2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---AT: AI Job Replacement
Orduña 21 – Nahia, contributor at the World Economic Forum and the Harvard Business Review, Engineering degree from the University of Deusto, and a business degree from Universidad del País Vasco, Nahia Orduña, 3-19-2021, "Why Robots Won’t Steal Your Job,", Harvard Business Review, , HKR-SWY
Last year, the World Economic Forum released a report estimating that by 2025, 85 million jobs may be displaced by a shift in labor division between humans and machines.
For new grads entering the workforce, or young professionals looking to land their first jobs, this is news worth paying attention to. Entry-level positions that include routine tasks are precisely the ones disappearing.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Other Barriers to Automation
Vincent 23 [Brandi Vincent is DefenseScoop’s Pentagon correspondent. Brandi worked on a long-form documentary and worked as a journalist at Nextgov, Snapchat and NBC Network. She was named a 2021 Paul Miller Washington Fellow by the National Press Foundation and was awarded SIIA’s 2020 Jesse H. Neal Award for Best News Coverage. Brandi grew up in Louisiana and received a master’s degree in journalism from the University of Maryland, “‘‘It’s about the DOD’ — New study explores obstacles hindering Pentagon’s AI adoption,” DefenseScoop, 5-18-2023, https://defensescoop.com/2023/05/18/its-about-the-dod-new-study-explores-obstacles-hindering-pentagons-ai-adoption/, accessed 7-17-2023, HKR-SWY]
To inform his 33-page paper and these overarching questions, Allen interviewed dozens of experts involved in driving AI and autonomous technologies and policies, including current and former members of the DOD, allied nations, and officials in the private sector. Among those many discussions were a number with “technology companies and individuals who have been supporting Ukraine” in the unfolding conflict since Russia’s invasion, he confirmed.
“I would say the first thing that really surprised me was just how rapidly the Ukrainian military has been able to apply AI — I mean there are cases where an AI model went from an idea in someone’s head to an AI-enabled military capability that warfighters are using and loving in a real war in a matter of weeks. From the perspective of the DOD, I knew that it’s really hard to do something that fast. And if the Ukrainians are doing it, that means that so much of what makes it hard to move that fast is not about AI. It’s about the DOD,” Allen explained.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Economy
1AC Merola 22 [Rossana Merola, Macroeconomist at the Research Department of the International labour Organization (ILO) , former visiting scholar at the Research Department of the Deutsche Bundesbank and the National Bank of Belgium. Rossana holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the Université Catholique de Louvain-la neuve and the University of Rome Tor Vergata, 5-31-2022 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9193369/]EKW
There are also arguments against the robot tax. First of all, as discussed in Section Challenges Arising From Robots and Artificial Intelligence, according to some studies employment effects from adopting robots remain rather limited or even positive at aggregate level (Acemoglu and Restrepo, 2017; Bessen, 2017; Graetz and Michaels, 2018; Koch et al., 2019; Acemoglu et al., 2020; Dixon et al., 2021). The main argument against taxing robots, however, is that it might impede innovation in an era of productivity slump. Over the last decades, advanced economies have experienced stagnating productivity. Taxing new technologies could make that slowdown worse, while according to some studies investing in robots enhances growth and productivity. A CEBR (2017) study finds that investment in robots contributed to 10 percent of GDP growth per capita in OECD countries from 1993 to 2016. Graetz and Michaels (2018) find that a unit increase in robotics density (defined as the number of robots per million of hours worked) is associated with a 0.04 percent increase in labor productivity. An analysis carried out by the Institute for Employment Research and the Düsseldorf Institute for Competition Economics finds that from 2004 to 2014 GDP has increased by 0.5% per person per robot as result of robotization (CEBR, 2017). Finally, another argument against the robot tax is that it would reduce the incentive for companies to invest in innovation and will make low wage traps more persistent, as argued by Robert D. Atkinson, president of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF). According to Atkinson, the main reason behind wage and GDP growth stagnation in advanced economies is the productivity slow-down. As mentioned above, there is empirical evidence that robots are driving labor productivity and GDP growth (CEBR, 2017; Graetz and Michaels, 2018). Therefore, creating disincentives to robotization may further impede labor productivity and perpetuate wage stagnation. Provided that automation increases overall productivity and efficiency and hence is beneficial to the society, hence the robot tax should be designed so to avoid discouraging the use of robots and automation. Some research shows that it is optimal to tax robots only for a limited time span. In this view, Guerreiro et al. (2020) propose to tax robots for three decades.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Economy
Cousins 17 (Steve Cousins, Steve Cousins is founder and CEO of Savioke, which develops and deploys autonomous robots that work in human environments to improve people’s lives. Steve was previously president and CEO of robotics incubator Willow Garage. “Is a “robot tax” really an “innovation penalty”?”. TechCrunch. April 22, 2017. . Accessed 7/20/23)//EKW
In reality, robots, like most automation, help people be more efficient and productive, rather than replace them. That’s been the case for centuries. A study of census data in England and Wales since 1871 found technology created far more jobs than it destroyed during that 140-year period. “Machines will take on more repetitive and laborious tasks, but seem no closer to eliminating the need for human labor than at any time in the last 150 years,” says the Deloitte report. When Gates talks about a robot tax, in essence, he’s talking about financially penalizing companies that deploy the latest automation technology — a sort of “innovation tax” — which, to me, is a backward tax. Shouldn’t our government support companies that embrace innovation in an effort to improve productivity and boost revenues? That’s what will make the US economy strong and competitive on a global scale. Perhaps a better way to ensure that automation improves the lives of all citizens — instead of becoming a wedge that creates a bigger and bigger divide between the haves and have-nots — is to ensure corporations pay tax on their profits. The more profitable a company becomes due to automation and increased productivity, the more income taxes it should pay into the collective system. Of course, closing loopholes that allow US corporations to dodge taxes will be difficult, but it’s critical to the long-term health of the global economy. Getting companies to pay their fair share of taxes won’t solve the larger societal challenge that automation will eventually displace low-skilled workers, nor would a robot tax. Instead, governments should focus on using corporate tax revenues to create free or low-cost education programs to prepare people to work alongside automation. For those unable to find work in tomorrow’s tech-driven society, governments could provide universal basic income or other safety nets for the least-advantaged. There are no easy answers to the growing divide between rich and poor, which will only accelerate in an automated age that leaves unskilled workers at a distinct disadvantage. But a robot tax is not the answer to this problem.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Economy
