Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – Pharma !

Puerto Rican pharmaceuticals are key to US biotech domination – otherwise dependence on foreign pharmaceutical supplies creates security risks.

Garcia and Beverly 21 (Lynne Chandler Garcia is an Assistant Professor of Political Science at the United States Air Force Academy. Michael Beverley is the Vice-Chair and Co-Founder of OneMedical Grouph; “Reinvigorating Puerto Rico’s Pharmaceutical Industry: A U.S. Security Imperative”; Centro Journal; Vol. 33 Issue 2; Summer 2021; https://web.s.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=19ad5725-03b5-438b-b2fa-185df1e64773%40redis&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#AN=152480710&db=a9h)

Puerto Rico’s lack of representation in Congress is a distinct disadvantage. State legislators may not support programs such as more favorable tax treatment through the repeal of GILTI if it has a negative impact on their own constituents. Puerto Rico’s unequal representation means that the territory must rely on the diaspora of Puerto Ricans living on the mainland. Approximately 5.4 million Puerto Ricans live on the mainland, with the largest concentrations in New York, Florida, and New Jersey. Harnessing the political capital of these citizens may be critical in swaying Congressional members to vote for legislation that favors the territory. For this reason, the recent collaboration between Resident Commissioner Jenniffer González Colón and Florida Senator Marco Rubio is sound strategy. Rubio can harness the strong Puerto Rican constituency in Florida while solving a broader U.S. security concern. Further, seeking support for economically distressed zones in general has a wider appeal than legislation aimed just at Puerto Rico. Thus, this type of legislation may have a stronger chance of being supported in Congress than bills aimed at eliminating the GILTI tax. Because solutions to the U.S.’s security issue involving dependency upon foreign pharmaceuticals and solutions to Puerto Rico’s economic crisis ultimately rest on political solutions, Puerto Rico will need to harness enough political capital to secure legislation that puts the Island at the center of reshoring efforts. At the same time, because Puerto Rico is ready to increase pharmaceutical production, almost any legislation to reshore Reinvigorating Puerto Rico’s Pharmaceutical Industry: A U.S. Security Imperative • Lynne Chandler Garcia and Michael Beverley 87 production will benefit the Island. Thus, Puerto Rico stands to benefit from any number of legislative initiatives currently in Congress. Concluding Thoughts Although this national security issue had been growing for decades, the COVID pandemic exposed the U.S’s critical dependency on foreign nations for prescription drugs and medical devices. White House Office of Trade and Manufacturing Director Peter Navarro commented, “If this crisis has taught us anything across party lines is that we do indeed need to bring home the pharmaceutical supply chain, that it is not just a public health issue, but a national security issue and an economic security issue” (Doyle 2020). Heading into the 2020 presidential elections, the fate of legislation and presidential plans for reshoring was precarious. On the campaign trail, President Trump boasted of his executive order to import less expensive pharmaceuticals from Canada. This was a step in the wrong direction because although it might reduce prices, it does not alleviate U.S. dependency on foreign countries. Candidate Joe Biden’s campaign promises included efforts to bring supply chains back from China, but his plan for Puerto Rico did not include a strong effort to bolster manufacturing. In recent months neither President Trump nor President-elect Biden has publically discussed the need to reshore the pharmaceutical industry. Further, the legislation discussed has stalled within Congress, and there is little indication that any movement on these bills is forthcoming. With COVID vaccinations rolling out to the public, a sense of complacency could set in, and there is a danger that the issue might fall off the political agenda as new security challenges take center stage. It remains to be seen if President-Elect Biden and the Democrat-controlled Congress will prioritize the security problems caused by foreign manufacture of pharmaceuticals and medical devices. The other unknown is if the citizens of the United States will be willing to bear the costs of reshoring in order to secure supply lines. Despite the urgency of this issue, the cost of reshoring will be extremely expensive. Higher wages, more expensive land, stricter quality and environmental standards, and increased government incentives all add up to much higher costs of production for American-made pharmaceutical products. These costs will likely be passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices. At the height of the 88 centro journal • volume xxxiii • number ii • summer 2021 COVID pandemic, consumers may be willing to pay more for American-made products. However, memories are short, and once fervor over the pandemic quiets down, consumers may be reticent to pay higher prices. The national security crisis caused by U.S. dependency on foreign pharmaceuticals must be solved, and Puerto Rico’s capacity to help solve this problem should be capitalized. Legislators must act while public sentiment is in favor of new solutions.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › PR Econ A/O – Pharma !

Puerto Rican competitiveness is key to Puerto Rican pharma R&D.

Juma’h et al. 15 [ Ahmad H. Juma’h , Ph.D., C.P.A., Ph.D. in Accounting and Finance from Manchester Business School; Doris Morales-Rodríguez , Ph.D., doctorate in Entrepreneurial and Management Development in International Business from Inter American University of Puerto Rico, Metropolitan Campus.; Antonio Lloréns-Rivera , Ph.D. in Public Policy and Management with majors in Public Finance and Urban Economics from The Ohio State University; “Pharmaceutical Industry and R&D in Puerto Rico”; Labor Markets and Multinational Enterprises in Puerto Rico; 2015; https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-17178-4_6]//eleanor

It is noted that the efforts of the Government of Puerto Rico to strengthen value- added activities in the biotechnology sector is one devoid of guarantees for the pharmaceutical long term activity on the Island due to an erosion of the global market. It argues that the Island faces the threat of development and manufacturing of medicines in low-cost jurisdictions such as India and China. It also faces the loss of competitiveness in the R&D sector in countries like Ireland and Singapore. Furthermore, changes in tax incentives at the local level have also weakened the mood of industry for economic activity in Puerto Rico. Considering adverse aspects, the fi nancial crisis of local government is also added. This situation is added to other events such as the maturity of the exemptions provided by Section 936 in 2006 and the increasing of labor costs (Business Monitor International 2006 ; Morales et al. 2012 ).

As presented by the Pharmaceutical Industry Executives some of the considerations for establishing both pharmaceutical operations and R&D include the following factors: the transaction costs, the economy, infrastructure, human resource, quality of life, technology, enabling environment for trade, education, cost of living and access to capital (PIE 2013 ). When analyzing the economic indicators of the countries with high establishment of the pharmaceutical R&D, these countries offer incentives and have a number of economic advantages over Puerto Rico; they have competitive advantages to multinationals for R&D center establishment. The economic indicators show how these countries are developing positively, with low unemployment rates and positive growth of GDP. Similarly, educational indicators can be used as a measure or important for the establishment of R&D centers factor. Higher education plays a key role in innovation, important part of R&D. Also, the location of the best universities in the world matches the host countries of R&D centers.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › Puerto Rico Econ A/Os – IL

Otherwise, public debt is unsustainable.

Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

[*1756] B. Puerto Rico and the U.S. Territories' Political-Process Problems: Colonialism Denies Both U.S. Representation and Economic and Political Autonomy

The plight of the U.S. territories is further obscured by the very colonial structure they seek to overcome. The territories exist in constitutional limbo, as they are considered to be "foreign in a domestic sense."216 They are neither states nor independent sovereigns. Under this unincorporated status, only constitutional guarantees not deemed "impractical and anomalous" apply.217 The territories lack voting rights and voting representation in Congress under the constitutional structure.218 They also lack economic and political autonomy. This is evidenced by the unequal and exploitative treatment that caused Puerto Rico's unsustainable public debt219 and the denial of Puerto Rico's self-governance or self-determination in addressing that debt.220

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › ADD-ONS › Puerto Rico Econ A/Os – IL

Arbitrary federal intervention and preemptions make it impossible for Puero Rico to address its fiscal crisis and impose strict austerity – that decimates Puerto Rican competitiveness.

Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

That same year, the Court held in Puerto Rico v. Franklin California Tax Free Trust154 that Puerto Rico could not reorganize its debt under the Puerto Rico Public Corporation Debt Enforcement and Recovery Act,155 nor could it use the U.S. Bankruptcy Code to do so.156 According to the Court's interpretation, the federal bankruptcy code treats Puerto Rico as a state such that the code preempts Puerto Rico's bankruptcy law but does not treat Puerto Rico as a state for the purposes of accessing the provisions of the code that authorize municipal debt reorganization.157 Thus, the Court determined that Puerto Rico was a "state for some purposes of the Code but not others,"158 thereby eliminating Puerto Rico's ability to address its fiscal crisis through either its own or the federal government's bankruptcy laws. To respond to [*1749] this conundrum,159 Congress did not amend the bankruptcy code160 but instead passed the Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act161 (PROMESA). PROMESA established a Fiscal Management and Oversight Board (FOMB) with broad federal statutory powers to reorganize Puerto Rico's debt and manage its fiscal affairs but without any meaningful local representation.162 FOMB was created by Congress under PROMESA, and its board members are appointed by the president, with no input by the Puerto Rican government or people.163

FOMB was the subject of a 2020 case, Financial Management Oversight Board for Puerto Rico v. Aurelius Investment, LLC,164 involving a challenge under the Appointments Clause.165 Plaintiffs argued that FOMB board members were appointed without the advice and consent of the U.S. Senate [*1750] in violation of the Appointments Clause, while defendants argued that the appointments were valid pursuant to the plenary powers granted by the Territorial Clause of Article IV.166 Following a determination by the First Circuit that "the Board Members . . . must be, and were not, appointed in compliance with the Appointments Clause,"167 the Supreme Court reversed and held that the Appointments Clause did not apply to FOMB because the board was a "local" territorial entity.168 As Justice Stephen Breyer put it, "whether the Board members are officers of the United States such that the Appointments Clause requires Senate confirmation . . . turns on whether the Board members have primarily local powers and duties."169 Justice Breyer acknowledged that the Appointments Clause applies to Congress's actions under Article IV and noted that the "Board possesses considerable power including the authority to substitute its own judgment for the considered judgment of the Governor and other elected officials."170 Yet he concluded that the Board's "power primarily concerns local matters," and therefore, the Board members are not "Officers of the United States."171

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › AT: SNAP & DLIS

Receiving SSI benefits enables access to SNAP and Medicaid programs

Hammond 21, -- Assistant Professor of Law, University of Florida Fredric G. Levin College of Law. (Hammond, Andrew. "Territorial Exceptionalism and the American Welfare State." Michigan Law Review, vol. 119, no. 8, June 2021, pp. 1639-1694. HeinOnline.) //EG

1. The Federal Framework Supplemental Security Income (SSI) is a cash benefit received by over eight million Americans who are elderly, blind, or have a disability as de- fined by federal law. 186 The maximum monthly SSI benefit for an individual 187 recipient is set at $794 and is not based on a recipient's prior earnings. Furthermore, the income threshold is set nationwide and the asset test is much lower than other means-tested programs.188 Notably, SSI recipients who live alone, or where all household members receive SSI, are eligible for SNAP and typically eligible for Medicaid.189 Lastly, as a part of the larger So- cial Security apparatus, SSI recipients have the same recourse to administra- tive procedure as recipients of benefits through the Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) program.190

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Poverty !

They don’t have SSI rights.

Reyes 21 (Raul Reyes is a graduate of Harvard University and Columbia Law and an immigration lawyer, “In SSI case, Supreme Court should extend a lifeline to Puerto Rico” 11-08-2021 ) [CT]

It is not good policy to exclude Puerto Ricans from SSI.  who live in Puerto Rico are American citizens. The island has a  and of . While the territory has its own version of SSI, called Aid to the Aged, Blind, and Disabled, that program has more stringent eligibility requirements and pays out less in benefits. The average monthly benefit under Puerto Rico’s  is $75 a month, while for  on the mainland it is $591 a month. Plus, in recent years the island has been hit hard by a financial crisis, Hurricane Maria, and the COVID-19 pandemic.

Leading advocacy and Latino organizations like the , , and  support Vaello-Madero’s position, as does the territory’s Republican . Guess who else thinks denying SSI benefits to Puerto Rico is a bad idea:  whose Justice Department is pursuing the case against Vaello-Madero. “I believe that Puerto Rico residents should be able to receive SSI benefits,” the president said , calling the current exclusion of Puerto Rico from the program “inconsistent with my administration’s policies and values.” 

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Poverty !

The U.S. federal government has a responsibility to help impoverished Puerto Ricans----but the aid gap is only growing

Povey 21 (Oliver Povey is a journalist with expertise in history, economics, labor, politics, world news, “Does Puerto Rico get social security benefits?” 11-16-2021 ) [CT]

"In the territories, Congress has the entire dominion and sovereignty, national and local, and has full legislative power over all subjects upon which a state legislature might act. It may legislate directly with respect to the local affairs of a territory or it may transfer that function to a legislature elected by the citizens thereof, which will then be invested with all legislative power except as limited by the Constitution of the United States and acts of Congress."

This fate is shared by other US possessions, such as Guam and American Samoa. in effect, it means the territories can be treated with nowhere near the care and support of the states in the US. This is where the court discussions surrounding Social Security are so important.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Disasters IL

SSI provides critical assistance for victims of natural disasters

State Department of Transitional Assistance and Commission for the Blind, 05 --- (State Department of Transitional Assistance and Commission for the Blind, "SSI Special Benefits", 10-26-2005, No Publication, https://www.masslegalservices.org/content/ssi-special-benefits)//EG

Information on 2005 SSI Special Benefits, which are benefits paid by the state to SSI recipients for disaster relief, funeral expenses, and moving expenses in some circumstances. State Assistance for Special Needs Administration State Department of Transitional Assistance and Commission for the Blind. Special Needs Circumstances Vendor payments in lieu of cash payments. Disaster benefits: Replacement of specific items of furniture, household equipment, supplies, food, and clothing for SSI recipients when these items were lost because of a natural disaster or fire. (Amounts exempted in determining SSI eligibility.) Burial expenses: Payment of funeral and burial expenses for SSI recipients shall not exceed $1,100, and the total expense shall not exceed $1,500. When a resource exists, it is deductible from the total expense (maximum $1,500), and the payment by the department must not exceed $1,100 of the balance. Rest home subsidies: When cost exceeds the total available income, excluding personal needs allowance, the state will pay difference up to established maximum rates. Moving expenses: The cost of moving within the state for SSI recipients may be paid once in a 12-month period if: Present living quarters have been certified as substandard, Moving to new quarters is necessary because of health problems or lack of safety in old neighborhood, Recipient is moving into federal or state subsidized housing, or Recipient is forced to move for other reasons. Total payment not to exceed $150. Homemaker and housekeeper services: The Department of Elder Affairs performs homemaker and housekeeping services for recipients aged 60 or older. The Massachusetts Rehabilitation Commission provides these services for recipients under age 60.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Disasters IL

Expanding social security benefits allows residents of Puerto Rico to grant relief without congressional action – makes funds available immediately and correctly distributes them

Fergus-Callahan, 4/12 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://irp.cdn-website.com/8c66f319/files/uploaded/Fergus_United%20States%20v.%20Vaello-Madero-d4cfc6a8.pdf)//EG

