Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Adv CP---States---TANF › Solves Inequality---2NC

(2NC) TANF reform can solve inequality by encouraging states to hire ELR’s.

Justin Schweitzer, 4-5-2022, Policy Analyst at the Center for American Progress and a masters from John Hopkins in Applied Economics "TANF Must Be Able To Respond Faster and Stronger to Economic Crises," Center for American Progress, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tanf-must-be-able-to-respond-faster-and-stronger-to-economic-crises/ Accessed 7/19/2023. 🔔

Replace the work participation rate and caseload reduction credit with new success measures that incentivize covering more families, not less

The main performance measure imposed on state TANF programs by the federal government is the work participation rate.57 In order for states to keep their full federal TANF funding, they must ensure that 90 percent of TANF recipients in two-parent families and 50 percent of all participating households meet requirements on work activities, including participating in subsidized or unsubsidized employment, job search activities, and training. States can also receive a caseload reduction credit that reduces the WPR requirement by 1 percentage point for every percent below the base year—currently 2005—that their TANF caseload is, meaning that the more a state lowers the number of families it assists through TANF, the easier it is for that state to meet its federal requirement on work participation.58

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Adv CP---States---TANF › Solves Resilience---2NC

(2NC) TANF should be used as an automatic stabilizer for the economy.

Justin Schweitzer, 4-5-2022, Policy Analyst at the Center for American Progress and a masters from John Hopkins in Applied Economics "TANF Must Be Able To Respond Faster and Stronger to Economic Crises," Center for American Progress, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tanf-must-be-able-to-respond-faster-and-stronger-to-economic-crises/ Accessed 7/19/2023. 🔔

Nevertheless, TANF is still vital to the families who do receive assistance, providing them with critical funds to buy basic necessities when their incomes are low, as well as connecting them to jobs, training, and other supports such as child care and domestic violence services.7 Yet most families in need either do not receive this assistance or receive too little of it. Making matters worse, since TANF is federally structured in a way that disincentivizes and hinders states from fully matching the amount of aid to the level of need, these problems are exacerbated during economic crises, when the number of people facing poverty and hardship rises rapidly.8

The solution to this problem: automatic stabilizers. In contrast to TANF’s current structure, automatic stabilizers are programs or features of the budget designed to quickly respond to changing economic conditions by expanding or contracting with the level of need, without waiting for a vote or new action from policymakers.9 Importantly, automatic stabilizers simultaneously protect individuals and stimulate the broader economy by providing vital assistance when people experience sudden drops in their incomes; supporting critical spending power; and multiplying in effectiveness during major economic downturns, when many households are facing big budget crunches. For example, unemployment insurance (UI) is an automatic stabilizer that significantly increases spending during recessions to cover the additional people losing their sources of income—although many still do not receive their benefits due to deteriorated administrative capacity, flawed eligibility rules, and defective verification or anti-fraud systems.10 In addition, UI’s Extended Benefits program kicks in automatically during periods of high unemployment after workers exhaust their regular UI benefits.11

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Adv CP---States---TANF › 1NC

States are not using their TANF dollars – instead they sit on 5.2 billion dollars.

Hannah Dreyfus, 12-29-2021, Investigative reporter with 6+ years of experience. Selected as a 2018 Writer of the Year by the New York Press Association. Published in The New York Times, ProPublica, Mother Jones, Slate, Business Insider, The Daily Beast & Vice; "States Are Hoarding $5.2 Billion in Welfare Funds Even as the Need for Aid Grows," ProPublica, https://www.propublica.org/article/states-are-hoarding-52-billion-in-welfare-funds-even-as-the-need-for-aid-grows Accessed 7/12/2023 🔔

When Congress passed welfare reform in 1996, states were given more autonomy over how they could use federal funding for aid to the poor. They could demand welfare recipients find work before receiving cash assistance. They could also use their federal “block grants” to fund employment and parenting courses or to subsidize childcare.

Twenty-five years later, however, states are using this freedom to do(ing) nothing at all with large sums of the money.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Adv CP---States---TANF › 1NC

TANF is about to expire – its necessary we expand it right now or else TANF will collapse

Rachel Mackey, 6-20-2023, Rachel Mackey is a research fellow at Hudson Institute, specializing in political philosophy and American politics,"Reauthorize the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) Block Grant," NACo, https://www.naco.org/resources/reauthorize-temporary-assistance-needy-families-tanf-block-grant-0 Accessed 7/12/2023. 🔔

TANF represents an important source of flexible fund(s)ing for a variety of anti-poverty activities benefiting vulnerable county residents, including cash assistance, child care, education, job training and work support programs. In FY 2020, states used 22.3 percent of TANF and MOE funds for basic assistance, 9.7 percent for work, education, and training activities and 16.6 percent for child care (including funds transferred to the Child Care Development Fund). While states have significant flexibility in using TANF funds, the program does impose certain limitations. Families do not qualify for cash assistance under TANF unless states require recipients to participate in narrowly defined “work activities” and a share of a state’s participants meet a minimum weekly work threshold of 30 hours. There is also a five-year limit for cash assistance to families that include an adult recipient, although states may exceed the time limit for up to 20 percent of their caseloads based on hardship. Program rules also require states to penalize individuals who fail to meet work requirements with a partial or full reduction in cash benefits. The recently passed Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (FRA) (P.L. 118-5), brought new program changes to TANF work requirements. Under current law, states must ensure that at least 50 percent of single-parent families and 90 percent of two-parent families have adults engaged in work-related activities to receive the full federal block grant. However, for states that have reduced their TANF caseloads since 2005, these percentages are lower. The FRA would recalibrate the caseload reduction credit to 2015 levels instead of 2005 levels, thus limiting the flexibilities for states. The FRA would also allow up to five states to establish six-year pilot programs, replacing their current work participation rate targets, requirements and penalties with alternative "work and family outcomes" benchmarks negotiated with HHS.

As an entitlement, TANF is not subject to the annual appropriations process. However, TANF funding has remained at $16.5 billion annually since its inception, with no growth for inflation, while the formula for state allocations remains linked to data from the mid-1990s. To be eligible for the block grant, states must meet a Maintenance of Effort (MOE) requirement, meaning they must spend state dollars on TANF-allowable activities. Congress last reauthorized TANF in the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 (P.L. 109-171) and has renewed the program through a series of short-term extensions since its expiration in 2010. Most recently, Congress passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 (P.L. 117-103), which extends TANF through September 30, 2023. Given our role in administering TANF and the importance of the program to supporting low-income county residents, a long-term TANF reauthorization with substantive program improvements and adequate funding is critical for all counties.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Adv CP---States---TANF › 1NC

5 reforms solve to make it an economic stabilizer.

