Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
Case

13] Puerto Rico needs stability america’s flawed social security simply is not good for it.

BY Debra Kahn (She previously served as California bureau chief and as California environment and transportation reporter, where she covered climate, water, air pollution, electric vehicles, fuel economy, high-speed rail and wildfires.) 3/28/23      

If you hear about Puerto Rico going through a third round of hurricane-induced blackouts in a few months, don’t be surprised.Think back to this story by Gloria Gonzalez, which details the territory’s struggles to shore up its power grid, keep electricity prices under control and transition to renewables, all at the same time.Six months after Hurricane Fiona and nearly six years after Hurricane Maria, Puerto Rico’s grid is still fragile. Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm is there this week, touring a technical college and meeting local homeowners, businesses using solar power and a community solar project.

“Will the grid be totally ready for the next hurricane season? In all candor it will not,” Granholm told Gloria. “But will it be better than it was last time? Will there be a quicker response than there was last time? That’s exactly what we are all striving for, that people will not be without power for months.”Local officials are still coming under fire for their management of the system, as well as their attempts to increase reliance on natural gas as a way to avoid future outages — a strategy that clean energy advocates and community group leaders say flies in the face of the territory’s quest to shift to 100 percent renewable energy.“The energy sector is probably the number one thing that you need to fix,” said Mujica, who previously served as former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s longtime budget director. “We don’t have real economic growth. We don’t have a reliable energy sector.”

2023 DDI Negative
Case

12] Social security has no stability.

By Andrew Rettenmaier and Dennis W. Jansen for The Conversation JUNE 1, 2023  

Social Security is in trouble.The retirement and disability program has been running a cash-flow deficit since 2010. Its trust fund, which holds US$2.7 trillion, is rapidly diminishing. Social Security’s trustees, a group that includes the secretaries of the departments of Treasury, Labor, and Health and Human Services, as well as the Social Security commissioner, project that the trust fund will be completely drained by 2033.Under current law, when that trust fund is empty, Social Security can pay benefits only from dedicated tax revenues, which would by that point cover about 77% of promised benefits. Another way to say this is that when the trust fund is depleted, under current law, Social Security beneficiaries would see a sudden 23% cut in their monthly checks in 2034.As economists who study the Medicare and Social Security programs, we view the above scenario as politically unacceptable. Such a sudden and dramatic benefit cut would anger a lot of voters. Unfortunately, the actions necessary now to avoid it – like raising taxes or cutting benefits – aren’t getting serious consideration today.  

2023 DDI Negative
Case

11] Social security trust fund is depleting

Lorie Konish(Prior to joining CNBC, Konish worked as an editor at InvestmentNews and On Wall Street covering issues affecting financial advisers and their clients) mar,31 2023   

The Social Security trust funds that about 67 million Americans rely on for benefits are scheduled to be depleted in 2034, one year earlier than was projected last year, according to the annual trustees’ report released by the Treasury Department on Friday.Unless Congress takes action, at that time, 80% of scheduled benefits will be payable from the combined funds for old age and survivors insurance and disability insurance.The new depletion date comes as the trustees updated their projections for the U.S. economy to include recent output and inflation data. The expected levels of gross domestic product and labor productivity were revised down by about 3% for the projected time period, which worsened the outlook for Social Security’s combined funds, according to the report.Meanwhile, Medicare’s hospital insurance trust fund will be able to pay 100% of scheduled benefits until 2031, three years later than projected last year. 

2023 DDI Negative
Case

10] Social security is altering in a very bad way and implementing it in Puerto Rico is a bad idea.

By Maurie Backman(Maurie Backman is a personal finance writer who's passionate about educating others.)-Apr 4,2023 at 4:02 AM   

Millions of seniors today rely on Social Security to cover their bills in retirement. And for many older Americans, those benefits are their primary or only source of income.The problem, though, is that Social Security is facing a funding shortfall. The program's main revenue source is payroll taxes. But in the coming years, that source is expected to shrink. We can thank a mass exodus of baby boomers from the workforce for that.Now, Social Security has trust funds it can tap to keep up with scheduled benefits, even once its payroll tax revenue is cut. But once those funds are depleted, Social Security may have to reduce benefits, despite the financial upheaval recipients are apt to experience as a result.Meanwhile, the Social Security Trustees just released their latest report. And it contains one piece of pretty unfavorable news. The Social Security Trustees are now projecting that the program's trust funds will be out of money by 2034. At that point, Social Security will only have the financial means to pay 80% of scheduled benefits.What makes this news particularly disturbing is that 2034 was not the projected trust fund depletion date the Trustees pointed to last year. Rather, it was 2035. So basically, this latest report puts benefit cuts one year ahead of last year's anticipated timeline.Of course, benefit cuts are bad news for current workers who hope to collect their share of Social Security once they retire. But they're even worse news for the millions of seniors who are already retired and can't afford a hit to their income.It's possible that lawmakers will come up with a viable solution to fix Social Security so that benefits don't have to be cut, or at least not to the tune of 20%. But as of now, there's no official solution in the works. And that's problematic, seeing as how the program's trust funds could be out of money in a little more than a decade.

One proposal that's been floated to pump more money into Social Security is to raise full retirement age, which is when seniors are entitled to their full monthly benefits based on their respective earnings histories. Right now, full retirement age is 67 for anyone born in 1960 or later. Moving that age to 68 or 69 buys Social Security some financial leeway, but it also might force millions of hardworking Americans to delay their retirement when they'd rather not. 

2023 DDI Negative
Case

9] Puerto Rico’s economy is struggling

Muchacho 2023 [Acc: July 20, 2023. Enrique Muchacho is a college student at Loyola University Maryland, majoring in Journalism and minoring in photography. https://www.theweeklyjournal.com/top-stories/puerto-rico-s-challenge-in-a-competitive-market/article_da5b6456-2702-11ee-b11a-af7100909aac.html]

