Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Crime

Plan solves crime

Kiara Alfonseca (ABC News) “Guaranteed income experiment for Black women aims to tackle racial wealth gap” January 12, 2022 https://abcnews.go.com/US/guaranteed-income-experiment-black-women-aims-tackle-racial/story?id=82073348

Cash assistance and guaranteed income have been repeatedly proven to be a major force against poverty, according to researchers at the Columbia University, Center on Poverty & Social Policy. Past studies and research has shown evidence that basic income experiments improved the happiness and health of its recipients and appeared to affect crime rates in the regions where it was implemented. The program won't offer any financial literacy courses nor advise how participants will use the money. Wollensack says that, in surveying and researching the community and its financial needs, people can be trusted to make the right choices using their resources, but don't have a lot of resources to start with. "It's hard to budget from zero," Wollensack said. "In fact, we've seen oftentimes community members with some of the fewest resources are the most resilient and resourceful." She added, "Instead of viewing communities that may have experienced cash shortfalls as a deficit, we actually know and believe that these communities were huge assets." Lockhart said she expects to see the effects of the income boost almost instantaneously. She says that when the COVID-19 stimulus reached the bank accounts of Old Fourth Ward residents, she saw a mood shift among her neighbors. She says people were out and chatting with neighbors, engaging with neighborhood businesses -- the weight of financial stress lessened for just a while. "They want to get out and work. They want to start their own businesses. They want to spend more time with their children," Lockhart said "This will help slow people down a little bit so that they can focus and center themselves and center their energy right."

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL – Healthcare

The plan increases access to healthcare

Drexel University (Center for Hungry-Free Communities) “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME: KEY TO REDUCING FOOD INSECURITY AND IMPROVING HEALTH” 2021 https://drexel.edu/hunger-free-center/research/briefs-and-reports/universal-basic-income/

Increase in insurance access by employers. Increased Part-time Employment. Opponents of UBI often raise the concern of cash grants discouraging work. However, studies of the impacts of the Alaska Permanent Fund income transfer program show employment was not negatively impacted by the funds. Part-time work actually increased by 17%. The concern over whether or not people are “willing to work” is rooted in problematic perceptions of labor. In reality, employers are concerned that people will refuse to continue to work for low wages and unfair or unsafe conditions. UBI will challenge low wage jobs and influence employers to pay a living wage and provide health and family benefits in order to recruit and retain employees.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL - Poverty

Poverty destroys human dignity by creating degrading dependence

Schaber 11 (Peter, “Absolute Poverty”, Humiliation, Degradation, Dehumanization: Human Dignity Violated, edited by Paulus Kaufmann, published 2011 by Springer)

Poverty, I have argued, does not violate the dignity of human beings because poor people lack vitally important goods. Neither does it violate dignity because poor people, due to poverty, are unable to realize their rights. Poverty violates human dignity, because, and insofar as, poor people are dependent on others in a specific way. It violates dignity when it is responsible for the fact that a person's survival and her way of survival are placed at the mercy of others. Individuals who have to live in poverty are not able to stand up to others when it comes to securing their own survival. This does not have to be the case with every form of poverty. There may be forms of relative poverty that allow individuals to live independent lives and stand their ground. Yet even individuals living in relative poverty may depend on others in a degrading way. If a person needs a pair of shoes and, in order to get them, has to file an application at the social security office, she may rightly see this as degrading. The more severe the poverty, the stronger this special form of dependence becomes, for the dependence concerned here rests upon a lack of options from which one can choose. And, given that the options decrease, the dependence grows as the poverty becomes more severe. The dependence of the poor is not necessarily always exploited by others. However, it exists even if the better-off mean well towards the poor and — to take our example — donate the shoes they need. The situation is degrading for the solicitant, even if help is granted. The humiliating dependence on others consists in the lack of options. Of course, others can use this dependence for their own ends and exploit the (emergency) situation of poor people, which in fact happens often enough. This is a violation of dignity in itself, but poverty is a violation of dignity even in the absence of such reactions — at least when, as a consequence of poverty, individuals cannot stand up to others, as independent beings. This does not apply to our castaway. He does not depend on others, simply because there are no others in his situation. He experiences great suffering. His fate, however, is not at the mercy of others, but at the mercy of (impersonal) nature. And this allows him to live a life according to his own ideas and convictions, until his physical forces will cease. The aforementioned ascetic does not live in dependence on others either. On the contrary, he lives an independent life that resembles a life in poverty only insofar as he lacks goods that are essential for any form of a good life in any imaginable society. This, however, does not constitute a violation of dignity. For the ascetic lives a life according to his own convictions. The dependence on others and the inability to stand up to them violates a person's self-respect, for in order to respect oneself, one must be able to live a life of one's own choice and to interact with others as an independent being. Yet this is possible only if one has options and one's survival is not entirely at the mercy of others. And this, in turn, presupposes that one has access to the goods and capabilities essential for a good life. This requires not only material goods but also abilities to enable the realization of options. The claim to self-respect therefore relates not only to a right to subsistence but also a right to basic education. Only when these rights are fulfilled is one able to lead a life in self-respect. The rights to subsistence and basic education must not be equated with the right to self-respect. These rights protect goods that enable individuals to stand up to others. The claim to self-respect entails them as means necessary to its realization. At this point, some will note that we all depend on one another in many ways. Children, for example, depend on their parents. At least during the first years of their lives, they are placed at the mercy of their parents or educators. This dependence of children, however, does not constitute a violation of dignity; this is, I would argue, because infants do not yet have a claim to self-respect. This claim comes with the ability to lead one's own life; for one's dignity is violated only if one has this ability but is hindered from using it by others or by circumstances. Of course, children must be treated in a way that enables them to realize the claim to self-respect in the future.5 Yet this does not imply that their dependence constitutes a violation of dignity. But we are all, many will nevertheless object, dependent on each another in many ways. How can dependence on others be considered a violation of dignity if it is a part of the conditio humana? The dependence I am concerned with here is a special form of dependence. It applies when, in order to acquire vitally important goods, I have to rely on others without having any choice. It is the lack of reasonable options that makes dependence on others degrading. Of course, everyone depends on others' willingness to, say, sell food. Nevertheless, as long as one can choose between different ways of obtaining basic goods, and as such has options, this form of dependence is not degrading. If it is this special form of dependence that makes poverty a violation of dignity, it is clear that poverty violates dignity regardless of whether or not it is self-induced. And accordingly, if it is the case that recognition of the dignity of other persons places upon us an obligation of respect (Schaber 2007b), then it is also the case that those who are able to prevent poverty have a moral duty to do so, no matter whether or not they have contributed to it.6 The dependence on others that poor people experience violates their dignity. To abolish poverty is the moral duty of those who have the ability to do so.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL - Poverty

UBI key to eliminating poverty caused by AI.

