Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Microorganisms › NEG › 2NC

Governments must commit to microbe R and D

Baylis 19 (Matthew Baylis PhD on the ecological interactions and a professor at the university of Liverpool “Don’t leave microbes out of climate change conversation, experts warn” 6-18-2019 University of Liverpool https://news.liverpool.ac.uk/2019/06/18/dont-leave-microbes-out-of-climate-change-conversation-experts-warn/

An international group of leading microbiologists have issued a warning, saying that not including microbes – the support system of the biosphere – in the climate change equation will have major negative flow-on effects. More than 30 microbiologists from nine countries have issued a warning to humanity – they are calling for the world to stop ignoring an ‘unseen majority’ in Earth’s biodiversity and ecosystem when addressing climate change. ‘Scientist’s warning to humanity: microorganisms and climate change’ was published today in the journal Nature Reviews Microbiology. With their statement, the researchers are hoping to raise awareness both for how microbes can influence climate change and how they will be impacted by it – calling for including microbes in climate change research, increasing the use of research involving innovative technologies, and improving education in classrooms. Co-author Professor Mathew Baylis of the University of Liverpool, says: “This publication shines a light on the vital role that microbes play in climate change, both affecting the rate of climate change by taking in or releasing greenhouse gases themselves, and also being affected by climate change, thereby affecting the health of our oceans, freshwater ecosystems, agriculture – and ourselves.” Professor Rick Cavicchioli, microbiologist at the School of Biotechnology and Biomolecular Sciences at UNSW Sydney, who led the global effort, adds: “Micro-organisms, which include bacteria and viruses, are the lifeforms that you don’t see on the conservation websites. They support the existence of all higher lifeforms and are critically important in regulating climate change. However, they are rarely the focus of climate change studies and not considered in policy development.” Microbes play critical functions in animal and human health, agriculture, the global food web and industry. For example, climate change is increasing the number and geographic range of mosquitos which are the major vector of dengue, Zika, chikungunya, yellow fever, West Nile fever and Japanese encephalitis viruses, thereby placing millions of people newly at risk. Professor Baylis adds: “Some of these changes are happening now. As a consequence of warming over recent years, we have already seen viral diseases of livestock, such as Bluetongue, emerge in mainland Europe and spread to the UK.” Greater commitment to microbe-based research needed In their statement, the scientists call on researchers, institutions and governments to commit to greater microbial recognition to mitigate climate change. “This goes to the heart of climate change, so if micro-organisms aren’t considered effectively, it means models cannot be generated properly and predictions could be inaccurate. Decisions that are made now impact on humans and other forms of life, so if you don’t take into account the microbial world, you’re missing a very big component of the equation,” concludes Professor Cavicchioli.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Microorganisms › NEG › 2NC

Microbes lower emissions by consuming greenhouse gases

Tiedje et al 22 (James M. Tiedje has a PhD in Agronomy and is a Plant, Soil and Microbial Sciences professor at Michigan State University “Microbes and Climate Change: a Research Prospectus for the Future” 4-19-2022 American Society for Microbiology https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00800-22)GH-HM

Climate change is now widely recognized as the most serious contemporary challenge for humanity. Indeed, a new report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) states that the situation has grown even worse, with 3.3 billion of the world’s population highly vulnerable to climate change, and that current unsustainable development patterns are increasing exposure of ecosystems and people to climate hazards (). We can engage in solutions to change from the current trajectory as individuals, as action leaders for society, and as microbiologists with domain expertise. Microbes have prominent roles related to climate change. They produce and consume the three dominant gases that are responsible for 98% of the increased warming: carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O). While microbes are sources of these gases as part of natural processes, some of their recent increase is due to changes in human activities that result in microbes having more access to carbon and nitrogen that they convert into these three products. Our actions can be to understand and then implement practices that mitigate microbial activities to decelerate the production of these gases, such as reduced soil tillage, or use microbes to repurpose waste carbon or nitrogen into useful and stable products. Fortunately, microbes also consume these three gases and do so when their growth conditions favor the use of these gases as resources, namely, photo- or chemoautotrophic growth (cyanobacteria, algae, nitrifiers), methanotrophy (methane oxidizers), and nitrous oxide reduction (denitrifiers). The environmental conditions and interactions of these microbes, often influenced by humans, determine whether they carry out production or consumption of these gases. In some cases, we can manage conditions to favor microbial consumption of these gases. Microbes that produce and consume these gases live in so many different habitats, and these habitats have very different spatial scales and process times, making it a challenge to quantify their contributions and changes in response to environmental conditions, e.g., warming, storms, and drought. Three ecosystem types pose three distinct assessment and management challenges: terrestrial, ocean, and urban. Improved measurements and models are keys to determine greenhouse gas (GHG) fluxes in these different systems, at different scales, and their patterns of change in response to human actions

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Microorganisms › NEG › 1NC

Microbes are key to regulating and solving climate change

  Mangodo et al 20 (Chimezie Mangodo has a Master of Science - Geography Environment Management and Assessment) focused in Atmospheric Sciences and Meteorology from University of Benin “Impact of Microorganisms on Climate Change: A Review” 4-25-2020 World News of Natural Sciences bibliotekanauki.pl) GH-HM

Recent research on biological responses to climate exchange has focused on animals and plants and their interactions (Pounds et al., 2006). It has been shown by several studies that certain groups of microorganisms preserved in lake sediments such as phototrophs and aerobes, may be useful in reconstructing recent environmental changes (Coolen et al., 2004a, 2004b). Microorganisms play important roles in carbon and nutrient cycle, animal, human and plant health, agriculture and the global food web. The microorganisms are involved in the emission and removal of greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide and methane, which in turn are responsible for climate change (Microbiology Online 2015). Microbes play an important role as either generators or users of these gases in the environment as they are able to recycle and transform the essential elements such as carbon and nitrogen that make up cells (Joshi & Shekhanat, 2010). If we ignore the importance of microbial processes, we fundamentally limit our understanding of Earth’s biosphere and response to climate change and hence jeopardize efforts to create an environmentally sustainable future (UN, 2018). The microorganisms are important to carbon and other biogeochemical cycles, and their role with respect to climate change requires attention (Walsh 2015). This review aim to call the attention of policy makers and the international community to the importance of microorganisms in fighting climate change while elucidating the role of biosphere reserves in mitigating climate change. 2. CLIMATE CHANGE – A WORLD PROBLEM Climate is defined as average weather conditions of a certain region, including temperature, rainfall and wind. Climate change is the most complex global issue of the present time, it includes scientific, economic, social, political, moral, and ethical aspects (NASA 2015a). The Earth is surrounded by a thick layer of gases which keeps the planet warm and allows plants, animals and microbes to live. These gases work like a blanket. Without this blanket the Earth would be 20–30 °C colder and much less suitable for life. It occurs as a result of higher atmospheric concentrations of four greenhouse gases- carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and chlorofluorocarbons (US EPA 2016). Green House effect is the phenomenon whereby the earth's atmosphere traps solar radiation, and is mediated by the presence in the atmosphere of gases such as carbon dioxide, water vapor, and methane that allow incoming sunlight to pass through, but absorb the heat radiated back from the earth's surface. The severity of the problem is evident from the fact that the daily level of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere surpassed 400 ppm for the first time in human history in 2013. Such high levels used to occur, approximately three to five million years ago during the Pliocene era (NASA 2015a). Carbon dioxide one of the causes of climate change comes from fossil fuel use in different sectors like transportation, building, heating, cooling and the manufacture of cement and other goods. It is also released from natural processes such as the decay of plant matter, respiration and microbial decomposition of organic matter (Davidson & Janssen, 2006). World News of Natural Sciences 31 (2020) 36-47 -38- Methane is a very powerful greenhouse gas because it traps about 20 times as much heat as the same volume of carbon dioxide. As a result it warms the planet up to 20 times more than carbon dioxide. In the carbon cycle methanogens convert carbon dioxide to methane in a process called methanogenesis Nitrous oxide is produced during fertilizer use and fossil fuel burning (Sanford et al, 2012). Chlorofluorocarbons (CFC-11 and CFC-12) which were used extensively as refrigerant and in other industrial processes before their presence in the atmosphere were found to cause stratospheric ozone depletion is another agent of climate change. Now a day, the abundance of chlorofluorocarbon gases is decreasing as a result of international regulations designed to protect the ozone layer. Ozone is a greenhouse gas that is continually produced and destroyed in the atmosphere by chemical reactions. In the troposphere, human activities have increased ozone through the release of gases such as carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxide, which chemically react to produce ozone. As mentioned above, halocarbons released by human activities destroy ozone in the stratosphere and have caused the ozone hole over Antarctica. Water vapour is the most abundant and important greenhouse gas in the atmosphere. However, human activities have only a small direct influence on the amount of atmospheric water vapour. Indirectly, humans have the potential to affect water vapour substantially by changing climate. For example, a warmer atmosphere contains more water vapour. Human activities also influence water vapour through CH4 emissions, because CH4 undergoes chemical destruction in the stratosphere, producing a small amount of water vapor. Aerosols are small particles present in the atmosphere with widely vary in size, concentration and chemical composition. Fossil fuel and biomass burning have increased aerosols containing sulphur compounds, organic compounds and black carbon (soot). Human activities such as surface mining and industrial processes have increased dust in the atmosphere. Natural aerosols include mineral dust released from the surface, sea salt aerosols, biogenic emissions from the land and oceans, sulphate and dust aerosols produced by volcanic eruptions (Charu et al, 2014, Hasin et al, 2010, Olufemi, 2014). 3. MICROORGANISMS AS A TOOL IN SOLVING CLIMATE CHANGE CHALLENGES Microbial processes play a central role in the production and utilization of the key biogenic greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide) and are likely to respond rapidly to climate change. It is widely accepted that microorganisms played a major role in determining the atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases (Singh et al., 2010, Zimmer, 2010). Microbial organic matter decomposition is highly sensitive to climatic trends (Crowther et al, 2015). Microbes are, in fact, responsible for about 85% of world methane release (Zimmerman and Labonte 2015). When microbial communities and biogeochemical cycles are linked together they act as a good mechanism to solve climate change. This can be exemplified by the enzyme methyl coenzyme M reductase, which is responsible for the transformation of carbon dioxide into methane. Warming trends could drive many such local microbes to release larger amounts of methane (Svoboda 2015a). Methane-consuming microorganisms are capable of removing atmospheric methane even at very low concentrations and occur in both land and sea (Zimmerman and Labonte 2015). In this way, microbes contribute toward controlling methane emission which in turn regulates climate change. It is World News of Natural Sciences 31 (2020) 36-47 -39- important to note that microorganisms use greenhouse gases as energy source to build their cell