Puerto Rico’s economic state in the global market is facing a challenging time. While the island still reels from the effects of hurricane Maria, the earthquakes of 2020, and the covid-19 pandemic, Francisco Montavol Fiol, professor and economic analyst believes that Puerto Rico is doing well when compared to the average of the U.S. “In some ways, Puerto Rico is in a better position in the sense of unemployment, inflation pressures, and even economic activity is better than the U.S. average. The United States usually analyzes it as a whole, but it’s actually six regions. In the case of Puerto Rico, it’s in much better shape,” Montavol Fiol said. On the other hand, economist Heidie Calero has other thoughts on the economic situation of the island. “Puerto Rico is still in a depression even though they’ve said that the fiscal year of 2022 we finished with 3.7% economic growth. I don’t believe it personally, even if that may be the official figure. The “promesa” board, which is in charge of providing forecast of the economy says that in 2024, is forecasting that Puerto Rico is going to be in a region of -0.1%, to -0.3%. They are forecasting that Puerto Rico’s economic growth is going to be lower instead of rising,” Calero commented. Many things contribute to Puerto Rico’s inability to compete in the global market. According to Montavol Fiol, “there are some very competitive products and services, and a lot has to do with not being knowledgeable with the global markets. Some local businesses are afraid of going out of their comfort zone, infrastructure problems such as the cost of electricity and the permit process to be able to do business, both for locals and offshore companies.” Calero has commented that energy reform will not do much to bring economic growth for the island. “By 2024, the energy reform will only contribute 0.1% as well as in 2025. All these structural reforms are not bringing economic growth. We used to be a top manufacturing economy. Since the end of Section 936, in 2006, some companies left or reduced manufacturing in the island. You can see several reducing their plants if they don’t see that the island is reconstruction,” Calero said. While Puerto Rico has seen a reduction in manufacturing plants, Eric Santiago, president of the Puerto Rico Manufacturing Association, says that Puerto Rico still has the advantage of attracting investment to the island given the island’s history with such investments. “Puerto Rico has certain advantages, specifically in the area of human capital. Puerto Ricans have an ability to adapt to a new high technology take action with any investment. You will notice that most of the firms investing or expanding in Puerto Rico are because of the knowledge, experience, technical capabilities, and willingness to deal with complex project in which Puerto Ricans have done before,” Santiago. Despite that, Santiago also claims that there are other factors that Puerto Rico needs to work on. “One of the factors Puerto Rico needs to work on is the general cost of making business in the island. We need to be faster in how to implement projects, be more effective in the cost of energy and the whole uncertainty behind the legal framework that Puerto Rico has because of the relationship with the U.S may give businesses the idea that it may be a risk given Puerto Rico may be a free state or an independent territory. Those things do not necessarily provide the power to attract investment. For me, the environment, how to deal with the legal framework of the island, and human capital are what attract investment,” Santiago said. According to Montavol Fiol, Puerto Rico is one of the few most dependent jurisdictions in the terms of federal transfers, with its budget being for the first time a total of $31 billion and the largest share was from federal transfers making the island highly dependent of the U.S. “Given its dependency, Puerto Rico is in an uncompetitive position since they don’t have the pressure to keep up. The world is dividing up and Puerto Rico must learn to compete on a global scale and there are private enterprises given their size, they do compete such as the financial sector,” Montavol Fiol said. According to Santiago, one of the main things that can help the island to grow in the economic sector can be the government’s interest in industry and entrepreneurship and the island’s willingness to show interest in their investments. “We need to show that we have a huge appetite for investment. We have to have this attitude that makes entrepreneurs come to the island and invest. Many organizations are doing their best, but what’s preventing us from doing business in Puerto Rico is the cost of doing business here and how easy it is to do business here,” Santiago commented. Despite the island working on its projects for structural reform, Calero does not believe that it will help that much. “All in all, Puerto Rico is not in great shape. The “promesa” board said that they need to take several structural reforms, but that will only contribute by 2025 0.15% of economic growth, which is nothing,” Calero said.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

8] Puerto Rico is drowning in debt, and efforts to cut debt has failed

Cheatham 2022 [Acc: September 29, 2022. The Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) is an independent, nonpartisan membership organization, think tank, and publisher to help them better understand the world and the foreign policy choices facing the United States and other countries. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/puerto-rico-us-territory-crisis#chapter-title-0-4]

Since it began defaulting on major debt obligations in 2016, Puerto Rico has struggled with how to pay its creditors—many of whom hold bonds that are protected by Puerto Rico’s constitution—while maintaining basic public services and avoiding an even deeper economic collapse. It took more than five years of negotiations for a federally appointed oversight board to approve a restructuring plan, and controversy persists. As a territory, Puerto Rico’s options were limited from the beginning. It could not receive assistance from the International Monetary Fund, like insolvent countries such as Greece have. Neither could it file for Chapter 9 bankruptcy, which municipalities such as Detroit have used to receive legal protection against creditor claims while restructuring their payments. Then there is the sheer size of the debt: Puerto Rico’s is by far the biggest government bankruptcy in U.S. history. The island’s legislature tried to design its own restructuring process [PDF], which would have allowed public services to continue uninterrupted while it negotiated lower debt payments, but the U.S. Supreme Court rejected the law. Congress and President Barack Obama’s administration drew up an alternative plan, the 2016 Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act (PROMESA). Most notably, PROMESA created a seven-member financial oversight board appointed by the White House that was granted full control of Puerto Rico’s finances. It also created a debt restructuring process similar to Chapter 9 that governed negotiations with creditors to reduce debt payments. Those negotiations were beset by controversy, as it became clear that all involved—bondholders, Puerto Rican pension funds, and other public services—faced steep losses. Several versions of a sweeping plan to cut the island’s debt were floated, but creditors promised legal challenges, and efforts were paused due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In January 2022, a federal judge approved a final plan between the PROMESA board and Puerto Rico’s government, paving the way for the island to escape bankruptcy and resume making payments to creditors. The deal cuts $33 billion in total debt obligations down to $7.4 billion, lowering Puerto Rico’s annual debt payments from nearly $4 billion to just over $1 billion. Supporters say the deal puts the island on a sustainable path while avoiding any cuts to public pensions, which had been a major point of contention. However, critics are wary of the resolution. Some argue that cutting debt without requiring deeper structural reforms means problems are likely to repeat. Others worry that maintaining pension obligations—which amount to $2.3 billion yearly—will prove unsustainable. Advocacy groups such as the Center for Popular Democracy say the deal will result in more economic austerity, including cuts to health care and education. They echo many critics who oppose the PROMESA process on the grounds that it undermines the territory’s already weak self-rule. PROMESA’s oversight board will remain in place until Puerto Rico meets several financial milestones—three more years at least. Meanwhile, experts have suggested that Puerto Rico’s restructuring experience could be a test case for heavily indebted U.S. states such as Illinois and New Jersey, which are also constitutionally ineligible for bankruptcy protections.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

7] Puerto Rico is in a fiscal crisis – Medicaid and Health Care are unsustainable

Balmaceda 2022 [Acc: October 21, 2022. Javier Balmaceda is a Senior Policy Analyst with the Center’s Federal Fiscal Policy team. His main area of focus is Puerto Rico. https://www.cbpp.org/blog/puerto-rico-risks-health-care-fiscal-crisis-without-medicaid-fix-this-winter]

