2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Inevitable---Link---2AC
McMeekin 23 [David, McMeekin, David is a Junior Research Fellow in Physics and a Marie Skłodowska-Curie Fellow at the University of Oxford. "The Inevitable Energy Transition", 03/10/2023, St Edmund Hall, . | czx]
We have just marked the anniversary of the devastating and senseless Russo-Ukrainian conflict. The invasion has taken the lives of tens of thousands on both sides of the conflict and created more than 8 million Ukrainians refugees. The current conflict has caused a major shift in global and European geopolitical tensions. This led to major Russian pipelines supplying Europe with gas to be shutdown. Nord Stream 1 pipeline, which normally supplies approximately 35% of all the gas to European Union States imported from Russia, has completely closed in late August 2022. Furthermore, Germany has recently halted the certification of Nord Stream 2, which was completed in 2021. In turn, energy prices have soared due to restrictions imposed on Russian imports of natural gas and other fossil fuels. This spike in energy prices and, more importantly, the sudden realisation that Europe’s energy policies are at the mercy of a handful of countries has further emphasised the need for countries to become energetically self-sufficient. An obvious solution to this energy catastrophe partially resides in a transition towards sustainable and renewable energy sources. Solar energy is the most abundant energy resource on earth and available in every country. Transitioning towards renewable energies has previously been difficult due to the need for direct or indirect government subsidies to support initial adoption of emerging technologies. However, this is no longer the case, where unsubsidised utility-scale bids for wind and solar projects have come in at lower price ranges than gas or coal projects, which have long been regarded as the lowest Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE). According to the Lazard’s report, utility-scale renewables are now below coal generation prices, where unsubsidised wind prices ranged from 28 to 54 USD/MWh, while utility-scale solar ranged from 32 to 42 USD/MWh, compared to coal priced at 66 to 152 USD/MWh, and gas combined cycle at 44 to 68 USD/MWh. Enabling this cost-competitiveness has triggered an inevitable energy transition from fossil fuel-based technologies to renewables. This transition is no longer an environmentalist’s pipe dream, but rather a current reality, which now has been accelerated by the soaring energy cost caused by the current geopolitical conflict. A viable, abundant and now relatively cheap source of energy is solar power. To date, crystalline silicon-based (c-Si) photovoltaics have dominated the solar market. Although c-Si-based solar cells have been around for many decades, they have only been truly cost-effective in the most recent decade. In the late 1990s, universities, research institutes and industrial partners have developed crystalline silicon technology to reach a 25% power conversion efficiency milestone. From that point forward, the world record efficiency has only risen to 26.7%, as we are approaching a theoretical limit of 33.16% for a single-junction solar cell, known as the “Shockley–Queisser limit”. Hence, it is becoming increasingly difficult to improve the efficiency of the conventional crystalline silicon solar cell. Recent cost reductions in solar energy have mainly been achieved by advancements in manufacturing techniques and reaching economies of scale. As silicon-based solar cells efficiencies converge towards their maximum theoretical limit, price reductions will soon become increasingly difficult to achieve. However, multi-junction architectures can overcome the single-junction efficiency limit, by absorbing distinct portions of the solar spectrum using materials with different band gaps, leading to an increase in solar cell efficiency. These architectures allow for a reduction in photon thermalisation losses; a loss mechanism that occurs when a high energy photon partially converts its energy to heat instead of transferring it to an electron. Multi-junction solar cells are formed by mechanically stacking, on top of one another, two or more solar cells with different band gaps, allowing each junction to absorb different portions of the solar spectrum. A relatively small increase in performance, obtained by transitioning towards multi-junction architectures, could lead to significantly lower solar energy prices, since the other major costs such as land rights, installation, and inverters should remain constant. A generic ABX3 metal-halide perovskite unit cell forming a cubic structure A strong candidate for multi-junctions are metal-halide perovskite solar cells, which form in a generic ABX3 crystal structure, where the A-site is typically an organic or inorganic cation, the B-site is a divalent metal cation, and the X-site a halide anion. Although perovskites materials have been discovered since the 19th century, perovskite structures have only emerged for solar application in the last decade or so. Oxide-based perovskite crystal structures occur abundantly in nature, with approximately 38% of the earth’s volume forming in a perovskite crystal structure. However, here in the Clarendon Laboratories, we focus our efforts on researching and developing halide-based perovskites, which form crystal structures that are particularly good at absorbing light, while maintaining long charge-carrier lifetimes with the semiconductors. Furthermore, we can fabricate metal-halide perovskite solar cells with various band gaps by tuning their chemical composition. The band gap of a semiconductor represents the energy required to promote an electron from the valence band to the conduction band, thus creating a “free-electron” that can move freely within the crystal lattice. This process occurs after a photon with enough energy gets absorbed by the perovskite material. Using specific materials or dopants, these free-electrons can then be extracted at their respective electrodes to create photogenerated current and voltage. A cross-sectional scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of an all-perovskite multi-junction solar cell The ability to tune their band gap makes metal-halide perovskite solar cells a perfect candidate for multi-junction solar cells. Perovskite-silicon tandems and/or all-perovskite multi-junction solar cells, may certainly be the next technological advancement in the photovoltaic roadmap, however, their long-term stability has yet to match conventional silicon-based technology. Hence, in the photovoltaic and optoelectronic group, located in Oxford’s Condensed Matter Physics (CMP) department, we are constantly trying to find new perovskite materials, architectures, or deposition techniques that improve the overall stability of these solar cells to make them commercially viable. As the cost of photovoltaic energy has plummeted, countries now have the option to lessen their dependence on fossil fuels, along with the countries that control these resources. Energy self-sufficiency has become a major policy concern since the start of the Russo-Ukrainian conflict. The energy policy change from non-renewable fossil-fuel based sources towards low carbon emission-based renewables is inevitable considering the economic advantages renewables now have to offer. Hence, in my opinion, along with the emergence of cheaper energy storage, it is not a question of “if”, but rather a question of “when” the world will change to a combination of renewable energy sources. However, citizens, politicians and scientists can significantly accelerate this change to mitigate the impact of climate change.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: GND---Link---2AC
Nick Sammarco 23, a sophomore economics major. "There’s nothing green about the Green New Deal," Suffolk Journal, https://thesuffolkjournal.com/26946/opinion/theres-nothing-green-about-the-green-new-deal/, accessed 7-12-2023 | AKG
The metaphorical nail in the coffin to any hopes the GND has at stopping climate change is that global fossil fuel consumption is set to massively increase, not decrease, in the coming decades. As The Economist reported in February, oil giants around the world are preparing to drill and ship more oil and natural gas, even as renewable energy becomes cheaper and more accessible. Exxon-Mobil alone is expecting a 25% increase in production in 2025 compared to 2017. The oil giants vision for the world years from now stands in stark contrast from the myopic vision of world Ocasio-Cortez presents us for a good reason. They know something she obviously does not: any cut in U.S. carbon emissions would be replaced in the future by foreign emissions, and then multiplied to levels the U.S. couldn’t ever imagine reaching. For instance, the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) estimates North American oil demand falling precipitously from now to 2040, but that fall in oil demand will immediately be made up by increased demand from the rest of the world. OPEC estimates that worldwide demand for crude oil is set to increase by 15.8 million barrels a day (mb/d) by 2040, even accounting for renewable energy advancement. China and India lead the pack in projected additional consumption (6.0 mb/d and 5.9 mb/d respectively).The developing nations of the world, mainly located in Africa and Asia, will account for an astounding 23.8 mb/d increase in oil production (more than current North American oil demand levels). There is little incentive for countries like China to slow their oil consumption, and there is virtually no incentive for developing nations to stop buying oil. According to the Institutional for Energy Research, an estimated 60% of China’s energy is produced via coal. I can’t see China kowtowing to the whims of Ocasio-Cortez.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: Middle East---Uniqueness---2AC
Qusay Hassan 23 [Febuary 23 Mohammed Al-Hitmi - Vahid Sohrabi Tabar - Aws Zuhair Sameen - Hayder M. Salman - Marek Jaszczur – Research Journal “Middle East energy consumption and potential renewable sources: An overview” NPAT ]
4.1. Potential wind energy Wind energy is the conversion of renewable energy into a form of energy that can be used. As a replacement for fossil fuels, wind energy is plentiful, renewable, widely available, clean, does not release greenhouse gases when it is made, and only needs a small amount of land (Hassan, 2020). The intensity of the wind fluctuates, therefore, an average number for numerous places in the Middle East does not reflect the amount of electricity a wind turbine may generate anywhere. Frequently, a probability density curve is fitted to observable data to determine the frequency of wind speeds in a given place. Wind speed distributions at various sites are very different (Jaszczur et al., 2019). Typically, winds near the ground are used to generate electricity, winds at higher elevations are faster and steadier, and their is worldwide potential. In recent times, major advancements have been made in the technology used to produce power from high-altitude winds. Wind energy is the potential energy associated with mass movement. Wind energy systems transform this kinetic energy into more practical kinds of energy. Compared to conventional fuels, the electricity generated by wind power systems emits less carbon dioxide. Consequently, it has a lower greenhouse impact. In addition, wind energy creates numerous employments. It should be emphasised that comparing the wind direction across several locations simultaneously is quite challenging. In this study, data mapping software (GIS) was used to make more informed decisions on wind feasibility studies. Since there were no wind data for any of the relevant possible sites, constant wind data and wind power densities were used to estimate the potential for renewable energy in areas without wind speed data. Three GIS maps are produced for the Middle East, using the average wind speed and wind battery capacity at two different heights. Different colors on the GIS map represent the wind velocity and specific power at each place. On the other hand, the various categories of wind speed and specific power could be highlighted in red for better