Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › AFF › 2AC

Existing super chimney model caused pollution, environmental degradation, and poor health

Bill Freedman ‘18 (Former Chair of Dalhousie University Dept of Biology “Environmental Science” Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial. https://digitaleditions.library.dal.ca/environmentalscience/)//aoh

Canadian Focus 16.1. Smog in Canadian Cities Smog is a serious problem in many cities and also in some rural areas because of LRTAP from urban areas. Smog is typically characterized as a noxious mixture of pollutants visible as a brownish-yellow or greyish-white haze. The key components are the following:

O3 gas, along with SO2 and NOx

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 2NC

How the super chimney works

Ming et al ’14 (Tingzhen Ming and Wei Liu School of Energy and Power Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China, Renaud de Richter and Sylvain Caillol Institut Charles Gerhardt Montpellier − UMR5253 CNRS-UM2 − ENSCM-UM1 – Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Chimie de Montpellier, 8 rue de l’Ecole Normale, 34296 Montpellier Cedex 5, France “Fighting global warming by climate engineering: Is the Earth radiation management and the solar radiation management any option for fighting climate change?” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews vol. 31 p. 792-834 sec. 6.4. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032113008460)//ahigh

The super-chimney imagined by Pesochinsky [150], [154] consists in a huge vertical open duct at both ends, which works as a giant vacuum cleaner, transferring hot air from the sea level to the atmosphere 5 km higher, where temperature is −30 °C. The principle consists in the chimney effect based on the fact that hot air rises by buoyancy above cold air, because hot air is less dense and therefore lighter than cold air. But the process can be made more intense preventing the mixing of warm and cool air, so a chimney prevents inside air from mixing with the outside air until the air exits. The chimney stack effect needs a differential of temperature between the air inside and outside to run correctly. Moreover, the higher the chimney is, the more efficient it is.

It is a similar concept to previously described SCPP [148], except that there is no solar collector at the bottom of the tower, which usually couples the GH effect to the sucking effect of the chimney. According to Pesochinsky the temperature difference between the bottom and the top of the tower is sufficient. Another difference with conventional SCPPs concerns the size, 5–10 times bigger: up to 10 km high with a diameter of up to 1 km. Even if these heights have never been reached by human buildings, some GE / CE projects reported in the initial part of this review envisioned similar heights [59], [60], [61], [62], [63], [64], [65].

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 2NC

Super chimney proven successful – more efficient than forestation

Michael Pesochinsky ’19 (Bachelors of Chemical Science in Research St. Petersburg State Institute of Technology, Masters of Science in Polymer Science & Engineering Brooklyn Polytechnic, Juris Doctor Intellectual Property Law/Community Law. Senior Consultant for Citigroup multinational investment bank and financial services corporation, Senior Consultant and Project Manager Infocraft, VP of Cyweb Holdings. “Super Chimney Project Makes Progre Towards Global Warming Solution” Cision PRWeb. Accessed 7-1-23. https://www.prweb.com/releases/super_chimney_project_makes_progress_towards_global_warming_solution/prweb16496666.htm)//ahigh

There has been a lot of talk lately about how forestation can be used as a means to reduce the levels of carbon dioxide in the Earth’s atmosphere. Proponents say that forests can sequester CO2 into soil, thus reducing global warming. Unfortunately, according to the latest IPCC report, land is a critical resource and attempts to curb CO2 by forestation are futile. This is because we do not have enough land and water to do forestation in sufficient proportions.

Luckily, there is solution which can solve this dilemma. Back in 2008, Michael Pesochinsky developed the idea of utilizing Super Chimney technology as a unique way to avert a global warming catastrophe and simultaneously generate clean energy and provide desert irrigation. A 5km tall structure can provide enough water precipitation to irrigate any desert at $0.00 energy costs. In addition, once our planet’s deserts are irrigated they will turn into forests. These forests will be carbon sinks without taking away arable land or food supplies from humanity.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 2NC

Tourism generated by super chimneys can provide numerous economic benefits –profit, employment, standard of living

A. M. Khavrulloevna ’20 (Ashurova Muborak Khavrulloevna - Senior Lecturer; FACULTY OF ECONOMY AND TOURISM, BUKHARA STATE UNIVERSITY “The Substantial Economic Benefits of Tourism” Bukhara State University. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/the-substantial-economic-benefits-of-tourism/viewer)//ahigh

Abstract: this article discusses the substantial economic benefits of tourism. The tourism industry generates substantial economic benefits to both host countries and tourists home countries. Especially in developing countries, one of the primary motivations for a region to promote itself as a tourism destination is the expected economic improvement. Keywords: tourism, economic benefits, positive and negative effects. As with other impacts, this massive economic development brings along both positive and negative consequences. There are many hidden costs of tourism, which can have unfavorable economic effects on the host community. Often rich countries are better able to profit from tourism than poor ones. Whereas the least developed countries have the most urgent need for income employment and general rise of the standard of living by means of tourism, they are least able to realize these benefits. Among the reasons for this are large-scale transfer of tourism revenues out of the host country and exclusion of local businesses and products. The positive and negative effects can be classified into the social & cultural impact, economic impact and environmental impact. Social & cultural impact signifies the impact which it creates in terms of social changes in the lives of local people, improvements in infrastructure, lifestyle changes etc. Economic impact can be quantified in terms of monetary benefits and overall economic development of the society. Environmental impact refers to the impact on the nature and surrounding areas social & cultural effects. Foreign experience which gained from abroad may have different effects on the social and cultural aspects of life in a particular region depending on the strengths of the region. The effect can be positive or negative. To boost tourism huge money is invested to preserve the local heritage, to improve infrastructure, to provide better local facilities which in turn creates better education, better leisure facilities, organizing frequent social events and thus a better lifestyle for the locale people. They interact with the tourists, mix with people from diverse backgrounds which creates a cosmopolitan culture in the region. Due to the demand for better services, varied employment opportunities are created within the region and therefore people do not feel the need to migrate to other cities to earn their living. Due to the heavy traffic in the region, the infrastructure may not be able to cope up the increased rush thus leading to overcrowding, poor sanitation which may further lead to diseases bot to the tourists as well as local people. The intrusion of outsiders in the area may disturb the local culture and create unrest among the people. The local people may copy the lifestyles of tourists through the demonstration effect and the result could be loss of native customs and traditions. Some people may enter into criminal activities to fetch easy money from tourists which leads to increased crime and anti-social activities and loss of moral and religious values. Now let's understand the impact of travel industry on the world and country economics. Environment is surrounding atmosphere or condition for existence. The impact of tourism on environment is both positive and negative. In order to attract more tourism special emphasis is given on overall beautification of the surroundings, regular planting of trees and landscaping are done to enhance aesthetics. Huge investment is done to improve the facilities in the area like sitting areas, shades, proper sanitation, drinking water etc. More emphasis is given to preserve the monuments, heritage structures to attract more tourists. Whereas the virtues of international tourism have been extolled as a major force for peace and understanding between nations the reality is often far removed from his utopian image. Long-haul travel between developed and developing countries is increasing annually and is bringing them into direct contact with each other. People come from widely different background and with every contrasting life styles and levels of income.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 2NC

Super stacks reduce pollution, iconify, and distinguish their homes

Kaleigh Bradley and Mike Commito ’14 (Bradley PhD candidate at York University, M.A. in Public History from Carleton University. Commito PhD candidate in the Department of History at McMaster University. Both are Sudbury residents. “’It’s history, like it or not’: the Significance of Sudbury’s Superstack” University of Saskatchewan and Huron University College. https://activehistory.ca/2014/11/its-history-like-it-or-not-the-significance-of-sudburys-superstack/)//ahigh