Implementing SNAP in Puerto Rico would significantly improve natural disaster relief efforts. In a 2019 audit report, after Hurricanes Irma and Maria, the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) for the U.S. Department of Agriculture reviewed the Food and Nutrition Service (FNS)'s supplemental funding to NAP and found several deficiencies that could be improved by a transition to SNAP.109 If Puerto Rico had used SNAP prior to the hurricanes, the island could have requested and operated a Disaster SNAP (D-SNAP), intended to respond to the expanding need following a natural disaster, which would have provided a full month's benefit allotment to households that may not normally have qualified for SNAP.1 0 Without D-SNAP, Puerto Rico must rely on Congress to pass disaster relief legislation that authorizes funding for additional benefits in the wake of a natural disaster.11 The FNS and Puerto Rico's Administration of Socioeconomic Development of the Family (ADSEF) must complete the grant cooperative agreement and the internal control plan.11 2 ADSEF must then develop and submit a comprehensive plan for how to spend the additional funding, a communications plan, and a regional impact plan for approval-all while operating in disastrous conditions. 113 The OIG audit report found that because of this process, emergency nutrition assistance funding did not reach Puerto Rico until six months after Hurricane Maria.11 4 In comparison, the U.S. Virgin Islands utilized D- SNAP and received aid 47 days after Hurricane Maria." 5 Without authority under D-SNAP, Puerto Rico is unable to effectively plan how to distribute emergency funding prior to a natural disaster because it does not know when it will receive funding, how much funding will be granted, or what requirements will be tied to the funds. 1 ' Implementing SNAP would grant Puerto Rico permanent statutory authority to operate D-SNAP, eliminate these planning and approval hurdles, and ultimately lead to faster aid in the wake of a natural disaster Quicker relief is not the only benefit to implementing SNAP in Puerto Rico. The OIG audit report also found that there is room to improve disaster nutrition assistance by improving coordination with other federal agencies performing disaster relief efforts on the island, like FEMA."1 7 Instead, FNS and ADSEF spent several months developing a comprehensive plan for administering the supplemental NAP funds after Hurricane Irma and Maria, leading to a six- to seven-month delay in setting up temporary application sites on the island for individuals seeking supplemental relief.iS Had SNAP been timely operating sites around the island, they could have been modified into joint application sites.i9 Joint application sites would have streamlined the application process and prevented individuals from needing to travel to multiple sites throughout the island to apply for aid from each agency individually, especially when structural barriers, such as transportation delays and road closures, made traveling even more challenging. A transition to SNAP would further strengthen FNS's oversight of Puerto Rico's eligibility system. The OIG audit report found that between March and September 2018, there were $1.4 million in overpayments of supplemental NAP funds, $1.5 million in underpayments, and $1.2 million in payments to deceased recipients. 120 This was partly due to a coding error in the eligibility system that overwrote data when caseworkers entered data in the retroactive claims module of the system, resulting in over or underpayments to some households. 121 Puerto Rico was also not using data from the Social Security Administration (SSA)'s death information to remove deceased participants from its records. 122 Instead, Puerto Rico used information from the Puerto Rico Department of Health Vital Records, which only had information on individuals who died between 2000 and 2015.123 Under SNAP, FNS requires state agencies to compare their records to SSA's database. 124 Thus, if Puerto Rico had operated SNAP, it would not only have planned for and received aid more quickly, but it also would have received better oversight from the federal government to eliminate administrative errors and increase better coordination with other federal agencies, allowing these agencies to pool resources and share data. All of these measures would create a more efficient system to aid Puerto Rico in its disaster relief efforts and provide enough funding to meet the needs of all of its eligible beneficiaries.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Disasters !

Puerto Rican Residents who are economically disadvantaged and lack access to supportive services are highly vulnerable to climate disasters

Climate Change Knowledge Portal, ND --- (Climate Change Knowledge Portal, "World Bank Climate Change Knowledge Portal", ND, World Bank Group, https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org/country/puerto-rico/vulnerability)//EG

With a population density of almost 449 inhabitants per km2 and 56% of its population living in the coastal municipalities, Puerto Rico’s population is highly vulnerable to hazards; particularly, those who are economically disadvantaged, less prepared, and under social inequitable conditions, such as insufficient infrastructure and services. Today, more than half of the population lives in the San Juan Metropolitan Area. The coastal zone of the San Juan Metropolitan Area as well as other coastal areas is where most hotels, essential infrastructure, and electric power plants are located (some power plants are less than 160 feet from the waterline and less than six feet above sea level). Rapid urbanization that occurred during past decades has drastically covered Puerto Rico’s watersheds with impervious surfaces. As a result, there are thousands of people living in flood-prone areas. Landslide hazards are also a growing concern in Puerto Rico. Bursts of heavy rainfall from intense storms trigger numerous landslides in the mountain areas of the island every year, causing substantial property damage and sometimes loss of life. (Puerto Rico Climate Change Council, 2015).

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › SOCIAL SECURITY ADV › XT Disasters !

Puerto Rico is uniquely vulnerable to increasing climate disasters that impair safe drinking water and cause catastrophic damage

Stormwater Report, 21 --- (Stormwater Report, "Puerto Rico Particularly Vulnerable to Climate Change, Research Suggests", 6-21-2021, Stormwater Report, https://stormwater.wef.org/2021/06/puerto-rico-particularly-vulnerable-to-climate-change-research-suggests/)//EG

When Hurricane Maria made landfall on Puerto Rico in September 2017, it quickly entered historical records as one of the most catastrophic natural disasters ever to affect the region, causing thousands of deaths and more than $90 billion in destroyed property. Researchers believe the compounding effects of climate change will prompt a gradual uptick in the number of extreme storms that will affect the northern Caribbean, making proactive flood management a top priority for Puerto Rico and surrounding islands. University of Texas at Austin (UTA) ecologist and Puerto Rico native Carlos Ramos-Scharrón has been studying the topographical and climatic conditions underscoring the island’s unique susceptibility to flooding since well before Hurricane Maria. According to his team’s most recent study, published May 2021 in the journal Hydrology, peak-streamflow estimates from hurricanes, such as Maria, suggest Puerto Rico is among the world’s most vulnerable regions to the effects of climate change. “We need to stop talking about climate change in future tense. It’s already here,” Ramos-Scharrón said in a release about the new study. “Puerto Rico needs to adapt its planning tools to the reality of what the island has experienced and scientists are documenting.” UNIQUELY VULNERABLE Much of Ramos-Scharrón’s research before Hurricane Maria dealt with surface erosion and sediment production in the Caribbean, illuminating the potential for sediment contributions from unpaved roadways to trigger or worsen destructive landslides during major storm events. Along with colleagues, Ramos-Scharrón undertook several modeling projects focused on Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and other sites, finding that sediments originating from roads in the region can threaten marine ecosystems and accumulate easily in runoff. Since 2017, his work has provided crucial context about the specific factors that made Hurricane Maria so destructive. One study compared Maria to about 60 similarly classified storms that have hit Puerto Rico since 1898, finding that the 2017 hurricane produced the highest island-wide daily rainfall amounts ever recorded. Another found that runoff produced during Hurricane Maria triggered more than 70,000 landslides, proposing a new framework to help predict where and when landslides will occur during major storm events. A subsequent inquiry identified these landslides as the main source of sediment that filled the island’s reservoirs, impairing drinking water supplies long after the storm dissipated. “Climate change projections for the Caribbean suggest longer dry periods interrupted by more intense storms,” Ramos-Scharrón said. “These storms release large quantities of sediment by landslides, and many of those end up reducing the island’s capacity to store water. The combined effect of these climate change projections is for a higher propensity for water scarcity.” Ramos-Scharrón’s newest study focuses on how Hurricane Maria and other extreme storms provoke riverine flooding in Puerto Rico. It uses historical data from the U.S. Geological Survey as well as previous research to compile a record of nearly 2,000 daily peak-streamflow measurements taken during hurricanes and tropical cyclones since 1898. Contextualizing these datapoints in terms of other world regions, the study finds that Puerto Rico’s low-lying geography, hydrological landscape, and size make it one of Earth’s most susceptible regions to riverine flooding during severe rainfall events.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › XT Ruling Racist

Its arbitrary, wrongly decided and racist.

