Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › BCA Bad

CBA is economic imperialism; breaks Paris Agreement

Ravikumar 20 (Arvind, Arvind Ravikumar directs the sustainable energy development lab at Harrisburg University of Science and Technology in Pennsylvania. His group studies US energy and climate policy and equitable transitions in the developing world. PhD and MA, Electrical Engineering, Princeton University, 2015. MSc, Physics, Birla Institute of Technology and Science, 2010. BE, Electrical Engineering, Birla Institute of Technology and Science, 2008. “Carbon border taxes are unjust”, MIT Technology Review, July 27, 2020, , Accessed July 16, 2023) // CD

The argument in favor is that carbon border adjustments will nudge developing countries to reduce emissions and level the playing field for local firms that develop low-carbon products. This is not just a European idea—several US organizations and former Democratic presidential candidates, including Senator Elizabeth Warren, have proposed the idea of carbon border adjustments as a means for the US to lead on international climate action. Although reasonable at face value, unilateral carbon border adjustments merely represent the latest form of economic imperialism and are antithetical to the principles of equity enshrined in the Paris Agreement (pdf). Article 2 clearly states that the agreement “will be implemented to reflect equity and the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities.” Without buy-in from countries like India and China, carbon border adjustments risk becoming a climate-based sanctions regime. A short history lesson can be helpful. That China, India, and other developing countries rely on fossil fuels to power their economies is not an accident. These growth models are a consequence of post–World War global dominance by the West in economic, political, and financial spheres.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › BCA Bad

Carbon Border Tax would hurt developing countries economies

Durántez and Obern 22—Calli Obern is the director of public policy and stakeholder engagement at Capture6, a research fellow at escospherics, and a research assistant at Stanford Law, holds a M.A. in International Policy from Stanford and a B.A. in Diplomacy and World Affairs from Occidental College, Miriam González Durántez is an international trade lawyer and guest lecturer at Stanford University, holds a M.A. in European Policy from the College of Europe, and a SAM specificed in the Middle East from Oxford University, 2022 (“The EU’s Carbon Border Tax Could Hurt Developing Countries,” Project Syndicate, available online at , accessed 07-16-2023) //LS

The CBAM would tax imported goods sold in EU markets on the basis of their carbon content (the emissions required to produce them), which depends on their material and energy inputs. The proposed levy is intended to address so-called carbon leakage, which occurs when businesses in the EU move production to non-member countries with less stringent emissions rules.

In other words, Europe would no longer ignore the climate effects of foreign goods. But while the measure could help to reduce emissions and level the competitive playing field for EU-based firms, the trade protectionism that it entails risks hurting developing countries.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › 1NC – BCA Non-Unique

Squo solves BCA — The EU’s carbon border tax is already promoting follow on

Durántez and Obern 22—Calli Obern is the director of public policy and stakeholder engagement at Capture6, a research fellow at escospherics, and a research assistant at Stanford Law, holds a M.A. in International Policy from Stanford and a B.A. in Diplomacy and World Affairs from Occidental College, Miriam González Durántez is an international trade lawyer and guest lecturer at Stanford University, holds a M.A. in European Policy from the College of Europe, and a SAM specificed in the Middle East from Oxford University, 2022 ("The EU’s Carbon Border Tax Could Hurt Developing Countries," Project Syndicate, available online at https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/eu-carbon-border-tax-could-hurt-developing-countries-by-miriam-gonzalez-durantez-and-calli-obern-2022-06, accessed 07-16-2023)

The CBAM will initially apply to the highest-emitting industries most at risk of leakage – iron and steel, cement, fertilizers, aluminum, and electricity generation – and will likely be expanded to other sectors in the coming years. Currently, EU-made products in these industries are taxed under the domestic carbon price, but those from outside the bloc are not. If a country already has a domestic carbon price, the border tax will be lowered or waived; this is meant to encourage countries to tax carbon in their own markets. Those that cannot or will not institute a carbon tax will have to pay the full levy.

The EU tax will be phased in over the next four years. By 2023, importers will be required to report emissions embedded in the goods they import, though the tax on those emissions will not be imposed until 2026. The €1 billion ($1.1 billion) of annual revenue expected from the CBAM, as well as the €9 billion in annual revenue expected from the EU Emissions Trading System from 2023-2030 and taxes on multinational corporations, will support the Union’s €750 billion COVID-19 pandemic recovery fund. These new sources of revenue will embed EU priorities – including the green transition – in the bloc’s budget for the first time.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › 1NC – Emission Reductions Fail

Cutting carbon doesn’t solve; Pushes past tipping points

SF 22 (Study Finds, Study Finds sets out to find new research that speaks to mass audiences — without all the scientific jargon, “Slashing carbon dioxide emissions alone can’t stop climate change, study warns ”, Study Finds, May 24, 2022, , Accessed July 16, 2022) //CD

WASHINGTON — Cutting carbon dioxide emissions alone won’t be enough to avert catastrophic climate change, according to the new study. Researchers say the world must tackle rising emissions of lesser-known toxic pollutants if global temperatures are to remain at safe levels. The pollutants include methane, hydrofluorocarbon refrigerants, black carbon soot, ground-level ozone smog, and nitrous oxide. The team, including researchers from Georgetown, Texas A&M, Duke, and UC San Diego, believe quickly cutting carbon emissions alone won’t hold global temperatures at 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels — a threshold which scientists consider safe for humanity. If temperatures rise above that level, however, the world could cross hazardous and irreversible “tipping points,” causing huge damage to the environment. In fact, cutting carbon dioxide emissions alone is unlikely to stop global temperatures rising higher than two degrees above pre-industrial levels. The study found other gases contribute almost as much to global warming as carbon dioxide. Most of them last only a short time in the atmosphere, which means cutting them slows warming faster than any other mitigation strategy. Some climate change strategies make things worse! Until now, the importance of these non-carbon dioxide pollutants has been underappreciated by scientists and policymakers alike and largely neglected in efforts to combat climate change. Recent reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change say cutting fossil fuel emissions — the main source of carbon dioxide — by decarbonizing the energy system and shifting to clean energy, in isolation, makes global warming worse in the short term. This is because burning fossil fuels also emit sulphate aerosols, which act to cool the climate – and these levels drop along with the carbon dioxide when switching to clean energy. These cooling sulphates fall out of the atmosphere within days or weeks, which leads to overall warming over the next decade. The new study, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), states that focusing exclusively on reducing fossil fuel emissions could result in “weak, near term warming.” This could cause temperatures to exceed the 1.5-degree threshold by 2035 and the 2-degree threshold by 2050. In contrast, a strategy to slash emissions of both carbon dioxide and other pollutants would help the world limit temperatures to “well below” two degrees above pre-industrial levels and would boost our chances of staying below 1.5 degrees of warming. The researchers believe their plan to tackle both types of pollutant offers humanity “the only hope” of making it to 2050 without triggering irreversible and catastrophic climate change.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › 1NC – Warming Inevitable

We Need To Give Up On Climate Change (pretty much idk how to tag this)