Since the nineteenth century, Sudbury’s landscape was ravaged by the effects of the mining industry; over the years the vegetation disappeared with acid rain, and farmers found themselves unable to grow crops in the highly acidic soil. The International Nickel Company (INCO) built the Superstack in 1972 to disperse sulphur dioxide (SO2) and other pollutants away from the area, thereby addressing health and environmental concerns. The Stack’s construction coincided with a community regreening movement, which has reversed some of the environmental damage. The Superstack reduced local emission rates in recent years, but one could argue that INCO simply passed the buck, and the dispersion of SO2 became somebody else’s problem. Moreover, the Sudbury area continues to have higher rates of asthma and lung cancer than other parts of Ontario. For better or for worse, the Superstack has been a landmark along the Sudbury skyline for over forty years. And when Vale (formerly INCO) recently proposed demolishing the Superstack in the local media, we watched as an interesting public debate about the significance, history, and future of the stack ensued. On November 3rd 2014, Kelly Strong of Vale announced that the company considered demolishing the Superstack. This news is not surprising and is in keeping with Vale’s ongoing $1 billion Clean AER Project, designed to reduce SO2 emissions. If the Superstack is removed it will be replaced by a smaller chimney, but this will mark a big departure not only in the company’s operational history, but for local history as well. We realized that as historians, we can help curate and analyze the varying memories and opinions people shared about the Stack. A brief snapshot of the conversation on the Northern Life’s Facebook page reveals that many Sudburians have a strong connection with the Superstack. While several people questioned whether the Stack deserved to be classified as an iconic landmark, a great deal more believed it represented a part of Sudbury’s history and it should be preserved. Sudburians argued that the Superstack was a beacon of homecoming; seeing the Stack jutting out of the skyline filled them with a sense of nostalgia and the realization that they were home. Commentators also noted that the Stack is often used by residents and outsiders to locate Sudbury. Some might say, “oh, you’re from the city with the giant smoke stack,” or, “Sudbury has the Superstack, right?” Not only do locals identify the Superstack with ‘home,’ but residents and visitors also use it to situate themselves in place. The potential absence of the Superstack as a physical reference point along the Sudbury horizon could create a (harmless yet interesting) sense of loss and dislocation for some. We found that the Stack is also a site of memory used to recall family histories. Residents fondly recounted memories of their parents or grandparents building the Stack, while others boasted of their relatives surviving Sudbury’s August 1970 tornado from high atop the chimney. The Stack is also a marker that roots blue collar workers and their families in place. It is an archive that embodies histories of work and family. In the Northern Life, Jonathan Migneault refered to the Stack as both an eyesore and an iconic landmark. Is the Stack nothing more than an industrial remnant? Deindustrialization is not just an economic process but a social one as well. The demolition of industrial sites are complex and emotional events for locals, especially for individuals who worked for decades in a single-industry town. Although the Stack is technically still functional, its replacement with a smaller chimney would mark the end of one era and the beginning of another. Historian Steven High studied the sense of loss and dislocation experienced by residents of Sturgeon Falls, Ontario, who struggled with the closure and demolition of their paper mill in the early 2000s. “What happens to a mill town that loses its mill?”, High questioned. High discovered that a part of local identity and history was lost when the paper mill was demolished. The physical absence of the mill served as a poignant reminder that prosperous times had come and gone in Sturgeon Falls. What will happen to Sudbury if it loses its Superstack? As the Sudbury economy continues to diversify, shifting away from mining towards other industries, its industrial landscapes will be renegotiated, rebuilt, or perhaps erased. Beyond the social media debates, the image of the Superstack boasts economic value for members of the community who use it to brand their products and services. Sudbury craft brewers Stack have tasted success, largely because of their quality beers, but also due to their savvy marketing campaign. Stack’s brand is aimed at a new generation of local consumers who embrace the Superstack somewhat nostalgically. The Stack brand evokes notions of home, nostalgia, and local identity for Sudburians, with beers labeled “Black Rock” (Sudbury is notorious for its black rocks, a product of nickel smelting), “Valley Girl” (based on the”valley” communities on the outskirts of Sudbury, such as Hanmer and Chelmsford), and “Saturday Night” (a nod at Stompin’ Tom Connors’ song, Sudbury Saturday Night).

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 2NC

Canadian super chimney reduced air pollution by 85% locally

Ramya Narendrula-Kotha and Kabwe K. Nkongolo ’17 (Narendrula-Kotha PhD student in Biomolecular Sciences, Nkongolo Master of Science Pathology and Toxicology Specialization, PhD Breeding and Genetics, Professor in Biology at Laurentian University of Sudbury. “Microbial Response to Soil Liming of Damaged Ecosystems Revealed by Pyrosequencing and Phospholipid Fatty Acid Analyses.” PLoS ONE. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0168497#authcontrib)//ahigh

Mining activities in the Greater Sudbury Region (GSR) in Northern Ontario (Canada) that started over century ago have resulted in serious damages to surrounding ecosystems. Logging and ore smelting led to a large scale of SO2 (sulphur dioxide) emissions and metal contamination (copper, Cu; iron, Fe; nickel, Ni and zinc, Zn). These have resulted in damaged ecosystems with reduced plant growth and population diversities within the region. Remediation projects were initiated to restore the affected lands and to decrease industrial emissions. Building of a super chimney in 1972 reduced metal particulates and SO2emissions by 50% and 85%, respectively. To decrease acidity, 10 tons of limestones per hectare were applied in 1978. This liming was followed by land fertilization, grass and legume seeding. In addition, since 1979, 12 million trees have been planted to complete the reclamation process.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Super Chimneys › NEG › 1NC

Super Chimneys produce renewable energy, water, and offset warming

Michael Pesochinsky ’08 (Bachelors of Chemical Science in Research St. Petersburg State Institute of Technology, Masters of Science in Polymer Science & Engineering Brooklyn Polytechnic, Juris Doctor Intellectual Property Law/Community Law. Senior Consultant for Citigroup multinational investment bank and financial services corporation, Senior Consultant and Project Manager Infocraft, VP of Cyweb Holdings. “Calculations” Super Chimney. https://www.superchimney.org/calculation.asp)//ahigh