Negron- Reichard 22 (Author: Sebastian Negron-Reichard** JD/MBA student at Harvard University; “United States v. Vaello Madero”; Harvard Law Review; November 10, 2022; https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/ )

58For example, the Court struck down the Rock Island Railroad Transition and Employee Assistance Act because it was "inconsistent with the uniformity requirement in the bankruptcy clause." 59The Court concluded that this law was "applicable to only one debtor, could be enforced only by one reorganization court presiding over that debtor, and [did] not address a class of similar debtors or a particular geographical problem." 60For "to hold otherwise would allow [*72] Congress to repeal the uniformity requirement from Art. I, § 8, cl. 4 of the Constitution." 61 Lastly, applying the absurdity doctrine, courts could find that it does not make sense for Congress to completely strip Puerto Rico's municipalities from any access to bankruptcy. "The [U.S.] Supreme Court has subscribed to the idea that judges may deviate from even the clearest statutory texts when a given application would otherwise produce 'absurd' results." 62The Marshall Court held that "a court's obligation to the text ceased when 'the absurdity and injustice of applying the provision to the case, would be so monstrous, that all mankind would, without hesitation, unite in rejecting the application.'" 63Congress designed Chapter 9 to provide municipalities throughout the United States with a "fresh start." 64Many insolvent municipalities throughout the United States have invoked Chapter 9 to seek this "fresh start," including Detroit, Michigan; Jefferson Country, Alabama; and Orange County, California. 65Special-purpose districts have also filed for bankruptcy, including entities dealing with fire protection, health care, and schools. 66Like these entities, Puerto Rico, through its municipalities and instrumentalities, provides essential government services. The U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Franklin California, although it did not address the constitutionality of the 1984 Amendments, effectively led to an absurd result. It is well summarized in Puerto Rico's brief before the U.S. Supreme Court: Finally, the decision represents the first time in the history of the United States that an entity has been categorically barred from seeking bankruptcy protection under both federal and state law. Prior to the First Circuit's decision, every person, corporation, organization, and municipality in the country had been permitted to commence debt-relief proceedings under either federal or state law, provided that they met the criteria prescribed in an existing federal or state bankruptcy statute. The court below upended nearly two centuries of bankruptcy practice when it prohibited Puerto Rico's municipalities from availing themselves of both federal law and Commonwealth law. 67 It is therefore an absurd and counterintuitive result that--because of the 1984 Amendments--municipalities serving as home to the over three million residents of Puerto Rico were left without any access to bankruptcy relief. [*73] In light of the framework discussed above, excluding Puerto Rico from deciding who may be a debtor under Chapter 9 of the Bankruptcy Code is unconstitutional and in violation of the uniformity principle of the Bankruptcy Clause of the U.S. Constitution. II. The 1984 Amendments violate the Equal Protection Component of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution "Discrimination by the federal government violates the Fifth Amendment when it constitutes 'a denial of due process of law.'" 68This denial of due process of law by the Federal Government is considered the Equal Protection Component of the Fifth Amendment. 69"Equal protection analysis in the Fifth Amendment area is the same as that under the Fourteenth Amendment." 70 The Federal Government argues in United States v. Vaello-Madero that the Territorial Clause allows Congress to "pass economic and social welfare legislation for the territories where there is a rational basis for such actions," relying on the U.S. Supreme Court's prior interpretation of the clause. 71Supporters of the constitutionality of the 1984 Amendments argue that they are constitutional because the uniformity clause does not apply to Puerto Rico. They use the Territorial Clause to argue that Congress can treat Puerto Rico differently. But the District Court for the District of Puerto Rico summed it up nicely when it said that the Federal Government cannot use the Territorial Clause as a "blank check" to violate the constitutional rights of residents of Puerto Rico. 72Considering the Equal Protection Component of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the 1984 Amendments are unconstitutional because they cannot withstand a rational-basis test. The Territorial Clause provides some leeway for the Federal Government's treatment of Puerto Rico, but not in all cases. The U.S. Supreme Court cases of Califano v. Gautier-Torres and Harris v. Rosario allowed Congress to legislate differently for Puerto Rico as long as it had a rational basis for the disparate treatment. 73 In Califano, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the denial of Supplemental Security Income ("SSI") benefits to a recipient who acquired them while a resident of one of the 50 states--but then moved to Puerto Rico--was constitutional. 74Congress amended the Social Security Act in 1972 and excluded [*74] Puerto Rico from SSI, a program meant to provide support to qualified aged, blind, and disabled persons. 75Based on the text of the statute, persons in Puerto Rico are not eligible to receive SSI benefits, but are eligible to receive benefits under the pre-existing programs that applied to Puerto Rico. 76In addition to Puerto Rico, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands are excluded from SSI payments, while the residents of the 50 states, the District of Columbia, and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands are eligible. 77 Appellees Torres, Colon, and Vega received SSI benefits while residing in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New Jersey, respectively, but lost them upon moving to Puerto Rico. 78The appellees filed different suits in the District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, which held that the Constitution requires that a person who travels to Puerto Rico must be given the same benefits they were receiving before. 79The U.S. Supreme Court reversed, stating that it has never held that the constitutional right to travel embraces the doctrine "that a person who travels to Puerto Rico is entitled to benefits superior to those enjoyed by other residents of Puerto Rico if the newcomer enjoyed those benefits in the State from which he came." 80It cautioned that such doctrine would open the door to benefits a state might provide for its residents, and then would require that state to continue providing them should a resident move to another state. 81The Court held that "the broader implications of such a doctrine in other areas of substantive law would bid fair to destroy the independent power of each State under our Constitution to enact laws uniformly applicable to all of its residents." 82 Califano, however, "is an opinion in which the footnotes are almost as important as its main text." 83The Court decided Califano on issues related to the right to travel, not on equal protection grounds. 84Two years later, in Harris, Justice Marshall [*75] confirmed that there was no equal protection question before the court in Califano. 85 In Harris, the Court held that a lower level of Aid to Families with Dependent Children ("AFDC") program reimbursement provided to Puerto Rico did not violate the Fifth Amendment's equal protection guarantee. 86Ultimately, the Court decided this case based on the Territorial Clause of the U.S. Constitution stating that Congress is empowered "to 'make all needful Rules and Regulations respecting the Territory ... belonging to the United States,' [and] may treat Puerto Rico differently from States so long as there is a rational basis for its actions." 87The Court listed three factors as a basis to justify the rational basis test: "Puerto Rican residents do not contribute to the federal treasury; the cost of treating Puerto Rico as a State under the statute would be high; and greater benefits could disrupt the Puerto Rican economy." 88 Califano and Harris, put together, held that "pursuant to Congress's powers under the Territorial Clause, only rational basis review is warranted when considering the validity of a statute that treats Puerto Rico differently." 89But Califano and Harris are not a carte blanche to discriminate against Puerto Rico residents in all cases, 90and the First Circuit declined to read the cases so broadly when deciding Vaello-Madero. 91Judge Torruella's concurrence in Franklin California also points to this distinction. 92The rulings in Califano and Harris did not address discriminatory treatment of Puerto Rico residents, specifically because the U.S. Supreme Court decided Califano on the basis of the right to travel 93and Harris on the basis of block grants received by the territory under the AFDC program. 94 The Bankruptcy Code is a statute that treats Puerto Rico differently, and thus a rational-basis test is warranted. It is well established that "[a] legislative classification ... be sustained, if the classification itself is rationally related to a legitimate government interest." 95The 1984 Amendments, insofar as they exclude Puerto Rico, could have been constitutional had there been a conceivable government interest in stripping the municipalities of [*76] Puerto Rico from access to Chapter 9. 