Justin Schweitzer, 4-5-2022, Policy Analyst at the Center for American Progress and a masters from John Hopkins in Applied Economics "TANF Must Be Able To Respond Faster and Stronger to Economic Crises," Center for American Progress, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tanf-must-be-able-to-respond-faster-and-stronger-to-economic-crises/ Accessed 7/19/2023. 🔔

Despite the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program’s ostensible purpose of alleviating poverty, it consistently fails to respond in a timely or sufficient manner during economic downturns, when need quickly intensifies. This report examines the rules and features of TANF, particularly at the federal level, that do not allow it to work as an automatic stabilizer—that is, as a government policy that counters recessionary forces by automatically increasing stimulus during economic downturns without the need for any action from lawmakers.1 It is critical that policymakers reform TANF into an automatic stabilizer so that it can perform better as an anti-poverty, anti-recessionary tool to help the low-income adults who continue to struggle with the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic.

To do so, the Center for American Progress recommends the following policy interventions:

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Mechanism › Lifting Caps---Solvency

States could lift restrictions on Local taxation and financial abilities, allowing for increased financial resilience.

Jeff Chapman 21, July 8, directs Pew’s state fiscal health initiative. Through cutting-edge research and customized technical assistance, he and his team help states maintain a balanced budget, prepare for downturns, invest in long-term economic growth, and strengthen local governments. Chapman provides strategic direction, including leading the development of additional innovative solutions for improving fiscal management, “Local Tax limitations Can Hamper Fiscal Stability of Cities and Counties,” https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/issue-briefs/2021/07/local-tax-limitations-can-hamper-fiscal-stability-of-cities-and-counties Rxie