Calculations Example for calculations. If we have super-chimney 5000 m high and diameter 1000m or 20m, wherein the temperature of air at the bottom is 30 °C and at 5000 m it is -20 °C 2. 1. Air Flow Calculations, according to Natural Draft Pressure Calculator 1 q = Π dh2 /4 [ (2 g (po - pr) h ) / ( λ (l pr / dh) + ∑ξ pr ) ]½ where dh = hydraulic diameter (m, ft) λ = D'Arcy-Weisbach friction coefficient l = length of duct or pipe (m, ft) g = gravity - 9.81 (m/s2) q = air volume (m3/s) po = density outside air (kg/m3) pr = density inside air (kg/m3) h = height between outlet and inlet air (m) ∑ξ = minor loss coefficient (summarized and taken as 1) We can expect the natural draft of air flow at the speed of 139.2 m/s. This translates into 109,357,369 m3/s of air going through the super-chimney (50,916 m3/s for 20m diameter). As the air density equal 1.164 kg/m3 at 30°C2, we can calculate that 127,292,000 kg/s of air moves through the super-chimney (50,916 kg/s for 20m diameter). 2. Producing electric power. Calculate amount of electric energy produced. Wind Turbine Power 7: P = 0.5 x rho x A x Cp x V3 x Ng x Nb where: P = power in watts (746 watts = 1 hp) (1,000 watts = 1 kilowatt) rho = air density (about 1.225 kg/m3 at sea level, less higher up) A = rotor swept area, exposed to the wind (m2) count as a whole super-chimney area (3.14 * 5002) Cp = Coefficient of performance (.59 {Betz limit} is the maximum theoretically possible, .35 for a good design) V = wind speed in meters/sec (139.2 m/s) Ng = generator efficiency (50% for car alternator, 80% or possibly more for a permanent magnet generator or grid-connected induction generator) Nb = gearbox/bearings efficiency (depends, could be as high as 95% if good) P= 0.5 *1.164 * (3.14)*(500)2*0.35*(139.2)3* 0.8 * 0.95 P=327,787,194,991.65696 watt=327,786 Mega Watt (131.1 Mega Watt for 20m diameter) 3. Calculation of amount of water condensate. Suppose the relative air humidity at the bottom of the super-chimney is 30%, which is typical for deserts. Thus, the air contains roughly 9g of water per kg of air. At elevation of 5000m the temperature is roughly -20C and the pressure is about 55,000 Pa (and this is roughly half of the pressure existing at sea level). At such conditions, air can hold at most 1.7 g of water per kg of air (point of saturation). Therefore, once the air from the super-chimney is expelled out, water from the air will condensate in the amount of 7.3g per kg of air. In the given system, where 127,292, 000 kg/s of air is going through the super-chimney, this means that 929,231 kg of water condensate per second (371 kg for 20m diameter). 4. Calculation of CO2 uptake by irrigated desert. There are different estimates of CO2 uptake capacity given by the EPA. For example, it is estimated that each acre of reforested land will absorb up to 2.1 tons of carbon per year for period of 120 years. In fact, this number does not count additional CO2 which will be fixed in soil. Thus, one super-chimney will allow to trap: 300* 640 Sq.Acres/ sq.mile* 2.1=403, 200 tons of carbon, 1 ton Carbon equivalent = 3.667 ton CO2, thus one super-chimney will allow to trap 1,478,354 tons of CO2 per year (592tons for 20m diameter) 5. Calculation of number of super-chimneys needed to cool the atmosphere. There are many factors to analyze. However, it is clear that in principle, the super-chimney will facilitate heat exchange and, given the enormous amount of air coming through the super-chimney, it will have effect on the heat balance of the Earth atmosphere. According to Kiehl3, annually Earth receives 492 W/m2 of radiation combined (direct solar and due to the green house effect) . Global Warming is attributed to the fact that the Earth is presently absorbing 0.85 ± 0.15 W/m2 more than it emits into space4 (Hansen et al. 2005). So the planet absorbs approximately 0.2% of radiation energy more than it should to maintain constant temperature. According to Wikipedia, Earth surface heat captured by the atmosphere. More than 75% can be attributed to the action of greenhouse gases that absorb thermal radiation emitted by the Earth's surface. The atmosphere in turn transfers the energy it receives both into space (38%) and back to the Earth's surface (62%), where the amount transferred in each direction depends on the thermal and density structure of the atmosphere.5 The super-chimney will emit air at the 5000m, which is roughly the point in the atmosphere where half the amount of air is below and half is above. Thus, it can be assumed that re-absorption will be cut in half. So, instead of normal distribution we will have ~70 % of energy lost to space and only 30% reabsorbed into atmosphere. In other words, the air, which will go through the super-chimney, will loose 30% more heat than a normal air. According to the above calculation 127,292, 000 kg of air will go through the super-chimney every second. In a year it comes to 4x10^15kg . According to the National Center for Atmospheric Research, "The total mean mass of the atmosphere is 5.1480×1018 kg...". Therefore, annually 7.7 ×10-4 of the whole atmosphere will go through the super-chimney. As shown above, that air will lose 30% more heat than normal air. Thus, the whole atmosphere will lose 2.31×10-4 or 2.31×10-2% more heat than it would otherwise. Since the planet absorbs approximately 0.2% of radiation energy more than it should to maintain constant temperature, we can approximate that 10 super-chimneys will offset Global Warming (25,000 for 20m diameter).

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › AFF › 2AC

The NIST is already providing quantum education as well as funds totaling approximately $120 million per year

William Thomas 1/4/19 (Senior Science Policy Analyst, FYI. “National Quantum Initiative Signed into Law.” American Institute of Physics. ) Date Accessed: 7/1/23 HRF

In general, the NQI Act directs DOE, NSF, and NIST to support R&D and education in QIS, set program goals, and facilitate partnerships among federal laboratories, universities, companies, and other entities. It also offers more specific directions for each NQI agency. NIST is directed to conduct R&D for “measurement and standards infrastructure necessary to advance commercial development of quantum applications.” It is also instructed to “establish or expand collaborative ventures or consortia with other public or private sector entities, including industry, universities, and Federal laboratories.” The agency already operates a Joint Quantum Institute and a Joint Center for Quantum Information and Computer Science with the University of Maryland. It also supports JILA, a joint center at the University of Colorado Boulder that has a major QIS research portfolio. The act further directs NIST to create a “quantum consortium,” in accord with plans the agency announced in September. The consortium will bring together stakeholders in the incipient QIS-based industry to identify research needs relating to measurement, standards, cybersecurity, and other matters. NIST is instructed to spend up to $80 million annually on NQI-related activities from fiscal year 2019 through fiscal year 2023. It is the only agency for which the legislation specifies an overarching funding level. NSF is directed to support not only QIS research but also“human resources development in all aspects of quantum information science and engineering,” including through graduate traineeships. NSF already funds QIS research and education through several of its divisions, and it has identified QIS as one of its “Big Idea” focus areas. In September, it announced $31 million in awards through new interdisciplinary QIS grant programs, and it is currently considering proposals for “foundries” for developing quantum materials and devices. While the act does not set an overarching spending target for NSF’s NQI-related activities, it does direct the agency to establish between two and five competitively awarded “Multidisciplinary Centers for Quantum Research and Education.” Each center will receive up to $10 million annually through fiscal year 2023 and will be eligible for renewal for an additional five years. Applicants can include higher education institutions and nonprofit organizations, as well as multi-institutional collaborations that can include private-sector entities. Among their activities, the centers are expected to help integrate “industry perspectives” into R&D and educational activities in QIS. DOE is directed to undertake a QIS research program and provide “research experiences and training” for undergraduate and graduate students. The act lists seven areas of specific interest for training: quantum information theory, quantum physics, quantum computational science, applied mathematics and algorithm development, quantum networking, quantum sensing and detection, and materials science and engineering. The act directs DOE to establish between two and five competitively awarded “National Quantum Information Science Research Centers.” Each is to be allocated up to $25 million annually through fiscal year 2023, which is similar to the funding level for DOE’s existing Nanoscale Science Research Centers. Like the NSF centers, the QIS center awards will be for five years with the possibility of renewal. Applicants can include national laboratories, universities, research centers, multi-institutional collaborations that can include private entities, as well as “any other entity that the Secretary of Energy determines to be appropriate.” As with NSF, the act does not set an overarching spending target for NQI activities. DOE has already been ramping up its investment in QIS. In September, it announced 85 single-year and multiyear research awards totaling $218 million and plans to spend about $120 million on QIS in fiscal year 2019.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › AFF › 2AC

Quantum is only environmentally affective when ocurring in tandem with green infrastructure.

