Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Kritik
Aff › Indicts › Turn—Corporations—2AC

Greed is not at the root of Capitalism rather it is empathy—socialism fosters Greedy companies

Rainer Zitelmann 2019, Dr. Rainer Zitelmann is a historian and sociologist. He is also a world-renowned author, successful businessman, and real estate investor. “The Driving Force of Capitalism is Empathy, Not Greed” Forbes LPlot

Both proponents of capitalism and anti-capitalists frequently accuse capitalism of being a system driven by selfishness and greed. Capitalism’s defenders sometimes say: “By nature, man is selfish, which is why socialism will never work. Capitalism better reflects the fundamental characteristics of human nature.” Anti-capitalists claim that capitalism promotes the worst characteristics in man, especially greed.

“Greed Is Good”: The Motto Of Modern Capitalism?

2023 Michigan Kritik
Aff › Indicts › Turn—Non-Violence—2AC

Violence is subject to change which means a definition or path of action of non-violence is impossible

Peter Gelderloos 15, Peter Gelderloos is an American anarchist activist and writer. “The Failure of Nonviolence” Chapter 1 Stanford LPlot

Perhaps the most important argument against nonviolence is that violence as a concept is ambiguous to the point of being incoherent. It is a concept that is prone to manipulation, and its definition is in the hands of the media and the government, so that those who base their struggle on trying to avoid it will forever be taking cues and following the lead of those in power.

Put simply, violence does not exist. It is not a thing. It is a category, a human construct in which we choose to place a wide array of actions, phenomena, situations, and so forth. “Violence” is whatever the person speaking at the moment decides to describe as violent. Usually, this means things they do not like. As a result, the use of the category “violence” tends towards hypocrisy. If it is done to me, it is violent. If it is done by me or for my benefit, it is justified, acceptable, or even invisible.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Aff › Indicts › Turn—Money Good—2AC

Money does buy happiness—its scientifically proven and our perception is the only thing that actually does that—alleviating poverty is proven to have the highest increase in happiness

Suliman 23, Adela Suliman is a breaking-news reporter in The Washington Post's London hub, covering news as it unfolds in the United States and around the globe during overnight and early morning hours in Washington. Previously, she has worked for NBC News, Al Jazeera English, Reuters and the Thomson Reuters Foundation and The Associated Press. She is a graduate of the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS), University of London, with a degree in Law, and Columbia’s Graduate School of Journalism. “Can money buy happiness? Scientists say it can.”, Washington Post, March 8, 2023, ,$$G

It’s a question that philosophers, economists and social scientists have grappled with for decades: Can money buy happiness?

For most people in the United States, the answer is, seemingly, yes.

2023 Michigan Kritik
Aff › Indicts › Buddhist Economics Wrong—2AC

Their portrayal of capitalism and their alternative is bad—they sever from true Buddhist teachings and their view of economics only reinforces capitalism. State action is possible to ensure a true change of the economy—complete and utter rejection of capitalism as an essential issue makes it worse and diverts attention away from true ways to solve.

Nelson 18, Julie Nelson currently conducts research on feminism and economics, with special interests in methodology and in implications for social and environmental policies. She has also published in the areas of ethics, the teaching of economics, and the empirical analysis of household and individual behavior. She has served as a Research Economist at the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, an Assistant and Associate Professor of Economics at the University of California-Davis, an Associate Professor of Economics at Brandeis University, a Visiting Associate Professor at Harvard University, a Fellow at the Center for the Study of Values in Public Life at Harvard Divinity School, and as the Visiting Sowell Professor of Economics at Bates College. “A Skeptical (and Buddhist) Take on “New Economy” Approaches*”, December 18, 2018, $$G

Before I get into the “skeptical” part of my argument, let me first outline a few points on which I enthusiastically agree with the views expressed by John Tomer (2017), Clair Brown (2017), and Joel Magnuson (2008). First, we are in deep trouble. Climate change and other forms of environmental degradation are real; injustices are widespread and persistent; human misery is rife. Second, many of these problems can, in fact, be traced to economic phenomena. These include fossilfuel-based industrialization, a narrow focus on material satisfactions and GDP growth, and policies that allow the few to get rich at the expense of the many. Third, Buddhism has something important to offer. This is particularly true in regard to its warnings about the “three poisons” of greed, anger, and ignorance.

But here is where I differ: These authors (along with other notable Buddhist writers such as David Loy (2015) and the Ven. Bhikku Bodhi (2015)) locate the root of these problems in various principles, such as greed and competition, which they believe are part of the inherent nature of our present economic system. Often this system is labeled simply as “capitalism.” They then advocate for dismantling the present system and replacing it with a “new economy” that would be governed by diametrically opposite principles. In the “new economy,” altruism and cooperation would, presumably, rule. I do not find this dualism helpful.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Permutations › Perm Core—2NC

4) Distraction DA: The aff distracts people from the true issue, capitalism, by providing substitutes that provide temporary “happiness”—they won’t change their mindset because they believe it makes them happy

Barua 10, Dr. Dipen Barua is an honorary lecturer at the Centre for Buddhist Studies at The University of Hong Kong. He has authored a book and published several articles in Bengali and English, on the subject of Buddhist studies, women’s issues, Buddhism in South and Southeast Asia, and cultural heritage. BuddhistDoor Global, “Application Of Buddhist Economics In Prevention Of Global Credit Crisis” January 10, 2010, //$$G