Wright et al 24/8/21. Robert Eric Wright is a business, economic, financial, and monetary historian and the inaugural Rudy and Marilyn Nef Family Chair of Political Economy at Augustana University in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. He is also a research economist at the National Bureau of Economic Research. “AI: UBI Income Portfolio Adjustment to Technological Transformation” . Accessed June 28th. -TP

Positive and normative claims that artificial intelligence (AI) will or should lead to adoption of a universal basic income policy (UBI) remain insufficiently empirically grounded to merit serious consideration. Long-term trends in individual/familial income portfolio adjustment (IPA) to business, economic, and technological change (BETC) point to continued incremental changes in the ways that individuals/families achieve life goals, not a fundamental structural break necessitating radical policy changes that may not be desirable in any event. Moreover, if AI proves a more rapid disruptor than anticipated, UBI-like payments can be made quickly, as recent bailouts and fiscal stimuli demonstrate.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL - Poverty

UBI is key to eliminating poverty caused by AI.

Katarzyna & Wright 22. Robert Eric Wright is a business, economic, financial, and monetary historian and the inaugural Rudy and Marilyn Nef Family Chair of Political Economy at Augustana University in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. He is also a research economist at the National Bureau of Economic Research .Aleksandra Katarzyna Przegalińska-Skierkowska (born 18 January 1982) is a Polish futurist. She is an associate professor of management and artificial intelligence as well as a vice-rector at Kozminski University. “In Favor: Safety from Artificial Intelligence” . Accessed June 28th 2023. -TP

Artificial Intelligence and robots are coming for almost everyone’s jobs and will soon take over. Business, economic, and technological change (BETC) will be too rapid and deep for people and institutions to adjust. People will starve and die, members of the unnecessariat or a desperate precariate, unless UBI is in place to provide them with necessities. Even if matters do not become that dire, UBI is a good idea anyway because it will help workers through rough patches and allow them to live their best lives with little need for labor regulations.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Quality of Life Advantage › QoL– Inequality

Targeted basic income solves racial inequality and drastically increases quality of life for recipients

Jeremy Rosen – Director of Economic Justice – Shiver Center on Poverty and Law “Guaranteed Income: An Economic Support Whose Time Has Come” June 21, 2021 https://www.povertylaw.org/article/guaranteed-income/

Everyone in this country should have the financial resources to support themselves and their family members. It’s long past time to unbuckle the “bootstraps” narrative arguing that people experiencing poverty simply need to work harder or make better personal choices. In fact, policies and laws that create and perpetuate poverty and racial inequity are written into the fabric of our nation. Systemic factors and inequities, including the legacy of racism and white supremacy, contribute to America’s high poverty rate. In particular, Black and Latino/a/x families, who face discrimination in employment, housing, and access to government benefits, suffer higher rates of poverty and have been unable to build generational wealth. It’s time to ensure the financial security of all families by providing a guaranteed income. A guaranteed income program provides recurring cash payments, with no strings attached, to a targeted group of people. Unlike Universal Basic Income (UBI), a guaranteed income program channels money to people who truly need it. As a result, guaranteed income programs are more effective at reducing the racial wealth gap and increasing equity. A guaranteed income program provides assistance to families in need quickly, with little bureaucracy, and can fill gaps left by existing social safety net programs. Families know how to spend money in ways that would best help them. Assistance flows in the most efficient way possible—simply by giving people in need cash that they can use to meet their needs. A guaranteed income also gives families resilience in the face of financially stressful life events, such as unemployment, divorce, disability, or health problems. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed how many Americans are close to the brink and lack sufficient resources to weather emergencies. In response to the COVID-19 crisis, direct economic support through Economic Impact Payments (more commonly known as “stimulus checks”)—once unimaginable—became policy, and during the Trump Administration no less. Early data show that most families used the money to buy basics, including food and gas. More recently, several key federal tax credits, including the Child Tax Credit, Earned Income Tax Credit, and Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, were temporarily expanded and made refundable. Eligible tax filers can get a sizeable check back from the federal government. Many families who in past years simply would have owed no money in federal taxes will now be getting checks for well over $10,000—some of which will be paid on a recurring monthly basis and nearly all of which will be exempted as income under public benefit programs. The Child Tax Credit alone is expected to reduce child poverty by 45 percent, with particularly large reductions for Black, Latino/a/x, and Native American children. A guaranteed income can dramatically reduce poverty and improve families’ long-term well-being. Across the country, pilot programs offering a guaranteed income to local residents have measurably improved participants’ financial stability. Participants in these programs are using funds in ways that benefit their families’ long-term economic health—by paying for rent in a better school district, taking a community college course to improve job skills, saving to cover the expenses of starting a small business, or eliminating old debts that would otherwise trap a family in perpetual poverty. For example, in Stockton, California, 125 residents living at or below median income were given a $500 monthly stipend with no strings attached for 24 months. Not only did recipients’ quality of life improve, but researchers found that their participation in full-time employment jumped from 28 to 40 percent. In the Shriver Center’s home state of Illinois, several guaranteed income initiatives and pilot programs are underway. At the local level, Chicago Alderman Gilbert Villegas has proposed a pilot program to provide $500 per month for a year to 5,000 low-income residents of the city, to be funded with $30 million of the city’s $1.9 billion in American Rescue Plan funds. Other pilot programs supported by private philanthropy are also underway. Cook County plans to build on a successful initiative that gave direct payments to families facing financial hardship during the pandemic with a similar program in 2021. And at the state level, a broad coalition of community-based and grass tops organizations is working together to study the results of Illinois pilot programs, educate legislators, and ultimately advocate for legislation to establish a statewide guaranteed income program. At the federal level, the Shriver Center is advocating to make temporary tax credits that help low-wage families permanent, a policy position shared by the Biden Administration. The Shriver Center strongly supports policies and programs that provide a guaranteed income floor for the lowest income people. Guaranteed income offers the best hope to provide people with resources to make important life choices that everyone wants the ability to make—where to live, how to invest in a better future through education or starting a business, and how to best support children. Where properly targeted, guaranteed income specifically gives this opportunity to people who have been systematically excluded from the financial resources to make these decisions, without imposing a massive administrative burden either to qualify or stay eligible. This is a program everyone should support.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Solvency

Plan solves poverty, increases employment rates, reduces food insecurity, and improved overall health outcomes

E. Napoletano (former registered financial advisor and award-winning author and journalist) “An Unexpected Outcome Of The Covid-19 Pandemic: A Slew Of Universal Income Programs” May 12, 2022 https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/universal-basic-income-programs/