conditions. Additionally, locations with low wind speed and power density are highlighted in green. Notice that the wind data throughput is at a height of 10 m. To facilitate a more accurate comparison of wind data from different stations and to account for wind shear, wind data have been estimated at a height of 50 m. As seen in Fig. 22 and 23, the eastern, southern and southeast parts of the Middle East have a high potential for the installation of wind turbines. These locations are known for their strong wind speeds. According to these maps, the central parts of Iran and the southern parts of Saudi Arabia have significant promise. Some of these areas are better suited for restricted applications, such as wind-powered cooling systems. ArcGIS can be used to locate potential locations for wind turbine installation, taking into account aspects such as proximity to cities, highways, and other needs (IMAGE OMMITED) Potential wind speed at 10 m (GIS map). Fig. 22 reveal that the power density at a height of 10 m is about 188 W/m2. From these numbers, the regions with the highest density of wind energy at a height of 10 m include central Iran and parts of Oman. Other nations, including Iraq, Kuwait, Jordan, and Lebanon, have a lower energy density. There is a significant potential value of energy output, modest wind turbines may be used, and smaller turbines can offer energy to rural regions with relative ease. Although this number climbs to around 520 W/m2 at a height of 50 m, which is considered an excellent wind location as presented in Fig. 23. Fig. 23 (GRAPH OMMITED) Potential wind speed at 50m (GIS map). There is a significant power concentration capacity at 50 m; consequently, large wind turbines can be constructed to supply energy to rural and urban regions and link to regional power systems. 4.2. Potential solar energy Solar energy is the direct or indirect conversion of irradiance into energy using photovoltaic or concentrating solar energy. Concentrated solar energy systems employ mirrors or lenses and tracking systems to condense radiation from a vast region into a narrow beam (Kabir et al., 2018). Solar energy is clean, renewable, and globally accessible. Solar energy may be used in several ways, including (Jaszczur et al., 2018; Hassan et al., 2022c): Produce energy with the use of photovoltaic solar cells; produce hydrogen using fuel cells; Produce hot and cold air using solar chimneys; Produce hot water using solar geysers. In addition to the benefits of renewable energy, solar energy has the following additional advantages (Hassan et al., 2022d). Restoration of degraded lands; less focus on the national electricity grid; Improve water quality throughout the country; and expand remote area electricity. The daily total worldwide horizontal radiation GIS map for the Middle East is displayed in Fig. 24. Solar radiation intensity is color-coded on GIS maps. Thus, regions with superior circumstances are indicated by hues that are closer to the color red. As places approach low levels of radiation, the color of the marker changes to green. According to the GIS maps shown in Fig. 24, the quantity of radiation generally increases as one moves from north to south. This is because the latitude decreases on this route, bringing it closer to the equator. Fig. 24 Fig. 24. Potential solar radiation (GIS map). 5. Middle East towards renewable energy The Middle East has benefited greatly from its large oil and gas deposits for many years. Fossil fuels have been the most affordable alternative for many due to their low cost of production and a lack of regulations to encourage the use of other sources of energy, which explains the region delayed adoption of sustainable energy. In recent years, there have been more projects to boost renewable energy, which shows that the countries in the area are moving toward more sustainable options. An increase in initiatives to encourage renewable energy sources indicates that the area is progressively moving toward sustainable options.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: Russia Oil---Uniqueness---2AC
Karacan et al. 21 – Department of Economy at Kocaeli University, Department of Economics at Baku Engineering University, Faculty of Economics and International Relations at Vistula University, Department of Social Work at Uskudar University, Department of Business Administration at Hitit University, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences at Kocaeli University (Ridvan Karacan, Shahriyar Mukhtarov, Ismail Baris, Aykut Isleyen, Mehmet Emin Yardimci“The Impact of Oil Price on Transition toward Renewable Energy Consumption? Evidence from Russia,” MDPI, 5-19-2021, Available Online: https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/14/10/2947, Accessed: 7-11-2023)//ILake- EN
Russia has great potential in terms of energy production dependent on fossil fuels. However, fossil fuel resources, which are already limited during this period when the population and needs are growing rapidly, are declining every day. In addition, the damage caused by fossil fuels to the environment and human health has begun to be better understood. Realizing this situation, the global energy industry has entered a new structuring process in terms of obtaining energy and has turned to renewable energy sources as an alternative. However, Russia has not yet made satisfactory progress on this issue. What is the reason for Russia’s slow progress, while many developed countries have made significant progress? The study was conducted to find the answer to this question, because Russia needs renewable energy policies in which it can compete on equal runs in the future in terms of the sustainability of its current energy superiority. In order to test the need for a sustainable energy policy, it is necessary to first examine the country’s energy production and consumption.
As well as being the biggest global crude oil producer, Russia holds the second place in dry natural gas production too. In addition, Russia produces large quantities of coal. Russia’s economy is highly reliant on hydrocarbons, with oil and gas revenues accounting for more than 33% of federal budget revenues [33].
