2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---LGSA
Congressional Budget Office (CBO) 23, federal agency that provides budget and economic information to Congress, 4-26-2023, "The Economic and Budgetary Effects of Discretionary Funding Caps as Specified in the Limit, Save, Grow Act of 2023," Congressional Budget Office, https://www.cbo.gov/publication/59390
The Congressional Budget Office has analyzed the economic and budgetary effects of imposing caps on discretionary budget authority.1 Specifically, the agency has estimated what the effects would be if the funding caps enacted in June 2023 had been those required under H.R. 2811, the Limit, Save, Grow Act of 2023 (LSGA), which was passed by the House of Representatives on April 26, 2023. CBO has previously published estimates indicating that, relative to the agency’s February 2023 baseline budget projections, caps under the LSGA would reduce the primary deficit—that is, the total deficit minus net interest outlays—by $3.2 trillion from 2024 to 2033.2 In comparison, the caps that became law under the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (FRA, Public Law 118-5) would reduce CBO’s projections of discretionary spending, and therefore the projected primary deficit, by $1.3 trillion over that period.3
Those estimates were prepared according to long-standing practice, reflecting the assumption that the total output of the economy, measured in current-year dollars (that is, in terms of nominal gross domestic product, or GDP), would not change. As a result, total income would be unchanged. The dynamic analysis described in this report considers a broader set of effects. It takes into account the ways that reductions in discretionary spending would affect the total output of the economy and how the resulting macroeconomic changes would in turn affect federal revenues and spending.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---FRA
Dr. David Holbrook 6/16, nationally recognized leader in federal programs administration, Executive Director with TransACT Communications, 6-16-2023, "Debt Ceiling Deal Could Impact Future Federal Education Funding," No Publication,
The U.S. Congress passed, and President Biden signed legislation to avoid defaulting on the U.S. government’s loans. Congress nearly failed to raise the debt limit, which is the amount of money the government can borrow. The U.S. actually reached the debt limit in March; however, the U.S. Treasury had been doing some fiscal juggling to avoid defaulting on the U.S. debt. If the U.S. were to have defaulted on its debt (not pay its bills), it could have had a devastating impact on both the U.S. and the world economy.
The debt ceiling deal, called the Fiscal Responsibility Act, raises the debt limit until January 2025. This effectively avoids another debt ceiling battle until after the 2024 presidential elections.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---FRA
Tim Smart and Kaia Hubbard 6/9, Smart has more than four decades of news reporting and editing experience, having worked at The Washington Post, The Orlando Sentinel, the Miami Herald and the St. Petersburg Times. He is a graduate of the University of Florida, where he served as editor of the college paper, The Independent Florida Alligator. Hubbard is a politics reporter at U.S. News & World Report. She joined the company in 2020 after previously writing for Willamette Week in Portland, Oregon. Kaia is a graduate of the University of San Diego, where she led her college paper as editor-in-chief, winning regional and national awards for her work., June 9th, 2023 accessed on 7-20-2023, The End of the Era of Exuberant Spending, https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2023-06-09/the-debt-deal-is-only-the-first-step-in-weaning-washington-off-its-spending-addiction, TGarcia
“The FRA is the largest deficit reduction bill in well over a decade, and it passed with support from both parties,” said Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. “The FRA is likely to generate at least $1 trillion in savings, and could save as much as twice that if appropriators take its targets seriously. That’s a very good starting point; now more work will be needed.” Added the Bipartisan Policy Committee: “The BPC applauds President Biden, Speaker McCarthy, and congressional leadership for crafting a bipartisan agreement addressing federal spending and avoiding a potentially disastrous default on our obligations. This kind of compromise is exactly how divided government should work.” But with barely a week to reflect on the achievement – arrived at after plenty of political gamesmanship and warnings of economic catastrophe should the government default on its debt – a new reality that an era of exuberant spending could be over is setting in. That, along with the predictable calls for new programs that could undo some of the law’s promises. One realization is that the days of easy money and expansive federal spending ushered in during the coronavirus pandemic may well have ended. Another is that the law does little to tackle the underlying structural imbalances between government spending and revenues, dealing with only discretionary spending outside of defense and not touching programs such as Social Security and Medicare. And finally, the reality that the law sets up another battle over the debt ceiling in two years, when a new Congress and perhaps a new president will face many of the same issues as well as the expiration of certain tax breaks that were enacted in 2017 during the term of former President Donald Trump. “Setting aside the specific figures, we think this bill marks an important inflection point in federal fiscal policy,” Wells Fargo economists Michael Pugliese and Karl Vesely wrote after the deal was struck. “The past several years have been marked by highly accommodative