2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › 1NC › 1NC
Kroenig & Trotti 20 [Matthew Kroenig & Christian Trotti, “Modernization as a Promoter of International Security,” Nuclear Modernization in the 21st Century, edited by Aiden Warren and Philip M. Baxter, 1st ed., Routledge, 02/17/2020, DOI.org (Crossref), doi:10.4324/9780429435829]
Does nuclear modernization promote international security? All the major powers are currently modernizing their strategic nuclear arsenals, and scholars and policymakers are debating the effect of such modernization on international politics. Some argue that nuclear weapons deter a great power war and, therefore, nuclear modernization will contribute to international stability.1 Others claim that modernization programs are fundamentally destabilizing; nuclear weapons are the deadliest weapons ever invented and their continued possession will eventually result in a catastrophic nuclear attack.2
This chapter introduces a third answer to the above question: it depends.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › 1NC › 1NC
Dayen 23 [David, staff at the American Prospect, “The Auto-CR Dilemma,” The American Prospect, 5/30/23, https://prospect.org/economy/2023-05-30-auto-cr-dilemma-debt-ceiling/]
Since my initial rundown of the debt ceiling deal was published, we got the actual text of the agreement. Let’s go through a few particulars that are new:
TANF changes are really a five-state pilot. Most states are not going to be affected. There is a “small checks” scheme where states get families eligible for TANF using their own expenditures. That faces a crackdown, but not until 2025.
2023
DDI
Disadvantage
Politics DA—TT Lab › 1NC › 1NC
Payne, 7/23 [Russell, political reporter at the New York Sun, ‘Senate Vote on Budget Bill Puts Upper Chamber on a Collision Course With House Republicans’, New York Sun, https://www.nysun.com/article/senate-vote-on-budget-bill-puts-higher-chamber-on-a-collision-course-with-house-republicans //alundy]
Putting itself at odds with the House’s spending plans, the Senate Appropriations Committee has added $13.7 billion to the spending limits agreed on in the debt ceiling deal in its markup of its plan for next year’s budget.
The chairwoman of the committee, Senator Murray, struck an agreement with the vice chairwoman, Senator Collins, adding $8 billion in defense spending and $5.7 billion in non-defense spending.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › NEGATIVE › AT: Solvency
Colón-Morera and Cordero-Nieves 22 [José Javier Colón-Morera, Department of Political Sciences, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; Yolanda Cordero-Nieves, Graduate School of Public Administration, CEMGAP, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; “Puerto Rico: Intergovernmental Relations, Territoriality, and the Political Question”; Public Organization Review; November 30, 2022; https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11115-022-00690-1#auth-Jos__Javier-Col_n_Morera]//eleanor
Fiscal policies precede government action. In that sense, fiscal powers are considered "keystones of autonomy" (Agranoff, 2004). Moreover, decisions regarding what gets funded or not are at the core of political control and autonomy (Krane & Wright, 2000). For that reason, most intergovernmental conflicts arise from the need to control public funds through fiscal policy decisions. Puerto Rico, however, is more dependent on federal funds than ever. Federal funds increased consistently from $2,680 billion (27% of the General Fund) in 2000 to $5,617 billion (35%) in 2017. Then, after Hurricane María federal funds increased considerably more reaching $13,437 billion (56%) in 2020 (Economic Report to the Governor, 2006, 2014, 2020). We argue that instead of improving the financial model to create a healthier economy and more employment, the U.S. Government has focused on increasing federal funds, leading to more dependency and less capacity to promote local policies.