Amin Khodaei 9/30/20 (Associate Professor, Electrical and Computer Engineering University of Denver. “How quantum computing is poised to support sustainable power grids.” GreenBiz. https://www.greenbiz.com/article/how-quantum-computing-poised-support-sustainable-power-grids) Date Accessed: 7/2/23 HRF

We set out to study how quantum computing could be applied to analyze and model DC power flow, a useful proxy for understanding power system behavior to aid timely decision-making. (DC power flow is the most widely used power system analysis technique as a stand-alone application or embedded in other applications.) Our DC power flow model was based on a three-node system (one virtual generation station and three virtual substations) using only four qubits on the IBM cloud-based quantum computing platform. "Qubit" is a combination of the words "quantum" and "bit." A qubit is the basic unit of information in quantum computing, as a bit is in classical computing. Using "only" four qubits for a DC power flow analysis is relevant due to its reduced hardware requirement and lower cost. The fewer the qubits used, the less expensive and more accurate this technology will be. Using the smallest number of qubits also will allow us to more easily scale up our approach to larger test systems as we move to pilot tests. We established the proof of concept that, in fact, quantum computing can be used to analyze a practical and fundamental power system problem, although on a small-scale test system. Our research on quantum computing focusing on grid resilience — how to prepare the grid against extreme events — is still ongoing and holds great promise for service restoration, minimizing the human and economic consequences of electricity disruption, and streamlining greater deployment of renewables.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › NEG › 2NC

Quantum computers have a laundry list of positive impacts on the environment

Prachi Mishra 8/23/22 (Prachi Mishra is a Young Leaders in Tech Policy Fellow at the University of Chicago, presently working at CSST for their quantum meta-ethics project. “Qubits for climate change.” ORF. https://www.orfonline.org/expert-speak/qubits-for-climate-change/) Date Accessed: 7/1/23 HRF

Pragmatic applications of quantum technologies in climate action Quantum computers deploy qubits rather than classical logical bits that aid in magnified computing power, exponential processing capabilities, and outcomes that are based on probabilities rather than binary decisions. This makes it easy for quantum computers to generate simulations that are otherwise complex and beyond the scope of classical computers. For instance, when coupled with Artificial Intelligence (AI), a quantum computer can assist in simulating tests for a water quality innovation with far more accuracy. They can also help in improving sustainability across the spectrum of the economy. A few ways in which quantum computers can reduce global warming are discussed below. Power storage and supply Electricity generation is one of the leading causes of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and a practical application of quantum computing in the realm of energy could be its ability to optimise power generation through simulations and map demand/supply with more accuracy. In addition to this, quantum capabilities can also identify leaks and gaps in power supply, dramatically impacting how it is stored, transmitted, and distributed. In India, 15 percent to 20 percent of renewable energy is wasted every year as the grid cannot manage energy fluctuations. These issues arise because of the variation in the wind speed and solar intensity, which can be predicted only up to a certain accuracy right now. Similarly, nearly 20 percent of electricity is lost in transmission. Smart grids that use quantum algorithms can help reduce AT&T losses. Quantum applications based on more incisive optimisation algorithms can reduce the wastage of power. The emerging technology can also be deployed to produce more effective solar panels by cutting solar losses and helping in the green energy transition. Construction materials The construction and building sector accounts for nearly 40 percent of the GHG emissions around the world. This opens up avenues for designing new sustainable materials, bringing down emission levels, and helping reduce pollution. Quantum technologies can aid in the design of such materials. Error-corrected quantum computers, which are at least 10 years away from now, can help synthesise new molecular structures that result in a low carbon footprint. Models derived from quantum chemistry can be useful in replacing materials like cement, aluminium, and steel that are energy intensive, account for high emissions in their production, and produce a large number of emissions while in use. These new materials would be lighter and more robust, improving the longevity of infrastructure and reducing the frequency of maintenance and replacement. Transportation and logistics Transportation of goods and materials with the help of trucks, trains, aeroplanes, and waterways and the movement of people via cars, buses, trains, and other private vehicles accounts for nearly 20 percent of the global GHG emissions. Modern-d transportation involves the use of fluid dynamics which gets restricted in efficiency because classical computing cannot simulate large surfaces. This implies that a lot of such simulations are to be carried out as physical prototypes, which not only lead to GHG emissions but also are limited to only a few use cases. Such problems can be rectified by the use of quantum simulations which can provide better designs and reduce losses based on the system’s constraints. Aircraft manufacturers like Boeing and Airbus are also contemplating quantum-led innovation which can reduce fuel consumption. Quantum computing for improved environmental decision-making Quantum computers can be used with other emerging technologies like AI and machine learning to improve evidence-based decision-making. They can run a high number of simulations in parallel that allows for swift testing, comparison, error correction, and deployment of a product or a service. For instance, many nations in the European Union are opting for cleaner fuel by replacing coal with liquified natural gas (LNG) which emits 40 percent less GHGs compared to black coal. However, most of the European states have to import LNG which poses challenges around finding the most optimal route, frequency of shipments, and employing the best possible ways that reduce transportation losses. Since classical computing is faced with limitations, tech giants like IBM have stepped in to assist oil and gas conglomerates like ExxonMobil to work on quantum computing-based decisions. This will save many natural resources and cut down on losses that otherwise are detrimental to the environment. When quantum computing algorithms are used along with predictive data modelling, forest fires can be pre-empted and flood mitigation can be scaled immensely. Other than this, extreme weather conditions that often impact power supply and surge in demand can also be predicted and addressed accordingly. At present, batteries of electric vehicles, whether acid-based or Li-based, have limited storage capacities and need to be replaced regularly. Further, their disposal has led to a severe environmental challenge as most of them are discarded without due caution, leading to soil, air, and water pollution. Quantum computers can suggest methods to improve the efficiency of power storage and also store power for longer periods, thereby cutting down on the need for replacing these batteries often. This would be critical to keeping global warming levels at less than 2℃ by 2050. The emerging technology will also be useful for the fertiliser industry. At present, fertiliser production accounts for nearly 2 percent of the global GHG tally. And with the use of quantum computers, the process of nitrogen fixation can be made more sustainable and eco-friendly. Researchers and scientists are using quantum modelling to fathom the process of natural nitrogen fixation used by soil bacteria which can later be developed synthetically to curb soil pollution and lower the energy demand in the production of chemical nitrogen-based fertilisers.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › NEG › 2NC

A National Quantum Research Task Force is necessary in order to provide reasonably priced cloud-based access as well as quantum training to academics

Hodan Omaar 4/27/21 (Hodan Omaar is a senior analyst focusing on AI policy at ITIF’s Center for Data Innovation. Previously, she worked as a senior consultant on technology and risk management in London and as a crypto-economist in Berlin. She has an M.A. in economics and mathematics from the University of Edinburgh. “Why the United States Needs to Support Near-Term Quantum Computing Applications.” ITIF. https://itif.org/publications/2021/04/27/why-united-states-needs-support-near-term-quantum-computing-applications/) Date Accessed: 7/1/23 HRF

However, the cost of quantum computing may be too high for many academic researchers and thus limit their ability to develop future talent in the field and apply quantum computing solutions to ongoing work. To address this problem, Congress should establish a National Quantum Research Task Force to provide academic researchers with affordable access to high-end quantum computing resources in a secure cloud environment, as well as the necessary training they need to make the most of it. This task force could be analogous to the AI research task force that was established as part of the National AI Research Resource Task Force Act of 2020 and consist of members from academia, government, and industry. Their goal should be to develop a roadmap for building, deploying, funding, and governing a national quantum computing research cloud that can accelerate access to quantum computing for research in the public interest. The National Quantum Research Task Force should also ensure it considers how to provide equitable access to quantum computing at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and Minority Serving Institutions (MSIs). The U.S. government itself should play a role in exploring quantum applications, not only to better solve agency-specific problems but also to signal the benefits of doing so to the private sector. To this end, the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) should issue a quantum challenge that requires every federal agency to identify at least two existing use cases for which they can use quantum computing. For instance, the Department of Transportation (DOT) could identify ways quantum computing could help optimize public transportation across cities. But, since this relies on access to mobility data that is often held by private companies, DOT should establish a platform that aggregates and centralizes mobility data across cities, which public and private players would contribute to. Finally, even though the development of a large-scale quantum computer capable of breaking cryptographic protocols is at least a decade away, Congress should consider incentivizing post-quantum cryptography transition (PQC) in the public and private sectors through mechanisms such as a dedicated fund to support state and local governments in their transition efforts and a certification scheme for companies that implement PQC protocols. As the development of quantum computing technologies will likely become globalized industries, the National Quantum Coordinating Office (NQCO) should publish a report outlining what the quantum supply chain looks like today and where risks are likely to emerge to better inform future economic and national security policies.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › NEG › 1NC