Yusuf 18 (Nojeem 'Nudge' Yusuf, Tax expert; Advocate of a new Nigeria; Family life activist; Public policy enthusiast. “Is Robotax a good idea?”. Nudge Tax Blog. January 8, 2018. . Accessed 7/21/23)//EKW
If you want to imagine what Robots are capable of doing, you may want to see RoboCop; a 1987 movie I watched as a child in the 90s. RoboCop was a robotically enhanced police officer used to fight crimes. Robots are capable of doing many of the jobs done by human beings, particularly jobs that involve repetitive tasks. The two key human attributes that are 'yet to be' substantially built into robots are emotional and creative capabilities. You may have read about robotic factory workers, pharmacists, surgeons, data analysts, news reporters, journalists, accountants and soldiers. Robots are taking jobs everywhere, and they may soon come for your job. Jack Ma recently said that in about 30 years time, the best CEO in the world could be a robot. The point I am trying to make here is that robots are already 'taking' jobs currently held by humans, thus potentially rendering humans jobless. A 2016 study carried out by the World Bank shows that as high as 85% of jobs currently held by Africans can be done by robots. In Africa, it is reported that there are about 400 industrial robots working in manufacturing environments. Robots are already controlling traffic in Congo; in South Africa/Botswana, robots are being used to access deep gold/diamond mines that are unsafe for humans. During the Ebola crisis in Liberia, robots were used to disinfect rooms holding Ebola patients. Eventually, robots will populate the African market, and we'll have to live by that reality. When you hire human beings, you pay them salaries and they pay taxes on those salaries. When you then replace humans with robots, of course you won't pay Robots salaries, you only buy and maintain them. Robots don't earn income, so they don't pay taxes. The taxman is going to be worried about this, because his tax revenue from PAYE taxes will deep naturally. There is every tendency that the taxman will seek to tax robots (or impose tax on acquisition of Robots) as a way of recovering taxes that may be lost because humans may be out of jobs. South Korea has the highest Robots to Humans ratio, and they have already imposed a Robotax. Robots are machines and tools of work that are capable of carrying out complex tasks with a high degree of automation. Irrespective of how well that look like humans, robots are not humans. If tax was not imposed on earlier technologies, then it will be unfair to impose tax on the technology of the moment - robotics. I think Robotax is a way of discouraging investment in automation and innovation. I can imagine that in a few years from now, we'll begin to have Robots in Nigeria particularly in the manufacturing environment. The tax authorities should begin to think of how to answer the Robotax questions before Robots begin to arrive in their numbers. The legislators should also begin to think about legislating generous tax incentives to encourage investments in robotics in Nigeria. Robots may render some people jobless, but it will create new jobs that attract significantly better income.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Economy
Mazur et. al 22 (Orly Mazur, who is a tax law professor at Southern Methodist University. She has an extensive background in tax law and technology, international and comparative taxation, and taxation of the digital economy. “Should we have a Robot Tax? Part 2”. Forbes. November 15, 2022. . Accessed 7/21/23)//EKW
Orly Mazur: Sure. One of the main fears is that there will be massive technological unemployment. That's what's spurring a lot of this robot tax discussion. But the claim that there will be massive technological unemployment and everyone will lose their jobs is very controversial. This, of course, raises the question: If we don't have massive unemployment, do we even need a robot tax? On the one hand, there are studies that support these claims that there will be massive unemployment. For instance, there are experts that have conducted studies that show that up to 30 percent of the hours worked globally could be automated by 2030. Then there's this other study that's cited frequently in this area that says 47 percent of total U.S. jobs will be displaced by the robots. These are scary numbers. These studies are basically arguing, "Well, this technological revolution is different than previous ones where we didn't see massive unemployment. Because here, all sectors of the economy are potentially affected. Robots can take any of our jobs, and this technological progress is happening much faster than other periods where we've had these automation revolutions." There are studies on the other side, though, that are saying these studies are incorrect. Instead, automation will either create no overall job loss, or maybe even it'll create new jobs at the end of the day. There is recent evidence that shows that the most automated countries have primarily had low unemployment rates, so that makes you think maybe automation is not hurting employment. Then there's other evidence that indicates employment has grown in nearly all occupations despite all this new automation going on. In reality, though, I would say that the predicted number of jobs is going to vary widely by the study, the industry, and the country in question. No one can say with certainty what the future holds. We don't really know if robots will take over all our jobs or not. But what everyone does agree on is that robots are going to at least disrupt the labor market significantly in the short term. We still have this problem of labor market disruption, even though it may not be as extensive as the robot tax proponents say. There is this threat of labor market disruption that we need to solve for. I just think that the robot tax is not the way to do it. Marie Sapirie: What are some of the other reasons not to adopt a robot tax? Orly Mazur: One of the main concerns raised by a robot tax is that it would hinder innovations. We know robotics creates many benefits for society, and if we tax the robots, we're increasing the cost of robots, and this could reduce the incentive for companies to innovate and invest in robotics. Never a good idea to penalize technological progress. Technological progress is great. It improves our productivity and our GDP, it provides more employment, and so many benefits to society. If we were to penalize this, we're taking away many of these economic and social advantages that robots provide. At the end of the day, we would exacerbate these problems that the robot tax is trying to address. When you take into account international tax competition, this picture looks even worse, because if you have one nation imposing a robot tax and another either doesn't tax the robots or even incentivizes investment in robots, businesses may relocate abroad. Now we're pushing more investments abroad and more jobs are going abroad, creating more problems than this robot tax is trying to solve for.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Economy