federal fiscal policy. This era may be coming to an end as federal fiscal policy is shifting to a more neutral stance.” The Congressional Budget Office estimates the debt ceiling agreement will reduce budget deficits by about $1.5 trillion over the next 10 years. Many private economists say it will reduce overall gross domestic product by 0.1 to 0.2 percentage points. That’s a drop in the bucket of an economy expected to produce an annual GDP of $26 trillion this year. And it’s not the only drag on economic growth underway, as the Federal Reserve has also raised interest rates by 5% in total over the past year and continues to reduce the assets of its balance sheet by up to $95 billion a month. Add in that the Treasury will now be issuing around $600 billion-$700 billion in new debt to make up for the time it was not raising funds during the standoff and it is likely that the economy will see a drying up of excess liquidity.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---FRA
Tim Smart and Kaia Hubbard 6/9, Smart has more than four decades of news reporting and editing experience, having worked at The Washington Post, The Orlando Sentinel, the Miami Herald and the St. Petersburg Times. He is a graduate of the University of Florida, where he served as editor of the college paper, The Independent Florida Alligator. Hubbard is a politics reporter at U.S. News & World Report. She joined the company in 2020 after previously writing for Willamette Week in Portland, Oregon. Kaia is a graduate of the University of San Diego, where she led her college paper as editor-in-chief, winning regional and national awards for her work., June 9th, 2023 accessed on 7-20-2023, The End of the Era of Exuberant Spending, https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2023-06-09/the-debt-deal-is-only-the-first-step-in-weaning-washington-off-its-spending-addiction, TGarcia
“The FRA is the largest deficit reduction bill in well over a decade, and it passed with support from both parties,” said Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. “The FRA is likely to generate at least $1 trillion in savings, and could save as much as twice that if appropriators take its targets seriously. That’s a very good starting point; now more work will be needed.” Added the Bipartisan Policy Committee: “The BPC applauds President Biden, Speaker McCarthy, and congressional leadership for crafting a bipartisan agreement addressing federal spending and avoiding a potentially disastrous default on our obligations. This kind of compromise is exactly how divided government should work.” But with barely a week to reflect on the achievement – arrived at after plenty of political gamesmanship and warnings of economic catastrophe should the government default on its debt – a new reality that an era of exuberant spending could be over is setting in. That, along with the predictable calls for new programs that could undo some of the law’s promises. One realization is that the days of easy money and expansive federal spending ushered in during the coronavirus pandemic may well have ended. Another is that the law does little to tackle the underlying structural imbalances between government spending and revenues, dealing with only discretionary spending outside of defense and not touching programs such as Social Security and Medicare. And finally, the reality that the law sets up another battle over the debt ceiling in two years, when a new Congress and perhaps a new president will face many of the same issues as well as the expiration of certain tax breaks that were enacted in 2017 during the term of former President Donald Trump. “Setting aside the specific figures, we think this bill marks an important inflection point in federal fiscal policy,” Wells Fargo economists Michael Pugliese and Karl Vesely wrote after the deal was struck. “The past several years have been marked by highly accommodative federal fiscal policy. This era may be coming to an end as federal fiscal policy is shifting to a more neutral stance.” The Congressional Budget Office estimates the debt ceiling agreement will reduce budget deficits by about $1.5 trillion over the next 10 years. Many private economists say it will reduce overall gross domestic product by 0.1 to 0.2 percentage points. That’s a drop in the bucket of an economy expected to produce an annual GDP of $26 trillion this year. And it’s not the only drag on economic growth underway, as the Federal Reserve has also raised interest rates by 5% in total over the past year and continues to reduce the assets of its balance sheet by up to $95 billion a month. Add in that the Treasury will now be issuing around $600 billion-$700 billion in new debt to make up for the time it was not raising funds during the standoff and it is likely that the economy will see a drying up of excess liquidity.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---FRA
Seamus P. Daniels 6/15, fellow for Defense Budget Analysis in the International Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C., 6-15-2023, "What the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 Means for Defense Spending," Center for Strategic and International Studies,
On June 3, 2023, President Biden signed into law the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, an agreement to suspend the debt ceiling through January 1, 2025. The law imposes limits on discretionary spending for defense and non-defense programs in exchange for lifting the debt ceiling before the government ran out of funding to pay federal obligations. The act is estimated to reduce projected deficit levels by approximately $1.5 trillion over the 10-year FY 2024–FY 2033 period, according to analysis by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). Below are four critical questions about the agreement and its implications for national defense.