Franzen 19 (Jonathan, high honors from , receiving a degree in German, he studied abroad in Germany during the 1979–80 academic year with , “What If We Stopped Pretending? ”, The New Yorker, September 8, 2019, , Accessed July 16, 2023) // CD

here is infinite hope,” Kafka tells us, “only not for us.” This is a fittingly mystical epigram from a writer whose characters strive for ostensibly reachable goals and, tragically or amusingly, never manage to get any closer to them. But it seems to me, in our rapidly darkening world, that the converse of Kafka’s quip is equally true: There is no hope, except for us. I’m talking, of course, about climate change. The struggle to rein in global carbon emissions and keep the planet from melting down has the feel of Kafka’s fiction. The goal has been clear for thirty years, and despite earnest efforts we’ve made essentially no progress toward reaching it. Today, the scientific evidence verges on irrefutable. If you’re younger than sixty, you have a good chance of witnessing the radical destabilization of life on earth—massive crop failures, apocalyptic fires, imploding economies, epic flooding, hundreds of millions of refugees fleeing regions made uninhabitable by extreme heat or permanent drought. If you’re under thirty, you’re all but guaranteed to witness it. If you care about the planet, and about the people and animals who live on it, there are two ways to think about this. You can keep on hoping that catastrophe is preventable, and feel ever more frustrated or enraged by the world’s inaction. Or you can accept that disaster is coming, and begin to rethink what it means to have hope. Even at this late date, expressions of unrealistic hope continue to abound. Hardly a day seems to pass without my reading that it’s time to “roll up our sleeves” and “save the planet”; that the problem of climate change can be “solved” if we summon the collective will. Although this message was probably still true in 1988, when the science became fully clear, we’ve emitted as much atmospheric carbon in the past thirty years as we did in the previous two centuries of industrialization. The facts have changed, but somehow the message stays the same. Psychologically, this denial makes sense. Despite the outrageous fact that I’ll soon be dead forever, I live in the present, not the future. Given a choice between an alarming abstraction (death) and the reassuring evidence of my senses (breakfast!), my mind prefers to focus on the latter. The planet, too, is still marvelously intact, still basically normal—seasons changing, another election year coming, new comedies on Netflix—and its impending collapse is even harder to wrap my mind around than death. Other kinds of apocalypse, whether religious or thermonuclear or asteroidal, at least have the binary neatness of dying: one moment the world is there, the next moment it’s gone forever. Climate apocalypse, by contrast, is messy. It will take the form of increasingly severe crises compounding chaotically until civilization begins to fray. Things will get very bad, but maybe not too soon, and maybe not for everyone. Maybe not for me. Some of the denial, however, is more willful. The evil of the Republican Party’s position on climate science is well known, but denial is entrenched in progressive politics, too, or at least in its rhetoric. The Green New Deal, the blueprint for some of the most substantial proposals put forth on the issue, is still framed as our last chance to avert catastrophe and save the planet, by way of gargantuan renewable-energy projects. Many of the groups that support those proposals deploy the language of “stopping” climate change, or imply that there’s still time to prevent it. Unlike the political right, the left prides itself on listening to climate scientists, who do indeed allow that catastrophe is theoretically avertable. But not everyone seems to be listening carefully. The stress falls on the word theoretically. Our atmosphere and oceans can absorb only so much heat before climate change, intensified by various feedback loops, spins completely out of control. Some scientists and policymakers fear that we’re in danger of passing this point of no return if the global mean temperature rises by more than two degrees Celsius (maybe more, but also maybe less). The I.P.C.C.—the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change—tells us that, to limit the rise to less than two degrees, we not only need to reverse the trend of the past three decades. We need to approach zero net emissions, globally, in the next three decades. This is, to say the least, a tall order. It also assumes that you trust the I.P.C.C.’s calculations. New research, described last month in Scientific American, demonstrates that climate scientists, far from exaggerating the threat of climate change, have underestimated its pace and severity. To project the rise in the global mean temperature, scientists rely on complicated atmospheric modelling. They take a host of variables and run them through supercomputers to generate, say, ten thousand different simulations for the coming century, in order to make a “best” prediction of the rise in temperature. When a scientist predicts a rise of two degrees Celsius, she’s merely naming a number about which she’s very confident: the rise will be at least two degrees. The rise might, in fact, be far higher. As a non-scientist, I do my own kind of modelling. I run various future scenarios through my brain, apply the constraints of human psychology and political reality, take note of the relentless rise in global energy consumption (thus far, the carbon savings provided by renewable energy have been more than offset by consumer demand), and count the scenarios in which collective action averts catastrophe. The scenarios, which I draw from the prescriptions of policymakers and activists, share certain necessary conditions. The first condition is that every one of the world’s major polluting countries institute draconian conservation measures, shut down much of its energy and transportation infrastructure, and completely retool its economy. According to a recent paper in Nature, the carbon emissions from existing global infrastructure, if operated through its normal lifetime, will exceed our entire emissions “allowance”—the further gigatons of carbon that can be released without crossing the threshold of catastrophe. (This estimate does not include the thousands of new energy and transportation projects already planned or under construction.) To stay within that allowance, a top-down intervention needs to happen not only in every country but throughout every country. Making New York City a green utopia will not avail if Texans keep pumping oil and driving pickup trucks. The actions taken by these countries must also be the right ones. Vast sums of government money must be spent without wasting it and without lining the wrong pockets. Here it’s useful to recall the Kafkaesque joke of the European Union’s biofuel mandate, which served to accelerate the deforestation of Indonesia for palm-oil plantations, and the American subsidy of ethanol fuel, which turned out to benefit no one but corn farmers. Finally, overwhelming numbers of human beings, including millions of government-hating Americans, need to accept high taxes and severe curtailment of their familiar life styles without revolting. They must accept the reality of climate change and have faith in the extreme measures taken to combat it. They can’t dismiss news they dislike as fake. They have to set aside nationalism and class and racial resentments. They have to make sacrifices for distant threatened nations and distant future generations. They have to be permanently terrified by hotter summers and more frequent natural disasters, rather than just getting used to them. Every day, instead of thinking about breakfast, they have to think about death. Call me a pessimist or call me a humanist, but I don’t see human nature fundamentally changing anytime soon. I can run ten thousand scenarios through my model, and in not one of them do I see the two-degree target being met. To judge from recent opinion polls, which show that a majority of Americans (many of them Republican) are pessimistic about the planet’s future, and from the success of a book like David Wallace-Wells’s harrowing “The Uninhabitable Earth,” which was released this year, I’m not alone in having reached this conclusion. But there continues to be a reluctance to broadcast it. Some climate activists argue that if we publicly admit that the problem can’t be solved, it will discourage people from taking any ameliorative action at all. This seems to me not only a patronizing calculation but an ineffectual one, given how little progress we have to show for it to date. The activists who make it remind me of the religious leaders who fear that, without the promise of eternal salvation, people won’t bother to behave well. In my experience, nonbelievers are no less loving of their neighbors than believers. And so I wonder what might happen if, instead of denying reality, we told ourselves the truth. First of all, even if we can no longer hope to be saved from two degrees of warming, there’s still a strong practical and ethical case for reducing carbon emissions. In the long run, it probably makes no difference how badly we overshoot two degrees; once the point of no return is passed, the world will become self-transforming. In the shorter term, however, half measures are better than no measures. Halfway cutting our emissions would make the immediate effects of warming somewhat less severe, and it would somewhat postpone the point of no return. The most terrifying thing about climate change is the speed at which it’s advancing, the almost monthly shattering of temperature records. If collective action resulted in just one fewer devastating hurricane, just a few extra years of relative stability, it would be a goal worth pursuing. In fact, it would be worth pursuing even if it had no effect at all. To fail to conserve a finite resource when conservation measures are available, to needlessly add carbon to the atmosphere when we know very well what carbon is doing to it, is simply wrong. Although the actions of one individual have zero effect on the climate, this doesn’t mean that they’re meaningless. Each of us has an ethical choice to make. During the Protestant Reformation, when “end times” was merely an idea, not the horribly concrete thing it is today, a key doctrinal question was whether you should perform good works because it will get you into Heaven, or whether you should perform them simply because they’re good—because, while Heaven is a question mark, you know that this world would be better if everyone performed them. I can respect the planet, and care about the people with whom I share it, without believing that it will save me. More than that, a false hope of salvation can be actively harmful. If you persist in believing that catastrophe can be averted, you commit yourself to tackling a problem so immense that it needs to be everyone’s overriding priority forever. One result, weirdly, is a kind of complacency: by voting for green candidates, riding a bicycle to work, avoiding air travel, you might feel that you’ve done everything you can for the only thing worth doing. Whereas, if you accept the reality that the planet will soon overheat to the point of threatening civilization, there’s a whole lot more you should be doing. Our resources aren’t infinite. Even if we invest much of them in a longest-shot gamble, reducing carbon emissions in the hope that it will save us, it’s unwise to invest all of them. Every billion dollars spent on high-speed trains, which may or may not be suitable for North America, is a billion not banked for disaster preparedness, reparations to inundated countries, or future humanitarian relief. Every renewable-energy mega-project that destroys a living ecosystem—the “green” energy development now occurring in Kenya’s national parks, the giant hydroelectric projects in Brazil, the construction of solar farms in open spaces, rather than in settled areas—erodes the resilience of a natural world already fighting for its life. Soil and water depletion, overuse of pesticides, the devastation of world fisheries—collective will is needed for these problems, too, and, unlike the problem of carbon, they’re within our power to solve. As a bonus, many low-tech conservation actions (restoring forests, preserving grasslands, eating less meat) can reduce our carbon footprint as effectively as massive industrial changes. All-out war on climate change made sense only as long as it was winnable. Once you accept that we’ve lost it, other kinds of action take on greater meaning. Preparing for fires and floods and refugees is a directly pertinent example. But the impending catastrophe heightens the urgency of almost any world-improving action. In times of increasing chaos, people seek protection in tribalism and armed force, rather than in the rule of law, and our best defense against this kind of dystopia is to maintain functioning democracies, functioning legal systems, functioning communities. In this respect, any movement toward a more just and civil society can now be considered a meaningful climate action. Securing fair elections is a climate action. Combatting extreme wealth inequality is a climate action. Shutting down the hate machines on social media is a climate action. Instituting humane immigration policy, advocating for racial and gender equality, promoting respect for laws and their enforcement, supporting a free and independent press, ridding the country of assault weapons—these are all meaningful climate actions. To survive rising temperatures, every system, whether of the natural world or of the human world, will need to be as strong and healthy as we can make it.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Warming Advantage › 1NC – Warming Inevitable