Modern Buddhism has become an intrinsic part of a globalized world. With its philosophy of the way of life, it takes special place in human and cultural identity. Buddhism shows us the possibility of a better way of leading a stress-free life. However, from a materialistic perspective and the social science of economics, such philosophical and spiritual understanding of life are considered as superstitious and escapist. [4,5,7]  The teachings of the Buddha are based on a different way of understanding the relationship between ourselves and the world. From the Buddhist perspective, economic growth and consumerism are unsatisfactory alternatives because they evade the basic problem of life, which is suffering, by distracting us with symbolic substitutes such as money, status and power.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Permutations › Perm Core—2NC

3) Decentralization DA: The affs centralization of resources is one that solidifies the economic institutions in place and coopts the project of Buddhist economics—link turns fail because of federal involvement

Bhusal 18, Indra Prasad Bhusal is Assistant Campus Chief of New Horizon College Butwal., “Fiscal decentralization in Buddhist economics: An interactive analysis from Lumbini”, Research Nepal Journal of Development Studies (RNJDS), October 5, 2018, ,$$G

At the beginning Buddhist perspective on the subject of economics was simple, a theological issue of Buddha’s ideology. While not seeking to present a completely comprehensive Buddhist economic theory, he provides many tools for reflection, ways of looking at economic question based on a considered appreciation of the way things are, the way we are. The hope that by making this work available in English it may go at least a short way towards resolving what has been called the current 'impasse of economics', and to awaken readers to the wide-reaching contemporary relevance of the timeless truths that the Buddha discovered and shared with us (Payutto, 2016).

“The federal system was created with the intention of combining the different advantages which result from the magnitude and the littleness of nations”. The quotes of Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America has given the base of theory decentralization. The research will be guided by this Toqueville ideology of Fiscal decentralization.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Permutations › Perm Core—2NC

1) It’s mutually exclusive—the aff entrenches fascination with money and wealth accumulation which drives further capitalism—consumption focused economics cannot happen in an economy in which the government gives out money to alleviate their own economic issues.

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

Pragmatism, however, does have a shadow side. If we become cynical and turn our backs on democratic participation as so many have done, the project of building better social institutions grinds down, the fabric of community ties becomes frayed, and we lose our sense of the common good. Things fall to pieces. Dewey’s message will be increasingly important in the years to come. Like ancient Rome in its twilight, our current system that is built on an unstable foundation of fossil fuels and the idolatry of money is in decline. As it passes its time of glory and gives way to something else, we will have an opportunity to begin making our system into something entirely different. That is, the direction and form of our great transition will be up to us to determine. Our current lives are the link between our past and our future. For those involved in social movements or working for social change, the past is what we are changing from and the future is what we envision changing into. This implies that our work for social change requires that we both look inward into our habits of thought as well as outward to our community. Cultivating a vision for change means questioning everything including our values, mindset, attitudes, and our expectations about what our economic institutions are supposed to do. If we cling to our old habits of thought and action, then we’ll continue to drift toward more destruction and instability.

Fostering change requires that we not only question and break out of our habitual ways of acting and thinking, but also to be open to which now seems unfathomable. We evolve by stretching ourselves outward and questioning all that is familiar and comfortable, and by working through experiences that challenge our intellect and abilities. We are in a continuous state of becoming and that implies an ever-expanding consciousness. As Dewey saw it, being engaged socially is the way we develop personally.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Answers To › AT//Link Turn—Federal Jobs Guarantee

The affs commodification of work and productivity through the federal government means that the link turn is false—only the alts worldview of local institution work can solve

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

Toward the end of his life, he left us with a vision of a future that is visible to us now. Schumacher the economist tells us of a future economic system that exists as a patchwork of semi-autonomous smaller scale organizations both public and private. With a different mindset people could re-create economic systems governed by rules and codes that lead to very different outcomes—ones that are governed democratically through worker and community-based councils. Like Ruskin and Morris, he had a vision of production systems that employ the skills of people who find actual joy in their work and at the same time innovate technology that is appropriate to lighten the burden of the workers yet does not take away their craft. Appropriate technology is improving the mastery of simpler methods of production and downgrading those that are excessive and overly complicated. He warns that what precisely is appropriate technology is difficult to pin down. There is no one-size-fits-all model. The technology is always developed within local institutions and local cultures. Most importantly is that it must be developed on a grass roots basis situated in the local culture and environmental habitat. Food production is by and for the local population. Smaller, simpler production systems naturally are more flexible and can be adapted to changing environments. He also envisioned a future social system of production that is grounded also in sound ecological principles.

Schumacher submitted that if people accept the notions that greed is good, foul is fair, and that vice leads to virtue, then our society will be molded accordingly into a culture of plunder. In such a culture, there occurs a general collapse of intelligence, a loss of wisdom, and people become blinded by their own rapacity. As Ruskin warned a century before, people lose insight into their own nature and the reality of things around them. Schumacher saw that by accepting these assumptions, we have created a culture conducive not to ecological permanence, but to devastation and ruin. Plunder is to destroy and strip bare all that has value from other people and from our natural habitat. It is rape, spoilage, and ruin, yet rationalized by orthodox economics by swift and cynical flourish, “foul is fair.”