Q1: What does the deal mean for defense spending?
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---FRA
Peter G. Peterson Foundation 6/3, nonpartisan organization that addresses America's long-term fiscal challenges, 6-3-2023, "How Much Will the Debt Ceiling Deal Reduce Deficits?," Peter G. Peterson Foundation,
Lawmakers resolved the latest debt-limit standoff by enacting the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 on June 3, 2023. The legislation suspends the debt limit through January 1, 2025 and implements caps on discretionary funding for fiscal years 2024 and 2025. It also includes other provisions related to discretionary programs and adjusts work requirements for certain income-support programs.
According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), those provisions will result in a $1.5 trillion decrease to the deficit over the next 10 years. Much of those savings stem from the imposition of caps — which limit the amount of discretionary spending — and the extrapolation of lower levels of funding for the next two years. CBO anticipates that such a reduction in deficits would reduce the amount of debt held by the public in 2033 from 119 percent of GDP to 115 percent.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Fiscal Crisis DA › 2NC---UQ---CBO
Paul M. 6-28 (Paul M., 6-28-2023, "CBO says long-term debt lower than forecast last year," Roll Call, https://rollcall.com/2023/06/28/cbo-says-long-term-debt-lower-than-forecast-last-year/)
This month's law suspending the debt ceiling and capping appropriations has lowered projected spending, deficits and debt over the long haul, the Congressional Budget Office said in its latest long-term budget outlook. Compared to the agency's report issued last year, overall spending and deficits are higher over the next several years in the updated forecast released Wednesday. But in part because of the spending caps in the debt limit law, estimated spending in the latter part of the 30-year projection period will be lower than the agency estimated last summer. The latest projections are different as well from a more recent long-term estimate CBO published in February based on more limited data. “The differences reflect reductions in CBO’s projections of outlays — particularly discretionary outlays, which the agency projects to decline in part because of the effects” of the debt limit law, the report says. “The reduction in discretionary outlays stems from CBO’s assumption that statutory caps established by the [debt limit law] will limit discretionary funding in 2024 and 2025,” the report says. The caps result in lower spending projections in future years because CBO generally estimates discretionary spending growth by adjusting previous year spending for inflation. Spending on the major health care programs is also expected to be lower over time, mostly because of reductions in projected Medicare spending, though that is partially offset by higher expected spending on other health programs. The CBO's forecast for Social Security is about the same as it was in February, though slightly different from last year's long-term report: the trust fund for retirees and survivors is expected to run out of money to pay full benefits a year earlier, in 2032, while the life of the disability insurance fund is extended by four years, to 2052. Combining the two trust fund balances produces the same exhaustion date as forecast last year, in 2033. The agency downsized its estimate of revenues over the three-decade period. “That overall decrease is mostly explained by lower receipts from individual income taxes — the largest source of revenues — in the current projections,” according to the report. The agency said estimated receipts are lower in the near-term because of reduced projections of capital gains realizations, which result from lower asset values. The longer-term reduction in revenue estimates is due to the CBO’s expectation of lower distributions from pensions and individual retirement accounts. In its long-term projections, the CBO estimates spending, revenue, deficits and debt as a share of the economy rather than providing numerical estimates as it does in its shorter-term 10-year projections. Despite lower revenue projections, the agency now believes that debt held by the public as a share of the economy will be 9 percentage points lower at the end of the 30-year period than they thought last year, though it will be larger over the next two decades. In an update of its economic projections since last year, the agency forecasts a larger increase in interest rates over the next decade, but less of a rise over the following two decades. The average interest rate on 10-year Treasury notes between 2023 and 2032 is now projected to be 3.8 percent, 0.2 percentage point higher than last year’s estimate, the CBO said. The agency increased its estimate because it expects the Federal Reserve will further raise the target range for the federal funds rate and maintain that target range longer than previously expected in response to “recent persistent high inflation.” But during the following two decades from 2034 to 2052, CBO anticipates lower interest rates than it estimated last year. The average rate on 10-year Treasury notes over the period is 4.1 percent in the agency’s projections, 0.2 percentage point lower than in last year’s estimate. The CBO said it expects lower interest rates down the road largely as a result of slower growth in the labor force than it earlier projected for the second half of the 30-year period. Over the course of the full three decades, generally the agency's forecasts for inflation and economic growth are "roughly unchanged" from last year's report, the agency said.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Safiyah Riddle, 7-11-2023, "Small business confidence reaches 7-month high in June, NFIB says," Reuters,
July 11 (Reuters) - U.S. small business confidence climbed to a seven-month high in June as pessimism about the economic outlook diminished sharply and sales expectations improved, but a still-tight labor market continued to drive concerns about inflation, according to a survey released on Tuesday.