Quantum computers will solve the climate crisis and are key to countries reaching emission goals

Peter Cooper et al. 5/19/22 (Peter Cooper is an associate partner in McKinsey’s London office, where Dieter Kiewell is a senior partner; Philipp Ernst is a senior expert in the Hamburg office; and Dickon Pinner is a senior partner in the Bay Area office. “Quantum computing just might save the planet.” McKinsey and Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/quantum-computing-just-might-save-the-planet)

The emerging technology of could revolutionize the fight against climate change, transforming the economics of decarbonization and becoming a major factor in limiting global warming to the target temperature of 1.5°C (see sidebar “What is quantum computing?”). Even though the technology is in the early stages of development—experts estimate the first generation of fault-tolerant quantum computing1 will arrive in the second half of this decade—breakthroughs are accelerating, investment dollars are pouring in, and start-ups are proliferating.2 Major tech companies have already developed small, so-called noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) machines, though these aren’t capable of performing the type of calculations that fully capable quantum computers are expected to perform. Countries and corporates set ambitious new targets for reducing emissions at the 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26). Those goals, if fully met, would represent an extraordinary annual investment of $4 trillion by 2030, the largest reallocation of capital in human history. But the measures would only reduce warming to between 1.7°C and 1.8°C by 2050, far short of the 1.5°C level believed necessary to avoid catastrophic, runaway climate change. Meeting the goal of net-zero emissions that countries and some industries have committed to won’t be possible without huge advances in climate technology that aren’t achievable today. Even the most powerful supercomputers available now are not able to solve some of these problems. Quantum computing could be a game changer in those areas. In all, we think quantum computing could help develop climate technologies able to abate carbon on the order of 7 gigatons a year of additional CO2 impact by 2035, with the potential to bring the world in line with the 1.5°C target. Quantum computing could help reduce emissions in some of the most challenging or emissions-intensive areas, such as agriculture or direct-air capture, and could accelerate improvements in technologies required at great scale, such as solar panels or batteries. This article offers a look at some of the breakthroughs the technology could permit and attempts to quantify the impact of leveraging quantum-computer technology that are expected become available this decade. Solving so far insoluble problems Quantum computing could bring about step changes throughout the economy that would have a huge impact on carbon abatement and carbon removal, including by helping to solve persistent sustainability problems such as curbing methane produced by agriculture, making the production of cement emissions-free, improving electric batteries for vehicles, developing significantly better renewable solar technology, finding a faster way to bring down the cost of hydrogen to make it a viable alternative to fossil fuels, and using green ammonia as a fuel and a fertilizer. Addressing the five areas designated in the as key for decarbonization, we have identified quantum-computing use cases that can pave the way to a net-zero economy. We project that by 2035 the use cases listed below could make it possible to eliminate more than 7 gigatons of CO2 equivalent (CO2e) from the atmosphere a year, compared with the current trajectory, or in aggregate more than 150 gigatons over the next 30 years (Exhibit 1). Exhibit 1 Shift 1: Electrifying our lives Batteries Batteries are a critical element of achieving zero-carbon electrification. They are required to reduce CO2 emissions from transportation and to obtain grid-scale energy storage for intermittent energy sources such as solar cells or wind. Improving the energy density of lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries enables applications in electric vehicles and energy storage at an affordable cost. Over the past ten years, however, innovation has stalled—battery energy density improved 50 percent between 2011 and 2016, but only 25 percent between 2016 and 2020, and is expected to improve by just 17 percent between 2020 and 2025. Recent research3 has shown that quantum computing will be able to simulate the chemistry of batteries in ways that can’t be achieved now. Quantum computing could allow breakthroughs by providing a better understanding of electrolyte complex formation, by helping to find a replacement material for cathode/anode with the same properties and/or by eliminating the battery separator. As a result, we could create batteries with 50 percent higher energy density for use in heavy-goods electric vehicles, which could substantially bring forward their economic use. The carbon benefits to passenger EVs wouldn’t be huge, as these vehicles are expected to reach cost parity in many countries before the first generation of quantum computers is online, but consumers might still enjoy cost savings. In addition, higher-density energy batteries can serve as a grid-scale storage solution. The impact on the world’s grids could be transformative. Halving the cost of grid-scale storage could enable a step change in the use of solar power, which is becoming economically competitive but is challenged by its generation profile. Our modeling suggests that halving the cost of solar panels could increase their use by 25 percent in Europe by 2050 but halving both solar and batteries might increase solar use by 60 percent (Exhibit 2). Geographies without such a high carbon price will see even greater impacts. Exhibit 2Through the combination of use cases described above, improved batteries could bring about an additional reduction in carbon dioxide emissions of 1.4 gigatons by 2035.Shift 2: Adapting industrial operations Cement Many parts of the industry produce emissions that are either extremely expensive or logistically challenging to abate. Cement is a case in point. During calcination in the kiln for the process of making clinker, a powder used to make cement, CO2 is released from raw materials. This process accounts for approximately two-thirds of cement emissions. Alternative cement-binding materials (or “clinkers”) can eliminate these emissions, but there’s currently no mature alternative clinker that can significantly reduce emissions at an affordable cost. There are many possible permutations for such a product, but testing by trial and error is time-consuming and costly. Quantum computing can help to simulate theoretical material combinations to find one that overcomes today’s challenges—durability, availability of raw materials and efflorescence (in the case of alkali-activated binders). This would have an estimated additional impact of 1 gigaton a year by 2035. Shift 3: Decarbonizing power and fuel Solar cells Solar cells will be one of the key electricity-generation sources in a net-zero economy. But even though they are getting cheaper, they still are far from their theoretical maximum efficiency. Today’s solar cells rely on crystalline silicon and have an efficiency on the order of 20 percent. Solar cells based on perovskite crystal structures, which have a theoretical efficiency of up to 40 percent, could be a better alternative. They present challenges, however, because they lack long-term stability and could, in some varieties, be more toxic. Furthermore, the technology has not been mass produced yet. Quantum computing could help tackle these challenges by allowing for precise simulation of perovskite structures in all combinations using different base atoms and doping, thereby identifying higher efficiency, higher durability, and nontoxic solutions. If the theoretical efficiency increase can be reached, the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) would decrease by 50 percent. By simulating the impact of cheaper and more efficient quantum-enabled solar panels, we see a significant increase in use in areas with lower carbon prices (China, for example). This is also true of countries in Europe with high irradiance (Spain, Greece) or poor conditions for wind energy (Hungary). The impact is magnified when combined with cheap battery storage, as discussed above. This technology could abate an additional 0.4 gigatons of CO2 emissions by 2035. Hydrogen Hydrogen is widely considered to be a viable replacement for fossil fuels in many parts of the economy, especially in industry where high temperature is needed and electrification isn’t possible or sufficient, or where hydrogen is needed as a feedstock, such as steelmaking or ethylene production. Before the 2022 gas price spikes, green hydrogen was about 60 percent more expensive than natural gas. But improving electrolysis could significantly decrease the cost of hydrogen. Polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) electrolyzers split water and are one way to make green hydrogen. They have improved in recent times but still face two major challenges. They are not as efficient as they could be. We know that “pulsing” the electrical current rather than running it constantly improves efficiency in lab environments, but we don’t understand this enough to get it to work at scale. Electrolyzers have delicate membranes that allow the split hydrogen to pass from the anode to the cathode (but keeps the split oxygen out). In addition, they have catalysts that speed up the overall process. Catalysts and membranes do not yet interact well. The more efficient we make the catalyst, the more it wears down the membrane. This doesn’t have to be the case, but we don’t understand the interactions well enough to design better membranes and catalysts. Quantum computing can help model the energy state of pulse electrolysis to optimize catalyst usage, which would increase efficiency. Quantum computing could also model the chemical composition of catalysts and membranes to ensure the most efficient interactions. And it could push the efficiency of the electrolysis process up to 100 percent and reduce the cost of hydrogen by 35 percent. If combined with cheaper solar cells discovered by quantum computing (discussed above), the cost of hydrogen could be reduced by 60 percent (Exhibit 3). Exhibit 3 Increased hydrogen use as a result of these improvements could reduce CO2 emissions by an additional 1.1 gigatons by 2035. Ammonia Ammonia is best known as a fertilizer, but could also be used as fuel, potentially making it one of the best decarbonization solutions for the world’s ships. Today, it represents 2 percent of total global final energy consumption. For the moment, ammonia is made through the energy-intensive Haber-Bosch process using natural gas. There are several options for creating green ammonia, but they rely on similar processes. For example, green hydrogen can be used as a feedstock, or the carbon dioxide emissions that are caused by the process can be captured and stored. However, there are other potential approaches, such as nitrogenase bioelectrocatalysis, which is