The U.S. Government granted Puerto Rico the fiscal autonomy to generate revenues and determine its allocation.Footnote6 Excluding the Island from Federal taxation was a decision taken in the aftermath of the 1898 Treaty of Paris. At the time, and still today, the Puerto Rican economy was too weak to absorb the impact of the Federal taxation system. This exclusion allowed subsidiaries of American companies an exemption from taxation for all income derived from their operations in the U.S. territories to stimulate job creation through, for example, Sect. 936 of the Federal tax code.Footnote7 This exemption made Puerto Rico more attractive to manufacturing and pharmaceutical companies. However, by 1995 the U.S. Congress had doubts about its benefits, and the Puerto Rican pro-statehood government supported its elimination since it was a policy not available to the states (González García, 2017; Maldonado, 2021). It was argued that the number of jobs created by the 936 Section companies was not enough to justify the loss in tax revenue (Hexner & Jenkins, 2016). Therefore, in 2006 it was eliminated. Section 936 was the last significant effort made by the U.S. Government to favor its territories' economic development (Caraballo-Cueto, 2021).
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › NEGATIVE › AT: Solvency
Colón-Morera and Cordero-Nieves 22 [José Javier Colón-Morera, Department of Political Sciences, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; Yolanda Cordero-Nieves, Graduate School of Public Administration, CEMGAP, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; “Puerto Rico: Intergovernmental Relations, Territoriality, and the Political Question”; Public Organization Review; November 30, 2022; https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11115-022-00690-1#auth-Jos__Javier-Col_n_Morera]//eleanor
We argued that the U.S. government opted to offer more federal funds instead of improving the financial model, leading to increased dependency. This unofficial policy debilitates Puerto Rico's self-government and positions the Island on the verge of becoming a mere federal funds administrator. The continuous effort of President Trump to curtail the adequate flow of federal funds to Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria is just an extreme example of the vulnerability of Puerto Rico under the current territorial model. In this sense, the failure of the Federal Government to respond to environmental challenges like the one created by Hurricane Maria is a symptom of a more significant problem. The death of more than three thousand Puerto Ricans during that crisis demonstrated an acute lack of preparedness and the limited political capital possessed by Puerto Rico to force effective Federal action.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: KRITIKS › PDB/LT – 2AC
Lippert-Figueroa 20
(Paul Lippert-Figueroa is a community activist in Puerto Rico, a candidate for San Juan City Council under the democratic-socialist Puerto Rican Independence Party (PIP) and a leader in the campaign “There Are Many Reasons to Vote No” calling on people to vote no in this November’s status referendum. “There Are Many Reasons to Vote “No” on STATEHOOD for Puerto Rico.” The Puerto Rican Community Center. October 23 2020. https://prcc-chgo.org/2020/10/23/there-are-many-reasons-to-vote-no-on-statehood-for-puerto-rico/)//PWD
Granting Puerto Rico statehood would at first glance be the logical solution to reconciling the abuses of the past, and the inconsistencies of this relationship. However, statehood poses many difficulties. Before becoming a state Puerto Rico would have to first become an incorporated territory where we would pay federal taxes without representation. The new federal taxes under statehood would cause the US companies in Puerto Rico to flee their Caribbean tax haven causing massive unemployment and increased poverty, while putting an increased tax-burden on Puerto Rico’s ever-shrinking middle class. The local government would have to cut essential services to decrease the tax-burden, meaning an increased dependence on federal programs. We must ask ourselves: what does real decolonization look like? Will statehood resolve the inequities of Puerto Rico’s relationship with the United States? Does statehood grant Puerto Rico the tools to rebuild and become sustainable?
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: KRITIKS › PDB/LT – 2AC
Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor
All of these efforts require education about history and the state of the law. The fact that the Insular Cases are rarely taught in history classes or law schools shows what erasure from the record can mean for marginalized [*1761] people. The fact that the Insular Cases remain on the books even after Vaello Madero and other cases clearly demonstrate the stark and cruel effects that the incorporation doctrine has had in denying equal protection to U.S. citizens solely because they reside in the U.S. "colony" of Puerto Rico. And it shows just how difficult the battle for racial justice can be even when the facts are presented in a clear and direct way.