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Answers To › AT//Link Turn—Redistribution Solves Buddhism

Dana is the only true redistribution of wealth—the tax and transfer destroys intent and only further entrenches the thought of “wealth” as a value and right

Barua 10, Dr. Dipen Barua is an honorary lecturer at the Centre for Buddhist Studies at The University of Hong Kong. He has authored a book and published several articles in Bengali and English, on the subject of Buddhist studies, women’s issues, Buddhism in South and Southeast Asia, and cultural heritage. BuddhistDoor Global, “Application Of Buddhist Economics In Prevention Of Global Credit Crisis” January 10, 2010, //$$G

The traditional Buddhist teachings have many important social implications. Buddhism does not separate economic issues from ethical or spiritual ones. The notion that economics is a social science related to discovering and applying impersonal economic laws always obscures two important truths. First important truth is that the concept of who gets what and who does not depends on moral considerations. So, production and distribution of economic goods and services should not be left only to the supposedly objective rules of the marketplace. If some people have much more than what they need while others have much less, some sort of redistribution is necessary. [1,2,3,4]

Thus, the practice of ‘D?na’ or ‘giving’ is the traditional Buddhist way of redistribution of wealth. D?na is selfless giving. It is giving in the spirit of Non-clinging. Non-clinging is the Wisdom of Insight into the Insubstantiality (Anatt?; Nair?tmya) or Emptiness (??nyat?) of all things. The emphasis on ‘D?na’ and merit-making is the Buddhist perspective on the economic globalization. [1,2,4,5]

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Alternative › Alternative – Spills Over—2NC

Localism solves—small, individual, movements can lead to transformation of local economies as well as global ones

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

For over a century the world has been on a trend of expanding the power of the corporate-dominated system. Most communities in the United States rely on large transnational corporations to make key decisions about where to locate manufacturing facilities and corporate headquarters. Transnational corporations move their financial and real investments from one location to the next, and communities that are economically dependent on these companies find themselves in a constant state of uncertainty and insecurity. They have no loyalty to any specific location and are indifferent to its own destruction of local environments and to people’s sense of place. Entire communities live under a constant threat of losing their economic vitality when a major employer decides to shut down and move operations elsewhere that promises a higher rate of return to investors. Workers are advised to be continuously upgrading their job skills to avoid having their livelihoods dissolve as the system no longer considers them useful. As the most powerful economic institutions in existence, corporations have the capability to create or destroy livelihoods without democratic accountability. Corporate decisions are not based on what is good for the people in those communities, but on what will bring the most profits to business. Corporations exert enormous pressure on local legislatures with the effective method of job blackmail—the threat of sacking workers while pulling up stakes to move elsewhere. With this kind of power, they control statehouse ability to democratically govern and force everyone to bend to their terms. They also have the capability to bend the arms of state and local government officials to get preferential treatment, tax abatements, subsidies; as well as cooperation in shredding land use planning laws, blocking regulations on controlling health insurance requirements, attacking minimum wage and living wage ordinances, and clawing back local resource conservation efforts and state environmental laws. The power of the corporate class works to undermine the will of residents by preempting laws which restrict their treatment of cities and towns as their fiefdoms. Corporations also provide no guarantees that they will not be bought out by another company, decide to relocate to another location or move offshore where costs are lower throwing scores of people in the community out of work. By being controlled by distant corporations, and by the fundamental separation of ownership and work, people have very little control over their economic lives. One of the main objectives of localism is to strengthen communities with resilience and self-reliance. The emphasis is on reshaping and strengthening local institutions in ways that give people and communities more democratic control over their economic lives. This does not imply reverting to provincialism or local nationalism. Local economies can become more self-reliant yet remain connected to the rest of the surrounding economy and world. Economic localism also does not mean focusing on a narrow segment of the economy like a single commodity or crop.