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Macro Media › AFF › 2AC

Government regulation of media should be minimal

Doris A. Graber 2017 (founding editor of Political Communication joint ICA-APSA journal, PhD Columbia University “Freedom of the Press- Theories and Realities ” 7-1-23)//PNA

THE idea that government control of news media content should be minimal and that freedom of the press should be guaranteed by the state’s most fundamental laws has be- come popular in countries throughout the world. Most modern constitutions explicitly promise their citizens the right to freely express and publicize their political views. In the United States, a democratic country, the Bill of Rights of the US Constitution, for exam- ple, prohibits the national legislature from passing any law abridging the freedom of speech or the freedom of the press. But freedom of the press is also legally protected even in states where authoritarian forms of government prevail. In Russia, which has traditionally had authoritarian governments, Article 29 of the Constitution nonetheless ex- plicitly guarantees freedom of speech and thought, unhindered public access to information, and freedom of the media from government pressure to control news coverage. Censorship is expressly forbidden. Those are the constitutional provisions; whether govern- ments obey them is a matter of debate.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Macro Media › Neg › 2NC

Government education regulations solve

University of Minnesota 2010. The author has requested to be removed. (“Understanding Media and Culture: An Introduction to Mass Communication” 7-1-23)//PNA.

Starting from the phenomenon of limitations, the government can introduce relevant industry regulations to force companies to improve the quality of censorship, thus can optimize the discussion environment. In the logic above, it can be found that companies wanting to reduce the cost of Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences EPHHR 2022 Volume 8 (2023) 208 censorship is one of the key factors of many problems. [7] In the trade-off between the government's policy requirement for "control of negative speech" and the gradually rising cost of censorship and maintenance, companies choose to lower the quality of censorship and sacrifice their user experience, leading to the gradual deterioration of the discussion environment. This dilemma could be improved if the government issued regulations to force platforms to raise their review costs. But the problem with this approach is that it only optimizes the quality of censorship, but the nature of the problems of vague regulations, differential enforcement, and unwritten rules, those related to radical social opinion control, will not be changed. And while the benefits of optimizing the social media discussion environment are latent and very long-term, the economic impact of intervening in the market and raising business costs will immediately be reflected in the economic data. The market does not welcome such changes, and the government has no strong desire to reform because not many officials think the present censorship is too harsh, so it will be difficult to promote the implementation of an intervention

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Macro Media › Neg › 2NC

Social media is softpower

Aleksandrina V . Mavrodieva ,Okky K. Rachman, Vito B. Harahap and Rajib Shaw 2019, ( Graduate School of Media and Governance, Keio University, Fujisawa 5322, Japan, “Role of Social Media as a Soft Power Tool in Raising Public Awareness and Engagement in Addressing Climate Change” 7-1-23)//PNA

More recently, with the fast and vast spread of the Internet technology a powerful tool of soft power has risen to prominence—the social media. Communication through social media, as well as news and opinion articles, is not only spread extremely quickly, but also extremely cheaply. A number of governments, from Obama and Trump to Xi Jinping, as well as not-state actors, such as terrorist organizations, are increasingly turning to social media to deliver their political messages and shape public opinion [17]. If soft power is the “second face of power” as described by Nye and media is the “fourth estate”, then social media, as the new mass communication platform, is its new tool. In the current paper, however, we are not looking into how states or designated organizations use the Internet and social media to influence people’s opinions, but are instead interested in the opposite process—if a bottom-up approach, that is, if individuals or community groups, presumably not connected to any specific political body or fraction, could spark public reactions and increase awareness towards climate change, consequently leading to action at the political level. The technological innovation and the spread of social media platforms have entirely changed the way soft power could be employed. The active public participation in societal and political discourses via online channels has overtaken the traditional diplomatic sources—“user-generated content” outlets, “where ordinary citizens, not government experts” share information and opinions, has started to dictate soft power dynamics [18]. In the period between 2005 and 2013, the percentage of people using various forms of online social communication in the United States grew from 8% to 72% [19] and Climate 2019, 7, 122 5 of 15 reached 81% by 2017 [20]. The number of Internet users worldwide in 2018 was a bit over 4 billion people [21]. The expectations are that by 2021, there will be about 3.02 billion active social media users per month worldwide, with Facebook, Youtube, and WhatsApp being the top three social media platforms as of January 2019 [22]. Not only do users spend more and more time communicating through social networks, but an increasing number of people report that they use social networks as a primary source for receiving news. In a Pew Research study from 2012, more than 6 in 10 millennials (61%) in the US indicated that they use Facebook to receive political news and approximately 32% reported that they use the platform to share information and opinions about government policy and politics. More importantly, 25% admitted that they had become more engaged in a given political issue after reading or discussing about it on social media [23]. As of March 2019, Facebook registered over 2.38 billion monthly active users [24] while Twitter is projected to reach 275 million active users in 2019 [25], revealing the enormous potential of these applications to reach out to a large audience and to support people in creating networks. Never before has it been easier for the wide public to share its views on policy decisions. In many places political decision-making is closely related to the perceptions, understanding, and pressure put by the public on the political powers. As wide-scale activities such as reduction of carbon emissions and move towards more sustainable energy resources requires the active participation by private sectors and the community, perceptions of the causes and consequences of climate change are increasingly important in granting political mandates and forming political programs [26]. In the realm of climate change, a number of studies have reported that there is a link between social media use and changing opinions on the climate change issue, which could be both positive and negative [3]. Online platforms have been used for raising awareness, as well as for mobilization of volunteers and movements in favor of tackling the negative effects of climate change. However, the effects of climate change are not equally felt and realized throughout the different regions of the world. For many people, the idea and the possible consequences of political inactivity is still a rather abstract concept at the moment. Scientific articles using specific jargon and the fact that a number of academic and scientific research is restricted and shared mainly in the scientific community makes it more difficult for the wider public to have a more in-depth understanding of the underlying issues and possible outcomes. Social media, on the other hand, using visual and easy-to-understand messaging, reaches millions of people every hour. Visual representation adds an additional persuasive dimension. The more people seek, click on and share such information, the more search engines are bound to show related type of information [27].

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Macro Media › Neg › 2NC

Social media key to solve climate

Aleksandrina V . Mavrodieva et al 19 (Aleksandrina V . Mavrodieva ,Okky K. Rachman, Vito B. Harahap and Rajib Shaw 2019, ( Graduate School of Media and Governance, Keio University, Fujisawa 5322, Japan, “Role of Social Media as a Soft Power Tool in Raising Public Awareness and Engagement in Addressing Climate Change” 7-1-23)//PNA

Several studies have explored the links between social media and public awareness of the climate change issue. Anderson [] analyzed the effects of social media on opinion, knowledge, and behavior, showing there is some evidence that information sharing through social media can raise awareness and encourage more environmentally-friendly behavior in people, but cautioning that it can also lead to opinion silos and opinion reinforcement, which could be both positive and negative for the issue of climate change. Williams et al. [] used a large dataset from Twitter to assess user attitudes towards climate change and found out that groups are usually segregated in like-minded communities, often on the extreme ends of the support/reject spectrum, with fewer people expressing less polarized opinions. Other studies paid attention to social media framing of the IPCC reports, and to the volume of climate change discussions on social media overall [], or have tried to understand climate change skepticism in online discussions, such as in blogs []. Little research, however, has been done on the role of social media as a trigger, or a support tool, for bottom-up initiatives and the extent to which those are effective in leading to practical change in policy development and implementation.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Macro Media › Neg › 1NC