As the COVID-19 pandemic continues, local governments across the country face the formidable task of committing resources to rising health care needs while maintaining services their communities expect, including schools, parks, and libraries. At the same time, the pandemic has created significant economic uncertainty for local leaders, with many experiencing large revenue shortfalls that make balancing budgets all the more difficult. When local governments struggle, states pay a price, too—because of lost jobs, reduced tax collections, diminished services, and, in extreme cases, costly state bailouts. To minimize harm during economic downturns and support localities’ financial stability over the long term, states could review any policies that restrict local budget flexibility— including the policy that is the focus of this issue brief: limitations that states impose on local taxation. Every state limits the revenue-raising capacity of its local governments, which include municipalities and counties,1 to some degree. For example, a state may prohibit localities from levying a tax entirely; restrict the tax rate, tax base, or total taxes collected; or require dollars to be used for specific purposes. Many local governments are subject to multiple constraints. Limits on local taxation reflect both the role of state governments in our federalist system as well as concerns of policymakers and taxpayers over rising tax burdens. However, through a literature review and interviews with state and local officials and experts, researchers from The Pew Charitable Trusts found that tax limitations have in some cases created significant budget challenges for local governments and amplified existing ones. Using examples from several states, this brief examines how these limitations can create long-lasting fiscal challenges for localities. The brief then outlines three strategies that states can consider to help localities manage the current downturn and beyond: Temporarily lift limitations to give local officials more options for responding to extraordinary fiscal challenges, including recessions and natural disasters. For example, states could allow localities to pass temporary tax changes or use revenue that is normally restricted to specific functions for other purposes. Adjust limitations that may prevent local government revenue from fully recovering after a downturn. In other words, states can allow tax revenue to grow as the economy recovers. Increase local budget flexibility in the long term. For example, states can provide financial aid to local governments to mitigate the impact of tax limitations or offer relief from state mandates that increase costs for localities. The landscape of local tax limitations Property taxes have long been the main pillar of local government finances in the United States. State limits on those taxes can be traced to the 1800s and gained momentum into the first half of the 20th century, spurred on by Americans’ economic struggles during the Great Depression.2 The popularity of these limits among state policymakers persists: In 2019, Texas lawmakers passed a bill that tightened limitations on the growth of local property tax revenue.3 States have adopted these limits in part because residential property taxes are often unpopular with taxpayers. Because property taxes depend on home values that may not reflect a homeowner’s income level, they can be a burden for lower-income households, whose homes also account for the majority of their wealth.4 While states have sought to curb the growth of property taxes, they have also limited the ability of local governments to adopt alternative revenue sources. Most local governments are still allowed to collect only one or two of the three major taxes (property, sales, and income taxes).5 These fiscal restrictions also extend in many cases to smaller tax streams, such as excise taxes. The range of these limitations on local taxation reflects efforts by state leaders to increase government accountability, restrain the growth of government, prevent mismanagement of local finances, and boost a state’s ability to attract individuals and businesses. Some limitations apply to all local governments within a state, while others differ among municipalities and counties. Some states also make exceptions for certain jurisdictions. The rise of home rule provisions in the early 1900s, used to extend the governing authority of local governments, has given some localities more fiscal tools than others. Ohio municipalities, for example, levy an income tax, which has become a growing revenue source as the state has sought to limit local property and sales tax bases.6 In some cases, states allow local governing bodies such as city councils to override a limitation with a simple majority or supermajority vote. But often, state law dictates that increased local taxing authority or local tax changes must either be voter-approved or enacted by the state legislature. Ballot initiatives have also codified local tax limits in state law, in some cases creating constitutional amendments that can be changed only through voter approval. Local tax limitations: a primer Property taxes For cities and counties, property tax revenue makes up 61% of own-source tax revenue—revenue from the local government levies—by far their largest tax source.7 At the same time, most states place restrictions on local property taxation, with limits that fall into three main types: rate limits, assessment limits, and levy limits. In many states, local governments are subject to more than one property tax limit. Michigan, for example, imposes all three types of limitations on its localities. Property tax is calculated based on two components: the assessed value of the property, which is determined by the local assessor as a percentage of the home’s market value, and the tax rate, usually expressed as what’s known as a millage rate, which is the amount a homeowner pays per $1,000 of the property’s assessed value. For example, an amount of $10 for every $1,000 of assessed value is expressed as 10 mills. Rate limits are typically caps on how high the millage can go within a jurisdiction. Assessment limits restrain the growth of the property value of individual homes (commonly measured as year-over-year increases). Levy limits restrict the amount or growth of total collections from a locality’s property tax. For local governments that develop their budgets around how much property tax revenue they will bring in each year, levy limits are in effect spending limits. Assessment and levy limits may be a fixed percentage or tied to an economic indicator such as inflation or growth in new construction. Sales taxes Although the property tax remains the primary source of tax revenue for local governments in most states, 35 states had some amount of local sales tax collections as of 2017, the most recent year for which complete data is available.8 And as with property taxes, local control of sales taxes is often limited. Many states limit the rates that can be set. Some states also cap the combined sales tax rate of overlapping jurisdictions. In Texas, the total local rate—summed for any city, county, transit district, and special purpose district that overlap at a given location—can’t exceed 2%.9 Often, states require local governments to restrict their sales tax revenue to specific uses: California, Mississippi, and North Carolina, for example, require their counties or municipalities to use sales tax revenue for infrastructure needs.10 And some states don’t allow the revenue from local sales tax to flow entirely to that government’s coffers; North Carolina counties, for example, are required to allocate a portion of their sales tax revenue to the municipalities within their borders.11 What’s more, many local governments have little discretion over the transactions they can tax; a locality may have only the option to adopt the same tax base as its state, with the state assuming responsibility for collecting the local taxes, a practice designed to reduce the burden of administration and compliance on government and businesses. If a state does not tax services, such as personal care and financial services, its local governments likely do not, either, though there are exceptions: Home rule municipalities in Colorado, for example, have the power to set their own sales tax base.12 Finally, states may have highly restrictive criteria around which jurisdictions can levy a sales tax, such as the “resort tax” Montana allows in communities that “meet specific population and economic conditions.”13 Income taxes At the local level, the personal income tax is the least common of the three major taxes. Local governments in four states—Kentucky, Maryland, Ohio, and Pennsylvania—brought in a quarter or more of their own-source revenue from income taxes in 2017, the most recent year for which complete data is available.14 States may also give income taxing authority only to select jurisdictions; in New York state, for example, only New York City and Yonkers are allowed to impose city income taxes. Common limitations that states place on local income taxes include parameters around the tax rate that can be set and the base that can be taxed. Although local income tax bases often include wage income, there are exceptions, such as the “intangibles” tax Kansas allows, which applies only to gross earnings from intangible property such as savings accounts, stocks, and bonds.15 While income taxes are typically levied on residents, some localities, such as cities in Ohio, can tax the income of nonresidents who commute in for work.16 Examples of how state revenue limits can hamper local fiscal stability State limits on local taxation can restrict the ability of localities to fulfill the growing public demand for services. For example, revenue caps are often based on the inflation in prices of consumer goods and services, which tend to grow at lower rates than many of the costs that governments face, particularly health care. Limitations can also curtail the ability of municipalities and counties to prepare for and recover from recessions. When revenue declines—as it tends to do during an economic downturn—certain limitations on local taxation can keep revenue from fully rebounding, leaving it at an artificially low level even as the economy grows. This socalled “ratchet-down” effect can continue to damage a locality’s revenue base over multiple cycles of economic recession and expansion. Furthermore, state restrictions on the number and types of taxes that local governments can levy have the effect of shrinking the options that local officials can use to respond to changing economic conditions. “All [of our] taxes are limited in one way or another,” said Geoff Neill, a legislative representative for the California State Association of Counties. “Counties have essentially no budget flexibility at all. They can’t decide how much revenue they want; they just look at how much they will be getting, and budget based on that.”17 In addition to creating year-to-year budget challenges, tax limitations may also affect how well local governments manage long-term liabilities such as public employee pension obligations. Moody’s Investors Service considers tax caps in its