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: Russia Oil---Uniqueness---2AC
Pagliaro 20 [Mario Pagliaro Research Director at Italy's Research Council, Mario Pagliaro is a chemistry and energy scholar based in Palermo, Italy, where he leads a focusing on nanochemistry, sustainability and the bioeconomy. 04 October 2020 Renewable energy in Russia: A critical perspective “https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ese3.820 NPAT]
The reason for which Russia will shortly emerge as a leading country in new energy technology based on renewable power generation and energy storage in Li-ion battery and solar hydrogen, I argue in this study, is of economic and industrial nature. As countries increasingly replace thermoelectric power generation with solar and wind power, the demand of gas-fired turbines has gone from over 71.6 GW to less than 30 GW in 2018,39 and this regardless of increased energy consumption. Under these conditions, and with BEVs now replacing ICE vehicles at quick pace, becoming a leading country in clean energy technology for Russia's economy becomes an inevitable option. Aware that solar PV generation is the cheapest way to generate electricity, governments across the world in 2018 auctioned 81 GW of PV power out of about 100 GW installed globally. In 2019, the amount of power contracts through a competitive procurement rose to 90 GW out of 114 GW installed.40 In 2018, only seven countries installed between 1 and 5 GW of PV power, but by 2022 the number of such countries is expected to almost triple to 19.40 The country currently lags behind in solar cell, Li-ion battery, wind turbine, and hydrogen fuel cells manufacturing but it excels in practically all fields of science, with numerous milestone achievements in the areas of physics, chemistry, mathematics, aerospace, medicine, and engineering. As put it by Hargittai, “there is no other city in the world that has so many memorials honoring scientists as Moscow.”41 According to Russian scholars writing about Li-ion battery manufacturing in Russia, “the current level of competences, technologies, and production volumes in the Russian Federation does not meet the needs of modern and future markets”.42 Yet, neither “competences” nor “technologies” can be a problem to scale-up Li-ion battery manufacturing in a country excelling in virtually all fields of today's science and advanced technology in fields far more complex than battery technology such as avionics, aerospace, and nuclear energy. To unleash its potential in clean energy technology manufacturing, Russia needs to develop its own national solar cell, Li-ion battery, and hydrogen fuel cell industries, reinvesting part of the huge revenues coming from oil and natural gas sales abroad into developing the national clean energy technology industry. One single example renders said potential. Russia's sole solar cell and PV module manufacturer was established in 2009 by government-owned Rusnano technology group in Novocheboksarsk. In 2018, the company (Hevel) started shipments of its new heterojunction solar modules replacing thin film modules not only to Russia's customers, but also to customers in Sweden, Thailand, Kazakhstan, and other countries.43 By mid 2019, the company completed the expansion of its heterojunction solar module production capacity from 160 to 260 MW annually. Though minuscule in volume in comparison with the yearly output of just one of the single top ten PV manufacturers (all based in China, with the first alone having delivered more than 11 GW of solar modules only in 2018),44 the new production line yields also 460 W bifacial modules comprised of 144 half-cut bifacial cells. On 1 July 2019, Hevel connected to the grid a 25 MW solar park in Yelshanskaya (Figure 1). All components of the power plant, including the inverters and support structures, were produced in Russia. Alone, the plant produces over 30 million kWh every year, saving the equivalent of 4 million m3 of natural gas. The competing dynamics of oil price, economic growth, and oil extraction costs require that by 2025, even keeping the oil fraction in the global energy mix at the 2015 low level of approximately 33%, more than 11 additional million barrels per day will have to be added to current oil production levels.45 Furthermore, this exceptional amount of extra oil should be available at low extraction costs. In brief, driven by socioeconomic and energy global drivers, mankind has in the switch to producing energy from renewable energy sources the only alternative to an energy crisis that would drive social and economic unrest.45 In this context, the widespread uptake of decentralized solar energy systems in the built environment on a truly global scale is now a realistic objective for all world's countries.46 Even in Moscow's huge (962 ha) Kuzminki-Lyublino urban park, for instance, 228 out of 505 existing lamps are ready to be replaced by solar street LED lights equipped with Li-ion batteries.47 The buildup of Russia's clean energy technology industry will require proper planning, rationalization efforts, and the development of creative and effective policies, which will include new educational initiatives in today's solar energy science and technology,48 and energy management.49 Addressing the delegates of the 1920 All-Russia Congress of Soviets Ulianov (Lenin) said: “Communism is Soviet government plus the electrification of the whole country”.50 One century later, with Russia fully electrified since decades and renewable energy technologies soon to power vehicles, buildings, and industries, Lenin's insight into the future might be reformulated as follows: “Russia's economy is its clean energy industry on the scale required by being the world's largest country”.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: Russia Economy---Uniqueness---2AC
Cooban 23 – Global markets writer, leads international coverage of market news, reports on shifts in business and global economy (Anna Cooban, “US has replaced Russia as Europe's top crude oil supplier,” CNN, 3-28-2023, Available Online: https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/28/energy/eu-us-oil-imports-overtake-russia/index.html, Accessed: 7-19-2023)//DD- ILake-EN
The United States is now the biggest supplier of crude oil to the European Union.