Global Warming Can’t Be Stopped

Rice 20 (Doyle, Master Degree in American/United States Studies/Civilization from University of Massachusetts Boston, Bachelors in Art History, Criticism and Conservation from Oberlin, “'Past a point of no return': Reducing greenhouse gas emissions to zero still won't stop global warming, study says ”,USA Today , November 12, 2020, , Accessed July 16, 2023) //CD

The scientists modeled the effect of greenhouse gas emission reductions on changes in the Earth's climate from 1850 to 2500 and created projections of global temperature and sea level rises. "According to our models, humanity is beyond the point of no return when it comes to halting the melting of permafrost using greenhouse gas cuts as the single tool," lead author Jorgen Randers, a professor emeritus of climate strategy at the BI Norwegian Business School, told . "If we want to stop this melting process we must do something in addition – for example, suck carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere and store it underground, and make Earth's surface brighter," Randers said. Scientists are seeing an 'acceleration of pandemics': The study said that by the year 2500, the planet's temperatures will be about 5.4 degrees Fahrenheit warmer than they were in 1850. And sea levels will be roughly 8 feet higher. The authors suggest that global temperatures could continue to increase after human-caused greenhouse gas emissions have been reduced as the continued melting of Arctic ice and carbon-containing permafrost increase water vapor, methane and carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The melting of Arctic ice and permafrost also would reduce the area of ice reflecting heat and light from the sun. According to the study, to prevent the authors' projected temperature and sea-level rises, all human-caused greenhouse gas emissions would have had to be reduced to zero between 1960 and 1970. To prevent global temperature and sea level rises after greenhouse gas emissions have ceased, and to limit the potentially catastrophic effects on Earth's ecosystems and human society, at least 33 gigatons of carbon dioxide would need to be removed from the atmosphere each year from 2020 onward through carbon capture and storage methods, according to the authors. That's roughly the total amount of carbon dioxide the global fossil fuel industry emitted in 2018, according to . One expert, Penn State University meteorologist Michael Mann, told USA TODAY that he was skeptical of the computer model used in the study: "The climate model they have used is a very low complexity model. It doesn’t realistically represent large-scale atmospheric circulation patterns, such as ocean circulation, etc.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 2NC – Carbon Dividend Bad

Companies are incentivized to go to low-regulatory areas to produce dirty, cheap goods.

Koester, 21 -- [Stefan Koester was a senior policy analyst with ITIF’s Center for Clean Energy Innovation. He has a background in energy and environmental policy and has worked on carbon pricing, corporate sustainability, energy efficiency, electricity markets, and issues related to the electric power sector and renewable energy at the state, regional, and federal levels, "," 9/20/2021, https://itif.org/publications/2021/09/20/unworkable-solution-carbon-border-adjustment-mechanisms-and-global-climate/, accessed 7-17-2023] // David