Eriksen 19 (Paul Ericksen is IndustryWeek’s supply chain advisor. He has 38 years of experience in industry, primarily in supply management at two large original equipment manufacturers. “A Robot Tax Is a Very Bad Idea”. Industry Week. September 20, 2019. . Accessed 7/21/23)//EKW
In last week’s recap, I recounted how Alec Ross, author and technology policy advisor, had speculated that robot design, development and manufacturing would be critical to future economic well-being worldwide. What I didn’t share was some of the background he provided that calls into question whether United States is positioning itself to be a leader in the robotics industry and the impact robotics will have on U.S. manufacturing jobs going forward. John Hitch has authored two recent articles on the robotics industry—a July 17 article, Reconciling Robot-Induced Anxiety and Admiration and an August 14 article, Manufacturing Obscurity is a Fate Worse than the Robopocalypse. These articles provide detail on these two questions above, and I highly recommend you read them. Here is some of the information they present. In 2017, U.S. companies lagged behind world leaders in installation of factory robots. In fact, China led the way with their manufacturers buying 138,000 robot units. Our country (33,192) was fourth after Japan (45,566) and South Korea (41,373). The two largest robotic manufacturers in this country are foreign-owned. They manufacture the bulk of robots sold in the U.S. Specifically, they are Swiss-based The U.S. doesn't have a single major homegrown industrial robot manufacturer. According to Hitch, while there are hundreds of robot startups flourishing across the country, this hasn’t translated into large-scale industrial robot manufacturing. What about Jobs? Hitch also cites both a recent Oxford Economics report that predicts automation and robots will displace 1.5 million additional jobs in the United States by 2030 and an Automation Readiness Index that listed the United States had ninth place in how prepared it was in terms of training, education and governmental policies. One of the people interviewed for Hitch’s articles makes an ominous point, saying, “Right now, robots are being fed the worse jobs. It’s only a matter of time before they take the better ones.” It is true that technical colleges are adjusting their curriculums to align with the need for new job skill. The question, though, is whether this will be enough to offset the efforts of foreign governments in prepping their manufacturing workforce for the robotics age. For instance, Germany is providing $78 million in annual cash grants for workforce development and apprenticeships. As Hitch points out, “Robots taking American jobs isn’t the biggest threat; other countries making the workforce of the future is.” Finally, Hitch points out that in this country, it is the small- and mid-sized manufacturing firms that are most lagging behind their foreign counterparts. Since small- and medium-sized manufacturers make up the bulk of most supply chains, this begs the question on how to get U.S. supply-manufacturers to make investments in more modern manufacturing equipment. Economic Un-Development During my career, I’ve played a hand in several supply chain-based economic development initiatives. In fact, for my efforts, I’ve received both state and federal accolades. So I think it’s reasonable to assume that I have some knowledge about what works relative to successful economic development as well as what doesn’t. A September 5 article on IndustryWeek’s partner website, Materials Handling & Logistics, asks, Will Taxing Robots Slow Automation? I can provide a short answer to that question: YES. Especially for this country’s small- and medium-sized supplier-manufacturers that are already lagging in adopting them. The robot tax is pitched as a disincentive to replace human workers with robots and a way of recovering some economic loss from lost jobs. Paul Ericksen's columns are part of IndustryWeek's Supply Chain Initiative. People who read my column know that I am an advocate of our government having skin in the game in economic and workforce development efforts. But in this instance, there could be nothing worse than a robot tax above and beyond what corporations are taxed today. Why? Because the tax would do the opposite of what needs to be done for us to become a worldwide leader in robotic technology. What needs to be done is jumpstarting our nation’s efforts in robotics by encouraging investment in it.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Implementation
1AC Merola 22 [Rossana Merola, Macroeconomist at the Research Department of the International labour Organization (ILO) , former visiting scholar at the Research Department of the Deutsche Bundesbank and the National Bank of Belgium. Rossana holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the Université Catholique de Louvain-la neuve and the University of Rome Tor Vergata, 5-31-2022 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9193369/]
Beside the opinion in favor or against the robot tax, there is however still discussion on how companies should pay the robot tax. A first proposal could be to tax robots themselves, in the amount of the salary paid to the hypothetical displaced human worker. This solution is however extremely complicated to be put in practice, since robots are unlikely to replace human workers in the entire set of their tasks. It is more common that robots take over only some tasks previously performed by humans and hence it is quite difficult to find a one-to-one link between the robot and the displaced worker difficult. Alternatively, another option could be to levy a tax on the use of robots, that is imposing a higher rate of corporate tax for using robots, since companies make higher profits due to the powerful efficiency of robots. This proposal is also complicated to be implemented, because what we see nowadays is a form of “cobotization”, which is a collaboration between robots and human workers to complete a task and jointly contribute to make profits. Therefore, it is not so straightforward to disentangle the profits or value created by the robot from that one created by the human worker. Another proposal is subjecting robots to VAT, since robots can replace humans in the supply of goods or services which are subject to the VAT. To avoid obstacles to the adoption of new technologies and innovation, a simpler approach could be levying a lump-sum tax, payable at the same level by everyone, which would not create distortions in the economy. However, lump-sum taxes present trade-off in terms of equity and distributional effects to be considered. A lump-sum tax would be regressive and bear more on small businesses. Since every business will pay the same amount of robot tax no matter the profits it runs, absorbing the fixed cost of a robot tax would be more arduous for small family businesses than for large companies. Overall, these proposals require international coordination to avoid that income could be taxed twice, at the robot level, in the amount of the imputed salary or higher profits associated to the use of robots, and at the corporation level (Oberson, 2017).