In December, 18% of the bloc’s crude imports came from America, EU data office Eurostat said Tuesday.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › AT: Russia Economy---Uniqueness---2AC
Rosenberg and Nostrand 23 – Elizabeth Rosenberg, Assistant Secretary for Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes, Eric Van Nostrand, Acting Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy (U.S. Department of the Treasury, “The Price Cap on Russian Oil: A Progress Report,” 5-18-2023, Available Online: https://home.treasury.gov/news/featured-stories/the-price-cap-on-russian-oil-a-progress-report, Accessed: 7-12-2023)// DD- ILake-EN
A year ago at the G7 Summit in Elmau, the leaders agreed to pursue a policy to cap the price of Russian oil to prevent Russia from continuing to earn a wartime premium. The price cap policy is a novel tool of economic statecraft designed to achieve two seemingly contradictory goals: restricting Russia’s oil revenues while maintaining the supply of Russian oil. Meeting these goals would make it harder for Russia to fund its brutal war in Ukraine while keeping energy costs down for consumers and businesses around the world. Nearly six months after implementation, the price cap is achieving both goals. We will continue to monitor dynamics in the global oil market going forward and adjust as necessary in support of these goals.
Russian exports have continued to flow, contributing to global oil market stability. Even as global oil prices have remained stable, the price of Russian oil has fallen significantly—driving down the Kremlin’s revenue. Immediately after the invasion, Russia received windfall profits on an oil price spike created by its war in Ukraine. But today, the price cap policy is taking that windfall off the table, which allows for low- and middle- income countries to purchase oil while at the same time making it increasingly challenging for Russia to finance its aggression.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Prices Thumper---Uniqueness---2AC
Borgen Project, ND, "Renewable Energy in Saudi Arabia," //ecam
You either get ahead [of changing weather patterns] or you are going to be buried by it,” suggested Saudi Arabia’s Climate Change Envoy at the COP27 conference in December 2022. This underscored the continued push toward renewable energy in Saudi Arabia as part of its Vision 2030 plan. Despite possessing around 17% of the world’s petroleum reserves, Saudi Arabia has considered diversifying its energy mix through investments in green technology and using its natural abundance of wind and sunlight. However, levels of crude oil production currently remain unchanged.
Saudi Arabia’s Circular Carbon Economy
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
Gross ’20 – (Samantha, Director of Energy Security and Climate Initiative, “Why are fossil fuels so hard to quit?” Brookings, June 2020,
Fossil fuels allowed us to move away from relying on today’s solar flows, instead using concentrated solar energy stored over millions of years. Before we could make efficient use of solar flows, this seemed like a great idea.
However, the advantages of fossil fuels come with a devastating downside. We now understand that the release of carbon dioxide (CO2) from burning fossil fuels is warming our planet faster than anything we have seen in the geological record. One of the greatest challenges facing humanity today is slowing this warming before it changes our world beyond recognition.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
Rob Alexander, 18, ecological economist with research interests in bioeconomic modeling and the economics of biodiversity conservation, taught water economics at the United Nations Environmental Program, worked on conservation issues at Kruger National Park, and worked with the State Forestry Administration of China on the economics of tiger conservation. One of the first to apply multispecies modeling to terrestrial bioeconomic models, currently working on determining the conditions under which trade may support the conservation of endangered species, taught for 10 years at Massey University in New Zealand and for 12 years at Sweet Briar College in Central Virginia."Would transitioning to renewable energy hurt the economy?," Kenyon Alumni Magazine, https://bulletin.kenyon.edu/article/would-transitioning-to-renewable-energy-hurt-the-economy/
The question is not whether we should transition to renewable energy, but whether the transition we must undertake will provide a net economic benefit or cost. As it turns out, the transition to renewable energy is likely to result in a net economic gain for our society.
That does not mean that every individual will benefit, nor that the transition will be without pain, but it does mean that the transition is likely to result in net economic growth, more jobs and a more efficient and resilient system of electricity production.
A recent study by the Risky Business Project provides a framework for an approach that is both technically and economically feasible. It is based on three principle transitions: shift from fossil fuels to electricity, generate electricity from low- and zero-carbon sources and use all energy more efficiently.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
Tierney and Bird 20 [Susan Tierney Vice Chair, WRI Global Board of Directors, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group, Inc, and Lori Bird Director, US Energy Program and Polsky Chair for Renewable Energy 5-12-2020, "Setting the Record Straight About Renewable Energy," World Resources Institute, | czx]
Solar and wind now provide the cheapest power for 67% of the world.