The National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) said its Small Business Optimism Index rose 1.6 points to 91 last month, the greatest month-to-month improvement since August 2022.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Tina Morrison 23, 6-29-2023, "Markets wrap: Business confidence highest since November 2021," Stuff, 7/21/23 JY
The sharemarket rose after a report showed businesses were feeling less downbeat about the economic environment.
The benchmark S&P/NZX 50 Index advanced 0.6%, or 74.659 points, to 11,808.12 on Thursday. On the broader market 76 stocks rose and 43 fell with $109 million shares traded.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Fibre2fashion 23, 07-21-2023, "Global business confidence slips in June 2023, yet remains strong," No Publication, 7/21/23 JY
The net balance of companies worldwide predicting a rise in business activity over the coming year ticked down to 28 per cent in June 2023 from 32 per cent in February. Although deteriorating, business confidence was still the second-strongest since early-2022.
Each of the six European economies for which combined manufacturing and services data are available saw a drop in confidence since the February outlook survey. A slight pull-back in sentiment was also seen in the US. Meanwhile, optimism in China waned following the jump in sentiment after the removal of pandemic-related restrictions around the turn of the year, according to the latest S&P Global Business Outlook Survey.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Abc News 23, 6-27-2023, ssMATT OTT AP Business Writer. "US consumer confidence jumps to highest level since early 2022," ABC News, 7/21/23 JY
WASHINGTON -- The American consumer's confidence jumped in June to its highest level in 18 months as a strong labor market continues to buoy the U.S. economy.
The Conference Board reported Tuesday that its consumer confidence index rose to 109.7 in June from 102.5 in May. That's the highest the reading has been since January of 2022 and much higher than economists had forecast.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Anne Petrik 23, 6-29-2023, As Vice President of Research for Vistage, Anne Petrik is instrumental in the creation of original thought leadership designed to inform the decision-making of CEOs of small and midsize businesses. These perspectives — shared through reports, blogs, webinars and events — are grounded in her analysis of data from Vistage CEO Confidence Index surveys and complemented by insights curated from experts and partners across the Vistage community. "Small Business Confidence Improves After Debt Ceiling Scare," Vistage Research Center, 7/15/23 JY
After the uncertainty of the debt ceiling status that impacted small business confidence in May, the June WSJ/Vistage Small Business CEO Confidence Index increased 6.5 points to reach 79.8, returning to the level recorded this past March.
Photo of Graph
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Alicia Wallace 23, 6-27-2023, Alicia Wallace is a senior writer for CNN Business covering the economy and topics such as cannabis. "Americans are feeling far more confident about the economy," CNN, 7-15-23 JY
Americans are feeling fairly bullish about the US economy: A key measurement of consumer confidence just jumped to its highest level since January 2022.
The Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Index was 109.7 in June, rising from 102.5 the month before, according to a report released Tuesday.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2NC---UQ---General
Ben Glickman 23 (Ben Glickman is reporting intern and part of the summer 2023 newsroom intern class at The Wall Street Journal. Ben is a recent graduate of Brown University, where he studied political science and data science. He previously interned at the Financial Times and served as editor in chief of his college newspaper, the Brown Daily Herald. He also has written for various local newspapers, including on Cape Cod and in Pelham, N.Y.7-11-2023, "U.S. Small-Business Owner Confidence Rises in June, But Remains Historically Low," WSJ 7-15-23 JY)
Confidence among U.S. small-business owners rose in June but remains below the long-term average, as inflation and labor concerns continue to weigh on owners. The National Federation of Independent Business said Tuesday that its small-business optimism index increased to 91 in June from 89.4 in May, well below the index’s 49-year average of 98. The index reading was, however, ahead of the 89.6 consensus forecast from economists polled by The Wall Street Journal. The NFIB survey provides a monthly snapshot of small businesses in the U.S., which account for nearly half of private sector jobs.
Inflation and labor quality were tied as the top concerns among owners, with 24% reporting each as their single most important challenge. The number of owners expecting better business conditions over the next six months improved by 10 percentage points from May to a net negative 40% in June, 21 points better than a year earlier. The portion of owners who said job openings were hard to fill declined two percentage points to 42% in June. But the June reading is still historically high. “Halfway through the year, small-business owners remain very pessimistic about future business conditions and their sales prospects,” said NFIB Chief Economist Bill Dunkelberg. “Inflation and labor shortages continue to be great challenges for small businesses.” Higher costs associated with inventory troubles, labor and energy are still forcing owners to raise prices, Dunkelberg added.
2023
Michigan
Disadvantage
MPS---Econ DA---Updates › Business Confidence DA › 2AC---UQ
Matthew Medsger, 06-05-2023, "Business confidence turns pessimistic for the first time since 2020," Boston Herald, https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/06/05/business-confidence-turns-pessimistic-for-the-first-time-since-2020/
Business confidence among the state’s employers fell last month to the lowest level seen since the height of the pandemic, according to a recent survey of Massachusetts employers. The Associated Industries of Massachusetts, in its monthly Business Confidence Index, says Massachusetts business owners’ faith in the economy plunged half-a-point in May, dropping from 50.1% to 49.6% and continuing a downward trend that first began in November. And while a half point may not sound like a lot, the move is significant as a reading below 50 indicates a pessimistic outlook. “Massachusetts employers turned pessimistic about the economy for the first time since December 2020 last month as the state economy slowed to a crawl and the Federal Reserve continued to raise interest rates,” the survey reads, in part. The index, taken well ahead of Friday’s unexpected report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showing the economy had added a further 339,000 jobs and before President Biden’s negotiated deal to suspend the debt ceiling until 2025 had cleared Congress, reflects an ongoing concern among employers that the nation may be barreling toward economic recession or policy driven calamity. “Businesses have been stung by both stubbornly high inflation and persistently high interest rates, which have dampened demand and raised costs. It’s unfortunately not surprising that the Future Index indicates that business leaders expect these conditions to worsen further,” Michael Tyler, Chief Investment Officer at Eastern Bank Wealth Management and Vice Chair of AIM’s Board of Economic Advisors said with the survey’s release. “Thankfully, a possible recession would likely be shallow and short, cushioned by a strong jobs market and healthy consumer spending,” Tyler said. Though circumstances may have seemed particularly dire to business owners as of last month, according AIM President John Regan, doing away with concerns of a U.S. default and the consequences of what might follow will hopefully put the minds of employers at ease. “The President and Congress did the right thing in hammering out an agreement that will maintain the stability of the global financial system. Employers need all the predictability they can get as the economy continues to slow down,” Regan said. Friday’s jobs report also showed a slight uptick in the unemployment rate, which has Fed watchers wondering if the economy has slowed enough that Federal Reserve Chair Jay Powell could consider a pause in the central bank’s on-going crusade against inflation via raises to the key interest rate, an eleventh of which may or may not materialize out of June’s meeting of the Board of Governors.
AIM surveys more than 140 Bay State businesses to produce their monthly index, the first of which was published in July of 1991. According to AIM, business confidence hit historic highs in 1997 and 1998, with two months in either year showing 68.5% confidence, and hit a low in February of 2009, when it was 33.3%.