Rather, the effort is on evolving into complete and diverse economic systems that are locally based. The institutions that people create to coordinate local production and distribution cannot exist as islands isolated from one another. They must cohere as compatible elements of a localized system with the aim to create economic communities that are more self-reliant and less dependent on global corporations. By taking local and democratic control over economic activity, communities make their own decisions and direct activity for their own benefit. By designing them in this way localized economic systems can be seen as critical steps toward broader systemic change, which local action and vision for the broader social firmament. The community orientation of local institutions provides checks and balances on each other to mitigate the potentially destructive development of greed-inspired actions. In addition, the process of creating community-based institutions that serve the needs of local populations involves a certain amount of legal wrangling to rewrite the charters and bylaws of enterprises in such a way that the activities of those enterprises are anchored to the local community. Following the tradition established by Karl Polanyi, we see locally structured institutions as embedded or rooted in a localized community culture.6 As embedded institutions, locally structured institutions are more likely to be accountable to the social needs and the cultural characteristics of the community. Going local in this sense goes beyond just shopping and producing locally, it entails building coalitions and networks that connect communities around the country and even internationally. This also, therefore, stresses a holistic, systems frame of reference. Recall that social systems are made up of networks of integrated institutions that work together to serve a broader social purpose. An economic system is an integrated network of economic institutions that direct the processes of production, distribution, and consumption. As people in a self-defined local community can do multiple tasks and produce a multitude of goods and services to meet their foundational needs, the structure of the community becomes more complex. With complexity, there occurs a reweaving the web of relationships among people and organizations as they perform variegated functions on different levels. By contrast, if the entire community revolved, say, around corn production, and depended on others on the outside for everything else, then there is little complexity—there are the landowners and farm workers and little else. As the web of complexity is weaved, feedback structures emerge within the connections. A more localized and diversified economic community will have shorter distances between producer and consumer and the communication of what is working or not working is more direct and effective. In a globalized corporate system, communication is dysfunctional and impersonal. Tighter connections among producers and consumers naturally leads to more accountability and this can serve the need for fairness as well. As re-localized economies evolve into fully functioning systems, they will give rise to fostering the development of new financial institutions, manufacturing systems, retail establishments, food cooperatives, and so on. Each of these elements will be tied to every other element in the system with tighter and more well-observed feedback mechanisms. Every individual and every business model will be contributing directly to the evolution of the new system. With strong and diverse local systems that are networked with other local systems, a platform is established from which citizens can push upward for national reform legislation. Seemingly disparate local initiatives can have broad national consequences as local strength begets national reform. For such a model to evolve, people must play an active role in the same way they must play an active role as citizens in any political democracy. In such a system, democratic institutions can be created to reintegrate ownership and work and to foster sustainability and stability. Citizens can use their constitutionally granted powers of procedural and substantive democracy and see to it that such values become legally written into corporate charters for businesses in their communities. Basic economic institutions can and do work toward eliminating the long-standing antagonisms between owners and workers or buyers and sellers, and by embedding the institutions into the local community, citizens can achieve more stability and direct community-based democratic control. By doing so, the individual’s role in the economy expands and becomes more active and complex as the pragmatists and institutionalists envisioned. By becoming an integrated member of an economic community, much more responsibility is placed on the individual. This burden is, in part, the price one must pay for democracy. People will become not only employees and consumers, but also owners who must actively participate in the governance of their local economic institutions.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Alternative › Alternative – Spills Over—2NC

Individual action is necessary—the work of change must happen with ourselves as well as in our societies.

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

The scope of socially engaged Buddhism is not limited to peace activism and extends to a addressing a host of other dimensions to social and environmental malaise. Engagement is predicated on an awareness that suffering is not just an individual condition, but it is also systemic as it originates in social and ecological conditions that have allowed suffering to fester and become more complex in time. For the transformation toward wellbeing, social transformation must be part of the movement. The process of changing society first begins with work on the self yet remaining mindfully present with affecting social change. Zen master Philip Kapleau reflects on this, “To help people without hurting them at the same time, or hurting yourself, means that we must first work on ourselves.” He uses the term middle way as a kind of metaphor, “A Middle Way that alternates between the life of inward meditation and the life of action-in-the-world….”9

The dharma practice of socially engaged Buddhism can be seen as having two aspects, the inner work of individual transformation from suffering to wellbeing and the outer work of social transformation of suffering to wellbeing. Like all things in complex systems, there is a dual nature to our existence: our individual selves and our social selves that are inextricably tied to social structures. If the individual is a kind of social molecule, then social institutions and cultures are the higher-level structures. Change happens at both levels continuously, whether we intend so or not, in a complex and dialectic process of interplay between the social self and social formations.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Alternative › Material Solves—2NC

Through consumption focused economics, a mindset shift occurs—we’re not epistemic fiat

Brown 19 Clair Brown is an American economist who is Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Work, Technology, and Society at the University of California, Berkeley. Brown is a past Director of the Institute of Industrial Relations at UC Berkeley. Clair has published research on many aspects of how economies function, including the standard of living, wage determination, inequality, sustainability, high-tech industries, and development engineering. Her books include American Standards of Living: 1919-1988 and Buddhist Economics: An enlightened approach to the dismal science (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) “Buddhist Economics: The Foundation for an Equitable, Sustainable, Caring Economy” American Economic Association, January 5, 2019 ,$$G

Our economy needs to focus less on income growth and more on quality of life. Buddhist economics focuses on creating sustainable lifestyles that reduce wasteful consumption and reduce overwork so people have time to enjoy life and help one another. We want to change the culture so people care about shared prosperity, rather than about how much money they are making. We do not want to replicate individualistic motivations that create injustice and inequality, and instead want to create a culture that supports human rights and healthy ecosystems. In a Buddhist economy, more natural options will become the new norm. Time for social and creative activities allow us to enjoy life. Lavish consumption will seem as crazy as it is, as people become healthier and happier with natural living and as the planetary ecosystems heal. The good news is that our way of life can remain meaningful and worthy as our consumption and lifestyles become sustainable.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Alternative › Alt Solvency—2NC

Movements are solving right now—the alt brings attention to them and helps unite them

Barua 10, Dr. Dipen Barua is an honorary lecturer at the Centre for Buddhist Studies at The University of Hong Kong. He has authored a book and published several articles in Bengali and English, on the subject of Buddhist studies, women’s issues, Buddhism in South and Southeast Asia, and cultural heritage. BuddhistDoor Global, “Application Of Buddhist Economics In Prevention Of Global Credit Crisis” January 10, 2010, //$$G

At present, without the help from government and industry for boosting a new direction in policy, people are starting to change the economy from the bottom up towards more human-scale structures which are more consistent with the Buddhist viewpoint. This process of localization has begun spontaneously, in countless communities all around the world. Because economic localization means an adaptation to cultural and biological diversity, no single strategy would be applicable everywhere. [3,6]