The 2022 Consolidated Appropriations Act increased the federal government’s share of Medicaid costs paid in the U.S. Territories, from the 55 percent set in statute to 76 percent for Puerto Rico and to 83 percent for Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, and American Samoa, but only until December 13, 2022. The recently enacted continuing resolution extended that deadline by a few days, to December 16. Absent congressional action, the rate will revert to 55 percent, which means Puerto Rico will have to pay a much larger share of Medicaid costs. While each state’s matching rate is tied to its per capita income and can reach as high as 83 percent, the territories’ matching rate is arbitrarily capped at 55 percent (except in recent years when Congress has temporarily raised it), even though their average per capita income is below the level in the poorest states. This means that territories must pay a much larger share of Medicaid costs for their residents than most states do, despite the states having higher average incomes. But that isn’t the only funding challenge facing the territories’ Medicaid programs. Unlike the states, whose federal funding is uncapped, the territories receive a fixed amount of funding in the form of a capped block grant, or allotment. Generally, this block grant has fallen well short of the funding that’s needed, and well short of what the territories would have received if they had access to the same uncapped funding structure as is available to states. Since 2010, Congress has periodically provided the territories with time-limited relief through supplemental funding and increased matching rates. But these temporary fixes and their associated funding cliffs have never provided the stable and adequate funding the territories need to improve their programs and provide coverage and benefits equal to the states. This funding uncertainty has meant that the territories operate precarious health care systems that are on the brink of draconian cuts in eligibility, benefits, and provider reimbursement rates. And the lack of open-ended funding means their Medicaid programs cannot respond to an increase in need during recessions, pandemics, and hurricanes and other natural disasters. Permanent changes to provide adequate allotments and matching rates would provide certainty and stability to make such changes possible. In the case of Puerto Rico, the upcoming Medicaid funding cliff is like no other. Not only is the territory in danger of seeing its Medicaid matching rate drop to 55 percent, it could see a disastrous decrease in its allotment if Congress reverses the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) interpretation that its future allotments should be based on its 2020 allotment. Reversing that interpretation would mean Puerto Rico’s block grant would plummet, decreasing from almost $3 billion to about $400 million in 2023. Members of the Republican Party have repeatedly and explicitly called for the repeal of the CMS interpretation. If Congress reverses the interpretation, it will need to provide a larger funding increase to Puerto Rico than would have been needed had the interpretation remained in place, to ensure that people in Puerto Rico have access to the Medicaid services they need. (CMS’ determination of allotments for the other territories is not in question although their allotments have also long been inadequate.) A large decrease in Medicaid funding, as would occur if the CMS interpretation is overturned and adequate resources are not added, would be a massive shock to Puerto Rico’s health care system. Because the CMS interpretation provides permanent ongoing allotments well above the original statutory level, Puerto Rico no longer sets aside extra funding to compensate for a potential loss in federal Medicaid funding. Further, it would deal a massive blow to Puerto Rico’s balance sheet, as the territory would have to make up for any shortfalls in federal funding for its health care system. The latest fiscal plan certified by Puerto Rico’s fiscal oversight board includes contingencies for a drop in the territory’s federal matching rate in view of the expiration of the appropriations package in December, but not for the allotments. A sudden loss of federal funding of this magnitude would almost certainly force Puerto Rico to find ways to prevent its Medicaid system from collapsing — and in doing so, it would also force the territory, within its limited means, to pull funding away from other critical areas. The immediate repercussions would likely include cuts in Medicaid eligibility, benefits, and provider payments; the elimination of contributions to a newly minted pension trust for public sector workers, which puts that system’s future at risk; and a reduction in funding for other areas critical to Puerto Rico’s economic health such as long-term capital investments and emergency reserve needs. These cuts would be nothing short of devastating for the territory, which is grappling with wide-scale damages caused by Hurricane Fiona while emerging from an arduous bankruptcy process, and still reeling from years of economic decline, natural disasters, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Even with the higher Medicaid amounts under the CMS interpretation, Puerto Rico and the other territories still lack the stable, adequate funding to operate a Medicaid program on par in terms of eligibility, benefits, and provider payments with the programs in states. Come December, Congress should take a first step by increasing Puerto Rico and the other territories’ allotments to a level more in line with their needs, and increase their federal matching rates to be more comparable with states. Ultimately, U.S. citizens and nationals in Puerto Rico and the other territories should have access to the same Medicaid program as those living in states. Establishing full funding parity — that is, eliminating the block grant structure and providing open-ended federal funding — is what’s ultimately needed to help the territories provide high-quality health care to their residents, better weather economic downturns, recover from natural disasters, and respond to other emergencies.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

6] Social Security in Puerto Rico is terrible

Cheatham 2022 [Acc: September 29, 2022. The Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) is an independent, nonpartisan membership organization, think tank, and publisher to help them better understand the world and the foreign policy choices facing the United States and other countries. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/puerto-rico-us-territory-crisis#chapter-title-0-4]

Puerto Rico also lacks economic sovereignty. The U.S. dollar is its currency, U.S. federal regulators oversee its businesses, and U.S. laws dictate its trade policy. Residents pay most federal taxes; their contributions totaled more than $4 billion in fiscal year 2021. However, Puerto Ricans generally do not pay federal income tax, and they continue to enjoy the tax exemptions that have historically incentivized outside investment. Largely because of these exemptions, residents receive fewer federal benefits than other Americans. Puerto Rico residents are ineligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit and earn less, on average, in Social Security and veterans’ benefits. However, some benefits could change as a result of legal challenges. In August 2020, a district court judge ruled that denying island residents several forms of federal assistance, including Supplemental Security Income (SSI), is unconstitutional. The federal government appealed the decision, and in November 2021, the case was heard by an appeals court, which held that Puerto Rico’s exclusion from the SSI program violates the Fifth Amendment. In April 2022, the Supreme Court reversed that decision. Like most U.S. states, the island receives billions of dollars more in federal spending, including on Medicare and Social Security, than its residents pay in taxes. In addition, the U.S. government has allocated more than $25 billion in disaster-recovery funding to the island since 2017. Puerto Rico continues to be ravaged by a sustained recession. Annual economic growth fell by roughly 12.5 percent overall between 2004 and 2020, while Puerto Rico’s population shrunk by more than 16 percent. It has also struggled under a large public debt in recent years, totaling about $70 billion—or 68 percent of gross domestic product (GDP)—in 2020. Puerto Rico’s downward spiral has been compounded by natural disasters, government mismanagement and corruption, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Unable to borrow on global markets, Puerto Rico was in economic limbo for years after turning over its budget to an independent control board appointed by Washington as part of a plan to restructure its debts. Making matters worse, in 2019, U.S. authorities arrested former high-level officials in a corruption scandal, leading to the resignation of Governor Ricardo Rosselló. The island’s average household income is about one-third of the U.S. average, and its poverty rate is more than twice that of the poorest state, Mississippi. Meanwhile, the territory’s unemployment rate has stayed at almost twice the national average for the past decade, at times reaching double digits. However, it fell to about 8 percent in 2021 and has continued to drop. Experts say the island’s economic crisis is rooted in [PDF] twentieth-century legislation that encouraged Puerto Rico’s reliance on debt to fill federal funding gaps. It did this by giving bond investors higher returns and loosening borrowing limits. Since 1917, lenders to Puerto Rico have been exempt from local, state, and federal taxes—the so-called triple tax exemption—effectively boosting their profits and making the island a more attractive investment. The territory’s constitution also allows Puerto Rico to balance its budget with its debt, among other provisions that facilitate borrowing. The debt problem accelerated after 1996, when the U.S. government began phasing out Internal Revenue Code Section 936. This provision had allowed American businesses to operate tax-free in Puerto Rico, which critics viewed as a windfall for wealthy corporations. Section 936’s repeal triggered a deterioration of Puerto Rico’s manufacturing sector, and the territorial government increasingly turned to debt to cover its spending. The 2008 global financial crisis hit Puerto Rico especially hard, with the recession further lowering tax revenues, souring an early-2000s construction boom, and giving investors pause. The territorial government implemented austerity measures, including layoffs of public workers, that sent unemployment soaring. It also crafted dubious deals to balance its budget, including letting government agencies borrow from one another to pay back bonds. On top of that, experts say, much of this money was poorly spent. Leaders failed to parlay the billions of dollars they borrowed into strong institutions, a deficit laid bare by the natural disasters that have devastated Puerto Rico’s underfunded and poorly maintained infrastructure. Hurricane Maria brought ruin to the island in 2017, causing about three thousand deaths [PDF], knocking out the electrical power grid, and costing tens of billions of dollars. An earthquake at the start of 2020, the island’s strongest in a century, also created a power blackout. Months later, the pandemic exposed the territory’s disjointed and inefficient health system, which critics say has impeded care for COVID-19 patients. In September 2022, Hurricane Fiona triggered severe flooding and mudslides and knocked out power to more than one million homes and businesses. The combination of government mismanagement and unrelenting natural disasters has driven an exodus from the territory, further depressing economic activity, crippling schools and other institutions, and leaving fewer taxpayers to shoulder the debt. More than 130,000 residents fled to the mainland after Hurricane Maria alone. Today, more people of Puerto Rican descent live on the mainland than on the island, and a 2019 study projected that the territory’s population would fall by another 8 percent [PDF] by 2024.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