That solves climate

Phillips, Morgan Hope 2008 (PhD thesis, University of Gloucestershire “Micro and Macro Approaches to Environmental Education” 07-1-23)//PNA

The root cause of the majority of environmental problems lies not in surface manifestations such as carbon dioxide and ozone, but with social and cultural factors that encourage people to consume far more than they need. Environmental education can be divided into two main kinds: micro approaches, which the majority of current approaches fall under, and macro approaches, which are currently emerging. Micro environmental education considers environmental problems in terms of surface manifestations, and proposes micro-changes such as recycling to address them, without questioning the possibility of a cultural shift away from consumerism. This form of environmental education typically seeks to change the behaviour of social actors by building and appealing to their environmental consciousness in the expectation that they will act rationally. It is argued here that this expectation fails to recognise that social actors are subject to plural rationalities and that their behaviour is driven by complex interrelationships with other social actors. As a result, micro environmental education, despite its best intentions, often fails to adequately address and change the environmentally unsustainable behaviour of the social actors it targets. This thesis firstly aims to uncover why micro approaches to environmental education exist and persist. Primary qualitative research with environmental educators drawn from formal, free-choice and accidental channels of environmental education was conducted and is presented alongside a review of the historical development of environmental education. The second aim of this thesis is to argue against a reliance on micro approaches to environmental education and environmentalism in general and propose instead that environmental education becomes embedded within a wider macro approach. Macro approaches seek to change behaviour through the development of a critical understanding of interrelationships among social actors, leading ultimately to environmentally positive changes in them. Findings from the primary research also help reveal the conditions necessary for macro approaches to emerge from the current environmental education infrastructure. The thesis concludes that macro environmental education is both necessary and possible and calls for further research into its development and practice.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Fossil Fuel Subsidies › AFF › 2AC

Removal of fossil fuel subsidies would only affect consumer subsidies, harming poor people and not solving climate change.

Sweeney 20 (Sean Sweeney; director of the International Program on Labor, Climate & Environment at the School of Labor and Urban Studies, City University of New York. Coordinator for Trade Unions for Energy Democracy (TUED, “Ending Fossil Fuel Subsidies the Wrong Way Could End Up Hurting the Poor,” New Labor Forum, https://truthout.org/articles/elite-led-efforts-to-end-fossil-fuel-subsidies-have-a-hidden-neoliberal-agenda/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwnf-kBhCnARIsAFlg492km1iBKhGZJrUlSqOkM73Cue1WCr7kOANDGsQiGPsgdc3bMUzXaRAaAgpiEALw_wcB) DSD-WHS

Know Your Zombies In order to assess these claims, first we need to recognize the difference between producer subsidies and consumer subsidies. Producer subsidies may take the form of subsidized inputs, preferential tax treatment, and direct budget transfers—straight-up corporate welfare for fossil fuel companies. For example, in 2015 when global oil prices were low, the U.K. government reduced the highest tax rate on North Sea oil production from 80 percent to 68 percent in order to keep oil operations in the black. According to IMF and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) data, producer subsidies in 2015 may have totaled some $17.9 billion, in which case they don’t amount to much. Some non-governmental organization (NGO) reports say G20 producer subsidies are as high as $70 billion—more than 70 percent of which goes to oil and gas. The same report adds $88 billion in public financing from majority government-owned banks. In fact, if all public support for, or investment in, fossil fuels is factored in, the total could reach $444 billion. These higher producer subsidy estimates have prompted claims from progressive NGOs that a significant amount of new fossil fuel production would have been “uneconomical” if not for government subsidies, thus the term “zombie energy.” But none of these “add-ons” are “subsidies” as typically understood. Public banks, for example, are also major investors in renewable energy, and these investments are packaged in ways that guarantee profit for renewable energy companies, which means these investments are also subsidizing producers. And while state-owned companies invested $286 billion in fossil fuels during 2013-2014, it’s a bit of a stretch to assert that public investment to meet energy needs is the same as a subsidy. Mind the Gap Either way, most “fossil-fuel subsidies” are not producer subsidies; they are consumer subsidies. These can be pre-tax or post-tax. Pre-tax consumer subsidies arise when the price paid by consumers is below the cost of supplying the energy. OECD, International Energy Agency (IEA), and IMF estimates for global pre-tax subsidies amounted to $305 billion in 2017. Pre-tax consumer subsidies are calculated based on the difference between an “international benchmark price” for coal, gas, and oil products (like gasoline or kerosene) and the actual retail price paid by consumers. According to the IMF, pre-tax consumer subsidies measure the degree of underpricing. So if the Venezuelan government decides to sell gasoline to Venezuelans at, say, $1.00 per liter below the international benchmark unit price, that dollar becomes a subsidy. If Algeria sells gas for cooking or heating to Algerians at 20 cents per therm below the benchmark price, that 20 cents is also a subsidy. If South Africa discounts electricity for some households to ensure affordable power, the discount below what the IMF calls the “efficient price” also counts as a subsidy. This method of calculation is very controversial. Poorer energy-producing countries argue that anything below the actual cost of producing the product can be legitimately described as a subsidy. If calculated in this way, the “cost-based” subsidies figure will be lower than the IMF’s $305 billion estimate by a considerable margin. But the IMF insists that the benchmark price—in other words, the level at which coal, oil, and gas can be sold on global markets—should determine how subsidies are calculated. This may sound like a minor detail, but it carries huge political and ideological significance. If energy is produced for human development, then actual costs are paramount; if energy is produced to maximize profit, then the global selling price is what really matters. Apparitional Subsidies Added together, these numbers still don’t begin to approach the IMF’s $5.2 trillion figure. In fact, if we stick to IMF data, pre-tax producer and consumer subsidies amount to just 6 percent of the $5.2 trillion—and that’s without challenging the IMF’s controversial “benchmark price” calculation. This is where the post-tax consumer subsidies come in. These post-tax subsidies reflect the difference between end-use prices and what consumers would pay if the price of “negative externalities” were included: local air pollution, effects of climate change, traffic congestion and road accidents, and other health impacts. Why is it called a “post-tax” subsidy? The “tax” in this instance is a “corrective” or “Pigouvian tax.” As an IMF working paper describes it, “When the consumption of a good generates an external cost to society, then efficient pricing requires that consumers face a price that reflects this cost.” This is an attempt to put a dollar figure on the environmental and other damages that result from lighting the cooking stove, taking a tuk-tuk (three-wheeled taxi) or colectivo (bus) to work, Therefore if someone dies of a cardiopulmonary condition as a result of the emissions or pollution-related activities, consumers should pay the value of that person’s lost productive potential. In other words, roughly 94 percent of the IMF’s $5.2 trillion in “fossil fuel subsidies” exists only in theory. These subsidies cannot be “removed” or “phased out,” because there’s nothing there. Post-tax subsidies—perhaps better described as “apparitional” subsidies—would only materialize as real money if the externalities (pollution and damage to health, for example) were actually paid for. But is this remotely likely? According to one of the IMF’s chief subsidy wonks, David Coady, full payment would mean, “At the global level, the price of coal, petroleum products, natural gas, and electricity would increase by around 200 percent, 50 percent, 45 percent, and 70 percent, respectively.” This, notes Coady, raises important issues regarding, “what might be done to address the challenges of implementing energy price reform in practice.” Green Structural Adjustment Reading the IMF, OECD, and similar reports on subsidies, it’s hard not to conclude that the calculations are being inflated and then weaponized to serve a purpose—and the purpose is not primarily to pressure fossil fuel interests. Rather, it is to strengthen the dominant neoliberal anti-government discourse. “Subsidy reform” provides a green protective blanket for the same anti-public, supply-side, and socially regressive “structural adjustment” agenda that was promoted so aggressively by these same institutions in the 1980s and 1990s across the global South. If the dollar value of subsidies has indeed been inflated for political and ideological purposes, then the same can be said of the emissions reductions estimates that derive from them. The IMF maintains that, if users paid the “full price” for fossil-based energy, consumption would fall and a more efficient use of energy would eventually follow. But the relationship between prices, fossil fuel use, and emissions reductions is based on what economists call “elasticities.” Research has shown that the “price-demand ratio” can be quite pronounced when consumers have alternative energy options. But when alternatives don’t exist—which is often the case—increases in prices produce a “low to moderate” reduction in demand. According to the IMF, “Consistent, country-level models of how fossil fuel use responds to price reform are not yet available on a wide scale.” In other words, the IMF’s assertion that “getting energy prices right” will dramatically curtail energy use is politically convenient, but it is not always supported by the data. Neoliberal institutions have consistently argued that decarbonization, liberalization, and privatization are inextricably connected. Therefore addressing climate change is contingent upon the consolidation of neoliberal energy policy. There is, always, no alternative. But if climate concerns were paramount, the neoliberal institutions would admit that their “green growth” policies have been a monumental failure. Mexico provides a good example of this “green structural adjustment.” A review team convened by G20 Finance Ministers and the OECD examined the “energy reform” measures pursued from 2012 to 2016 by the neoliberal (and hugely unpopular) government of Peña Nieto. Subsidies for gas and electricity were removed, and parts of the energy sector have been privatized. Praising the government for its “remarkable accomplishment,” the review team’s November 2017 report noted, “The country’s opening up of its markets to foreign producers and distributors has been accompanied by the raising of consumer prices for transport fuels, and the establishment of higher levels of excise taxes, plus the introduction of the carbon excise tax.” A series of incremental increases in the price of gasoline over several years was capped by a 20 percent increase in January 2017. This led to human road blockades, strikes, and nation-wide protests. But the increase in prices has done little to alter Mexico’s dramatic rise in energy use. Mexico’s gas consumption for power generation has almost tripled since 2000, “enabled by the expanded availability of gas from the United States” due to fracking. Vehicle ownership has risen dramatically while, notes the IEA, “the public transport fleet is ageing and polluting.” In Mexico and elsewhere, subsidy reform is being used as a political water cannon—to flush the state out of the way. The desired effect of the reform is to raise the price of energy. “Getting prices right” creates space for profit making, and incentivizes private investment. But its impact on emissions levels has been barely noticeable.¶ Shock Therapy 2.0 It remains the case that “removing” subsidies—more accurately, imposing higher prices on fossil fuels—would hurt a lot of ordinary people, especially in poorer countries. It would exacerbate global inequalities. As a share of Gross Domestic Product (GDP), the 20 countries with the highest pre-tax consumer subsidies are all in the global South. They include Iran, Venezuela, Algeria, Bolivia, Indonesia, and Pakistan. One study advocating subsidy reform suggests, “The removal of subsidies translates into an increase of the fossil fuel prices…contributing to a generalized contraction of domestic economic activity.” Of course, triggering a deep recession and inducing poverty is one way of reducing emissions, as billions of people who have found themselves on the receiving end of IMF “shock therapy” can attest. As for the 94 percent “apparitional subsidies,” if these were ever to materialize as money, the global South would be contributing more than two thirds of the total. This is because one of the legacies of the fight against colonialism was for nation states to provide energy at prices that could advance human and national development objectives. Countries of the North no longer need to do this because they are so rich that energy subsidies are no longer needed. But these same rich countries are responsible for 70% of carbon in the atmosphere and currently warming the planet (so-called “cumulative CO2”). They made themselves wealthy but paid nothing for the emissions they created along the way. For activists in the North, making fossil fuel subsidies a key political target is a mistake. It buys into the IMF’s obsession with “getting energy prices right” which targets state ownership and regulation of prices. Such an approach may lead to a more judicious use of energy, but it won’t address the mammoth challenges involved in transitioning away from fossil fuels, controlling and reducing unnecessary economic activity, or reducing emissions is expeditiously as possible. The problem is fossil-fuel dependency, not underpriced energy. Raising the price without alternative forms of low-carbon energy available for all will not produce the kind of emissions reductions the world needs. This does not mean that progressive unions and the left should support subsidies for fossil fuels—especially when the beneficiaries are large for-profit industrial users or billionaire Lamborghini owners cruising the strips in Riyadh or Shanghai. But there is a need to be aware of what the IMF and the subsidy reform organizations are proposing, and what these proposals might mean for workers and ordinary people, especially in the global South.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Fossil Fuel Subsidies › NEG › 2NC