2023
Michigan
Kritik
Aff › Links › Link Turn—Redistribution—2AC
Brown 17, Clair Brown is an American economist who is Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Work, Technology, and Society at the University of California, Berkeley. Brown is a past Director of the Institute of Industrial Relations at UC Berkeley. Clair has published research on many aspects of how economies function, including the standard of living, wage determination, inequality, sustainability, high-tech industries, and development engineering. Her books include American Standards of Living: 1919-1988 and Buddhist Economics: An enlightened approach to the dismal science (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) “Buddhist Economics”, Humans and Nature, April 6, 2017, ,$$G
My book: (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) also addresses this question. Buddhist economics assumes that humans are interdependent with each other and with nature, and happiness comes from helping others and living a meaningful life, and not from consumption. Society can structure the economy and regulate markets to provide opportunities for everyone to live a comfortable worthwhile life while caring for the environment.
Buddhist economics integrates the capabilities approach of Sen, with the ecological economic approach compatible with strong sustainability (boundary thresholds for ecosystems), with the UN sustainable development approach for shared prosperity worldwide. Happiness comes from creating a worthy life, based on Aristotle, rather than hedonic happiness based on “more is better.” We move from a “closetful economy” to a “mindful economy.”
2023
Michigan
Kritik
Aff › Links › Link Turn—Redistribution—2AC
Doyle 23, Hannah Doyle Current student at Claremont McKenna College in Southern California, studying Economics, Philosophy, and Leadership. “A Philosophical and Empirical Investigation into Buddhist Economics”, CMC Senior Theses, 2023 ,$$G
Finally, we evaluate the issue of property rights. In returning to the Buddha’s recommendations for monarchs, we summarize that all must have a chance to make an honest living, equal protection must be provided to all in the land, and there must be measures to protect against exploitation. I think it is highly possible that a fully-fledged Buddhist economic system might dismantle property rights entirely to promote a greater sense of interconnection. However, the intermediate value of property rights in a Buddhist sense can be understood from their necessity in promoting a standard level of wellbeing in the world, such that all groups do receive equal protection, are guaranteed not to be exploitation, and are able to make an honest living. On a final note, we will look to the economic principle of diminishing marginal utility to uncover an additional benefit of wealth distribution beyond mere equality. Essentially, this 32 principle implies that more total utility is achieved through more equal distribution of wealth, because one dollar taken from a rich household costs them less utility than that gained from the same dollar given to a poor household. Although this understanding is not nearly enough to justify wealth redistribution on its own, it’s a useful fact to keep in mind in discussions of inequality, redistribution, and collective wellbeing. A Buddhist system of economics could also harness this economic truth, such that overall suffering could be decreased while promoting greater total equality. After this divergence from Buddhist philosophy, we can see a few key themes that allow us to better compare neoclassical economics to Buddhist economics. As demonstrated by Adam Smith’s original understanding of markets, Buddhist economics’ inclusion of government and institutional reform and regulation to promote equality and freedom are in alignment with founding market ideologies, even if later economics strayed away from these considerations. Second, modern markets suffer from numerous forms of market failure, including a lack of effective property rights, protection against monopolies, access to sufficient information to make rational decisions, and the inclusion of externalities in economic calculations. Lastly, the role of markets, specifically labor markets, in producing preferences and real capabilities cannot be overstated. This justifies evaluating market failure beyond mere efficiency. These analyses highlight potential reasons why current markets fail to promote overall equality, as well as why they should consider the distributive effects they produce altogether. It also suggests that the overall market system may not be entirely flawed, and that proper governmental intervention could be utilized to promote equality, at least from Adam Smith’s viewpoint.
2023
Michigan
Kritik
Aff › Alt › Perm Do Both—2AC
Gordon ’23. Robert Edward Gordon is an Assistant Research Professor in the Center for the Philosophy of Freedom at the University of Arizona. He is a Fellow at UArizona’s Center for Buddhist Studies. “Modern Economics and What the Buddha Taught,” published 2/28/23 on The American Institute of Economic Research, accessed 4/12/23. . LeoXF
Indeed, I believe that the current Buddhist economic point of view starts from a flawed premise that is unduly negative towards free markets and its precepts. Clair Brown states that “Free market economics holds that human nature is self-centered and that people only care about themselves as they push ahead to maximize their incomes and fancy lifestyles.” On the contrary, economic self-interest does not mean self-centeredness or greed. It does not even lead to it. Greed is an individual character flaw, not an economic or political one. At its root, economic self-interest means taking responsibility for one’s own survival and material well-being; it means taking care of oneself so as not to burden society, which lays the foundation for a happiness based on achievement and self-worth.