evaluation of the credit quality of local government debt, for example.18 Tax limitations lower credit ratings when they restrict financial flexibility and make it difficult for a locality to maintain healthy reserves. Moreover, reduced flexibility may force local governments to use debt rather than cash to address infrastructure needs, which can lead to rising debt burdens that may become unaffordable.19 The following examples demonstrate how some of these challenges have played out around the country. Michigan Two property tax limitations in Michigan have led to ratchet-down effects on local revenue. Property values tend to fall temporarily during recessions. But as those values start recovering with the economy, one limitation in Michigan restricts growth in the taxable value of individual parcels while the other requires rate reductions when there is substantial growth in the local housing market overall.20 As a result, in 2019, some communities in the state still had not seen property tax revenue return to 2008 levels, even though real estate values had recovered.21 Michigan’s local governments are constitutionally required to balance their budgets.22 To do so with little revenue flexibility means cutting expenses and chipping away at the local services that residents expect, such as parks and fire protection. Anthony Minghine, deputy executive director of the Michigan Municipal League— an organization that represents the interests of the state’s municipalities—notes that “everyone has a stake in having communities that work and function appropriately.”23 He adds that one long-term consequence of cutting services is that it can make a community less desirable, which further erodes the tax base and creates a negative cycle that’s hard for a locality to break.24 What’s more, this challenge often besets communities that were among the state’s less affluent even before the onset of fiscal problems. A 2018 analysis by Michigan’s Treasury Department also showed that although the state’s overall local fiscal health has improved since the Great Recession, some communities remain in distress.25 Analysts traced these challenges back to the early 2000s, when the state began to reduce revenue sharing with municipalities, pension and retiree health care costs started to rise, and economic growth slowed. Given these enduring risks to local fiscal health—and inevitable future challenges—the department called on the state to “ensure the local government system is as robust and resilient as possible to economic shocks.”26 "Everyone has a stake in having communities that work and function appropriately." Anthony Minghine, deputy executive director MICHIGAN MUNICIPAL LEAGUE Colorado The state’s Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights—commonly known as TABOR and enacted in 1992—features a strict constitutional limit on revenue growth while also requiring new taxes and tax increases to be approved by voters. Because the TABOR limit for a given year depends on the prior year’s spending level, it also leads to a ratchetdown effect during recessions when budgets shrink.27 Given the severity of the revenue growth limit, cities and counties across Colorado have appealed to voters to change or eliminate the cap. So far, 51 out of 64 counties and 230 out of 274 municipalities have secured voter approval for retaining revenue in excess of the limit, increasing taxes, or enacting new levies—though in many cases these measures are temporary, attached to a specific revenue stream, or both.28 For example, much of Boulder’s sales tax is restricted to specific purposes such as acquisition, maintenance, and programming of open space and mountain parks. The pandemic provides a dramatic example of how TABOR can amplify recessionary pressures. “For municipalities that have not [voted to exempt themselves from TABOR limits], if they saw a 10% decrease this year in sales tax revenue like we have and then it bounced back next year, [the increase] would be limited to inflation plus a measure of local growth,” said Cheryl Pattelli, chief financial officer for the city of Boulder. “So, basically, they wouldn’t get back what they lost.”29 Tax limitations in Colorado have also caused greater challenges for communities that are among the state’s less prosperous. The Gallagher Amendment, which voters repealed last November, aimed to protect homeowners from rising property taxes by fixing the ratio of residential to commercial taxable property values—so when residential values grew, the residential assessment rate decreased to maintain that ratio.30 But because this restriction was tied to the value of property statewide, as booming housing markets in places such as Denver drove up total property value, the Gallagher Amendment significantly reduced taxable value elsewhere. Colorado’s legislative council staff wrote in July 2020, before the repeal, that the amendment had created stark regional disparities: Slow-growing counties saw their tax bases shrink by as much as half from 2004 to 2019, while other counties grew their tax bases, some by greater than 50%.31 What’s more, many of the struggling communities are small and rural, with little commercial real estate to depend on for additional revenue.32 The scope of local government authority in the United States The power to grant authority to local governments is reserved for states under the 10th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, and because of subsequent court decisions, this authority is now defined as one of two types, either home rule or Dillon’s Rule.33 As a result, state-local relations and the degree of local discretion vary widely across states. Dillon’s Rule stems from two court decisions issued by Judge John F. Dillon of the Iowa Supreme Court in 1868 and affirms that a local government can only exercise powers explicitly authorized by the state. For any additional authority, localities must secure permission from the state legislature. Beginning in the 1900s, the inflexibility of Dillon’s Rule prompted many states to enact so-called “home rule” provisions, delegating state power to their local jurisdictions without requiring them to seek legislative permission. Although home rule tends to increase local autonomy, especially over governing structure, tax policy authority typically remains limited. Even those localities with more fiscal freedom are subject to a restricted set of policy tools defined in their state’s constitution.34 The practical distinction between home rule and Dillon’s Rule is not always straightforward: Home rule status does not preclude states from adding restrictions, and some local governments under Dillon’s Rule may enjoy relatively broad freedom to make certain decisions. Although the majority of states adhere to Dillon’s Rule, some of those states have nonetheless designated select localities as home rule.35 For example, Illinois uses a population threshold to grant home rule status to cities and counties with relatively large populations.36 New York A law that took effect in 2012 restricts property tax revenue growth in New York to the lesser of 2% and the prior year’s inflation rate.37 “[Inflation] has been as low as 0.1% or 0.2%, which essentially means a municipality can’t increase its levy at all,” said Barbara Van Epps, deputy executive director of the New York State Conference of Mayors. “So [city officials] have to be able to explain to residents, ‘Look, we’re overriding [the cap] so we can keep collecting garbage and keep the streetlights on and keep our parks clean.’”38 The Office of the New York State Comptroller has assessed the fiscal health of the state’s local governments each year since 2012.39 “What we often find for local governments in stress is that they have high fixed costs that they fund with limited revenue options,” said Tracey Hitchen Boyd, the assistant comptroller for the Division of Local Government and School Accountability. “The tax cap is a limit on flexibility—flexibility that may be greatly needed.”40 The state also imposes a constitutional limit on total property tax revenue in a single year, currently set at 1.5% to 2.5% of real property value.41 If a locality exceeds the limit, the state withholds its aid payments to the locality by the excess amount. Since the limit depends on property values, it fluctuates with the local housing market, meaning a downturn in values can push a community closer to its limit. Along with the 2012 growth cap, the single-year limit only makes it harder for local governments to use property tax revenue to shore up their budgets when taxes that are more sensitive to changes in the economy, such as the sales tax, dip. The pandemic, for example, has led to local sales tax revenue across New York being down nearly $1.6 billion from January through October 2020 compared with the same period in the previous year.42 Wisconsin During a statewide period of rapid economic growth, Wisconsin capped annual property tax revenue increases at the rate of new construction (calculated as the value the construction adds as a percentage of total taxable property).43 But the Great Recession ended the boom and, years later, growth in many communities remains sluggish. In 2018, the Wisconsin Policy Forum—an independent policy research organization—found that for over 60% of cities and villages, the average rate of new construction from 2012 to 2017 was 1% or less. That means that under the state’s cap, property tax revenue growth didn’t even keep pace with inflation for most of that period.44 Even in the capital city and university town of Madison, for example, with its relatively strong and stable economy and robust development, new construction has amounted to only 1% to 2% of total taxable property value annually in recent years.45 According to city finance director David Schmiedicke, the corresponding constraint on property tax revenue growth has made it hard to finance wage increases for city staff and spending initiatives such as expanding the transit system. At the same time, the taxes Wisconsin cities can levy are extremely limited. Schmiedicke added that while the one-time aid to local governments under this year’s American Rescue Plan Act will help Madison recover from the pandemic’s short-term impacts, the city’s budget will continue to face significant structural challenges because of the state’s constraints on local revenue.46 "I think there’s value to having locally elected officials being able to look at their tax structure, their population, and make their own decision in terms of what the right tax structure should be." Andrew Sheaf, local government policy manager PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Pennsylvania The Keystone State limits local governments to a few broad-based revenue sources, for which the tax rates are capped.47 Andrew Sheaf, a local government policy manager with the state’s Department of Community and Economic Development, helps localities in fiscal distress get back on their feet through the department’s Act 47 program,48 which allows for tax increases beyond the state’s cap—a solution that is often needed to help a distressed locality balance the following year’s budget. From Sheaf’s experience, local governments would benefit from more revenue flexibility: “I think there’s value to having locally elected officials being able to look at their tax structure, their population, and make their own decision in terms of what the right tax structure should be,”49 he said. Absent this flexibility, Pennsylvania localities can face a set of hard choices when trying to balance their budgets. Although they can raise rates on property taxes up to a limit, the challenge then becomes whether homeowners can afford the increases—especially the significant share of older residents who are out of the workforce and have relatively low incomes.50 But given the lack of alternative revenue options, not increasing property taxes may require service cuts that affect quality of life. Ultimately, said Amy Sturges, director of governmental affairs for the Pennsylvania Municipal League, either option—increasing property taxes or reducing services—could drive away current residents and discourage people looking to move into the community, which could erode the tax base over time.51 In the wake of the pandemic, cities with long-standing financial issues are now facing multimillion-dollar deficits and considering major spending cuts, said John Brenner, the league’s executive director designate. “In Pennsylvania, we seem to lag behind a recession. We have issues years after recession numbers start to change. Local leaders will have to wrestle with [the current crisis] for multiple years.”52 States can consider increasing local budget flexibility As cities and counties begin to recover from the pandemic and recession, states can strengthen the capacity of their local governments to respond to fiscal challenges in three ways: 1. Temporarily lift tax limitations to give local officials more options for responding to extraordinary fiscal challenges, including recessions and natural disasters. States can give their localities more room to maneuver by temporarily lifting certain revenue restrictions—on a case-by-case basis or in reaction to a recession or natural disaster. Some states have already put this idea into practice. Governor Phil Murphy signed legislation in August 2020 to allow New Jersey’s local governments to borrow for pandemic-related expenses and back those bonds with property taxes that do not have restrictions.53 In Texas, the 2019 bill that tightened the property tax cap makes exceptions for emergency declarations (though policymakers are currently debating whether the pandemic applies).54 Pennsylvania’s Act 47, enacted in 1987, assists local governments that the state designates as financially distressed and grants them options to raise revenue beyond what is normally allowed.55 Implementing Pennsylvania’s approach, however, requires the state to monitor local finances closely and regularly. More importantly, policymakers could take action to give a locality more fiscal options well before it falls into financial distress. 2. Adjust limitations that may prevent revenue from fully recovering after a downturn. As local governments in Michigan and Colorado can attest, certain tax limitations can erode revenue over time and create fiscally unsustainable conditions. Fundamentally, limitations are meant to check the long-term growth of revenue and spending. But revenue growth following a recession helps cities and counties rebuild their budgets— and reverse spending cuts to the government services their residents expect. After a recession, states can allow the pace of economic recovery—rather than an artificial cap—to dictate a return to pre-recession conditions. Colorado’s Referendum C, passed by the voters in 2005 to eliminate TABOR’s ratchet-down effect on state revenue, shows that a simple modification can ensure that a tax limit does not impede revenue recovery after a recession.56 Before the referendum, the TABOR cap was calculated by adjusting the prior year’s spending level by inflation plus population growth. Referendum C changed the formula for the cap to use a fixed base, which means that even when spending drops during recessionary periods, the cap does not. In some states, property tax rates can adjust to keep revenue from falling when property values decline— helping to smooth the revenue stream during economic downturns and making it more stable than other more economically sensitive tax sources. Maryland, for example, allows for this adjustment by not imposing a property tax rate limit.57 Although New York state limits property tax bases, New York City’s property tax rate can fluctuate to generate the revenue needed to pay for a determined level of public services: As the last act in adopting its budget, and after all other revenue has been calculated, the city sets the rate to yield the property tax revenue it needs to balance the budget.58 3. Increase local budget flexibility in the long term. In addition to putting local governments in a better position to handle fiscal crises, states would also benefit from evaluating if and how tax limitations and other state constraints are impeding local fiscal sustainability in the long term. States can then consider ways to increase the flexibility localities have to address ongoing fiscal challenges, ensure a resilient tax base, and maintain the service quality their residents expect. The pandemic’s effects may add to local budget challenges. Uncertainties around teleworking, commercial real estate values, and consumer behavior, for example, have raised questions about whether some key local revenue streams will become unreliable in the long term. Increased budget flexibility can allow local officials to more effectively adapt to potentially lasting changes to the economy and to their tax base. There are various ways states can grant more flexibility to their local governments apart from modifying tax limitations. Policymakers can evaluate which approaches are most suitable given their state’s current fiscal conditions and state-local dynamics. Many local governments must by law adopt their state’s sales tax base and are unable to better align their own base to changes in the economy until the state takes steps to do so. The majority of states—and, as a result, localities—now tax online sales, a revenue stream that has been a boon during the pandemic as online purchases have largely replaced in-person shopping.59 However, most states do not tax many services—for example, personal care and professional consulting—even though consumer spending has shifted significantly to the service sector and away from goods over time. According to a 2017 survey by the Federation of Tax Administrators, only Hawaii and New Mexico have sales tax bases that include nearly all of the 176 services listed in the survey.60 Florida’s 2020 Tax Handbook estimated the fiscal impact of adding personal services to the sales tax base to be $277 million for fiscal year 2021—up from the 2010 estimate of $168 million—a percentage of which would be distributed to local governments according to Florida’s local half-cent sales tax allowance and state revenue-sharing formulas.61 "We’d love to figure out new ways to do what we’re mandated to do. The challenge is that we’re required to do these things and yet we’re not given the tools to pay for them." Danene Sorace, mayor of Lancaster, Pennsylvania Local governments are often subject to various state and federal mandates, many of which require funds from localities’ own budgets. A 2016 analysis by the National Association of Counties found that over the previous decade, nearly three-quarters of states had increased mandates, decreased funding, or both.62 States could reduce the burden of mandates on localities by shouldering a portion of the costs. When Indiana imposed new tax rate limits in 2010, for example, the state also took over about $3 billion of local spending, including school operating costs and police and fire pensions.63 States could also allow cities and counties to levy a new tax to fund specific additional functions or expenses they require localities to take on, such as those associated with maintaining the court system and providing health services.64 “We’d love to figure out new ways to do what we’re mandated to do,” said Danene Sorace, mayor of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. “The challenge is that we’re required to do these things and yet we’re not given the tools to pay for them.” In addition, states could permit and support partnerships between cities and counties to jointly deliver services— which, at a minimum, could help localities avoid budget cuts that affect service quality, especially during recessions when demand increases for certain services. A 2020 report by the Government Finance Officers Association sampled 200 cities and counties and found that local officials deemed several key government services as shareable, in particular maintenance services.65 Texas, for example, gives local governments the legal authority to enter into interlocal agreements to increase efficiency in effectively providing services such as police, fire protection, public health, and waste disposal.66 In 2007, New Jersey adopted a new law to more effectively promote the use of shared services with a goal of reducing local expenses that lead to high property tax burdens on residents.67 In Gloucester County, efforts to share services among various municipalities began when smaller communities were struggling to provide some services on their own. Now, because of the demonstrated cost savings and quality of service delivery, all of the county’s municipalities participate in sharing services, including stormwater management, trash disposal, and 911 dispatch. The county has addressed job losses that resulted from service sharing by helping municipalities reallocate workers whose positions were eliminated.68 Lastly, states can reassess why they impose limits on local taxation. If a state’s primary concern is reducing the property tax burden on constituents, policymakers could consider applying and strengthening targeted tax relief measures—such as homestead exemptions, which are widely used and typically exempt some portion of a home’s value from property taxes69—rather than restricting localities’ overall revenue. Other targeted measures aimed at providing tax relief to certain segments of the population include “circuit breaker” programs that give tax credits to low-income homeowners if their property tax bills exceed a certain share of their income. Additionally, states could balance more restrictive tax limits with direct financial aid to local governments: Minnesota, for example, strictly targets its state aid payments to help localities keep property tax growth low.70 Conclusion Tax limitations can create daunting challenges for cities and counties as they try to balance their budgets while maintaining the level of services their residents expect in the long term. And evaluating if and how states’ tax limitations impede the ability of local officials to manage their finances and provide services effectively is a key first step. Policymakers can then take the appropriate measures to ensure that local governments have the necessary tools to weather unexpected budget crises and strengthen their fiscal health into the future.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Mechanism › PRWORA Reform---Solvency