The truth about American history and its relationship to current law and social organization must continue to be told.244 This retelling is especially urgent at a time of racial reckoning. Now more than ever, we must confront forces actively engaged in efforts to obscure relevant history, current law, and proven facts as a means of maintaining and reinforcing deeply ingrained and unacceptable inequality in law. Confronting these forces is crucial to fulfilling the American promises of self-governance, equal justice, and equal protection.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: KRITIKS › PDB/LT – 2AC
Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor
Recent developments indicate that the Supreme Court will do little, if anything, to address the untenable status of the territories. The current Court shows scant interest in advancing progress toward equality or improving racial equity and justice Vaello Madero is just one example.221 As Joshi notes, "[i]f the Supreme Court is unable to implement solutions . . . and [*1757] continues to reinforce rather than resolve disputes over America's historical legacies, other segments of society will need to take the lead."222
Thus, a full range of tools organizing, advocacy, legislation, and policy change is needed. All of this, however, must begin with education, through a full account of U.S. history and law based on facts. Education about the Insular Cases as current, de jure discrimination is important to this effort. It encourages those who would otherwise distance themselves from structural and systemic racism to reckon with it. It challenges those who would censor discussions about inequality based on race to argue that the origins and implications of current law should not be taught. Most of all, education highlights the urgent need to examine notions of U.S. identity as a world leader in democracy, liberty, equality, human rights, and anti-colonialism if we are to live up to those ideals.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: COUNTERPLANS › AT: PR Statehood CP – 2AC
Guerrero 21, -- Jean Guerrero is an opinion columnist at the Los Angeles Times. She is a graduate of USC’s journalism school and has a master of fine arts in nonfiction from Goucher. (Jean Guerrero, “Column: Puerto Rico’s future status should not be a pawn in political gameplay”, 3/2/21, LA Times, https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-04-14/op-ed-puerto-rico-future-statehood-status)//EG
For Democrats who want to stop the right-wing assault on democracy, statehood for Puerto Rico can seem like a simple fix — one so enticing it may be easy to forget the will of the Puerto Rican people.
As a Boricua journalist who covers the insurrectionist right and comes from a pro-statehood family, I’d love to see Puerto Rico become a state. But Puerto Rico’s fate is not for any person stateside to dictate.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: COUNTERPLANS › AT: PR Statehood CP – 2AC
Lippert-Figueroa 20
(Paul Lippert-Figueroa is a community activist in Puerto Rico, a candidate for San Juan City Council under the democratic-socialist Puerto Rican Independence Party (PIP) and a leader in the campaign “There Are Many Reasons to Vote No” calling on people to vote no in this November’s status referendum. “There Are Many Reasons to Vote “No” on STATEHOOD for Puerto Rico.” The Puerto Rican Community Center. October 23 2020. https://prcc-chgo.org/2020/10/23/there-are-many-reasons-to-vote-no-on-statehood-for-puerto-rico/)//PWD
Granting Puerto Rico statehood would at first glance be the logical solution to reconciling the abuses of the past, and the inconsistencies of this relationship. However, statehood poses many difficulties. Before becoming a state Puerto Rico would have to first become an incorporated territory where we would pay federal taxes without representation. The new federal taxes under statehood would cause the US companies in Puerto Rico to flee their Caribbean tax haven causing massive unemployment and increased poverty, while putting an increased tax-burden on Puerto Rico’s ever-shrinking middle class. The local government would have to cut essential services to decrease the tax-burden, meaning an increased dependence on federal programs. We must ask ourselves: what does real decolonization look like? Will statehood resolve the inequities of Puerto Rico’s relationship with the United States? Does statehood grant Puerto Rico the tools to rebuild and become sustainable?
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: COUNTERPLANS › AT: PR Independence CP – 2AC
Puerto Rico Report, 13 --- The Puerto Rico Report is an educational resource dedicated to the mission of informing the general public of Puerto Rico's status as a territory of the United States and the related implications of that status (Puerto Rico Report, "Is Independence a Realistic Option for Puerto Rico?", 5-31-2013, PUERTO RICO REPORT, https://www.puertoricoreport.com/is-independence-a-realistic-option-for-puerto-rico/)//EG
Without an appreciation for the fear and despair caused by this century of repression, the small percentage of votes cast for independentista parties makes no sense.