how nitrogen fixation works naturally when plants take nitrogen gas directly from the air and nitrogenase enzymes catalyze its conversion into ammonia. This method is attractive because it can be done at room temperature and at 1 bar pressure, compared with 500°C at high pressure using Haber-Bosch, which consumes large amounts of energy (in the form of natural gas) (Exhibit 4). Exhibit 4 Innovation has reached a stage where it might be possible to replicate nitrogen fixation artificially, but only if we can overcome challenges such as enzyme stability, oxygen sensitivity, and low rates of ammonia production by nitrogenase. The concept works in the lab but not at scale. Quantum computing can help simulate the process of enhancing the stability of the enzyme, protecting it from oxygen and improving the rate of ammonia production by nitrogenase. That would result in a 67 percent cost reduction over today’s green ammonia produced through electrolysis, which would make green ammonia even cheaper than traditionally produced ammonia. Such a cost reduction could not only lessen the CO2 impacts of the production of ammonia for agricultural use but could also bring forward the breakeven for ammonia in shipping—where it is expected to be a major decarbonization option—forward by ten years. Using quantum computing to facilitate cheaper green ammonia as a shipping fuel could abate an additional CO2 by 0.4 gigatons by 2035. Shift 4: Ramping up carbon capture and carbon sequestration activity Carbon capture is required to achieve net zero. Both types of carbon capture—point source and direct—could be aided by quantum computing. Point-source capture Point-source carbon capture allows CO2 to be captured directly from industrial sources such as a cement or steel blast furnace. But the vast majority of CO2 capture is too expensive to be viable for now, mainly because it is energy intense. One possible solution: novel solvents, such as water-lean and multiphase solvents, which could offer lower-energy requirements, but it is difficult to predict the properties of the potential material at a molecular level. Quantum computing promises to enable more accurate modeling of molecular structure to design new, effective solvents for a range of CO2 sources, which could reduce the cost of the process by 30 to 50 percent. We believe this has significant potential to decarbonize industrial processes, which could lead to additional decarbonization of up to 1.5 gigatons a year, including cement. If the cement clinker approach described above is successful, this would still have an effect of 0.5 gigatons a year, due to fuel emissions. In addition, alternative clinkers may not be available in some regions. Direct-air capture Direct-air capture, which involves sucking CO2 from the air, is a way to address carbon removals. While the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says this approach is required to achieve net zero, it is very expensive (ranging from $250 to $600 per ton a day today) and even more energy intensive than point-source capture. Adsorbents are best suited for effective direct-air capture and novel approaches, such as metal organic frameworks, or MOFs, have the potential to greatly reduce the energy requirements and the capital cost of the infrastructure. MOFs act like a giant sponge—as little as a gram can have a surface area larger than a football field—and can absorb and release CO2 at far lower temperature changes than conventional technology. Quantum computing can help advance research on novel adsorbents such as MOFs and resolve challenges4 arising from sensitivity to oxidation, water, and degradation caused by CO2. Novel adsorbents that have a higher adsorption rate could reduce the cost of technology to $100 per ton of CO2e captured. This could be a critical threshold for uptake, given that corporate climate leaders such as Microsoft5 have publicly announced an expectation to pay $100 a ton long term for the highest-quality carbon removals. This would lead to an additional CO2 reduction of 0.7 gigatons a year by 2035. Shift 5: Reforming food and forestry come from agriculture—and methane emitted by cattle and dairy is the primary contributor (7.9 gigatons of CO2e, based on 20-year global-warming potential). Research has established that low-methane feed additives could effectively stop up to 90 percent of methane emissions. Yet applying those additives for free-range livestock is particularly difficult. An alternative solution is an antimethane vaccine that produces methanogen-targeting antibodies. This method has had some success in lab conditions, but in a cow’s gut—churning with gastric juices and food—the antibodies struggle to latch on to the right microbes. Quantum computing could accelerate the research to find the right antibodies by precise molecule simulation instead of a costly and long trial-and-error method. With estimated uptake determined according to data from the US Environmental Protection Agency, we arrive at carbon reduction of up to an additional 1 gigaton a year by 2035. Another prominent use case in agriculture is green ammonia discussed as a fuel above, where today’s Haber-Bosch process uses large amounts of natural gas. Using such an alternative process could have an additional impact of up to 0.25 gigatons a year by 2035, replacing current conventionally produced fertilizers.Additional use cases There are many more ways that quantum computing could be applied to the fight against climate change. Future possibilities include identification of new thermal-storage materials, high-temperature superconductors as a future base for lower losses in grids, or simulations to support nuclear fusion. Use cases aren’t limited to climate mitigation, but can also apply to adaptation, for example, improvements in weather prediction to give greater warning of major climatic events. But progress on those innovations will have to wait because first-generation machines will not be powerful enough for such breakthroughs (see sidebar “Methodology”). Opportunity for corporates The leap in CO2 abatement could be a major opportunity for corporates. With $3 to $5 trillion in value at stake in sustainability, according to , climate investment is an imperative for big companies. The use cases presented above represent major shifts and potential disruptions in these areas, and they are associated with huge value for players who take the lead. This opportunity is recognized by industry leaders who are already developing capabilities and talent. Nevertheless, quantum technology is in the early stage and comes with the risks linked to leading-edge technology development, as well as tremendous cost. We have highlighted the stage of the industry in the .6 The risk to investors can be mitigated somewhat through steps such as onboarding technical experts to run in-depth diligence, forming joint investments with public entities or consortia, and investing in companies that bundle various ventures under one roof and provide the necessary experience to set up and scale these ventures. In addition, governments have an important role to play by creating programs at universities to develop quantum talent and by providing incentives for quantum innovation for climate, particularly for use cases that today do not have natural corporate partners, such as disaster prediction, or that aren’t economical, such as direct-air capture. Governments could start more research programs like the partnership between IBM and the United Kingdom,7 the collaboration between IBM and Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft,8 the public–private partnership Quantum Delta9 in the Netherlands, and the collaboration between the United States and the United Kingdom.10 By tapping into quantum computing for sustainability, countries will accelerate the green transition, achieve national commitments, and get a head start in export markets. But even with those measures, the risk and expense remain high (Exhibit 5).Exhibit 5 Here are some questions corporates and investors need to ask before taking a leap into quantum computing. Is quantum computing relevant for you? Determine whether there are use cases that can potentially disrupt your industry or your investments and address the decarbonization challenges of your organization. This article has highlighted anecdotal use cases across several categories to showcase the potential impact of quantum computing, but we’ve identified more than 100 sustainability-relevant use cases where quantum computing could play a major role. Quickly identifying use cases that are applicable to you and deciding how to address them can be highly valuable, as talent and capacity will be scarce in this decade.How do I approach quantum computing now, if it is relevant? Once you have engaged on quantum computing, building the right kind of approach, mitigating risk and securing access to talent and capacity are key. Because of the high cost of this research, corporates can maximize their impact by forming partnerships with other players from their value chains and pooling expense and talent. For example, major consumers of hydrogen might join up with electrolyzer manufacturers to bring down the cost and share the value. These arrangements will require companies to figure out how to share innovation without losing competitive advantage. Collaborations such as joint ventures or precompetitive R&D could be an answer. We also foresee investors willing to support such endeavors to potentially remove some of the risk for corporates. And there are large amounts of dedicated climate finance available, judging by pledges11 made at COP26 that aim to reach the target of $100 billion a year in spending. Do I have to start now? While the first fault-tolerant quantum computer is several years away, it is important to start development work now. There is significant prework to be done to get to a maximal return on the significant investment that application of quantum computing will require. Determining the exact parameters of a given problem and finding the best possible application will mean collaboration between application experts and quantum-computing technicians well versed in algorithm development. We estimate algorithm development would take up to 18 months, depending on the complexity. It will also take time to set up the value chain, production, and go-to-market to ensure they are ready when quantum computing can be deployed and to fully benefit from the value created. Quantum computing is a revolutionary technology that could allow for precise molecular-level simulation and a deeper understanding of nature’s basic laws. As this article shows, its development over the next few years could help solve scientific problems that until recently were believed to be insoluble. Clearing away these roadblocks could make the difference between a sustainable future and climate catastrophe. Making quantum computing a reality will require an exceptional mobilization of resources, expertise, and funds. Only close cooperation between governments, scientists, academics, and investors in developing this technology can make it possible to reach the target for limiting emissions that will keep global warming at 1.5°C and save the planet.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Quantum Computing › NEG › 1NC