What Are the Arguments Supporting Universal Basic Income/Cash Transfer Programs? “Clearly people in our economy and society who need help,” says David Sacco, a finance instructor at the University of New Haven. Programs like UBI and cash transfer programs make the most sense, he says, for people who can most benefit from them. Proponents of cash transfer and UBI point to these benefits: Reduced poverty rates. The U.S. Census Bureau reported that supplemental payments and social assistance program expansions early in the Covid pandemic lifted 11.7 million people out of poverty. Additional unemployment benefits during that time prevented 5.5 million people from falling into poverty. Improved employment prospects. After one year of participating in a guaranteed income initiative in Stockton, California, the number of participants who were employed full-time jumped from 28% to 40%. Program reporting suggests that participants were able to reduce gig work and part-time shifts to pursue better positions, noting that reducing financial scarcity reduced time scarcity, too. Reduced food insecurity. Covid pandemic EBT payments helped reduce children’s food insecurity by 30%. Improved health. Participants in Stockton’s program reported lower anxiety and depression, and an improved sense of wellbeing.

2023 SDI Affirmative
****Case Extensions**** › Uniqueness

No federal guaranteed basic income now

Amritpal Kaur Sandhu-Longoria (USA TODAY) “Guaranteed basic income pilot programs are growing around the country, and community leaders are doing something about it” February 17, 2023 https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2023/02/17/how-universal-basic-income-program-works/11263986002/

How is guaranteed basic income funded? Currently, guaranteed basic income pilot programs are being funded through philanthropic donors and the American Rescue Plan Act. There is no federal funding program. A universal payment of $12,000 a year to each U.S. resident over the age of 18 would cost $3 trillion a year, the National Bureau of Economic Research concluded after studying this issue in 2019. In 2021, Congresswoman Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-N.J.), introduced a measure to launch a 3-year pilot program and offer 6,000 people a cash payment equal to the fair market rent for a 2-bedroom home in their zip code. But, that bill hasn't moved since its introduction in July 2021.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Economy Advantage

And economic decline cascades – nuclear war. This is especially true given the rapid pace of automation

Maavak 21 – Dr. Mathew, PhD in Risk Foresight from the Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, External Researcher (PLATBIDAFO) at the Kazimieras Simonavicius University, Expert and Regular Commentator on Risk-Related Geostrategic Issues at the Russian International Affairs Council. “Horizon 2030: Will Emerging Risks Unravel Our Global Systems?”, Salus Journal, The Australian Journal for Law Enforcement, Security and Intelligence Professionals, Vol. 9, No. 1, pg. 2-8, , 04-14-2021