Toward a Climate-Innovation-Friendly Global Trade Regime Free trade agreements, while effective in advancing IT innovation, will not necessarily accelerate climate innovation. The reason is the costs of GHGs to the global environment are not incorporated into market prices. More open international competition may well drive down prices by allowing dirty-but-cheap producers in one country to undercut clean-but-expensive innovators in another. To avert the worst consequences of climate change, a global trade regime must be created that is sufficiently open to drive innovation through as many trade channels set forth as possible, but also constrained so that traded sectors move in climate-friendly directions. Carbon pricing on a global scale is, on the surface, an appealing basis for such a regime. It seems relatively simple, particularly since a small number of traded sectors are responsible for the bulk of traded emissions. But appearances can be deceiving. The problem is that global carbon pricing, implemented through CBAMs around the world, would be devilishly difficult to negotiate and, even if it were implemented, would be unlikely to spur innovation at the scale and pace the global climate needs. CARBON PRICING, CARBON LEAKAGE, AND BORDER ADJUSTMENTS Carbon pricing is premised on the core economic principle that consumers prefer lower prices. An effective carbon price, whether imposed through a tax or a cap-and-trade scheme, raises the cost of carbon-intensive energy. Producers might respond by passing along the increase to consumers. But, knowing that consumers may cut back their purchases in response, producers have an incentive to find ways to cut their emissions and thereby minimize the cost increase. The incentive is even stronger when producers compete with one another.10 Innovation is the most important way they might do this. “Induced innovation,” which is spurred by the relative increase in the cost of one factor of production (in this case, carbon-intensive energy), is a well-established phenomenon.11 A recent review of the literature led by Michael Grubb concludes that “the case for carbon pricing is enhanced … in light of the push it may give to low carbon innovation.”12 Induced innovation has an important role to play in driving incremental change, but it will not lead to the more-radical breakthroughs “However,” Grubb and his co-authors continued, “carbon pricing alone may be a very blunt way of stimulating innovation.”13 As the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF) has long argued, induced innovation has an important role to play in driving incremental change when low-carbon technologies are close to cost-competitiveness with “dirty” incumbents. But it will not lead to the more-radical breakthroughs needed in sectors wherein the incremental cost of cutting emissions is far greater than any plausible carbon price. The push of public RD&D investment, along with a range of other policies, must complement the pull of carbon pricing to drive rapid innovation in these sectors.14 Carbon Leakage Even induced innovation will be undermined if carbon pricing merely shifts emissions from within one set of borders to another location. “Carbon leakage,” as such shifting has become known, is a likely result in the real world, since there is no global government to impose a global carbon price. Firms that emit GHGs located outside jurisdictions that impose a price gain a competitive advantage by exporting to them, while exporters that are subject to the price but seek to sell in jurisdictions that do not impose one are put at a competitive disadvantage. The fear of industrial production shifting to jurisdictions without a carbon price is a persistent concern for climate policymakers. (The same issue also impacts regulatory approaches to climate policy; low-regulation jurisdictions are more attractive to high-emitting sectors than high-regulation ones.) It is not an idle fear. Research by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) estimates that up to 25 percent of global GHG emissions are embodied in goods traded across borders. Emissions-intensive trade is concentrated in a handful of sectors, including chemicals, metals, and electronics, as seen in figure 1.15 Many of these sectors are poised for growth and expanded trade, particularly involving producers based in developing countries, which could dramatically increase global emissions. As table 1 shows, export-intensive nations such as China account for a large fraction of emissions embodied in trade flows (leading to the negative numbers on the table), while import-intensive nations such as the United States tend to receive emissions-intensive goods. Emissions from goods produced in China and shipped elsewhere made up 10 percent of that nation’s total. The countries that imported these goods avoided those emissions—in the case of the United States, to the tune of 6.3 percent of its national total. The more emissions-intensive and trade-exposed a nation’s domestic industry is, the more vulnerable it is to carbon leakage. Some have speculated that carbon-importing nations such as Germany and the United Kingdom have already become victims of direct carbon leakage as a result of the EU’s carbon pricing policy, since they import 14 and 42 percent, respectively, of their overall emissions in the form of products from other countries. While research suggests that this effect was blunted by the large allocation of free ETS allowances to EITE industries, they may well become vulnerable when these allowances are eliminated, giving the ETS real teeth in these sectors.17 How a CBAM works CBAMs seek to solve the problem of carbon leakage and free-ridership by adding a tariff to imports. The tariff equalizes the carbon price paid by importers with that paid by domestic producers, taking into account any carbon price paid by the importer in the production location. CBAMs may also provide export rebates for domestic manufacturers, allowing them to be competitive in international markets that do not have a comparable carbon price. For example, a steel manufacturer located in a jurisdiction with a carbon price of $40 per ton must pay an extra cost for fossil fuel and other inputs. A CBAM would adjust for this extra cost by imposing a tariff on each ton of imported steel that is equivalent to the carbon price the importer would have paid if the steel had been produced domestically. Domestic manufacturers that export steel to a jurisdiction that does not have a carbon price would receive an equivalent rebate. Steel imported from a jurisdiction that has a carbon price of $15 per ton would be credited for that amount but would have to pay the remaining $25 per ton of imported emissions for the CBAM. CBAMs seek to solve the problem of carbon leakage and free-ridership by adding a tariff to imports. The revenue raised by a CBAM can be used to support the associated export rebates or for any other purpose, such as funding clean-energy RD&D. To be effective, a CBAM would have to be product-specific. The carbon content across steel industry segments, (e.g., flat hot-rolled products and long products, such as rebar and wire) differs greatly due to diverse manufacturing methods. A national or regionally-specific carbon intensity benchmark for each of these specific products would need to be determined on a life-cycle basis that accounts for upstream emissions and uses transparent and verifiable data from the source country. Ironically, the threat of carbon leakage may grow if CBAMs are restricted to only EITE sectors, as some have proposed. In addition to direct carbon leakage, in which producers in sectors facing the carbon price depart or expand abroad to avoid having to pay, a sector-limited CBAM may lead to indirect carbon leakage. In such a setup, imports of final goods-producing sectors (e.g., cars that use EITE inputs such as steel) are exempted from the CBAM. The importers gain an advantage because their input costs are lower, since domestic producers must pay for inputs that are subject to the carbon price if made domestically or the CBAM if imported. Imported cars that use cheap, dirty steel could outcompete domestically made cars that must pay highe r prices for clean steel. Whether emissions embodied in international trade are associated with direct or indirect carbon leakage, they weaken incentives for climate innovation. The fact that EITE industries such as steel, aluminum, and cement, are also generally sectors for which few viable technological options to abate emissions exist—and therefore have the greatest need for innovation—makes the challenge to climate policy more acute.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 2NC – Carbon Dividend Bad

Carbon dividend’s taxes siphoned away alt causes

https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/429489-carbon-tax-dividends-open-a-pandoras-box-of-problems/

The tax “dividend” proposal is intriguing theoretically, but it would expose the carbon tax to the machinations of politics as discussed in my “The Perils of Carbon Taxes” just published in the Cato Institute’s “Regulation.” My paper reveals that the “dividend” program opens a Pandora’s box of problems for advocates of limited government. Carbon tax advocates argue that carbon taxes are necessary to limit climate change. Rather than reduce other taxes that are more economically distortionary, resulting in a “revenue neutral” outcome, this proposal expands tax collection. The “dividend” program creates a new income-redistribution arrangement that collects taxes on fossil fuels and then sends those dollars to citizens in a political game of expanding the welfare state. New redistributive promises quickly become entitlements, expand and are nearly impossible to unwind. Tax collection rises without a healthy debate on which ongoing spending and tax programs should be reformed, downsized or eliminated. The “dividend” program simply adds a new tax source onto our existing tax code. More tax revenue, more government. The U.S. Treasury estimated that a carbon tax that started at $49 per metric ton of carbon dioxide and increased to $70 in 2028 would generate net revenues of $194 billion in the first year of the tax and $2.2 trillion over the 10-year period. The impending expected escalation of government debt will also undoubtedly encourage many attempts at siphoning off carbon tax revenues for other uses. The Congressional Budget Office projects that federal deficits will average $1.2 trillion per year and total $12.4 trillion over the 2019–2028 period. Much of the spending growth reflects increases for Social Security, Medicare and interest on government debt. A great many politicians, interest groups and voters can be expected to seek new tax revenues rather than cut or reform spending programs to fund this widening budgetary gap. The carbon tax “dividend” proposal is likely to become the best friend of those believing government under-taxes rather than over-spends. Government spending and tax programs are unlikely to receive much scrutiny as long as new tax revenues keep flowing to Washington. Carbon tax “dividends” appear to fit this profile since it is very unlikely to foster a holistic discussion about the proper role of government. A carbon “dividend” program essentially closes discussion of which taxes will be swapped, reduced or eliminated that harm economic growth and job creation. Moreover, the “dividend” program encourages citizens to believe (incorrectly) they bear little to no cost themselves for checks from the U.S. government, thus fostering greater demands for government expansion. Revenue neutrality of course will not make government hyper-efficient, but it will provide a fixed pool of funds for policy advocates to draw from. Think tanks have devoted much energy to proposing how best to cut wasteful government programs. These are excellent starting points for improving the efficiency of government. Carbon tax proponents who truly believe it is essential for mitigating the effects of climate change should be willing to negotiate a tax swap that promotes a more efficient government. Proponents unwilling to negotiate are probably more interested in growing tax revenue than decreasing greenhouse gas emissions.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 1NC – Dividends Bad