Quantum computing is capable of helping the environment now, but government funding is key for development past near-term applications.

Hodan Omaar 4/27/21 (Hodan Omaar is a senior analyst focusing on AI policy at ITIF’s Center for Data Innovation. Previously, she worked as a senior consultant on technology and risk management in London and as a crypto-economist in Berlin. She has an M.A. in economics and mathematics from the University of Edinburgh. “Why the United States Needs to Support Near-Term Quantum Computing Applications.” ITIF. https://itif.org/publications/2021/04/27/why-united-states-needs-support-near-term-quantum-computing-applications/) Date Accessed: 7/1/23 HRF

Overcoming technical challenges on the path toward large-scale quantum computers will depend on the ability to scale the number of qubits in quantum systems, much like modern classical computers have depended on the growth in the number of transistors in superconducting chips. The current enthusiasm for quantum computing could lead to a virtuous cycle of progress, as the semiconductor industry has already seen, but only if near-term applications for the quantum computing technologies under development are successful. The U.S. government can best support the scaling of current quantum technologies by fostering a commercial market for them in the near term. Current quantum devices can already solve problems in an array of application areas, such as health care, manufacturing, transportation, and the environment. Researchers have identified several other potential application areas, but these findings remain in the research space. To ensure quantum research is effectively translated into real-world applications, Congress should provide $500 million in funding over 5 years for academic research projects that have near-term applications to work with industry on research and development (R&D). Ideally, this program would encourage and support research projects that align with regional economic development goals by fostering collaboration and partnerships between universities, local businesses, and state and local governments.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Print Money › AFF › 2AC

Inflation caused by percieved value of money, leads to collapse of entire economic systems

Ashley Asante – 2013 – (MBA. Economics )“National Economic Collapse and Revival, The Case of Zimbabwe” https://www.theseus.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/65537/Ashley%20Asante.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y --l.e.hernandez--

Inflation is the process were by a currency loses its value due to many factors that in- clude for example; a increase in demand for products and extreme printing of money by central banks. (Andrew B. Abel, Inflation, 2008) It can also be described as a sustained increase in the general price levels in an economy over a given period of time. According to (Andrew B. Abel, 2008); Inflation is the rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services is rising, and, afterwards, purchasing power is declining or, the on-going fall in the overall purchasing power of the monetary unit. Inflation rates vary from year to year and, from currency to currency. Inflation can also be defined as an increase in money supply and increase in credits. Inflation can be complex but can also be controlled if governments are strict on themselves by carefully following the monetary and fiscal policy laws. (Gillespie, 2007) Inflation can be measured in different ways, commonly by the gross domestic product deflator or the consumer price index indicator which measure the general changes in prices for a wide range goods.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Print Money › AFF › 2AC

Printing more money unsustainable

H. Erich Heienmann - access date - 7/1/23 – (M.B.A Economics from harvard, an economist and financial writer) https://urresearch.rochester.edu/institutionalPublicationPublicView.action?institutionalItemId=1102 --l.e.hernandez--

Four highlights: If the Fed sticks to its strategy of a disciplined monetary policy aimed at a zero inflation, long-term interest rates should continue to decline; Inflation occurs only when central banks print more money than people wish to hold. Inflation is not due to capacity use in manufacturing, unemployment or even the price of oil; Profits are under pressure in private sectors' and the U.S. Budget is in better shape than Washington admits. However, rapid growth in revenue and stagnant spending are not sustainable.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Print Money › NEG › 2NC

The US ought to follow the examples of those in Europe and Asia in order to lift the entire country out of trillions of dollars worth of debt.

Stephen Parker – 12/19/96 (Trade economist and policy reform expert Stephen Parker specializes in Southeast Asia, where he has led USAID projects since 2001. He currently serves as Chief of Party of the USAID-funded Transparency and Inclusive Growth Activity in Yangon, Burma, following COP roles in two earlier economic reform projects in Burma.) Economies in Transition; Comparing Asia and Europe” --l.e.hernandez--

2. TVEs are non-state enterprises. This feature is important in relation to the "softness" of budget constraints. The most important institutional superiority of TVEs over the SOEs is that the former cannot borrow forever to cover their losses. Being a non-state enterprise means that the rescue of a bankrupt TVE is not the state's responsibility. The SOEs, on the other hand, have repeatedly been able to force the state to print more money to bail them out. This institutional feature is the reason why competition does not shut down bad SOEs. 3. Institutional innovation. The institutional evolution of TVEs has been faster because TVEs, unlike SOEs, can implement institutional innovations without central government approval. Recent locally initiated development of a "shareholding collective system" in TVEs and rural community economies shows this feature very well. This freedom of TVEs has enabled them to move closer to best international practices in corporate govemance. In a nutshell, the TVEs, unlike the SOEs, live by the market. During the last economic downturn, the number of industrial TVEs fell from 7.7 million in 1988 to 7.2 million in 1990, while the number of industrial SOEs increased from 99,000 to 104,000. It must be emphasized that the SO sector has not been withering away, as suggested in some claims that China has "grown out of the plan." The SOE sector has actually retained its relative standing in employment: 18 percent of the 1978 and 1993 labor force. There were 35 million more SOE workers in 1993 than in 1978.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Print Money › NEG › 1NC

Printing more money solves economic collapse

Kieron O'Hara – March 2012- (an associate professor in Electronics and Computer Science at the University of Southampton.) “The Politics of Responsibility Contribution to debate on ‘The Future of Conservatism’ The European” https://web.archive.org/web/20181103204506id_/https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/336916/1/ohara_european.pdf --l.e.hernandez--

The conservative’s insight is that we never know enough. Society is too complex and dynamic; we can’t foresee the consequences of policy. Change is therefore risky. Theory has its purpose, but should be kept in its place. The credit glut that followed the financial reforms in the UK and elsewhere in the 1980s is perhaps our major current problem. Economists will tell you that the Modigliani-Miller Theorem shows that it makes no difference whether investment is funded by debt or by equity. Conservatives reply: ‘do you trust your eyes, or economic theorems?’ Indeed, no ideology has a ready answer to today’s politics of austerity. The demands of the media and the uncertainty of electoral cycles drive politicians to promise more, financing today’s spending by tomorrow’s growth. Optimism is the single European political currency, and like the euro it will be put under strain in the medium term. But the main requirement is for individuals, companies and governments to act responsibly; that cannot be imposed by any ideology. In particular, there is an obvious mantra for European governments: if you don’t want to be pushed around by the bond markets, don’t borrow on the bond markets. You can either spend less money, or tax your citizens more, or (if you are not in the Eurozone) print more money. That’s the choice; you can no more spend without limit than you can repeal the law of gravity.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Polycentric Communities › AFF › 2AC

PDB – Let communities handle their own policies while also upholding carbon taxes and green infrastructure policies.