Various scholars and institutions regard global social instability as the greatest threat facing this decade. The catalyst has been postulated to be a Second Great Depression which, in turn, will have profound implications for global security and national integrity. This paper, written from a broad systems perspective, illustrates how emerging risks are getting more complex and intertwined; blurring boundaries between the economic, environmental, geopolitical, societal and technological taxonomy used by the World Economic Forum for its annual global risk forecasts. Tight couplings in our global systems have also enabled risks accrued in one area to snowball into a full-blown crisis elsewhere. The COVID-19 pandemic and its socioeconomic fallouts exemplify this systemic chain-reaction. Onceinexorable forces of globalization are rupturing as the current global system can no longer be sustained due to poor governance and runaway wealth fractionation. The coronavirus pandemic is also enabling Big Tech to expropriate the levers of governments and mass communications worldwide. This paper concludes by highlighting how this development poses a dilemma for security professionals. Key Words: Global Systems, Emergence, VUCA, COVID-9, Social Instability, Big Tech, Great Reset INTRODUCTION The new decade is witnessing rising volatility across global systems. Pick any random “system” today and chart out its trajectory: Are our education systems becoming more robust and affordable? What about food security? Are our healthcare systems improving? Are our pension systems sound? Wherever one looks, there are dark clouds gathering on a global horizon marked by volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity (VUCA). But what exactly is a global system? Our planet itself is an autonomous and selfsustaining mega-system, marked by periodic cycles and elemental vagaries. Human activities within however are not system isolates as our banking, utility, farming, healthcare and retail sectors etc. are increasingly entwined. Risks accrued in one system may cascade into an unforeseen crisis within and/or without (Choo, Smith & McCusker, 2007). Scholars call this phenomenon “emergence”; one where the behaviour of intersecting systems is determined by complex and largely invisible interactions at the substratum (Goldstein, 1999; Holland, 1998). The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic is a case in point. While experts remain divided over the source and morphology of the virus, the contagion has ramified into a global health crisis and supply chain nightmare. It is also tilting the geopolitical balance. China is the largest exporter of intermediate products, and had generated nearly 20% of global imports in 2015 alone (Cousin, 2020). The pharmaceutical sector is particularly vulnerable. Nearly “85% of medicines in the U.S. strategic national stockpile” sources components from China (Owens, 2020). An initial run on respiratory masks has now been eclipsed by rowdy queues at supermarkets and the bankruptcy of small businesses. The entire global population – save for major pockets such as Sweden, Belarus, Taiwan and Japan – have been subjected to cyclical lockdowns and quarantines. Never before in history have humans faced such a systemic, borderless calamity. COVID-19 represents a classic emergent crisis that necessitates real-time response and adaptivity in a real-time world, particularly since the global Just-in-Time (JIT) production and delivery system serves as both an enabler and vector for transboundary risks. From a systems thinking perspective, emerging risk management should therefore address a whole spectrum of activity across the economic, environmental, geopolitical, societal and technological (EEGST) taxonomy. Every emerging threat can be slotted into this taxonomy – a reason why it is used by the World Economic Forum (WEF) for its annual global risk exercises (Maavak, 2019a). As traditional forces of globalization unravel, security professionals should take cognizance of emerging threats through a systems thinking approach. METHODOLOGY An EEGST sectional breakdown was adopted to illustrate a sampling of extreme risks facing the world for the 2020-2030 decade. The transcendental quality of emerging risks, as outlined on Figure 1, below, was primarily informed by the following pillars of systems thinking (Rickards, 2020): • Diminishing diversity (or increasing homogeneity) of actors in the global system (Boli & Thomas, 1997; Meyer, 2000; Young et al, 2006); • Interconnections in the global system (Homer-Dixon et al, 2015; Lee & Preston, 2012); • Interactions of actors, events and components in the global system (Buldyrev et al, 2010; Bashan et al, 2013; Homer-Dixon et al, 2015); and • Adaptive qualities in particular systems (Bodin & Norberg, 2005; Scheffer et al, 2012) Since scholastic material on this topic remains somewhat inchoate, this paper buttresses many of its contentions through secondary (i.e. news/institutional) sources. ECONOMY According to Professor Stanislaw Drozdz (2018) of the Polish Academy of Sciences, “a global financial crash of a previously unprecedented scale is highly probable” by the mid- 2020s. This will lead to a trickle-down meltdown, impacting all areas of human activity. The economist John Mauldin (2018) similarly warns that the “2020s might be the worst decade in US history” and may lead to a Second Great Depression. Other forecasts are equally alarming. According to the International Institute of Finance, global debt may have surpassed $255 trillion by 2020 (IIF, 2019). Yet another study revealed that global debts and liabilities amounted to a staggering $2.5 quadrillion (Ausman, 2018). The reader should note that these figures were tabulated before the COVID-19 outbreak. The IMF singles out widening income inequality as the trigger for the next Great Depression (Georgieva, 2020). The wealthiest 1% now own more than twice as much wealth as 6.9 billion people (Coffey et al, 2020) and this chasm is widening with each passing month. COVID-19 had, in fact, boosted global billionaire wealth to an unprecedented $10.2 trillion by July 2020 (UBS-PWC, 2020). Global GDP, worth $88 trillion in 2019, may have contracted by 5.2% in 2020 (World Bank, 2020). As the Greek historian Plutarch warned in the 1st century AD: “An imbalance between rich and poor is the oldest and most fatal ailment of all republics” (Mauldin, 2014). The stability of a society, as Aristotle argued even earlier, depends on a robust middle element or middle class. At the rate the global middle class is facing catastrophic debt and unemployment levels, widespread social disaffection may morph into outright anarchy (Maavak, 2012; DCDC, 2007). Economic stressors, in transcendent VUCA fashion, may also induce radical geopolitical realignments. Bullions now carry more weight than NATO’s security guarantees in Eastern Europe. After Poland repatriated 100 tons of gold from the Bank of England in 2019, Slovakia, Serbia and Hungary quickly followed suit. According to former Slovak Premier Robert Fico, this erosion in regional trust was based on historical precedents – in particular the 1938 Munich Agreement which ceded Czechoslovakia’s Sudetenland to Nazi Germany. As Fico reiterated (Dudik & Tomek, 2019): “You can hardly trust even the closest allies after the Munich Agreement… I guarantee that if something happens, we won’t see a single gram of this (offshore-held) gold. Let’s do it (repatriation) as quickly as possible.” (Parenthesis added by author). President Aleksandar Vucic of Serbia (a non-NATO nation) justified his central bank’s gold-repatriation program by hinting at economic headwinds ahead: “We see in which direction the crisis in the world is moving” (Dudik & Tomek, 2019). Indeed, with two global Titanics – the United States and China – set on a collision course with a quadrillions-denominated iceberg in the middle, and a viral outbreak on its tip, the seismic ripples will be felt far, wide and for a considerable period. A reality check is nonetheless needed here: Can additional bullions realistically circumvallate the economies of 80 million plus peoples in these Eastern European nations, worth a collective $1.8 trillion by purchasing power parity? Gold however is a potent psychological symbol as it represents national sovereignty and economic reassurance in a potentially hyperinflationary world. The portents are clear: The current global economic system will be weakened by rising nationalism and autarkic demands. Much uncertainty remains ahead. Mauldin (2018) proposes the introduction of Old Testament-style debt jubilees to facilitate gradual national recoveries. The World Economic Forum, on the other hand, has long proposed a “Great Reset” by 2030; a socialist utopia where “you’ll own nothing and you’ll be happy” (WEF, 2016). In the final analysis, COVID-19 is not the root cause of the current global economic turmoil; it is merely an accelerant to a burning house of cards that was left smouldering since the 2008 Great Recession (Maavak, 2020a). We also see how the four main pillars of systems thinking (diversity, interconnectivity, interactivity and “adaptivity”) form the mise en scene in a VUCA decade. ENVIRONMENTAL What happens to the environment when our economies implode? Think of a debt-laden workforce at sensitive nuclear and chemical plants, along with a concomitant surge in industrial accidents? Economic stressors, workforce demoralization and rampant profiteering – rather than manmade climate change – arguably pose the biggest threats to the environment. In a WEF report, Buehler et al (2017) made the following pre-COVID-19 observation: The ILO estimates that the annual cost to the global economy from accidents and work-related diseases alone is a staggering $3 trillion. Moreover, a recent report suggests the world’s 3.2 billion workers are increasingly unwell, with the vast majority facing significant economic insecurity: 77% work in part-time, temporary, “vulnerable” or unpaid jobs. Shouldn’t this phenomenon be better categorized as a societal or economic risk rather than an environmental one? In line with the systems thinking approach, however, global risks can no longer be boxed into a taxonomical silo. Frazzled workforces may precipitate another Bhopal (1984), Chernobyl (1986), Deepwater Horizon (2010) or Flint water crisis (2014). These disasters were notably not the result of manmade climate change. Neither was the Fukushima nuclear disaster (2011) nor the Indian Ocean tsunami (2004). Indeed, the combustion of a long-overlooked cargo of 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate had nearly levelled the city of Beirut, Lebanon, on Aug 4 2020. The explosion left 204 dead; 7,500 injured; US$15 billion in property damages; and an estimated 300,000 people homeless (Urbina, 2020). The environmental costs have yet to be adequately tabulated. Environmental disasters are more attributable to Black Swan events, systems breakdowns and corporate greed rather than to mundane human activity. Our JIT world aggravates the cascading potential of risks (Korowicz, 2012). Production and delivery delays, caused by the COVID-19 outbreak, will eventually require industrial overcompensation. This will further stress senior executives, workers, machines and a variety of computerized systems. The trickle-down effects will likely include substandard products, contaminated food and a general lowering in health and safety standards (Maavak, 2019a). Unpaid or demoralized sanitation workers may also resort to indiscriminate waste dumping. Many cities across the United States (and elsewhere in the world) are no longer recycling wastes due to prohibitive costs in the global corona-economy (Liacko, 2021). Even in good times, strict protocols on waste disposals were routinely ignored. While Sweden championed the global climate change narrative, its clothing flagship H&M was busy covering up toxic effluences disgorged by vendors along the Citarum River in Java, Indonesia. As a result, countless children among 14 million Indonesians straddling the “world’s most polluted river” began to suffer from dermatitis, intestinal problems, developmental disorders, renal failure, chronic bronchitis and cancer (DW, 2020). It is also in cauldrons like the Citarum River where pathogens may mutate with emergent ramifications. On an equally alarming note, depressed economic conditions have traditionally provided a waste disposal boon for organized crime elements. Throughout 1980s, the Calabriabased ‘Ndrangheta mafia – in collusion with governments in Europe and North America – began to dump radioactive wastes along the coast of Somalia. Reeling from pollution and revenue loss, Somali fisherman eventually resorted to mass piracy (Knaup, 2008). The coast of Somalia is now a maritime hotspot, and exemplifies an entwined form of economic-environmental-geopolitical-societal emergence. In a VUCA world, indiscriminate waste dumping can unexpectedly morph into a Black Hawk Down incident. The laws of unintended consequences are governed by actors, interconnections, interactions and adaptations in a system under study – as outlined in the methodology section. Environmentally-devastating industrial sabotages – whether by disgruntled workers, industrial competitors, ideological maniacs or terrorist groups – cannot be discounted in a VUCA world. Immiserated societies, in stark defiance of climate change diktats, may resort to dirty coal plants and wood stoves for survival. Interlinked ecosystems, particularly water resources, may be hijacked by nationalist sentiments. The environmental fallouts of critical infrastructure (CI) breakdowns loom like a Sword of Damocles over this decade. GEOPOLITICAL The primary catalyst behind WWII was the Great Depression. Since history often repeats itself, expect familiar bogeymen to reappear in societies roiling with impoverishment and ideological clefts. Anti-Semitism – a societal risk on its own – may reach alarming proportions in the West (Reuters, 2019), possibly forcing Israel to undertake reprisal operations inside allied nations. If that happens, how will affected nations react? Will security resources be reallocated to protect certain minorities (or the Top 1%) while larger segments of society are exposed to restive forces? Balloon effects like these present a classic VUCA problematic. Contemporary geopolitical risks include a possible Iran-Israel war; US-China military confrontation over Taiwan or the South China Sea; North Korean proliferation of nuclear and missile technologies; an India-Pakistan nuclear war; an Iranian closure of the Straits of Hormuz; fundamentalist-driven implosion in the Islamic world; or a nuclear confrontation between NATO and Russia. Fears that the Jan 3 2020 assassination of Iranian Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani might lead to WWIII were grossly overblown. From a systems perspective, the killing of Soleimani did not fundamentally change the actor-interconnection-interaction adaptivity equation in the Middle East. Soleimani was simply a cog who got replaced.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Economy Advantage