The costs associated with solar and wind have fallen dramatically in recent years. According to BNEF, the cost of energy globally for onshore wind and utility-scale solar is now $44 and $50/MWh (on a levelized basis), compared to $100 and $300/MWh only a decade ago. In the U.S., the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) associated with onshore wind ($24-46/MWh) and utility-scale solar ($31-111/MWh) is now less than that of almost all gas-fired power production. Battery storage, which is crucial to address the variability of wind and solar power, has seen the swiftest global price drop among all technologies, from nearly $600/MWh in 2015 to about $150/MWh in the first half of 2020.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
Tierney and Bird 20 [Susan Tierney Vice Chair, WRI Global Board of Directors, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group, Inc, and Lori Bird Director, US Energy Program and Polsky Chair for Renewable Energy 5-12-2020, "Setting the Record Straight About Renewable Energy," World Resources Institute, | czx]
Wind and solar plants can be built with minimal environmental impacts, and often with co-benefits.
All power plants, including renewables, result in some environmental impacts during siting, development and operation. Over the past two decades, siting practices for U.S. wind projects have become more sophisticated and effective at minimizing impacts. As a result, wind projects have fewer impacts than other types of projects, falling near the bottom on lists of developments that can have negative effects on the environment and wildlife, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. What’s more, these projects often provide co-benefits. Wind farms sited in rural areas benefit farmers and ranchers by providing annual revenues from $4,000 and $8,000 per turbine, while allowing landowners to continue to use the sites for agriculture or grazing. Additionally, wind farm owners pay county property taxes that support schools, recreation centers and other county activities.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
Lotzof 23 – Journalist for the The Natural History Museum of London (Kerry Lotzof, “Renewable energy and its importance for tackling climate change,” The Natural History Museum of London, Date Published Found Using Wayback Machine, Available Online: https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/renewable-energy.html, Accessed: 7-11-2023)//ILake- EN
Replacing fossil fuel-reliant power stations with renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, is a vital part of stabilising climate change and achieving net zero carbon emissions.
Professor Magda Titirici, Chair in Sustainable Energy Materials at Imperial College London, offers an introduction to renewable energy and the future of clean, green power in the UK.
2023
Michigan
Evidence
AFF › Renewables Good---Impact---2AC
McMeekin 23 – Researcher in Physics and in the Marie Skłodowska-Curie fellowship at the University of Oxford (David McMeekin, “The Inevitable Energy Transition,” St Edmund Hall University of Oxford, 3-10-2023, Available Online: https://www.seh.ox.ac.uk/blog/the-inevitable-energy-transition, Accessed: 7-19-2023)//DD- ILake-EN
Solar energy is the most abundant energy resource on earth and available in every country.
Transitioning towards renewable energies has previously been difficult due to the need for direct or indirect government subsidies to support initial adoption of emerging technologies. However, this is no longer the case, where unsubsidised utility-scale bids for wind and solar projects have come in at lower price ranges than gas or coal projects, which have long been regarded as the lowest Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE). According to the Lazard’s report, utility-scale renewables are now below coal generation prices, where unsubsidised wind prices ranged from 28 to 54 USD/MWh, while utility-scale solar ranged from 32 to 42 USD/MWh, compared to coal priced at 66 to 152 USD/MWh, and gas combined cycle at 44 to 68 USD/MWh. Enabling this cost-competitiveness has triggered an inevitable energy transition from fossil fuel-based technologies to renewables. This transition is no longer an environmentalist’s pipe dream, but rather a current reality, which now has been accelerated by the soaring energy cost caused by the current geopolitical conflict.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff Answers › UBI Bad
Minogue ’18 [Rachel Minogue, Leader of Professional and Business Services Portfolio as Senior Analysis on Supply Chain Resiliency, International Trade Administration, Washington D.C.; May 2018; “Five Problems with Universal Basic Income”; https://www.thirdway.org/memo/five-problems-with-universal-basic-income]
The numbers speak for themselves: UBI is either very expensive or very stingy. The progressive version of UBI is expensive to the point of impossibility, while the conservative version is penny-pinching and punitive. Looking first at the former, consider an annual grant of $12,000 for all American adults aged 18 to 64, like Stern proposes. Stern estimates his plan would cost between $1.75 trillion and $2.5 trillion. The high end of this range seems realistic. Almost two-thirds of the population, or 200 million people, would receive a monthly UBI check for $1,000, with a cost of approximately $2.4 trillion every year, or one-eighth of GDP.9 Social Security beneficiaries currently receiving less than $1,000 a month would also get a supplement, adding an estimated $52 billion a year.10 By comparison, our entire existing social safety net costs $2.6 trillion. That includes Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Unemployment Insurance, and veterans’ benefits.11
Unless these critically important programs are eliminated, a UBI program would need to be paid for with higher taxes. It’s not clear whether it’s even possible to raise enough revenue for this initiative. The federal government took in approximately $3.3 trillion in 2017, so a taxes-only approach to funding Stern’s UBI would require an unheard-of 73% increase in federal revenue.12 Even if defense spending was slashed by one-third, for example, a 52% tax increase would still be required.13 Funneling all of a tax increase into UBI would also neglect our existing programs, like Social Security, which needs financial support to remain solvent past 2034.14
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff Answers › UBI Bad
Hughes, ’23 [Ryan A. Hughes, Founder of Bull Oak Capital, an investment advisory firm in San Diego, CA; January 2023; “Universal Basic Income is a Bad Idea” https://bulloakcapital.com/blog/universal-basic-income-is-a-bad-idea/#:~:text=UBI%20is%20expensive.,require%20a%20significant%20tax%20increase.]
