (La Communaute inavouable; 1983) and Jean-Luc Nancy (La Communaute desoeuvree; 1985).

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille = Fascist

Bataille’s ideals are inhumane, outdated, and unethical, and the AFF condones this.

Landa 14 [Ishay Landa, Department of History, Philosophy and Judaic Studies, The Open University, May 30, 2014, Bataille: The Master, the Slave, and Consumption, Pg 10-11, The Open University, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0896920514526624]

For all his emphasis on consumption, Bataille flatly rejected capitalist modernity, which is after all the historical class system which has ushered in considerable mass – as distinct from solely elite – consumption. Bataille did not mean to contradict Marx; he was after all a self-avowed ‘communist’. Yet his position on consumption was nonetheless fundamentally at odds with that expounded by Marx. For the latter, capitalism signified a marked improvement when adjudged historically, compared to former modes of production. It entailed a favorable, if flawed and limited, democratization of politics and culture. ‘This progression,’ Marx ascertained (1993: 589–590), ‘belongs [to] and is exploited by capital. All earlier forms of property condemn the greater part of humanity, the slaves, to be pure instruments of labour. Historical development, political development, art, science, etc. take place in higher circles over their heads. But only capital has subjugated historical progress to the service of wealth.’ Bataille’s ideal of consumption, by contrast, was ensconced in the remote past. For examples of formidable expenditure he needed to retreat as far back as the Middle Ages or the Aztec rites of human sacrifice. He affirmed the consumption of the rich aristocrat of yore, whose acts of squandering were interpreted as signs of prodigality, actes gratuites, opposed to the puny bourgeois emphasis on production. Consumption he recognized in the first stages of the historical dialectic, in the sovereign activity of the master. He drew a distinction between modern ‘productive consumption’, which is merely a leftover of production, and ancientcum-medieval ‘unproductive expenditure’ which includes ‘luxury, mourning, war, cults, the construction of sumptuary monuments, games, spectacles, arts, perverse sexual activity (i.e. deflected from genital finality).’ These are all activities, Bataille asserted (1985: 118), ‘which, at least in primitive circumstances have no end beyond themselves. Now it is necessary to reserve the use of the word expenditure for the designation of these unproductive forms, and not for the designation of all the modes of consumption that serve as a means to the end of production.’ Marx, once again, strongly disagrees. In revealing passages he attacked such propositions as Bataille’s on both quantitative grounds – underlining the great increase in consumption brought about by capitalism – and qualitative grounds – dismissing the extravagant consumption of the ancient elite as hollow and, in a sense, an optical illusion. Marx agrees with Ricardo, that under capitalism ‘the great majority of producers remains more or less excluded from the consumption of wealth.’ But he stresses that their exclusion was more hermetic in former times: This was indeed also the case, and to an even higher degree, in the ancient modes of production which depended on slavery … The wealth which they produced for private consumption was therefore relatively small and only appears great because it was amassed in the hands of a few persons, who, incidentally, did not know what to do with it. Although, therefore, there was no over-production among the ancients, there was over-consumption by the rich, which in the final periods of Rome and Greece turned into mad extravagance. (Marx, 2000: 528) But, of course, it is precisely consumption as ‘mad extravagance’ that Bataille sought to reanimate. Bataille conceived of consumption in such a ‘grandiose’ way, as to exclude, ignore, or dismiss the mundane understanding of the term. Common, ‘small’, everyday acts of consumption simply cannot expect to meet such a standard. To start with, they were associated with what is natural and affords straightforward, plentiful, instinctual enjoyment. In the early Marx we find a vindication of this sunny aspect of human nature in the characterization of a protagonist of a novel by Eugène Sue: surroundings. She is good because the sun and the flowers reveal to her her own sunny and blossoming nature. She is good because she is still young, full of hope and vitality. Her situation is not good, because it puts an unnatural constraint on her, because it is not the expression of her human impulses, not the fulfillment of her human desires; because it is full of torment and without joy. (Marx and Engels, 1975: 200, emphases in original) For Bataille, however, human desire rather thrives on torment, not joy. He exalted acts of consumption which tend to be destructive and negative. Such acts were purposefully defined as destructive, their negativity becoming their mark of honor. Far from shunning the causing of ‘suffering to anyone’, the inflicting of pain, on oneself as well as others, was considered a major source of pleasure and humanity, perhaps their very mainspring. Hence Bataille’s notorious fascination with rites of sacrifice, mutilation, necrophilia, and so on and so forth. Sexuality for him was closely linked with death, which explains why the medieval mass killer and pedophile, the aristocrat Gilles de Rais, formed a subject of his admiration.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille = Fascist

The AFF endorses a Bataille philosophy, -- fascist, and perverse.