The range of possibilities for local grassroots efforts is as diverse as the locales in which they take place. In many towns community banks and loan funds have been set up, thereby increasing the capital available to local residents and businesses. This system is promoting people to invest in their neighbors and their community, rather than in a faceless global economy. In other communities, ‘buy-local’ campaigns are helping locally owned businesses survive even when pitted against heavily subsidized corporate competitors. These campaigns not only help to keep money from leaking out of the local economy, but also help educate people about the hidden costs in purchasing cheaper, but distantly produced products.  [3,6]

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Alternative › Alt Solvency—2NC

Small political movements can complement or even solve for Buddhist economics—villages in Thailand prove that consumption based economics work—the alt just does that on a larger scale

Prayukvong et al 17, Wanna Prayukvong, is an associate professor at a rural branch campus of Mahidol University in Nakon Sawan, Thailand, Springer, “Clair Brown, Buddhist economics: an enlightened approach to the dismal science”, June 23, 2017, //$$G

Clair Brown’s Buddhist Economics: An Enlightened Approach to the Dismal Science takes a different approach from the first book-length attempt by a Westerner to explain why Buddhist economics can help meet contemporary human and environmental challenges. E. F. Schumacher’s Small Is Beautiful: Economics as if People Mattered (1973) recommended smallness for the sake of people and the natural environment. Brown is less focused on the economic implications of the scale of our institutions. Her concern is mindfulness and changing how we think about happiness, wealth, inequality, and the environment. She aims less to downsize business, government, and politics than to make them more Buddhist. For Brown, the use of Buddhist economics lies in measuring economic progress in terms of its effects on nature, on communities, and on the health of the human spirit. Mindfulness, nonviolence, and meditation create “inner wealth,” a sense of peace and happiness (p. 22). A more generous sense of our independence with nature and other people would enable us to see that a transfer of wealth can improve the well-being of all even though aggregate wealth does not go up. Awareness of our interdependence with nature would encourage us to “develop simpler, sustainable lifestyle” (p. 85). On the basis of these insights, Brown offers an 8-point plan for a “Leap to Buddhist Economics”—practicing sustainable agriculture, producing green products, living mindfully, collective action, and so on. When Brown talks about action she is referring to political action—the stuff of demonstrations, protests, electoral campaigns and so on. But for Buddhists it is also possible to take collective action in a sense that is not only political but more than political. There is an economic imperative for us to change our ways right now, in the present moment, not just as individuals but together, in groups. The fundamental spirit of Buddhism is the elimination of suffering by moving past attachment to objects of desire to mindfulness of our interdependence with other people and nature. The economic implications of this process have been fruitfully modeled by Serge-Christopher Kolm. According to Kolm, a Buddhist has to divide his time between consumption and meditation—consumption in order to survive and meditation in order to minimize the desire to consume. So what is the right balance between consumption and meditation? It is a “Middle Way” in which “the marginal productivity of labor involved in producing consumption is equal to the marginal efficacy of the meditation involved in economizing on consumption without altering satisfaction” (Kolm 1985, quoted in Zsolnai 2011, p. 5). Kolm’s focus on the economic trade-off between consumption and meditation suggests that the establishment of Buddhist institutions can be begun by small groups working at the local level. It is not necessary to wait until we have persuaded politicians, plutocrats, and others to change their hearts and their practices. In Thailand there is an incipient movement for “community mechanisms” to replace or at least complement the market mechanism. For example, lay members of the Ashoka monastery in Bangkok sell organic vegetables, cooking oil, tofu, and other essentials for a vegan diet at below market prices. Initially, the buyers were people in the surrounding community. But the movement has been so successful that the producers now sell in several locations which are open only a few hours a day in order to permit the producers and consumers to meet each other in person. Such personal contact helps sellers remember to set the price compassionately for the buyers and to explain the virtue of a vegan diet to them. It allows the consumers to offer personal support to the producers and to act in a spirit of appreciation for their organic products and their work protecting the earth. It is a way for all involved to raise and maintain their awareness of their interdependence with other people, other creatures, and the earth (Prayukvong 2006). Such community mechanisms might complement, not contradict, Brown’s idea of working together and taking action through campaigns, rallies, and protests. She writes approvingly of local initiatives to build bike paths, waste management systems, programs for elders and children. By also implanting Buddhist community mechanisms in local economic systems, people can help prepare themselves and others to transform and to work in the better macro level economy at which Brown aims. In other words, Buddhist economics, operating in the spirit of interdependence, will not separate macro and micro levels.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Framework › Framework Core—2NC

Economic institutions are merely a figure of complexity and interconnectedness—the self and their portrayal of it is their attempt to fit in the system. They must understand why their portrayal of the individual is uniquely bad for the system—capitalism survives through their attempts to justify it

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

John Dewey, arguably the most important figure in American pragmatism, was also critical of the M-C paradigm as a distorted representation of humanity. He was particularly critical of how social atomism is used in economic theory to justify asocial egoistic behavior. As atomism and individualism are dimensions of the same mechanistic paradigm, social atomism is the extension of this paradigm to characterize human social behavior as self-contained, asocial, and non-cultural—like pebbles or nuts and bolts. For Dewey and other pragmatists, however, a core aspect of human life is to be interactive and socially engaged, not contained in the cage of an atomistic, egoistic self. In their view, the individual is not a passive unit bumped into motion by external forces. Rather, it is fundamentally active and socially interactive in such a way that makes social context is as much a part of our being as our physical selves. The contours of individual engagement are shaped by social context, which includes habits of thought and habits of behavior that are passed down into the community through time by way of institutions. Such habits include those perpetuated by standard economics and the social atomism of homo economicus.