The time for reform is now; all the tools are right in front of us.

Sanchez et al 20 (Lourdes Sanchez; Lourdes is Senior Policy Advisor and Lead, Indonesia, working in IISD's Energy program. Her research focuses on the analysis and production of data of energy subsidies (electricity and fossil fuels), the evaluation and design of sustainable energy policies and on developing communication strategies for energy subsidy reforms, Peter Wooders; Senior Director of Energy at the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD). He has 20 years of experience across the energy sector, with a particular specialization in electricity generation, Ronja Bechauf; Policy Analyst with IISD's Economic Law and Policy Program. Works with the Infrastructure and Finance team to demonstrate the track record of sustainable infrastructure, “53 Ways to Reform Fossil Fuel Consumer Subsidies and Pricing,” International Institute for Sustainable Development, 8/18/20, https://www.iisd.org/articles/deep-dive/53-ways-reform-fossil-fuel-consumer-subsidies-and-pricing) DSD-WHS

The evidence is crystal clear that fossil fuel subsidies are environmentally harmful and undermine global efforts to tackle climate change. Despite this, support for fossil fuels costs governments USD 300–600 billion every year—depending on fuel prices on the world markets—a huge sum that could otherwise be spent on global priorities such as health, education, social protection, and a just transition to a clean energy future. As countries struggle to support their economies in the aftermath of the COVID-19 crisis, it’s more important than ever to align climate ambitions with economic priorities. Governments have the opportunity to look closely at fossil fuel subsidy reform and fuel taxation as effective tools for a green recovery as they work to maintain climate commitments while generating revenue to support pressing social needs. The recent drop in global oil prices provides an exceptional chance for countries to reform their fossil fuel subsidies without burdening consumers, as fuel prices would remain low without government support. The drop in oil prices also opens a window of opportunity to improve fuel taxation: IISD experts have shown that a small tax on fossil fuels could generate much-needed funds to react to and recover from the COVID-19 crisis, while being fair toward—and having a moderated effect on—consumers. Several countries are already seizing this opportunity, while many others are asking: what do successful fuel subsidy reform and fuel taxation look like in practice? To address this question, Global Subsidies Initiative (GSI) experts offer insight into global trends in tackling wasteful fossil fuel subsidies with a new detailed map of fossil fuel consumer subsidy reform and taxation between January 2015 and May 2020. Our experts identified that within this period, at least 53 countries implemented some kind of fossil fuel consumer subsidy reform or increased taxes on fossil fuels. Breaking that down, we see that 34 countries reformed consumer subsidies, while 14 countries increased fossil fuel taxation, and seven countries did both. It is important to note that this list may not be comprehensive and remains a work in progress. As countries struggle to support their economies in the aftermath of the COVID-19 crisis, it’s more important than ever to align climate ambitions with economic priorities. It is also important to note that producer subsidies—subsidies to upstream oil, gas, and coal exploration, mining, and production—amount to at least USD 100 billion per year worldwide. There have been some producer subsidy reforms in the 2015–2020 period: for example, Germany has committed to phasing out subsidies to hard coal mining by the end of 2018 as part of the EU-wide commitment to end these subsidies. On the other hand, recent low oil prices and the COVID-19 crisis have further degraded the economics of fossil fuel production, and this has led to the implementation of new producer subsidies in many jurisdictions. The Energy Policy Tracker, developed by IISD and 13 other partners, is one source of information for new support to the fossil fuel sector, and it is expected that reporting under SDG Indicator 12.c.1 should yield new, official information from this year (2020) as countries report. This further information will then help to assess whether countries are moving forward with reforming their producer subsidies. What Strategies Have Countries Used and How Did It Work Out? Gradual Approach Every country has a different starting point, and the policy specifics of each reform are unique. However, if there is one thing that we can learn from all governments that implemented fossil fuel subsidy reform or increased fossil fuel taxation, it’s the success of their phased approach. We can see the benefits of this design in Egypt. Spending about 7% of its GDP on fossil fuel subsidies in 2013, Egypt has been reforming its consumer subsidies for the last six years, gradually freeing up resources to support other sectors such as health and education. Egypt has been reforming its consumer subsidies for the last six years, gradually freeing up resources to support other sectors such as health and education. Supported by the World Bank, Egypt approached its subsidy reforms step-by-step, taking careful measures to protect poor people from negative impacts through helpful initiatives like cash transfer programs. The reforms were accompanied by an effective communications strategy targeting citizens, which explained why the reforms were important and illustrating the tangible benefits the country was going to see as a result. The Right Timing Evidence shows that the timing of reforms can also play an important role in their success. Between 2015 and 2017, countries on all continents and with different economic backgrounds took advantage of low international oil prices to increase fuel taxation or phase out consumer subsidies. In India, ambitious subsidy reform implemented during a period of low oil prices caused oil and gas subsidies to drop from INR 158,482 crore (USD 26.2 billion) in fiscal year 2014 to INR 67,679 crore (USD 10.1 billion) in fiscal year 2019. When global oil prices crashed again in early 2020, the Indian government once more took advantage of the price drop to raise duties on fuel without straining consumers, as retail prices remained stable. The taxes on fossil fuels send an important carbon mitigation signal to consumers and generate much-needed revenue. Shifting Support to Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Case studies clearly illustrate that subsidy and taxation reforms work better when they are part of a wider push for energy sector transformation. Reallocating savings from subsidy reform to alternative sources of energy and energy efficiency helps to further advance a gradual phase-out of fossil fuels by investing in the industries of tomorrow. Case studies clearly illustrate that subsidy and taxation reforms work better when they are part of a wider push for energy sector transformation. This kind of “subsidy swap” has been successfully implemented in Zambia and Morocco. It has also been one of the pillars of the energy transition in India, where support for renewable energy and electric vehicles has more than tripled since fiscal year 2017, and subsidies for electric vehicles have grown by more than 11 times. Invest in Social Protection Subsidy reform and increased taxation must be fair for all citizens. It is critical to include investment in social protection in the plan and redirect savings toward those who need it most. There are many examples of governments successfully protecting the vulnerable and using fossil fuel subsidy reform to implement effective social programs. Ghana implemented a targeted support program to provide income support and health insurance to poor households. The Philippines implemented targeted cash transfers to help build a national safety net alongside lifeline tariffs to protect the poor in the reform process. A similar approach was seen in Morocco, where the government increased funds for education and implemented a health insurance scheme. In order to protect the poor, Morocco also kept some subsidies for liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), basic food items, and electricity in place. Removing gasoline and diesel subsidies in 2015 allowed Indonesia to free up around USD 15.6 billion and invest the savings into special programs for poverty eradication and human development, infrastructure development, and social welfare programs such as assistance to poor students and cash transfers. Which Countries Have Cancelled Reforms and Why? Even for countries that successfully start removing subsidies or increasing taxation, it can be challenging to stick to these measures. Our experts identified 13 cases of cancelled subsidy reforms or decreased fuel taxation between 2018 and 2019. Why did the reforms fail, and what could have been done to avoid it? High Oil Prices, High Pressure It's no coincidence that so many countries experienced difficulties with their reforms in years when global oil prices soared. Especially during oil price spikes, governments try to protect their economies and consumers from rising energy prices and removing subsidies can be unpopular. For example, Thailand had deregulated LPG prices in 2017, but when prices hiked in 2018, subsidies for LPG and diesel were reintroduced. Similar backsliding was observed in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka, putting significant pressure on public budgets. Reforms were also cancelled in countries such as Algeria, Brazil, France, and Iran. But cancelling reforms and reintroducing subsidies when oil prices rise is not the solution. There are a number of price adjustment mechanisms that can be used to avoid major shocks for consumers and ensure fiscal sustainability. Long-term strategy can significantly reduce economic uncertainty related to energy price fluctuations. Fuel pricing tools such as price caps and floors can help governments fill reserves when prices fall below the price floor, and support consumers when market prices rise above the cap. Avoiding the highest peaks