Despite the high price tag – the plan will save the government billions over the long term. It also has a multiplier effect meaning even small payments make big impacts on the economy

Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/

And yet, the adage that it is expensive to be poor applies not just to individuals, but to their governments. A mountain of evidence shows how tightly income inequality correlates with crime rates, education levels, drug abuse, incarceration, intimate-partner violence, and physical and mental health, which together cost billions upon billions of tax dollars. Numerous studies, for example, have found it would be cheaper to give homes to unhoused people than it is to cover all the costs associated with allowing them to stay on the streets, but progressives have faced an uphill climb to convince policymakers and voters that providing free housing is a worthwhile strategy. While there isn’t yet research on the potential economic benefits of guaranteed income specifically, studies of similar initiatives have shown that pulling people out of poverty generates a huge increase in tax revenue as well as savings on public assistance programs. First, though, the guaranteed-income movement had to show that its idea worked at all. When the current wave of experiments kicked off, the goal was to drown opponents in data demonstrating that the simplest idea for alleviating poverty was in fact the silver bullet it appeared to be. Of course, whether something “works” depends on the definition. Obviously giving people more money makes them less poor, but the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration team set out to show that as little as $500 a month — not nearly enough to replace actual income — would have a multiplier effect, allowing recipients to improve their employment prospects, their physical health and mental well-being, their children’s education, and their overall stability.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Economy Advantage

Automation coming now – basic income key to navigate the transition without collapsing the economy or causing massive amounts of poverty. Without the plan a massive economic collapse is inevitable

Cecil De Jesus (Futurism Magazine) “Is a Universal Basic Income the Answer to Automation-Caused Unemployment?” December 25, 2016 https://futurism.com/is-a-universal-basic-income-the-answer-to-automation-caused-unemployment

While technological advancements in  and  will clearly make a lot of processes easier and more cost-effective, the impending repercussions need to be addressed before the inevitable happens. As automation begins to take over several jobs, the world is turning to  as a possible solution to the anticipated unemployment it will create, which is estimated to be in the millions by the end of the decade. One proponent of such a system is Andy Stern, author of the book "Raising the Floor: How a Universal Basic Income Can Renew Our Economy and Rebuild the American Dream." Stern spent 38 years of his life working for the Service Employees International Union (SEIU), a labor union that aims to improve the lives of workers and their families. He resigned after serving as its international president for 14 years. In an interview with Vox, Stern talks about how he believes that the American dream is sure to die unless we become proactive about finding a way to keep it alive. “I think that if people don't intervene right now, it will [die]. Fifty percent of Americans say they don’t believe in the American dream, and they’re justified in believing that,” he says. “People with college degrees are not making anywhere near the kind of progress that their parents made, and that’s not their fault,” he added. In the interview, Stern tells Vox that he thinks "a tsunami of change" is on the way in the U.S. economy, and he proposes instilling a UBI system to cope with that change. “I believe a UBI is a way to ease the transition, and it's also a way to provide a floor for people — not necessarily a substitute for work, but a supplement to work that allows them to have a sense of economic security, have consumer buying power," he asserts. "We want to allow people to be entrepreneurs, to take risks and raise kids and do other things without turning the world into the Hunger Games."

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Economy Advantage

First, basic Income breaks the cycle of intergenerational poverty and allows upward social mobility

Michael Howard “The U.S. Could Help Solve Its Poverty Problem with a Universal Basic Income” January 06, 2023 https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-u-s-could-help-solve-its-poverty-problem-with-a-universal-basic-income/

Then in January 2022, the expanded tax credit expired, which plunged 3.7 million back into poverty, with higher percentage increases in poverty among Hispanic and Black children. The credit showed us that cash assistance could help families stay afloat and, contrary to some political beliefs, parents would not leave the labor system because of it. Even so, the failure to renew the expansion should not negate this important political milestone: Congress came within one vote of abandoning parental work requirements as a condition to get cash assistance for their families. The child tax credit expansion is one step toward a universal basic income that could eliminate poverty without increasing unemployment. There are 37.9 million people in poverty in the U.S., according to 2021 Census Bureau figures. Providing a government-funded monthly payment to every individual would broadly lift them out of poverty, while providing millions of children a better chance at a good education, improved health and higher future earnings. With 11.6 percent of people in the U.S. living at or under the poverty line, this payment would benefit millions and save hundreds of billions of dollars by reducing the social costs of poverty. The question becomes: Can we convince our elected officials that poverty is not a moral failing, but a social condition that can be addressed by establishing an income floor below which no one falls?’

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Economy Advantage

The US economy is losing steam – fear of recession is looming.