Dewey challenged the neoclassical assumption that it is human nature to be economically inactive unless spurred on by external stimuli. He joined Peirce and James in envisioning human behavior as intrinsically purposeful in a wide range of possible modes of development. He rejected the idea that human economic behavior is inert unless prompted by promise of utility or financial gain, “The idea of a thing intrinsically wholly inert in the sense of absolutely passive is expelled from physics and has taken refuge in the psychology of current economics.”23 Dewey also rejected the assumption that greed in economic behavior is human nature, “Those who attempt to defend the necessity of existing economic institutions [of capitalism] as manifestations of human nature convert this suggestion of a concrete inquiry into a generalized truth and hence into a definitive falsity.”24 Humans are much more socially malleable. Greed and endless striving for financial and material gain are socially constructed phenomena, potent but not deterministic, and are passed on from one generation to the next.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Institutionalized Economics/MMT—2NC

The attempt at “new economics” only further re-entrenches capitalism

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

For decades we have seen one economic initiative after another stepping forward promising to turn our social and environmental messes around. In the mid-1980s, for instance, a group of scholars convened for two conferences aimed at building a “New Economics” paradigm. The first was held in London, England in 1984 and the second was held in Bonn, Germany the following year. The goals set out for the new paradigm were to develop and promote an economic system that is centered on social justice, the satisfaction of a wide range of human needs, sustainable use of resources, and environmental conservation. The meetings were called The Other Economic Summit (TOES) to symbolize a clean break from the business-as-usual Group of Seven meetings or World Economic Forums. TOES addressed a spectrum of economic issues that were becoming increasingly exigent such as the problem of trying to achieve endless economic growth within the confines of a finite planet, the widening income and wealth gap between the world’s rich and poor, the need for economic indicators that could better assess human wellbeing than gross domestic product (GDP), chronic unemployment, access to education and health care services for the world’s population, alternative business models, alternative systems of finance and trade, gender equality, and tax policies. The conference presentations were compiled, edited by conference organizer and economist Paul Ekins, and a year later published in a book titled, The Living Economy: A New Economics in the Making (1986).

This was followed by a host of a new economics proposals. Among the pioneers were Paul Hawken, Frances Cairncross, Amory and Hunter L. Lovins, Jonathan Porrit, Lester R. Brown, James “Gus” Speth, and others. Of the next two decades the like-minded economists launched a library of information in books: Costing the Earth (1992), Ecological Commerce (1993), Natural Capitalism (1999), Eco-Economy (2001), Capitalism as if the World Mattered (2005), and the Green Collar Economy (2009). The core message in all this work is summarized by Yale economist and founder of the National Resource Defense Council, Gus Speth, as an articulation of the notion that, “the market can be transformed into an instrument for environmental restoration; the incentives that govern corporate behavior can be rewritten; growth can be focused on things that truly need to grow and consumption on having enough, not always more; and the rights of future generations and other species can be respected.”14 As this “new economics” vision continued to gain momentum, market-oriented eco-entrepreneurship expanded with differentiated green product identities, conventional products were rebranded as to be seen as sustainable to stay ahead of market saturation. At the same time, there was an explosion of socially responsible investment funds, or SRIs, which later morphed into impact investing

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Institutionalized Economics/MMT—2NC

The affs view that economics is a system that is mechanically integrated into all of our lives only perpetrates neoliberalism. Changing the paradigm through MMT only misdirects the true issue of neoliberalism away from itself once again, by burying institutionalized greed—if we win the link we win serial policy failure

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

As we saw in the last chapter, the progressive changes brought by the emergence of capitalism and the corporate system gave rise to the need for a new economic paradigm. With the collapse of the institutions of feudalism and the development of the Commercial Revolution, a new paradigm of social order that was more conducive to capitalism and the individual accumulation of wealth ascended. As the authoritarian and paternalistic view of economics of the Church scholars began to fade, economic individualism and self-interest arose to take its place, complete with an emphasis on normalizing greed as the drive of economic productivity. As the Buddha warned, greed, hatred, and delusion are pathologies that lie at the foundation of much human suffering, and with the institutional and ideological development of capitalism, these pathologies became institutionalized and normalized in modern culture. Socially engaged Buddhism thus faces the challenge of recognizing that the three fires are not only in our hearts but are writ large as destructive social phenomenon. It also faces the challenge of changing the social conditions that perpetuate these fires and their destructiveness. The order business in this chapter is to look carefully at the paradigm underlying standard economics which serves as an instrument to perpetuate greed-centered economics by ignoring society altogether with ideology masked as science.

Modern capitalist economics is based in part on the notion that there are no such things as social structures, only individual producers and consumers pursuing self-interest in the open field of the marketplace. This notion dates to the very beginnings of capitalism four hundred years ago when the market system began its dramatic and rapid expansion. In this view, it is the nature of humanity to feel the need to be free from restrictions in the open market in order to pursue unlimited wealth accumulation. Against the authoritarian and paternalistic structure of feudalism and the church, the market system began to foster a different sensibility in which the individual ought to be independent a unit distinguished from the social mass rather than submerged in it. As an institutional requirement, the capitalist market system needs self-seeking, acquisitive behavior to function. Early modern theorists began to assert that such egoistic inclinations were the primary, if not the only, motivations that would compel an otherwise passive individual into productive action. Through individual actions, completely disconnected from one another, the natural tendency is for everything to balance and move in harmony like planetary orbits—all of which guided by the superstition of the “invisible hand.”