Carbon dividend causes recession

Daniel 6/21 (Will Daniel - Will Daniel is a reporter at Fortune, covering markets and the economy. Will previously worked at Markets Insider and has an MS in Business Journalism from Arizona State's Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, Fortune, Jun 21, 2023, “5 reasons why top economist Mark Zandi says ‘this time is different’ and he’s ‘betting against’ a U.S. recession”, ) //AHK

Zandi’s quals - Dr. Zandi is on the board of directors of MGIC, the nation’s largest private mortgage insurance company, and is the lead director of Reinvestment Fund, one of the nation’s largest community development financial institutions, which makes investments in underserved communities.Moody’s Analytics, a subsidiary of Moody’s Corp., is a leading provider of economic research, data and analytical tools. Dr. Zandi is a cofounder of Economy.com, which Moody’s purchased in 2005. He is a trusted adviser to policymakers and an influential source of economic analysis for businesses, journalists and the public. Dr. Zandi frequently testifies before Congress and conducts regular briefings on the economy for corporate boards, trade associations, and policymakers at all levels. He is often quoted in national and global publications and interviewed by major news media outlets, and is a frequent guest on CNBC, NPR, Meet the Press, CNN, and various other national networks and news programs.

5. Low oil prices Finally, Zandi said, there have been a dozen recessions since World War II, and almost all of them were “preceded by a spike in oil prices”—but that hasn’t manifested this time around. After Russia invaded Ukraine last year, analysts expected oil prices to not only soar, but remain elevated for years to come. However, a mix of sanctions work-arounds and fears over waning demand from China amid the country’s slower than expected post-COVID recovery have led crude prices to drop this year. “Global oil markets have gracefully adjusted to prewar levels. Oil prices are down, and so too is inflation, both in the U.S. and globally,” Zandi wrote. Falling oil prices should help to keep inflation low, and combined with stable consumer finances and the strong labor market, Zandi argues, it means this time is different. “Yes, the economy will ultimately slump, but odds are fading that a recession is dead ahead,” he wrote. Of course, like every economic prognosticator, Zandi has been confident that recessions wouldn’t occur before, and been mistaken. In September of 2007, for instance, just months before the Global Financial Crisis kicked into full gear, Zandi said he believed a downturn wasn’t likely. “I’m fundamentally optimistic we won’t see job loss,” he said at the time.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 1NC – Recession Good/Normal

The recession is a needed part of the economic cycle and can provide benefits in the long run.

Bromberg 22 Michael Bromberg has been a financial editor for over a decade. “Do Recessions Have a Silver Lining.” Investopedia. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/lessons-recessions-depressions.asp#:~:text=Correcting%20Market%20Imbalances,-A%20recession%20resulting&text=Although%20the%20process%20can%20be,the%20foundations%20for%20economic%20growth. //AKA

From worries about job security to the sinking feeling caused by shrinking balances in your retirement accounts, there are plenty of negative consequences of a recession. However, an economic downturn is not the end of the world. In fact, recessions are an inevitable and necessary part of the economic cycle. History has shown that, when it comes to the financial markets, what goes down eventually comes back up, although the road to recovery may be a bumpy one. And while it may seem counterintuitive, recessions aren't all bad news. From the chance to earn higher yields on your savings account to the potential for bargains and low-cost dividends in the stock market, the clouds that settle over the economy during a recession do in fact have a few silver linings. KEY TAKEAWAYS Recessions have plenty of negative consequences, but they can provide a necessary reset for the markets. Higher interest rates that often coincide with the early stages of a recession provide an advantage to savers, while lower interest rates moving out of a recession can benefit homebuyers. Investors may be able to find bargains on assets that have decreased in price during a recession. 1:44 What Is an Economic Depression? Correcting Market Imbalances A recession resulting from an economic imbalance may rectify it, clearing the way for a return to growth. For example, the 1981-1982 recession, which was triggered by Federal Reserve interest rate increases in response to high inflation, helped to lower the inflation rate from 11% in June 1979 to 5% by October 1982, and the U.S. economy grew for the next eight years. 1 Similarly, a recession can end the misallocation of investment capital, whether fueled by a housing bubble or a dot-com one. Although the process can be painful for many investors, recessions may be instrumental in bringing the markets back down to earth, setting the stage for an eventual recovery and renewing the foundations for economic growth. Incentivizing Savings The early phases of an economic downturn often coincide with increases in interest rates as the Federal Reserve pulls the levels of monetary policy in an attempt to combat inflation. For example, in 2022, the Fed engaged in a series of 75-basis-point interest rate hikes, lifting the federal funds rate to a range of 3.75% to 4% at its meeting on Nov. 2. While rate hikes may have a cooling effect on the economy, there is a bright side, as the higher rates translate to higher yields on deposits in savings accounts. 2 While other assets may be subject to heightened levels of risk as the economy tumbles, savings accounts benefit from the higher interest rates during the early stages of a recession, providing stable returns. Savings vehicles like certificates of deposit (CDs) and money market accounts may offer even higher rates than traditional accounts, and online accounts often have the best terms, 3 so it's important to shop around before stashing your cash. The advantages of higher savings account rates make this stage of the economic cycle a perfect time to focus on beefing up your emergency fund. 3 This way, if you lose your job or suffer another economic setback during the recession, you will have a cushion of cash on hand to pull through the difficult time. What's more, you can use the cash you accumulate in your savings account to allocate to other investments as the economy begins to recover. If the higher rates aren't enough, depositing your money in a savings account can help you rest easier during a recession because the funds are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). Bringing Bargains to the Market Recessions can be a stressful time for investors. To put it simply, it can be quite distressing to watch your portfolio shed value as the economy takes a dive. This is especially true for retirees or those nearing retirement who don't have the luxury of time to recover from investment losses. However unsettling it may be to see all that red ink on your account statement, it's important to avoid overreacting and selling your assets at their recession-induced lows. In fact, if you have the patience and are able to adopt a long-term perspective, a recession can be a good time to hunt for bargains and purchase undervalued assets. In addition to identifying stocks of resilient companies that may have suffered overblown declines, investors who continue to buy through a recession stand to benefit from lowering the average cost paid for their assets. For example, if a stock you own has lost value during a recession but you remain bullish on the company's outlook, you could buy additional shares at the reduced price. This will bring down the overall cost per share that you paid for your position, making it easier for you to break even and setting you up for extra gains when the stock recovers. 3 Declining stock prices during a recession also have the potential to benefit investors seeking income from dividends. As the price of a stock decreases, its dividend yield increases, generating higher returns for shareholders. 3 However, the perks of increased dividend yield come to fruition only if the company maintains its dividend, despite the recession's potential negative impacts on its business. While such due diligence is important any time you are researching a dividend-paying stock, it is particularly critical during a recession to seek companies with a history of stable payouts and the capacity to weather the current downturn. Purchasing shares of index funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can be one way to mitigate the risk of investing during a recession. If you invest in individual stocks, there is a chance that the company you choose may post outsized losses or even fail to survive the downturn. On the other hand, pooled index funds and ETFs offer built-in diversification that enhances your chances for weathering the recession. 3 Foreshadowing Lower Interest Rates In contrast with the interest rate hikes that often accompany the beginning of a recession, the later stages of an economic downturn frequently see policymakers lower rates in a bid to jumpstart the sputtering economy. While vehicles like savings accounts lose much of the appeal they generated earlier in the downturn, there are other advantages to the prospects of lower rates on the horizon. For instance, a lower fed funds rate translates to lower mortgage rates. The favorable borrowing environment during the later stages of a recession could provide an excellent opportunity for homebuyers. What Is a Recession? A recession is a substantial, broad-based decline reflected in numerous indicators of economic performance and typically lasting longer than a few months. Can I Benefit From a Recession? By their nature, recessions have far-reaching consequences, with negative effects spanning multiple areas of the financial markets. Although it is impractical to expect to reap a financial reward from a struggling economy, recessions have a few silver linings. Heightened interest rates at the beginning of a recession may allow you to earn more on your savings deposits, while lower rates moving out of the recession may provide opportunities to secure a favorable mortgage loan. You may also be able to buy assets at a discounted price after they have depreciated in value. How Do I Manage My Portfolio During a Recession? If you have a longer investment horizon that will give your assets time to recover from any losses during the recession, you may benefit from maintaining your existing asset allocation, remaining invested in the markets and poised to gain from an eventual recovery. However, there are ways that you can reduce your portfolio's risk in response to an economic downturn. Riskier assets like stocks and high-yield bonds tend to lose value in a recession, while assets that are seen as more stable like gold and U.S. Treasuries tend to appreciate. Within the stock market, shares of large companies with solid cash flows and dividends tend to outperform in downturns. The Bottom Line Recessions are a natural, unavoidable stage of the economic cycle that invariably brings hardship to individuals who lose their jobs or businesses. Economic downturns can also be a difficult time for investors, especially people nearing retirement who can't afford losses in their portfolios. However, for those with the flexibility to adopt a long-term perspective, recessions have a few silver linings. It's difficult if not impossible to time the bottom of the market, but depressed asset prices during a recession could offer buying opportunities for investors. Shifts in interest rates throughout the course of an economic downturn also provide certain advantages—higher rates aimed at fighting inflation benefit savings deposits, while lower interest rates implemented to spur a recovery make it cheaper to take out a loan. Although they don't make up for the economic pain experienced during a recession, these bright spots could be helpful in weathering the storm and positioning for an eventual recovery.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › AT – Recession public/private debt