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Implementation
Chand et Al. 21 – Prof. Dr Vikram Chand, LLM, is an Associate Professor at the University of Lausanne, Faculty of Law. He is also the Program Director of the Executive Program in Transfer Pricing. Vikram Chand,* Svetislav Kostić** and Ariene Reis, 2021, “Taxing Artificial Intelligence and Robots: Critical Assessment of Potential Policy Solutions and Recommendation for Alternative Approaches – Sovereign Measure: Education Taxes/Global Measure: Global Education Tax or Planetary Tax,” , HKR-SWY
First, from an effectiveness standpoint, the authors believe that proposals that are dependent on defining AI/robots would lead to a compliance nightmare and even if this hurdle is overcome, governments will find it extremely difficult to enforce the collection of such taxes. For example, if more than 10 million self-driven autonomous vehicles enter into the market (e.g. US market) then, under the proposals that deal with taxing AI/robots as independent taxable subjects or deeming a notional salary in the hands of the owner, we would have to assess taxes with respect to 10 million new taxpayers. In this regard, it could well be possible that owners would be tempted to not disclose the ownership of AI/robots on their tax return. Also, it could be difficult for the tax administration to carry out an audit to understand whether or not a taxpayer uses AI/robots or whether or not an AI/robot is autonomous. Thus, tax collection and control could be a challenge.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Implementation
Mazur 19 – Assistant Professor of Law, SMU Dedman School of Law. Orly Mazur, 2019, “Taxing the Robots,” Pepperdine Law Review, , HKR-SWY
A robot tax also may be subject to significant tax avoidance techniques, thereby limiting its effectiveness at achieving its goals. This is partly because a robot is relatively mobile. Automation of jobs is often created by software that does not require a physical structure, which allows many of these systems to be hosted in the "cloud" or on the internet and to be accessed remotely. 137
In many instances, this makes it possible to move the "robot" to a no- or lowtax jurisdiction.1 3 8 Because a robot tax generally creates a tax at the source (i.e., the location of the robot), in the absence of substantial international tax reform, a company, with sufficient advance planning, can potentially avoid the robot tax altogether. 13 9 Even if a company is unable to relocate a robot, the adoption of a robot tax may result in companies relocating to other jurisdictions that do not impose a robot tax.140 Also, because a robot tax is essentially a tax on a specific type of corporate profits, it would further incentivize the use of aggressive tax planning methods that exist today.' A robot tax is also likely to add more complexity into our tax system. 14 2 With additional complexity, there is an increased risk of tax non-compliance, as companies may not know how much tax they are required to pay, and of enforcement difficulties, as tax authorities may not be able to verify the accuracy of the asserted tax liability.14 3
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---Robotax Bad---Implementation
Kovacev 20 – Robert Kovacev is a Partner in the San Francisco and Washington, D.C. offices of Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP. Robert Kovacev, 2020, “A Taxing Dilemma: Robot Taxes And The Challenges Of Effective Taxation Of Ai, Automation And Robotics In The Fourth Industrial Revolution,” The Ohio State Technology Law Journal, , HKR-SWY
Robot taxes, imposed at any level short of universal global acceptance, gives rise to the potential for tax competition.86 A tax imposed on businesses in San Francisco may simply cause businesses to relocate their robots across the bay; a tax in California may cause moves to Nevada; a tax in the United States may cause moves to Mexico or China.87 This suggests that a global, multilateral solution would ultimately have to be found in order to impose an administrable robot tax. Easier said than done.