Scott Horsley 4-27-2023. (. "The U.S. economy is losing steam. Bank woes and other hurdles are to blame.." NPR. Web. accessed 5-16-2023 < https://www.npr.org/2023/04/27/1171993308/economy-gdp-growth-recession-mcdonalds >.)MSUCB

From banks to burger joints, the U.S. economy is showing signs of stress as nervous shoppers watch their spending and anxious lenders keep a tight grip on credit. A report from the Commerce Department Thursday shows the nation's gross domestic product grew at an annual rate of just 1.1% in the first three months of the year, compared to a 2.6% pace in the previous quarter. Growth was weighed down by declining inventories and housing investment. The economy is projected to lose more steam in the months to come as rising prices and higher interest rates take a toll on families and businesses. "Our base expectation is for a mild recession in the U.S.," McDonald's CEO Chris Kempczinski said this week. Although the fast-food chain reported strong sales so far in 2023, customers are less likely to splurge after two years of rising food costs, he said in an earnings call with investors. "Things like — did someone add fries to their order?" Kempczinski said. "We're seeing that go down in most of our markets around the world — slightly — but it's still going down." ECONOMY Inflation eased in March but prices are still climbing too fast to get comfortable Virginia resident Desiree Prince says she's more budget conscious now than she used to be, and making decisions about what she spends with an eye on the price tag. "Once upon a time, I might have said, 'I'd like to have steak and potatoes for dinner,'" Prince said. "Now it's like, 'Let's see what's in the refrigerator and cobble together a meal from things that I already have." Prince, who lives in Alexandria, is planning a vacation this summer with her mom and sister, but with airfares up nearly 18% this year, they're limiting themselves to places they can go by car. "We did have to be a bit selective about what we'll be doing on vacation," Prince said. "Do we want to pet the dolphins? That's a bit pricey. Maybe we'll just do the free national park. So we've been frugal with our travels." Consumers are spending enough to keep the economy going Spending by consumers like Prince is the biggest driver of the U.S. economy. Personal spending grew at an annual rate of 3.7% in the first quarter, with increased spending on both goods and services. "The American consumer is the firewall between a recession and an economy that moves forward. And right now the firewall is holding firm," said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics. People may not be spending aggressively, "but they are spending enough to keep the economy moving forward," he said. Zandi believes the U.S. can avoid an outright recession this year, but he argues it won't be easy, especially after the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank and the resulting drop in lending by other banks. "The Federal Reserve is still raising interest rates," Zandi said. "You throw into the mix the ill effects of the banking crisis and it does suggest that growth through the remainder of this year and into next is going to be very much on the soft side." Mike Kaeding, who builds and leases apartments in Minnesota, has noticed the sharp drop in loans. "Some of the regional banks here in the Twin Cities that do a lot of construction [loans], they're not lending at all right now," Kaeding said. "I think there's going to be a negative impact on the construction industry, where we'll actually see for the first time in a while where jobs start to dry up." Construction companies cut 9,000 jobs last month. Many other businesses are still hiring, but job growth in March was the slowest in more than two years. Even profitable companies like McDonalds and General Motors have been cutting white-collar jobs. That rattles Prince, even though her own job as a nuclear engineer seems secure. "You start seeing banks start to fail, companies like Microsoft and Facebook laying people off," she said. "I'm not an economist so I don't know what to think, but it doesn't feel great."

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Lack of food security causes conflict and escalates

Ore Koren, 16, (Ore Koren, Ore Koren is a PhD candidate at the University of Minnesota and a Jennings Randolph Fellow at the United States Institute of Peace., 11-23-2016, Washington Post, Food scarcity causes conflicts — but so can food abundance. Here’s why., https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/11/23/food-scarcity-causes-conflicts-but-so-does-food-abundance-heres-why/, 6-28-2021) SCade

For a new U.S. administration facing global security challenges, the relationship between food security — what the World Bank defines as “access to enough food for an active, healthy life” — and armed conflict deserves serious consideration. As new research shows, even an abundance of food resources can cause conflict. Recent studies theorize that in Syria, where an estimated 250,000 to 400,000 people have died since 2011, the drought that preceded the civil war played a significant role in fueling political tensions. Increases in food prices caused by drought were also a factor in the 2011 Arab Spring uprisings in Tunisia, Jordan, Yemen and Egypt. The fact that prolonged food shortages can lead to drastic, violent behavior is becoming increasingly evident. The relationship between food and war is both complex and multidimensional, though. The links between food scarcity and war Warmer countries are more war-prone — that’s what researchers studying the relationships between environmental factors and civil war argue. As global temperatures increase, prolonged heat waves reduce crop yields. The impact is strongest in tropical regions, which are more likely to experience the harshest effects of global warming. Lower crop yields increase the competition for remaining crops. And rising prices mean that many people cannot afford to buy food to compensate for resources lost because of climatic shifts. In countries that lack a social “safety net,” the only alternative in many cases is to obtain food through stealing, looting and — frequently — fighting over fertile land. Anecdotal evidence from eastern Africa and the Middle East, at least, supports this theory. Attempts to measure the linkages between climate change and armed conflict, however, have yielded mixed results, with some studies at least partly reaffirming these connections and others debunking them. Some regions adapt to climate conditions better than others Studies of the “Green Revolution” movement of the 1960s suggest that regions such as Asia were far more successful than Africa at adopting drought-resistant crops, which improved food security and helped offset the risk of war. Similar efforts in sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East were weak and generally unsuccessful until the late 1980s. These efforts met with limited success because of the types of grain available and other socioeconomic complexities, which left these regions food insecure. Had Syria successfully adopted drought-resistant crops, for instance, the social unrest of 2011 might have taken a different, less-violent course. As researchers continue to debate how climate change and its effects on global food stocks will impact food security in future decades, short-term environmental “shocks” such as droughts or floods have become more frequent in many parts of the world and are a potentially salient cause of armed conflict. These environmental disturbances can lead to sharp price increases that, in turn, can cause another well-established tradition: the food riot, when civilians take to the streets to protest high food prices. Low-income countries are particularly susceptible because high food prices in these situations have an especially destabilizing effect. In these countries, high food prices expose the government’s lack of ability to shield consumers. They also create opportunities for civilians to mobilize against the regime. Even in locations where food is sourced locally, drought-induced shocks may incite violence against civilians when rebel groups seek to appropriate local food supplies. My research documents this happening not only in the Syrian conflict but also in India and Thailand during a 2004 drought. Riots, protests and massacres are among the types of unrest that can lead to civil war — and all can be linked to food conflicts.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Finally, basic income key to food security – no other programs solve.