J. Tosun ’18 (PhD at the University of Konstanz on the topic of transformative change of environmental policy in Latin America and Eastern Europe, research Fellow at the Mannheim Centre for European Social Research)

The EU’s push to become an international climate leader has resulted in two important processes. First, within the EU a diffusion process has started, which in some cases (e.g. the promotion of renewable energy) has resulted in the adoption of harmonised policy measures, whereas in other cases the policy innovations have been adopted by only some EU member states (e.g. carbon taxes). The diffusion of climate policies within the EU has helped to establish the EU as a domain in which polycentric climate governance takes place.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Microorganisms › AFF › 2AC

Perm do both. Green infrastructure increases microbe diversity

Joyner 19 et al (Jessica Lee Joyner, Department of Biological Sciences, Brooklyn College of The City University of New York, Brooklyn, NY, United States, Department of Biology, Georgia State University, Atlanta, Georgia “Green Infrastructure Design Influences Communities of Urban Soil Bacteria” 5-16-2019 Frontiers in Microbiology https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6531853/)GH-HM

Among the ecosystem services provided by GI features, these data suggest that Technosol associated bacteria have the potential to utilize or break down urban contaminants in addition to TPH. This ecosystem service is valuable for management strategies of urban ecosystems to remediate chemical and oil spills as well as heavy metals, especially for long-term contaminated sites (Wilson et al., 1999; Ellis et al., 2000; Mishra et al., 2001; Delgado-Balbuena et al., 2016). Bacterial Orders in the top 10% of Technosol community that were enriched compared to urban surface soils, were RB41, iii1-15, Saprospirales, Cytophagales, Pirellulales, Opitutales, Anaerolineae__envOPS12. These bacteria are likely the initial description of a potential consortium that characterize the GI Technosol community through contributing to bioremediation or are indicating of contamination. The top two groups are RB41 (Class Chloroacidobacteria, Order Acidobacteria) and iii1-15 (Class Acidobacteria-6, Order Acidobacteria) and they are common in urban soils and are prominent in soils globally; though their enrichment and role in the context of bioremediation in GI Technosols is unclear (Fierer, 2017; Huot et al., 2017). Natural urban surface soils had a greater abundance in Myxococcales, which contribute to removal of trace organic contaminants, specifically uranium, and may additionally suppress unwanted organisms (Cardenas et al., 2010; Phan et al., 2016; Robinson et al., 2016). The increase in abundance of Cytophagales in GI Technosols may indicate some functional redundancy within the diverse bacterial community. Cytophagales have previously been documented as enriched in urban soils contaminated with crude oil and can metabolize heavy metal (e.g., Selenium) (de Souza et al., 2001), which also reinforces their potential functional role as a bioremediator within GI features (Mukherjee et al., 2017). Rhodospirillales had decreased abundance in the Technosols, however, their presence may still contribute to pollutant degradation, since soils with phenanthrene,n-octadecane and PAH pollution had thriving populations of Rhodospirillales (Ji et al., 2013; Jiao et al., 2016). In the GI Technosols studied here, the contaminant concentrations were most likely too low to drive a response. Additional indicators of bacterial community response to TPH contaminants may also be detected through the increased abundance of bacteria typically used to facilitate bioremediation; such as, Corynebacterium, Flavobacterium, and Bacillus species, as well as Pseudomonas and Micrococcus species because of their notable biodegradation of crude oil (Mishra et al., 2001; Rahman et al., 2002; Paul et al., 2005). Since overall TPH levels were low GI sites were not considered polluted. The consequence of the low levels of contaminants detected in the GI sites is likely why respective taxa for bioremediation were not abundant. The bacterial communities of Technosols at GI sites have limited evidence of known urban contaminants. Further understanding of the role of GI features for bioremediation in urban areas requires future studies focused on the enrichments of specific bacterial taxa and contaminants. The bacterial community of different GI designs are influenced by a combination of biogeochemical parameters and GI features. Future studies using shotgun metagenome sequencing would corroborate functional capabilities (e.g., nutrient cycling and bioremediation of contaminants) from these unique GI sites and facilitate comparing observations regarding the urban soil microbiomes across analysis platforms. Conclusion Our description of the microbiome of urban GI features has improved our understanding of the factors influencing bacterial community composition and the role of GI features in an urban ecosystem. GI design that integrates connectivity to urban street runoff can be a key constraint on the bacteria present in Technosol communities; in contrast, they may not have overwhelming effects on microbial-mediated ecosystem processes. Biogeochemical parameters were not reduced in highly connected, highly engineered GI features. Therefore, design and management of GI features that support high levels of soil organic matter will be important for sustaining the functions of GI features in highly stressed urban environments. One important consideration is the maintenance of healthy plant communities as part of the management and sustainability of GI features and functions. Storm events and resulting urban runoff will have strong impacts to GI sites and bacterial community, particularly in ROWB, and further investigation can address specific differences between SSIS and ETP designs.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Microorganisms › AFF › 2AC

Microbes are massive emitters making more accelerates climate

Zimmer 10 (Carl Zimmer writes about science for The New York Times He is currently a lecturer at Yale University. A 2007 winner of the National Academies of Science Communication Award “The Microbe Factor and Its Role in Our Climate Future” 6-1-2010 Yale Environment 360 https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_microbe_factor_and_its_role_in_our_climate_future) GH-HM

Even more impressive is the vast amount of carbon that microbes pump around the biosphere. On the surface of the ocean, photosynthetic bacteriasuck vast amounts of carbon dioxide dissolved in the water and turn it into organic molecules. The ocean is also rife with bacteria that feed on organic matter and release carbon dioxide as waste. Meanwhile, the microbes that break plant matter into soil release 55 billion tons a year of carbon dioxide. “It’s eight times what humans are putting into the atmosphere through fossil fuel burning and deforestation,” says Allison. Microbes have been absorbing and releasing greenhouse gases ever since they first evolved in the ocean more than 3.5 billion years ago and spread on land about 2 billion years ago. And in the process they’ve influenced the Earth’s climate. But the influence doesn’t just flow one way, from microbes to the climate. As the climate changes, it can change the planet’s microbial menagerie. Scientists are only just starting to figure out some of the rules that govern this feedback. They know just enough to recognize that as we raise the planet’s temperature, we will alter the planet’s microbes. And as we change the world’s microbes, we will also change their impact on the climate. But scientists have only a rough sense of what those changes will turn out to be. It’s possible that we will cause bacteria to churn out greenhouse gases far faster than they do today, adding to our own global warming. Gulf Oil Spill Wikimedia Commons A microscopic view of oscillatoria, a bacteria found in freshwater. Or they may be stimulated to draw carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere, softening the blow of climate change. Or all of the above.