Landa 14 [Ishay Landa, Department of History, Philosophy and Judaic Studies, The Open University, May 30, 2014, Bataille: The Master, the Slave, and Consumption, Pg 7, The Open University, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0896920514526624]

Bataille’s theory registers a genuine confusion besetting his thought, regarding political aims and social affiliation. This confusion, in turn, manifests itself in ambivalent terminology and elusive use of language. Bataille, one should always bear in mind, was an elitist with radical aspirations, or a radical with a strong elitist predisposition. These vacillations explain the often noted fact that this self-proclaimed ‘communist’ was evidently tantalized by fascism during the 1930s. Bataille truly and sincerely – in subjective terms that is – hated ‘the bourgeoisie’: this accounts for his ‘communism’, the desire[d] to destroy bourgeois civilization with the help of the repressed, toiling masses. But at the same time, ‘the bourgeoisie’ for him meant not so much a social class of exploiters, a privileged minority imposing itself on the masses, but the reified masses themselves oppressing a tiny minority of authentic people aspiring to sovereignty. Bataille’s attack on the bourgeoisie, therefore, turned out to be typically bourgeois, incorporating the elite’s disdain for mass society. Bataille was thus patently attracted to the fascist leaders, who represented some perverse reincarnation of ancient ‘sovereignty’ under modern conditions, an exciting, if flawed, resurgence of individual ‘heterogeneity’ under conditions of mass ‘homogeneity’.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille = Fascist

Bataille idolizes fascists like Hitler and justifies totalitarianism.

Stevenston 17 [Guy Stevenston, Department of English and Comparative Literature, Goldsmiths College, University of London, London, United Kingdom, March 10 2017, Pg 89, Taylor&Francis Online, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13825577.2016.1274542]

In a reversal of the same dialectic, the attraction to excess that differentiates Bataille from orthodox Marxist economists also led him to flirt with his avowed enemies on the right. Despite his position as co-founder of Critique, the Parisian leftist magazine aimed at countering fascism, various of his essays demonstrate[d] an interest in Hitler and Mussolini that was in many ways as emotionally charged as Pound’s. With a group of like-minded thinkers including Maurice Blanchot and Pierre Provost, Bataille envisioned Critique as a corrective to Action française, Pierre LaSerre’s radical rightist group that grew out of 1894’s Dreyfus Affair, and was inspired by Italian and German fascism. Unpardonably, to the Nietzschean Bataille, Action française also followed the Italian and German examples in appropriating Nietzsche to justify its totalitarian stance. And yet, in a 1933 essay entitled ‘The Psychological Structure of Fascism’, Bataille explains fascism’s mass appeal in terms of the heterogeneous truth discussed earlier. ‘The fascist leaders,’ he writes, ‘are incontestably part of heterogeneous existence. Opposed to democratic politicians, who represent in different countries the platitude inherent to homogeneous society, Mussolini and Hitler immediately stand out as something other’ (Bataille, 1985b: 143, emphasis in original). Looking beyond his objections to their politics, Bataille assigns value to these figureheads because they symbolise and facilitate unproductive expenditure. The strong man at the heart of a populist movement such as fascism, he says, is a conduit through which the ‘excessive energies’ accumulated by ‘the common consciousness’ can be channeled and released: The affective flow that unites him with his followers – which takes the form of moral identification of the latter with the one they follow … is a function of the common consciousness of increasingly violent and excessive energies and powers that accumulate in the person of the leader and through him become widely available. Bataille is interested in Hitler and Mussolini as symptoms of the powerful natural human desire to transcend rational, political thought and discourse. While he acknowledges the dangers inherent in such a process – a form of mass ‘hypnosis’, as he later calls it (Bataille, 1985: 143) – he also celebrates its potential for psychological liberation. Quoting from the same essay, Habermas notes that Bataille was himself seduced by these leaders’ rupture with a ‘boring’ homogeneous reality: Into this rationalised world irrupt the fascist Fuhrer and this entranced masses. It is not without admiration that Bataille speaks of their heterogeneous existence … He is fascinated by the violence ‘that raises them [Hitler and Mussolini] above the people, the parties, and even the laws, a violence that penetrates the normal course of affairs, the peaceful but boring homogeneity that is impotent when it comes to maintaining itself by its own force.’