Drexel University (Center for Hungry-Free Communities) “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME: KEY TO REDUCING FOOD INSECURITY AND IMPROVING HEALTH” 2021 https://drexel.edu/hunger-free-center/research/briefs-and-reports/universal-basic-income/

Economic inequality in the United States is a major threat to public health. During the COVID-19 pandemic, economic injustice increased, disproportionately impacting women and people of color. The government’s efforts to protect families are failing, leading to widespread struggle for families to meet their basic needs. Minor increases to publicly funded benefits, meager one-time direct cash payments, and community efforts to increase emergency food resources are attempts to keep families afloat. But they have fallen short. Low wages and public assistance programs simply perpetuate inequality and do not address the root causes of poverty. Transformative solutions are long overdue. The pandemic is an inflection point: communities can either help their citizens by implementing income guarantees or watch as families plunge deeper into poverty and food insecurity. Based on evidence from communities that implemented guaranteed income programs, it is clear that universal basic income can begin to remedy these inequalities and create healthier, wealthier communities. POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS Establish a universal basic income program to complement existing aid in communities across the country Provide ongoing, direct cash payments to residents—without means testing, burdensome administrative requirements, or other spending restrictions—thereby acknowledging that families know how best to meet their own needs. Advocate for raising statewide and federal minimum wages Raise minimum wage to establish a living wage and advocate for the changing of statewide and federal minimum wages to meet the needs of all workers Declare food security, housing security, and medical care as basic human rights Officially declare the right for all residents to a standard of living adequate for their health and well-being, which includes adequate food, safe housing, and medical care, and ensure policies and programs support these basic human rights for all KEY TERMS AND DEFINITIONS Food Insecurity: Lack of consistent access to sufficient food for all members of a household to live an active and healthy life Means Testing: An evaluation determining whether a person or household is eligible for a payment or benefit, based on the person’s or family’s income and assets Universal Basic Income (UBI): A program of consistent, unconditional payments distributed by the government to ensure a basic standard of living for every member of a community BACKGROUND Over the past fifty years, the cost of living increased significantly. The income of the lowest 80% of workers hardly changed since the 1970s. The federal minimum hourly wage of $7.25 has not increased since 2009. Nor has it kept pace with increasing cost of living – challenging families to meet their basic needs. In 2019, 10.5% of American households were living below the federal poverty line – more than 34 million people including 10.4 million children. This figure includes those working while remaining in poverty. This number increased drastically with the pandemic. Research shows that public assistance programs are inadequate in addressing income inequality and related disparities. Nutrition assistance programs, such as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC), leave gaps and do not provide consistent food security. Resources such as food banks may address the immediate needs of hunger in the U.S. However, their impact is a small fraction of what can be accomplished by a comprehensive government safety net.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Pandemics causes extinction – maintaining system resilience is key

Millett 17 [Piers Consultant for the World Health Organization, PhD in International Relations and Affairs, University of Bradford, Andrew Snyder-Beattie. “Existential Risk and Cost-Effective Biosecurity.” http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1089/hs.2017.0028]

Historically, disease events have been responsible for the greatest death tolls on humanity. The 1918 flu was responsible for more than 50 million deaths,1 while smallpox killed perhaps 10 times that many in the 20th century alone.2 The Black Death was responsible for killing over 25% of the European population,3 while other pandemics, such as the plague of Justinian, are thought to have killed 25 million in the 6th century—constituting over 10% of the world’s population at the time.4 It is an open question whether a future pandemic could result in outright human extinction or the irreversible collapse of civilization. A skeptic would have many good reasons to think that existential risk from disease is unlikely. Such a disease would need to spread worldwide to remote populations, overcome rare genetic resistances, and evade detection, cures, and countermeasures. Even evolution itself may work in humanity’s favor: Virulence and transmission is often a trade-off, and so evolutionary pressures could push against maximally lethal wild-type pathogens.5,6 While these arguments point to a very small risk of human extinction, they do not rule the possibility out entirely. Although rare, there are recorded instances of species going extinct due to disease—primarily in amphibians, but also in 1 mammalian species of rat on Christmas Island.7,8 There are also historical examples of large human populations being almost entirely wiped out by disease, especially when multiple diseases were simultaneously introduced into a population without immunity. The most striking examples of total population collapse include native American tribes exposed to European diseases, such as the Massachusett (86% loss of population), Quiripi-Unquachog (95% loss of population), and theWestern Abenaki (which suffered a staggering 98% loss of population). In the modern context, no single disease currently exists that combines the worst-case levels of transmissibility, lethality, resistance to countermeasures, and global reach. But many diseases are proof of principle that each worst-case attribute can be realized independently. For example, some diseases exhibit nearly a 100% case fatality ratio in the absence of treatment, such as rabies or septicemic plague. Other diseases have a track record of spreading to virtually every human community worldwide, such as the 1918 flu,10 and seroprevalence studies indicate that other pathogens, such as chickenpox and HSV-1, can successfully reach over 95% of a population.11,12 Under optimal virulence theory, natural evolution would be an unlikely source for pathogens with the highest possible levels of transmissibility, virulence, and global reach. But advances in biotechnology might allow the creation of diseases that combine such traits. Recent controversy has already emerged over a number of scientific experiments that resulted in viruses with enhanced transmissibility, lethality, and/or the ability to overcome therapeutics.13-17 Other experiments demonstrated that mousepox could be modified to have a 100% case fatality rate and render a vaccine ineffective.18 In addition to transmissibility and lethality, studies have shown that other disease traits, such as incubation time, environmental survival, and available vectors, could be modified as well.19-2

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Crime wrecks public health

Theo Lorenc (et al), 2014, London School of Hygiene

Crime, fear of crime and mental health: synthesis of theory and systematic reviews of interventions and qualitative evidence. Public Health Research, No. 2.2 (Chapt 3) Theo Lorenc (et al),1,* Mark Petticrew,1 Margaret Whitehead,2 David Neary,2 Stephen Clayton,2 Kath Wright,3 Hilary Thomson,4 Steven Cummins,5 Amanda Sowden,3 and Adrian Renton6. March 2014 1 Department of Social and Environmental Health Research, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK 2 Department of Public Health and Policy, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK 3 Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, University of York, York, UK 4 MRC Social and Public Health Sciences Unit (SPHSU), University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK 5 School of Geography, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK 6 Institute for Health and Human Development, University of East London, London, UK * Corresponding author