Reform PRWORA –politically popular, allows states to create programs, based on federal funding

Sheely 12 – Amanda Sheely, Associate Professor – London School of Economics & Political Science (“Devolution and Welfare Reform: Re-evaluating “Success”, Oxford Academic; Social Work, 11-11-2012, Accessible Online at )

How might the current welfare reform be altered to address discrimination, limited resources, and fragmented services? As stated by Lens (2002), there are two ways to approach revising the program: (1) make radical changes to the PRWORA legislation or (2) make incremental changes to improve the program. Given that Republicans and Democrats alike support shifting responsibility for welfare—and many other programs—to lower levels of government, returning to the federal system that existed under AFDC does not seem feasible. Nevertheless, the following recommendations suggest concrete changes to help make welfare reform more equitable.

First, it is vital to modify the current federal performance requirements to make state programs more responsive to the needs of poor families. Under PRWORA, the federal government requires states to place increasing percentages of their caseloads in work activities or face reductions in their block grants. The required ratio of cases in work activities can also be satisfied by reducing caseload size (that is, a caseload reduction credit), which has been the compliance mechanism for most states. Indeed, this credit seems to have given states the wrong focus during the current economic recession, in which caseloads have remained largely unchanged despite steep increases in unemployment and poverty. One way to improve welfare reform's responsiveness is to change the performance goals to focus on outcomes other than caseload reduction, including a reduction in poverty and material hardship among families. This change is desperately needed at a time when the percentage of children living in poverty has climbed to over 20 percent (DeNavas-Walt, Proctor, & Smith, 2010). It may be harder for states to create programs to reduce poverty rather than caseloads. However, this change seems necessary given the long-term education, health, and economic consequences of poverty for children. States have shown great flexibility in creating ways to limit caseloads. Now, the same innovation should be harnessed to promote poverty reduction. For example, some states can choose to change program requirements to allow recipients to use education and training programs to fulfill their work requirements while creating community college classes to train welfare recipients for the well-paying jobs available in their states. States may also create programs to ensure that families access the federal benefits for which they qualify, including SNAP and Medicaid. Recognizing the limitations of current performance requirements, NASW recommended making poverty reduction, instead of caseload reduction, the primary goal of welfare reform during the last reauthorization debate (Woodside, 2001).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Mechanism › Interstate Compacts---Net Benefit---Division

State Divisions lead to War

Marvin Kalb, 9-16-2021, "Is the US headed for another Civil War?," Brookings,

Is it really possible that America could face the possibility of civil war in the near future? It may seem unthinkable, and yet there’s much to worry about.

A 2021 national survey by pollster John Zogby found a plurality of Americans (46%) believed a future civil war was likely, 43% felt it was unlikely, and 11% were not sure. War seemed more likely for younger people (53%) than older ones (31%), and for those residing in the South (49%) and Central/Great Lakes region (48%) relative to those in the East (39%).

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Mechanism › Interstate Compacts---Solvency---Tax Evasion

Interstate compacts prevent tax evasion by migration

Schubert-Akin 23 (Jennifer Schubert-Akin, CEO, chair, and co-founder of The Steamboat Institute, graduate of the University of Oklahoma and received her M.B.A. from St. Edward’s University in Austin, Texas, 1-20-2023, "State wealth tax compact is short on logic and high on ideology," Restoring America, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/fairness-justice/state-wealth-tax-compact-is-short-on-logic-and-high-on-ideology/Accessed July 24, 2023) sns

This interstate tax compact attempts to overcome one of the biggest problems with a wealth tax: the ability of those affected simply to move jurisdictions. One slight problem for the compact? There are still 43 other states that the wealthy in their states could move to. A recent analysis by James Doti, president emeritus and economics professor at Chapman University, finds people are already moving from high-tax states into low-tax ones. He concludes the 10 highest tax states lost nearly 1 in 100 residents in net domestic migration between July 2021 and July 2022. He assesses that the 10 lowest tax states gained almost 1 in 100. Top line: Higher taxes only accelerate tax migration. LARRY HOGAN IS BETTING ON A REAGANITE REVIVAL The top 1% of taxpayers already pay approximately 50% of state income taxes, so wealth taxes that chase them away could significantly imperil states' fiscal positions. Low-tax states have gained tens of billions of dollars in gross income in recent years due to the relocation of the wealthy and upper-middle class, while high-tax states have lost a comparable amount. Think financiers moving from New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut to Florida, businessmen fleeing Illinois for Tennessee, and entrepreneurs decamping California for Nevada, Arizona, and Texas. What high-valuation/cash-poor startup would submit to a state wealth tax in this environment? As Jared Walczak, a policy analyst at the Tax Foundation, explains, "The economic consequences — both from out-migration and lower economic activity — are so significant that even at the national level, most countries have abandoned any wealth taxes they once had." There's an alternative approach. The Congressional Budget Office reported that the government collected a record $4.9 trillion in revenue last year, almost $500 billion more than it had projected. Corporate tax receipts, reduced corporate tax rates being the centerpiece of the Republican-led 2017 tax cuts, surpassed the government's projection by 25%. Tax revenue as a share of GDP hit 20% last year, one of the highest levels in history. The data suggest states that want to improve their budgets should shelve tax hike plans in favor of reducing tax burdens. Just don't expect the tax compact architects to recognize this logic. They seem to care more about punishing the wealthy than raising revenues.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › Mechanism › Interstate Compacts---Solvency

Interstate compacts create state policy and connect states in a flexible, credible way.

Farren 20 (Michael D. Farren, Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, specializing in labor, economic development, and transportation issues, 1-28-2020, "Using an Interstate Compact to Solve the Problems with Economic Development Subsidies," Mercatus Center, https://www.mercatus.org/research/state-testimonies/using-interstate-compact-solve-problems-economic-development-subsidies/Accessed July 12, 2023) sns

A Primer on Interstate Compacts Interstate compacts aren’t well known, even though they’re part of the original US Constitution. However, there are currently more than 200 compacts and most states are members to dozens of such agreements. Interstate compacts allow the states to work together to solve common policy problems without intervention by the federal government. Their constitutional nature means that compacts carry the weight of federal law, meaning they offer a credible way for states to commit to a given course of action. But compacts can also be flexible. For example, the recent Enhanced Nurse Licensure Compact repealed and replaced the original Nurse Licensure Compact to motivate greater participation in the compact. During the compact drafting process states can decide what enforcement mechanisms to put into place and what penalties should befall states that violate the compact. The only limits on what can be put into the compact are what measures the states themselves want to agree to, what Congress will consent to (according to the Supreme Court, congressional consent is required in cases where the compact intrudes on the authority that the states delegated to the federal government in the Constitution), and what the Constitution itself permits (for example, states could not enter into a compact that abridges rights guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment). Critical Elements for an Economic Development Interstate Compact New Hampshire’s interest in convening a committee to study how a compact can be used to mutually solve the problem of economic development subsides is a step in the right direction. I would recommend that the committee discuss several particular elements of such a compact, because they will be critical to creating an effective solution to the problem. Defining a subsidy: an interstate compact will have to explicitly define what constitutes a subsidy, as discussed earlier. Compact enactment and administration: a compact will also have to determine how and when the compact takes effect, how the compact will be enforced, and how (or if) states are able to exit the compact. Dispute resolution: a compact will need mechanisms to flag violations, create procedures for dispute resolution, and set penalties for states that breach the compact. Reforms: a compact should also have a mechanism or advisory body to identify deficiencies in the compact in order to propose appropriate reforms. Conclusion The problem of economic development subsides existed before the American founding and unfortunately has worsened in recent decades. The broad body of academic research clearly shows that, contrary to the claims made by consultants, instead of enhancing economic development, subsidies are more likely to reduce it. There is widespread public misunderstanding of subsidies, and as a result, policymakers face strong incentives to continue offering them. This divergence between what is economically efficient and what is politically expedient keeps policymakers trapped in a self-destructive subsidy war. An interstate compact offers a politically feasible long-term solution. Policymakers would be wise to explore the opportunity, because real economic development depends on it.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Misc---Squo Solves---1NC

Squo solves inequality --- existing welfare programs.