In the U.S., the Roosevelt Institute think tank says that a $1,000 a month payment would grow the economy by $2.5 trillion by 2025 if paid for by increasing the federal deficit. On the other hand, if the UBI were paid for with taxes, there would be no net benefit to the economy.
However, net wealth is not created by simply redistributing money from one class of people to another. Wealth is created by increased labor, trade, and innovation. As such, I have difficulty believing that UBI could grow the economy by $2.5T.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff Answers › Jobs Key
Correira, 12. (David Correira; His work, whether in the archives, on the street, or in the classroom, focuses on the state's police powers, law and its relation to violence, and environmental politics. He is a co-founder of the research and mutual aid collective AbolishAPD (abolishapd.org).; February, 2012; “Degrowth, American Style: No Impact Man and Bourgeois Primitivism”; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10455752.2011.648847?journalCode=rcns20; Taylor and Francis Online; Accessed 7/24/2023; JB)
The point of this essay has been to argue that the enormous popularity of No Impact Man, along with its critique[s] of mainstream environmentalism, means that a critical politics of anti-consumption as part of a transformation in socio-ecological relations must take bourgeois primitivism seriously. Otherwise bourgeois primitivism, like mainstream environmentalism before it, will offer capital the environmental legitimacy it requires to resolve crises and restructure the terms of access to nature and labor. Degrowth, as of yet, has not done this. For the remainder of the essay, I offer a brief summary of six areas where it could.
First, the focus of bourgeois primitivism on material objects has eclipsed a concern for structural processes, the role of political institutions and the politics of scale and space. This, I would argue, is a function of seeing the city, and all the privileges that the capitalist city bestows on its affluent residents, as an ontology of space, a pre-existing politics that makes challenging the socio-ecological foundation of capitalist relations impossible through a bourgeois primitivist lens. Bourgeois primitivist environmental political philosophy considers the social costs and collapse of economic restructuring only in terms of individual happiness and bourgeois socio-ecological security. Left without a critical vision of the uneven distribution of social and environmental costs, Beavan’s environmental politics is an aspatial, asocial politics. Therefore primitivist answers to environmental problems can only be located in certain privileged subjectivities of consumption.
2023
Michigan
Counterplan
Aff Answers › JG Bad For Economy
Earl 18, (Peter C. Earle; is an economist who joined AIER in 2018. Prior to that he spent over 20 years as a trader and analyst at a number of securities firms and hedge funds in the New York metropolitan area. His research focuses on financial markets, monetary policy, and problems in economic measurement. He has been quoted by the Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg, Reuters, CNBC, Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, NPR, and in numerous other media outlets and publications. Pete holds an MA in Applied Economics from American University, an MBA (Finance), and a BS in Engineering from the United States Military Academy at West Point, 11/19/18, investors.com/politics/commentary/federal-jobs-guarantee-democrats/, Investors.com)
With the midterm victories in the House of Representatives, Congressional Democrats are likely to begin a full-court press on their most recent policy initiative: a federal jobs guarantee program. Senators Corey Booker, D-N.J., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., have advanced their own, and with the arrival in Congress of affirmed Democratic Socialists like Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Rashida Tlaib of Michigan additional support seems likely.
Several think tanks — including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), Levy Economics Institute (LEI), PolicyLink, and the Center for American Progress — have proposed job guarantee plans. While there are minor differences between them, each essentially contemplates a massive, government-run program to provide work (at a predetermined wage) and benefits to enrollees on demand.