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Reform—2NC

The affs “sweeping legislation” doesn’t actually do anything—it makes people believe help is on the way while discouraging radical movements. Only grassroots movements can let us truly institute large scale and true social change.

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

Building new economic institutions at the local level and having the work infused with a set of ethics to guide us is where the rubber meets the road for Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics. Without these, there is only theorizing. The project ultimately is about redrawing the institutional map of the economy. By this, we mean actively mapping out a new set of institutions that are fully integrated and cohere systemically. This involves envisioning systemic change from both the bird’s-eye view of the whole system and the worm’s-eye view of the specific institutional parts. Such change will require not only changing how we see our economy, it will also require fundamentally changing how we go about our daily work of producing, distributing, and consuming goods and services. Bringing this vision to reality requires a willingness to accept the fact that the economic activity going forward will be radically different from the one we have now—which is what the IPCC is telling us we have no choice but to do.

Proposing an economy that is radical different is not the same thing as proposing revolutionary ideology. It is practically inconceivable that a massive Twenty-plus-trillion-dollar economy can be fundamentally altered in a peaceful or meaningful way through a sudden revolutionary catharsis. Bringing our vision of a mindful economy to a reality will also require much hard work and patience. What is more conceivable and practical than cathartic revolution is a process of implementing real economic change in small incremental steps beginning with the development of locally based alternative institutions. Capitalism and all other major economic systems that have existed historically were originally small and localized systems. In a mindful economy, smaller-scale local economic systems are not enclaves of economic utopias or communes, they are merely the starting places from which a broader and more comprehensive system can evolve and grow.

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Green Tech—2NC

Faith in technology is a unique link—it justifies endless growth through the attempt to decouple, but in reality continues far towards extinction and is terminally unsustainable.