96But there are no conceivable reasons that withstand the rational-basis test to remove Puerto Rico's power to authorize its municipalities to access bankruptcy. Congress's decision to treat Puerto Rico--and its residents--differently is arbitrary because it is not rationally related to any conceivable legitimate purpose. In essence, the 1984 Amendments benefited creditors at the expense of the residents of the Island. Puerto Rico was unreasonably and arbitrarily barred from accessing a remedy it had previously been afforded access to for four decades. The following are the five key reasons for making the case that the 1984 Amendments violate the Equal Protection Component of the Fifth Amendment. First, "there is absolutely nothing in the record of the 1984 Amendments to justify [the majority's statement that Congress sought to preserve to itself the power to authorize Puerto Rican municipalities to seek Chapter 9 relief] or Congress's legitimate purpose in adopting them." 97In Franklin California, Judge Torruella's concurrence is an eloquent walk through the scant information available as to how the 1984 Amendments came to fruition. 98The U.S. House of Representatives originally passed H.R. 5174--which eventually became law after amendments--without the Chapter 9 debtor eligibility exclusion for Puerto Rico. However, then-Senator Strom Thurmond, a Republican from South Carolina, introduced the amendment during the Senate's review of H.R. 5174 to exclude Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia from this provision. 99The U.S. Senate's original bill also did not have a provision excluding Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia. 100Then-Senators Dole, Thurmond, and Hefflin, without giving any explanation, introduced an amendment to incorporate the Chapter 9 exclusion. 101 Second, courts are required to carefully examine Congress's statutory text and justifications when interpreting changes to bankruptcy statutes. 102"There is hermetic silence regarding all of the issues or questions that would normally arise and be discussed when a provision that was part of the Bankruptcy Code for close to half a century, and whose elimination would affect [*77] millions of U.S. citizens, is deleted." 103There is nothing in the text and legislative history regarding why there should be changes to a part of the Bankruptcy Code that had been in place for nearly 50 years, and whose elimination would impact millions of U.S. citizens. Courts must find this silence alarming, as courts are required to examine these justifications. Third, the 1984 Amendments stripped Puerto Rico of an important component of state-like functions that it formerly had the right to exercise. The Court held in 1976 that Puerto Rico has "the degree of autonomy and independence normally associated with States of the Union." 104In that vein, the Third Circuit held in 2009 that "Puerto Rico has the same level of authority over its municipalities" as compared to the states. 105Moreover, in 1928 the First Circuit held that "in the matter of local regulations and the exercise of police power Porto Rico possesses all the sovereign powers of a state, and any exercise of this power which is reasonable and is exercised for the health, safety, morals, or welfare of the public is not in contravention of the Organic Act nor of any provision of the Federal Constitution." 106The First Circuit has also found that "there would have to be specific evidence or clear policy reasons embedded in a particular statute to demonstrate a statutory intent to intervene more extensively into the local affairs of post-Constitutional Puerto Rico than into the local affairs of a state." 107There is no such evidence nor specific policy reasons for the differential treatment of Puerto Rico in this instance. Fourth, the lack of access of Puerto Rico's municipalities to Chapter 9 violates the Equal Protection Component of the Fifth Amendment because--absent PROMESA--creditors would be treated preferentially in Puerto Rico as opposed to the 50 states. A municipal bondholder in the 50 states would have been in a significantly riskier position as compared to Puerto Rico (where there was no access to bankruptcy pre-PROMESA) and the District of Columbia. Because Congress's power to regulate commerce uniformly under the Commerce Clause applies in full force to Puerto Rico, 108it would not make sense to provide unequal treatment to bondholders who invest in Puerto Rico. The fact that Puerto Rican bonds are triple tax exempt from federal, state, and local taxes is not a sufficient reason to sustain the unequal treatment because "Puerto Rico's status in this respect is not entirely remarkable. [*78] State and local bonds have enjoyed federal tax-exempt status 'since the modern income tax system was enacted in 1913.'" 109 Fifth, this differential treatment of Puerto Rico specifically targeted a minority group for discriminatory treatment. In such cases, the rational-basis test standard does not warrant judicial deference. 110 For similar reasons, the First Circuit recently decided in Vaello-Madero excluding Puerto Rico residents from SSI benefits violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. 111The Vaello-Madero case originated when New York resident Jose Luis Vaello-Madero moved to Puerto Rico and was stripped of his SSI benefits. 112Like in Califano and Harris, 113Vaello-Madero could no longer access the SSI program due to being domiciled in Puerto Rico. 114Instead, he was entitled to a separate, Puerto Rico-specific program with far fewer benefits. 115The First Circuit, upholding a decision from the District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, stated that "the Fifth Amendment does not permit the arbitrary treatment of individuals who would otherwise qualify for SSI but for their residency in Puerto Rico (those plausibly considered least able to 'bear the hardships of an inadequate standard of living')." 116The future of this case, however, remains to be seen. 117 Similar to the logic of Vaello-Madero, residents of Puerto Rico who relocate to one of the 50 states would live in a municipality and receive services from entities with access to Chapter 9 relief. This unequal treatment would certainly be barred by the Fifth Amendment. Again, "here the situation is different than in Califano and Harris because, contrary to the Supreme Court's statements in those two cases, [here there is not a] single plausible explanation as to why Congress opted for the disparate treatment of Puerto Rico." 118In response to this argument, the Federal Government might recycle its logic from Vaello-Madero to argue that Puerto Rico's municipalities should not get access to Chapter 9 protections because its residents do not pay federal taxes. 119While most residents of Puerto Rico do [*79] not pay federal income taxes, Puerto Rico taxpayers paid over $ 3.5 billion into the federal treasury in 2019. 120This sum includes "the payment of federal income taxes by residents of Puerto Rico on income from sources outside Puerto Rico for which they are liable under the Internal Revenue Code, the regular payment of federal income taxes by all federal employees in Puerto Rico, 121as well as the full Social Security, Medicare, and Unemployment Compensation taxes that are paid in the rest of the United States." 122Moreover, this argument would fall on its face because the District of Columbia is also excluded from the Chapter 9 provision, 123but its residents do pay federal taxes. The Court, in Carolene Products, established that "prejudice against discrete and insular minorities may be a special condition, which tends seriously to curtail the operation of those political processes ordinarily to be relied upon to protect minorities, and which may call for a correspondingly more searching judicial inquiry." 124Courts have held that judicial deference is warranted "absent some reason to infer antipathy" because "even improvident decisions will eventually be rectified by the democratic process." 125But in this case, there is reason to infer antipathy. Puerto Rico is excluded from the political process in Congress and this "is asking it to play with a deck of cards stacked against it." 126All in all, a case about the constitutionality of the 1984 Amendments is certainly one that would call for more searching judicial inquiry. PROMESA and the path forward The passage and existence of PROMESA does not obviate the need for this discussion. First, PROMESA would have been needed regardless of mere access to Chapter 9 of the Bankruptcy Code. Even if Puerto Rico's municipalities could access Chapter 9, Puerto Rico's "state" government issued a great chunk of Puerto Rico's debt--and states themselves do not have access to a bankruptcy mechanism. 127 Second, PROMESA exists for now, but what happens after its expiration date? When the Oversight Board established by PROMESA certifies that Puerto Rico has met the termination requirements established in the law, 128it is unclear what would happen in a subsequent case where a Puerto Rico municipality needs bankruptcy relief. [*80] Even though the Oversight Board has sought to do a "once and done" approach to Puerto Rico's restructuring, it is evident that Puerto Rico's politicians have not proven to be effective financial managers. Thus, if ever in need of bankruptcy relief for Puerto Rican municipalities, and absent Congressional action to amend Chapter 9, Puerto Rico could bring suit regarding the constitutionality of the 1984 Amendments to right a wrong that has been inflicted upon it. While it remains to be seen whether the U.S. Supreme Court will uphold Vaello-Madero in the near future, there are strong arguments coming out of the First Circuit that point to Congress's unequal treatment of Puerto Rico. The violation of both the Bankruptcy Clause and the Fifth Amendment's Equal Protection Component of the U.S. Constitution through the exclusion of Puerto Rico from the 1984 Amendments is just one example of this unequal treatment, but a very powerful one with far-reaching consequences.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › XT Ruling Racist

Vaello reifies centuries of racial discrimination and exacerbates poverty.