Crime may impact on health in a range of ways,112 which can broadly be grouped into two categories, namely direct and indirect impacts.113 Direct impacts include physical injuries caused by violent crimes against the person and the psychological trauma that may accompany crimes involving violence or the threat of violence, or crimes such as burglary that involve intrusions into the private sphere. In the model, this is represented by the link from violent crime to physical and mental health. Indirect impacts include a wide range of negative effects that crime can have at a community level, for example by exacerbating social problems that impact on health. This distinction corresponds roughly to that between an individual perspective on crime and health and a social perspective. The individual perspective, which focuses on the direct impacts of victimisation on individuals, has been the primary focus of the literature on crime and health.113–115 These physical and mental health impacts on victims are often substantial and long-lasting.116,117 ‘Domestic’ crimes, including child abuse and intimate partner violence, may have particularly serious health impacts.118–120 However, at a community level, the health impacts are likely to be less substantial, because serious violent crime is relatively rare. In 2010–11 there were approximately 2.2 million incidents of violent crime in England and Wales,121 representing approximately 42 incidents per 1000 people per year. Dolan et al.122 estimate the total health loss from the direct physical and psychological impacts of violent crime as being equivalent to 0.0024 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) per person per year. However, this may be an underestimate as it includes costs relating to victims only rather than also including those relating to witnesses or victims’ families or friends, and the figures on which it is based may underestimate certain types of crime, particularly domestic crimes. In addition, crime and the health burdens of crime are highly unequally distributed, so the health impact is likely to be substantially higher than the average for some subgroups of the population. The community- or social-level perspective on crime and health presents a more complex picture. Violent crime has been found to be associated with a wide range of negative health status outcomes at a neighbourhood level, including all-cause mortality,123 coronary heart disease124 and preterm birth and low birthweight,125 as well as health behaviour outcomes such as lower levels of physical activity.126,127 Exposure to community violence is also known to be associated with negative physical and psychological health, particularly for children and young people.128,129 However, although these associations are well established, the causal pathways involved remain open to debate in many cases.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Additionally, guaranteed income solves crime, domestic violence, and creates safer communities

Lea Hoeffer et al. “The Little-Known Violence Prevention Tool Cropping Up in Cities Across the Country” March 08, 2022 https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2022/03/how-cash-transfer-programs-prevent-violent-crime.html

Cash transfer proposals are cropping up across the country. Los Angeles, for example, began allocating $1,000 per month to some of its poorest residents in January 2022. Approximately 40 other cities are considering implementing some form of guaranteed income, according to Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, which supports pilot cash transfer initiatives in U.S. cities. As in Chicago, the introduction of guaranteed income in U.S. cities has been couched as an anti-poverty measure largely detached from the problem of violence. In an American political context in which violent crime is a perennial centerpiece of electoral politics that is repeatedly invoked to perpetuate commitments to oppressive policing and carceral systems, this is a wasted opportunity to realign public perceptions of violence prevention with more constructive, equitable policy agendas. Abundant evidence shows that cash transfer programs and robust welfare systems are extremely effective policies for reducing homicide, assault, property crime, overdose deaths, and intimate partner violence. This should come as no surprise to anyone who is remotely attuned to human reality. Indeed, the logic of cash transfer programs as anti-violence policy is so self-evident that its elaboration feels redundant: Cash transfer programs reduce economic inequality. The relationship between inequality and violence is well-established. Reducing inequality alters the cost-benefit calculation of criminal acts by reducing desperation (e.g., the sense of having little to lose). Because cash transfers reduce poverty, financial need, and inequality, they decrease the perceived benefits of crime and increase its felt costs to others and oneself, fostering reductions in crime and increased experiences of shared community. Alongside such basic explanations of how guaranteed income reduces violence, there is also the fact that the social and psychic security it affords mitigates experiences of everyday stressors, distrust, anger, envy, and resentment that can provoke violent fantasies and actions, reducing the build-up of tension that exacerbates irrational human drives towards violent outbursts. We could additionally understand the violence-reducing effects of cash transfers through frameworks that foreground the social determinants of health––or, put more directly to underline that what is most at play is specific policy rather than vague cultural dynamics, the political determinants of health. Indeed, studies have found that not only do cash transfers decrease homicide, crime, and hospitalization rates, they also function through dose-dependent responses like those we see with the medications we use to treat our patients. In a large study of Brazil’s Bolsa Família cash transfer program, for example, for every 1 percent increase in the proportion of the target population receiving cash transfers, homicide rates decreased by 0.3 percent and hospitalizations from violence by 0.4 percent. Furthermore, the benefits of cash transfers grew over time: when at least 70 percent of the target population had received cash transfers for one, two, three, and four years, hospitalizations from violence decreased by 8 percent, 14 percent, 20 percent, and 25 percent, respectively

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

Independently, guaranteed income necessary for better health outcomes – key to quality of life

Kiara Alfonseca (ABC News) “Where guaranteed income programs are growing in the US” June 21, 2023

Guaranteed income experiments are popping up or expanding around the country, offering no-strings-attached temporary cash payments to low-income residents. Some governmental programs limit what recipients can or cannot pay for with their assistance. Guaranteed income programs select certain groups impacted by income inequality -- such as the impoverished or the formerly incarcerated -- and gives them monthly cash payments for an allotted amount of time. This allows participants to use money on whatever they need or want, which allows residents to fill in the gaps of what other financial assistance may not cover. These programs have been lauded by recipients, who say the payments have acted as a support system and offered mental and financial relief. Recipients have said the money has gone toward things like bills, debt repayment, childcare and more. Some research has indicated programs have the ability to increase employment in participants, improve financial and housing stability and improve physical and mental health in participants.

2023 SDI Affirmative
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative › 1AC › 1AC Quality of Life Advantage

It is important to make a distinction here. Poverty and economic growth are not the same thing. The plan is key to true, long-term poverty reduction.

Hanna, Rema, and Benjamin A. Olken. 2018. "Universal Basic Incomes versus Targeted Transfers: Anti-Poverty Programs in Developing Countries." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 32 (4): 201-26. DOI: 10.1257/jep.32.4.201

Of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals articulated by the United Nations, number one is the elimination of extreme poverty by 2030. While future economic growth should continue to reduce poverty, it will not solve the problem by itself; thus, there is a potentially important role for national-level transfer programs that assist poor families in developing countries. Such programs are often run by developing country governments. Many countries have implemented transfer programs that seek to target beneficiaries: that is, to identify who is poor and then to restrict transfers to those individuals. Some people have begun to advocate for "universal basic income" programs, which dispense with trying to identify the poor and instead provide transfers to everyone. We begin by considering the universal basic income as part of the solution to an optimal income-taxation problem, focusing on the case of developing countries, where there is limited income data and inclusion in the formal tax system is low. We examine how the targeting of transfer programs is conducted in these settings, and provide empirical evidence on the tradeoffs involved between universal basic income and targeted transfer schemes using data from Indonesia and Peru—two countries that run nationwide transfer programs that are targeted to the poor. We conclude by linking our findings back to the broader policy debate on what tools should be preferred for redistribution, as well as the practical challenges of administering them in developing countries.