If Puerto Rico were to become independent, there would be no guarantee that Puerto Ricans could keep their U.S. citizenship and ability to travel freely to and from the United States. U.S. tourism to Puerto Rico may also suffer. Puerto Rico would ultimately lose all Federal benefits, including Social Security, law enforcement support, school lunches, etc. It is likely that arrangements with U.S. companies currently maintaining a presence in Puerto Rico would change, but it is not possible to predict the precise nature of those changes. The exchange of goods would be subject to new international trade laws.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › AT: COUNTERPLANS › AT: Free Association CP – 2AC
Puerto Rico Report, 12 --- The Puerto Rico Report is an educational resource dedicated to the mission of informing the general public of Puerto Rico's status as a territory of the United States and the related implications of that status (Puerto Rico Report, “What's Wrong with Free Association for Puerto Rico?", 11/1/12, PUERTO RICO REPORT, https://www.puertoricoreport.com/whats-wrong-with-free-association-for-puerto-rico/)//EG
Free Association is once again being discussed as a possibility for Puerto Rico.
Much of the discussion has centered around abstract ideas of rights and responsibilities. There has also been discussion of the economic consequences of choosing statehood compared with remaining a territory. We looked at the economic implications of the free associated state option with regard to personal income, and at the likely economic benefits of statehood .
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › Abelism A/O
Harris, 23 [Jasmine Harris, professor of law at UPenn with expertise in disability law and antidiscrimination law, 2-22-23, ‘Locating Disability Within a Health Justice Framework’, https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/D9190F76D4AF4FDECE2CA9A85AAB749C/S1073110523000062a.pdf/locating-disability-within-a-health-justice-framework.pdf //alundy]
Immigration/nationality status offers another important analytical entry point typical of a health justice framework.48 Positioning disability downstream might miss an important structural barrier to health justice that turns on Aida’s identity as a disabled Puerto Rican. Although Aida’s permanent residence is in New York, she spent four years in Puerto Rico caring for her dying father. Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens; however, pursuant to the Jones Act and the Supreme Court’s decisions in the insular cases, Puerto Rico’s territorial status constrains certain rights, responsibilities, and entitlements of citizenship for those living in Puerto Rico rather than the continental United States. This includes receipt of SSI benefits.49 Congress’s decision to exclude residents of Puerto Rico from eligibility for the SSI safety net program meant that Aida’s change in address during that four year period made her ineligible for receipt of SSI benefits.50 Aida, unaware of this, continued to use her benefits during those four years but recently, now living in New York again, received a letter from the Social Security Administration seeking to recoup more than twenty thousand dollars for payments while she lived in Puerto Rico or potentially face additional monetary and even potential criminal charges for “fraud.”51 Housing offers another analytical path to understand disability within the health justice framework. Disability as demographic enhances an understanding of Aida’s housing precarity, another typical element of a health justice framework. Aida and her family reside in public housing regulated by the New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA), the largest public housing administration in the country.52 Aida has lived in the same NYCHA unit since she was a child and, despite years of open work orders seeking to address heating and plumbing issues, Aida could not secure affordable housing elsewhere in New York City and the waitlists for other subsidized housing, including for other units in the same public housing development, were years long for similar conditions.53 Aida has chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in addition to cerebral palsy, the former which has been exacerbated by mold from a leaking pipe. A recent study reported that more than eighty percent of NYCHA buildings had mold and other conditions that could contribute to asthma in children, one of the leading causes of school absence. In 2008, for example, school-aged children missed more than 10.5 million school days, with children from low-income communities among those most affected by school absences.54 A health justice analysis that tracks disability (asthma and COPD as a product of or corollary to mold exposure) solely as a health outcome for vulnerable populations along the axis of race, fails to capture the compounded discrimination Aida experiences as a disabled Latina. Ensuring access to healthcare, reducing cost, or