Gonzalez 22 (Professor González, Ph.D., Linguistics, University of Southern California), Associate Professor of Spanish, specializes in phonology.; “Civil Rights Groups Condemn the Supreme Court’s Decision in U.S. v. Vaello-Madero”; Latino Justice; April 21, 2022; https://www.latinojustice.org/en/news/civil-rights-groups-condemn-supreme-courts-decision-us-v-vaello-madero.)

WASHINGTON — Civil rights groups condemn the Supreme Court’s decision to exclude citizen residents of Puerto Rico from federal safety-net programs in the U.S. v. Vaello-Madero case, and demand the Biden administration stop defending discrimination against Puerto Ricans and other citizens living in U.S. territories, especially when it comes to federal benefits for disabled, low-income, and elderly citizens. The Supreme Court’s decision today represents the continuation of the U.S. government's century-long discriminatory treatment of Americans living in Puerto Rico and other U.S. territories. In spite of the Court’s assertion, this discrimination is not just based on the Territorial Clause of the Constitution but also on racist cases decided by the Supreme Court in the early 20th century in a series of decisions known as the Insular Cases. Despite his campaign promise to end discrimination against Puerto Ricans, President Biden failed to use this historic opportunity to exercise his powers and immediately fulfill his commitment. Instead, he deferred to Congress, whose rationale for this discrimination seems to be that it is too costly to ensure that a federal safety-net exists for all of the nation’s most vulnerable if they live in a U.S. territory. The lone voice of justice on the court came from Justice Sotomayor, who in her dissent stated, “SSI is designed to support the neediest citizens. As a program of last resort, it is aimed at preventing the most severe poverty. In view of that core purpose, denying benefits to hundreds of thousands of eligible Puerto Rico residents because they do not pay enough in taxes is utterly irrational. Congress’ decision to deny to the U. S. citizens of Puerto Rico a social safety net that it provides to almost all other U. S. citizens is especially cruel given those citizens’ dire need for aid.” We concur. Hispanic Federation and its allies recognize this decision as a setback, not a defeat, and vow to continue our collective work to ensure all U.S. citizens are treated equally and fairly regardless of where they live. Congress must act now to end this injustice that perpetuates a two-tier system of citizenship among potentially millions of residents of Puerto Rico and other territories. We also call on President Biden to fight to ensure Congress enacts legislation to treat Puerto Ricans equitably in all federal safety net programs that support the most vulnerable citizens. “We condemn the Supreme Court’s decision today to exclude Puerto Ricans from SSI and their defense of ongoing discrimination in federal safety-net programs. It is shameful that our nation’s highest court once again failed to protect the democratic and constitutional rights of ALL U.S. citizens and continues to treat Puerto Ricans with such appalling injustice. Such cruel practices counter the fundamental objective of federal welfare programs, helping the most vulnerable citizens. Although this decision is a setback, it is not a defeat. Hispanic Federation will continue to work to ensure that all U.S. citizens, regardless of where they live, are treated equally and fairly,” said Frankie Miranda, President and CEO of Hispanic Federation. Vaello-Madero, a U.S. citizen with a disability, was sued for nearly $28,000 for receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI) payments after he moved from New York to Puerto Rico to be with his family. Although Madero won his case in the lower courts, the Justice Department appealed it at the Supreme Court. SSI provides funding to the most vulnerable people, including the disabled, blind, and elderly, who cannot support themselves. It is available only to U.S. citizens living in the 50 states, D.C., and the Northern Mariana Islands but excludes U.S. citizens living in other territories. “The Supreme Court turned a blind eye to the historical discrimination in federal safety-net programs against Puerto Ricans and other citizens living in U.S. territories. SSI is not just a policy; it is a policy that could save the lives of vulnerable people, including my daughter Isabella who was born with major heart conditions. My daughter did not ask for her illness, yet she has to continue to suffer the consequences of such injustice. Is it fair to prevent Puerto Ricans from accessing potentially life-saving assistance only because of where they live? This injustice is causing a lot of pain and suffering for families in similar situations and worse because they may not have a voice to be heard against this discriminatory decision. I am hurt and disappointed that the U.S. government, once again, decided to discriminate against my daughter and the thousands of families like ours. Now it is time for Congress to fight this discriminatory practice and guarantee that all U.S. citizens receive equal access to federal safety-net programs, no matter where they live,” said Aurelis Aponte, mother of a child with a disability who lost benefits when returning to Puerto Rico. “Excluding Puerto Rico’s residents from the SSI program is particularly harmful given the island’s older population, high poverty rate, and the number of older adults with disabilities,” said Kate Lang, senior staff attorney at Justice in Aging. “Puerto Rico has a higher percentage of older residents than any state in the U.S., and more than 40% of Puerto Rico’s residents 65 and older live in poverty. We are disappointed in the Supreme Court’s ruling and urge Congress to take steps to correct this injustice.” “LatinoJustice PRLDEF is appalled by the Supreme Court’s decision to deny Jose Luis Vaello-Madero, and by extension all residents of Puerto Rico, entitlement to SSI. This decision is outrageous on many fronts. In opposition to the findings of the District Court and Court of Appeals, in this case, the Supreme Court decision wrongly reinforces the notion that those in Puerto Rico are less than full citizens of the United States and deserve less than full access to the rights and benefits of citizenship. The decision also prolongs the racist exclusion of Puerto Ricans from vital federal benefits afforded to citizens living in the 50 states, undergirded by precedents that compound wrongs and historical practices that should have been rejected long ago. As Justice Sonia Sotomayor stated in her dissent, there is ‘no rational basis’ to treat U.S. citizens anywhere so differently, especially when the impacts of this differential treatment so starkly abdicate basic responsibilities to the neediest citizens. We agree with Justice Neil Gorsuch that the Insular Cases ‘rest on a rotten foundation’ and must be discarded as a rationale for discriminatory decisions that exclude Puerto Ricans and residents of other U.S. territories from the Constitutional rights and protections to which they are entitled,” said Lourdes M. Rosado, President and General Counsel, LatinoJustice PRLDEF.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › XT Ruling Racist

It facilitates indefinite colonial domination and lacks a rational basis.