5] Social Security, including Medicare, is destined to fail

Seitz 31 [Acc: Mar 31, 2023. PBS NewsHour is the most centrist news program on television and the closest to a truly objective stance. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/medicare-social-security-could-fall-short-over-next-decade-report-says]

WASHINGTON (AP) — The financial safety nets millions of older Americans rely on and millions of young people are counting on will run short of money to pay full benefits within the next decade, the annual Social Security and Medicare trustees report released Friday warns. Medicare, the government-sponsored health insurance that covers 65 million older and disabled people, will be unable to pay full benefits for inpatient hospital visits and nursing home stays by 2031, the report forecast. And just two years later, Social Security won’t have enough cash on hand to pay out full benefits to its 66 million retirees. The report is another prod for politicians to address the fragile financial state of the social programs, which are only expected to get more expensive in the coming years as more Americans age into eligibility for them. “The Trustees continue to recommend that Congress address the projected trust fund shortfalls in a timely fashion to phase in necessary changes gradually,” said Kilolo Kijakazi, acting commissioner of Social Security. Friday’s report is a mix of good and bad news: The forecasted go-broke date for Medicare was moved back three years — last year’s report predicted the government wouldn’t have enough money to start paying those benefits in 2028. But the date for Social Security’s trust was moved up one year earlier. On its current track, Medicare would be able to cover only 89 percent of costs for patients’ hospital visits, nursing home stays and home health care starting in 2031. Social Security, meanwhile, will be able to cover only 77 percent of benefits starting in 2033. Social Security’s disability trust fund is in much better shape — it’s not expected to be depleted within the next 75 years. The future of Social Security and Medicare has become a top political talking point as President Joe Biden heads into his expected 2024 reelection campaign. Biden, a Democrat, has vowed to rebuff any Republican-led efforts to cut Medicare or Social Security benefits to brace for the shortfall. Instead, he’s pitched raising taxes on some of the country’s wealthiest people, those making $400,000 or more a year, to shore up Medicare. Republican leaders, meanwhile, say they don’t intend to ax benefits either, but they’ve yet to coalesce behind a plan to keep the programs solvent. Last year, however, members of the House Republican Study Committee proposed raising the age at which someone could qualify for Social Security and Medicare. Peterson Foundation CEO Michael Peterson said ahead of the report’s release that “if lawmakers do nothing, in less than a decade more than 70 million beneficiaries would face an automatic 23 percent cut, reducing the average benefit by several thousand dollars per year. We simply can’t let that happen.” “The sooner we act, the easier it will be to ensure the future of Social Security,” he said. “Lawmakers shouldn’t take anything off the table, and the good news is there are plenty of reasonable options on both the revenue and spending side of the ledger to implement fair, gradual and common sense reforms.” Lawmakers have for years kicked Social Security and Medicare’s troubling math to the next generation. Social Security benefits were last reformed 40 years ago, when the federal government raised the eligibility age for the program from 65 to 67. The eligibility age has never changed for Medicare, with people accessing the medical coverage when they turn 65. The funds’ future should be a top priority for Congressional leaders, AARP CEO Jo Ann Jenkins said in a statement, calling on elected officials to hammer out a plan. “Today’s Social Security and Medicare Trustees reports reinforce that while they are financially strong today, both programs face long-term funding needs, and Congress must act to find solutions to ensure Social Security and Medicare will be there for the next generation and into the future,” Jenkins said.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

4] Social Security is bound to collapse by 2033

Horsley 2023 [Acc: March 31, 2023. Scott Horsley is NPR's Chief Economics Correspondent. He reports on ups and downs in the national economy as well as fault lines between booming and busting communities. https://www.npr.org/2023/03/31/1167378958/social-security-medicare-entitlement-programs-budget]

The Social Security program is expected to run short of cash to pay promised benefits in about ten years, while a key trust fund for Medicare will run out of funds by 2031, according to new forecasts issued Friday by trustees of both programs. The projections serve as an annual reminder that the popular programs rest on shaky financial footings. While any effort to patch them is sure to face stiff political opposition, doing nothing is likely to be worse. Social Security benefits for retirees and others are primarily paid for through payroll taxes on current workers, and are supplemented by a trust fund. High inflation leads to the biggest raise in Social Security in more than 40 years. Benefits paid out by the program have exceeded money coming in since 2021, and the trust fund is now expected to be depleted by 2033. That's a year earlier than forecast last year, thanks in part to slower economic growth. Unless changes are made before then to shore up the program, 66 million Social Security recipients would see their benefits cut by 23-25%. Meanwhile, the Medicare trust fund, which supplements payments to hospitals and nursing homes, is also running out of cash. That could result in an 11% pay cut to health care providers unless changes are made by 2031. That deadline is three years later than had been forecast last year. Millions depend on Social Security, Medicare Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, who leads the trustees, stressed the importance of propping up both trust funds to avoid draconian cuts in benefits and provider payments. "Social Security and Medicare are two bedrock programs that older Americans rely upon for their retirement security," Yellen said in a statement. "The Biden-Harris Administration is committed to ensuring the long-term viability of these critical programs so that retirees can receive the hard-earned benefits they're owed." President Biden speaks during an event to discuss Social Security and Medicare held at the University of Tampa on Feb. 09, 2023 in Tampa, Florida. The Medicare trust fund, which supplements payments to hospitals and nursing homes, is running out of cash. Joe Raedle/Getty Images As part of its budget, the Biden administration proposed extending the life of the Medicare trust fund by 25 years, largely through higher taxes on wealthy individuals. The administration has not proposed similar fixes for Social Security. The primary challenge for Social Security is demographic. As aging baby boomers retire, there are fewer workers paying into the program to support the rising cost of benefits. As of last year, there were just 2.7 workers paying into the system for each person drawing Social Security benefits. Additionally, a smaller fraction of income is now subject to the payroll taxes that support Social Security. Patching the program will require higher taxes, lower benefits or some combination of the two. "The only responsible thing to do is admit that we've got to make changes and we disagree about how to do it but let's sit down and try to figure those out," said Maya Macguineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. "If we wait until the last minute, they'll be much, much harder."

2023 DDI Negative
Case

3] The expansion of Social Security is a fake façade, used by the far right to say that they “help” the oppressed, but then refer to the recipients as a welfare queen.