and lowest valleys of energy prices helps maintain subsidy reform and fuel taxation during difficult times without undue pressure on consumers Another option is to implement pricing formulas that follow international oil prices to at least some extent or limit the duration of subsidization, by moving back to tracking world prices as soon as they are able. This allows governments to reduce spending on fossil fuel subsidies while still protecting consumers from price shocks. For example, Tunisia moved quickly to take advantage of the current situation and improve public budgets. In April 2020, the government introduced a new automatic price adjustment formula for gasoline and diesel. Through this mechanism, domestic prices will adjust to changes in international fuel prices. When the new system was first applied on April 7, 2020, it resulted in a slight decline in fuel prices. This step can be an effective fossil fuel subsidy reform that sticks, as subsidies are prevented from returning when oil prices increase. If there is one thing that we can learn from all governments that implemented fossil fuel subsidy reform or increased fossil fuel taxation, it’s the success of their phased approach. Too Much, Too Fast If done too hastily, phasing out fossil fuel consumer subsidies or increasing fuel taxation can lead to widespread political unrest. This was seen in Ecuador in October 2019, when the government announced the rapid phase-out of subsidies for gasoline and diesel. The immediate policy change led to drastic price hikes and widespread protests. In order to restore public order, the government quickly reintroduced the subsidies. To avoid this kind of backlash, it is important that governments not try to change everything at once. Instead, they should plan to gradually move from fixed prices toward a market-based pricing mechanism, as described above, and tax fossil fuels appropriately. Indeed, in July 2020, following low international oil prices, Ecuador tried again to reform, this time by introducing a price band mechanism. This and other cautionary tales teach us that unsuccessful reform attempts were also missing a communications plan to explain the benefits to the public or lacked mechanisms to compensate vulnerable groups. Governments should develop compensation packages to manage the impacts of their reforms. Possible consequences of reforms need to be analyzed, and support measures need to be visible and effective. Where Do We Go From Here? The Time Is Now: Using reform to raise funds for a green recovery Today’s low global oil prices provide a chance for countries to reform their fossil fuel subsidies without burdening consumers. The map shows that several countries have already embarked on this journey, such as India, Costa Rica, and Tunisia. Fossil fuel subsidy and taxation reform can increase government revenues and raise much-needed funds to respond to and recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. IISD experts have shown that we could generate USD 1 billion worldwide per day with just a small tax of 12.5 cents per litre of gasoline and diesel. And, because of today’s low oil prices, consumers would still benefit from markedly lower prices at the pump than before the COVID-19 crisis. The IISD experts conclude that a temporary increase in taxes on gasoline and diesel “is one of the fairest, greenest ways to fund post-pandemic economic stimulus packages.” The process of reforming fossil fuel subsidies or increasing taxation is complex and politically challenging. But, as seen on our map, many countries manage their reforms in a careful, courageous, and well-communicated way, and even more can learn by example to seize this opportunity and build a better future for all. Countries around the world need to take action now to shift money from harmful subsidies to sustainable recovery projects that minimize impacts on nature, accelerate the low-carbon transition, and improve social cohesion.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Fossil Fuel Subsidies › NEG › 2NC

Fossil fuel subsidies are an international threat, but more needs to be done.

Urpelainen 21 (Johannes Urpelainen; director and Prince Sultan bin Abdulaziz Professor of Energy, Resources and Environment at Johns Hopkins SAIS, founding director of the Initiative for Sustainable Energy Policy (ISEP), Elisha George was a guest writer for this article, “Reforming global fossil fuel subsidies: How the United States can restart international cooperation,” The Brookings Institution, 7/14/21, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/reforming-global-fossil-fuel-subsidies-how-the-united-states-can-restart-international-cooperation/) DSD-WHS

The sheer scale of subsidies makes them an important pillar of the fossil fuel industry. The International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) found that production subsidies by the G20 countries averaged $290 billion annually during 2017-2019. Of this amount, almost 95% went towards oil and gas, with a relatively small amount earmarked for coal. Similarly, in 2019, global consumption subsidies stood at around $320 billion. Once more, oil subsidies were the largest component, followed by electricity, natural gas, and then coal. While these subsidies have declined over the past several years—consumption subsidies were over $500 billion in 2013—they are still far higher than they should be.

Table 1: A snapshot of consumption subsidies (IEA)

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Fossil Fuel Subsidies › NEG › 1NC

Decreasing the use of fossil fuel subsidies is key to climate change solvency.

IMF No Date (International Monetary Fund; The IMF works to achieve sustainable growth and prosperity for all of its 190 member countries. It does so by supporting economic policies that promote financial stability and monetary cooperation, which are essential to increase productivity, job creation, and economic well-being., “Fossil Fuel Subsidies,” https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/climate-change/energy-subsidies) DSD-WHS

Impacts of Subsidy Reform Raising fuel prices to their fully efficient levels reduces projected global fossil fuel CO2 emissions 36 percent below baseline levels in 2025—or 32 percent below 2018 emissions. This reduction is in line with the 25-50 percent reduction in global GHGs below 2018 levels needed by 2030 to be on track with containing global warming to the Paris goal of 1.5-2C. Globally, around 74 percent of the CO2 reduction comes from reduced use of coal, while 21 and 3 percent respectively are from reductions in consumption of petroleum and natural gas.

Full price reform raises revenues of $4.2 trillion, 3.8 percent of global GDP, in 2025 (relative to baseline levels and accounting for revenue losses due to erosion of pre-existing fuel tax bases). Revenue gains vary substantially across regions, largely mirroring the distribution of (explicit and implicit) subsidies. The revenues generated by full price reform in 121 EME and developing countries in 2025 would amount to $3 trillion, which is broadly in line with their additional spending needs for Sustainable Development Goals.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Education › AFF › 2AC

Organizing educational policies for economic means leads to waste and disappointment.

Alison Wolf 5-30-2002 (Baroness Alison Wolf CBE was appointed as a Non-Executive Director at the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology in April 2023. Alison is the Sir Roy Griffiths Professor of Public Sector Management at King’s College London, “Does Education Matter?: Myths About Education and Economic Growth”, Penguin UK, https://books.google.com/books?id=8vvyad9lmOEC&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false) --cpstk

But what doesn’t follow is that vast amounts of public spending on education have been the key determinant of how rich we are today. Nor is it obvious that they will decide how much richer, or poorer, we will be tomorrow. The simple one-way relationship which so entrances our politicians and commentators – education spending in, economic growth out – simply doesn’t exist. Moreover, the larger and more complex the education sector, the less obvious any links to productivity become. Developed countries have now moved well beyond providing basic education for all, and instead spend more and more on higher education, technical provision, vocational programmes, and adult training. These are my main subject matter, for they are also the main recent targets of government policies inspired by ambitions for growth. Unfortunately, while an overwhelmingly strong case can be made for the state’s responsibilities in basic education – and, indeed, for the latter’s economic importance – not one of these newer enthusiasms deserves any such accolade. Governments’ expansion into ever larger areas of education and training has run parallel to their growing enthusiasm for detailed intervention. This is doubly unfortunate for, if the evidence in favour of indiscriminate education spending is weak, that in favour of government fine-tuning is even weaker. Most politicians, if asked directly, would probably deny believing that any and all education spending is a good thing regardless. What they do believe in, of course, is higher levels of spending ‘properly’ targeted to develop those high skills that the economy needs. Yet their record on just this point is largely dismal. The more overtly and the more directly politicians attempt to organize education for economic ends, the higher the likelihood of waste and disappointment. This book focuses largely on a quarter-century of British government activity, but British politicians are not unusual in believing that they can improve their country’s economic performance through government-led education policies. What marks them off from their international counterparts is simply the speed with which, in our hugely centralized system, they can launch off one educational broadside after another.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Education › AFF › 2AC

Perm do Both – Jobs Guarantee and adult education solves residual economic downturn and educational impacts from covid.