Christopher Wimer ‘20, co-director of the Columbia University Center on Poverty and Social Policy and the Project Director on the Robin Hood Poverty Tracker. “The Direct Effect of Taxes and Transfers on Changes in the U.S. Income Distribution, 1967–2015” August 24. file:///C:/Users/Remy.Xie26/Downloads/Michigan/taxandtransfersonchangesinusincome.pdf Rxie

In this study, we set out to offer a clearer picture of changes in the U.S. income distribution since 1967. We use several measures of trends in income inequality to understand how taxes and transfers directly shaped income growth across the distribution and across household type. Our findings lead to three main conclusions. First, trends in the Gini coefficient tell an incomplete story with respect to the uneven changes in America’s income distribution. Trends in the Gini align almost perfectly with trends in the p90-p50 ratio but very poorly with trends in the p50-p10 ratio. This is not surprising. As others have shown, the Gini is particularly sensitive to income changes at the top of the distribution. However, our findings also emphasize the importance of multiple indicators to understand changes in the income distribution. We show that the American welfare state has worked particularly well to lift incomes near the 10th percentile of the distribution, to the point where lower-tail inequality actually declined from 1967 to 2015 after taxes and transfers were accounted for. This is consistent with other research showing that these benefits have become more important for the working poor, particularly since the 1990s when expansion of Social Security, the EITC, and SNAP generally offset the decline of ADFC and TANF, shifting support from the poorest families to the working poor, elderly, and disabled (Hardy et al. 2018; Moffitt and Scholz 2010). Our second main finding is that changes to the U.S. tax and transfer system have greatly strengthened income growth at the bottom of the distribution. Omitting taxes and noncash transfers when measuring a household’s resources, as is the common practice in U.S. Census Bureau reports, leaves an incomplete understanding of inequality and changes in the income distribution. Specifically, we find that food and nutrition assistance (such as benefits from the SNAP program) and refundable tax credits (such as the EITC) have increasingly benefited individuals with low pre-tax income. This increase in transfers has contributed to nearly all the income growth at the 5th percentile of the distribution from 1967 to 2015 and roughly one-half the rise of the 10th percentile. Moreover, taxes and transfers largely account for the 5th through 15th percentiles experiencing net income growth at the same rate as the 50th percentile from 1967 to 2015. We emphasize again that these are relative growth rates (the percentage change in each percentile from 1967 to 2015) rather than measures of absolute income growth. Although the American tax and transfer system is still weaker than that of other advanced economies, it appears to have strengthened considerably over time in its ability to raise the incomes of low earners. That said, our third key finding reveals a large gap in the welfare state’s treatment of households with children versus those without. Taxes and transfers tend to offer less for individuals in households without children (and working-age adults without children, in particular) relative to households with children. As a result, we see rising inequality across the income distribution of individuals in households without children but declining lower-tail inequality among households with children. As Figs. 5 and 6 demonstrate, there is much less difference in pre-tax and transfers versus post-tax and transfer resources for individuals in households without children. There are several limitations to our study. First, even our expanded definition of resources does not provide a complete picture of inequality trends. For instance, we consider only metrics based on income and ignore consumption, which could change 1848 C. Wimer et al. the picture. Future research should use hardship metrics from the Survey of Income and Program Participation—measuring households’ abilities to meet expenses for mortgages, rent, utilities, or medical care—to investigate whether trends in household hardship run parallel to our findings. In terms of income measures, even our expanded definition does not include several important components. First, income and payroll taxes are not the only taxes that affect households. Sales taxes, property taxes, corporate profits taxes, and excise taxes also matter (Newman and O’Brien 2011). Second, our figures do not account for employeror government-provided health insurance (Burkhauser and Simon 2008), which clearly impacts the well-being of families at different points in the distribution over time. Third, the figures presented here include the value of housing subsidies for low-income families but not the value of mortgage subsidies for homeowners or the use value of owner-occupied housing. Arriving at a full definition of post-tax resources that includes all these components is beyond the scope of this article (and probably beyond the scope of available data), but it is important to acknowledge that accounting for these omissions might change our revised picture of trends in economic inequality in other new ways.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Misc---Inequality D---1NC

Aff stats on inequality are bunk.

Jamie Bryan Hall, 2-20-2018, Jamie is a Research Fellow for quantitative analysis in the Center for Data Analysis at The Heritage Foundation "Examining Extreme and Deep Poverty in the United States," Heritage Foundation, 🔔

There are four major problems with the Census Bureau’s official measurement of poverty and deep poverty:

Means-tested welfare benefits are almost entirely ignored;

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---A2: Court Strikedown

Links to the aff

Darius Tahir and Alice Ollstein 19 Tahir is a Standford graduate, reporter for Politico, history of reporting on healthcare. Ollstein is a healthcare reporter for Politico, also covers political stories. 06/10/2019 “Death by a thousand lawsuits’: The legal battles that could dog ‘Medicare for All’ https://www.politico.com/story/2019/06/10/medicare-lawsuit-1356592

Championed by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and other progressive Democrats, Medicare for All faces enormous political obstacles — not the least of which is a major industry lobbying effort against the plan and anything that resembles it. But should it ever become law, it would also invite constitutional challenges. Just like the lawsuits targeting Obamacare — not to mention the blue state challenges against all sorts of Trump administration anti-Obamacare initiatives — the legal battles could directly threaten or undermine the new system for many years.

In particular, the single-payer bill’s ban on most private health insurance — a huge U.S. industry employing millions of people — would be an instant legal quagmire. And a host of other issues, including abortion rights enshrined in the legislation, could easily produce another wave of lawsuits.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---Socialism---2NC

State-level single-payer is a key step in the socialist movement.

Casey Buccholz et al 21 Buccholz and Attar are graduate student in economics at the University of Massachusetts, cochair of the Political Education Committee for River Valley DSA. 10/15/2021

The Sanders campaign was a cheat code. It took the socialist movement from irrelevance to national prominence in only five years. How to avoid a return to irrelevance is now the most pressing question confronting socialists in the United States. In the post-Bernie context, organizing to win state-based single-payer offers socialists the opportunity to continue their work of the last five years.

The socialist movement and the labor movement will rise or fall together. State-based single-payer provides common ground both socialists and labor can unite around to fight for a shared goal and, in turn, build a militant labor movement with the organizational capacity to take on bigger and broader  to advance the cause of the entire working class, such as winning Medicare for All or ending global vaccine apartheid.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---2NC

States are very well-positioned to enact healthcare reform, can account for disparities and avoid political barriers

Zeke Emanuel et al. 16, Ezekiel J. Emanuel is a senior fellow at American Progress and the vice provost for global initiatives, the Diane S. Levy and Robert M. Levy University Professor, and chair of the department of medical ethics and health policy at the University of Pennsylvania. He is also an op-ed contributor to The New York Times. He was the founding chair of the department of bioethics at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), “State Options to Control Health Care Costs and Improve Quality,” https://www.americanprogress.org/article/state-options-to-control-health-care-costs-and-improve-quality/ Rxie

The recent debate on health care reform has occurred mostly at the national level. The Affordable Care Act, or ACA, was a momentous change for the U.S. health care system. So far, 20 million people have gained health insurance coverage due to the ACA—a historic reduction in the number of uninsured people in the United States.