Gomez-Velez 23 [Natalie Gomez-Velez is a Professor of Law at the City University of New York (CUNY) School of Law, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs from 2007- 2010. She is a graduate of New York University School of Law where she was an Arthur Garfield Hays Civil Rights/Civil Liberties Fellow; “SYMPOSIUM: An Anomalous Status: Rights and Wrongs in America's Territories: DE JURE SEPARATE AND UNEQUAL TREATMENT OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO AND THE U.S. TERRITORIES, 91 Fordham L. Rev. 1727”; Fordham Law Review; April 2023; Lexis]//eleanor

[*1736] Oral argument revealed facts contradicting the government's argument that tax distinctions and cost barriers established a rational basis for the government's denial of SSI benefits and discrimination.58 For example, Justice Sotomayor stated that "Puerto Ricans pay . . . as much taxes . . . as other states in the union" and that "[t]he government gives some tax benefits to some things and not others."59 She also noted that the record "shows Puerto Ricans as a community . . . pay more than many states of the union."60 The record contained ample evidence showing that Puerto Rican residents paid more in aggregate taxes than many states and that there was no "real connection" between tax burdens and benefits provided under the SSI program.61 Nor is cost alone a rational basis for denying equal protection in providing a public benefit.62

The Court ruled 8-1 in the government's favor.63 The majority ignored compelling facts and sound legal arguments showing the government's failure to articulate a rational basis for unequal treatment of Puerto Rican and other U.S territorial residents with respect to SSI benefits. Justice Kavanaugh's six-page majority opinion gives startlingly short shrift to key arguments about the scope and limits of the Territorial Clause, the Insular Cases' impact on the Court's interpretation of that clause, and how that interpretation facilitates indefinite U.S colonial dominion over Puerto Rico and other territories.64 The opinion's similarly limited consideration of the Equal Protection Clause argument completely elided important facts and context. For example, it ignored evidence in the record that Puerto Rico's tax burden was greater than that of several states, and that SSI was available even without state or local contribution.65 It also summarily referred to Califano and Harris as "dictat[ing] the result"66 without acknowledging that the First Circuit distinguished both cases. In short, the majority opinion punts. It fails to engage with important facts and context that drive unequal treatment of more than three million residents of Puerto Rico and the U.S. [*1737] territories, including through the denial of equal SSI benefits to needy citizens.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › AT: They don’t pay taxes

57% of SSI applicants in the states don’t pay federal taxes either.

Fergus-Callahan, 4/12 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://www.denverlawreview.org/united-states-v-vaello-madero-a-shameful-failure-to-protect-needy-american-citizens-living-in-the-u-s-territories)//EG

3. The Classification at Issue Is Not Rationally Related to a Legitimate Interest. Even if the Court accepts that limiting benefits from the SSI program based on tax status is a legitimate government interest, the action here- excluding Puerto Rico from the program-is not "rationally related "254 to that interest. When the Court considers a classification's rationality, it must decide "whether the classifications drawn in a statute are reasonable in light of its purpose. * Although a state does not violate the Equal Protection Clause "merely because the classifications [it makes] are imperfect" and generally allows laws to be both overinclusive and underinclusive, 25 the law still must have some " reasonable basis. »2 Here, the problem is not that the classification at issue, the exclusion of Puerto Rico from SSI benefits, is both over- and under-inclusive, but rather that the classes created by that exclusion are virtually identical. Because neither SSI applicants in Puerto Rico nor SSI applicants in the states pay federal taxes, there is no rational basis upon which the Government can discriminate against one. The majority's acceptance of Puerto Rico's tax status as a rational basis for excluding needy residents there who do not pay taxes is flawed. To qualify for the SSI program, applicants must have very little income or resources. 258 Fifty-seven percent of SSI recipients in December 2021 had no other source of income,2 meaning they were paid the full basic monthly SSI benefit of $841 for an individual or $1,261 for a couple. 260 While status and age changes the threshold tax filing requirements in the United States, neither $841 nor $1,261 of income would meet any threshold for any filing status or age.261 Therefore, fifty-seven percent of SSI recipients do not pay federal taxes. For SSI recipients that do report income, the average of that income for all categories of beneficiaries is still so low? that the vast majority of SSI recipients would not meet even the standard deduction for single taxpayers under sixty-five. 263 Because SSI candidates in the states have little, if any, tax liability, it is therefore irrational to conclude that SSI candidates in Puerto Rico may be excluded from the program entirely because they do not have any tax liability. As the First Circuit Court of Appeals noted in its decision, the Suprme Court's holding is "antithetical to the entire premise of the [SSI] program. *264 Taken to its logical conclusion, Justice Sotomayor noted, it could also have "dramatic repercussions. * If Congress can exclude needy citizens from welfare programs on the basis that the Territory does not contribute enough to the federal treasury, presumably it could also exclude needy residents of lesser contributing states. 266 It is worth noting as well that a lesser contributing state would have political recourse if Congress took that action; residents of Puerto Rico, on the other hand, do not.267 Congress has fashioned a tax scheme it has imposed on the people of Puerto Rico, and now it is punishing them for the same.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › AT: They don’t pay taxes

Limiting benefits based on jurisdictional tax status is not a legitimate state interest as Eligibility for SSI benefits is only based on income

Fergus-Callahan, 4/12 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://www.denverlawreview.org/united-states-v-vaello-madero-a-shameful-failure-to-protect-needy-american-citizens-living-in-the-u-s-territories)//EG

2. Limiting SSI Benefits by Tax Status is Not a Legitimate State Interest. A court will uphold a discriminatory legislative classification only if it bears a rational relationship to a legitimate state purpose.240 A court will not uphold such a classification if the interest advanced amounts to "a bare congressional desire to harm a politically unpopular group. »241 Where a classification's "sheer breadth is so discontinuous with the reasons offered for it that the amendment seems inexplicable by anything but animus toward the class it affects; it lacks a rational relationship to legitimate state interests. "242 The stated Congressional intent in creating the SSI program was "[ffor the purpose of establishing a national program to provide supplemental security income to individuals who have attained age [sixty-five] or are blind or disabled. "24 Because the exclusion of otherwise-eligible residents of Puerto Rico from the SSI program does not advance that statutory purpose in any way, the exclusion must advance some other legitimate state interest to withstand rational basis review. Again, citing Califano and Harris, the Court accepted that Puerto Rico's "tax status" constitutes a rational basis for that exclusion. Put differently, the majority accepted that "limiting benefits from the SSI program based on tax status" was a "legitimate interest." The tax status of the jurisdiction where a prospective SSI recipient lives, however, cannot constitute a legitimate interest that justifies exclusion from a uniform, federalized, direct-to-individual poverty reduction program like SSI. »245 SSI is a cash bene. paid to elderly, blind, or disabled Americans, provided they meet "stringent financial criteria. "246 Beneficiaries may have no more than $2,000 in assets for individuals and $3,000 for couples, with certain exceptions. 247 Unlike the Social Security program, which is funded by payroll taxes, general tax revenues fund SSI. 248 Beneficiaries of SSI do not need to have earned an income or paid taxes on that income to qualify for SSI.349 Instead, the government has conditioned eligibility on a uniform nationwide income threshold.250 While benefit amounts rewarded may vary based on an individual's income and assets, they do not vary based on jurisdiction.'§ Accordingly, "IrJather than dispensing money through block grants to the States," thus creating a system that would be illogical where the program is one-hundred percent federally funded, "SSI provides monthly cash benefits directly to qualifying low-income individuals. "252 Limiting benefits from the SSI program based on the tax status of the jurisdiction where a prospective resident lives, therefore, cannot constitute a legitimate state interest. SSI is a means-tested program paid directly to beneficiaries from the federal government, and eligibility is conditioned only on a beneficiary's income and assets.233 Excluding otherwise eligible individuals from the program based on the tax status of the jurisdiction where they live, therefore, is not a legitimate interest.

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › AT: They don’t pay taxes

That makes no sense.