Aveek Bhattacharya 2-12-2021 (Research Director of the Social Market Foundation and PhD in Social Policy, “The pandemic has enriched some and weakened others. That makes new policies even more urgent,” LSE Research Online, http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/109059/1/covid19_2021_02_12_the_pandemic_has_enriched_some_and_weakened_others.pdf) –cpstk

The pandemic has enriched some and weakened others. That makes new policies even more urgent Many workers have lost out with the shift to remote working and online shopping, but others will gain. Aveek Bhattacharya (LSE and Social Market Foundation) says this means the case for overdue shifts in policy – such as a progressive wealth tax, a jobs guarantee and support for adult education – is even stronger than before. When the current health emergency begins to pass, COVID-19 will continue to shape the economy in two ways. The first will be the enduring legacy of the temporary shocks the economy has received, which take time to absorb. That means higher unemployment, which is forecast to peak at 7.5% (or around 2.6 million people). It means higher levels of debt, not just for the government but more concerningly for businesses, with 900,000 firms at risk of closure by April. It means higher savings for most households as a result of reduced spending on things like commuting and eating out – the overall savings rate has risen from 10% to 29% of disposable income. But for a significant minority, hit by furlough, pay cuts or unemployment, it means more precarious finances – two million more people are now categorised as having low financial resilience. The educational impact of school, college and university closures could also weigh on the economy in years to come: on average, pupils are estimated to have lost two months worth of learning over the last year. One possible silver lining might lie in the housing market Second, COVID-19 has brought structural changes to the economy, often accelerating changes that were already in train. Remote working is likely to become far more common: around half of workers have done some work from home over the course of the pandemic, and the majority would like to continue to do so. More spending will be online. Internet sales have risen from less than a fifth to over a third of all retail. Several markets are likely to consolidate, with smaller firms going bust, and larger ‘superstar’ firms like Amazon profiting from or being able to ride out the crisis. 15% of firms with fewer than 10 employees are currently facing failure, compared to 4% of firms with over 100 workers. The picture for automation is less clear. Some companies have invested in technology to adapt to social distancing – for example, using drone deliveries or robots for meatpacking. However, high unemployment pushing down labour costs could discourage further uptake or indeed lead to backsliding – just as the Great Recession led to the resurgence of hand car washes. What does it mean for inequality? Almost all of these developments seem like bad news for economic equality. The shift to online shopping will continue to hit the retail sector, which employs a large number of low-skilled workers. Those in professional, higher- paying ‘white collar’ work are more able to take advantage of home working and the cost savings it brings. That will continue to exacerbate the gap in savings between the richest and poorest. Industry consolidation is also liable to increase inequality: large superstar firms tend to pay out a smaller share of their income in wages to workers, with a higher share going to wealthier shareholders. Over the longer term, this will be compounded by higher educational inequality: children and young people from disadvantaged backgrounds have been worst affected by the disruption to their studies. One possible silver lining might lie in the housing market, which plays a central role in Britain’s inequalities. Remote working is likely to shift economic activity away from more expensive cities. In the first instance, this will benefit the more affluent workers who are able to work from home. However, as they shift their spending to local shops and restaurants, it is likely to create opportunities for lower-skilled workers to move out to cheaper areas as well. COVID-19 could encourage spending on health, social care and education – all of which are major employers of women It is possible to imagine a future in which COVID-19 spurs a reduction in inequality between regions. But this would require people to move much further than they currently do. Analysis of the likely economic impact of remote working based on existing commuting patterns suggests that the areas likely to benefit most are towns and suburbs close to major cities, especially in the South East, rather than poorer and more distant parts of the country. COVID-19 could also have a negative effect on gender equality. Women were marginally more likely to be put on furlough. They are more likely to work in retail, and so are more exposed to job losses in that sector. Moreover, those that lose their jobs may be more likely to drop out of the workforce if they are unable to find similarly flexible work to fit around caring responsibilities. On the other hand, COVID-19 could encourage spending on health, social care and education – all of which are major employers of women. Women may who bear the larger share of family care duties may benefit from increased opportunities to work from home – although this risks reinforcing the pressure for them to choose parttime and remote work that results in them falling behind male peers. The impact of COVID-19 on global inequality has been less bad than might have been feared. The global distribution of income has become slightly more unequal, but this is a consequence of China (now a middle income country) growing faster than poorer countries. In general, poor countries have fared better than richer ones so far – which was far from certain when the crisis broke. The key question is whether that will remain the case, with vaccination moving painfully slowly in Africa and a number of countries facing debt crises. What should policymakers do? If the social impact of the pandemic can be described as the same trends as existed before, just arriving sooner, the policy response largely consists of things governments should have been doing anyway – just more urgently. The case for progressive taxes, perhaps on wealth, has only grown stronger. The government should actively seek to support employment, maybe through a jobs guarantee. More support for skills and learning – particularly adult education – will be essential to ensuring people can adapt to the changing needs of the economy. Investment in transport and telecommunications infrastructure can help promote regional rebalancing.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Education › NEG › 2NC

Education positively impacts the economy and allows the furtherance of technologies.

Eny Lestari Widarni and Suryaning Bawono 5-1-2021 (Dr Eni Lestari Widarni is a practitioner and academic in human resource management. Dr Eni Lestari Widarni is the leader of the university of economics in Indonesia, namely the Jaya Negara Tamansiswa Malang School of Economics. Suryaning Bawono is Researcher, Entrepreneur, and Investor. He is the founder of PT. Frost Yunior. He has a masters in economics, “Human Capital, Technology, and Economic Growth: A Case Study of Indonesia,” Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=814097103098091078021115025067077029017056072092062036000096089108096030030127030027043029022061045007055002096066086027116065029094032037017028120111065076084008019070003023124081105012095089000064097072101113126107094002102070088103008126099005093094&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE) -- cpstk

4. Results and Discussion Human capital indicators in the form of educational services as a form of work participation in Indonesia have a significant positive effect on Indonesia’s economic growth. More specifically, increasing human capital will have an impact on increasing economic growth in accordance with theoretical provisions. These results corroborate the findings of other similar studies conducted for Indonesia (Alfada, 2019). The relationship between technology and economic growth based on the estimation results is a significant positive. This is in accordance with the theory where technology has an influence on economic growth. Theoretically, technology is able to accelerate production, increase productivity or the performance of labor or human resources, improve the quality of the products produced. Technology also plays a role in improving communication between producers and consumers as well as all stakeholders, where information and communication technology is currently developing very rapidly. There are many other things that are influenced by technology in increasing production. All things that are influenced by technology in increasing aggregate production affect economic growth. Our estimation results are in accordance with this, namely, technology can affect economic growth or have a significant positive relationship. Our research results are in line with the research of Banerjee and Roy (2014). Other theoretical variables in human capital theory which are used as the basis for equations in the model, namely labor and human capital, in the long run, based on the estimation results, have a significant positive effect on economic growth. However, human capital in the short term has a negative and insignificant effect. This is because human capital investment is needed for improving workforce performance in the long-term. As such, in the short term, human capital has a negative and insignificant effect because human capital investment is still in the process of encouraging employee performance. As such, human capital will be effective in stimulating the economy in the long term and less effective in driving economic growth in the short term. The technology variable is the most effective in driving economic growth both in the long and short term. Based on our estimation results, we find that technology is effective in the long and short term in driving economic growth. However, to master technology and encourage technological development, human capital is needed. And to improve the welfare of the population and increase economic growth, it is necessary to increase labor participation for workers who are ready to contribute to the economy, which of course requires human capital to improve their performance. The estimation results are presented in Table l. Table 1 presents the long and short-run results of the Model, which include human capital, labor, financial capital, and technology. In the long term, human capital based on estimates has a significant positive effect. This proves that education participation and the quality of education services in Indonesia have a significant positive effect on longterm economic growth. As such, education is important in economic development. The increase in work participation in Indonesia continued during the study period. This result is in line with Alfada (2019) who stated that human capital and economic growth are positively related in Indonesia. Based on the results of technology-based estimates, it has a positive relationship with economic growth both in the short and long term, therefore, technology is an important factor in Indonesia’s economic growth. The factors of labor and financial capital also show a positive relationship both in the long and short term with economic growth in Indonesia. Although in the short-term human capital does not have a positive relationship, in the short-term human capital has a positive and significant relationship. The technology variable remains positively and significantly related in the short and long term. 5. Conclusion Human capital has an effect on economic growth. However, based on the estimation results, human capital is effective in driving the economy in the long run with technology and labor as key factors driving economic growth. Based on the estimation results in this study, the impact of human capital and technology on economic growth in Indonesia during the period 1984 to 2019 is significant in the long term. Using annual data for 35 years, the ARDL approach with cointegration techniques is used to examine the long-term relationship between economic growth and its determinants, as well as to ascertain the impact of human resources and technology on economic growth both in the long and short term. The estimation results concluded that human capital is effective in promoting long-term economic growth. And effective technology drives economic growth in the long and short term.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Education › NEG › 2NC