The ACA also contained several tools designed to control health care costs. It created the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Innovation, or CMMI, which is authorized to test new payment and delivery methods in order to lower costs and improve quality for individuals who receive benefits from Medicare; Medicaid; or the Children’s Health Insurance Program, or CHIP. CMMI is currently testing and evaluating many different models, including accountable care organizations, bundled payments for hip and knee replacements, and primary care medical homes. The ACA also reduced Medicare payments to Medicare Advantage plans; to hospitals with poor quality measures; and to medical providers, which has had a spillover effect on private insurance.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---2NC

Other countries prove Federal single-payer CAN’T solve – doesn’t guarantee access to health services. AND turn: Federal systems EXACERBATE inequality.

Meridian Baldacci and Robert Moffit 18 Baldacci is a Former Research Assistant, Domestic Policy Studies. Moffit is a PhD and Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy. 09/26/2018 “Why Single-Payer Would Make Things Worse for Americans” , AnKh

But claims of lower costs and better, more efficient care are widely overblown. Here are the facts.

What Is Single-Payer?

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---2NC

A state policy solves better the public health system AND balances control between the public and the government.

Linda Wiley 19 has a JD and MPH (Master of Public Health), is with the Health Law and Policy Program, American University Washington College of Law, Washington, DC. 11/2019 “State-Level Single-Payer Health Care From a Public Health Perspective” , AnKh

As I have argued elsewhere, compared with federal single-payer reform, a state-level approach offers enhanced opportunities to integrate public health goals into health care financing and administration. Regulations and programs that influence the social determinants of health operate primarily at the state and local level. In contrast to a state-by-state approach, federal single-payer reform could further federalize policies on healthy eating, active living, tobacco control, overdose prevention, and more, possibly at the expense of more progressive approaches in some states.

Through value-based reimbursement, payers are increasingly holding providers financially responsible for the health of the populations they serve. But the focus is on insured patients over an annual budget, whereas public health must serve the entire community—especially the most vulnerable—throughout the life course. Chances are slim that the insurer who reimburses a pediatrician for talking to a vaccine-hesitant parent will be the same one bearing the costs of treating an infant infected by the unvaccinated child. The company reimbursing treatment for a 14-year-old person’s nicotine dependence likely will not be responsible for health care costs if he develops cancer decades later.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Solvency---Single Payer---2NC

Successful implementation of the single-payer system STARTS at the state level – Canada proves.

Linda Wiley 19 has a JD and MPH (Master of Public Health), is with the Health Law and Policy Program, American University Washington College of Law, Washington, DC. 11/2019 “State-Level Single-Payer Health Care From a Public Health Perspective” , AnKh

If public health care financing is to become more universal in the United States (a big “if”), it will likely be pioneered state-by-state, much like Canada’s single-payer system began in the provinces. Several states are seeking to succeed where federal reformers have failed, by using Medicaid as a platform for a public-option or single-payer program. The “Medicaid for All” label, widely used by politicians and commentators, is somewhat misleading. State-level proposals typically rely on the infrastructure that states already have in place for Medicaid but eliminate means testing and special benefits, such as long-term-care insurance, that define Medicaid as fundamentally different from other forms of coverage, private or public. Coverage would be state-financed with help from federal funds obtained via administrative waivers or facilitating federal legislation. Coverage could be administered by a state agency or through contracts with private administrators. A public-option approach would allow at least some residents to buy into the program as an alternative to private insurance, whereas a single-payer approach would aim to cover as many residents as possible and could eliminate employer-based coverage. Some reformers advocate for a public option as a “glide path” to a single-payer program.

This editorial focuses on one choice among the many choices that reformers face: what role will states play in financing and administering more universal public health coverage? As a long-term goal, federal reform modeled on the Canada Health Act could enshrine states as administrators of federally financed coverage. In the short term, Democrats would be wise to gather support for state-by-state experimentation with public-option and single-payer reforms rather than focusing exclusively on reforms built on Medicare, in which states play no role.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Net Benefit---State Flexibility---2NC

State governments solve terrorism, democracy, and the economy.

Allen Lottinger 11, Publisher Emeritus for The Herald. https://www.heraldguide.com/editorial/states-can-solve-many-problems-better/

The stage is set for the push toward democracy, not just in the mideast but here in the United States as well. While protesters are yelling for change in Tripoly and Egypt and other nearby countries, governors of many states here are telling the feds to stay out of our business, and let us solve our budget shortfall problems at the lower level. The states, reportedly, have made $75 billion in budget cuts and raised taxes $33 billion in the last two years to help cure the lack of cash caused by the recession. Now they are developing ways to remake state governments that will meet their budgets. The states can do that much better than the federal government. Helping to spread democratic practices in other areas of the world is the feds job. That will help preserve peace, end terrorism and promote freedom for people of other nations. Meanwhile, here at home we should downsize the federal government and let state and local governments run their areas more which will get democracy down to the people where it can do the most good. We need to cut federal taxes so the local governments can decide where to tax and spend. It is obvious that it costs much more for the federal government to do a job at the local level that the local government. Such a turnaround would provide much more efficiency in government and would cut out a lot of government expense that is not necessary. That money can then be used by the people to improve the economy, something that will never be done if it goes to Washington.

2023 Michigan Counterplan
States CP Updates › General › Net Benefit---State Flexibility---2NC

Stronger state governments are better at solving any issue.

Marcus Hawkings, B.A., Political Science, Florida Atlantic University, political reporter and writer. https://www.thoughtco.com/marcus-hawkins-3303071

One of the clear benefits of a weaker federal government and stronger state governments is that the needs of each state are more easily managed. Alaska, Iowa, Rhode Island, and Florida, for example, are all very different states with very different needs, populations, and values. A law that may make sense in Iowa might make little sense in Florida. For example, some states have determined that it's necessary to prohibit the use of fireworks due to an environment that is highly susceptible to wildfires. Some allow them only around July 4, and others allow those that don't fly in the air. Other states allow fireworks. It would not be valuable for the federal government to make one standardized law for all states prohibiting fireworks when only a handful of states want such a law in place. State control also empowers states to make tough decisions for their own well-being rather than hope that the federal government will see the states’ problem as a priority. A strong state government empowers citizens in two ways. First, state governments are far more responsive to the needs of the residents of their state. If important issues are not addressed, voters can hold elections and vote for candidates they feel are better suited to handle the problems. If an issue is important to only one state and the federal government has authority over that issue, then local voters have little influence to get the change they seek; they're just a small part of a larger electorate. Second, empowered state governments also allow individuals to choose to live in a state that best fits their personal values. Families and individuals can choose to live in states that have no or low income taxes or states with higher ones. They can opt for states with weak or strong gun laws. Some people may prefer to live in a state that offers a wide range of government programs and services while others may not. Just as the free market allows individuals to pick and choose products or services they like, so can they choose a state that best fits their lifestyle. Over-reaching federal government limits this ability. State-Federal Conflicts Conflicts between state and federal governments are becoming more common. States have begun to fight back and have either passed their own laws or have taken the federal government to court in protest.