The recent “digital tax” debate provides a useful illustration of this problem. One of the hallmarks of the modern economy is the prevalence of multinational corporations whose economic reach extends far beyond their country of origin, or even those countries where they have a physical presence.88 Many goods are tradeable across borders, and many services even more so due to the internet.89 Historically, the lynchpin of international taxation has been that businesses may be taxed in a country only if they have a permanent establishment in that country.90 In the internet era, where goods and services can be ordered online from a company without any presence in the country, many businesses pay little or no tax in countries from which they derive considerable profits.91 Accordingly, the EU and several nations have proposed “digital tax” regimes that would tax the gross receipts or profits earned in jurisdictions where the business has no traditional permanent establishment.92 Discussions at the OECDlevel toward a consensus approach have continued for several years, but agreement seems elusive.93 A cross-border robot tax, imposing a tax related to the use of AI, robotics, and automation outside the taxing jurisdiction, poses the same challenges of lack of international consensus and difficulty of administration and enforcement.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---US-China Tech Dominance
Ding ’23. [ Jeffrey Ding is an Assistant Professor of Political Science at George Washington University. He received his PhD from the University of Oxford and his bachelors degree from the University of Iowa.] “The U.S. May Be Overstating China’s Technological Prowess.” June 7, 2023. https://www.chinafile.com/reporting-opinion/notes-chinafile/us-may-be-overstating-chinas-technological-prowess
China’s technological prowess is frequently invoked by U.S. policymakers hoping to get votes, attention, or enough bipartisan support to pass a bill. Competition with China was a central motivating factor in federal legislation like the CHIPS and Science Act and the Inflation Reduction Act, not to mention the work of the House Select Committee on the Strategic Competition Between the United States and the Chinese Communist Party. “Beating China”—specifically in science and technology development—is a key driver of U.S. governance and, ahead of the 2024 presidential race, elections. George Washington University Assistant Professor of Political Science Jeffrey Ding published a recent article that explains why measuring a state’s scientific and technological power should include not only how many innovations a country can check off, but also the degree to which new technologies are integrated into the economy and society. Ding spoke with Johanna Costigan about his new paper. The following is an edited transcript of their conversation. —Johanna Costigan Johanna Costigan: Can you explain the distinction between innovation capacity and diffusion capacity? Jeffrey Ding: Innovation capacity refers to a state’s ability to pioneer new-to-the world breakthroughs in science and technology. Diffusion capacity refers to a state’s ability to spread those innovations across a wide range of productive processes in an economy. I argue in my paper that we tend to gravitate toward measures of innovation and pay insufficient attention to diffusion. How did diffusion occur in the second Industrial Revolution in the U.S., and why does that example show diffusion is an essential metric? In the late 19th century, the U.S. was not at the forefront of science and technology—our best and brightest went to Germany to study. Even though other nations were leading the way in fields like chemical engineering, the U.S. was much stronger in terms of diffusion capacity; it was better at applying those uses across a wide range of processes. If you only looked at which countries were winning the most Nobel Prizes or had the most advanced research institutes, you would be underestimating the scientific and technological prowess of the U.S. Assessments that are more oriented around diffusion capacity would have predicted the U.S. to sustain its economic rise and become the preeminent economic power. Back then, there wasn’t a global innovation index, but the case study was to go back and see if we rank different countries based on this, only using the innovation indicators provides an incorrect view. Diffusion is central to a state’s ability to convert science and technology into economic strength. You write that academic research in the U.S. was more closely tied to commerce than it was in Europe, which allowed American breakthroughs to spread more rapidly. Given the close relationship between government and industry in the PRC, why might that not be the case in contemporary China? The government acts as a bottleneck within China’s scitech ecosystem, stifling organic industry-university collaborations. A lot of the research happens at government institutions as opposed to corporate-sponsored R&D [research and development]. The channels between universities and industry are not as robust, so some of that has to do with surrounding legal regimes and whether university research can be translated into a startup company. Unlike China, the U.S. has a really good set of legal rules that enable that to happen. But Chinese companies are trying to address this; more AI companies, for example, are trying to set up labs in universities to foster that. But if you look at co-authorship rates in publications on AI (papers that have at least one author from a university and one from industry), those rates are very low in China compared to countries in Europe and the U.S. A lot of the story here is just the vestiges of central planning that are still in China’s scitech ecosystem and that just don’t foster the organic fast-acting processing that is required for diffusion. How would you characterize American assessments of China’s science and technology power? What’s missing? The consensus significantly overstates China’s scitech capability. One recent example from the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI), which while it is not American has been used to justify more extreme China policy, says China is leading the U.S. in 37 of 44 considered technologies, all of which were focused on innovation. (I don’t even think that conclusion is accurate based just on innovation.) It reflects the United States’ obsession with innovation capacity when it comes to assessing scitech power. Even if you go back and review Biden’s first remarks to Congress, he argued that China is closing in quickly and that it’s