No recession

Daniel 6/21 (Will Daniel - Will Daniel is a reporter at Fortune, covering markets and the economy. Will previously worked at Markets Insider and has an MS in Business Journalism from Arizona State's Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, Fortune, Jun 21, 2023, “5 reasons why top economist Mark Zandi says ‘this time is different’ and he’s ‘betting against’ a U.S. recession”, ) //AHK

Zandi’s quals - Dr. Zandi is on the board of directors of MGIC, the nation’s largest private mortgage insurance company, and is the lead director of Reinvestment Fund, one of the nation’s largest community development financial institutions, which makes investments in underserved communities.Moody’s Analytics, a subsidiary of Moody’s Corp., is a leading provider of economic research, data and analytical tools. Dr. Zandi is a cofounder of Economy.com, which Moody’s purchased in 2005. He is a trusted adviser to policymakers and an influential source of economic analysis for businesses, journalists and the public. Dr. Zandi frequently testifies before Congress and conducts regular briefings on the economy for corporate boards, trade associations, and policymakers at all levels. He is often quoted in national and global publications and interviewed by major news media outlets, and is a frequent guest on CNBC, NPR, Meet the Press, CNN, and various other national networks and news programs.

3. Light debt loads There’s been a lot of concern about rising public and private debt over the past few years, but U.S. consumers and businesses actually have their finances in order, according to Zandi, and that could help prevent a recession. “Households and businesses have borrowed prudently since the global financial crisis over a decade ago,” he argued, noting that although household debt is near a record high, when compared with disposable income, consumers aren’t overly burdened. The economist pointed out that household debt service payments as a percentage of disposable income were just 9.6% in the first quarter. That’s compared with an average of over 11% since 1980 and over 13% before the Global Financial Crisis of 2008, Fed data shows. Zandi also said that businesses are “devoting a near record low amount of their profits to debt payments, freeing up cash to finance hiring and investment.” Corporate interest payments as a percentage of cash flow are now roughly 7.5%, compared with over 20% before the Global Financial Crisis of 2008, according to a May Moody’s Analytics report. 4. Anchored inflation expectations While year-over-year inflation, as measured by the consumer price index, fell to 4% in May, it was still well above the Fed’s 2% target rate. But Zandi noted that inflation has been on a consistent downward trajectory and consumers’ outlook on potential price hikes has also improved. That could enable the Fed to pause its rate hikes this year, and prevent the Fed-induced recession that some investment banks have forecast. One-year-ahead inflation expectations declined to 4.1% in May, the lowest reading in two years, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York’s latest Survey of Consumer Expectations. “The Fed’s success so far in pinning down inflation expectations makes its job easier,” Zandi wrote. “If consumers and businesses believe the Fed will do what is needed to ensure inflation recedes, then they will behave accordingly. And that makes it more likely to come true.”

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 2NC – Predictions Bad

Economic predictions fail

Krugman 18 (Paul Krugman - an American economist who is the Distinguished Professor of Economics at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York and a columnist for The New York Times.[7] In 2008, Krugman was the winner of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for his contributions to New Trade Theory and New Economic Geography.[8] The Prize Committee cited Krugman's work explaining the patterns of international trade and the geographic distribution of economic activity, by examining the effects of economies of scale and of consumer preferences for diverse goods and services., “Good enough for government work? Macroeconomics since the crisis”, pg 158-159) // AHK

First, was the failure of prediction a consequence of failures in the economic framework that can be fixed by adopting a radically different framework? It’s true that a significant wing of both macroeconomists and financial economists were in the thrall of the efficient markets hypothesis, believing that financial overreach simply cannot happen—or at any rate that it can only be discovered after the fact, because markets know what they are doing better than any observer. But many macroeconomists, especially in policy institutions, knew better than to trust markets to always get it right—especially those who had studied or been involved with the Asian crisis of the 1990s. Yet they (we) also missed some or all of the signs of overreach. Why? My answer may seem unsatisfying, but I believe it to be true: for the most part what happened was a demonstration of the old line that predictions are hard, especially about the future. It’s a complicated world out there, and one’s ability to track potential threats is limited. Almost nobody saw the Asian crisis coming, either. For that matter, how many people worried about political disruption of oil supplies before 1973? And so on. At any given time there tends to be a set of conventional indicators everyone looks at, determined less by fundamental theory than by recent events, and big, surprise crises almost by definition happen due to factors not on that list. If you like, it’s as if meteorologists with limited resources concentrated those resources in places that had helped track previous storms, leading to the occasional surprise when a storm comes from an unusual direction. A different question is whether, now that we know whence the 2008 crisis came, it points to a need for deep changes in macroeconomic thinking. As I’ve already noted, bank runs have been fairly well understood for a long time; we just failed to note the changing definition of banks. The bursting of the housing bubble, with its effects on residential investment and wealth, was conceptually just a negative shock to aggregate demand. The role of household leverage and forced deleveraging is a bigger break from conventional macroeconomics, even as done by saltwater economists who never bought into efficient markets and were aware of the risk of financial crises. That said, despite the impressive empirical work of Mian and Sufi (2011) and my own intellectual investment in the subject, I don’t think we can consider incorporating debt and leverage a fundamental new idea, as opposed to a refinement at the margin.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 2NC – Predictions Bad