Investment in education increases economic growth and income - empirics

Saima Bashir et al 2012 (Saima Bashir is a professor of business administration at Central State University. She has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Janaranjana Herath is an associate professor and a researcher in the fields of agricultural economics, health economics, business management, and finance at West Virginia University. He has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Tesfa Gebremedhin is a professor emeritus of resource economics and management at West Virginia University, “An Empirical Analysis of Higher Education and Economic Growth in West Virginia,” Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/124829/) –cpstk

The empirical results show that income change (INCC) is significantly and positively related to education change (EMPC) such that a one percent increase in education increases income by 0.3 percent in West Virginia. This result is supported by the findings of Chen and Wu (2007) which shows that development of higher education creates positive effects on the employment and income. The result also is supported by the findings of Ranis et al. (2000), Jorgenson and Fraumeni (1992), and Barro (2001). Population change (POPC) is significant and positively related to income change (INCC) indicating that when population change increases by one percent, income change increases by 0.3 percent. This may be due to creating more income opportunities with increasing population at county level. The initial value of income (INCBASE) has a negative and significant relationship with employment change; thus, counties that reported high initial percentages of income had lower growth rates of income. Poverty indicates significant and a positive relationship with income change; but impacts are minimal. Results for the education change equation indicate that a one percent change in income growth increases educational growth by 1.7 percent. One reason for this could be that high income leads to more savings and investment which increases opportunities for education. Also, high income in a county may lead to improved educational facilities, healthcare facilities and other local amenities that increase the number of jobs Created. The result is supported by the study of Gyimah-Brempong et al. (2006) which shows that all levels of education for human capital development, including higher education for human capital development, are statistically significant and have a positive effect on the growth rate of per capita income in African counties. Results further indicate that growth in population (POPC) has a negative relationship with education change. This is a common trend with higher education people to control family size. Also it is a general trend with higher education people to out-migrate from poor counties in West Virginia (ARC, 2010b ). The initial level of income (INCBASE) has a positive relationship with education growth. Thus, the counties that reported high initial percentages of income had higher growth rates of education compared to the other counties. This means that higher investment in education occurs with higher income level. The initial level of education (EDUBASE) indicates a significant and negative relationship with education change. This means that the counties which reported high initial percentages of education had lower growth of education in West Virginia. The empirical results for the population change (POPC) equation indicate that increasing education change (EDUC) decreases population growth in West Virginia. Results also show that education in 2000 (EDUBASE) has a negative relationship with population change. This means that the counties reported higher rates of education at 2000 were less populated compared to others. The significant and positive relationship of unemployment rate (UNEMP) with changing population may indicate that lower income and education together with high unemployment rate leads to bigger family sizes in West Virginia. With high unemployment and poverty rates people may tend to be less educated and have less accessibility to birth control facilities and family planning and other related educational programs. 6. Summary and Conclusions The main purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between education and economic growth in West Virginia. County level analysis based on the changes of income, education and population, highlight two important points. First, empirical analysis reveals that both education growth and income growth positively affect each other. Thus, more attempts to increase job or income generation opportunities would be beneficial. According to the ARC (2010b ), only 35 of the 420 counties in Appalachia reported positive employment growth from 2007 to 2010. However, according to the strategic plan of Appalachia, the region is expected to create 120,000 new jobs from 2011-2016 (ARC, 2011). This would enhance education growth as well as income growth of West Virginia. Educational attainment raises productivity, increases income earnings, reduces poverty risk and improves living standards. Thus, investment in education, particularly targeting to the poor counties, would be essential for income growth. Second, the empirical analysis reveals the impact of higher education on population growth. Thus adequate policy measures are needed to control out migration and create employment opportunities within the state. One way of maintaining economic development is to create „occupational competitiveness‟ with a higher share of the workforce employed in „creative class‟ positions – those who specialize in knowledge-based and idea creation, such as engineers, designers, business managers and scientists (ARC, 2011). Overall, the empirical results and analysis highlights the need for a comprehensive set of policies to enhance economic growth of West Virginia. These policies should adequately improve and increase educational facilities, income earning opportunities, along with development in basic infrastructure. According to the ARC (2010b ), the Appalachian region

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Education › NEG › 1NC

Investments in education not only increase economic growth but are crucial to the future.

Saima Bashir et al 2012 (Saima Bashir is a professor of business administration at Central State University. She has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Janaranjana Herath is an associate professor and a researcher in the fields of agricultural economics, health economics, business management, and finance at West Virginia University. He has a PhD in Natural Resource Economics. Tesfa Gebremedhin is a professor emeritus of resource economics and management at West Virginia University, “An Empirical Analysis of Higher Education and Economic Growth in West Virginia,” Agricultural and Applied Economics Association, https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/124829/) –cpstk

Investment in education to increase economic growth, as one form of human development strategy, has gained economists‟ and policy makers‟ interest. It establishes human capital that makes a substantial contribution to economic and income growth. Its contribution returns in the form of skilled labor which leads to increased development and improved quality of life. Different theories and models have been used to examine the relationship between education and economic growth. Most of them concentrated on human capital accumulation as source of acceleration in economic growth. Some of them used human capital as an engine of economic growth to technological change. But for human accumulation, a country should invest more on education. Thus, the main objective of the study is to analyze the relationship between higher education growth and economic growth in West Virginia. A set of simultaneous equations with three endogenous variables namely, per capita income change, education change and population change were used for the analysis. Empirical results indicate that income growth and education growth are positively related while education growth reduces population growth in West Virginia. 1. Introduction Investment in education to increase economic growth, as one form of human development strategy, has gained economists‟ and policy makers‟ interest (Johnson, 2011). Investment in education preserves returns in the form of skilled labor which leads to increased development and improved quality of life (Yogish, 2006). Investment in education not only benefits individuals through income but also benefit economy as a whole through skilled labor who increase competition and economic growth (Alam, 2009). The relationship between education and economic growth was first developed by Adam Smith, followed by Marshall, Schultz, Bowman and others (Pradhan, 2009). Empirical estimation of the relationship dated back to 1957 when Robert Solow estimated the contribution of labor, capital and technological change to economic growth in the United States over the period 1909-1949 (Chaudhary et al., 2009; Matsushita et al., 2006). Different theories and models have used to examine the relationship between education and economic growth (Romer, 1990; Chakraborty, 2005). Most of them concentrated on human capital accumulation as a source of acceleration in economic growth. Some of them used human capital as an engine of economic growth to technological change. Individuals and society gained economic benefits because of higher education gained by individuals (Krueger and Lingahl, 2001). It benefits to society both on micro and macro level. It affects the economic system directly and indirectly, where a rise in individual‟s wage is a direct effect and an increase in education is an indirect effect (Heckman and Klenow, 1997; Pradhan, 2009). Economists and policy makers face the problem of low level of skilled labor in countries which are trying to increase their economic growth (McClelland, 1966). According to policy makers and economists, countries or states should spend a significant amount on education for their population, which will increase income significantly and leads to strengthen the economy (Krueger and Lingahl, 2001). Thus, the main objective of this study is to analyze the relationship between economic growth and higher education in West Virginia. The paper is organized into six sections. Section 2 describes the background information of West Virginia. Section 3 provides the literature review. Section 4 covers the methodology and data sources. Section 5 describes the empirical results and analysis. Section 6 presents the summary and conclusions. 2. Background of the study area West Virginia, one of the rural states, has low educational attainment and high unemployment rate (US Census Bureau, 2010). Nearly 44 percent of the population lives in rural areas. The average population density is about 75 people per square mile and the per capita personal income was $32,219 in 2009, which was 17.7 percent below the national per capita income of $39,138 (Hammond, 2012). The average per capita income in the rural area was $29,200 compared to $33,578 in the urban area in 2008 (ERS-USDA, 2008). Nearly 24 percent of the total land area is used for farming (ERS, 2011). Approximately 3.7 million acres are farmlands with 23,200 farms and average farm size is 159 acres (USDA/NASS, 2010). Apart from agriculture, manufacturing, services, mining and tourism (an emerging sector) are currently the major economic sectors in West Virginia (ERS, 2011). West Virginia has relatively low higher education rates, high unemployment rates (Gebremeriam et al., 2006), low per capita income compared to other states in Appalachian region (Appalachian Regional Commission, 2010a ). The economic status of 22 counties is “Transitional,” 20 counties “At Risk”, 11 counties “Distressed,” and 2 counties “Competitive” in West Virginia. Thirty – four of total 55 counties are located within rural (non-metropolitan) areas (Appalachian Regional Commission, 2010a ). The slow growth of income and employment, large out-migration are the major reflections of persistently high rates of poverty in West Virginia (US Census Bureau, 2010). This is related to less job opportunities and is a hazard to economic growth of West Virginia (D‟Souza and Gebremedhin, 1999). According to Herndon (2008), expenditures on investment in education for human capital formation have increased in West Virginia, but the number of higher education graduates working within the state have decreased over time (Hammond, 2012). 3. Literature Review The role of education has been acknowledged widely by economists and policy makers (Gilead, 2012). The utilization of infrastructure and technology requires a leading role of higher education system in regional economic development (Schlottmann, 2010). Economists believe that investment on education or human capital increases output and labor productivity. Investment in human capital is crucial in the future because the economy is turning into knowledge-based from post-industrial economy (Dickens et al., 2006). Teles and Andrade (2004) estimated the relationship between government spending on basic education and economic growth. Results revealed that economic decision makings of an agent are affected by his/her educational level. Jorgenson and Fraumeni (1992) estimated the impact of investment in education on U.S. economic growth. They used data from 1948 to 1969. Results revealed that an appropriate value of investment in education was given by its impact on lifetime labor income of an individual. Hanushek and Wobmann (2007) examined the role of education in promoting economic well-being focusing on the role of educational quality. Results showed that cognitive skills of population have strong relationship with individual earnings, distribution of income, and economic growth. Barro (2001) studied on education as a measure of human capital in his study. Results showed that economic growth is positively related to starting level of average years of school attainment of adult males at the secondary and higher level. Results further revealed that the quality of school education and its impact on economic growth is different among rich and poor countries. Investment in education and health services are the major factors for human capital development and the subsequent impact on economic growth. However, economic growth is also the main source for human capital development. Ranis et al. (2000) estimated the effects of economic growth as the result of human capital development and the effects of human capital development as the result of economic growth. Results showed that economic growth had positive and strong impact on human capital development. Results also showed that significant and strong GDP per capita income growth leads to higher human capital development. Dowrick (2002) reviewed empirical studies that examined the relationship between economic growth and education and R&D (Research and Development). These studies showed that education and R&D are substantial sources to promote economic growth. Participation in education and public expenditures on education increased during 19th and 20th centuries. Enrolment in public education system has increased by 40 percent from 1870 to 2001 whereas public expenditure on education increased from 0.86 percent to 4.85 percent of GDP during the same time period. GDP also increased nine times in the same time period (Carpentier, 2006). Previous studies revealed that investment in education resulted in economic benefits. However, the size and margin of these benefits vary by race, gender, and ethnicity. Graph 1 below represents unemployment rate by race. Unemployment rate decreases from 13.9 percent to 4.5 percent in black population if individuals completed their bachelor degrees or higher. There is 5 per cent reduction in unemployment rate in white population for completing the same degree (Williams and Swail, 2005). Education has an influence on crime rate in several ways. First, education increases the opportunity cost of crime due to higher wage rate. Second, educated people are more patient and less risk takers. Third, attending school keeps young people busy and reduces criminal participation (Lochner and Moretti, 2003). One good reason to increase policymakers‟ interest in education to raise the economy of metro areas is to encourage students to stay in the region or attract others to come from outside to the region (Bartik and Erickcek, 2007).