improving its quality will not resolve health inequities for Aida or others who are similarly situated.55 Moreover, Aida’s disabilities cannot be reduced to her environment; for example, Aida’s cerebral palsy, while congenital, has actual functional impairments that cause her pain. To reduce her disability to a social construction alone ignores the lived reality of physical pain. Finally, health justice interrogates law as a source of health inequities. Situating Aida as a disabled person, the question becomes “how do law and policies create or reinforce health inequities for disabled people?” Aida’s case study demonstrates the ways in which laws and policies designed by and for able-bodied and neurotypical individuals have created an inaccessible world where disabled people must ask ablebodied and neurotypical individuals and institutions to accommodate them, individually, without expecting the fundamental redesigns that change the baseline norms themselves. The following part argues that shifting disability in a health justice framework offers a descriptively richer and more complete account of health inequities and opens remedial avenues available when disability is understood as demographic in addition to evidence of health inequity.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › Precedent A/O – SS Spillover IL
De Vogue, 23 [Ariane de Vogue, reporter for CNN covering the Supreme Court and legal issues, CNN, 4-21-23, ‘Supreme Court Rules Puerto Ricans don’t have constitutional right to some federal benefits’, https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/21/politics/puerto-rico-supreme-court-federal-disability-benefits/index.html#:~:text=He%20noted%20that%20residents%20of,for%20Social%20Security%20and%20Medicare //alundy]
The Biden administration had defended the exclusion, noting that most Puerto Ricans are exempt from federal taxes, so Congress could take into consideration that reduced contribution when excluding them from some disability benefits. A government lawyer stressed that it would be up to Congress to extend the benefits, and President Joe Biden has already called on Congress to do so.
“It is always appropriate for Congress to take account of the general balance of benefits and burdens associated with a particular federal program,” deputy Solicitor General Curtis Gannon told the justices at oral arguments.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › Precedent A/O – SS Spillover IL
Rubin 22 (Lisa Rubin is a former litigator and an MSNBC legal analyst.; “Puerto Rico, precedent, and a surprising concurrence”; MSNBC; April 21, 2022; https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/puerto-rico-precedent-surprising-concurrence-rcna25503)
Today, I learned something about our federal law that I’ll confess to never knowing before. Under Supreme Court precedent dating back to 1901, the federal government does not have to grant the full range of constitutional rights to residents of the U.S. territories. And also today, SCOTUS extended that line of cases, ruling that Congress was within its rights to exclude Puerto Rico residents from the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program, even where the applicant is a U.S. citizen. How is that possible, you ask? Well, let’s start with the basics. SSI is a federal benefits program for those with limited resources and income and who are either disabled or blind. Jose Vaello Madero is a U.S. citizen who lived in New York for nearly three decades. In 2012, he started receiving SSI after he became seriously ill, and he moved to Puerto Rico about a year later. At first, he continued to receive SSI checks. But when the Social Security Administration realized he had moved to Puerto Rico, it not only terminated his benefits but sued him to recover the nearly $30k in checks he had “illegally cashed.” Vaello Madero defended himself, in part, by arguing that under the Fifth Amendment’s equal protection clause, he could not be lawfully excluded from the SSI program. A Puerto Rico-based district court agreed, and the First Circuit affirmed. Today’s ruling by the Supreme Court not only overturns Vaello Maduro’s victory in two lower courts; it’s also awful news for the roughly 300,000 Puerto Ricans who would otherwise qualify for SSI benefits. Justice Sotomayor, whose parents were born in Puerto Rico, was the sole dissenter, and hers is a fiery dissent. She observes, for example, that one of the justifications for excluding residents of the territories from benefit programs is that they contribute fewer federal tax dollars. That’s perverse, Sotomayor, argues when SSI disburses benefits to those too poor to pay much, if any, federal tax. Plus, Sotomayor reasons: If Congress can exclude citizens from safety net programs on the ground that they reside in jurisdictions that do not pay sufficient taxes, Congress could exclude needy residents of Vermont, Wyoming, South Dakota, North Dakota, Montana, and Alaska from benefits programs on the basis that