a race to see who can dominate new innovations in these technologies. The contribution of my paper is partly to argue that assumptions about innovation shape the perception that China is improving rapidly and has already taken over the U.S. in some critical technologies. Reorienting ourselves to a diffusion-centric framework is an important first step to having a more balanced understanding of what’s happening in China’s scitech ecosystem. Members of the Biden administration like Jake Sullivan have described moves like export controls aimed at China as “narrowly focused on technology that could tilt the military balance.” What do you think of that depiction, and how do judgments of relative military strength fit into the diffusion/innovation breakdown? When it comes to competition with China over military AI applications, I think the Biden administration’s approach is overly preoccupied with maintaining a lead in innovation capacity. Their theory of victory, in my view, seems to be all about preventing China from building the biggest and baddest autonomous weapon, trained on the largest amount of data using the most amount of computing power. If the history of military electrification is a useful guide for how AI will affect the military balance of power, as I argue in a recent article, then AI’s most substantial impact on military power will take decades as advances diffuse across a broad range of applications in logistics, decryption, targeting, and intelligence. Ensuring that the military is able to tap into a broad base of AI engineering talent is a more effective route to ensuring that AI’s effect on the military balance will favor the U.S. You write: “A rebalanced evaluation of China’s potential for S&T leadership requires looking beyond multinational corporations like Huawei, first-tier cities like Beijing, and flashy R&D numbers to the humble undertaking of diffusion.” Why do you think such limited analyses are tempting? Why are they dangerous? Firstly, it’s just a lot harder to get diffusion capacity indicators. Many metrics of innovation, like government R&D funding indicators, patent rates, and publication numbers are all tracked, whereas it takes more work to get indicators of diffusion capacity. Finding systematic and reliable numbers of diffusion capacity is crucial. And misleading assessments carry a few dangers. Having an accurate sense of where you stand provides a solid foundation for science and technology policy. There is something to be said about having a true—or truer—understanding of the world. Additionally, overestimating China’s scitech capabilities may lead the U.S. to engage in more reckless policies and provide more momentum for containment-type measures that backfire on both sides. It could lead to the mentality we saw in the Cold War where the U.S. was concerned about the missile gap with the Soviet Union that turned out to be illusory and resulted in wasted expenditures, spiraling fears, and an arms race that put the two superpowers on a path toward conflict. There are people in the U.S. government who probably agree with me in that a lot of assessments on China’s tech development are overhyped, but they think it’s necessary to pump up China’s prowess in order to motivate certain policies. But that could easily backfire and is a dangerous precedent to set. While that justification might in some cases be used to make sound decisions, in other cases it could be used to enact dangerous policies.
Chinese technological innovation good—spurs competition and economic growth. Jin ’23. [ Keyu Jin is an associate professor at the London School of Economics.] “The U.S. Tech Industry Needs China.” May 16, 2023. https://time.com/6280004/us-tech-china/
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Military Automation High Now
Webb 18 [Whitney Webb is a professional writer, researcher and journalist since 2016. She has written for several websites and, from 2017 to 2020, was a staff writer and senior investigative reporter for MintPress News. She currently writes for her own outlet Unlimited Hangout and contributes to The Last American Vagabond and MintPress News, “The U.S. Military Will Have More Robots Than Humans by 2025,” MintPress News, 2-19-2018, https://www.mintpressnews.com/the-u-s-military-will-have-more-robots-than-humans-by-2025/237725/, accessed 7-17-2023, HKR-SWY]
WASHINGTON – While cyborg soldiers and fully automated weapons have long been fodder for futuristic sci-fi thrillers, they are now a reality and, if the Pentagon gets its way, will soon become the norm in the U.S. military. As Defense One reported last Thursday, the Army had just concluded a live-fire exercise using a remote-controlled ground combat vehicle complete with a fully automated machine gun. The demonstration marked the first time that the Army has used a ground robot providing fire in tandem with human troops in a military exercise and, as Defense One noted, “it won’t be the last.”
Indeed, last week’s exercise represents just the latest step in the Pentagon’s relatively quiet tip-toe into converting the U.S. Armed Forces to a machine-majority force. Faced with low recruitment and an increased demand for soldiers, the Department of Defense is seeking to solve that problem altogether while also increasing the military’s firepower and force in combat.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Military Automation High Now
Gosselin-Malo 23 [Elisabeth Gosselin-Malo is a freelance security and defence reporter. She has been published several times internationally including for the Globe and Mail, Shephard Media, the Aspen Institute, and other media networks. She joined the Italian Institute for International Political Studies (ISPI) working as an Events and Conference Assistant in charge of Italy’s largest international conference Rome Mediterranean Dialogues. She is a Research Fellow at the Italian research centre TheSquare where most of her work has focused on drones and European defense. She completed her Master’s degree in Terrorism and Political Violence at the University of St-Andrews in Scotland, “The military robots are coming — at some point,” Defense News, 7-6-2023, https://www.defensenews.com/unmanned/2023/07/06/the-military-robots-are-coming-at-some-point/, accessed 7-17-2023, HKR-SWY]
LÄSNA, Estonia — An hour from Estonia’s capital Tallinn, on a hot day in late June, a robot-like vehicle glides over dense vegetation, clearing sandy and bumpy terrain with a mechanical hum. It negotiates through the trees of a small forest, revealing a team of operators in tow who warn their fellow human observers to keep their distance.