Dow ‘15 [Dow, D. M. (2015). Negotiating “The Welfare Queen” and “The Strong Black Woman”: African American Middle-Class Mothers’ Work and Family Perspectives. Sociological Perspectives, 58(1), 36–55. ] [CL] // re-cut David

During the early part of the twentieth century when pensions were created to enable widowed mothers to stay at home to care for their children, African American mothers were generally denied access to these benefits (Glenn, Chang, and Forcey 1994; Gordon 1994; Quadagno 1994). Social historian Linda Gordon (1994) has described how the administrators of these programs, particularly those in southern states, believed that African American mothers did not need financial assistance because they had always worked outside of the home. In 1935, Mothers’ Pensions became a part of the Social Security Act’s Aid to Dependent Children with the condition that states retain discretion in determining who was eligible to receive these benefits. This ensured that beneficiaries initially continued to be primarily white mothers (Abramovitz 1996). Indeed, in the 1960s, when beneficiaries began to include a larger number of African American mothers, these recipients were increasingly demonized by conservative politicians as deceitful and unworthy of benefits (Hirschmann and Liebert 2001). Ronald Reagan first used the term welfare queen during his 1976 Republican presidential campaign to describe a mythical black woman from the South Side of Chicago who was unjustly receiving aid. He said, There’s a women in Chicago. She has eighty names, thirty addresses, twelve Social Security cards and is collecting veteran’s benefits on four non-existing deceased husbands . . . She’s got Medicaid, getting food stamps and she is collecting welfare under each of her names. Her tax-free cash income alone is over $150,000. (Washington Star 1976)  

2023 DDI Negative
Case

2] The history of social security is rooted in systematic oppression of Black people that has extracted wealth from black bodies. Historically, fiscal redistribution has acted as a way to oppress and dehumanize black bodies.

Holtz ’96 [Geoffrey T. Holtz is the author of the book "Welcome to the Jungle: the Why Behind Generation X," and has written and lectured widely on litigation and intellectual property matters. He is admitted to practice to practice in all of the U.S. District Courts in California and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Holtz, Geoffrey T. Social Security Discrimination against African-Americans: An Equal Protection Argument, repository.uclawsf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3259&context=hastings_law_journal. Accessed 12 July 2023.] *we don’t endorse gendered language // re-cut David

In enacting the Social Security Act of 1935, Congress was doubtless acting primarily out of concern for the financial situation of older Americans, a dire situation made worse by the Great Depression. However, the details of the Act were the subject of great debate. A complete history of the 1935 legislation is beyond the scope of this Note, but a few illustrations of this debate indicate that racism played a significant role in the design of the program. Southern congressmen were opposed to federal encroachment on the states' ability to set their own standards for determining benefits and to differentiate among individuals in whatever manner the states considered reasonable. In particular, the southern delegation was averse to providing any aid to African-Americans. Edwin E. Witte, the Executive Director of the Committee on Economic Security in 1934-35, has written that "[t]he southern members did not want to give authority to anyone in Washington to deny aid to any state because it discriminated against negroes in the administration of old age assistance. The Jackson (Mississippi) Daily News editorialized, "The average Mississippian can't imagine himself chipping in to pay pensions for able-bodied negroes to sit around in idleness on front galleries, supporting all their kinfolks on pensions, while cotton and corn crops are crying for workers to get them out of the grass."' Senator Byrd of Virginia, a member of the Senate Finance Committee in 1935, voiced a concern shared by nearly all the southern delegation on the Social Security committees that the measure might serve as an "entering wedge" for federal interference with the handling of "the Negro question" in the South. Edwin Witte, whose committee was largely responsible for drafting the Act, writes that due to the southern resistance, "it was apparent that the bill could not be passed as it stood," given the inclusion of African-Americans in the program. During the Senate Hearings on the bill, National Association for the Advancement of Colored People representative Charles H. Houston urged passage of the bill in its original form while acknowledging the difficulties in getting any southern congressmen to vote for a bill "if Negroes are to benefit from it in any large measure."81 Nevertheless, in order to procure the necessary support of the southern legislators, substantial modifications to the bill were made before the final vote which adversely affected African-Americans in ways that continue to the present. The Act omitted from coverage agricultural and domestic workers, excluding 3.5 million of 5.5 million African-American workers. This was despite-or because of-testimony before the House Committee on Labor that "[p]ractically 85% of the Negroes in the South are agricultural workers. In addition, the southern opposition forced a compromise that returned much of the control over Social Security to the states. This allowed the states to include racially discriminatory practices in the administration of the program. For example, many Social Security programs in the South operated under "the assumption that the Standard of living of the Negro and his cost of living do not rise above the barest subsistence. Consequently, "there was a tendency to grant lower sums, especially in the South, to aged blacks than to aged whites. Amendments to the Act which Congress later passed exacerbated these direct, intentional adverse effects on African-American workers. For example, while in 1939 Congress added spouse and widow benefits to those (largely white) workers who were covered under the Act, the majority of occupations in which African-Americans were employed remained excluded from coverage. Finally, the choice of age 65 as the threshold for eligibility for retirement benefits in 1935 reflected a disregard for an already stark discrepancy in life expectancies between African-Americans and whites at the time. While 52.9 percent of white male and 60.5% of white female Americans could be expected to reach this retirement age and start collecting benefits, only 29.3% of male and 30.8% of female African-Americans could do so. Thus, even for those African-Americans who worked in areas that were covered under the Social Security Act, 70% could expect to die before receiving a single benefit check.

2023 DDI Negative
Case

1] Social security is racist.

This card just says social security isn’t good for black people compared to whites but that doesn’t matter for Puerto rico

Baldwin 21 -- [William Baldwin is a senior contributor to forbes, "Is Social Security Racist?," Forbes, 8-25-2021, https://www.forbes.com/sites/baldwin/2021/08/25/is-social-security-racist/?sh=35650a7e4ab1, accessed 7-18-2023] // David

Yes—although it’s not as bad as it used to be. Two elements of Social Security contribute to racial inequality. One is that the system rewards marriage. The other is that it rewards longevity. Black people get shortchanged on both scores. It’s one more illustration of how a seemingly neutral system can have injustice built into it. The marriage benefit is a large one. While both members of a couple are alive, a spouse with a small or nonexistent paid work history can collect 50% of the other spouse’s benefit. Also, when one of them dies, the survivor gets the larger of his/her own benefit or the other spouse’s benefit. So two people who are married get a larger return on the Social Security taxes they have paid than the same two people would have gotten from the same taxes if they had stayed single. Blacks tend to miss out on the marriage bonus; 50% have never married, versus 34% for the population as a whole. As for the longevity gap: It’s smaller than it used to be, but still significant. Blacks at age 65 have a life expectancy of 18.0 years, whites 19.4 years. Which is to say, whites who collect get benefits for more years. Now consider the people who chip in but never collect. Blacks alive at 30 have a 21% probability of being dead by age 65; the corresponding figure for whites is 15%. The good news in this part of the story is that health is improving and the longevity gap is narrowing. Between 1999 and 2013, reports the National Center for Health Statistics, life expectancy at birth for the whole U.S. increased from 77.3 to 79.1 years; during that time the racial gap at birth narrowed from 5.9 to 3.6 years.