2023
Michigan
Negative
NEG › advantage cp › 2nc---independence key
Hunt 23 [ Edward Hunt writes about war and empire. He has a PhD in American Studies from the College of William and Mary, 3-15-23, Foreign Policy in Focus, “CONGRESSIONAL INACTION PRESERVES U.S. COLONIALISM IN PUERTO RICO” ] DarG
The people of Puerto Rico, who were granted U.S. citizenship by Congress in the early twentieth century, lack many of the same rights as U.S. citizens living in the states. Islanders do not have full voting representation in Congress. They cannot vote in presidential elections, despite the fact that the president can send them into war. They pay taxes that fund social programs such as Medicaid and food stamps, but they receive fewer benefits. Essentially, the people of Puerto Rico are treated as second-class citizens. Last year, the Supreme Court that Congress is not required to include Puerto Rico in the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program, which provides benefits to poor elderly Americans and poor Americans with disabilities. Although Congress has extended the program to some U.S. territories, it has excluded Puerto Rico and other territories. Consequently, Puerto Ricans can receive SSI benefits while they are living in the states but not while they are living in Puerto Rico. “If you believe in equality, you cannot expect the American citizens in Puerto Rico to consent to discrimination and unequal treatment,” Pierluisi said. Many Puerto Ricans view the island’s territorial status as a for their unequal treatment, but they disagree over what to do about it. Some islanders want Puerto Rico to declare its independence from the United States. Others hope that Puerto Rico will join the United States as the 51st state. Many desire some kind of middle ground that would preserve U.S. citizenship while establishing autonomy for a Puerto Rican nation. The Puerto Rican government has held several non-binding on the nation’s status, but each one has been mired in controversy, making the results open to interpretation. The last , held in November 2020, resulted in 52 percent of voters opting for statehood, but only a slight majority of registered voters cast ballots. Historically, Congress has shown little interest in decolonizing Puerto Rico. Some officials have strongly criticized U.S. colonial control of the island nation, but they have introduced , with some geared toward independence and others focused on statehood. Over the past year, a growing number of Democratic politicians have grown increasingly convinced of the need to change the colonial status quo. Starting from this common ground, they have created a , the , that would enable the people of Puerto Rico to choose among three options: independence, statehood, or a compact of free association with the United States. “Our agreement will allow our fellow Americans in Puerto Rico to determine their own future,” Representative Steny Hoyer (D-MD) in May 2022, when he and several of his colleagues introduced their plans. Over the next several months, many Democrats came to support the bill. During a on the House floor in December, several representatives made unusually strong statements against U.S. colonialism and called for passage of the legislation. Representative Nydia Velázquez (D-NY) criticized U.S. colonialism for destroying the Puerto Rican economy, dividing the Puerto Rican people, undermining the dignity of the Puerto Rican people, and making Puerto Rico dependent on the United States. “Colonialism is not only humiliating for Puerto Rico, but it is an embarrassment to the United States,” Velázquez said. The United States “stands up to imperialist tyrants abroad while keeping colonies in the Caribbean and the Pacific.” “The time has come to fully decolonize Puerto Rico,” she said. Representative Darren Soto (D-FL), who expressed similar concerns, declared that “it is time to set our people free.” The U.S. government, Soto insisted, must provide the people of Puerto Rico with the opportunity to choose their own form of government. “The Puerto Rico Status Act will finally allow Puerto Ricans to throw off their colonial bonds, finally end their territorial status, and choose for themselves,” he said. Following additional discussion, including some pushback from Republicans who called for more time to consider the issue, the House voted on the bill, which 232 to 191, largely along party lines. All Democrats voted in favor of the bill, and 16 Republicans joined them. On the day of the vote, the Biden administration acknowledged in a that the people of Puerto Rico “have not received the full rights and benefits of their citizenship.” President Biden called on Congress to “act swiftly to put the future of Puerto Rico’s political status in the hands of Puerto Ricans, where it belongs.” Since then, however, there has been little movement in Washington. Now that the Republicans have acquired a majority in the House, Democratic leaders have seen for moving forward with the legislation. Representative Bruce Westerman (R-AR), who has dismissed the bill as “,” now chairs the House Committee on Natural Resources, which would have to restart the legislative process in the House for the bill to be considered by the current Congress. At last month’s Senate hearing on the U.S. territories, no representatives of either party raised the issue. They ignored Pierluisi’s statements in support of the Puerto Rico Status Act, including his insistence that the Senate “not allow this important opportunity to pass by.” “Puerto Rico will remain hindered until our century-long status question is resolved,” Pierluisi said. Unmoved by such concerns, the current congressional leadership has shown little interest in moving forward with the plebiscite. Despite the strong anti-colonial sentiment that many House leaders expressed on the House floor just a few months ago, the momentum for change has come to a halt. By opting for inaction, congressional leaders are preserving an oppressive colonial system that denies the people of Puerto Rico their most fundamental human rights.
2023
Michigan
Negative
NEG › advantage cp › 1nc---independence cp
Bonilla 22 [Dr. Bonilla is the director of Centro, the Center for Puerto Rican Studies at unter College, and a professor of anthropology at the City University of New York Graduate Center, 5-19-22, The New York Times, “For Puerto Ricans, Another Reminder That We Are Second-Class Citizens” https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/19/opinion/puerto-rico-supreme-court-social-security.html]
It’s certainly past time to repeal these racist and xenophobic precedents. But even if the Insular Cases were repealed, there is no guarantee that other arguments would not be used to keep denying S.S.I. and other entitlements to Puerto Ricans and residents of other unincorporated territories. What we need to address is the very concept of unincorporation, which is little more than a justification for colonialism.
Two competing bills that seek to end Puerto Rico's colonial status are currently deadlocked in Congress. The Puerto Rico Statehood Admission Act, introduced by Darren Soto and Puerto Rico's nonvoting representative Jennifer González-Colón, would lead to an immediate and binding yes or no vote on statehood. The other bill, known as the Puerto Rico Self-Determination Act, co- sponsored by Representatives Nydia Velázquez and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Robert Menendez, would facilitate a longer process of discussion, deliberation and, most importantly, education on the question of status options. A third consensus bill is now under consideration.\