The platform is the THeMIS 4.5, and it belongs to Milrem Robotics, a 10-year-old company founded in Estonia and bought by the United Arab Emirates’ Edge Group this year that now competes with big players in the unmanned ground vehicle (UGV) market. Standing at a population of just 1.3 million inhabitants, the Baltic nation has become a hub of innovation for UGV technology over the last few years.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Military Automation High Now
Wong 22 [Andy Wong is a Joint (Hons) Politics and History graduate from the University of Hull. He specialises in Asia-Pacific history and international geopolitical issues, as well as maritime and naval strategy, with an interest in nuclear warfare. He is currently pursuing a Masters in International Security at the University of Bath., “Uncrewed Drones in Naval Warfare: A Force Multiplier?,” Wavell Room, 12-2-2022, https://wavellroom.com/2022/12/02/drones-the-future-of-maritime-warfare/, accessed 7-17-2023, HKR-SWY]
Uncrewed drones: better kit, cheaper costs and more useful than ever
In recent years the idea of leveraging on uncrewed drone technologies for use in naval warfare has been increasing in credibility and varieties. This is in no small part due to the proliferation of such drone technologies driving down costs, as well as maturing technology components and platforms allowing for greater reliability and stability for such platforms.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---Military Automation High Now
Dawes 23 [James Dawes is the author of The Novel of Human Rights (Harvard University Press, 2018); Evil Men (Harvard University Press, 2013), winner of the International Human Rights Book Award; That the World May Know: Bearing Witness to Atrocity (Harvard University Press, 2007), Independent Publisher Book Award Finalist; and The Language of War (Harvard University Press, 2002). He has written for or appeared as the feature guest on media outlets ranging from National Public Radio, the BBC, and Bulgarian National Radio to the Boston Globe, the Chronicle of Higher Education, and CNN.com. He was a Junior Fellow at the Society of Fellows, Harvard University. He received his Ph.D. in English Literature from Harvard University and his M. Phil. from Cambridge University, “Killer robots are the future of warfare and the 'inevitable next step' in Russia's long, bloody invasion of Ukraine,” Fortune, 1-25-2023, https://fortune.com/2023/02/21/killer-robots-a-i-future-warfare-russia-ukraine-invasion/, accessed 7-17-2023, HKR-SWY]
The U.S. military is intensifying its commitment to the development and use of autonomous weapons, as confirmed by an update to a Department of Defense directive. The update, released Jan. 25, 2023, is the first in a decade to focus on artificial intelligence autonomous weapons. It follows a related implementation plan released by NATO on Oct. 13, 2022, that is aimed at preserving the alliance’s “technological edge” in what are sometimes called “killer robots.”
Both announcements reflect a crucial lesson militaries around the world have learned from recent combat operations in Ukraine and Nagorno-Karabakh: Weaponized artificial intelligence is the future of warfare.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---General Automation High Now
Ulla 23 (Zabi Ulla leads the The HyperSense Product Line Management team at Subex and has 16+ years of experience with a data science background and a focus on AI and how it effects business. “The Future is Now: Why Your Business Needs to Embrace (and Implement) AI Adoption”. HyperSense. 5/20/23. . Accessed 7/20/23)//EKW
Today AI’s impact and potential value are undebatable. Many businesses have already evaluated and experimented with AI in various forms. To the extent that applications of AI are actively investigated in healthcare, recruitment, law, and government. However, the adoption rate varies across industries and companies, but AI is becoming increasingly prevalent in the business world. However, AI boost and bust cycles are seen over time, which makes potential adopters wary. On one side, there are greater success stories of AI implementation, especially within the technology and healthcare domain. There are other traditional businesses where AI adoption is much slower than expected. Technology adoption is an ongoing process of operational use of technology, according to Neumann, Guirguis & Steiner. I prefer this definition because it clearly defines adoption as not being achieved at a single point in time. It is also emphasized for the operational success of AI, especially in the business context of AI adoption. Any technology adoption depends on not just technological advancement but also external factors such as social, economic, and environmental influences. Technological advancement, for instance, is the ease of use, efficiency, value drivers, etc.; external factors are social, economic, and environmental factors. All these factors are unequivocally applicable to AI today, evidently enforcing their effects on us today, creating an environment that demands either adoption or failure. Given the potential impact and value of AI, enterprise AI practitioners and managers need to approach adoption in a thoughtful and strategic manner. This may involve carefully evaluating business needs, identifying appropriate use cases, and considering the ethical and social implications of AI adoption. By focusing on operational success and understanding the broader contextual factors influencing AI adoption, businesses can navigate the potential challenges and maximize the benefits of this transformative technology.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---General Automation High Now
Watters 23 (Ashley Watters, Journalist covering tech and AI. “30+ Artifical Intelligence Statistics for 2023”. CompTIA. January 13, 2023. . Accessed 7/20/23)//EKW
Artificial intelligence is a hot topic for businesses. AI capabilities are expanding the possibilities for how businesses approach real-time engagement with their customers, manage their operations and ensure business continuity through the pandemic. As the technology advances, companies are finding new ways to innovate and expand. Here are some artificial intelligence statistics to help you understand AI usage in 2023. The State of AI in Business Everyone loves to talk about AI and the potential for business growth and enhancement—but what’s the general outlook for business use? 35% of companies are using AI and 42% of companies are exploring AI for its implementation in the future, according to a TechJury article 91.5% of leading businesses invest in AI on an ongoing basis Gartner also tells us that customer satisfaction is expected to grow by 25% by 2023 in organization that use AI IT analyst firm, Info-Tech Research Group reports that 44% of private sector companies plan to invest in AI systems in 2023 Overall, there is a widespread adoption of AI in business, but most companies aren’t using it for world domination, but rather to automate processes, enhance customer service and personalization, increase output, and analyze data. Overall, businesses are trying to obtain a competitive advantage.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---General Automation High Now