2023 DDI Negative
51st State CP › 1NC – Shell

Making Puerto Rico the 51st state would give them equal benefits and pull them out of an imminent financial crisis – and this can only be done through Congress

Stout 4/21 Nolan Stout is a reporter covering federal agencies for Courthouse News Services. He has his Bachelor’s Degree in communications from High Point University. “Bill introduced to resolve Puerto Rico status.” Courthouse News Service. //AKA

WASHINGTON (CN) — Sinking beneath the weight of tens of billions of dollars in debt, the trappings of paradise in Puerto Rico belie an island where poverty is rampant and communities struggle to rebound from years-ago disasters like Hurricane Maria, to say nothing of the Covid-19 pandemic. Any discussion of the predicament inevitably leads back to the U.S. territory's nonstate identity. This week, on the mainland, members of Congress renewed legislative efforts to resolving the island's status. If it were a state, Puerto Rico, home to more than 3.28 million U.S. citizens, would rank 30th in population. But it has been hemorrhaging residents over the past 20 years, with more than 522,000 people leaving between 2000 and 2020, mostly to seek better opportunities in the continental U.S. About 40.5% of Puerto Ricans live in poverty, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, more than triple the national poverty rate of 12.8% and double the rate of 19.4% in Mississippi, the poorest state in the union. Median household income on the island is only $22,237, compared with $69,717 nationwide and $48,716 in Mississippi. Puerto Ricans generally don’t pay federal tax on income earned on the island, but they are not equally eligible for some federal programs either. Even as citizens, they cannot vote in U.S. presidential elections and do not have a voting representative in Congress. “That is fundamentally undemocratic,” George Laws Garcia, executive director of the Puerto Rico Statehood Council, said in an interview. “It goes against America’s core founding value which is government by the consent of the governed.” The House of Representatives passed a measure in December to hold a binding election on the island’s future, but it never made it to the Senate floor. Because Puerto Rico has no elected representation in the chamber, legislation the island considers favorable has historically struggled in the Senate even if it manages to clear the House, Laws Garcia noted. Even so, he said, “the fact that there was House passage in December was still a huge, huge, huge step in the process." This past Thursday, the legislation was reintroduced, offering Puerto Ricans a choice between statehood, independence or independence with free association with the U.S. “After more than one hundred years of colonial rule, Puerto Ricans need a democratic mechanism to determine their own future,” Representative Nydia Velazquez said in a press release. “The people of Puerto Rico must decide their future, and Congress has the responsibility and power to facilitate that process.” Puerto Rico’s nonvoting member of Congress, Representative Jenniffer Gonzalez-Colon, put it more bluntly: "Territorial status is the problem and cannot be part of the solution." “The people of Puerto Rico have voted on multiple occasions for Statehood and this bill provides the mechanism to achieve that quest,” she said in a press conference. “Nothing comes above the people’s will. The Constitution clearly states that solving Puerto Rico's political status is Congress' responsibility. After 125 years of debate the time has come for Congress to commit to real action and end our shameful territorial reality.” Puerto Rico is officially a commonwealth under its 1952 constitution, but it remains an unincorporated territory along with Guam, American Samoa, the Northern Mariana Islands and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The commonwealth status removed it from the United Nations’ list of non-self-governing territories and freed the U.S. from mandated annual reports, but the international body has still criticized its status as recently as June 2022. “The label ‘commonwealth’ was intended to erase ‘colony,’ but it effectively assured that the island would remain a US colony indefinitely,” Ed Morales, a professor at Columbia University, wrote in the 2019 book "Fantasy Island." For more than 500 years, Puerto Rico has been held as a colony of a larger country, stretching back to Christopher Columbus’ second voyage to the Americas. It was one of the spoils of war that went to the U.S. after the Spanish-American War in 1898, and David Badillo, a professor of Latino studies at Lehman College, said it established the new emerging county's influence at the edge of the Caribbean. But Washington gave little thought to the island’s political future. “The United States wasn’t sure what to do with it after the Spanish-American War,” Badillo said in an interview. “It’s been over 100 years, and Puerto Rico is still indeterminate.” Puerto Rico’s legal standing was cemented in 1901 through what are known the Supreme Court's Insular Cases, which declared that Puerto Rico, the Philippines and Guam “belong to, but are not part of the United States.” Laws Garcia noted that all but one of the justices who upheld racial segregation under Plessy v. Ferguson also ruled in the Insular Cases. Eventually Plessy was overturned, but the precedent of the Insular Cases remains. “We’re still under a legal framework set by the Supreme Court that we can be not only separate, but we can be unequal,” he said. “There’s no way to achieve full equality as U.S. citizens under the territory status.” Movements for statehood and independence have grown and waned over the decades, sometimes violently. Nationalist uprisings in the 1950s culminated in a shooting on the floor of Congress, the attempted assassination of President Harry Truman and the only instances that the military has conducted air bombings of U.S. citizens. Badillo said the current status debate is driven by the island’s bleak economic situation, which is fueled by U.S. development policies, accumulating debt and tax laws. Throughout Puerto Rico’s history, the United States has sought to encourage outside economic investment rather than sustained indigenous development. For a large part of its history, corporations were able to get a special tax break by going to the island, but that was phased out by 2006. The island’s government has been buried in debt through the complex business of municipal bonds, which are used by local, state, territorial or federal entities to take out loans. The bonds are primarily used for onetime capital expenses or projects, with governments frequently warned by their financial and legal departments that using the funds for ongoing expenses can create a cycle of debt. Municipal bonds can be more attractive to local investors because they offer some form of federal tax exemption. For nearly all such bonds, the exemption has narrowly focused to apply if the person purchasing the bonds resides within the state issuing them. But in Puerto Rico, the Jones-Shaforth Act of 1917 created triple tax exemption regardless of where the purchaser lives. A succession of governors turned to bonds to fund operating expenses over the years, causing the island’s debt to accumulate. By 2015, then-Governor Alejandro Padilla said the island’s debt was an “unpayable” $72 billion. The heaviest blow came at the turn of the century when federal tax reform law prohibited Puerto Rico from seeking bankruptcy relief. “Without bankruptcy protection, Puerto Rico could never default on the bonds — they would always be required to pay back in full,” Morales wrote in "Fantasy Island." In response to the debt crisis, Congress passed a bankruptcy law called the Promesa Act, which created an unelected federal oversight board to manage the island’s finances. The board, which some Puerto Ricans derisively call la junta, was given final say over any decisions by the Legislature or governor that involved spending money. In January 2022, a federal judge approved an agreement between the board and the island’s government to cut $33 billion in debt obligations, reducing annual payments to about $1 billion. The deal avoided cuts to public pensions, but critics worried that without structural reforms, the island is likely to return to the same financial struggles. Laws Garcia said the debt crisis is “intricately, fundamentally and structurally connected” to Puerto Rico’s territorial status. Because islanders receive stronger rights and benefits as citizens on the mainland, Puerto Rico’s government faces pressure to keep up with progress in the states, he noted. “The only way politicians can try to meet that demand from constituents is by borrowing,” he said. Badillo opined that Puerto Rico also is plagued by a political system that seems to promote uncertainty about the island’s status by making it difficult to form a coalition across the Legislature and governorship. Puerto Rico’s Legislature has representatives from five political parties, but two have remained the dominant forces over the past half century. The Popular Democratic Party advocates for a continuation of the status quo with semi-autonomy from the United States. The New Progressive Party advocates for statehood, while the smaller Puerto Rican Independence Party favors full independence. A plurality of each chamber of the Legislature is held by the Popular Democrats, which hold the presiding seat in each house. Governor Pedro Pierluisi, however, is with the New Progressives. “The whole structure is almost set up to promote indeterminacy,” Badillo said. “The whole thing is designed toward preserving stasis because there’s so many moving parts.” Martin Kifer, a political science professor at High Point University, said a resolution is difficult because “it’s tough to change the status quo no matter what.” “It just takes a lot — a big push and a recognition of the parties that can make the decision,” he said. Democrats who controlled the U.S. House of Representatives managed to pass last year's bill on Puerto Rican statehood with support from only 16 Republicans. In a Republican-controlled House, the legislation faces an uphill climb from lawmakers who have balked at making the District of Columbia a state. Kifer spoke to some of the partisan forces in play. He said Republicans are unlikely to support statehood for an area they believe would generate more Democrats in Congress and shift the balance of power. It’s hard to estimate exactly how the electorate would fall if Puerto Rico were a state. In the 2016 presidential primary, about 88,000 turned out for the Democratic primary, while about 41,000 voted in the Republican primary. Both sets of numbers pale meanwhile against the roughly 1.3 million who voted in a 2020 referendum on the island’s status. On his campaign website, President Joe Biden promised to “work with representatives who support each of the status options in Puerto Rico to engage in a fair and binding process to determine their own status.” He also pledged to create a federal working group that would ensure the commitment of resources and technical assistance to Puerto Rico The Biden administration gave an update on the working group in a December fact sheet. While it announces several agency programs to support economic growth and hurricane recovery in 2023, there is no mention of a path to resolution of the island’s status. Those on the island have little legislative recourse other than making noise about their status. Laws Garcia said any resolution relies on the will of those on the mainland. “The federal government is holding Puerto Rico as a territory against the will of your fellow U.S. citizens on the island,” he said. “We need U.S. citizens stateside to get interested in this topic.” The White House and leading Puerto Rican politicians did not return multiple requests for comment. Representatives for Gonzalez-Colon said she was unavailable over multiple weeks and did not return a request for emailed comments as of Friday afternoon.