This is completely in keeping with Buddhism as promulgated by its founder, Siddhartha Gautama. In What the Buddha Taught, Walpola Rahula — a Buddhist monk and scholar of impeccable reputation — clearly outlines the basic ideas of the religion from its oldest known writings. Rahula quotes the Buddha as saying “One is one’s own refuge, who else could be the refuge?” He tells his followers “never to seek refuge in or help from anybody else,” to be “a refuge to themselves.” Buddhism is about coming to grips with the Truth or Reality of things. It is a way or “path” that promotes questioning what is given and assuaging doubt. As Rahula writes, “[The Buddha] taught, encouraged, and stimulated each person to develop himself and to work out his own emancipation, for man has the power to liberate himself from all bondage through his own personal effort and intelligence.”
2023
Michigan
Kritik
Aff › Alt › Perm Do Both—2AC
Brown 19 Clair Brown is an American economist who is Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Work, Technology, and Society at the University of California, Berkeley. Brown is a past Director of the Institute of Industrial Relations at UC Berkeley. Clair has published research on many aspects of how economies function, including the standard of living, wage determination, inequality, sustainability, high-tech industries, and development engineering. Her books include American Standards of Living: 1919-1988 and Buddhist Economics: An enlightened approach to the dismal science (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) “Buddhist Economics: The Foundation for an Equitable, Sustainable, Caring Economy” American Economic Association, January 5, 2019 ,$$G
Often when people are confronted with the climate crisis that is killing the earth for humans, they shrug it off, as in “this is how everyone is living, and how people like us have always lived”. Then they continue to destroy our planet with their wasteful lifestyle that pollutes the air, water and earth. We do not have the right to harm people and other species as we overheat the earth. Our entitlement is to clean air and water and care of basic needs, and not to our addictions to fossil fuel, meat, and wasteful consumption. To create the economy that we desire, people must work with environmental and political groups to demand that local to global governments restructure the economy to use clean energy, develop regenerative agriculture, redistribute resources from the rich to the needy, promote peace, and evaluate economic performance as quality of life. Our economy needs to focus less on income growth and more on quality of life. Buddhist economics focuses on creating sustainable lifestyles that reduce wasteful consumption and reduce overwork so people have time to enjoy life and help one another. We want to change the culture so people care about shared prosperity, rather than about how much money they are making. We do not want to replicate individualistic motivations that create injustice and inequality, and instead want to create a culture that supports human rights and healthy ecosystems. In a Buddhist economy, more natural options will become the new norm. Time for social and creative activities allow us to enjoy life. Lavish consumption will seem as crazy as it is, as people become healthier and happier with natural living and as the planetary ecosystems heal. The good news is that our way of life can remain meaningful and worthy as our consumption and lifestyles become sustainable.
2023
Michigan
Kritik
Aff › Indicts › Turn—Growth—2AC
Bernhard Schroeder, 2019, Entrepreneurship, creativity, branding, product branding, internet marketing and marketing. He works at San Diego State University, “12 Advantages of a Growth Mindset That Could Accelerate Your Career” Forbes LPlot
Adopting a growth mindset is not just essential in your life, it’s critical. Those people with a growth mindset understand that knowledge can be acquired and intelligence can be developed. With a growth mindset, people focus on improvement instead of worrying about how smart they are. They work hard to learn more and get smarter. A “growth mindset,” thrives on challenge and sees failure not as evidence of unintelligence but as a heartening springboard for growth and for stretching our existing abilities.
A “fixed mindset,” on the other hand, assumes that our character, intelligence, and creative ability are static givens, its what we were born with, which we can’t change in any meaningful way. Out of these two mindsets, which we manifest from a very early age, comes our belief about whether or not we believe we can succeed at whatever we want to be. We are not what other people said we were at a young age. Ever had a parent or teacher say this to you as a child,” You’re drawing is terrible. You just don’t have math skills. You are not athletic.” They were wrong. Here’s the good news. No matter your current mindset, you can adopt and nurture a growth mindset but you have work to do.