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

In a previous chapter, we took a critical look at the multitude of promises made over the last three or four decades that our economic system can simultaneously produce sustainability, climate change mitigation, and hefty incomes for all. Books and articles with such promises continue to get trotted out will a certain regularity with doing well while doing good as the core message. While we have been telling ourselves this for a very long time, yet the conditions for creating global warming have worsened steadily and unabated. Proponents of so-called green capitalism argue that the reason for this is that the suggestions have never been properly implemented. The reason for that, however, is that they are contradicting goals. Capitalism is a system that is programmed for continuous growth, and continuous growth is the opposite of sustainability. In the previous three chapters, we explored the problems of a declining resource base and environmental destruction, rising inequality, and financial market instability. To a significant degree, these problems are the destructive consequences of the capitalist system’s relentless drive for profits and growth. We saw that environmental degradation and resource depletion are the direct consequences of the growth imperative that is inherent in the capitalist system, and any serious reflection on continuous growth must inevitably lead to the conclusion that it cannot be sustained. We saw that stark inequalities of wealth and income are also inherent features of a capitalist economy, and any serious reflection on principles of social justice, fairness, or democracy must lead to the conclusion that such inequalities are also not sustainable. Finally, we saw that a chief cause of financial market instability is speculative buying and selling, which are inherent features of capitalism, and any serious consideration on how to avoid another financial crisis must lead to the conclusion that this speculation cannot be sustained. That these problems are both systemic and unsustainable indicates that comprehensive change will be inevitable. Given that such change is inevitable, we must consider whether we want to bring about change in a thoughtful and careful way, or have it thrust upon us in the form of a continuous series of massive economic and environmental crises. In a mindful economy, we seek to avoid debilitating crises and set out to follow a thoughtful and careful path toward change. Throughout the years between 1980 and 2005 there was a general assumption that technology was going to transform economic production in ways that would require fewer resources. This included the so-called “New Economy” years of the 1990s in which the U.S. economy was supposed to be shifting to a resource-light “information economy.” Computers and the internet were supposed to make us efficient and help us save on material resources, but the result was the opposite. During that twenty-five-year period, the consumption of materials in North America increased many times over whereas increased by a much slower rate. This means that material consumption per person has steadily risen without regard for the carrying capacity of the planet. Information technology served to pick up the pace of globalization and economic expansion such that consumers were able to devour ever-larger quantities of our planet and spewed ever-larger quantities of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Endless growth on a finite planet is not possible. Among the first to raise this issue in economic discourse was Kenneth Boulding with his 1966 essay, “The Economics of the Coming Spaceship Earth.” Boulding warned that the relationship we have with the planet is going to change.11 His message was primarily directed at his fellow economists who see the national economy as a super machine that rolls out ever larger quantities of things for consumers to buy. The economists have been correct about this machine up to now. Aside from recessions that occur now and then, the machine has been running nonstop. Boulding’s warning was that such a perpetual growth machine will eventually slam against a wall of limitations to growth imposed on us by the laws of nature and physics. He concluded that a rather more sobering and realistic image would be to see ourselves as passengers on a spacecraft, which implies that our survival depends on how we use the finite and limited provisions that are stored on the ship. One aspect of the scenario Boulding missed in the spaceship metaphor is that we are not only using up our provisions we are toxifying the ship’s internal atmosphere. But that was when scientists were just beginning to form their hypotheses about the effects of elevated levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Over five decades have passed since Boulding wrote his essay and the economics profession remains captured by the myth of the everlasting growth machine. Though economists acknowledge that resources are scarce and finite, they assume that the machine will always be kept running with the support of new technologies. This is like believing in magic or the transmutation powers of alchemy. Ancient alchemists were obsessed with discovering the elixir of longevity. In addition to their fascination with trying to turn lead into gold, they sought tirelessly to find a substance that could keep restoring the human body to youth so that they could live forever. In a similar way, economists hold on to the belief that technology is a magic elixir that will allow the growth machine to defy the immutable laws of physics and expand forever. The general belief is that as we bring one important resource to exhaustion, we will always be able to concoct new resources with new technology, and when those resources are exhausted, others will be invented to replace them, and so on into infinite growth. Whenever they are called on to address the physical limits to economic growth, economists inevitably turn to the technology-willsolve-it arguments. Most economists would admit that things like turning lead to gold or eternal life are scientifically not possible, but for them such science apparently does not apply to economic growth. In the Buddhist view of the three fires of greed, hatred, and delusion this could very well be the premier delusion of our time. It is a delusion defended fiercely with a certain wrath as it the last line of defense for the argument of why there is nothing wrong with greed—institutionalized or otherwise. Technology will be an important part of our efforts to cope with the economic and ecological issues that confront us. It provides hope and possibilities. Not many of us would advocate that we should allow our productive technology to regress back to premodern standards. Technology can and does lead to effective solutions and this should not be ignored, but technology is always fostered within a specific institutional context, and this should not be ignored either. If our institutions are warlike, then we will develop weapons technology. If our institutions are oriented toward economic growth for growth’s sake, then we will develop technology that serves that purpose. If they are oriented toward social provisioning and genuine sustainability, then we will develop technology that leads to provisioning and sustainability. Without a critical perspective, belief in technology becomes an irrational faith that every problem we face will always have a technological fix. Like a secular religion, blind faith in technology provides comfort and reassurance in the delusion that perpetual growth is possible. The appropriateness of technology should be assessed mindfully, and with a critical understanding of kinds of institutions fosters its development. Recall the IPCC 2018 report in which it warned that to avoid the worst-case scenario “would require rapid and far-reaching transitions in energy, land, urban and rural infrastructure (including transport and buildings), and industrial systems.” The message is that we have no choice now but to move toward a very different type of economic system from what we have, and one that will foster technologies that are yet to be imagined. If the IPCC is correct, the biggest obstacle is to mitigate global warming’s effects is institutional, then institutional change has to be the solution. This means creating new social structures that will script our social behavior with entirely different rules, norms, and codes. If done with insight, wisdom, and a wholesome set of beliefs about our relationships with nature and each other, then our survival as a species is possible. This will also require a transformation of our mindset, expectations, and what we consider to be the good life. This is a tall order. But as Paul Rogat Loeb reminds us, “the impossible will take a little while,” and in fact the process is already happening.2

2023 Michigan Kritik
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP › Links › Link—Generic—2NC

Modern, capitalistic, economics makes the human into a being that is pushed around by the system, by perpetrating the fear of lack—the aff only feeds into that desire for more, causing endless environmental destruction

Magnuson 22, Joel Magnuson is an Affiliated Professor of Economics at Portland State University. He is the author of many books, as well as numerous articles in journals and anthologies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. His research interests include mindful economics, Buddhist economics, and institutional reform. “The Dharma and Socially Engaged Buddhist Economics”, , March 17, 2022, ,$$G

When we approach global warming from the individualistic (social atomism) perspective, the tendency is to argue that consumerism is the mother of all environmental problems. If people would just stop demanding so much stuff, so the argument goes, we would not be putting so much strain on the environment. As we emphasized here, greed and acquisitiveness, stem from deluded sense of self-attachment. In the Buddhist view, the ontology of self is emptiness. To those who have become self-attached, this is feared in the same way people fear the dark void of death. From this fearful existential state arises a kind of grasping or clinging ego. In a turn of mind from Descartes, the fearful ego may assert “I grasp, therefore I exist.” What do we grasp onto? This is anything and everything that could give a sense of being grounded. In Western cultures, this often takes the form of grasping onto money, possessions, and power. It could also be holding onto narratives, other people, careers. David Loy refers to these as “lack projects” (because we believe they will fill up our sense of lack) or “reality projects (because we believe they will makeus feel more real).”15 Consumerism is a term widely used to express lack projects that have grown into a sociological phenomenon.

The generally accepted view of consumerism, particularly in American culture, is that consumers are sovereign in the marketplace. Most proponents as well as critics of capitalism hold the belief that instinctive consumer demand is the prime mover in the basic economic processes. That is, consumers will express their demands in the markets and businesses dutifully follow. Proponents argue that growth serves to satisfy the demands of people, and critics argue that people are selfishly, or perhaps unwittingly, creating their own destruction with excessive demands. In either view, the line of causality begins with consumption and consumption drives production. There is truth in the assertion that consumerism and self-attachment are key elements in the creation of global warming. But we need to also see that the self-attached consumer is a product of social conditioning.