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Bomb Madagascar › AFF › 2AC

War is a waste of money

Tejvan Pettinger 2-24-22 (Economics teacher and writer, “Economic Impact Of War, Economics Help accessed 7-1-23 https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/2180/economics/economic-impact-of-war/”)--DSP06

Putting aside the very real human cost, war has also serious economic costs – damage to infrastructure, a decline in the working population, inflation, shortages, uncertainty, a rise in debt and disruption to normal economic activity. From some perspectives, war can appear to be beneficial in terms of creating demand, employment, innovation and profits for business (especially when the war occurs in other countries.) However, when we talk about the ‘economic benefits’ of war we must be aware of the ‘broken window fallacy‘ – when we spend money on war, this creates demand, but also it represents a huge opportunity cost – rather than building bombs and rebuilding destroyed towns, we could have used this money to improve education or health care. For example, the opportunity cost of the Iraq war was estimated at $860 billion by end of 2009 (source: NY Times) In many circumstances, war can lead to inflation – which leads to loss of people’s savings, rise in uncertainty and loss of confidence in the financial system. For example, in the US civil war, the Confederacy struggled financially to meet the cost of the war. Therefore, they started printing money to pay soldiers’ salaries. But, as they printed money, the value of money soon declined. High inflation hits middle-income savers the most as they see the value of their savings wiped out. During the Second World War, the United States saw a rise in inflation because the economy was running close to full capacity, the high levels of government spending and shortage of workers saw inflationary pressures. During war, the economy can also experience cost-push inflation due to shortages of goods and services and rising price of raw materials like oil. (Interestingly inflation in the Second World War was limited by price controls and rationning) If a country is devastated by war and the capacity to produce goods is sharply reduced, it can create the circumstances of hyperinflation as governments desperately print money to try and deal with the lack of goods. For example, with a devastated economy, in 1946, Hungary and Austria experienced the highest rates of hyperinflation on record.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Bomb Madagascar › AFF › 2AC

War tanks mental health

R. SRINIVASA MURTHY and RASHMI LAKSHMINARAYANA 2006 (World health worker and London school of medicine and hygiene graduate, “Mental health consequences of war: a brief review of research fundings, accessed 7-1-23 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1472271/#:~:text=War%20destroys%20communities%20and%20families,in%20material%20and%20human%20capital.”)--DSP06

Among the consequences of war, the impact on the mental health of the civilian population is one of the most significant. Studies of the general population show a definite increase in the incidence and prevalence of mental disorders. Women are more affected than men. Other vulnerable groups are children, the elderly and the disabled. Prevalence rates are associated with the degree of trauma, and the availability of physical and emotional support. The use of cultural and religious coping strategies is frequent in developing countries.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Bomb Madagascar › NEG › 2NC

War is beneficial and creates opportunity

Robert Kaplan 10-6-14 (Economic analyst, Stratfor Contributor, “Why War is Good, Forbes accessed 7-1-23 https://www.forbes.com/sites/stratfor/2014/10/06/why-war-is-good/?sh=38999ba85b96”)--DSP06

Some of the most terrifying moments of my life have been in the midst of conflict: with American marines in Fallujah in 2004 and with armed bands in Sierra Leone in 1993. I stood next to mounds of dead Iranian soldiers, teenagers actually, during the Iran-Iraq War in 1984. The horror of war is a reality I have experienced firsthand. And yet an analyst must never give in to his or her emotions. He or she must view history with a heart of ice to find patterns that others miss. This is what Stanford classics professor Ian Morris does in his new book, War! What Is It Good For? Conflict and the Progress of Civilization from Primates to Robots. Morris, both an archaeologist and a historian, surveys thousands of years of history and comes away with the seemingly startling thesis that human progress has been helped, rather than hindered, by war. As he writes, "by fighting wars, people have created larger, more organized societies that have reduced the risk that their members will die violently." Indeed, in the Stone Age, you had as much as a 20 percent chance of dying violently at the hands of another human being. But in the 20th century -- even with the trenches, even with Hitler, with Hiroshima, with terrorism and with a panoply of Third World wars -- you had only a 1 or 2 percent chance of dying violently. Yes, as many as 200 million people may have died in wars throughout the 1900s, but roughly 10 billion lives were lived during that period. One may argue that this has merely been a matter of food production outpacing the production of assault rifles, so that violence has not so much been suppressed as overwhelmed by science. But Morris sees another factor: the rise of Hobbesian Leviathans that could only come about by war itself. A Leviathan is the horrifying monster that Job beheld in the Bible, the "king over all the children of pride." The 17th century English philosopher Thomas Hobbes used the concept as a metaphor for a strong central government that, by monopolizing the use of force, would make men no longer fear each other but only the authorities above them. Such was the way toward peaceful progress. Morris shows that, ironically, throughout history Leviathan has generally been created not by reasoned discussion but by war. He laments that this is so but demonstrates that humanity has thus far found no other way. Morris recounts the sheer dreadfulness of Rome's conquests over the northern tribes of Europe. "Rome had made a wasteland and called it peace," went the famous adage. But that wasteland, he goes on, became the most productive and the most developed part of Greater Europe and the Mediterranean basin, even as life under Roman rule was safer and more predictable for the average person compared to any of the so-called barbarian precincts adjacent to Rome. Leviathan quelled violence, even as it demanded it. The political philosopher Francis Fukuyama in his 2011 book, The Origins of Political Order, posed the question, how do we get to Denmark -- Denmark being a metaphor for a humane and efficient polity? Morris essentially answers that we get to Denmark by starting with Rome. A theme that runs through Morris' book is that while some idealists worship primitive societies and the noble savages who populate them, primitive societies rather than idyllic retreats have more often been filled with the terrifying human monsters associated with William Golding's 1954 novel, Lord of the Flies. Thus, the idea is to incorporate primitive societies within Leviathan, and that has usually happened through military conquest.