residents of those States pay less into the Federal Treasury than residents of other States. . . . The Court’s holding today suggests that doing so would be constitutional and not a violation of the Constitution’s promise of equal protection of citizens. She doesn’t name those “other states,” but among states that contribute the most in federal tax revenue, it’s not hard to guess her native New York was on her mind. And her dissent ends with this critique of the Court’s treatment of Puerto Ricans as contrasted with their lack of political power: Equal treatment of citizens should not be left to the vagaries of the political process. Because residents of Puerto Rico do not have voting representation in Congress, they cannot rely on their elected representatives to remedy the punishing disparities suffered by citizen residents of Puerto Rico under Congress’ unequal treatment. The Constitution permits Congress to “make all needful Rules and Regulations” respecting the Territories. That constitutional command does not permit Congress to ignore the equally weighty constitutional command that it treat United States citizens equally. I respectfully dissent. But notwithstanding Sotomayor’s sharp dissent, what captivated Supreme Court watchers today was Justice Gorsuch’s concurrence. Its first paragraph alone is a blistering indictment of how Supreme Court precedent institutionalizes and excuses racism: A century ago in the Insular Cases, this Court held that the federal government could rule Puerto Rico and other Territories largely without regard to the Constitution. It is past time to acknowledge the gravity of this error and admit what we know to be true: The Insular Cases have no foundation in the Constitution and rest instead on racial stereotypes. They deserve no place in our law. In other words, Gorsuch admits that today’s result flows directly from a line of early 1900s cases that twisted racist tropes into a constitutional justification. (For more about the Insular Cases, this piece is a helpful, accessible overview.) MADDOWBLOGAfter GOP relies on accused operative, Dems press Comer for answers You might be asking, “Why would Gorsuch concur if, in his view, the majority’s holding rests on cases that are themselves unconstitutional and racist?” The answer — which isn’t satisfying necessarily — is a technical one, as Gorsuch explains: “Rather than ask the Court to overrule the Insular Cases, both sides in this litigation work from the shared premise that the equal protection guarantee under which Mr. Vaello Madero brings his claim is a ‘fundamental’ feature of the Constitution and thus applies in ‘unincorporated’ Territories like Puerto Rico.” That Gorsuch acknowledged the Court’s racism so bluntly stunned many on LegalTwitter. And the irony of his concurrence as the anti-CRT movement sweeps across red states was not lost on some, like The Atlantic’s Adam Serwer, who tweeted, “Shame you can’t teach about this opinion from a Trump appointed justice in many public schools, since it identifies systemic racism in the American legal system.” But for now, no matter how critical Gorsuch was, the reasoning of the Insular Cases remains very much alive.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – Secession !
Kahn 17 [Gretel Kahn is a U3 student currently pursuing a degree in Honours International Development with minors in History and Gender; “Made in the USA: The Question of Puerto Rican Secession”; The McGill International Review; November 16, 2017; https://www.mironline.ca/made-usa-question-puerto-rican-secession/]//eleanor
Several secessionist groups exist on the island. One group, the Autonomy for Puerto Rico Association, boasts about its 300 000 members and argues for reunification with the Spanish motherland. Another group, the Reunification of Puerto Rico with Spain, promotes the same ideals adding that the island would receive more political rights with Spain. While this option seems far-fetched, support for independence is an issue to take seriously, especially in the midst of a humanitarian crisis that is being ignored by the United States. The group Movimiento Nacionalista Revolucionario takes a different approach to independence. In its manifesto, it argues that the colonialist policies of the United States have facilitated the economic crisis Puerto Rico is embroiled in today. It goes a step further by pushing for independence against “Yankee imperialism” in order to stop the exploitation of the Island. Puerto Rico currently stands on a debt of $74 billion which is only expected to further grow as a result of damage incurred from the hurricanes. It is estimated that the cost of the damage may be around $40 billion in lost economic output and $50 billion in property damage. The response of the Fiscal Control Board has been to allocate only $1 billion when it is clear that Puerto Rico will need so much more to get back on track. Puerto Rico’s debt position is clearly unsustainable and it can only recover with a fresh start.