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille Wrong

The economy is self sustaining—has automatic stabilizers built in

Johnson 8 [Simon Johnson is Economic Counsellor and Director of the IMF's Research Department, Finance and Development | F&D, 6-1-2008, "Finance and Development," https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2008/06/straight.htm]

Economists are fond of the term "automatic stabilizers." In general, it refers to anything that naturally tends to adjust so as to offset other changes and make a system more stable. One obvious example is unemployment benefits. As an economy slows and people lose their jobs, unemployment insurance provides them with replacement income, which helps keep consumption higher than it would be otherwise. Falling income tax revenue plays a similar role when the economy contracts— with larger fiscal deficits as a consequence. These things happen without any change in laws: they are built into the system and kick in automatically. And they are reassuring. To some extent, any move into recession is offset automatically in a way that naturally leads to recovery.The global version. Several important automatic stabilizers are built into the global economic system. The most important relate to how this system reacts when growth slows in a major economy, such as the United States. One effect should be a fall in long-term interest rates. And these rates have, to some extent, declined since summer 2007. Over time, lower rates should both underpin investment and help the global housing market turn around. But another key automatic stabilizer has traditionally been commodity prices. Normally, as the United States and other economies slow, the demand for and prices of commodities—such as oil—decline. This is a well-established fact. A fall in commodity prices helps keep purchasing power and, thus, demand higher than they would otherwise be in the United States and other advanced economies. Lower inflation also means more room for the U.S. Federal Reserve and other central banks to cut interest rates and, if necessary, for governments to increase their fiscal spending. A fall in commodity prices is not such good news, of course, for commodity exporters, but it is stabilizing for global economic growth as a whole.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille Wrong

The existing economic system is self-correcting

Keynes 63- John Maynard Keynes, 1st Baron Keynes CB, FBA was an English economist and philosopher whose ideas fundamentally changed the theory and practice of macroeconomics and the economic policies of governments. [ Nebraska Journal of Economics and Business, Vol. 2, No. 2 (Autumn, 1963), pp. 11-15 (5 pages) ] //LS

On the one side were those who believed that the existing eco- nomic system is in the long run self-adjusting, though with creaks and groans and jerks, and interrupted by time-lags, outside inter- ference and mistakes. One adherent of this school of thought laid stress on the increasing difficulty of rapid self-adjustment to change in an environment where population and markets are no longer expanding rapidly, Another stressed the growing tendency for out-side interference to hinder the processes of self -adjustment, while a third stressed the effect of business mistakes under the influence of the uncertainty and the false expectations caused by the faults of post-war monetary systems. These economists did not, of course, believe that the system is automatic or immediately self-adjusting, but they did maintain that it has an inherent tendency towards self- adjustment, if it is not interfered with, and if the action of change and chance is not too rapid.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Bataille Neg 23 › Case › Bataille Wrong

Theorizing the gift radically reconceptualizes the idea of debt: the Aff, by enacting deficit spending—buying credit by taking out a debt it has no intention of returning in service of its gift-giving—rethinks economics outside of restrictive frames and frees the gift from the implicit expectation of reciprocity as an act of deliberate waste.

McGoey ‘18 – Linsey McGoey is a Canadian sociologist and academic based in England. She is a Professor in the Department of Sociology at the University of Essex. “Bataille and the Sociology of Abundance: Reassessing Gifts, Debt and Economic Excess” in Theory, Culture & Society: Special Issue: Bataille and Heterology, Vol. 35(4–5), 07/28/2017, pg. 81-84; DOI: 10.1177/0263276416637905 | RN *Modified for problematic language **4pt text is just a critique of certain readings of Mauss—no Neg cards hidden

What is less known today is that Mauss, like Keynes, was preoccupied with challenging the imposition of war reparations. He published numerous financial journalism articles underscoring the negative economic repercussions of debt repayment efforts. A recent body of scholarship has even suggested that Mauss may have written The Gift in order in part to emphasize the importance of debt forgiveness by sovereign states (see, in particular, Mallard, 2011).

Why is Mauss’s writing on debt relief largely overlooked today? The problem rests partly with Mauss. During his career, he endeavoured to keep his political and financial journalism separate from his anthropological writing. Keith Hart suggests that this separation has been entrenched and exaggerated by his followers since then, many of whom treat The Gift as a masterful synthesis of earlier ethnographic studies (Mauss himself did not conduct primary research for it), with much to say about the social implications of reciprocity as a means of exchange, but with less relevance for understanding the geopolitics of sovereign states (Hart, 2014: 34).