Hammond 21 [Andrew Hammond, Assistant Professor of Law, University of Florida Fredric G. Levin College of Law; “Territorial Exceptionalism and the American Welfare State”; Michigan Law Review; 2021;

Rationale #1: Federal Income Tax. The federal government has argued in both cases that the fact that Puerto Rican residents only pay federal income tax on certain sources of income provides a rational basis from excluding them from SSI, SNAP, and the Medicare subsidies. 244 That's true: residents of Puerto Rico do not pay federal income tax on most types of income. 245 Unlike other Social Security benefits which are paid for through payroll taxes (taxes that Puerto Ricans pay), SSI is paid for by general tax revenue, including income tax receipts. 24 6 Yet, while the Supreme Court in Rosario states that Puerto Ricans "do not contribute to the federal treasury," recent tax receipts suggest otherwise. 247 Puerto Rico contributes roughly $4 billion in annual tax revenue to the federal government, exceeding the contribution of several states.248

More importantly, this is a confused justification for excluding any group of Americans from SSI. As a means-tested program, SSI's eligibility rules are not based on past or future federal tax payments. SSI is a program that only kicks in when an applicant has been shown to have insufficient work history to qualify for Social Security Disability Insurance and has little or no income. 249 The idea that Congress could use a logic of contributory insurance to justify a noncontributory (i.e., means-tested) program is odd. 250 The same is true for SNAP. No other group of Americans are excluded from SNAP because they do not pay income taxes. While it is difficult to find national data on tax receipts by these recipients, it is highly unlikely that many Americans who receive SNAP, SSI, or Medicare Part D have any federal income tax liability. 251 As the First Circuit noted, an individual cannot have more than $8,796 in countable annual income to receive SSI, which is significantly less than the standard deduction of $12,400 for single tax filers, let alone for the blind and elderly.252 Perhaps that is why there is no other case where the federal government has defended its exclusion of a group of people from a welfare program on the basis of federal tax contributions. 253

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › PRECEDENT ADV › XT Strict Scrutiny Review

US v. Valleo-Madero should have been considered under strict scrutiny due to the discrimination involved and lack of political power possessed by the residents of Puerto Rico

Fergus-Callahan, 4/12 --- Senior Articles Editor, Denver Law Review  (Carolyn Fergus-Callahan, "UNITED STATES V. VAELLO-MADERO: A “SHAMEFUL” FAILURE TO PROTECT NEEDY AMERICAN CITIZENS LIVING IN THE U.S. TERRITORIES", 4-12-2023, Denver Law Reveiw, https://www.denverlawreview.org/united-states-v-vaello-madero-a-shameful-failure-to-protect-needy-american-citizens-living-in-the-u-s-territories)//EG

III. ANALYSIS Although Congress retains broad authority under the Territory Clause to legislate in Puerto Rico, that authority is necessarily limited by other provisions of the Constitution, including its equal protection guarantee. Is When a court considers a challenge to a legislative classification on equal protection grounds, it employs a system of "tiered scrutiny" by which it considers actions under either "strict scrutiny" or "rational basis review. 1S The Supreme Court has held that when Congress acts pursuant to the Territory Clause, its actions are entitled to rational basis review unless the challenged law results in a "suspect classification. " 160 In its equal protection jurisprudence, however, the Court has previously held that territorial residency is not considered a suspect classification. 161 Therefore, when a Congressional action is challenged in a U.S. territory on equal protection or other constitutional grounds, the Court applies rational basis review. 162 This Part will argue that in its equal protection jurisprudence, the Court's standard of review is flawed and that classifications made based on territorial residency should be subject to strict scrutiny, not rational basis review, by the Court. Because territorial residents have experienced historical discrimination at the hands of the federal government empowered by a series of Supreme Court decisions resting on overtly racist reasoning, territorial residency should constitute a suspect classification. That the same set of cases resulted in the indefinite disenfranchisement of territorial residents lends additional support to this contention. This section additionally argues that Vaello-Madero was incorrectly decided not only because the standard of review should be heightened in cases concerning discrimination against territorial residents, but also because, even considered under deferential rational basis review, the Congressional exclusion of residents of Puerto Rico from the SSI program, specifically, is irrational. A. Territorial Residency Should Constitute a Suspect Classification Necessitating Strict Scrutiny Denial of due process occurs when the legislature classifies in a manner that the Court finds "suspect," meaning it discriminates against a class "subjected to such a history of purposeful unequal treatment, or relegated to such a position of political powerlessness as to command extraordinary protection from the majoritarian political process. "163 In other words, a classification is suspect if it burdens a group that (1) has been subiected to a history of purposeful unequal treatment or (2) is politically powerless to protect itself from the legislative process. I A challenge to this type of a suspect classification necessitates the Court's strict scrutiny, and such a classification will be upheld only if it is "narrowly tailored" to further compelling governmental interests. "16

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

Reversing discrimination is key to signaling promotion of self-determination.

Ocasio Palacios 23 [Jameris M. Ocasio Palacios, Duke University School of Law, J.D. and LL.M. in International & Comparative Law expected 2023.; “Puerto Rico: Insular, Incongruous, and Internationally Ignored”; January 2, 2023; https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4310045]//eleanor

198 Fortunately, a recent International Court of Justice (“ICJ”) Advisory Opinion199 presents a glimpse of hope for questioning the legitimacy of the U.S.’s relationship with Puerto Rico under international law.

The 2019 opinion concerns the Chagos Archipelago, which was administered by the U.K. as a dependency of the colony of Mauritius between 1814 and 1965. 200 In 1965, the UK entered into an agreement with the Premier and other representatives of the colony of Mauritius to detach the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius for the purpose of establishing military facilities on the island of Diego Garcia.201 Mauritius became an independent state within the British Commonwealth in 1968, but the Chagos Archipelago was not included in the definition of Mauritius in its constitution—which was promulgated by the U.K.202

2023 DDI Evidence
AFF – Vaello Madero – TT Lab › 1AC › 1AC – Precedent ADV

Vaello’s discriminatory treatment of territories in the US serves as evidence of an acceptable international legal standard – that decks self-determination globally.

Ocasio Palacios 23 [Jameris M. Ocasio Palacios, Duke University School of Law, J.D. and LL.M. in International & Comparative Law expected 2023.; “Puerto Rico: Insular, Incongruous, and Internationally Ignored”; January 2, 2023; https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4310045]//eleanor

The preceding case studies highlight how several states treated their territories post-colonialization in recognition and fulfilment of the right to self-determination. Scholars have criticized the U.N. for failing to clarify what it means for a nation to be “self-governing” such that the right to self-determination would be fulfilled.137 Indeed, a 2008 statistical study found that some territories which have been deemed meaningfully self-governing by the U.N. are in fact less autonomous than some of the territories still considered non-self-governing.138 When formal written conventions and treaties fail to adequately define state obligations in international law, customary international law may prove more useful. “Customary international law results from general and consistent practice of states that they follow from a sense of legal obligation.”139 “[C]ourts do not create but rather find international law, by examining the practices and attitudes of foreign states.”140 This notwithstanding, the standard to find state custom as evidence of binding international law “is a stringent one,”141 and modern judges are not likely to abuse discretion in applying this standard.142 Moreover, customary international law is limited insofar as it is susceptible to domestic legislation overriding its substantive rules or the jurisdiction of judges to apply this body of law.143 While the brief survey conducted in this Section undoubtedly falls short of the standard required to establish binding international customary law, observations of consistent state practice interpreting and responding to the international obligation to respect the principle of self-determination of non-self-governing peoples could indicate an emerging or evolving custom. At a minimum, this comparative study illustrates a variety of approaches to the problem arising from free-association-type arrangements, and the extrapolation of trends (below) highlights the best practices states should follow to ensure their territories’ right to self-determination is respected.

The previous survey of the world’s non-sovereign, inhabited, insular territories and their diverse power-dividing arrangements reveal key trends. All have either: (1) been afforded the ability to unilaterally become independent or have been expressly guaranteed access to independence in accordance with the will of its people, (2) had binding status referendums, (3) been fully integrated or afforded adequate representation in the administering power’s government, (4) secured autonomy over all internal affairs and the ability participate in international relations, or, (5) if the territory lacks any of these characteristics or if it is questionable whether it does, it is on the U.N. Decolonizing Committee’s list of non-self-governing territories.