While the humanitarian crisis was propelled by forces of nature, the United States has a history of ignoring Puerto Rico’s financial problems. Last year, Congress passed the ironically named Promesa Law (Promise Law) which was supposed to resolve the debt crisis mentioned above and put Puerto Rico’s economy back on track. The results, however, further aggravated the island’s ability to provide for its citizens. Prior to even contending with the impact of Hurricanes Irma and Maria, Puerto Rico was forced to cut funding to public services and already roughly 46 per cent of the population live below the poverty line. After the hurricanes, the lack of public services was felt further profoundly.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – O-Crime !
Meacham 15 [Carl Meacham, Director of the CSIS Americas Program, served as Senior Advisor for Latin America and the Caribbean on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee; “Why Puerto Rico’s Economy Matters for U.S. Security”; Center for Strategic International Studies; January 27, 2014; https://www.csis.org/analysis/why-puerto-ricos-economy-matters-us-security]//eleanor
But the Puerto Rican economy does matter for the United States—and particularly for U.S. security. Given the island's proximity and ties to the United States—not to mention the perennial (and highly controversial) debate over Puerto Rico's status as a U.S. commonwealth and the ease of entering the United States once on the island—drug trafficking and violent crime in Puerto Rico have direct implications for U.S. security policy in the region. In the absence of a healthy economy and given the shrinking private sector in Puerto Rico, the growth of informal activities—drug trafficking and organized crime chief among them—is the unfortunate consequence.
In 2011, Puerto Rico saw a record-breaking 1,136 murders. According to the World Bank, in 2010 its per capita murder rate exceeded Mexico's by nearly 15 percent—and was almost 500 percent higher than that of the mainland United States.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – O-Crime !
Colón-Morera and Cordero-Nieves 22 [José Javier Colón-Morera, Department of Political Sciences, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; Yolanda Cordero-Nieves, Graduate School of Public Administration, CEMGAP, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; “Puerto Rico: Intergovernmental Relations, Territoriality, and the Political Question”; Public Organization Review; November 30, 2022; https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11115-022-00690-1#auth-Jos__Javier-Col_n_Morera]//eleanor
Puerto Rico is subjected to Federal legislation regarding most areas of governmental action. This includes, among others, citizenship and naturalization, international trade, government's international representation, postal services, interstate commerce regulations, migration, most diplomatic representation, military affairs, monetary policy, and federally defined crimes and drug interdiction.Footnote2 In many ways, Puerto Rico has a subordinate status of a state in modern times but with no meaningful type of political sovereignty. The expansion of federal powersFootnote3 in Puerto Rico is not protected by representation in the Federal system. That is why students of Puerto Rico's political status agree it is a modern variant of colonialism (Cabán, 2017; Rivera Ramos, 2007). Contrary to the case of the federal states, a non-incorporated territory is not represented in the U.S. Senate, has limited representation in the House of Representatives, and Puerto Ricans residing in the territory do not vote in Federal elections. From this point of view, it is a strange case of direct colonial control characterized by a heavy dose of democratic deficit (Torruella, 1988; Trías Monge, 1997; Weiss & Setser, 2019).
As part of this territorial relationship, Puerto Ricans were collectively naturalized as U.S. citizens in 1917 and subsequently granted birthright citizenship (Venator Santiago, 2017). This gives Puerto Ricans free access to the states and the protection of most U.S. individual civil rights. The Island receives, on average, approximately $20 billion in annual transfers from Federal programs related to health, education, family services, and housing (U.S. Spending Profile, 2021–2022). In fact, 33% of the personal income of Puerto Ricans comes from Federal transfers (Economic Report to the Governor, 2020).
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – Pharma !