McKinsey 22 (McKinsey & Company, McKinsey is the company behind QuantumBlack Labs is where technologists, designers, and product managers build cutting-edge tools and assets that reduce risk and accelerate impact at every stage of the AI transformation journey. “The State of AI in 2022- and a half decade in review”. QuantumBlack by McKinsey. December 6, 2022. . Accessed 7/20/23)//EKW
Adoption has more than doubled since 2017, though the proportion of organizations using AI1 has plateaued between 50 and 60 percent for the past few years. A set of companies seeing the highest financial returns from AI continue to pull ahead of competitors. The results show these leaders making larger investments in AI, engaging in increasingly advanced practices known to enable scale and faster AI development, and showing signs of faring better in the tight market for AI talent. On talent, for the first time, we looked closely at AI hiring and upskilling. The data show that there is significant room to improve diversity on AI teams, and, consistent with other studies, diverse teams correlate with outstanding performance. Table of Contents Five years in review: AI adoption, impact, and spend Mind the gap: AI leaders pulling ahead AI talent tales: New hot roles, continued diversity woes About the research 1. Five years in review: AI adoption, impact, and spend This marks the fifth consecutive year we’ve conducted research globally on AI’s role in business, and we have seen shifts over this period. First, AI adoption has more than doubled.1 In 2017, 20 percent of respondents reported adopting AI in at least one business area, whereas today, that figure stands at 50 percent, though it peaked higher in 2019 at 58 percent. While AI adoption globally is 2.5x higher today than in 2017, it has leveled off over the past few years. We strive to provide individuals with disabilities equal access to our website. If you would like information about this content we will be happy to work with you. Please email us at: McKinsey_Website_Accessibility@mckinsey.com Meanwhile, the average number of AI capabilities that organizations use, such as natural-language generation and computer vision, has also doubled—from 1.9 in 2018 to 3.8 in 2022. Among these capabilities, robotic process automation and computer vision have remained the most commonly deployed each year, while natural-language text understanding has advanced from the middle of the pack in 2018 to the front of the list just behind computer vision. Responses show an increasing number of AI capabilities embedded in organizations over the past five years. We strive to provide individuals with disabilities equal access to our website. If you would like information about this content we will be happy to work with you. Please email us at: McKinsey_Website_Accessibility@mckinsey.com The top use cases, however, have remained relatively stable: optimization of service operations has taken the top spot each of the past four years. We strive to provide individuals with disabilities equal access to our website. If you would like information about this content we will be happy to work with you. Please email us at: McKinsey_Website_Accessibility@mckinsey.com Second, the level of investment in AI has increased alongside its rising adoption. For example, five years ago, 40 percent of respondents at organizations using AI reported more than 5 percent of their digital budgets went to AI, whereas now more than half of respondents report that level of investment. Going forward, 63 percent of respondents say they expect their organizations’ investment to increase over the next three years.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs KM UBI VAT › Case › 1NC---UQ---General Automation High Now
Jaffri 22 (Afraz Jaffri is a Research Director at Gartner, a website focused on information technology and AI adoption, where he focuses on Analytics, Data Science and AI. He advises Data and Analytics leaders on making the most from their investments in modern data science, machine learning and analytics platforms. “What’s New in Artificial Intelligence from the 2022 Gartner Hype Cycle”. Garter. September 15, 2022. . Accessed 7/19/23)//EKW
“Notably, the AI Hype Cycle is full of innovations expected to drive high or even transformational benefits,” says Afraz Jaffri, Director Analyst at Gartner. “Pay particular attention to innovations expected to hit mainstream adoption in two to five years, including composite AI, decision intelligence and edge AI. Early adoption of these innovations can drive significant competitive advantage and business value and ease problems associated with the fragility of AI models.” AI innovations fall into four categories The wide range of AI innovations is expected to impact people and processes within and outside an enterprise context, making them important to understand for many stakeholders, from business leaders to the enterprise engineering teams tasked with deploying and operationalizing AI systems. Data and analytics (D&A) leaders have the most to gain, however, from using the Hype Cycle outlook to craft their AI strategies for the future and use technologies that offer high impact in the present. The AI innovations on the Hype Cycle reflect complementary and sometimes conflicting priorities across four main categories: Data-centric AI Model-centric AI Applications-centric AI Human-centric AI Data-centric AI The AI community has traditionally focused on improving outcomes from AI solutions by tweaking the AI models themselves, but data-centric AI shifts the focus toward enhancing and enriching the data used to train the algorithms. In addressing AI-specific data considerations, data-centric AI disrupts traditional data management, but organizations that invest in AI at scale will evolve to preserve evergreen classical data-management ideas and extend them to AI in two ways: Add capabilities necessary for convenient AI development by an AI-focused audience that is not familiar with data management. Use AI to improve and augment evergreen classics of data governance, persistence, integration and data quality. Innovations in data-centric AI include synthetic data, knowledge graphs, data labeling and annotation. Download Now: A Framework for Capturing the Business Value of Artificial Intelligence Synthetic data, for example, is a class of data that is artificially generated rather than obtained from direct observations of the real world. Data can be generated using different methods, such as statistically rigorous sampling from real data, semantic approaches and generative adversarial networks or by creating simulation scenarios where models and processes interact to create completely new datasets of events. Adoption is increasing across various industries, along with use in computer vision and natural language applications, but Gartner predicts a massive increase in adoption as synthetic data: These innovations go beyond everyday AI techniques already being used to add intelligence to previously static business applications, devices and productivity tools. Pay early attention to innovations expected to hit mainstream adoption in two to five years, including composite AI, decision intelligence and edge AI.