2023 DDI Negative
51st State CP › 1NC – Shell

Granting Puerto Rico with statehood gives citizens higher social security benefits – and the policy is overwhelmingly supported by the population

Matthias ND Meg Matthias is a senior producer at Encyclopedia Britannica. She has a Bachelor’s degree in English. “Why Is Puerto Rico’s Political Status So Complicated?” Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/story/what-was-frederick-douglasss-position-on-womens-rights //AKA

It’s the centuries of colonization, then, that make Puerto Rico’s political status so complicated. Though we can never know what the island would look like if freed from that history, methods of disentangling Puerto Rico from colonial rule have been debated for decades, sometimes in the form of referenda that have usually presented the people of Puerto Rico with three options: Statehood: Puerto Rico would be admitted as the 51st state in the union. The island would receive increased financial help and social security from the U.S. government but lose its current constitution, which is distinct from the U.S. Constitution. In 2012, 61.2 percent of Puerto Rican voters favored statehood over remaining a commonwealth; in 2017, 97 percent (of a small voter turnout) chose statehood over independence or commonwealth status; and in 2020 about 53 percent voted for statehood. Independence: Puerto Rico would become an independent country. It would gain complete and total powers of self-governance, but it would likely struggle economically as it separated from the United States. Proponents of total independence were behind the 47 percent of voters who rejected statehood in 2020 as well as 2017’s small voter turnout. (Because nationalists boycotted the 2017 referendum, only 23 percent of registered voters turned out—a percentage far lower than for most elections, which had drawn more than 80 percent.) Retaining commonwealth status: Puerto Rico would remain a commonwealth of the United States. Some Puerto Ricans have proposed “enhanced commonwealth status,” which would increase the island’s powers of self-rule while retaining a relationship with the United States, or “Sovereign Free Associated State” status, under which Puerto Rico would function as an independent country with strong ties to the United States. However, these latter options have appeared on referenda infrequently. In 2020 Puerto Rico’s sixth referendum presented a straightforward yes-or-no question: “Should Puerto Rico be immediately admitted into the Union as a state?” A majority (52.34 percent) of voters chose yes. Thus, in 2021 came H.R. 1522 (or the Puerto Rico Statehood Admission Act), a bill that may have lacked the referendum’s directness but still clearly made its point: “Puerto Ricans have contributed greatly to the nation and its culture and distinguished themselves in every field of endeavor. However, the denial of equal voting representation and equal treatment by the Federal Government stands in stark contrast to their contributions.”

2023 DDI Negative
Migration CP › 1NC – Shell

Solves the Aff---Puerto Rican migration has empirically benefits social programs, overpopulation, and economic development.

Meléndez 17 [Edgardo Meléndez is a Professor of Africana and Puerto Rican/Latino Studies at Hunter College-CUNY. “Sponsored Migration: The State and Puerto Rican Postwar Migration to the US.” Centro Voices. Center for Puerto Rican Studies. 25-09-2017. https://centropr-archive.hunter.cuny.edu/centrovoices/reviews/sponsored-migration-state-and-puerto-rican-postwar-migration-us. Accessed 18-07-2023.]/ISJD

What prompted Puerto Rico's government to approve the 1947 migration law that established its migration policy and defined its role in the postwar migration process for decades to come? By 1947 the leadership of the PPD government had reached the same conclusion as previous colonial administrations and conceived migration as the best solution to the perceived problem of overpopulation. Migration became a crucial element in the PPD's social and economic program for postwar Puerto Rico.

As I argue throughout Sponsored Migration, at this time migration was as important for the PPD leadership as were the economic development and the political status issues. In fact, all three were deeply interrelated for them. Migration officials, such as Sierra Berdecía, Clarence Senior, and Joseph Montserrat used to say that the government's migration policy was the other face of Operation Bootstrap. That is, that economic growth and development would have not occurred without the massive exodus of people from Puerto Rico.

2023 DDI Negative
Migration CP › 1NC – Shell

The CP solves---newly-migrated Puerto-Ricans access SSI benefits.

CRS 22 [The Congressional Research Service (CRS), a federal legislative branch agency located within the Library of Congress, serves as shared staff exclusively to congressional committees and Members of Congress. CRS experts assist at every stage of the legislative process — from the early considerations that precede bill drafting, through committee hearings and floor debate, to the oversight of enacted laws and various agency activities. “Equal Protection Does Not Mean Equal SSI Benefits for Puerto Rico Residents, Says Supreme Court.” Congressional Research Service. 28-04-2022. https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/LSB/LSB10737#:~:text=Vaello%2DMadero%2C%20a%20case%20asking,residents%20of%20the%2050%20states. Accessed 18-07-2023.]/ISJD

While living in New York, José Luis Vaello-Madero became eligible for, and began receiving, SSI disability benefits. He later moved to Puerto Rico, where he continued to receive SSI payments. By law, a person must be a resident of the United States to be eligible for SSI benefits. For purposes of the relevant statute, Congress defined “United States” to mean the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Congress extended SSI eligibility to residents of the Northern Mariana Islands in 1976 but has not done so for Puerto Rico or other U.S. territories. Accordingly, the Social Security Administration sued Vaello-Madero to recover the payments he received while living in Puerto Rico. In response, Vaello-Madero argued that excluding Puerto Rico residents from SSI eligibility was unconstitutional—specifically, that it violated his constitutional right to equal protection under the law.

2023 DDI Negative
Congress CP › AT: PDB

Congress and the Courts disagree over social security law---the perm fails due to overrides that deck solvency over government programs.