Garcia and Beverly 21 (Lynne Chandler Garcia is an Assistant Professor of Political Science at the United States Air Force Academy. Michael Beverley is the Vice-Chair and Co-Founder of OneMedical Grouph; “Reinvigorating Puerto Rico’s Pharmaceutical Industry: A U.S. Security Imperative”; Centro Journal; Vol. 33 Issue 2; Summer 2021; https://web.s.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=19ad5725-03b5-438b-b2fa-185df1e64773%40redis&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#AN=152480710&db=a9h)
In the wake of COVID-19, U.S. policymakers have come to the realization that overreliance on foreign manufacture of medical devices, pharmaceuticals, and active pharmaceutical ingredients is a danger to U.S. security. Countries such as China, upon which the U.S. is dependent for pharmaceuticals, could use this dependency to its advantage in a time of conflict by withholding supplies or producing medicines that are laced with contaminants. The U.S. must take action to reshore its pharmaceutical industry and bolster American made products. Historically, Puerto Rico has led the U.S.’s pharmaceutical production, and with the current crisis, Puerto Rico has an opportunity to bolster manufacturing on the Island. This paper explores whether Puerto Rico can reinvigorate its pharmaceutical industry, thereby not only bolstering the island’s crippled economy but also helping the U.S. meet a national security imperative. [Key Words: COVID, pharmaceuticals, national security, reshore, Hurricane Maria, Puerto Rico] The COVID-19 pandemic served as a wakeup call to U.S. policymakers who have come to the grim realization that overreliance on foreign manufacture of medical devices, pharmaceuticals, and active pharmaceutical ingredients (API) is a danger to U.S. security.1 Whereas it was once the world’s leader in producing drugs and medical equipment, the U.S. is now dependent on foreign nations, especially China and India, for many pharmaceutical products, most notably APIs (the core ingredients used to manufacture finished pharmaceuticals) and generic drugs. With overreliance on foreign production of drugs and medical products both a national health problem and a national security issue, the U.S. must take action to reshore the manufacturing of pharmaceutical products. Puerto Rico leads the U.S. in pharmaceutical manufacture, although production in the territory is down after the economic downturn on the Island that began with the repeal of favorable tax laws and continued through Hurricane Maria. This paper explores whether Puerto Rico can reinvigorate its pharmaceutical industry, thereby not only bolstering the Island’s crippled economy but also helping the U.S. meet national health and security imperatives.
2023
DDI
Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – Pharma !
Garcia and Beverly 21 (Lynne Chandler Garcia is an Assistant Professor of Political Science at the United States Air Force Academy. Michael Beverley is the Vice-Chair and Co-Founder of OneMedical Grouph; “Reinvigorating Puerto Rico’s Pharmaceutical Industry: A U.S. Security Imperative”; Centro Journal; Vol. 33 Issue 2; Summer 2021; https://web.s.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=19ad5725-03b5-438b-b2fa-185df1e64773%40redis&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#AN=152480710&db=a9h)
COVID has demonstrated that pandemics and medical crises are national security concerns for which the U.S. must be prepared. The U.S. must regain its ability to independently manufacture enough pharmaceuticals to meet U.S. 62 centro journal • volume xxxiii • number ii • summer 2021 domestic needs and break its reliance on other nations. In doing so, the U.S. will need to follow China’s lead and create incentives for pharmaceutical companies to return to American soil. Tax breaks, grants, and creating special economic zones are possible methods to support the U.S.-based pharmaceutical industry. In April 2020, President Donald Trump signed an executive order requiring federal agencies to buy essential drugs and medical products from U.S.-based manufacturers rather than from overseas. Additionally, Congress passed the CARES Act, an omnibus bill that includes provisions to secure the American supply chain of pharmaceuticals and empowers the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA) to work with private firms to produce COVID-related treatments. Through Operation Warp Speed, BARDA is already providing funding to companies researching COVID treatments that have a U.S. base or extensive American operations. While this is a step in the right direction, it is not enough to return manufacturing to American soil. The U.S. must jump start manufacturing in locations that have a history of pharmaceutical production and many of the resources in place—Puerto Rico might fit this requirement.