Recession predictions blown over

Wilkins 7/9 (Joseph Wilkins, July 9, 2023, Business Insider Africa, “The much-predicted recession may not happen at all”, https://africa.businessinsider.com/markets/the-much-predicted-recession-may-not-happen-at-all/z3gq174)

But six months later, the most predicted recession in recent memory is yet to materialize – and some experts are now suggesting the risk may have blown over. Encouraging economic data – highlighted by a combination of resilient job-market numbers and cooling inflation – gives some support to that argument too. On its part, the stock market has defied Wall Street's doom-and-gloom predictions for the economy to notch the best first-half gain since 2019 – thanks in part to an explosion of investor interest in artificial intelligence. Morgan Stanley's chief economist Seth Carpenter and Nobel laureate Paul Krugman are among top voices that remain bullish on the trajectory of the economy. Here's what they had to say: ADVERTISEMENT Seth Carpenter, global chief economist at Morgan Stanley "The labor market is one of the key stories so far this year," the bank's top economist recently told Yahoo Finance. "There has been clear slowing, however, the rate of job gains has been pretty strong and we think that's been contributing to resilience spending." "That also means as things do cool down with the Fed rate hikes, we're just not likely to tip over into recession," he added. Paul Krugman, Nobel-prize winning economist "US economic news has been increasingly encouraging: falling inflation, no sign of a recession," the economics professor at the City University of New York tweeted in late June. ADVERTISEMENT More recently, he wrote in a New York Times op-ed this week: "The plunge in the misery index reflects both what didn't happen and what did. What didn't happen, despite a drumbeat of dire warnings in the news media, was a recession. The U.S. economy added four million jobs over the past year, and the unemployment rate has remained near a 50-year low." Robert Hoffman, Citi private bank strategist Hoffman, the Citibank's head of investment counselors in South Asia, told CNBC International last Friday: "What we were originally anticipating – a recession towards the end of 2023 – has now been pushed very far off, we're actually looking much closer to the end of 2024 now." "We think the US mid-cap space offers very compelling valuations and an opportunity if you do avert a recession or should it get pushed further out," he added. The BoA published a research note last week explaining how the sharp inversion of the yield curve may be signaling a sharp decline in inflation, and that they believe the US economy will emerge intact. "While curve inversion near historical extremes has garnered higher recession probabilities from models, we think curve shape is more a function of expectations for declining inflation than a deterioration in growth," strategists at the bank wrote. "A look under the hood suggests that forward real rates do not price elevated recession risk and instead may reflect expectation for softer landing vs consensus," they added.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › Recession inevitable

Countercyclical policies don’t affect recession

Chatterjee ND (Satyajit Chatterjee, no date, pg 19 – 21, “Real Business Cycles: A Legacy of Countercyclical Policies?”, ) //AHK

Real-business-cycle theory simply calculates the optimal response to random variations in TFP growth for an economic model that resembles the U.S. economy in important respects. Prescott presented these calculations as a prediction of how the U.S. economy would actually behave when faced with erratic TFP growth. He made this connection by invoking a general principle of economics, namely, that competition tends to produce economically optimal outcomes.7 In other words, Prescott proceeded on the assumption that for the purposes of business-cycle analysis, the actual workings of the U.S. economy are well approximated by a model economy with perfect markets, that is, a model economy in which all markets are highly competitive and all markets function smoothly without any need for government regulation. Since, according to economic theory, a perfect-markets economy will generate optimal economic outcomes, Prescott simply calculated the optimal response of his model economy to fluctuations in TFP growth and took FIGURE 1 Annual Growth Rate Of Real Output FIGURE 2 Annual Growth Rate Of Real Investment 7 The principle dates back, in the guise of Adam Smith’s famous “invisible hand,” to the origin of modern economics. Smith was one of the first social philosophers to argue that intrusive regulation of commerce and industry is economically harmful. He argued that the freedom to form mutually advantageous contracts (unregulated markets) is the best guarantor of efficient economic outcomes. Reprinted, with permission, from Plosser, Charles I., "Understanding Real Business Cycles," Journal of Economic Perspectives 3, 1989, p. 64. Reprinted, with permission, from Plosser, Charles I., "Understanding Real Business Cycles," Journal of Economic Perspectives 3, 1989, p. 65. Banking Industry Consolidation: What's a Small Business to Do? Loretta J. Mester 21 these responses to be a prediction of how the actual U.S. economy would behave with respect to those same fluctuations. The close match between predictions and fact means that his assumption was not far off the mark; somehow, the U.S. economy manages to mimic a perfect markets economy.

2023 DDI Negative
DDI LS Carbon Dividend Neg 23 › Econ Advantage › 1NC – Recession Unlikely

Recession highly unlikely

Daniel 6/21 (Will Daniel - Will Daniel is a reporter at Fortune, covering markets and the economy. Will previously worked at Markets Insider and has an MS in Business Journalism from Arizona State's Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication, Fortune, Jun 21, 2023, “5 reasons why top economist Mark Zandi says ‘this time is different’ and he’s ‘betting against’ a U.S. recession”, ) //AHK

Zandi’s quals - Dr. Zandi is on the board of directors of MGIC, the nation’s largest private mortgage insurance company, and is the lead director of Reinvestment Fund, one of the nation’s largest community development financial institutions, which makes investments in underserved communities.Moody’s Analytics, a subsidiary of Moody’s Corp., is a leading provider of economic research, data and analytical tools. Dr. Zandi is a cofounder of Economy.com, which Moody’s purchased in 2005. He is a trusted adviser to policymakers and an influential source of economic analysis for businesses, journalists and the public. Dr. Zandi frequently testifies before Congress and conducts regular briefings on the economy for corporate boards, trade associations, and policymakers at all levels. He is often quoted in national and global publications and interviewed by major news media outlets, and is a frequent guest on CNBC, NPR, Meet the Press, CNN, and various other national networks and news programs.