Widiss 20 [Deborah A. Widiss is Professor of Law, Associate Dean for Research and Faculty Affairs, and Ira C. Batman Faculty Fellow at the Indiana University Maurer School of Law. “Communication Breakdown: How Courts Do — and Don’t — Respond to Statutory Overrides.” Duke Judicature. Vol. 4. No. 1. 2020. https://judicature.duke.edu/articles/how-courts-do-and-dont-respond-to-statutory-overrides/. Accessed 17-07-2023.]/ISJD

Mistakes in Applying New Statutory Language. The ADA Amendments Act of 2008 (ADAAA) explicitly repudiated prior Supreme Court decisions that had interpreted the meaning of “disability” in the Americans with Disabilities Act very stringently. The ADAAA’s stated purpose was to “reinstat[e] a broad scope of protection” under the ADA. It passed with high levels of bipartisan support and was signed by President George W. Bush. Several years after it was enacted, I assessed the degree to which courts were appropriately following the new statutory standards. I found that, with some regularity, courts continued to apply the overridden cases for propositions that were unquestionably superseded by the new statute. The mistakes fell into two categories. First, there were decisions that failed to mention the ADAAA at all, even though the events giving rise to the dispute occurred after the effective date of the ADAAA. These cases simply applied the prior precedent as if the ADAAA had never been enacted. Second, there were many decisions in which courts observed (correctly) that the ADAAA had superseded the pre-ADAAA precedent in some respects but then asserted (incorrectly) that the relevant portion of such precedent still applied, even in contexts where the judicial interpretations at issue were clearly and indisputably incompatible with the new statutory language. Courts also sometimes observed (correctly) that the ADAAA had superseded pre-ADAAA Supreme Court precedent, but then followed circuit court precedent based on the superseded Supreme Court precedent, without acknowledging that the circuit precedent should also be reconsidered in light of the new statutory language. For example, numerous lower courts applied prior Supreme Court and circuit court precedent concerning what was necessary to establish that a plaintiff was “regarded as” having a disability, even though the amended statute established a new, far more flexible standard for “regarded as” claims. Our adversarial system depends primarily on lawyers to identify the relevant law and make arguments that will benefit their clients. I assume that in many of these cases, the lawyers failed to properly use the new statutory standard in their briefs. However, even if lawyers make such mistakes, judges have an independent responsibility to apply the governing statutory law. Additionally, sometimes the party who would have benefited from the new language was pro se, making it even more imperative that judges research the applicable law carefully.

In many instances, the legal mistake may not have affected the outcome of the specific case, as there may have been independent grounds that justified the ultimate decision. However, the error is still problematic. I found several cases in which the flawed reasoning of one court was cited and followed by other courts. In other words, once a court has incorrectly characterized the scope of an override, it can be difficult to stamp out.

2023 DDI Negative
Congress CP › 1NC – Shell

The BBB would extend benefits to people in the “coverage gap”

Park et al. 21 — Edwin Park, a research professor at Georgetown, former health policy advisor for the national economic council, The White House, holds a J.D. from Harvard Law and a B.A. in international affairs from Princeton, Sabrina Corlette, a research professor at Georgetown, holds a B.A. in history and literature from Harvard University and a J.D. from UT Austin, Anne Dwyer, an associate research professor at Georgetown, former US Senator, holds a J.D. in health law and bioethics concentration from University of Minnesota and a B.A. in University of Wisconsin-Madison, Maggie Clark a program director for Georgetown University Health Policy Institute Center for Children and Families, holds a M.A. in Journalism from the University of Maryland and a B.A. in international affairs from FSU, 2021 (“Build Back Better Act: Health Coverage Provisions Explained,” Georgetown University Health Policy Institute, November, available online at https://ccf.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Build-Back-Better-FINAL-Nov19.pdf, accessed 07-24-2023)

On November 19, 2021, the House of Representatives passed the Build Back Better Act, the budget reconciliation bill, with the Senate expected to consider the legislation in coming weeks. The Build Back Better Act includes numerous provisions that would dramatically strengthen and expand both public and private health insurance coverage. Some of the new provisions would build on actions Congress previously took in the American Rescue Plan Act, enacted earlier this year.1

Among its Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) provisions, the Build Back Better Act would permanently require states to provide 12 months of postpartum health coverage and 12 months of continuous coverage for children, make federal funding for CHIP permanent, and provide a permanent, significant increase in federal Medicaid funding for Puerto Rico and the other territories. Among its private insurance provisions, the Build Back Better plan would temporarily extend marketplace subsidies to those in the “coverage gap” in the 12 states that have not yet expanded Medicaid and also extend the availability of the enhanced marketplace subsidies enacted in the American Rescue Plan Act.

2023 DDI Negative
Congress CP › 1NC – Shell

The BBB would significantly increase federal funding for Puerto Rico

Park et al. 21 — Edwin Park, a research professor at Georgetown, former health policy advisor for the national economic council, The White House, holds a J.D. from Harvard Law and a B.A. in international affairs from Princeton, Sabrina Corlette, a research professor at Georgetown, holds a B.A. in history and literature from Harvard University and a J.D. from UT Austin, Anne Dwyer, an associate research professor at Georgetown, former US Senator, holds a J.D. in health law and bioethics concentration from University of Minnesota and a B.A. in University of Wisconsin-Madison, Maggie Clark a program director for Georgetown University Health Policy Institute Center for Children and Families, holds a M.A. in Journalism from the University of Maryland and a B.A. in international affairs from FSU, 2021 (“Build Back Better Act: Health Coverage Provisions Explained,” Georgetown University Health Policy Institute, November, available online at https://ccf.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Build-Back-Better-FINAL-Nov19.pdf, accessed 07-24-2023)

Federal Medicaid funding for Puerto Rico and the other territories — American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands and the U.S. Virgin Islands — is capped, with the block grant amounts set at highly inadequate levels that have forced the territories to operate Medicaid programs that are far less generous than those in the states.11 In addition, the regular matching rate for the territories is officially 55 percent, even though the FMAPs for the territories would equal 83 percent if they were calculated in the same way the matching rate for states is determined, due to the territories lower per-capita income. Over the last decade, Congress has provided additional federal Medicaid funding and FMAP increases over the last decade in order to avoid draconian cuts, respond to recent natural disasters, and to institute modest eligibility, benefit and provider rate improvements. But those increases have always been temporary.

The Build Back Better bill provides a permanent, significant increase in the territories’ block grant amounts. In fiscal year 2022, for example, Puerto Rico’s base block grant amount would be set at $3.6 billion, well above the $2.8 billion level for 2021 that was provided under the latest temporary increase enacted by Congress two years ago. These higher block grant amounts would then be adjusted annually by the percentage increase in national Medicaid spending in the preceding year (as determined using the most recent National Health Expenditure data). In addition, the FMAP for the territories would be permanently increased to 83 percent. The most recent federal funding increase for the territories temporarily raised the FMAP for Puerto Rico to 76 percent and the FMAP for the other territories to 83 percent. Unlike for the other territories, for which the 83 percent FMAP would take effect in fiscal year 2022, Puerto Rico’s matching rate would remain at 76 percent for one year and then rise to 83 percent in 2023. The Build Back Better Act would also require Puerto Rico to maintain physician reimbursement rates at certain minimum levels.12 Otherwise Puerto Rico would see its FMAP reduced by 0.5 percentage points in the first quarter it is out of compliance and then by an additional 0.25 percentage points in subsequent quarters, but not to exceed a total of 5 percentage points.