Despite more than a year of consistent recession predictions from Wall Street’s top minds and dozens of Fortune 500 CEOs, the U.S. economy has remained remarkably resilient in 2023. Stubborn inflation and rising interest rates that typically signal the peak of an economic cycle haven’t managed to spark the job-killing downturn that many feared was inevitable. And now, one of the world’s leading economists is making the case that his peers’ consensus forecast for a recession this year is “off base.” “This time is different,” Mark Zandi, Moody’s Analytics chief economist, wrote in a CNN op-ed Tuesday titled, naturally: “Why I’m betting against a U.S. recession.” “Yes, the economy is fragile and vulnerable to losing the script,” Zandi writes. “And goodness knows we have been off script more often than not in recent years. But odds are that we will buck history and avoid recession.” Zandi isn’t alone in his increasingly optimistic outlook for the economy. With unemployment sticking near pre-pandemic lows and the latest inflation metrics continuing to fall, some investment banks are changing their previously melancholic tune. Goldman Sachs now believes there is just a 25% chance of a recession over the next 12 months, down from 35% in March. And Bank of America revised its 2023 recession forecast last week, arguing there’s going to be a “softer” downturn that won’t come until next year. Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, is also growing more bullish after consistently warning that a mild recession is likely to hit the economy. “As the Fed continues tightening policy and interest rate hikes work their way through the economy, we still believe a recession is more likely than not, but we have lowered our recession odds to 55%,” he wrote in a Wednesday note to clients. For Zandi, there are five key reasons why the economy could avoid a recession entirely this year, and they’re all “more or less unique to this time.” 1. Excess savings The first reason why Zandi believes this time is different is due to so-called excess savings. During the pandemic-era lockdowns, consumers weren’t able to spend as they typically would, no trips to the local diner, no movies, and no summer vacations. At the same time, in order to stave off a recession, the federal government launched several stimulus packages that injected roughly $5 trillion into the economy. This period of reduced spending, coupled with stimulus that boosted incomes, helped consumers sock away more cash than they typically would have. Economists have labeled the phenomenon “excess savings.” While excess savings peaked at $2.1 trillion in 2021, consumers still held $500 billion of these funds as of this May, according to research from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. And with consumer spending accounting for roughly 70% of GDP, that money could prompt Americans to shop, enabling the economy to avoid a recession. “Consumers are the firewall between recession and a growing economy, and the firewall is holding firm,” Zandi explained. 2. Labor hoarding Continued strength in the labor market due to “labor hoarding” is another reason why the economy could avoid a serious downturn, according to Zandi. The economist noted that businesses struggled to hire and find talent both before and during the pandemic, which makes them more likely to avoid layoffs at all costs moving forward. “On the other side of the pandemic, businesses understand that labor shortages will be a persistent problem as the baby boomer generation retires in the coming decade,” he explained.

2023 DDI Negative
Extensions › Training PIC › Mandatoriness Key / AT: Voluntary Solves—2NC

Workers will not participate in job training unless it is mandatory

Sandvik et al. 21 (Jason Sandvik is a professor of Finance at Tulane University, Richard Saouma is a professor of Business at michigan State University, Nathan Seegert is a professor of Finance at the university of Utah, Christopher Stanton is a professor of Business at harvard University, “SHOULD WORKPLACE PROGRAMS BE VOLUNTARY OR MANDATOORY? EVIDENCE FROM A FIELD EXPERIMENT ON MENTORSHIP,” 8-21) [MO]

There is substantial variation in whether workplace training and mentorship programs are voluntary or mandatory. When programs are voluntary, many workers do not participate. We conducted a natural field experiment on a mentorship program in a sales call center where in one treatment arm, labeled the Mandatory-Condition, all subjects were either randomly assigned a mentor or not. A second treatment arm, labeled the Voluntary-Condition, required subjects to opt into the program before randomization into receiving a mentor. In the Mandatory-Condition, the mentorship treatment raised workers’ daily revenue by 17% in their first two months of tenure. In the Voluntary-Condition, those who opted out of the program were substantially less productive than those who opted in, and treatment gains conditional on program participation were negligible. Comparing the conditions indicates that treatment effects are largest for workers who are most likely to opt out of participating in the program. We conclude that workplace programs can raise the productivity of lower performing employees but these workers may require inducements or mandates to participate.

2023 DDI Negative
Extensions › Training PIC › Mandatoriness Key / AT: Voluntary Solves—2NC

Employees are less likely participate in job training if voluntary

Sweeney and Martindale 21 (Joseph P. Sweeney is a professor of Instructional Design and Technology at University of Memphis, Emery T. Martindale is a professor of Instructional Design at University of Memphis, “Increasing Employee Participation in Voluntary Training: Issues and Solutions,” 12-21, https://members.aect.org/pdf/Proceedings/proceedings12/2012i/12_21.pdf) [MO]

Voluntary training is typically a part of a company’s strategy to improve employee knowledge, skills, and job performance. However, it can be difficult to get employees to participate in these programs because they are voluntary. Increasing participation in these training programs not only increases organizational effectiveness, but also is of benefit to the individual employee. Voluntary training can be a win-win situation. Also, if the company infrastructure for web-based training is present (networks, computers, learning management system, etc.), the cost of providing the training opportunity is relatively low. Problem Statement Problem: Companies desire to increase employee and organizational capabilities via voluntary trainining, but in many cases and for various reasons employees do not participate.

2023 DDI Negative
Extensions › Training PIC › Training Key/JG Insufficient—2NC

Growing demand for skilled workers now.

Diana Dumitrascu, 04-11-2023, " Manufacturing returns, the labor shortage and the skills gap overlapping the green transition requirements “ Linked In, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/manufacturing-returns-labor-shortage-skills-gap-green-dumitrascu/

As the world transitions to a more sustainable future, there is a growing demand for skilled workers in emerging green industries.

However, the shift is also creating a skills gap in traditional industries, leading to labor shortages and challenges in meeting the demands of the green economy.

2023 DDI Negative
Extensions › Training PIC › Training Key/JG Insufficient—2NC

Workers trained in green-tech are essential to meeting the demands of the green economy.

ILO International Labour Organization, 2016, "Advancing Green Human Capital – A Framework for Policy Analysis", https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_emp/---ifp_skills/documents/publication/wcms_607491.pd

Efforts must be made to incorporate changes into training practices, revise training programmes and introduce new ones so as to ensure the employability of workers in a rapidly changing world. The green transition is generating far more demand for upgraded skills in established occupations than it is creating brand new occupations (ILO et al., 2013). In both cases, as green markets evolve and mature, there is an increasing tendency for the related jobs to require more specialized and better-skilled personnel, preferably with formal qualifications. While the initial training system has a role in bringing in a new generation of professionals well prepared for the opportunities and challenges of the twenty first century, continuing training is essential to ensure that those already in work adjust to the rapidly evolving and urgent demands of the green economy. The timeliness or the lack thereof with which TVET systems respond to sustainability concerns and the demand for related skills can put these systems in a virtuous cycle of interaction with the labour market, or alternatively widen the disconnect between the demand for and the supply of skills. A demand-driven approach to greening skills is therefore necessary: the needs of the economic market in terms of jobs and skills must be identified and then answered through appropriate training offers, with the final aim being to ensure the employability of professionals and future professionals in the green economy. However, despite recent changes, many employers still have a lack of knowledge on sustainability related skills and do not explicitly demand such skills or qualifications from their employees (Strietska-Ilina et al., 2011). This is why the TVET system should not be limited to being a mere supplier satisfying economic demands. It also has a responsibility and opportunity to help generate a new generation of workers and entrepreneurs willing and able to frame an economic model adhering to the principles of sustainable development, in a way that fits the national political orientation (Majumdar, 2010). Moving towards sustainability while improving the quality and status of TVET requires innovative and transformational leaders in all policy, economic and educational spheres who can seize the opportunities to create a new vision for twenty-first century skills, jobs, economies and societies.

2023 DDI Negative
Extensions › Training PIC › Training Key/JG Insufficient—2NC

Training is key to solve the climate.

ANGHELUTÃ 16 (Anghelutã, Petricã Sorin. Bucharest University of Economic Studies “Green Economy and the Importance of the Education of Human Capital.” Calitatea, 17(150), 69. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/green-economy-importance-education-human-capital/docview/1764884498/se-2. Accessed 7/12/23)

The transition to the green economy requires the education and the development of new skills needed for new jobs. The training programs for green jobs can be included in formal and informal education systems.

2. Green economy